Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.742 of 2021
Sri Arindam Paul, S/o Sri Alok Baran Pal, resident of T.G. Road,
Krishnanagar, Agartala, P.O. Agartala HPO, P.S. West Agartala, SubDivision: Sadar, District: West Tripura, Pin:799001, through his power of
attorney Sri Anupam Paul, S/o Sri Alok Baran Pal, resident of T.G. Road,
Krishnanagar, Agartala, P.O. Agartala HPO, P.S. West Agartala, SubDivision: Sadar, District: West Tripura, Pin-799001
.........Petitioner(s);
Versus
The High Court of Tripura, represented by its Registrar General, having his
office at New Capital Complex, Agartala, P.O. New Secretariat, P.S. New
Capital Complex, Sub-Division: Sadar, District: West Tripura, Pin:799010
.........Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Anupam Paul, Advocate,
Mr. Sankar Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Bibhal Nandi Majumder, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. D.J. Saha, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
Date of hearing
: 27.08.2025 & 03.09.2025
Date of Judgment & Order : 19.09.2025
Whether Fit for Reporting : YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(M.S. Ramachandra Rao, C.J.)
1)
Petitioner was appointed as a Judicial Officer Grade-III of
Tripura Judicial Service on 03.02.2004. He was promoted to Grade-II post of
the said service on 22.12.2010. By an order dt. 30.01.2015, he was promoted
to Grade-I of the said service with effect from 02.02.2015.
2)
On 26.3.2018, he was posted as Director of the Tripura Judicial
Academy.
3)
On 11.02.2020, adverse remarks along with „average‟ grading
were recorded in the Annual Confidential Report (ACR) of the petitioner for
the year 2018, and were communicated to him. They were:
“Grading:- “Average”
Adverse entry recorded by the Reporting Authority:
During my tenure, he was always trying to motivate me to provide
him financial power which was and still is under the control of High
Court. I discussed the issue with Brother Justice S. Talapatra who
suggested me not to do that. In spite of my unwillingness he left no
stone unturned to motivate me in this regard. I found him misusing
the official vehicle allocated to him as Director. During Regional
Conference of NJA, Mr. Pal‟s activities in many matters including
Hotel booking, purchase of backpack. During my tenure in the year
2018-19 I found him to be very arrogant. As I newly took over the
charge I proceeded on good faith. Many cautioned me about him in
regard to financial transactions. Then, I came to know about some
irregularities which he committed abusing his position as
Additional District & Sessions Judge, Kamalpur. Mr. Pal under the
garb of carrying electrical repair, two Air Conditioners have been
included in the items of repairing by way of manipulating the list.
Full Court had observed that Air Conditioners being new item
cannot be shown under the head of repair. And it was not the end
when it was found that those Air Conditioners were already
installed in the residence of Mr. Pal without any prior approval and
sanction of the High Court. Furthermore, when Mr. Arindam Pal
was holding the post of the Chief Judicial Magistrate-cum-Civil
Judge (Sr. Division), Unakoti Judicial District, Kailashahar, Air
Conditioner was installed in his official chamber. At that relevant
period only the Judges in the rank of District Judge or Addl.
District Judge were entitled for Air Conditioner machine in their
official chamber. Mr. Pal was directly involved in the installation of
two Air Conditioners in the official chambers of CJM, Kailashahar,
SDJM, Kailashahar and Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Kailashahar. He
also abused his power in engaging 3(three) PSOs for him. The
officer was show-caused for irregularities during Hon‟ble Chief
Justice Deepak Gupta though no final order was passed. However,
subsequently, it was withdrawn.”
4)
On 26.02.2020, petitioner submitted a representation in
connection with the adverse remarks recorded in the ACR for the year 2018.
5)
By a letter dt. 23.03.2020, the decision of the Full Court, whereby
the representation submitted by the petitioner was rejected, was communicated
to the petitioner. The Full Court held:
“Considered the representation of the concerned Judicial Officer to
the adverse remarks. The Full Court noted that the following
portion of the said remarks was only by way of a reference and
should not be treated as adverse remark:
“Then, I came to know about some irregularities
which he committed abusing his position as Additional District &
Sessions Judge, Kamalpur. Mr. Pal under the garb of carrying
electrical repair, two Air Conditioners have been included in the
items of repairing by way of manipulating the list. Full Court had
observed that Air Conditioners being new item cannot be shown
under the head of repair. And it was not the end when it was found
that those Air Conditioners were already installed in the residence
of Mr. Pal without any prior approval and sanction of the High
Court. Furthermore, when Mr. Arindam Pal was holding the post of
the Chief Judicial Magistrate-cum-Civil Judge (Sr. Division),
Unakoti Judicial District, Kailashahar, Air Conditioner was
installed in his official chamber. At that relevant period only the
Judges in the rank of District Judge or Addl. District Judge were
entitled for Air Conditioner machine in their official chamber. Mr.
Pal was directly involved in the installation of two Air Conditioners
in the official chambers of CJM, Kailashahar, SDJM, Kailashahar
and Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Kailashahar. He also abused his power
in engaging 3(three) PSOs for him. The officer was show-caused for
irregularities during Hon'ble Chief Justice Deepak Gupta though no
final order was passed. However, subsequently, it was withdrawn."
Subject to the above observation there is no reason to delete the
adverse remarks. The representation is rejected.”
( emphasis supplied)
6)
For the year 2019, adverse remarks along with „average‟ grading
were recorded in the petitioner‟s ACR, and they were communicated to him
by a letter dt. 20.02.2021. The noting of the Reporting Authority is as under:
„Grading: Average
Remarks: “ „Copy and paste‟ habit is required to be avoided.
Similar case laws are referred in almost all the judgments. It is not
clear how the principle of a case law is relevant to the factual
context of a particular case. The officer should apply his mind and
discuss as to how the principle enunciated in a judgment of the
higher Courts is applicable to the facts of the case in hand. The
officer needs to improve better relationship with the Bar.”
7)
On 15.03.2021 petitioner submitted representation in connection
with the adverse remarks recorded in his ACR for the year 2019.
8)
By a letter dt. 16.04.2021, the decision of the Full Court rejecting
petitioner‟s representation subject to partial modification, was communicated
to him. It recorded:
“In partial modification of the remarks conveyed, the group
of words “Copy and paste habit is required to be avoided” may be
substituted by “The Judicial Officer may discuss the applicability of
reproduced portion of earlier orders or judgments in proper
perspective.”
The Writ Petition
9)
Petitioner, therefore, filed the instant Writ Petition for
quashing/setting aside of the adverse remarks and the „average‟ grading
recorded in his ACR for the years 2018 and 2019 along with Full Court
resolutions dt. 20.03.2020 and 13.04.2021 which were communicated to him
on 23.03.2020 and 16.04.2021, and also the Full Court resolution dt.
18.07.2019 insofar as it relates to his ACR. He also prayed for sending his
ACR for the year 2018 to the Chief Justice for proper assessment, and for
upgrading his ACR for both years.
10)
The petitioner inter alia contended that for the previous years his
ACR gradings were “Very Good” or “Good”, that his work was appreciated,
that he was handpicked by the then Chief Justice to head the Tripura Judicial
Academy as it‟s Director, that the adverse comments for 2018 and 2019 were
recorded by the Judge-in-charge, Judicial Education and Training ( for short
„the Judge-in-Charge”) who was newly sworn in and that he had worked
under the said Judge-In-Charge only for 4 months.
11)
Petitioner contended that the recording of adverse entries in the
ACR for 2018 had no reasonable basis and has no factual foundation; that he
had merely reminded the Judge-in-Charge of the pending proposal for
adoption of Delegation of Financial power Rules followed by the State
Government for the Judicial Academy, that this cannot be the basis of
recording of an adverse remark, that no show cause notice was issued to him
for misusing the official vehicle, that events relating to NJA Regional
Conference held in 2018 or purchase of Air Conditioners which happened in
2015 cannot be included in the ACR of 2018.
12)
Petitioner contends that in 2019 he was posted as Judge, Family
Court, Kailashshahar, Unakoti District where he worked till 16.04.2021 and
same learned Judge-in-Charge was Portfolio Judge of Unakoti Judicial District
and he assessed the petitioner‟s performance in ACR of 2019 also and again
recorded „average‟ grading and certain adverse remarks therein. He
contended that criticism by the said Judge of petitioner adopting „copy-paste‟
method in writing judgments was also not warranted. He explained that since
facts and circumstances were similar in almost every case, similar case laws
were applied by him. He also stated that he had good relationship with the
Bar.
13)
He also claimed that he had dealt with a Criminal case in which
the father of the Judge-in-Charge was a charge sheeted accused and he took
steps for its early disposal and this might have displeased the Judge-in-Charge.
14)
According to petitioner, in 2018, the Service Rules did not
provide as to who would be the Reporting Authority and would record the
ACR; that the Chairman of the Judicial Academy was the Chief Justice as per
the bye-laws and they did not provide for the Judge-in-Charge to be the
Reporting Authority; that the resolution dt.18.07.2019 changed it; the said
resolution cannot be applied retrospectively; and so the ACR for 2018 could
only have been written by the Chief Justice as he was reporting to him and not
by the Judge-in-Charge. This is an error of procedure according to him.
15)
He pleaded that having modified to some extent the remarks of
the Judge-in-Charge in the ACRs of 2018 and 2019, the Full Court erred in
maintaining the „average‟ grading.
16)
He contended that the impugned proceedings deserve to be
quashed in the light of above contentions
The stand of the High Court of Tripura ( respondent no.1)
17)
The Registrar General of the High Court of Tripura has filed a
response to the Writ Petition, and defended the decision of the Full Court with
regard to the ACRs for 2018 and 2019 as regards the petitioner.
18)
It is pointed out that after the establishment of the Tripura
Judicial Academy, the petitioner was the first in-service Judicial Officer
appointed to the post of Director of the said academy, and all the former
Directors were retired officers of the Tripura Judicial Service.
19)
As a result, the matter of evaluation of ACR of the Director,
Tripura Judicial Academy i.e. the petitioner, came up for consideration before
the High Court for the first time, and it was duly considered by the Full Court
in a meeting held on 18.07.2019.
20)
In the said Full Court meeting, it was decided by the Full Court
that for the purpose of evaluation of the ACR of the Director of the Tripura
Judicial Academy, the Judge-in-Charge, Judicial Education and Training of
the High Court shall be the Reporting Authority, and the Full Court would be
the Reviewing and Accepting Authority.
21)
Pursuant to this decision dt. 18.07.2019 of the Full Court, the
Judge-in-Charge, Judicial Education and Training became the Reporting
Authority of the Director, Tripura Judicial Academy towards evaluation of his
performance. The resolution of the Full Court dt. 18.07.2019 is filed as
Annexure-R/3.
22)
The allegations levelled by the petitioner against the respondent
were denied.
The consideration by the Court
23)
Before we consider the respective contentions of the parties, we
may refer to the legal position with regard to scope of judicial review of a
challenge to the decisions of the Full Court concerning ACRs of Judicial
Officers.
24)
In the case of Syed T.A. Naqshbandi & others v. State of Jammu
& Kashmir and others1, the Supreme Court held that judicial review of the
ACRs/Full Court decisions regarding them is permissible only to the extent of
finding whether the process in reaching the decision has been observed
correctly and not the decision itself, as such.
It held that critical or independent analysis or appraisal of the
materials by the courts exercising powers of judicial review unlike the case of
an appellate court, would neither be permissible nor conducive to the interests
of either the officers concerned or the system and institutions of
administration of justice by going into the correctness as such of ACRs or the
assessment made by the Committee of the High Court and approval accorded
by the Full Court of the High Court.
It held that in cases of assessment of ACRs, evaluation and formulation
of opinions, a vast range of multiple factors play a vital and important role and
no one factor should be allowed to be overblown out of proportion either to
decry or deify an issue to be resolved or claims sought to be considered or
asserted.
It declared that in the very nature of things it would be difficult,
nearing almost an impossibility to subject such exercise undertaken by the
Full Court, to judicial review except in an extraordinary case when the Court
is convinced that some monstrous thing which ought not to have taken place
has really happened and not merely because there can be another possible
view or someone has some grievance about the exercise undertaken by the
Committee/Full Court.
(2003) 9 SCC 592
In that case, the Supreme Court upheld the evaluation made by the
Committee/Full Court with regard to the opinion expressed in the ACR and
held that it is neither arbitrary nor capricious, nor irrational as to shock the
conscience of the Court to warrant or justify any interference.
25)
This was reiterated in S.D. Singh v. Jharkhand High Court
through R.G. and Others2 in the context of the question as to whether
petitioner therein could have been asked to retire at the age of 58 years and his
service not extended to the age of 60 years.
The said decision had been taken on the basis of the petitioner‟s ACRs
wherein he was graded only “Average” in respect of the years immediately
preceding his attaining the age of 58 years, and also on the basis of a vigilance
proceeding initiated against him on the basis of several allegations made
against him including a report made by the Inspecting Judge who had made an
inspection, and had reported that petitioner did not have a good reputation.
However the allegation of the Inspecting Judge was concerned, the matter was
placed in the Standing Committee meeting and was ultimately dropped.
The Supreme Court upheld the decision of the Full Court saying that “it
cannot be said that there was no material on the basis of which the Evaluation
Committee and subsequently the Full Court of the High Court formed the
opinion that the petitioner was not suitable for continuing in service beyond
the age of 58 years”.
26)
In Arun Kumar Gupta v. State of Jharkhand3, while affirming
the judgment in Syed T.A. Naqshbandi (1 supra), the Supreme Court held:
(2005) 13 SCC 737
(2020) 13 SCC 355
“ 24. As is obvious from the law quoted above, adverse entries with
regard to integrity do not lose their sting at any stage. A judicial
officer‟s integrity must be of a higher order and even a single aberration
is not permitted. As far as the present cases are concerned, the matter
has been considered by the Screening Committee on two occasions and
the recommendations of the Screening Committee have been accepted by
the Standing Committee on both occasions. The action taken is not by
one officer or Judge, it is a collective decision, first by the Screening
Committee and then approved by the Standing Committee.
25. Senior Judges of the High Court who were the members of the
Screening Committee and Standing Committee have taken a considered
and well-reasoned decision. Unless there are allegations of mala fides
or the facts are so glaring that the decision of compulsory retirement is
unsupportable this Court would not exercise its power of judicial
review. In such matters the court on the judicial side must exercise
restraint before setting aside the decision of such collective bodies
comprising of senior High Court Judges. In our opinion these are not fit
cases to interfere with the said decisions.”
It dismissed the Writ Petition in that case and did not grant relief to the
Judicial Officers concerned.
27)
Counsel for the petitioner does not dispute that there is a very
limited scope of judicial review in the light of the decisions referred to supra,
and that there can be no appraisal of merits and only the decision making
process is to be seen i.e. whether there exist materials on the basis of which
the grading could have been given by the Reporting Authority and confirmed
by the Full Court.
28)
There is no dispute that Justice A. Lodh had been elevated as
judge of the High Court on 07.05.2018 and he was appointed as the Judge-inCharge of Judicial Education and Training, High Court of Tripura by the then
Chief Justice of the High Court on 14.05.2018 through a notification issued,
which has been placed on record by the counsel for the High Court.
29)
By that date, the petitioner was already the Director of the
Judicial Academy. So the Judge-in-Charge had opportunity to observe
petitioner‟s conduct as the Director till the petitioner was moved to the Family
Court Kailashshahar, Unakoti District in 2019. The same Judge of the High
Court was admittedly the Portfolio Judge of Unakoti District where he worked
till 16.04.2021. So the Judge of the High Court had occasion to consider the
Judgments of the petitioner and have awareness of petitioner‟s relationship
with the Bar.
30)
It is not in dispute that prior to 2018, the Tripura Judicial
Academy was always headed by a retired Judicial Officer and so there did not
arise the question of who would be the Reporting authority to write the ACRs
of the Director of the Judicial Academy.
31)
The petitioner was the first in-service Judicial officer who was
posted as Director of the Judicial Academy on 26.03.2018.
32)
Thus a need arose for designating the Reporting authority, the
Reviewing and Accepting Authority. This need was realized in 2019 and
accordingly the matter was decided by the Full Court on 18.07.2019.
33)
Annexure-R/3 resolution of the Full Court was passed on
18.07.2019 directing that the Judge-in-Charge, Judicial Education and
Training should be the Reporting Authority of the Director, Tripura Judicial
Academy, that the Full Court will be the Accepting and the Reviewing
Authority. The said resolution of 18.07.2019 in fact directed that the
petitioner‟s ACR be placed before the Full Court along with the assessment
report of the Judge-in-Charge, Judicial Education and Training since the
petitioner had worked as a Director of the Tripura Judicial Academy from
26.03.2018 to 31.12.2018 during the reporting year.
34)
The plea of the petitioner that this resolution was applied
retrospectively cannot be countenanced for the reason that even if he was
reporting in 2018 to the Chief Justice, who was the Chairman of the Academy,
the byelaws of the academy also did not designate the Chairman as Reporting
Authority. So even if the Chief Justice had written the petitioner‟s ACR for
2018, if there were adverse comments, petitioner would have raised the plea
that the Chief Justice was not competent to write the ACRs.
35)
Therefore, the Full Court was right in designating on 18.07.2019
the Judge-in-Charge A. Lodh to be the Reporting Authority and asking the
latter to write his ACR as he was familiar with the work and conduct of the
petitioner as Director of the Judicial Academy from 14.05.2018 till
31.12.2018.
36)
Had this not been done, none would have been competent to
write petitioner‟s ACR for 2018 and if it is not written, the petitioner himself
would have suffered in his career.
37)
There cannot be an interpretation of a situation which would
create a vacuum in the service career of an employee and also complicate the
duty of the employer of doing the impossible.
38)
Therefore the doctrine of necessity would have to be applied and
the decision dt.18.07.2019 of the Full Court cannot be found fault with.
39)
The plea of petitioner that the Judge-in-Charge was acquainted
with his work and conduct for only 4 months is incorrect since the record
shows that 7 and a half months was the period of observation available to the
Judge-in-charge. The petitioner tried to mislead the Court by trying to give a
false impression that only for a short while, the Judge-in-Charge had known
about his work as Director of the Judicial Academy.
40)
This period is a substantial period on the basis of which the ACR
for 2018 could be written by the said Judge-in-Charge after noting the conduct
of the petitioner as he would have interacted with him constantly.
41)
Obviously this must have been written after Justice A. Lodh was
designated as Judge-in-Charge of Judicial Education and Training on
14.05.2018, and after the Full Court passed the resolution on 18.07.2019
making him (the Judge-in-Charge, Judicial Education and Training) as the
Reporting Authority.
42)
This grading and adverse entry recorded by the Reporting
Authority was communicated to the petitioner on 11.02.2020 when he was
working as a Judge, Family Court, Kailashahar, Unakoti Judicial District.
43)
He then gave a representation on 26.02.2020 raising certain
contentions including the contention that the Judge-in-Charge, Judicial
Education and Training had a very limited role of assisting the Chairman
(Chief Justice) to conduct training programmes, that financial and day to day
administrative control remained with the Chief Justice, and he had reported to
the Chief Justice for the most part of 2018 and the Chief Justice should have
assessed his performance for the year 2018.
44)
The Full Court considered his representation in its meeting held
on 20.03.2020. As set out above in para 5 supra, a major portion of the
adverse remarks contained in the Reporting Authority‟s views was directed to
be treated by the Full Court not as adverse remark. However, the first portion
of the remarks of the Judge-in-Charge/Reporting Authority was retained and
so was the „average’ grading.
45)
The adverse remarks which were retained were that the petitioner
was always trying to motivate the Judge-in-Charge to provide him financial
powers which was and still is under the control of the High Court at that point
of time, and in spite of the unwillingness of the Judge-in-Charge, the
petitioner left no stone unturned to motivate him in that regard.
46)
In the Writ Petition at para 10.1, the petitioner himself admitted
that he had moved a proposal for adoption of Delegation of Financial Power
Rules followed by the State Government for the Tripura Judicial Academy
with suitable amendments as there was no Delegation of Financial Power
Rules laying down the procedure and safeguards to be followed by the Tripura
Judicial Academy for financial transactions.
47)
So the petitioner has admitted that he himself proposed the
conferment of financial powers on himself by the High Court as regards the
financial affairs of the Judicial Academy are concerned. The petitioner did not
dispute that at that point of time, the financial powers qua the Judicial
Academy were still under the control of the High Court.
48)
Admittedly the Chairman of the Judicial Academy was the Chief
Justice of the High Court and financial powers vested in the High Court. We
find this anxiety of petitioner to get the full financial powers as regards the
affairs of the Judicial Academy delegated to him, to be highly inappropriate
and unwarranted. He ought to have left it to the High Court to deal with the
issue instead of putting pressure on the Judge-in-Charge for it.
49)
It would also have been extremely awkward for the Judge-in-
Charge to press the Chief Justice/Full Court to confer the financial powers on
the Director of the Academy, and the petitioner must also realize the
embarrassment which would be caused to the Judge-in-Charge, if he put it to
the Chief Justice and the latter declined.
50)
No doubt as per the bye-laws of the Academy, the Director of the
Judicial Academy was held responsible for all the administrative and financial
matters of the Society under Clause 25(iii)(e). But this is admittedly subject to
order which may be passed by the Board of Governors, the Chairman i.e. the
Chief Justice or the Judge-in-Charge, Judicial Education and Training. So
unless such orders are passed, he cannot clamour for delegation of the said
powers.
51)
The Judge-in-Charge also found the petitioner misusing the
official vehicle allocated to him as Director, and he also found him to be very
arrogant. These would naturally be within the knowledge of the Judge-inCharge and noticed by him during the petitioner‟s tenure as Director of the
Judicial Academy.
52)
The contention of the petitioner that there was no discernable
basis for the Reporting Authority to say these things, and no instances have
been set out cannot be countenanced because of the limited scope of judicial
review which precludes this Court from going into the merits of the material,
and only requires this Court to go into the existence of the material, which
cannot be doubted.
53)
To this extent the Full Court had accepted the view of the learned
Judge-in-Charge and maintained the „adverse remarks‟ and the „average‟
grading.
54)
It cannot be said these 3 items are not valid „material‟ for the
Judge-in-Charge to record the same as an „adverse remark‟ and give him
„average‟ grading in the ACR of 2018.
55)
Though there is a reference to certain conduct of the petitioner
during the Regional Conference of the National Judicial Academy at Agartala
in 2019 in regard to hotel booking and purchase of backpack, the said sentence
in the noting of the Judge-in-Charge is incomplete, and it does not convey any
adverse comment.
56)
Anyway since the said Regional Conference of the National
Judicial Academy was held in 2019, the reference to the same in the ACR of
2018 was unnecessary. But as pointed out above, nothing adverse is conveyed
by the Judge-in-Charge with regard to the said conference vis-à-vis the
petitioner.
57)
More importantly, the Full Court had looked at the totality of the
circumstances and focused only on the portion of the Reporting Authority‟s
view which is required to be taken into account, by eschewing the other
portion by not treating it as „adverse‟ remark, and it approved the „average‟
grading given to him by the Reporting Authority on the basis of remarks of the
Reporting Authority to the extent it had relied on. So the action of the Full
Court in that regard does not warrant any interference.
58)
Coming to the ACR for the year 2019, the same Reporting
Authority had made the notings/grading and remarks in his ACR referred to in
para 6 supra. These were communicated to the petitioner on 20.02.2021, and
the petitioner gave a representation on 15.03.2021. In the said representation,
he had made some reference to one criminal case in which the father of the
learned Judge had been charge-sheeted as an accused on the ground that he
was Director of a Company which case he claimed had been tried by him.
59)
But the Full Court rejected his representation on 16.04.2021 by
modifying partially the remarks of the Judge in the manner set out in para 8
supra while affirming the „average‟ grading.
60)
In our considered opinion, if the Judge-in-Charge of Judicial
Education and Training had recorded about the manner of writing judgments
by the petitioner in the manner indicated above, and the Full Court had also
agreed with the same by modifying the language used by the Judge-inCharge/Reporting Authority, no exception can be taken to it.
61)
As regard the petitioner‟s allegation that he tried a criminal case
in which the father of the Judge-in-Charge was an accused, and that this might
have affected the Judge-in-Charge is concerned, no material in that regard is
filed before this Court about the details of the said case i.e. the period it was
pending, the Court where it was pending, who decided it and what was the
verdict therein.
62)
This allegation levelled by the petitioner against the Judge-in-
Charge in that representation is wholly unwarranted and it had not been part of
his previous representation dt. 26.02.2020 to the ACR of 2018, the remarks in
which were communicated to him on 11.02.2020.
63)
Counsel for the petitioner has relied upon a decision of the Apex
Court in the case of Union of India and Others v. G.R. Meghwal4. He has
also relied upon a decision of this Court rendered in the case of Rajib Ray v.
State of Tripura and Others5 and also a decision of Delhi High Court in the
case of Barkha Gupta v. High Court of Delhi through Registrar General
and another6.
64)
The conclusions in those judgments cited by the counsel for the
petitioner turned on the facts peculiar to the parties therein. These decisions do
not deviate from the principles laid down in the above decisions cited and
relied upon by us highlighting the limited scope for interference.
65)
For all the aforesaid reasons, keeping in mind the limited scope
of judicial review, we see no reason to grant relief to the petitioner in the writ
petition.
66)
The Writ Petition is accordingly dismissed. No costs.
67)
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand dismissed.
(S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA, J)
Pijush/
signed by MUNNA SAHA
MUNNA SAHA Digitally
Date: 2025.09.19 13:06:42 +05'30'
2022 SCC OnLine SC 1291
(2025) 1 TLR 681
2007 (93) DRJ 586(DB)
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review