The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
8. 10.88) Provided that in a case in which it is proposed to enhance punishment, the accused shall be given an opportunity to show cause either orally or in writing as to why his punishment should not be enhanced. (G.S.R. No-476 dt 22.4.80)” From the said order, it is evident that there had been no reference made, except to Section 11 of the Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949 which is evidently the source of drawing up any departmental proceeding against any enrolled member of the said force. Section 11(1) as referred provides: “11(1) The Commandant or any other authority or officer as may be prescribed, may, subject to any rules made under this Act award in lieu of or in addition to, suspension or dismissal any one or more of the following punishments to any member of the force whom he considered to be guilty of disobedience, neglect of duty, or remissness in the discharge of any duty or of other misconduct in his capacity as a member of the force, that is to say : (a) reduction in rank; (b) fine of any amount not exceeding one month’s pay and allowances; (c) confinement to quarters, lines or camp for a term not exceeding one month; (d) confinement in the quarter-guard for not more than twenty eight days with or without punishment drill or extra guard, fatigue or other duty; and (e) removal from any office of distinction or special emolument in the force.” Thus, it is apparen…
02. 03.2021 was passed, thereby reversing the order, passed by the Revisional Authority, and directing the dismissal of the petitioner from service. Mr. Deb has also brought to the notice of this court, the reply filed by the respondents, in response to the averment of the petitioner. In para 11 of the reply, filed by the respondents, the following has been stated: “11. That, in response to the averments made in para 2.7 of the writ petition under reply, I state that the averments made in this para are not tenable in the eye of law and hence denied. I further state that as per provision laid down in the Rule 29(D) and 30 of the CRPF , 1955, the re-instatement order passed by the IGP, Tripura Sector vide office order No.R.XIII-2/2020-TPAEstt-III dated 16/07/2020 was reviewed by the SDG, NEZ, CRPF, Guwahati and awarded him the punishment of dismissal from the force vide their office order No.R.XIII-01/2020-NEZCV-1 dated 02/03/2021 is correct. A copy of the re-instatement order dated 16/07/2020 is enclosed herewith and marked as Annexure-8 and a copy of the dismissal order dated 02/03/2021 along with its English translation is enclosed herewith and marked as Annexure-9.” Therefore, it is apparent that according to the reviewing authority, he has drawn the power of review from Rule 29(d) and Rule 30 of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955. For purpose of better reference, Rule …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP (C) No. 615 of 2021
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Adv.
Ms. R Chakraborty, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. B Majumder, Asst. SG.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Order
01.02.2022
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by
Ms. R Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as well
as Mr. B Majumder, learned Asst. SG appearing for the Union of Indiarespondents.
By means of this petition, the petitioner who is serving as
the constable under the Central Reserve Police Force has laid the facts
that a departmental proceeding under Section 11(1) of the Central
Reserve Police Force Act was initiated against him, on the charge that
by
producing
a
doubtful
document
as
regards
his
educational
qualification he had entered in the service. The said certificate was held
to be fake by the school authority. But in the meantime, the petitioner
had served the CRPF for thirteen years. The disciplinary authority, on
the basis of the inquiry report and following the process, dismissed the
petitioner from service by the order dated 17.02.2019 (Annexure-2 to
the writ petition). The petitioner being aggrieved thereof, preferred a
departmental
appeal
which
was
also
dismissed
by
order
dated
25.09.2019 (Annexure-3 to the writ petition). Thereafter, the petitioner
filed a revisional petition under Rule 29 of the Central Reserve Police
Force Rules, 1955. The revision petition had been considered and
disposed of by an elaborate order passed on 16.07.2021 (Annexure-4 to
the writ petition). By the said order, the order of penalty passed by the
disciplinary authority has been reversed with direction to reinstate the
petitioner with full back wages from the date of dismissal.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has apprised this court that
pursuant to the said order, the petitioner has been reinstated, but the
Addl. Director General, North Eastern Region Head Quarters, Central
Reserve Police Force has taken up for review of the order dated
16.07.2021 (Annexure-4 to the writ petition). That the said order dated
16.07.2021 was taken up for review came to be known to the petitioner
when the order in that proceeding was passed on 06.03.2021
(Annexure-6 to the writ petition). It has been observed in the said order
that as per the existing rules and the order No. 3/2004, and as per the
instructions contained in serial No. 49/93 of the Government of India,
whenever it is found that a government employee who was not fit for
employment or has furnished false information or a false document, he
shall not be retained in service. If he is under probation or is a
temporary government employee than he shall be freed from the
service, or his service shall be terminated. In case of permanent
government employees, as per the procedure prescribed in the rules,
inquiry shall be made, and if the charge is proved, then he shall be
dismissed or removed from the service. Under any circumstances, no
other penalty shall be imposed. Whenever in such cases, any decision is
made, then the staff may prefer an Appeal or seek for review of the
same, and on the basis thereof, also may approach the court inter alia
stating that he has served for a long-term period and for which
sympathetic approach may be taken in his favour. Hence, there is no
other alternative, other than taking into consideration of the instruction
and acting according to the provisions. This is perhaps the perceived
source of exercising the review jurisdiction by the said Addl. Director
General, North Eastern Region Head Quarters, Central Reserve Police
Force.
By the said order, the order passed by the revisional
authority has been set aside observing further that the petitioner does
not have the right to stay in the force and accordingly the order of
dismissal was restored. The petitioner has challenged that order dated
06.03.2021 (Annexure 6 to the writ petition) by means of this petition
on two fundamental grounds viz, (i) there is no provision of review in
the Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949 or Central Reserve Police
Force Rules 1955; and (ii) the provision that has been borrowed for
purpose of exercising the review jurisdiction is alien to the provisions as
applicable to the services of the petitioner. That apart, it appears that
such note of the Government of India as quoted in the impugned order
is emanating from Rule 29 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 which is for
review, but not applicable to the service of the petitioner.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has made an extensive
reference to Rule 29 of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955.
For purpose of reference, the entire provision of Rule 29 of the said
Rules is reproduced hereunder:
“29. Revision:
(a) A member of the Force whose appeal has been
rejected by a competent authority may prefer petition
for revision to the next Superior Authority. The power of
revision may be exercised only when in consequence of
some material irregularity, there has been injustice or
miscarriage of justice or fresh evidence is disclosed.
(b) The procedure prescribed for appeals under sub rules
(c) to (g) of rule 28 shall apply mutatis mutandis to
petitions for revision.
(c) The next superior authority while passing orders on a
revision petition may at its discretion enhance
punishment, Provided that before enhancing the
punishment the accused shall be given an opportunity to
show cause why his punishment should not be
enhanced:
Provided further that an order enhancing the
punishment shall for the purpose of appeal. be treated as
an original order except when the same has been passed
by the Government in which case no further appeal shall
lie and an appeal against such an or.er shall lie. (i) to the
Inspector General if the same has been passed by the
Deputy Inspector General: and (ii) to the Director
General, if the same has been passed by the Inspector
General , and (iii) to the Central Government, if the same
has been passed by the Director General.
(second proviso substituted vide GSR 476 dated 22.4.80)
(d) The Director General or the Additional Director
General or the Inspector General or the Deputy
Inspector General may call for the records of award of
any punishment and confirm, enhance, modify or annul
the same, or make or direct further investigation to be
made before passing such order: (GSR 784 dated
8.10.88)
Provided that in a case in which it is proposed to
enhance punishment, the accused shall be given an
opportunity to show cause either orally or in writing as
to why his punishment should not be enhanced.
(G.S.R. No-476 dt 22.4.80)”
From the said order, it is evident that there had been no
reference made, except to Section 11 of the Central Reserve Police
Force Act, 1949 which is evidently the source of drawing up any
departmental proceeding against any enrolled member of the said force.
Section 11(1) as referred provides:
“11(1) The Commandant or any other authority or officer
as may be prescribed, may, subject to any rules made
under this Act award in lieu of or in addition to,
suspension or dismissal any one or more of the following
punishments to any member of the force whom he
considered to be guilty of disobedience, neglect of duty,
or remissness in the discharge of any duty or of other
misconduct in his capacity as a member of the force, that
is to say :
(a) reduction in rank;
(b) fine of any amount not exceeding one month’s pay
and allowances;
(c) confinement to quarters, lines or camp for a term not
exceeding one month;
(d) confinement in the quarter-guard for not more than
twenty eight days with or without punishment drill or
extra guard, fatigue or other duty; and
(e) removal from any office of distinction or special
emolument in the force.”
Thus, it is apparent from the reference as made in the
impugned order dated 02.03.2021 that no other provision has been
invoked for taking up the review jurisdiction in order to examine the
legality or irregularity of the revisional order.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has further submitted that
on evaluation of the entire statute, the Central Reserve Police Force Act
and the Rules made thereunder, it would be apparent that the
legislature has not created any provision for review in the framework.
In view of that, the exercise of the review jurisdiction is ex facie illegal
and arbitrary. Moreover, before the decision was taken in that
purported review proceeding, he was never informed and thus he was
denied the valuable right of defending himself under the principles of
natural justice. On the face of it, the order dated 06.03.2021 is
unsustainable.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel in order to nourish his
submission has referred to paragraph 2.7 of the writ petition where the
petitioner has asserted that without issuing any show cause notice
therefor, in utter violation of the principles of the natural justice, and in
gross defiance of the statutory prescriptions, contained in the Central
Reserve Police force Act, 1949 & the CRPF Rules, the order dated
02.03.2021 was passed, thereby reversing the order, passed by the
Revisional Authority, and directing the dismissal of the petitioner from
service.
Mr. Deb has also brought to the notice of this court, the
reply filed by the respondents, in response to the averment of the
petitioner. In para 11 of the reply, filed by the respondents, the
following has been stated:
“11. That, in response to the averments made in para 2.7 of the
writ petition under reply, I state that the averments made in
this para are not tenable in the eye of law and hence denied. I
further state that as per provision laid down in the Rule 29(D)
and 30 of the CRPF , 1955, the re-instatement order passed by
the IGP, Tripura Sector vide office order No.R.XIII-2/2020-TPAEstt-III dated 16/07/2020 was reviewed by the SDG, NEZ,
CRPF, Guwahati and awarded him the punishment of dismissal
from the force vide their office order No.R.XIII-01/2020-NEZCV-1 dated 02/03/2021 is correct.
A copy of the re-instatement order dated 16/07/2020 is
enclosed herewith and marked as Annexure-8 and a copy of the
dismissal order dated 02/03/2021 along with its English
translation is enclosed herewith and marked as Annexure-9.”
Therefore, it is apparent that according to the reviewing
authority, he has drawn the power of review from Rule 29(d) and Rule
30 of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955. For purpose of
better reference, Rule 30 of the Central Reserve Police Force rules,
1955 is extracted:
“30. Petitions:
A Subordinate Officer or an officer of any other rank below him
including an enrolled follower who has any grievance may
present a petition subject to the condition that it should be
addressed to the officer of the lowest rank who is empowered
to pass the desired order.”
In the considered view of this court, the provisions of Rule
30 of the Central Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955 does not have any
relevance in the present context. As such, the fundamental question
this court is confronted with is whether the Rule 29(d) of the Central
Reserve Police Force Rules, 1955 provides the power of review or
provides the power of review by a different authority of the order
passed by the some other authority.
Mr. B Majumder, learned Asst. SG appearing for the
respondent has urged this court that if the decision of the revisional
authority is examined, it will shock the conscience of this court as a
person who has committed a serious misconduct by producing a
fraudulent document has been let off on consideration of his service for
thirteen years. The revisional authority has pointed out that the service
of the petitioner was outstanding and that fact, according to Mr.
Majudmer, learned Asst, SG is completely irrelevant for consideration
and on the basis of such consideration, the order of penalty passed by
the disciplinary authority and affirmed by the appellate authority has
been reserved. Such intervention is grossly illegal and beyond the
jurisdiction of the revisional authority. Mr. Majudmer has also referred
to a few decisions, but having considered those decisions, this court is
of the view that those are not germane to the present context and
accordingly, those decisions are not considered. Even no reference
therefrom is required to be made.
But the pertinent question that emerges from the challenge
is whether the CRPF Act or Rules provides any provision for review.
There is no controversy at the bar that there is no such provision in the
statute, as germane to the services of the petitioner. As such, now the
controversy melts down to one single point that whether Rule 29(d)
creates any authority for a superior officer to review the order passed
by the revisonal authority or to examine the legality or regularity of the
said order.
This is a threshold question of jurisdiction. Unless a person
wields jurisdiction, even if a meritorious case falls as he cannot exercise
that jurisdiction. This is the fundamental tenet of the rule of law.
From repeated readings of Rule 29(d), it cannot be held that
this rule has provided any authority to review any order under the CRPF
Act and Rules. It only provides the authority of revision.
As such, this court does not have any hesitation to hold that
the Addl. Director General, North Eastern Region Head Quarters,
Central Reserve Police Force has exercised the power of review without
jurisdiction and sanction of law. As such, the decision he has taken is ex
facie illegal and is bound to be interfered with. Accordingly, the
impugned order dated 02.03.2021 (Annexure-6 to the writ petition)
stands quashed and set aside. The petitioner shall be reinstated in
service w.e.f. 06.03.2021 within a period of one month from today and
he will be entitled to the back wages in terms of the revisional order.
However,
this
order
shall
not
create
any
impediment
for
the
respondents to challenge the legality and irregularity of the order before
the appropriate forum, if it is permitted by law.
In terms of the above, this writ petition stands allowed.
There shall be no order as costs.
A copy of this order be served to the counsel for the parties
for their benefit.
JUDGE
satabdi
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review