Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.704 of 2024
W.P.(C) No.705 of 2024
In W.P.(C) No.704 of 2024
Sri Amaresh Debbarma,
son of late Amar Kumar Debbarma, R/OSaipaihowar, Amtali Bazaar, Rajmangal
Para, P.O. Champahowar, P.S. Khowai,
District- Khowai, PIN-799201
……… Petitioner(s)
By Advocate:
Mr. A. Bhowmik, Adv.
–Versus–
1.
The State of Tripura,
represented by its Secretary, Rural
Development, Government of Tripura, P.O.
Secretariat, P.S. New Capital Complex,
District- West Tripura, PIN-799010
2.
The Chief Engineer,
Rural
Development
Department,
Government of Tripura, P.O. Agartala, P.S.
West Agartala, District- West Tripura, PIN799001
3.
The District Magistrate & Collector,
Khowai District, Government of Tripura,
P.O. & P.S. Khowai, District- Khowai, PIN799201
4.
The Block Development Officer,
Tulashikhar
R.D.
Block,
P.O.
Champahowar, P.S. Khowai, DistrictKhowai, PIN-799201
…….. Respondent(s)
By Advocate:
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. GA
In W.P.(C) No.705 of 2024
Sri Prahllad Debbarma,
son of late Laha Kumar Debbarma, R/OBisharad Chowdhury Para, Purba Champa
[2]
Cherra, P.O. & P.S. Champahowar,
District- Khowai, Tripura, PIN-799201
……… Petitioner(s)
By Advocate:
Mr. A. Bhowmik, Adv.
–Versus–
1.
The State of Tripura,
represented by its Secretary, Rural
Development Department, Government of
Tripura, P.O. Secretariat, P.S. New Capital
Complex, District- West Tripura, PIN799010
2.
The Chief Engineer,
Rural
Development
Department,
Government of Tripura, P.O. Agartala, P.S.
West Agartala, District- West Tripura, PIN799001
3.
The District Magistrate & Collector,
Khowai District, Government of Tripura,
P.O. & P.S. Khowai, District- Khowai, PIN799201
4.
The Block Development Officer,
Tulashikhar R.D. Block, Tulashikhar, P.O.
Champahowar, P.S. Khowai, DistrictKhowai, PIN-799201
…….. Respondent(s)
By Advocate:
Mr. K. De, Addl. GA
Date of hearing
:
17.11.2025
Date of delivery of
Judgment & order
:
17.01.2026
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Common
issues
being
involved,
both
the
writ
petitions were heard together and are being disposed of by this
common judgment.
[3]
[2]
In the writ petition bearing W.P.(C) No.704 of 2024,
the petitioner was engaged as Contingent Driver on 16.11.2009
by
the
Block
Development
Officer
[in
short,
the
BDO],
Tulashikhar R.D. Block. Thereafter, vide letter dated 28.08.2010
[Annexure-2 to W.P.(C) No.704 of 2024], the BDO wrote to
District Magistrate & Collector, West Tripura, Agartala to engage
him as DRW-Driver as he was experienced in Light Motor
Vehicle driving and there was no driver for the vehicle of the
establishment of said BDO. Thereafter, the Deputy Secretary to
the Government of Tripura, Rural Development Department vide
letter dated 11.09.2012 [Annexure-3] requested the DM &
Collector, West Tripura to send the requisite information about
the present writ petitioner and another Sri Prahllad Debbarma,
the writ petitioner of W.P.(C) No.705 of 2024 as to whether both
persons were still in service. The purpose of seeking such
information was for regularization of their services. The DM &
Collector,
Khowai,
Tripura
vide
letter
dated
12.10.2012
[Annexure-4] sent the required information about said Amaresh
Debbarma and Prahllad Debbarma accordingly but nothing
progressed further.
[3]
On 26.06.2024, the writ petitioner sent one advocate
notice to the State-respondents seeking minimum of regular pay
scale meant for the post of Driver (Group-C) but according to
him, no response was received by him in this regard. Therefore,
the present writ petition has been filed praying for minimum of
[4]
pay scale of Driver (Group-C) from the date of his completion of
10 years of service as contingent-driver. According to him, he is
discharging his 8 hours (full time) duty as Driver (Group-C).
[4]
In writ petition bearing W.P.(C) No.705 of 2024, said
Sri Prahllad Debbarma also similarly stated that he was engaged
as DRW in the office of the BDO, Tulashikhar R.D. Block on
01.12.1994. He is also discharging 8 hours duty in a day as
peon like any other Group-D employee in respect of maintaining
of files and peon book etc. but he was not regularized. In this
regard, a letter was forwarded by the Chairman, Block Advisory
Committee, Tulashikhar R.D. Block to the Joint Secretary to the
Government of Tripura vide letter dated 21.07.2012 [Annexure3 of W.P.(C) No.705 of 2024] for providing him regular scale of
pay.
Thereafter,
he
also
sent
one
advocate
notice
on
12.06.2024 [Annexure-6] seeking such minimum of the pay
scale meant for Peon (Group-D) but the same has also not been
responded by the state-respondents and therefore, ultimately
with similar prayer, he filed the present writ petition.
[5]
Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioners submits that as contingent workers, both the
petitioners are working for more than decades but neither they
have been regularized nor they are paid minimum of the pay
scale,
meant
for
Driver
(Group-C)
and
Peon
(Group-D)
respectively and State is deriving the benefit of their services to
[5]
their exploitation and therefore, necessary direction may be
issued to the respondents to provide them minimum of the pay
scale like regular employees. Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel also
relies on the following decisions of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
and the High Court:
(i) In the case of State of U.P. and others vs.
Putti Lal, (2006) 9 SCC 337, it was observed at paragraph
no.5 that in several cases, this Court, applying the principle of
equal pay for equal work has held that a daily wager, if he is
discharging
the
similar
duties
as
those
in
the
regular
employment of the Government, should at least be entitled to
receive the minimum of the pay scale though he might not be
entitled to any increment or any other allowance that is
permissible to his counterpart in the Government.
(ii) In State of Punjab and others vs. Jagjit
Singh and others, (2017) 1 SCC 148, at paragraph nos.58 &
60, the followings were observed:
58. In our considered view, it is fallacious to
determine artificial parameters to deny fruits of
labour. An employee engaged for the same work
cannot be paid less than another who performs the
same duties and responsibilities. Certainly not, in a
welfare state. Such an action besides being
demeaning, strikes at the very foundation of human
dignity. Anyone, who is compelled to work at a lesser
wage does not do so voluntarily. He does so to
provide food and shelter to his family, at the cost of
his self-respect and dignity, at the cost of his selfworth, and at the cost of his integrity. For he knows
that his dependants would suffer immensely, if he
does not accept the lesser wage. Any act of paying
less wages as compared to others similarly situate
constitutes an act of exploitative enslavement,
emerging out of a domineering position. Undoubtedly,
[6]
the action is oppressive, suppressive and coercive, as
it compels involuntary subjugation.
60. Having traversed the legal parameters with
reference to the application of the principle of “equal
pay for equal work”, in relation to temporary
employees
(daily-wage
employees,
ad-hoc
appointees, employees appointed on casual basis,
contractual employees and the like), the sole factor
that requires our determination is, whether the
employees concerned (before this Court), were
rendering similar duties and responsibilities as were
being discharged by regular employees holding the
same/corresponding posts. This exercise would
require the application of the parameters of the
principle of “equal pay for equal work” summarized
by us in para 42 above. However, insofar as the
instant aspect of the matter is concerned, it is not
difficult for us to record the factual position. We say
so, because it was fairly acknowledged by the learned
counsel representing the State of Punjab, that all the
temporary employees in the present bunch of
appeals, were appointed against posts which were
also available in the regular cadre/establishment. It
was also accepted that during the course of their
employment, the temporary employees concerned
were being randomly deputed to discharge duties and
responsibilities which at some point in time were
assigned to regular employees. Likewise, regular
employees holding substantive posts were also
posted to discharge the same work which was
assigned to temporary employees from time to time.
There is, therefore, no room for any doubt, that the
duties and responsibilities discharged by the
temporary employees in the present set of appeals
were the same as were being discharged by regular
employees. It is not the case of the appellants that
the respondent employees did not possess the
qualifications prescribed for appointment on regular
basis. Furthermore, it is not the case of the State that
any of the temporary employees would not be
entitled to pay parity on any of the principles
summarized by us in paragraph 42 hereinabove.
There can be no doubt, that the principle of “equal
pay for equal work” would be applicable to all the
temporary employees concerned, so as to vest in
them the right to claim wages, on a par with the
minimum of the pay scale of regularly engaged
government employees holding the same post.
(iii) In the case of Sabha Shanker Dube vs.
Divisional Forest Officer and others, (2019) 12 SCC 297,
the appellants were the daily-rated workers employed in GroupD posts in the Forest Department in the State of Uttar Pradesh.
They filed the writ petitions before the High Court of Allahabad
seeking regularization of their services, the minimum of the pay
[7]
scales available to their counterparts working on regular posts.
In this case, in one appeal, the learned Single Judge of the High
Court rejected the claim of minimum of the pay scales by
holding that such direction cannot be issued under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India. The Division Bench also dismissed the
said appeal.
In another appeal decided analogously, filed by daily
wagers working in Group „C‟ and Group „D‟ posts in the Forest
Department of the State of Uttar Pradesh similarly sought for
their regularization of services and „equal pay for equal‟ work
was also the relief that was sought by the Petitioners in those
Writ Petitions. The learned Single Judge allowed the Writ
Petitions directing the State Government to re-consider the
Petitioners-therein for regularization of their services, ignoring
their artificial breaks and by relaxing the minimum educational
qualifications
and
the
physical
endurance
requirements
prescribed by the service rules.
In the appeal, the Division Bench of the High Court
set aside the direction relating to the relaxation of minimum
educational qualifications and physical endurance requirements
and also the direction pertaining to the minimum of the pay
scales to be paid to them.
[8]
Finally, referring to the decision of Jagjit Singh
(supra) Hon‟ble Supreme Court held that the appellants were
entitled to be paid the minimum of the pay scale.
[6]
In the case of Smt. Suchitra Malakar vs. State of
Tripura and others, W.A. No.134 of 2024, decided on
05.11.2025, the claim of the petitioner for minimum of the
regular pay scale to a Daily Rated Worker (for short, DRW)
working in the Public Works Department (R&B), Government of
Tripura was turned down by the learned Single Judge on the
sole ground that she had been appointed illegally without
following normal rules of public employment and holding that
she cannot be equated to the employees who had been
appointed in terms of Articles 14 & 16 of the Constitution of
India. The Division Bench set aside the judgment of the learned
Single Judge, relying on the decision of Jagjit Singh (supra)
and held that the petitioner was entitled to the wages at the
minimum of the pay scale (at the lowest grade in the regular
pay scale extended to regular employees holding the Group-D
post).
[7]
Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the
state-respondent in W.P.(C) No.704 of 2024 submits that the
petitioner of said writ petition was a contingent driver and was
meant for doing any kind of work whenever entrusted and for
getting the benefit of pay parity he should have to acquire
[9]
similar qualification like regular employees and shall have to
undergo regular recruitment process and then only he can enjoy
the similar benefits like a regular employee.
[8]
Learned Addl. G.A. also relies on the following
decisions:
(i) In the case of Harbans Lal and others vs. State
of Himachal Pradesh and others, (1989) 4 SCC 459, the
petitioners were the carpenters 1st and 2nd grade employed at
the Wood Working Centre of the Himachal Pradesh State
Handicraft Corporation. They were termed as daily rated
employees. They sought for enforcement of their fundamental
right to have “equal pay for equal work” in terms as paid to
their counterparts in their regular services. They wanted the
same pay of regular employees as carpenters or in the
alternative, the minimum wages prescribed by the Deputy
Commissioner for like categories of workmen.
The Corporation has clearly stated in their counter
affidavit that there were no regular employee of the petitioners'
categories in their establishment and, as such, the payment to
the petitioners, of the pay admissible to regular employee was
not permissible.
Hon‟ble Supreme Court found that the Corporation
was running in loss and even to minimize the further loss, they
[10]
reduced their staff strength in the production centers and, it was
also observed by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court that the petitioners
were not entitled to enforce the right under “equal pay for equal
work” as to apply such principle, the discrimination complained
of must be within the same establishment owned by the same
management. But there the petitioners were claiming wages
payable to the carpenters working in government service.
It
was also further observed that a comparison cannot be made
with
counterparts
management,
or
in
other
even
establishments
with
different
establishments
in
different
in
geographical locations though owned by the same master and
unless it is shown that there was a discrimination amongst the
same set of employees by the same master in the same
establishment, the principle of "equal pay for equal work" could
not be enforced.
While refusing the claim of minimum wages as
prescribed by the Deputy Commissioner, it was also observed
that
said
minimum
Commissioner
for
wages
the
were
skilled
and
fixed
by
unskilled
the
Deputy
workers
in
Government service and the said notification was not extended
to employees of the Corporation. It appears that this decision of
Hon‟ble Supreme Court was rendered in a complete different
context.
[11]
(ii)
In the
case
of
Ghaziabad
Development
Authority and others vs. Vikram Chaudhary and others,
(1995) 5 SCC 210, the appellants, Ghaziabad Development
Authority in its planned development of urban areas, pursuant
to U.P. Urban Planning and Development Act, 1973, engaged
the respondents on daily wages in the project on hand. But the
respondents filed a writ petition claiming parity in appointment
and pay with the regular employees and also for regularization
of their services. In that contexts, it was observed by the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court that the appellant needed to take the
services of the persons according to the requirement in the
projects on hand and if on completion of the existing projects in
which the respondents were working, the appellant undertook
any fresh project, in that case, instead of taking the services of
fresh hands at the place of their new project, the appellant
should take the services of the existing temporary daily wage
workers. In the event of the appellant not having any project on
hand, the obligation to pay daily wages to the daily wage
workers did not arise. Therefore, it was further held that since
those respondents were temporary daily wage employees, so
long as there were no regular posts available for appointment,
the question of making pay on a par with the regular employees
did not arise. But the appellant should necessarily and by
implication, pay the minimum wages prescribed under the
statute, if any, or the prevailing wages as available in the
[12]
locality. The fact of the present case also similarly differs with
the fact of the present writ petitions in hand.
(iii) Though learned Addl. G.A., Mr. Sarma, relies on
State of Haryana and others vs. Jasmer Singh and others,
(1996) 11 SCC 77, but said Jagjit Singh (supra) which was a
later decision, distinguished the decision of Jasmer Singh
(supra) and observed that the said judgment is required to be
examined and explained independently. At paragraph no.46.9 of
Jagjit Singh (supra), it was also observed that it was not
necessary for the Bench to refer the matter for adjudication to a
larger bench, because the judgment in Jasmer Singh (supra),
was irreconcilable and inconsistent with a large number of
judgments, some of which were of larger benches, where the
benefit of the principle in question was extended to temporary
employees (including daily-wagers). This being the position, the
decision of Jasmer Singh (supra) is not further elaborated
herein.
(iv) Mr. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A. also relies on a
decision of the Division Bench of this Court in case of Sri
Sukradhan Chakma and others vs. the State of Tripura
and others, W.A. No.10 of 2023, decided on 05.03.2024 where
the petitioners sought for regularization and absorption in
service which was rejected by the learned Single Judge as there
was no policy of Government existent for absorption.
[13]
(v)
appellants
In
appeal
contended
before
that
the
they
Division
became
Bench,
the
entitled
for
regularization as Group-D employee with effect from the date
when they had completed 10 years of service as DRW and they
were having requisite qualifications of a Group-D employee and
they were discharging duties beyond 8 hours per day. They also
claimed that they were entitled to minimum wages as per
Minimum Wages Act, 1956. The Division Bench ultimately
upheld the judgment of the learned Writ Court holding that the
scheme as formulated by the State for regularization in terms of
the
direction of
Hon‟ble
Supreme
Court
in
the case of
Secretary, State of Karnataka and others vs. Umadevi (3),
(2006) 4 SCC 1, was already withdrawn by the State and the
regularization or absorption could only be made against the
sanctioned vacant post. Ultimately, their claim for regularization
was not accepted by the Division Bench. In the said case, there
was no claim for minimum of the pay scale of regular employee
and the claim of the appellants regarding minimum wages as
per Minimum Wages Act, 1956 was also not specifically
discussed in the said judgment.
[9]
Mr. K. De, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the state-
respondents in W.P.(C) No.705 of 2024 also made similar
submissions, like Mr. Sarma, learned Addl. G.A., Mr. De, learned
Addl. G.A. also relies on a decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme court
in the case of S.C. Chandra and others vs. State of
[14]
Jharkhand and others, (2007) 8 SCC 279. In the said
decision, in one appeal, the writ petitioner approached before
the High Court of Jharkhand for a direction to fix their pay scale
on a par with the pay scale of Government Secondary School
teachers or on a par with Grade I and II Clerks of the
respondent-Bharat Coking Coal Limited [for short, the BCCL].
They also prayed that the facilities such as provident fund,
gratuity, pension and other retiral benefits should also be made
available to them and the State Government should take over
the management of their school, namely Ram Kanali School
under the provisions of the Bihar Non-Government Secondary
Schools (Taking over of Management and Control) Act, 1981. In
the said case, the Bharat Coking Coal Limited [for short, the
BCCL] contended that the said Ram Kanali School was not
owned by the BCCL, rather it was run by the Managing
Committee and the writ petitioners were never appointed by the
BCCL and therefore, they were not the employees of BCCL.
According to them, they used to release non-recurring grants to
the privately managed schools on the recommendation of the
Welfare Committee subject to certain conditions and such
release of non-recurring grant-in-aid did not make the school a
part of the management of BCCL and therefore, any teacher in
such privately managed school could not be said to be the
employee of BCCL thereby entitling them all benefits as are
available to the regular employees of BCCL.
[15]
Learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition and
directed that the teachers of the said school were entitled to the
pay scale given to the clerks working in the BCCL with effect
from the date of the judgment with all consequential benefits
but did not issue any direction for taking over of the said school
by State of Jharkhand. The Division Bench in appeal came to the
conclusion that the incumbents were not entitled to the pay
scale of the employees of BCCL or equivalent to the Government
employees and accordingly, set aside the order of the learned
Single Judge.
Hon‟ble Supreme Court finally endorsed the view of
the Division Bench to be correct view on the ground that the
school was not being managed by BCCL, rather they were
extending only financial assistance to the said school and
therefore, they could not be saddled with the liability to pay
these teachers of the school as being paid to the clerks working
with BCCL or in the Government of Jharkhand.
[10]
In the supplementary note, His Lordship, Hon‟ble Mr.
Justice Markandey Katju concurring with the view of His
Lordship Hon‟ble Mr. Justice A.K. Mathur, who authored the
judgment, and keeping in view of the above said facts of the
case, at paragraph no.26 observed the followings:
26. Fixation of pay scale is a delicate mechanism which
requires various considerations including financial
capacity, responsibility, educational qualification, mode
of appointment, etc. and it has a cascading effect. Hence,
[16]
in subsequent decisions of this Court the principle of
equal pay for equal work has been considerably watered
down, and it has hardly ever been applied by this Court in
recent years.
As it appears that the said judgment was also passed
completely in a different factual matrix.
[11]
I have considered the submissions of both sides and
have taken due consideration to the materials placed in the
records and the above said decisions as relied upon by the
parties.
[12]
It is not disputed that the petitioner of W.P.(C)
No.704 of 2024, Sri Amaresh Debbarma was engaged as
contingent driver w.e.f. 16.11.2009 and the petitioner of
W.P.(C) No.705 of 2024, Sri Prahllad Debbarma was engaged as
Peon-cum-Night Guard w.e.f. 01.12.1994 and since then they
have been working under the control of DM & Collector, Khowai
till date. Though the petitioner of W.P.(C) No.704 of 2024, Sri
Amaresh Debbarma has claimed for minimum of pay scale of
driver (Group-C) but in the document relied upon by him under
Annexure-4 i.e. the letter dated 12.10.2012 of the DM &
Collector, Khowai his designation has been mentioned as Driver
(Group-D) and not Driver (Group-C). It is also true that for
more than a decade they are discharging their duties to the
satisfaction of the authorities of similar nature like other GroupD employees which are of perennial nature and related to day to
day official functions. Though from time to time their wages
[17]
were enhanced by the respondents but such enhancement will
not meet up the constitutional principle of “equal pay for equal
work”.
[13]
It is clearly discernible that both the petitioners are
performing
and
discharging
similar
duties
like
other
counterparts in the regular services. In Jagjit Singh (supra) it
is clearly observed by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court that it would
be fallacious to determine artificial parameters to deny the fruit
of the labour. An employee engaged for same work cannot be
paid in less amount then another who performed the same
duties and responsibilities.
[14]
Earlier thereto, in Putti Lal (supra) also, Hon‟ble
Supreme Court clearly observed that the principle of “equal pay
for equal work” would be applicable when a daily wager is
discharging the similar duties like those who are in regular
employment in the Government and they should receive the
minimum of the pay scale without any increment or allowances.
[15]
In view of the above position of law and considering
the facts of the case relating to both the writ petitions, it is held
that both of them are entitled to get the minimum of the pay
scale as meant for a Group-D employee without any increment
or allowance.
[16]
Both the petitioners have approached this Court in a
very belated manner. Considering thus, the respondents are
[18]
directed to extend the benefit of minimum of the pay scale of a
Group-D employee to both the petitioners from the period
preceding 3[three] years from the date of filing of their
respective writ petitions. Arrears should be paid within 3[three]
months from the date of receipt of the copy of this judgment
and order.
With such observations and directions, both these
writ petitions are allowed and accordingly, disposed of.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
shall
also
stand
disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2026.01.20 18:11:57 +05'30'
Sujay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review