Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.08.24
TELEN KOM Date:
15:34:40 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.433 of 2022
Shri Sorensangbam Nabadwip Singh, aged about 41 years old, S/o
S. Tomba Singh a resident of Kiyam Siphai, Amvreijam Leikai PO &
PS Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur
…Petitioner
– Versus –
1. The
State
of
Manipur
represented
by
the
Principal
Secretary/Commissioner, Consumer Affairs, Food and Public
Distribution, Government of Manipur, Old Secretariat Block, PO
& PS Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
2. The Director, Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution,
Government of Manipur, Sangaiprou FCS Complex, PO Imphal
PS Lamphel, Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
…. Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. HS Paonam Sr. Adv.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. KH. Athouba, GA
Date of reserved.
:
31.07.2023
Date of Judgment & Order :
23.08.2023.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. HS Paonam, the learned senior counsel for the petitioner
and Mr. Kh. Athouba, the learned Government Advocate for the
respondents.
[2]
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner to quash the
impugned order dated 11.5.2022 passed by the second respondent and
to direct the respondents to reconsider the case of the petitioner for
appointment to the post of Civil Supply Inspector in Consumer Affairs,
Food and Public Distribution, Government of Manipur against the 16
available vacancies.
[3]
The case of the petitioner is that pursuant to the advertisement
dated 16.12.2017 the petitioner had applied for the post of Civil Supply
Inspector and competed along with other eligible candidates in the
recruitment process. The roll number of the petitioner is 3254(A) and he
was successful in the written test. In the notification dated 3.1.2017, the
roll number of the petitioner appeared at Serial No.6 of the ST category,
however, the name of the petitioner was replaced by the name of Palmei
Poupangai.
Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner has filed W.P.(C)
No.222 of 2017 before this Court and, by the order dated 16.7.2018, the
said writ petition was dismissed. After the dismissal of the writ petition, on
12.1.2022, the petitioner approached the second respondent for providing
certain information in regard to the vacancy position for the post of Civil
Supply Inspector in CAF & PD Department and the petitioner has received
information on 19.1.2022 stating that there are 16 vacancies in the
Department.
Thereafter, on 29.3.2022, the petitioner submitted a
representation to the Hon’ble Chief Minister for considering his case for
providing the benefit of appointment. Since no positive response received
on the representation dated 29.3.2022, the petitioner again submitted two
representations on 26.4.2022 and 27.4.2022 before the second
respondent.
The second respondent by the impugned order dated
11.5.2022 rejected the request of the petitioner on the ground that due to
typographical mistake, the Role No.3254(A) occurring at Serial No.6 of ST
category was wrongly typed and after acknowledging the mistake a
corrigendum dated 3.1.2017 was issued rectifying the mistake.
Challenging the same, the petitioner has filed the present writ petition.
[4]
The respondents filed affidavit in opposition stating that due to
typing mistake the roll number of the petitioner was wrongly inserted and
the petitioner had applied for the post of Civil Supply Inspector under OBC
category and, as such, his name could not be proposed in the ST
category. It is stated that inserting the roll number of the petitioner in the
select list of the ST category was a typographical mistake and a
corrigendum was issued on the same day thereby correcting the error. It
is stated that the overall mark obtained by the petitioner is much lower
than the overall marks obtained by the selected candidates both in the ST
as well as OBC category. Based on the overall mark obtained by the
petitioner, his name could never have been recommended in the select
list of Civil Supply Inspector.
After considering the existing facts, the
representation of the petitioner was rejected. Hence, prayed for dismissal
of the writ petition.
[5]
Assailing the impugned order, the learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that since the petitioner found to be declared successful in the
written test under Roll No.3254(A) and had also participated in the vivavoce under the same roll number and having regard to the vacancies now
available in the Department, the petitioner should be considered for the
post of Civil Supply Inspector.
[6]
Mr. HS Paonam, the learned senior counsel further submitted that
rejecting the representation of the petitioner by referring to the order of the
dismissal of the earlier writ petition filed by him clearly shows the nonapplication of mind.
[7]
The learned senior counsel urged that one cannot take advantage
of their own wrong inasmuch as one cannot be victimized because of the
commission and omission on the part of the authority. Therefore, the
respondent authorities who are responsible for the controversy which left
the petitioner as the victim of the circumstances, adequate reasonable
consideration by way of extending the benefit of reconsideration against
one of the available post without disturbing the other candidate including
the one bearing Roll No.3254 which is not found in the list of successful
candidate in the written test would be equitable consideration acceptable
to all concerned and a way which may not prejudice the interest of third
party. Thus, a prayer has been made to reconsider the case of the
petitioner for affording appointment to the post of Civil Supply Inspector.
[8]
Per contra, Mr. Kh. Athouba, the learned Government Advocate for
the respondents submitted that inserting the roll number of the petitioner
in the select list of the ST category was a typographical mistake and a
corrigendum was issued correcting the said error.
The petitioner had
applied for the post in question under OBC category and, therefore, his
name could not be proposed in the ST category. The mark obtained by
the petitioner is lower than the overall marks obtained by the selected
candidates both in the ST as well as OBC.
[9]
The learned Government Advocate further submitted that in
W.P.(C) No.222 of 2017, this Court held that showing of Roll No.3254(A)
in the list of successful candidates against the ST quota declared by the
authorities was a clerical mistake, as the petitioner never recommended
by the Selection Committee.
[10]
The learned Government Advocate added that after thoroughly
analyzing the representation of the petitioner, the representation of the
petitioner was rejected on the ground (a) the petitioner was an OBC
candidate and insertion of roll number of the petitioner in the ST
appointment list was typographical mistake and (b) the High Court in its
order dated 16.7.2018 in W.P.(C) No.222 of 2017 had dismissed the writ
petition stating that there is no merit in the petition as the petitioner was
never recommended by the Selection Committee. As the name of the
petitioner was not recommended by the Selection Committee as also the
overall mark obtained by the petitioner is much lower than the mark
obtained by the selected candidates, the learned Government Advocate
prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.
[11]
This Court considered the rival submissions and also perused the
materials available on record.
[12]
The case of the petitioner is that though he was shown to have been
declared successful for appointment to the post of Civil Supply Inspector,
he has not been given appointment and instead one Palmei Poupangai
has been given appointment. The further case of the petitioner is that he
was assigned Roll No.3254(A) and having shown to be declared
successful in the result, denying appointment on the ground that there was
typographical error in inserting the roll number of the petitioner in the
select list is unacceptable. Further, taking into consideration the untold
misery inflicted upon the petitioner and also number of posts available in
the Department, the petitioner should be considered for appointment to
the post of Civil Supply Inspector.
[13]
Earlier the petitioner filed W.P.(C) No.222 of 2017 contending that
though his name was shown to have been declared successful for
appointment to the post of Civil Supply Inspector, he has not been given
appointment and one Palmei Ponpangai was given appointment. By the
order dated 16.7.2018, the said writ petition was dismissed by this Court
holding that the controversy has arisen only because of the fact that the
roll number of the petitioner which is 3254(A) has been shown against the
name of Palmei Ponpangai at the time of declaration of the results. It is
seen from the records of the proceedings of the selection committee that
Palmei Ponpangai was one of the candidates who was recommended
against the ST category for appointment to the aforesaid post of Civil
Supply Inspector whose actual Roll Number is 3254 as shown in the
corrigendum dated 3.1.2017 issued by the authorities in this regard, but
due to certain mistakes, Palmei Ponpangai has been shown to having the
Roll Number 3254(A) which actually belongs to the petitioner. Ultimately,
the findings of this Court in the earlier round of litigation is that showing of
Roll Number 3254(A) in the list of successful candidates against the ST
quota declared by the authorities on 2.1.2017 was a clerical mistake as
the petitioner was never recommended by the Selection Committee for
appointment, for which, the authority also made necessary correction as
mentioned in the corrigendum dated 3.1.2017. Resultantly, this Court
dismissed the writ petition filed by the petitioner. Admittedly, the petitioner
has not challenged the said order of this Court dated 16.7.2018.
[14]
After the dismissal of the writ petition, the petitioner submitted
several representations to the second respondent for considering his
name for appointment to the post. The last representation of the petitioner
is dated 27.4.2022, wherein, the petitioner, inter alia, stated that he had
applied for the post of Civil Supply Inspector under OBC category and in
view of the admit card issued by the competent authority by mentioning
the Roll Number as 3254(A), it is only the petitioner who was declared as
successful candidate for the post. The act of the officials concerned in
regard to replacement of the name and roll number of the petitioner by
one Palmei Poupangai is discriminatory to the extent that fundamental
right of the petitioner has been deprived of.
[15]
Admittedly, the aforesaid plea of the petitioner has been considered
by this Court in the earlier round of litigation in W.P.(C) No.222 of 2017
and dismissed the said writ petition. Therefore, the petitioner cannot now
canvass the same plea in this writ petition.
While rejecting the
representation of the petitioner, the second respondent stated as under:
“I am directed to refer to your letter No. Nil dated 27.04.2022 on
the above subject and to states that in the notification
no.1/910/2015-CAF&PD
dated
3rd
Jan.,
2017,
due
to
typographical mistake, the roll no.3254(A) occurring at Sl.No.6 of
ST category was wrongly typed. After acknowledging the mistake
a corrigendum was issued on 3rd January, 2017 rectifying the
mistake.
The Hon’ble High Court of Manipur had also dismissed the
petition, W.P.(C) No.222 of 2017 (Sorensangbam Nabadwip
Singh v. The state of Manipur & 2 Ors) filed by you on 16.07.2018
by giving the judgment that showing Roll No.3254(A) in the list of
successful candidates against the ST quota was a clerical
mistake.
Considering the facts and circumstances given above your
request cannot be acceded.”
[16]
In view of the categorical finding arrived at by this Court in the
earlier round of litigation, this Court cannot find any infirmity in the order
impugned. If this Court express any opinion on the merits of the impugned
order, it would have a direct impact on the order passed by this Court in
W.P.(C) No.222 of 2017. As stated supra, the wrong mentioning of the roll
number and its correction thereafter has been considered by this Court in
the earlier round of litigation instituted by the petitioner. In view of the
above, this Court is not inclined to enter into the said factual aspect.
[17]
Now the prayer of the petitioner is that there are 16 vacancies
available in the Department and taking into consideration of the situation
faced by the petitioner, his case has to be re-considered by the respondent
authorities.
[18]
According to the learned senior counsel for the petitioner, one
cannot take advantage of their own wrong inasmuch as one cannot be
victimized because of the commission and omission on the part of the
authority. The respondent authorities are responsible for the controversy
which left the petitioner as a victim of circumstances. Reasonable
consideration by way of extending the benefit of reconsideration against
one of the available posts without disturbing the other candidate including
Roll No.3254 would be equitable consideration.
[19]
The petitioner had obtained RTI information dated 19.1.2022 in
respect of the available vacancies for the post of Civil Supply Inspector.
On a perusal of the same, it is seen that out of the sanctioned 71 posts,
55 posts have been filled and there are 16 vacancies available. The said
letter has not been disputed by the respondents.
[20]
The consideration of the petitioner to the post of Civil Supply
Inspector in the existing vacancies is within the domain of the respondent
authorities. Exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the High Court cannot issue any positive direction to the
respondents to afford appointment to the post of Civil Supply Inspector to
the petitioner, as prayed for by him. At the same time, the untold misery
inflicted upon the petitioner cannot ignored. Therefore, in the interest of
justice, it would be appropriate to remit the matter to the respondent
authorities for consideration of the case of the petitioner in accordance
with law.
[21]
In the result,
(i) The writ petition is disposed of.
(ii) The matter is remitted to the respondent
authorities for considering the claim of the
petitioner and pass orders on merits and in
accordance with law.
(iii) The said exercise shall be carried out by the
respondent authorities within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.
(iv) There will be no order as to costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review