Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.954 of 2021
Sri Amritangshu Bal
…..Petitioner.
_V_E_R_S_U_S_
The State of Tripura and 5 Others.
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
…..Respondents
Mr. K. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
27/03/2023
Heard Mr. K. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the
respondents.
[2]
The petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs:
i.
Issue rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to
show cause as to why a writ of mandamus and/or in the nature thereof,
shall not be issued, mandating/directing them to revoke/rescind the
impugned memorandum dated 10.07.2018, the impugned letter dated
27.12.2018 and the impugned memorandum dated 26.08.2019
(Annexures-6, 8 & 15 respectively supra).
ii. Issue rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to
show cause as to why a writ of mandamus and/or in the nature thereof,
shall not be issued, mandating/directing them to fix the pay of the
petitioner at Rs.9,920/-, with effect from the date of his promotion to the
post of Upper Division Clerk (i.e. w.e.f. 09.10.2014), along with arrears of
financial benefits, as per the 6th Amendment to the ROP Rules, 2009 and
to re-fix the pay of the petitioner at Rs.10,620/- with effect from the said
date of 09.10.2014, along with arrears of financial benefits, with effect
from 01.04.2015, i.e. after the promulgation of the 12th Amendment to the
ROP Rules, 2009, in parity with Sri Kriti Bhushan Chakma & said Sri
Atul Debbarma, for the period stretching from 09.10.2014 to 31.08.2019
[i.e. with effect from the date of promotion to the post of UDC, up to the
date of effect as recorded in the impugned Memorandum dated 26.08.2019
(Annexure-15 supra).
iii. Call for the records, appertaining to this writ petition.
iv. After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the rule absolute in
terms of (i) & (ii) above.
v. Costs of and incidental to this proceeding.”
[3]
The case of the petitioner is that on 07.10.2005, the petitioner
was initially appointed to the post of LDC on fixed pay basis. On 07.10.2010,
the petitioner was granted regular pay scale, under Pay Band-2, Rs.5,31024,000/-, with Grade Pay of Rs.1,800/-. On 09.10.2014, the petitioner was
promoted to the post of UDC, in the pay scale of Rs.5,310-24,000/-, with Grade
Pay of Rs.2,100/- (Pay Band-2), but his pay was wrongly fixed at Rs.9,520/-,
instead of Rs.9,920/-. On 01.06.2017the petitioner submitted representation.
[4]
On 10.08.2018, the said representations were rejected. In terms of
the impugned memorandum dated 26.08.2019, the pay of the petitioner was
notionally fixed at Rs.9,920/- (Rs.7,820/- + Grade Pay of Rs.2,100/-), w.e.f. the
date of his promotion to the post of UDC (i.e. 09.10.2014) and the financial
benefits were released in his favour only w.e.f. 01.09.2019. The petitioner has
been deprived of his financial benefits, w.e.f. 09.10.2014 to 31.08.2019 (i.e.
w.e.f. the date of his promotion to the post of UDC, up to the date of effect as
recorded in the impugned memorandum dated 26.08.2019.
[5]
Hence, the present petition has been filed by the petitioner before
this Court for redress.
[6]
Mr. K. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
has submitted that the petitioner was initially appointed as LDC vide order
dated 07.10.2005 issued by the District Magistrate and Collector, West Tripura,
Agartala under the Revenue Department, Government of Tripura on fixed pay
basis with monthly pay of Rs.2,245/-. Pursuant to the said order of
appointment, the petitioner joined to the post of LDC on 07.10.2005, in the
office of the District Magistrate and Collector and at present, the petitioner is
discharging his duties and responsibilities in the post of UDC, in the office of
the District Magistrate and Collector, South Tripura Belonia.
[7]
After completion of five years of service, vide order dated
11.10.2010 issued by the D.M. & Collector, West Tripura, Agartala, the
petitioner was granted with regular pay scale, under Pay Band-2, Rs.5,31024,000/- with Grade Pay of Rs.1,800/- w.e.f. 07.10.2010. At a later stage, the
DM & Collector issued an order dated 09.10.2014, promoting the petitioner to
the post of UDC in the pay scale of Rs.5,310-24,000/- with Grade Pay of
Rs.2,100/- (Pay Band-2) and his promotional post of UDC was accepted w.e.f.
09.10.2014.
[8]
He has further contended that posterior to the joining of the
petitioner to the said post of UDC, the petitioner noticed that w.e.f. the said
date of joining i.e. 09.10.2014, his pay was fixed at Rs.7,420/- along with
Grade Pay of Rs.2,100/- totaling to Rs.9,520/- whereas, on being promoted to
the said post of UDC, the petitioner was entitled to the pay of Rs.7,820/- along
with Grade Pay of Rs.2,100/- totaling to Rs.9,920/- as per the Tripura State
Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 [ROP Rules, 2009 for short] and the
Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay 6th Amendment) Rules, 2012.
[9]
Thereafter, the petitioner has prayed for fixation of his pay to the
tune of Rs.7,820/- along with Grade Pay of Rs.2,100/- totaling to Rs.9,920/with effect from the date of his promotion to the post of UDC. The petitioner
has submitted representation to the respondents. In response to this, the
respondents issued letters dated 10.07.2018 thereby rejecting the said prayer of
the petitioner.
[10]
Mr. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
pointed out that much prior to the negation of the said prayer of the petitioner,
one Sri Kriti Bhushan Chakma, whose pay was wrongly fixed on being
promoted to the post of UDC, was re-fixed in the PB-2, Rs.5,310-24,000/- with
GP of Rs.2,100/- at Rs.9,920/- along with all financial benefits again re-fixed
at Rs.10,620/- in accordance with 12th amendment to the ROP Rules, 2009
w.e.f. 01.04.2015. He has further contended that the said pay fixation, the
Accounts Officer, Office of the Accountant General (A&E), Tripura, Agartala
issued a letter dated 09.05.2017 recording that the said pay fixation made in
favour of Sri Kriti Bhushan Chakma at Rs.9,920/- has been found to be correct.
Thereafter, vide letter dated 11.07.2017, issued by the Senior Deputy
magistrate, West Tripura, Agartala the said proposal of pay fixation was
forwarded to the Under Secretary, Revenue Department, Govt. of Tripura.
[11]
Pursuant thereto, the pay of said Kriti Bhushan Chakma was re-
fixed at Rs.9,920/- w.e.f. 28.11.2014 i.e. from the date when he was promoted
to the post of UDC, along with financial benefits and thereafter, again re-fixed
at Rs.10,620/- in accordance with 12th Amendment to the ROP Rules, 2009
with financial benefits w.e.f. 01.04.2015.
[12]
It has been further averred that the for fixation of pay at
Rs.9,920/- on being promoted to the post of UDC, from the feeder post of
LDC, one Atul Debbarma, serving in the Home Department, Government of
Tripura, had filed a writ petition before this Court and subsequently, that
petition was disposed of directing the respondents to consider the
representation of the petitioner. After passing of such order , the SP
(Procurement), Tripura, Agartala issued an office order dated 02.01.2019
thereby re-fixing the pay of said Atul Debbarma at Rs.9,920/- as per 6th
Amendment of ROP Rules, 2009 from the date he was promoted to the post of
UDC. From this instance of said Kriti Bhushan Chakma and Atul Debbarma, it
is crystal clear that an incumbent, on being promoted to the higher post of UDC
from the feeder post of LDC is entitled to the pay of Rs.9,920/- w.e.f. the date
of such promotion.
[13]
Mr. Chakraborty, learned counsel has submitted that the
petitioner was promoted to the post of UDC on 09.10.2014 i.e. after
promulgation of the 6th Amendment of the ROP Rules, 2009 and his pay was
fixed at Rs.7,420/- along with GP of Rs.2,100/- i.e. Rs.9,520/-. It is thus crystal
clear that he petitioner was getting a lower pay than that of the direct recruits
placed in the PB-2 who were getting a higher pay of Rs.7,820/- along with GP
of Rs.2,100/- totaling to Rs.9,920/-. From letter dated 26.08.2019 issued by the
Deputy Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. Tripura, wherein, it has been
decided that “....3 The matter has been examined in Finance Department and
after careful examination, it has been clarified that the pay of those
Government employees who have been drawing revised pay in the lower post in
terms of TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 and subsequently gets promoted to
higher post during the period under TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 shall not
receive pay lower than the entry pay as indicated in Part-E read with Part-D of
Schedule-I of TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009....
....4. In the light of the above, the undersigned is directed to inform you
that if the pay of a Government employee who has been drawing revised pay in
the lower post in terms of TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 and who has
subsequently been appointed to a higher post on promotion during the period
under TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009, happens to be lower than the entry pay
as mentioned at Part-E read with Part-D of Schedule-I of TSCS (Revised Pay)
Rules, 2009 then the revised pay due to promotion shall not be less than the
said entry pay of the promotion post.....
....5. The undersigned is further directed to inform you that the above
benefit of revised pay shall be allowed notionally, even for the purpose of
revision of pay in respect of TSCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2017 and it is
amendment. Actual financial benefits of higher pay scale may be allowed to
eligible cases from 1st September, 2019....”
[14]
The petitioner was drawing the revised pay in the lower post i.e.
LDC and on being promoted to the higher post of UDC in terms of the said
impugned memorandum dated 26.08.2019 (Annexure-15) the pay of the
petitioner was notionally fixed at Rs.9,920/- w.e.f. the date of his promotion to
the post of UDC i.e. 09.10.2014 and the financial benefits therefore were
released in his favour only w.e.f. 01.09.2019.
[15]
Vide letters dated 11.07.2017 and 09.05.2017 and the
memorandum dated 16.11.2016 and the office order dated 02.01.2019 Sri kriti
Bhushan Chakma and Atul Debbarma were not only provided with the pay of
Rs.9,920/- and the amended pay of Rs.10,620/- w.e.f. their respective dates of
promotion to the post of UDC, but were also accorded with arrears of such
financial benefits. In such view of the matter, it is submitted that the petitioner,
being subsequently promoted to the post of UDC on 09.10.2014 is equally
entitled to the arrears of the said financial benefits.
[16]
Without any foundational basis, only to deprive the petitioner and
other similarly situated persons from their legitimate entitlements by the
impugned memorandum dated 26.08.2019 it was decided to restrict the
financial benefits by giving its effect from 01.09.2019, which is wholly
unsustainable. It is settled legal principle that a promotee cannot draw a lesser
pay than a direct recruit. Applying the said principle to the case in hand, it is
submitted that the petitioner was entitled to the pay of Rs.9,920/- w.e.f. the date
of his promotion and had the pay of the petitioner was duly fixed in the said
relevant point of time the petitioner would have received higher financial
benefits. It is submitted that just due to the delayed decision of the respondents
as made vide the impugned memorandum dated 26.08.2019, the petitioner
cannot be deprived of the actual benefits of such fixation.
[17]
It has been further submitted that where a service related claim is
based on a continuing wrong, relief merits to be granted, even if there is a long
delay in seeking remedy, with reference to the date on which the continuing
wrong commenced, if such continuing wrong creates a continuing source of
injury. It is submitted that the non-grant of the arrears of actual financial
benefits, in favour of the petitioner, is not intercepted by accrual of any third
party rights, and therefore, the said benefit cannot be denied to the petitioner,
on the ground of delay and laches.
[18]
In view of above averments made in this petition and after gone
through the material evidence on record, this Court is of the view that the
Government Order itself caters to situation where pay of the promotee after
using the methodology prescribed in the government order is found to be lesser
than the minimum of the higher pay band of the promotional post, the same
needs to be stepped up to the minimum of the pay scale of the promotional
post. The said government order, in my opinion, itself provides for stepping up
of pay of the promotees of the minimum of the higher pay band to which post
promotion has taken place.
[19]
In a case of Satyendra Kumar Sharma and Others v. Principal
Secretary, Deptt. of Finance and Others, in writ petition No.410 of 2014
[MANU/UC/0700/2018] the Court has observed thus:
“13. From the perusal of the Government Order dated 17.10.2008, it can
be said that promotee is also entitled for step up to the minimum of pay in
pay band with grade pay. It is a settled position that a direct recruit gets
minimum of the pay scale and Government Order dated 13.02.2009
prescribes the minimum entry pay for direct recruit. In this way, it can
safely be construed that if basic pay of promotee remains less than that of
direct recruit, then in such eventuality, it should be stepped up upto the
level of direct recruit. In other word, a promotee is also entitled to get the
minimum entry pay meant for direct recruit, if he is drawing pay less than
that of pay meant for direct recruit. Our conclusion gets fortification from
the judgments of Hon'ble Supreme Court and Hon'ble Delhi High Court in
the case of Somvir Rana and Shashikant (supra). After judgment of
Hon'ble Supreme Court, Government of India has already issued Circular
granting the minimum entry pay, meant for direct recruit, to the
promotees.
14. State cannot create class amongst the class. Our State is a welfare
State. It cannot create two minimum entry pay in one pay scale, one for
direct recruit and another for promotee that too without any cogent reason,
rationale or justification. Even though no direct recruit joins in the present
case but by way of Sixth Pay Commission, State Government decided to
give revised pay scales to all government employees. It is settled position
that by implementing new pay commission, old pay scales are replaced by
new ones. It is also settled that every pay scale has one minimum entry
pay therefore, Government cannot create two different minimum entry pay
for one pay scale and if a person joins on particular pay scale, then he is
entitled to get the minimum entry pay of that pay scale irrespective of the
fact how he joins the cadre. Therefore, we find no force in the argument of
learned Standing Counsel for the State that no direct recruitment took
place in the present matter. In our view, different fixation of pay for
promotees and direct recruits would lead to invidious discrimination and
violates Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The same pay scale cannot
have two different entry pay, one for the promotees and other for direct
recruits. The provision for two different entry pay one for promotees and
another for direct recruits is clearly violative of the principle of 'equal pay
for equal work' enshrined in Article 39A of the Constitution of India.
17. In view of the above, the writ petition deserves to be allowed. The
same is allowed. Impugned order passed by the Pay Anomaly Committee
is quashed. Respondents are directed to grant the minimum entry pay to
the petitioners meant for the direct recruits and re-fix the pay of
petitioners, at the level of minimum entry pay, applicable for direct
recruits in Pay Band 3 with Grade Pay Rs. 6600/-, as per Government
Order dated 13.02.2009 from the date of their respective promotions.
Respondents are further directed to pay the arrears arising out of pay
fixation pursuant to the order passed by this Court. The above benefits
shall be granted to the petitioners within a period of three months from
today.”
[20]
In view of the above, observations and submissions made by
the learned counsel appearing for the parties, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the petitioner has made out a case for interference
and accordingly, the prayer as sought for by the petitioner in the present
writ petition stands allowed. Consequently, the impugned letter dated
27.12.2018 and the impugned memorandums dated 10.07.2018 and the
impugned memorandum dated 26.08.2019 stand set aside as the notional
fixation is unreasonable. The proceeding under challenge which is for
denying the arrears of the petitioner is also set aside. The respondents are
directed to pay the arrears of the petitioner within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of the copy of this order.
[21]
In the result, the present petition stands allowed and thus
disposed of.
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
A. Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review