Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.77 of 2025
Sri Abhijit Das, son of Sri Naresh
Chandra Das, resident of Village
College Square & PO- Sarashima, PSBelonia, Sub-Division- Belonia, DistrictSouth Tripura, PIN-799155, aged about
36 years.
……… Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1.
The State of Tripura, represented by
the Commissioner & Secretary, Labour
Department, Government of Tripura,
having
his
office
at
Secretariat
Building, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New
Capital
Complex,
DistrictWest
Tripura, PIN-799006.
2.
The Commissioner & Secretary,
Labour Department, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Secretariat
Building, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New
Capital
Complex,
DistrictWest
Tripura, PIN-799006.
3.
The Commissioner & Secretary,
G.A. (P & T) Department, Government
of Tripura, having his office at
Secretariat Building, P.O. Kunjaban,
P.S. New Capital Complex, DistrictWest Tripura, PIN-799006.
4.
The Joint Recruitment Board of
Tripura, Employment Services & Man
Power
Planning
Department,
Government of Tripura, represented by
its Member Secretary, having his office
at Office Lane, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West
Agartala, District- West Tripura.
5.
The Member Secretary,
Joint Recruitment Board of Tripura,
Employment Services & Man Power
Planning Department, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Office
Lane,
P.O.
Agartala,
P.S.
West
Agartala, District- West Tripura.
6.
The Chairman,
Joint Recruitment Board of Tripura,
Directorate of Employment Services &
Man Power Planning Department,
Labour Department, having his office
at Office Lane, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West
Agartala, District- West Tripura.
7.
The Controller of Examination,
Joint Recruitment Board of Tripura,
Directorate of Employment Services &
Man power Planning Department,
Labour Department, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Office
Lane,
P.O.
Agartala,
P.S.
West
Agartala, District - West Tripura.
…….. Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing and
delivery of judgment
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. P Debbarma, Advocate.
Mr. M Debbarma, Addl.GA
:
20.08.2025
Whether fit for reporting
:
NO
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
20.08.2025
Heard learned senior counsel Mr. S Deb, assisted
by Mr. P Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. M Debbarma, learned Addl. GA appearing
for the respondents.
[2]
According to the petitioner, in pursuance of
advertisement No.1/2020 (Annexure-1) dated 27.11.2020
for recruitment of 1500 nos. of Lower Division Clerk, GroupC, Non-Gazetted posts, he applied for the said post and
thereafter,
another
notification
was
issued
Recruitment
Board
of
(JRBT)
on
Tripura
by
Joint
12.02.2021
(Annexure-2) adding further 910 nos. of posts [22 posts of
Agriculture Assistant (Except TAFS Grade-III), 443 posts of
Agriculture Assistant (TAFS Grade-III), 236 posts of Junior
Operator (Pump) and 209 numbers of post of Junior Multi
Tasking Operator (Uncommon)] in the said recruitment
process. It was also categorically mentioned in the said
notification that the candidates who had already applied for
the posts of 1500 nos. Lower Division Clerk, Group-C, NonGazetted posts would not require to apply once again in
respect of the newly added 910 Group-C posts and their
candidature for all the 2410 nos. Group-C posts would be
considered on their educational qualification etc.
[3]
It is the grievance of the petitioner that he scored
57 marks being a SC category candidate in the written
examination, but he was not called for document verification
and interview, despite the fact that in the advertisement
dated
12.02.2021
against
instruction
No.8
it
was
categorically mentioned that primary merit list would be
prepared by adding marks obtained in all papers of written
examination to restrict the number of candidates to be called
for interview, and candidates equivalent to three times to the
number of vacancies (1:3) shall be called for an interview
(category wise) subject to attainment of minimum qualifying
marks in written examination (35% for UR candidates and
30% for Reserved candidates).
[4]
Learned senior counsel Mr. Deb refers to clause
25 of the prospectus-cum-instruction manual issued by JRBT
in respect of the said recruitment process wherein also it was
mentioned that a candidate who would secure 35% (for UR
candidates) and 30% (for Reserved candidates) or more
marks, would be considered to have passed the examination
and the candidates who scored the pass marks or more,
would be asked for scrutiny of certificate/document of
academic and professional qualification.
[5]
Now, it is the primary grievance of the petitioner
that even though he has qualified the written examination,
was not called for document verification and interview. With
such grievance, he has filed the writ petition praying for the
following reliefs:-
(i) Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and
each one of them, to show cause as to why a Writ
of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall not
be issued, for directing them, to transmit the
records, lying with them, for rendering the
impugned
Notification
dated
29.11.2022
(Annexure-6 supra), Notice dated 30.11.2022
(Annexure-7 supra), Notification dated 13.09.2023
(Annexure-8 supra) & the Notification dated
13.09.2023 (Annexure-9 supra).
(II) Issue rule , calling upon the respondents and
each one of them, to show cause as to why a Writ
of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall
not be issued, for mandating/directing them, to
revoke/rescind the impugned Notification dated
29.11.2022 (Annexure-6 supra), Notice dated
30.11.2022 (Annexure-7 supra), Notification dated
13.09.2023 (Annexure-8 supra) & the Notification
dated 13.09.2023 (Annexure-9 supra), and
thereupon, for mandating/directing them, to
forthwith draw up a separate Select List for the
posts of Junior Operator (Pump) & Junior Multi
Tasking Operator (Uncommon);
(III)
Issue
Rule,
calling
upon
the
respondents and each one of them, to show cause
as to why a Writ of Prohibition and/or in the
nature thereof, shall not be issued, for
restraining/prohibiting them, from acting in any
manner, in furtherance of the impugned
Notification dated 29.11.2022 (Annexure-6 supra),
Notice dated 30.11.2022 (Annexure-7 supra),
Notification dated 13.09.2023 (Annexure-8 supra)
& the Notification dated 13.09.2023 (Annexure-9
supra);
(iv)
In the Ad-Interim, and thereafter, on
hearing the parties, an Order, in terms of Relief
(iii) supra;
(v) Call for the records appertaining to this
petition;
(vi) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make
the Rule Absolute in terms of i. to iv. above;
(vii) Any other Relief(s) as to this Hon‟ble High
Court may deem fit and proper;
[6]
Learned senior counsel Mr. Deb, submits that
despite having specific condition in the instruction manual
itself that candidates who obtained the qualifying marks
would be called for document verification, the recruiting
authority has violated the said condition by depriving the
petitioner from appearing for document verification and
thereafter for interview. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel also
submits that the petitioner was an aspirant for both the
posts of LDC, Group-C as well as Junior Operator (Pump) and
Junior Multi Tasking Operator (Uncommon). According to
learned senior counsel Mr. Deb, the provisions of ST/SC
Reservation Act, 1991 was also not properly followed in the
matter of determination of post meant for reserved category
candidates.
[7]
Learned Addl. GA Mr. M Debbarma, in reply firstly
refers to the acknowledgement slip (Annexure-5) issued by
JRBT in favour of the petitioners which shows that the
petitioner applied against the advertisement No.2/2020,
though in the column “post applied for” it was mentioned
that he had applied for Group-C post (LDC, Agri-Assistant,
Pump Operator, Multi Tasking Operator).
[8]
Learned Addl. GA Mr. Debbarma, also submits
that he has no proper information as to whether the
petitioner had applied against the advertisement No.1/2020
or against the advertisement No.2/2020. Mr. Debbarma, also
contends that the petitioner being SC category candidate
only scored 57% marks but as it was a common recruitment
process for all the above said five posts, a common merit list
meant for all the candidates who applied for different posts,
were prepared and published wherein the last candidate
called for interview under SC category scored 74% marks
which was higher than the marks obtained by the petitioner
and therefore, he was not called for document verification.
[9]
According to Addl. GA the process as followed by
the Recruitment Authority was totally in terms of the
advertisement and related instruction manual and no error
has been committed by said authority in selection of
candidates for above said posts.
[10]
This Court has considered the submissions of both
sides and also has gone through the records.
[11]
So far the first plea taken by the learned Addl. GA
that acknowledgement slip mentions that the petitioner has
applied for the advertisement No.2/2020, is concerned, it
appears that perhaps in the acknowledgement slip it was
wrongly mentioned by the JRBT, as against the column
“posts applied for”, it was specifically mentioned that the
petitioner had applied for Group-C post.
Even in their
counter affidavit also the respondents have categorically
stated in paragraph No.8 that the petitioner had scored 57
marks out of total 170 marks in the written examination
whereas the last provisionally qualified candidate of „SC‟
category scored 74 marks and that a separate examination
was conducted by JRBT on 20.08.2021 for the post of Multi
Tasking Operator (Group-D) following the advertisement
notification No.2/2020 dated 03.12.2020.
[12]
Above said assertions of the respondents itself
clarifies the position that advertisement No.02/2020 was
relating to a Group-D post whereas the petitioner applied for
Group-C post and his marks was counted with reference to
the
advertisement
No.01/2020
and
not
against
the
advertisement No.02/2020.
[13]
So far the second challenge of the respondents
that the petitioner got less mark than what the last
provisionally qualified candidate of SC category had scored,
is concerned, said matter along with matters of challenge
made by the petitioner are already decided by this court on
12.08.2025 in another identical writ petition being WP(C) No.
264/2024 in between Sri Kinkar Bhowmik vs. The State
of Tripura & Ors., and therefore, no detailed discussion is
required to be repeated in this judgment. The present writ
petition is wholly covered by said decision. Some of the
relevant portions of the judgment in Kinkar Bhowmik’s
case is also extracted hereunder:
“[18]
Said memorandum dated 26.7.2018 takes into account the fact
of differences between a general posts and a technical posts for the purpose of
selection process through written examination with further noting that the
pattern and syllabus for written examination may be different for technical and
non-technical posts. For clubbing of posts for common recruitment process, it is
also indicated therein that the posts of similar nature i.e. LDC, LDC (Store) and
LDC (certificate) may be clubbed together in a common recruitment process. It
is also further suggested therein that the recruiting agency should go for such
selection process based on the attitude and skill set required for a particular
posts. Here in the case in hand, post of lower division clerk is a general post
and Junior Operation (pump), Junior Multitasking Operator (un-common) are
technical posts for which separate trade certificate are required for
appointment against said posts. But the JRBT has failed to take note of said
guidelines and proceeded for selection through a common recruitment process
just only for the reason all these posts are Group-C posts.
[19]
That apart, the Clause 25(a) and Clause25(c) of the prospectus
cum instruction manual as indicated earlier clearly shows that a candidate who
secures 35 per cent marks (for UR candidate) and 30 per cent marks (for
reserved candidate) or more will be considered to have passed the written
examination and they will be asked for their appearance for scrutiny of
certificates/documents. If said instructions is read with instruction No.8 as
mentioned in the notification dated 12.02.2021(Annexure-2), it becomes quite
clear that primary merit list will be prepared by the recruiting agency based on
the marks obtained by a candidate in all papers of written examination for
short listing purpose and candidates who have qualified the written
examination with above said minimum marks or above will be called for
interview subject to the ratio 1:3. In instruction No.8 it is clearly and
specifically mentioned that such 1:3 ratio shall be determined „category-wise‟.
The word category-wise‟ has to be read keeping in mind said clarification or
guideline issued by the state in memorandum dated 26.7.2018. But most
erroneously, the JRBT has read the word „category-wise‟ in the instruction no.8
as category-wise representation of the candidates based on the reservation rule
such as UR, SC or ST. The categorization as made by JRBT as discernable form
the counter-affidavit submitted by the Respondent nos. 1-3 is also reproduced
herein below:
Vacancy details
Total
Post
Category-wise
vacant post
Category wise total
number of
vacancies
UR
ST
SC
Total number of candidates
called for document
verification and interview
process
Category-wise
provisionally
qualified candidates
UR
ST
SC
Total of Number
candidates who
came under the
purview of the 1:3
ratio including
candidate(s)
scoring marks equal
to that of the last
candidate in
thewritten
examination called
for interview and
document
verification process
Total
PwD
Total ExServiceman
Total
PwD
Total ExServiceman
This chart itself indicates that without taking into consideration the fact
that the different nature of posts under the advertisements require different
qualifications, nature of works and skill. But the JRBT not only clubbed together
all these posts at the initial stage of the process, even maintained the same till
the end of the process including the phase of interview, by misconstruing said
clarification or guidelines issued by the state. One will fail to understand as to
what purpose would be or have been served by taking all „UR‟ category of
candidates into one group for interview purpose though they were aspirant of
different nature of jobs and similarly the „SC‟ category and „ST‟ category as
other two distinct categories.
[20]
Here, category-wise vacancy against each post under the
advertisement in terms of said instruction no.8 was not taken into account by
the recruiting authority while calling the candidates for interview. Such
erroneous process adopted by the JRBT by misconstruing the recruitment rules
or procedure has led to the possibility of debarring a genuine candidate(s) from
appearing before the interview board in respect of a particular post despite
qualifying the written examination. An example in this regard will demonstrate
the situation with more clarity. Suppose in respect of an advertisement for
filling up 10 post of LDC and 10 posts of Pump Operator, total 60 candidates (3
times of total vacancy) of „ST‟ category have been called for oral interview
according to their merit position and out of said 60 candidates, 55 candidates
have actually applied for the post of LDC and only 05 candidates have applied
for the post of Pump Operator; by said process as adopted, 05 posts of Pump
Operator will certainly remain still vacant and this way the other candidates
who also applied for the post of Pump Operator, despite qualifying the written
examination, would be deprived of appearing before the interview board and
from getting the job, which will ultimately lead the selection process to be
frustrated to a considerable extent. This is what has actually been happened in
the instant case. The data as has been placed in the notification of JRBT dated
13.09.2023 (Annexure-A to the supplementary affidavit of the petitioner)
projects that out of total 209 numbers of post of Junior Multitasking Operator,
only 8 numbers of posts were filled up and total 201 nos. of posts remained still
vacant. Similarly against total 236 nos. of posts of Junior Operator (Pump),
only 54 numbers of posts could be filled up and rest 182 numbers of posts still
remained vacant. For the above said reasons, the procedure as adopted by
JRBT in the instant recruitment process for short listing of candidates for oral
interview is not at all acceptable.
[21]
Some anomaly is also noticed regarding determination of
vacancies meant for reserved category of candidates. The following chart as
placed in the affidavit in opposition of respondent nos.1-3 and as indicated
earlier is again reproduced here under at the cost of repetition, for convenience
of examination and discussions:
Vacancy details
Total Post Category-wise
vacant post
Category wise total
number
of
vacancies
UR
ST
SC
Total
PwD
Total
ExServiceman
The above chart leaves the impression that out total 2410 nos. of
vacant posts of all categories, the recruiting authority determined the UR
category posts to be 1253 i.e.(52%), ST category to be 747(31%) and SC
category to be 410(17%) by straightway calculating the percentage from the
total nos. of vacancy.
[22]
In this respect Section 4(1) and Section 2(e) of the Tripura
Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe Act, 1991 require reference. Both the
above said provisions are extracted below:
“2. Definitions.
In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires --………………………………………………………………………………
……………………
(e) “Establishment” means [any office under the State] , a local
or statutory authority constituted under the constitution of India
or any other law for the time being in force or a Corporation in
which not less than fifty one percent of the paid-up share
capital is held by the State Government and includes
Universities and Colleges affiliated to the Universities, Primary
and Secondary Schools and also other educational institutions
which are owned or aided by the State Government and also
includes an establishment in Public Sector ;”
“4. Reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes [in
services and posts under the State] to be filled up by direct
recruitment.
[(1) Reservation for the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled
Tribes in any vacancy or vacancies in services or posts in an
establishment which are to be filled up by direct recruitment]
shall be regulated in the following manner, namely –
[(a) There shall be seventeen percent reservation for the
Scheduled Castes and thirty one percent reservation for the
Scheduled Tribes in the manner as set out in the schedule;]
[Provided that the State Government may from time to time
review the implementation of the reservation policy and take
adequate measures including increase of percentage
mentioned in sub-section (a) above]
(b) The candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes and the
Scheduled Tribes who qualify for selection on merit shall be
included in the general list and not against reserved quota ;
(c) Fees, if any, prescribed for any examination for selection to
any service or post shall be reduced to one-fourth in the case
of candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes and the
Scheduled Tribes ;
(d) The members of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled
Tribes shall be entitled to a concession of five years over the
prescribed maximum age limit for appointment to any service
or post. [and also for admission to educational institutions and
undergoing any kind of training]"
[23]
On plain reading of sub-section(1) of Section 4 of the said Act, it
appears that reservation for the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes in
any vacancy in services or posts in an establishment (emphasis laid) which are
to be filled up by direct recruitment shall be regulated in the manner as
prescribed in the said provision and also as set out in the schedule of the Act.
Further Section 2(e) defines the word „establishment‟ to be any office
(emphasis laid), a local or statutory authority constituted under the
Constitution of India or any other law for the time being in force or a
Corporation in which not less than fifty one percent of the paid-up share capital
is held by the State Government etc.
[24]
Further schedule of the said Act also prescribes that the
reservation for the schedule castes and scheduled tribes in the service or posts
both in case of direct recruitment and promotion in an establishment (emphasis
laid) shall be given effect in accordance with two rosters namely hundred point
roster as shown in the table (a) and replacement roster as shown in Table (b)
of the said Schedule. The above said provisions, without any ambiguity, lay
down that determination of number of posts under reserved category should be
made office-wise. Therefore the procedure of first amalgamating all vacant
posts of different departments under different categories and then to determine
such vacancy position of reservation by way of making calculation of
percentage from the total vacancy is also erroneous, in as much as when the
recruitment process was initiated, the vacancy position of posts under reserved
quota would like to be different in each offices and also in respect of different
posts. Proper procedure, as such, would be to collect information of vacancy
position both post wise as well as department wise to be manned by reserved
category of candidates and thereafter to finally determine the number of
vacancies reserved for schedule caste and schedule tribes candidates.
[25]
Ld. Addl. GA, Mr. De tries to highlight the principle that when a
person consciously participates in any recruitment process without raising any
objection regarding terms and condition of such recruitment, he cannot
thereafter challenge the same. But said principle is not also applicable in the
present case, for, the petitioner nowhere has challenged the terms and
condition of such recruitment rather he himself also insisting for proper
adherence to the same by the recruiting authority. His challenge is regarding
misconstruction of said terms by JRBT.
[26]
In view of above discussions, it is held that the proper procedure
was not followed by the JRBT in terms of the instructions as borne in the
advertisements as well as prospectus cum instruction manual, and also in
terms of the clarification and guidelines issued by the State regarding the
Recruitment Policy as noted earlier. Even the provisions of the Tripura Schedule
Castes and Schedule Tribes Reservation Act, 1991 do not appear to have been
followed properly while determining the number of posts meant for reserved
category candidates. Therefore, the selection process is required to be
interfered with. However, the position of the candidates who have already been
selected, will remain unaffected and undisturbed, as admittedly, they scored
higher marks in the written examination occupying higher position in the merit
list than the candidates who were not called for interview and there is also no
challenge or allegation that such recruitment process was vitiated by biasness
or unfairness.
[27]
Consequently, the writ petition is allowed. The respondent no. 4
to 7 are directed to take up again the process of filling up of rest vacant posts
of LDC, Junior Operator (Pump), Junior Multitasking Operator (Un-common),
Agricultural Assistant (TAFS Grade III) where vacancies still remain, and in that
process, firstly, the candidates who have already scored the cut off marks i.e.
qualifying marks or above in the written examination, shall be called for
document verification and during that stage the respondent Nos.4 to 7 will
ascertain the posts against which they actually applied for. Thereafter, separate
lists will be prepared post-wise at the ratio of 1:3 on the basis of their merit
position in the written examination and the persons who comes under the zone
of consideration for calling for interview, will only be called for such interview
and final list of selected candidates will be prepared and published thereafter.
Simultaneously, the respondent No.4 to 7 shall also re-visit the vacancy
position meant for reserved category of candidates in respect of above said
posts under advertisements, in the light of the discussions made in paragraph
nos. 21 to 24 above. It is also clarified that the candidates who despite calling
for interview in the earlier phase of the selection process, remained
unsuccessful, will also be called for interview again, if their names find place in
the list prepared as per said ratio of 1:3.
[28]
The respondent Nos.4 to 7 will make endeavour to complete the
entire process within next 6 months.”
[14]
In the light of above said decision in Kinkar
Bhowmik’s case this writ petition is also disposed of with
the similar direction as given in said case and no further
separate order/direction is required to be passed in the
present case.
The respondents No.4-7 are accordingly directed
to act in accordance with the directions mentioned in
paragraph Nos. 27 and 28 of the judgment of Kinkar
Bhowmik’s case as extracted above.
With the above said terms the writ petition is
disposed of accordingly.
Interim application(s), if any, also stand disposed
of.
JUDGE
signed by SATABDI DUTTA
SATABDI DUTTA Digitally
Date: 2025.08.25 18:27:32 +05'30'
Satabdi
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review