Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 745 OF 2021
Sourav Bhattacharya,
son of Dr. Debasish Bhattacharya,
resident of Krishnanagar, Agartala,
P.O. Agartala, District: West Tripura, PIN:799001
– Vs –
………… Petitioner
1.
Union of India,
represented by the Secretary,
Ministry of Education, Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi:110001
2.
National Institute of Technology, Agartala,
Represented by the Director, National Institute of Technology,
Agartala, Sub Division : Jirania, District: West Tripura,
P.O. Tripura Engineering College, PIN: 799055
3.
The Director,
National Institute of Technology, Agartala,
Sub Division : Jirania, District: West Tripura,
P.O. Tripura Engineering College, PIN: 799055
4.
The Registrar,
National Institute of Technology, Agartala,
Sub Division : Jirania, District: West Tripura,
P.O. Tripura Engineering College, PIN: 799055
5.
The Chairman,
Advisory Committee on Faculty Recruitment (ACOFAR),
National Institute of Technology, Agartala, Sub Division : Jirania,
District: West Tripura, P.O. Tripura Engineering College,
PIN: 799055
6.
The HOD, Department of Mathematics,
National Institute of Technology, Agartala, Sub Division : Jirania,
District: West Tripura, P.O. Tripura Engineering College,
PIN: 799055
………… Respondents
For the petitioner
:
For the respondents
:
Mr. P Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. K Nath, Adv
Ms A Debbarma, Adv
Mr. B Majumder, Asst. SG
Date of hearing
Date of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
:
02.04.2022
28.04.2022
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
Judgment & Order
The petitioner, in response to the Faculty Recruitment Notice
dated 26.02.2021 issued by the National Institute of Technology (NIT),
Agartala (Annexure-1 to the writ petition) had applied for the post of Assistant
Professor (Grade-II) in Mathematics. The said post was under open category.
According to the petitioner, he had all the requisite qualifications for the said
post. The petitioner had uploaded the documents/certificates in support of his
eligibility. Those certificates have also been enclosed with the writ petition. The
application that was uploaded by the petitioner is available with the reply filed
by the respondents. The said copy is the computer generated copy for which it
transpires that the petitioner had the following educational qualifications:
Exam
Adm
Year
Pass
Year
School/Inst
Board/Uni
Private/govt.
Matric/10th
Pre Uiv/12th
UG
Bhavans Tripura
Vidyamandir
Hindi Higher
Secondary School
Presidency College
Central Board of Secondary
Education
Central Board of Secondary
Education
University of Calcutta
GOVERNMENT/CFTI
PG
University of Calcutta
GOVERNMENT/CFTI
PH.D
Department of Pure
Mathematics,
University of Calcutta
University of Alabama
at Birmingham, USA
University of Alabama at
Birmingham, USA
GOVERNMENT/CFTI
2.
NIRF
Rank &
Year
% Mark
/CGPA
Class/Grade/Awd
Date/Def Date
PRIVATE
A1
GOVERNMENT/CFTI
82.6
A1
I-Class
81.3
I-Class
01/05/2021 /
05/03/2021
But it is to be noted that the petitioner has shown his PG degree
from the Department of Pure Mathematics, University of Calcutta and no other
PG degree has been shown in the said online application. That part, it has
been provided that the petitioner has acquired the Ph.D degree in the year
2021, precisely on 01.05.2021 / 05.03.2021. On the basis of the said disclosed
educational qualifications, the petitioner was graded „eligible‟ as would be
apparent from the scrutiny carried out for shortlisting the ten candidates. The
shortlist (Annexure-5 to the writ petition) contains the name of the petitioner
at Sl. No. 83 clearly showing the petitioner as eligible based on his qualification
but he was not shortlisted as eligible candidate while preparing the final
shortlist from the provisional list of candidates. It is further apparent from the
notification dated 25.08.2021 (Anneuxre-4 to the writ petition) that the
following criterions were followed for shortlisting candidates:
“Shortlisting criteria for pay level-10
1. 10th level for weightage 10%
2. 12th level for weightage 10%
3. UG level for weightage 20%
4. PG level for weightage 30%
Total weightage
=70%
Shortlisting criteria for pay level-11 & 12
1. 10th level for weightage 05%
2. 12th level for weightage 05%
3. UG level for weightage 20%
4. PG level for weightage 30%
5. CP level for weightage 10%
Total weightage
=70%”
3.
In the notification issued by the Registrar, NIT, Agartala it has
been clearly stated that the candidates may send their representation or lay
their grievances, if any, relating to the said shortlist by 29.08.2021.
4.
It has been stated by the petitioner that the petitioner had
immediately mailed his grievances to NIT, Agartala on 26.08.2021 (Annexure-6
to the writ petition). In the said communication/representation the petitioner
had disclosed that he had two Masters degrees in Pure Mathematics, one from
University of Calcutta, which he had secured in the year 2015 with 81.3%
marks and the other in Applied Mathematics from University of Alabama,
Birmingham, USA with 4.0 out of 4.0 CGPA in 2017.
5.
While applying online, he noticed that there was only one
space/tab for entering the masters‟ marks and so he had entered the marks
from the University of Calcutta to show continuation of his studies. He could
not find any room in the prescribed MIS format to mention his latter Masters‟
marks from University of Alabama, Birmingham, USA.
6.
At that point of time, the petitioner had no knowledge that
shortlisting will be done exclusively on the basis of the academic performance.
According to the petitioner, he realized after publication of the shortlist that
the score in the masters‟ degree played a significant role in the shortlisting.
Then he had requested the NIT, Agartala to consider his latter masters marks
in Applied Mathematics. The petitioner has stated that he was awarded the
best Ph.D student by the Department of Mathematics, University of Alabama,
Birmingham, USA for excellence in the graduate studies in Dynamical Systems.
He has also attached the certificate in support of that claim.
7.
Mr. P Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. K Nath,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has strenuously argued that the
method of shortlisting as applied in this case is in deviation from the declared
policy of NIT, Agartala. In the Faculty Recruitment Notice (Anneuxre-1 to the
writ petition) under General Instructions for Recruitment of Faculty positions, it
has been provided that the institute has the right to set norms higher than
minimum and areas of specialization will be taken into account, for addressing
the specific requirement of the individual departments. The shortlisting norms
may not be uniform across the departments/posts of the Institute and shall be
binding on all the applicants. The decision of the Institute related to all matters
pertaining to the recruitment shall be final and binding on the applicants.
8.
It may not be out of place to refer, even though Mr. Roy Barman,
learned senior counsel has not made any reference to that aspect, that it has
been also provided in the said Faculty Recruitment Notice that the minimum
qualifications, experience and credit points are the minimum criteria only for
deciding
the
eligibility.
This
shall
not
ensure
short-listing
for
the
Interview/Selections. The Institute [NIT, Agartala] reserve rights to set a
higher criterion for short listing. The Institute reserves the right to screen and
call only those candidates who are found prima-facie suitable for being
considered by the Selection Committee. Thus, just mere fulfilling the
prescribed conditions would not entitle a candidate to be called for
presentation and interview. The Institute reserves the right to restrict the
number of candidates to be called for interview to a reasonable exent on the
basis of qualifications and experience, higher than the minimum prescribed in
the advertisement and other academic achievements. Candidates shall have
the bright career throughout with education from the reputed institutions.
Thereafter, the mode of interview has been provided and it has been
categorically stated that the final shortlisted candidates might be required to
appear in the written test/certificate verification/department presentation, etc.
9.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel has quite robustly
asserted that the communication dated 25.03.2021 issued by the University of
Alabama at Birmingham, USA (Annexure-9 to the rejoinder filed by the
petitioner) shall be treated as the provisional certificate within the meaning of
the Provisional Certificate, as provided under clause 41 of Faculty Recruitment
Notice. According to Mr. Roy Barman, it has been clearly certified by the
University of Alabama that the petitioner has successfully defended his
dissertation on March 5, 2021 and he has conformed to all degree
requirements. The official diploma date will be May 1, 2021. He has also taken
us to the degree of Ph.D as awarded on 01.05.2021 (Anneuxre-10 to the
rejoinder).
10.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel has further submitted
that the respondents have unabashedly deviated from the laid down criteria as
circulated by the communication dated 17.11.2017 (part of Annexure-7 to the
writ petition). According to that guidelines, the department will make attempt
to set “shortlisting criteria” that can be easily implemented. But, considering
the multiple attributes the need is to be considered. It may become necessary
to make case by case exceptions. In all such cases, the general shortlisting
criteria and the reasons for exception, if any, are to be recorded in writing. The
shortlisting criteria may include, among others, such conditions as:
(i) superior academic record – all through first class career or
higher grades in B.Tech/M.Sc./M.Tech, higher than advertised
criteria,
(ii) reputation of institutions from where the candidate has
obtained his degrees,
(iii) number of unsuccessful attempts for the same post
[Candidates who have been rejected in the past may be called
only if there is a good reason, the reason to be recorded in
writing.]
(iv) specialization, including micro-specialization,
(v) professional service record – reputation of organization
where experience has been earned, nature of job, current
activities etc.
According to Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel, the said
guidelines are binding on the NIT, Agartala.
11.
Finally, Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel has submitted
that by not considering the petitioner‟s Ph.D degree and his degree of M.Sc in
Applied Mathematics as awarded by the University of Alabama in Birmingham,
USA, the respondents have acted arbitrarily and to the serious detriment of the
petitioner. Hence, he has urged this court to direct the respondents to
reconsider the shortlisting and include the petitioner in the shortlist so that the
petitioner can appear before the selection committee for interview.
12.
Mr. B Majumder, learned Asst. SG having appeared for the
respondents, has stated that the petitioner had failed to submit his certificate
of M.Sc. in Applied Mathematics and his degree of Ph.D with his application
that was made online. That apart, the respondents have categorically stated in
their reply that the petitioner failed to submit the necessary documents within
the stipulated time. It has been stated in para 12 of the reply filed by the
respondents as follows:
“As because subsequently it has been found that he
had not the requisite degree of Ph.D on the last date
of application on 31.03.2021 but only on 1st May,
2021 he obtained the said degree. So he had no
requisite qualification on the last date of submission
of online application for the post as such not eligible
for the post applied for.”
13.
The respondents have categorically denied that there had been
no space for incorporating the petitioner‟s second M. Sc./Ph.D degree in the
online application form, but he did not submit the same for the reason best
known to him. It has been further stated by the respondents that in the online
application form, the petitioner has mentioned the date of award of Ph.D
degree as 01.05.2021. Similar contents existed in the transcript issued by the
University of Alabama on 16.06.2021 which is after a long period from the last
date of submission of the online application, i.e. 31.03.2021. According to the
respondents, the date of award of Ph.D degree is 01.05.2021 and the
petitioner has not mentioned further details to appreciate his qualification on
the basis of those certificates.
14.
There is no dispute that the last date of filing the application in
terms of the said Faculty Recruitment Notice was 31.03.2021. The second PG
certificate was communicated by the petitioner on 26.08.2021 which is far
beyond the date of submission of the application. As such, the respondents
have also asserted that it had been clearly mentioned in the Faculty
Recruitment Notice that applications received without required documents shall
not be accepted by the institute, if submitted after 31.03.2021, if any.
15.
Mr. Majumder, learned Asst. SG has categorically referred to the
Faculty Recruitment Notice where the conditions, etc, have been laid down. It
has been provided under the General Instructions for Recruitment of the
Faculty Positions, that (i) after final submission, the data cannot be altered
further; (ii) all qualifications, experience and the preferred age limit will be
considered as on the last date of submission of application online i.e.
31.03.2021. Based on those stipulations, Mr. Majumder, learned Asst. SG has
submitted that the subsequent introduction of the second M.Sc. certificate,
after the shortlist was public, is of no use and the petitioner cannot garner any
advantage therefrom. That apart, the communication dated 25.03.2021 cannot
be treated as the provisional certificate inasmuch as this is a certificate
recording the petitioner‟s completion of the degree requirements, but the
degree of Ph.D had not been awarded and it was declared that the official
degree of Ph.D will be awarded on 01.05.2021.
16.
In support of his plea, Mr. Majumder, learned Asst. SG has relied
on a decision of the apex court in Rekha Chaturvedi Vs. University of
Rajasthan & Ors. reported in 1993 Supp (3) SCC 168 where the apex
court has laid down the guidelines for the future selection process. In the said
guidelines the following clause, according to Mr. Majumder, learned Asst. SG,
has relevance in the present controversy.
“11. …….
B. The candidates selected must be qualified as on
the last date for making applications for the posts in
question or on the date to be specifically mentioned
in the advertisement/notification for the purpose. The
qualifications acquired by the candidates after the
said date should not be taken into consideration, as
that would be arbitrary and result in discrimination. It
must be remembered that when the advertisement/
notification represents that the candidates must have
the qualifications in question, with reference to the
last date for making the applications or with reference
to the specific date mentioned for the purpose, those
who do not have such qualifications do not apply for
the posts even though they are likely to acquire such
qualifications and do acquire them after the said date.
In the circumstances, many who would otherwise be
entitled to be considered and may even be better
than those who apply, can have a legitimate
grievance since they are left out of consideration.
………………”
17.
To appreciate the rival contentions as projected by the counsel
for the parties, we have scrutinized the averments in the writ petition and the
reply filed by the respondents, along with the rejoinder filed by the petitioner.
It has been alleged by Mr. P Roy Barman, learned senior counsel that the
criteria based on which the shortlisting has been made is not in tune with „the
guidelines‟ inasmuch as the petitioner has stated that paras 15 and 18 of the
Appendix A1 clearly provide that the shortlisting would be on the basis of
multiple attributes. The personal interview is not part of the shortlisting criteria
but from the notification dated 25.08.2021, it is found that the Faculty
interaction and presentation have been made part of the shortlisting criteria by
keeping 30% weightage on that count.
18.
The petitioner is utterly confused in respect of the criteria as
disclosed in the said notification dated 25.08.2021. The question that has been
robustly raised by the petitioner is whether the interview or the personality test
has been considered for shortlisting.
19.
In the reply, the respondents have stated that no document
relating to the award of Ph.D degree or for securing the M. Sc. Degree in
Mathematics from Alabama University had been uploaded along with the
application filed online before the last date of application i.e. 31.03.2021.
Therefore, the petitioner was not at all eligible to be shortlisted. On the basis
of information as laid down in the online application, the petitioner was
declared eligible but on final scrutiny it has been found by the respondents
that the petitioner was not eligible as there was no valid document of the
petitioner‟s having the Ph.D degree.
20.
Moreover, this court has noticed that there is no challenge
against the criteria based on which the shortlisting has been made. The reliefs
sought in the writ petition are (i) to quash the provisional shortlist; (ii)for
declaration that the petitioner is shortlisted for the post of Asst. Professor
(Grade-II) in the Pay level-10 in Mathematics at NIT, Agartala; (iii) for
quashment of email dated 15.09.2021 issued by the Head of Department,
Mathematics rejecting the petitioner‟s application dated 26.08.2021.
21.
It is apparent on the face of the writ petition that there is no
challenge against the „criteria‟ that has been laid down by the respondents for
shortlisting the eligible candidates. It has been categorically declared by the
Faculty Recruitment Notice that eligibility will be adjudged prima facie for
shortlisting (See para 20 of the Faculty Recruitment Notice). Thus, the
contention of Mr. P Roy Barman, learned senior counsel that once the
petitioner has been declared eligible, the respondents cannot cancel his status
as such or can hold the view that the petitioner was not suitable.
22.
The plea that the respondents ought to have considered the
documents viz, the degree certificate of M.Sc issued by the University of
Alabama and the Degree certificate of Ph.D. which were admittedly filed after
31.03.2021, the last date of filing the application [those were filed along with
the representation dated 26.08.2021] is unique in nature requiring close
scrutiny. The certificates those are not filed before the closing date or the
certificate which indicated the possibility of the conferment of the degree
cannot be considered inasmuch as in Rekha Chaturvedi (supra) the apex
court in unequivocal terms has held that the candidate must have the
qualification in question with reference to the last date for making the
application or with specific reference to the last date for making the application
or with reference to the specific date mentioned for the purpose, those who do
not have such qualifications do not apply for the posts even though they are
likely to acquire such qualifications and do acquire them after the said date. In
the circumstances, many who would otherwise be entitled to be considered
and may even be better than those who apply, can have a legitimate grievance
since they are left out of consideration. It has be categorically observed that
the qualification acquired by the candidates after the last date should not be
taken into consideration as that would be arbitrary and would result in
discrimination.
23.
As already noted, there is no challenge against the criteria as laid
down by the respondents. Even there is no averment that in terms of the
unchallenged criteria, the petitioner is entitled to shortlisting. The two
documents which could not be filed before 31.03.2021 cannot be taken into
consideration for obvious reasons. Afterwards, the petitioner may not press for
consideration of those documents for purpose of his shortlisting.
24.
The cumulative effect of those observations as made above, is
that the petitioner has not been shortlisted even though he was declared prima
facie eligible by those criteria as laid down by the respondents. This court does
not have any hesitation to hold that those criteria as laid down by the
respondents for shortlisting do not suffer from any infirmity, even after those
are tested in terms of the guidelines or provisions as made in the Faculty
Recruitment Notice, as reproduced before. Hence, this writ petition is bereft of
merit.
25.
In the result, this writ petition is bound to fail. Accordingly, it
stands dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
lodh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review