The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. Having applied for promotion in the year 2014, before acquiring the minimum qualification, the respondent would be aware of the necessity for filing a fresh application on acquiring the qualification. It is the duty of the respondent to seek promotion on acquiring the qualification, since the University or the College would not be aware of the acquisition of qualification WA NO. 1464 OF 2022 2025:KER:30737 by the respondent. Having submitted a belated application, the respondent now cannot give a go-by to her own laches and contend that the University ought to have granted her promotion against Clause 6.3.12. The learned Single Judge went wrong in properly appreciating the literal interpretation of Clause 6.3.12 of Ext.P1. The respondent is entitled for promotion only in terms of Clause 6.3.12 of Ext.P1, i.e., from the date of her application after acquisition of the qualification as provided under clause (b) of that Regulation. In such circumstances, the impugned judgment is liable to be set aside. In the result, the writ appeal is allowed by setting aside the impugned judgment dated 07.06.2022 in W.P.(C)No. 4181 of 2020 and the writ petition stands dismissed. Sd/ANIL K.NARENDRAN, JUDGE Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE sks
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WA NO. 1464 OF 2022
2025:KER:30737
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 1464 OF 2022
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 07.06.2022 IN WP(C) NO.4181 OF 2020 OF
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS:
SREE SANKARACHARYA UNIVERSITY OF SANSKRIT
REPRESENTED BY THE REGISTRAR, KALADY, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT683 574.
THE SELECTION COMMITTEE FOR THE POST OF PROFESSOR IN
ENGLISH DEPARTMENT, SREE SANKARACHARYA UNIVERSITY OF
SANSKRIT, KALADY, ERNAKULAM DISTRICT-683 574, REPRESENTED
BY ITS CHAIRMAN (VICE CHANCELLOR).
SRI.DINESH MATHEW J.MURIKAN
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
DR. NISHA VENUGOPAL
AGED 57 YEARS, D/O.P.VENUGOPAL, PROFESSOR, DEPARTMENT OF
ENGLISH, SREE SANKARACHARYA UNIVERSITY OF SANSKRIT, KALADY,
ERNAKULAM DISTRICT-683 574, RESIDING AT 6/342, FLAT NO.Al,
DOCTORS DIAMOND HILL APARTMENTS, IDAMALAYAR IRRIGATION
PROJECT ROAD (I.I.P ROAD), EAST NAGAR, NEAR SNDP, ANGAMALY683 572.
BY ADVS.
SAIJO HASSAN,NAGARAJ NARAYANAN(K/700/1994),BENOJ C
AUGUSTIN(K/189/2004.),
ABRAHAM J. KANIYAMPADY(K/3280/2023)
SANGEETH MOHAN(K/3399/2023)
V.P.REJITHA(K/899/2001)
MEERA J. MENON(K/000860/2024)
THIS WRIT APPEAL WAS FINALLY HEARD ON 18.03.2025, THE COURT ON
10.04.2025 PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
WA NO. 1464 OF 2022
2025:KER:30737
JUDGMENT
Muralee Krishna, J.
This is an intra-court appeal filed under Section 5(i) of the
Kerala
High
W.P.(C)No.4181
Court
Act,
of
1958,
by
the
respondents
challenging
the
judgment
in
dated
07.06.2022 passed by the learned Single Judge in that writ
petition directing the 1st appellant University to issue appropriate
orders granting the benefit of promotion to the respondent in the
cadre of Professor with effect from the date on which she had
acquired her minimum eligibility qualification in June 2015.
2. The facts that led to the filing of the above writ appeal can
be summarised as follows:
The respondent
entered the service of 1st
appellant
University as a Junior Lecturer on 20.08.1998. The post of Junior
Lecturer was subsequently redesignated as Lecturer and then as
Assistant Professor as per the UGC norms. The respondent was
later placed in the cadre of Reader, which was redesignated as
Associate Professor on 20.08.2010. The respondent completed
three years of service in the cadre of Associate Professor on
20.08.2013. She
acquired mandatory scores on
Academic
WA NO. 1464 OF 2022
2025:KER:30737
Performance Indicators (API scores) on the Performance Based
Appraisal System (PBAS) for the cadre of Professor as per the UGC
Regulations on 10.12.2014. She submitted Ext.P2 application
dated 10.12.2014 for the purpose of placing her in the cadre of
Professor. According to the respondent, the application has to be
assessed by the 2nd appellant as per UGC Regulations, 2010.
Though the Regulation does not contemplate any scrutiny by the
Screening Committee, the 1st appellant University as a practice
placed the application before the Screening Committee. By Ext.P4
decision, the Screening Committee refused to recommend the
name of the respondent to the Selection Committee for the reason
that the respondent had been lacking three publications out of five
mandatory publications, since the respondent counted some
publications wrongly from her old publications. Subsequently, by
the publications listed in Ext.P3 in June 2015, the respondent
secured the number of publications that required and fully
qualified for promotion to the cadre of Professor. The Screening
Committee considered the application of the respondent and took
Ext.P5 decision dated 16.04.2018 and recommended to place the
application of the respondent before the Selection Committee. In
WA NO. 1464 OF 2022
2025:KER:30737
that decision, the Screening Committee recommended the
placement of the respondent with effect from the date of fifth
publication. Subsequently, on 11.03.2019, by Ext.P6 decision the
Selection Committee recommended to place the respondent in the
cadre of Professor with effect from her date of eligibility. By Ext.P7
order dated 22.06.2019 the 1st appellant placed the respondent in
the cadre of Professor with effect from 28.09.2017. Aggrieved by
Ext.P7, the respondent preferred Ext.P8 representation dated
18.07.2019 before the 1st appellant seeking to place her in the
cadre of Professor from her original date of application. However,
the 1st appellant by Ext.P9 reply dated 13.08.2019 refused to
place the respondent from the date of her original application.
Thereafter the respondent approached this Court with the writ
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking a
writ of certiorari to quash Exts.P7 and P9 to the extent it
determined the effective date of placement of the respondent in
the cadre of the Professor as 28.09.2017 instead of June, 2015.
The respondent also sought for a declaration that she is entitled
to be placed in the cadre of Professor in English in the 1 st appellant
University with effect from the date of acquisition of 5 th
WA NO. 1464 OF 2022
2025:KER:30737
publication, that is from June 2015 and also a writ of mandamus
commanding the appellants to confer the respondent, placement
in the cadre of Professor in English with effect from the date of
acquisition of her 5th publication.
3.
The
1st
appellant
filed
a
counter
affidavit
dated
11.01.2021 producing therewith Exts.R1(a) and R1(b) documents.
It is contended in the counter affidavit that the respondent
submitted Ext.R1(a) application only on 28.09.2017 producing the
articles. Though she had submitted Ext.P2 application, she was
not having the required minimum publications as mandated in the
UGC Regulations and thus her application was defective. The
Screening Committee was constituted as per the provisions of
Statute 4 of Chapter III of Sree Sankaracharya University of
Sanskrit Statutes, 1997. By virtue of Ext.R1(b) order dated
16.09.2015 issued by the 1st appellant, the respondent has also
been part of the Screening Committee and is thus well aware of
the statutory procedures. Ext.P2 application submitted by the
respondent
publications.
was
rejected
as
she
did
not
have
sufficient
As per the UGC Regulations, the respondent is
eligible for placement only from the date of the application fulfilling
WA NO. 1464 OF 2022
2025:KER:30737
the criteria and hence the respondent was entitled for placement
with effect from 28.09.2017 only. Ext.P2 application was rejected
and hence she cannot take a contention that the application was
pending.
4. To the counter affidavit, the respondent filed a reply
affidavit dated 09.07.2021. After hearing both sides, the learned
Single Judge allowed the writ petition as said above.
5. Heard the learned counsel on both sides.
6. The learned counsel for the appellants argued that the
interpretation given by the learned Single Judge to sub-clause (b)
of Clause 6.3.12 of UGC Regulations, 2010 is illegal. The Court
cannot read anything to a statutory provision which is plain and
unambiguous. The respondent acquired the required qualification
for promotion only in the month of June 2015. Ext.P2 application
filed by her before acquiring the required qualification was
rejected by Ext.P4 decision of the Screening Committee. Hence
Ext.R1(a) application submitted by the respondent on 28.09.2017
cannot be considered as a continuation of Ext.P2 application.
Therefore the finding of the learned Single Judge entitling the
benefit of promotion to the respondent from June 2015, is
WA NO. 1464 OF 2022
2025:KER:30737
incorrect.
7. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent
submitted that Ext.P2 application submitted by the respondent
was not rejected by the appellants. Ext.P5 minutes of the
Screening
Committee recommended
her
placement
in the
promotion post with effect from the date on which her fifth
publication was published or one year after the date of her
previous assessment whichever is later. In such circumstances, no
interference is needed to the impugned judgment.
8. The 1st application claiming her placement in the cadre
of
Professor
made
10.12.2014. As per
by
the
respondent
was
Ext.P2
dated
Clause 6.3.12 of Ext.P1 UGC Regulations,
2010, (a) If a candidate applies for promotion on completion of
the minimum eligibility period and is successful,
the date of
promotion will be from that of minimum period of eligibility, (b) if,
however, the candidates find that he/she fulfils the eligibility
conditions at a later date and applies on that date and is
successful, his/her promotion will be effected from that date of
application fulfilling the criteria, (c) of the candidate does not
succeed in the first assessment, but succeeds in the eventual
WA NO. 1464 OF 2022
2025:KER:30737
assessment, his/her promotion will be deemed to be from the later
date of successful assessment.
9. On the date of 1st application in the year 2014, the
respondent was not qualified for promotion since a sufficient
number of publications as per UGC Regulations 2010 was not there
in her account. Therefore, as per Ext.P4 decision of the Screening
Committee her claim for promotion was rejected. She acquired
the qualification in the month of June 2015 by publishing her fifth
publication. However, she chose to submit an application for
promotion only on 28.09.2017 by Ext.R1(a). The said application
was scrutinised by the Screening Committee and recommended
her promotion by Ext.P5. The Selection Committee also satisfied
with
the
qualification
of
the
respondent
and
decided
to
recommend the respondent in the cadre of Professor in English by
Ext.P6 minutes dated 11.03.2019. By Ext.P7, the University
accorded sanction and notified the placement of the respondent in
the cadre of Professor with effect from 28.09.2017. The reading
of Clause 6.3.12 (b) makes it clear that if a candidate fulfils the
eligibility conditions at a later date, his or her promotion will be
effected from the date of application fulfilling the criteria. If he or
WA NO. 1464 OF 2022
2025:KER:30737
she is entitled for promotion from the date of acquiring the
minimum eligibility period, then there need not be three clauses
in Clause 6.3.12. Clause (a) meets the situation when the
candidate applies for promotion on completion of minimum
eligibility period and is successful. In that case, the date of
promotion will be from the date of the minimum period of
eligibility. Clause (c) makes it further clear that the candidate who
does not succeed in the first assessment as that of the respondent
herein, but succeeds in the eventual assessment, his or her
promotion will be deemed to be from the later date of successful
assessment. By going through the literal meaning of Clause 6.3.12
of Ext.P1 Regulations, one cannot stretch it to the extent of giving
the benefit of clause (b) from the date of acquisition of minimum
qualification.
10.
Having applied for promotion in the year 2014, before
acquiring the minimum qualification, the respondent would be
aware of the necessity for filing a fresh application on acquiring
the qualification. It is the duty of the respondent to seek
promotion on acquiring the qualification, since the University or
the College would not be aware of the acquisition of qualification
WA NO. 1464 OF 2022
2025:KER:30737
by the respondent. Having submitted a belated application, the
respondent now cannot give a go-by to her own laches and
contend that the University ought to have granted her promotion
against Clause 6.3.12. The learned Single Judge went wrong in
properly appreciating the literal interpretation of Clause 6.3.12 of
Ext.P1. The respondent is entitled for promotion only in terms of
Clause 6.3.12 of Ext.P1, i.e., from the date of her application after
acquisition of the qualification as provided under clause (b) of that
Regulation. In such circumstances, the impugned judgment is
liable to be set aside.
In the result, the writ appeal is allowed by setting aside the
impugned judgment dated 07.06.2022 in W.P.(C)No. 4181 of 2020
and the writ petition stands dismissed.
Sd/ANIL K.NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
sks
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review