Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. A. (J) 31/2022
Sri Ajoy Urang
son of Sri Badal Urang, resident of Chantail, P.O. + P.S. Kailasahar,
District- Unakoti Tripura (at present detained in Kailasahar District Jail,
Kailasahar, Unakoti, Tripura)
----Appellants
Versus
The State of Tripura
----Respondent
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing & delivery of :
Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. B. Banerjee, Advocate
Mr. S. Ghosh, Addl. PP
30.08.2023
Yes / No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(Amarnath Goud, J)
Heard Mr. B. Banerjee, learned counsel appearing for the appellant. Also
heard Mr. S. Ghosh, learned Additional PP appearing on behalf of the
respondent-State.
2.
This present appeal is filed against the judgment of conviction and order
of sentence dated 20.09.2021 passed in connection with case No. S.T./11
(UK) of 2020 by the learned Sessions Judge, Unakoti Tripura, Kailasahar,
whereby the learned Sessions Judge convicted the appellant for commission
of offence punishable under Section 302 of the IPC, and sentenced him to
suffer R.I. for life and also directed him to pay a fine of Rs. 10,000/- with
default stipulation.
3.
In short, the fact leading to institution of this appeal is that, on
20.06.2019 the appellant and his family members alongwith the family
members of the informant were invited in the house of Nadi Urang and after
taking dinner, they all went to sleep. In the intervening night of 20.06.2019
Page 2
and 21.06.2019 at about 02:00 hours, the informant heard screaming of
Fulmani Urang and someone had put on the lights and at that time he saw the
appellant giving dao blow indiscriminately to everyone who were in the
house, resulting which 6 persons sustained injuries out of whom Jhalo Urang
had succumbed to her injuries. Thereafter, the informant caught hold of the
appellant and tied him with rope in the verandah of his house and arranged for
shifting the injured to the hospital.
4.
The said complaint was registered as Irani PS case no. 45 of 2019. The
matter was investigated by the investigating officer, and after completion of
investigation submitted charge-sheet against the appellant under Sections 302/
307/326 of the IPC. At the commencement of trial, the learned Sessions Judge
had framed charge against the appellant to which he pleaded not guilty and
claimed to be tried.
5.
During trial, the prosecution to establish the charge had adduced 18
witnesses. After closure of recording evidences, the appellant was examined
under Section 313 Cr.P.C. wherein he denied all the allegations leveled
against him by the prosecution witnesses, but adduced 3 witnesses in his
defence. After hearing arguments and on examining the evidences and
materials on record, the learned Sessions Judge had convicted and sentenced
the appellant for committing offence, as aforestated. Hence, this appeal before
this court.
6.
Mr. Banerjee, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted
that the appellant is a patient of Epilepsy and when the appellant receives the
attack of Epilepsy, he fails to remember or recognize everything, and also he
loses control over himself. Learned counsel has also submitted that there is no
eye
witness
to
the
alleged
incident.
Learned
counsel
has
Page 3
further argued that none of the prosecution witnesses are trustworthy and
there evidence has no evidentiary value, hence, learned counsel has urged this
court to set the appellant at liberty. In fine, learned counsel has argued that
without properly appreciating the evidences on record, the learned trial court
had convicted the appellant.
7.
On the other hand, learned Additional PP appearing for the respondent-
State has urged to maintain the findings of the learned trial court since there is
no infirmity or illegality in the findings of the learned trial court.
8.
We have considered the submissions for learned counsel appearing for
the parties. We have perused the evidences and materials on record and the
judgment passed by the learned Sessions Judge.
9.
To substantiate the findings of the learned trial court, this court has
perused the deposition of the prosecution witnesses as well as the defence
witnesses wherefrom it is revealed that PW-1 is the eye witness to the alleged
incident. As per deposition of PW-1, on the alleged date, the appellant and his
family including the family of the informant were the invitees in the house of
PW-8 wherein after celebrating the occasion, they all went to sleep, but in the
night at about 2:00 PW-1 woke up from sleep after hearing hue and cry of
Fulmani Urang and later on someone had put on the light and thereafter he
saw the appellant was striking dao blow upon every persons in the house
resulting which Ajoy Urang, Fulmani Urang, Jhalo Urang, his wife Merry
Urang, daughter of Fulmani Urang, his son Elion Urang and another woman
sustained cut injuries on their person. He further deposed that thereafter, he
caught hold of the appellant and tied him with rope and kept aside in the
verandah of the house and arranged for shifting the injured to the hospital. He
further deposed that after two days Jhalo Urang had died in the hospital.
Page 4
PW-7 and PW-13 are the eye witnesses to the alleged incident. They
also stated to the same tune to that of PW-1.
The deposition of PW-1, PW-7 and PW-13 was corroborated by the
depositions of PW-2, PW-3, PW-4, PW-5, PW-6, PW-8. Though, these
witnesses were not the eye witnesses, but they conjointly deposed that the
appellant had caused dao blows upon the injured persons and they also could
name the injured persons. They also unequivocally stated that when they went
to the house of Nadi Urang, they saw the appellant was tied with rope in the
verandah of the house of Nadi Urang.
The deposition of PW-14, who conducted the post-mortem over the dead
body of the deceased Jhalo Urang also proves that the cause of death of Jhalo
Urang was due to impact of heavy sharp edged weapon.
PW-15, the Medical Officer, treated the injured persons in the hospital
and from his report it is well established that the injured persons received the
injuries due to assault with sharp cutting weapon.
10.
On the other hand, nothing material could have been elucidated
from the depositions of the defence witnesses, as produced by the appellant,
but the defence witnesses have unanimously stated that the appellant suffers
from Epilepsy and when the appellant receives the attack of Epilepsy, he loses
sense.
11.
On appreciation of the evidences of prosecution witnesses, there is
ample evidence and material implicating and establishing the appellant’s
involvement in crime beyond doubt. However, from the deposition of the
defence witnesses, it is seen that the appellant had been suffering from a
disease called ‘Epilepsy’ which means that the appellant has brain disorder
that causes recurring seizures. The episode of Epilepsy is totally absent in the
Page 5
trial and the same cannot be taken into consideration at this stage. However,
learned counsel for the appellant has placed some prescriptions and
documents before this court relating to the treatment of Epilepsy provided to
the appellant in jail since long. We have seen the said documents and
prescriptions, as produced by learned counsel for the appellant, which
according to us reveals that the appellant is being treated by the jail authority
for suffering from Epilepsy.
12.
Obviously the certificates produced from the jail authority as regards
the disease of the appellant, was an expert evidence about the nature and
consequence of the disease which would determine to the mental condition of
the accused at the time of the act. The defence witnesses also spoke about the
mental condition of the accused. Thus, it could be presumed that the accused
was in a disturbed state of mind on the alleged date of the incident. From the
examination of the accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C., it is seen that while
answering to question no. (3), the accused has replied “I donot know. I cannot
remember the matter of night. I gained my consciousness in the hospital.
There was injury on my face. Stitching was done. Again to answer question
no. (5), the accused has replied “I have forgotten. Fulmani is my wife. Why I
would kill her. To answer question no. (6), the accused has replied “My wife
Fulani her daughter Rubina is my daughter. Why I would kill them”. From
the answer to question no. (9), it is seen that, the accused has replied “I cannot
remember the matter of night of 15.01.2021. I have visited a house at day
time. I do not know whose house was than.” Again to question no. (64), the
accused has replied “I cannot remember what I do. When I go through the
disorder, I cannot remember what had happened on that night. I cannot
remember what had happened.”. From the entire examination of the accused
Page 6
under Section 313 CrPC, it is revealed that the accused was not at all aware of
the incident that took place due to his act and continuously he replied that he
is not responsible and he does not know anything since he cannot remember
anything. The medical certificates, as produced by learned counsel for the
appellant from the jail authority at least confirms that the accused suffers from
epilepsy. Epilepsy is a kind of disease which may cause insanity. In this
insanity, the patient may commit crime without knowing what he was doing.
Here also the accused, who suffered from epilepsy, has committed a brutal
murder. There is thus ground to believe that he may have committed this
murder in a fit of epileptic insanity. These things give rise to the inference
that the accused may have committed the crime in a fit of insanity and without
knowing that what he was doing either wrong or contrary to law. In the
instant case, there is no other involvement in the alleged crime except the
present appellant who has inflicted injuries to the victims by dao blow.
13. It is contended by learned counsel for the appellant that the appellant
cannot not be held guilty of murder under Section 302 IPC, but must be held
guilty of culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 IPC.
From the medical documents, as placed by the learned counsel for the
appellant and also going through the examination of the accused under
Section 313 CrPC, it can be presumed that the accused is a patient of
Epilepsy, who lost awareness during a seizure and also lost control upon
himself. Thus, in such peculiar situation, there seems to have no intention of
accused of causing such brutal crime, for which could not be held guilty either
of murder or of culpable homicide not amounting to murder but only of
causing simple injuries. Culpable homicide is of two kinds, culpable homicide
Page 7
amounting to murder and culpable homicide not amounting to murder. It is,
therefore, necessary first to examine the sections themselves.
“Section 299. Culpable homicide.—Whoever causes death by doing an act with the intention
of causing death, or with the intention of causing such bodily injury as is likely to cause
death, or with the knowledge that he is likely by such act to cause death, commits the
offence of culpable homicide.
300. Murder.—Except in the cases hereinafter excepted, culpable homicide is murder, if the
act by which the death is caused is done with the intention of causing death, or—
2ndly-If it is done with the intention of causing such bodily injury as the offender knows to be
likely to cause the death of the person to whom the harm is caused, or—
3rdly- If it is done with the intention of causing bodily injury to any person and the bodily
injury intended to be inflicted is sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death,
or—
4thly-If the person committing the act knows that it is so imminently dangerous that it must,
in all probability, cause death or such bodily injury as is likely to cause death, and commits
such act without any excuse for incurring the risk of causing death or such injury as aforesaid.
Exception 1- When culpable homicide is not murder- Exception 1.—When culpable homicide
is not murder.—Culpable homicide is not murder if the offender, whilst deprived of the
power of self-control by grave and sudden provocation, causes the death of the person who
gave the provocation or causes the death of any other person by mistake or accident.
The above exception is subject to the following provisos:—
First —That the provocation is not sought or voluntarily provoked by the offender as an
excuse for killing or doing harm to any person.
Secondly —That the provocation is not given by anything done in obedience to the law, or by
a public servant in the lawful exercise of the powers of such public servant.
Thirdly —That the provocation is not given by anything done in the lawful exercise of the
right of private defence.
Explanation.—Whether the provocation was grave and sudden enough to prevent the
offence from amounting to murder is a question of fact.
Exception 2: Culpable homicide is not murder if the offender, in the exercise in good faith of
the right of private defence of person or property, exceeds the power given to him by law
and causes the death of the person against whom he is exercising such right of defence
without premeditation, and without any intention of doing more harm than is necessary for
the purpose of such defence.
Exception 3: Culpable homicide is not murder if the offender, being a public servant or aiding
a public servant acting or the advancement of public justice, exceeds the powers given to him
by law, and causes death by doing an act which he, in good faith, believes to be lawful and
necessary for the due discharge of his duty as such public servant and without ill-will towards
the person whose death is caused.
Exception 4: Culpable homicide is not murder if it is committed without pre-meditation in a
sudden fight in the heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel and without the offender having
taken undue advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner.
Explanation: It is immaterial in such cases which party offers the provocation or commits the
first assault.
Exception 5: Culpable homicide is not murder when the person whose death is caused, being
above the age of eighteen years, suffers death or takes the risk of death with his own
consent.”
14. From the entirety, this court is of the opinion that the act of the accused
in the alleged crime is proved beyond reasonable doubt, but the said act was
due to temporary loss of self-control as the appellant might have suffered
seizure at that relevant point of time. There is, however, evidence of a medical
character before this court, and there are statements made by the defence
Page 8
witnesses, that the accused suffered from epileptic. The Court has had further
evidence especially in the prison records, of his having attacks of epilepsy.
Applying this exception, we would convert the conviction of the appellant
from Section 302 to Section 304 of the IPC.
"304. Punishment for culpable homicide not amounting to murder. Whoever commits
culpable homicide not amounting to murder, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or
imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also
be liable to fine, if the act by which the death is caused is done with the intention of causing
death, or of causing such bodily injury as is likely to cause death; or with imprisonment of
either description for a term which may extend to ten years, or with fine, or with both, if the
act is done with the knowledge that it is likely to cause death, but without any intention to
cause death, or to cause such bodily injury as is likely to cause death."
15. From the above discussion, we are of the view that the present case falls
under the exception contained in Section 300 IPC and is a case of culpable
homicide not amounting to murder, for which, maximum punishment
prescribed in Section 304 Part-II IPC is ten years.
Hence, this appeal is allowed in part. The conviction awarded to the
appellant
under Section
302 IPC
is
converted
into
the
conviction
under Section 304 Part II IPC, and sentence of life imprisonment awarded to
the appellant is reduced to 10 (ten) years, however, the appellant shall pay the
fine of Rs.10,000/- imposed by the trial court, in default of payment of fine, he
shall further undergo one year rigorous imprisonment
Send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
SAIKAT KAR
SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2023.09.04
14:49:15 +05'30'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review