The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. Accordingly, this petition is disposed of with a direction to the official respondents to conduct and conclude an enquiry regarding the residential status of respondent No. 5 as on the date of submission of her application for engagement as ReT Teacher in Upgraded Primary School, Manghal, within 30 days from the date of receipt of a copy of this order, and thereafter proceed in accordance with the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir & Others v. Saba Wani, 2026 INSC 439.
15. In view of the above, the relief sought by the petitioner for a direction to respondent No. 2 to approve the recommendation dated 15.10.2014 of respondent No. 3 and engage the petitioner as ReT Teacher in the aforesaid school cannot be granted at this stage. (Rajnesh Oswal) Judge Jammu
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU &KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
…
SWP No. 1732/2015
Reserved on: 08.07.2026
Pronounced on: 23.07.2026
Uploaded on: 23.07.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced: Full
Sonia Kumari
…….Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Ashok Sharma, Advocate
Versus
State of J&K and ors..
…..Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Achal Sharma, Advocate
Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner has filed this writ petition for quashing of the panel dated
15.07.2014 prepared by respondent No. 4, whereby private respondent
No. 5 has been placed at Serial No. 1 for engagement as a Rehbar-eTaleem (ReT) Teacher (Science) in Upgraded Government Primary
School, Manghal, Zone Arnia. The petitioner also seeks a direction
upon respondent No. 2 to approve and finalize the recommendation of
respondent No. 3 made vide communication No.CEOJ/30188 dated
15.10.2014 and to engage the petitioner against the said post.
2.
Brief facts necessary for disposal of the writ petition are that respondent
No. 3, vide Advertisement Notice No. 10 of 2014 DIP/J-2313 dated
SWP No. 1732/2015
10.07.2014, invited applications for engagement of three ReT Teachers
(Math & Science, Social Science and Language) in Upgraded Primary
School, Manghal, Zone Arnia under the SSA Scheme. The petitioner
applied for the post of ReT Teacher in the Science stream for the said
School alongwith other eligible candidates.
3.
The petitioner's grievance is that respondent No. 5, though placed at
Serial No. 1 in the select panel, was not the resident of the concerned
village/habitation on the cut-off date, as she had shifted her residence to
Village Swankha More, Tehsil Vijaypur, District Samba, where she was
also working as an Anganwadi Worker. It is alleged that respondent No.
5 secured her name in the panel on the strength of false residential
documents. The petitioner relies upon resolutions of the Panchayat and
Village Level Education Committee (VLEC), ration card, voter lists and
other material to substantiate her claim. It is further pleaded that
respondent No. 3, after considering her objections, recommended her
candidature vide communication dated 15.10.2014, but respondent No.
2 has failed to accord approval, compelling the petitioner to invoke the
writ jurisdiction of this Court.
4.
The official respondents have contested the writ petition by asserting
that respondent No. 5 was found eligible after the verification of her
Residence Certificate, Permanent Resident Certificate, Voter Card and
other relevant documents. It is pleaded that her candidature was duly
recommended by the Village Education Committee and verified by the
competent authorities. According to the respondents, successive
enquiries established that respondent No. 5 is a resident of Village
SWP No. 1732/2015
Manghal and that Village Manghal and Village Rakh Manghal are
separate revenue villages. It is further stated that her temporary
engagement as an Anganwadi Worker did not render her ineligible for
ReT engagement and, in any case, such engagement stood terminated.
The respondents have also raised the plea that the writ petition involves
disputed questions of fact.
5.
Respondent No. 5, in her reply, has supported the stand of the official
respondents and submitted that she fulfilled all the eligibility conditions
and had produced all the requisite documents establishing her
permanent residence in Village Manghal. She has further stated that her
residence was repeatedly verified by the competent authorities during
the enquiries initiated on the petitioner's complaint and all such
enquiries confirmed her eligibility. It is also contended that the
petitioner belongs to Village Rakh Manghal, a separate revenue village,
and was therefore not entitled to claim engagement in the school
situated at Village Manghal. According to respondent No. 5, her
temporary engagement as an Anganwadi Worker did not constitute any
disqualification for appointment as ReT Teacher.
6.
Mr. Ashok Sharma, learned counsel for the petitioner, submitted that
respondent No. 5 was ineligible for engagement under the ReT Scheme
as she was not residing in the concerned village on the cut-off date. It
was argued that her permanent residence was at Village Swankha More,
District Samba, where she was residing serving as an Anganwadi
Worker. Learned counsel further submitted that respondent No. 3 found
merit in the petitioner's objections and recommended her candidature
SWP No. 1732/2015
vide communication dated 15.10.2014, but respondent No. 2 failed to
act upon the said recommendation.
7.
Per contra, Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, learned counsel appearing for the
official respondents, submitted that respondent No. 5 was duly reflected
in the panel after verification of all relevant documents and in
accordance with the applicable rules. She contended that repeated
enquiries conclusively established her residence in Village Manghal
and that her temporary engagement as an Anganwadi Worker did not
affect her eligibility for ReT engagement.
8.
Mr. Achal Sharma, learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 5,
adopted the submissions advanced on behalf of the official respondents
and further contended that respondent No. 5 was the most meritorious
eligible candidate. According to the learned counsel, the allegation
regarding her residence stands conclusively repelled by the official
records and enquiry reports, leaving no ground for interference with her
inclusion in the panel.
9.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
10.
The core controversy in the present petition centres on the residential
status of respondent No. 5, which is heavily disputed by the petitioner
on the grounds that the respondent was a resident of Village Swankha
More, Tehsil Vijaypur, District Samba, and had applied for the post of
ReT Teacher in the Science stream on the strength of fabricated
documents. In order to substantiate her contention, the petitioner has
placed on record, a copy of the ration card of husband of the respondent
No. 5 and copy of the surrender certificate in respect of the ration card
SWP No. 1732/2015
dated 19.07.2014 issued by the TSO, CAPD, Vijaypur. The petitioner
has also placed on record a resolution to assert that Neelam Kumarirespondent No.5 alongwith her family had left the village 15 years ago
and settled at Swankha More Tehsil and District Samba. It is further the
case of the petitioner that respondent No. 5 was already serving as
Anganwadi worker in the Social Welfare Department in District Samba
at the relevant point of time.
11.
On the contrary, respondent No. 5 has stated that the ZEO has written a
letter to the CEO Jammu dated 17.11.2014, wherein it is stated that the
respondent No. 5 was recommended for engagement as ReT Teacher in
MS Manghal as shown at Sr. No. 1 of the panel (Math/Science) only on
the basis of residence of village Manghal produced by her and issued by
the revenue authorities. Alongwith the said letter, Residence Certificate,
Voter Card, PRC (Ajay Kumar) Scheduled Certificate of Neelam
Kumari were also enclosed. Thereafter, vide communication dated
26.12.2014, the Directorate of School Education, Jammu (placed on
record by respondent no. 5 herself), asked the Chief Education Officer,
Jammu to furnish report with documentary proof from the competent
authority in order to proceed further in the matter. Yet again, it is
respondent No. 5 only, who has placed on record the communication
dated 02.05.2015 addressed by the ZEO Arnia (Bishnah) to the Chief
Education Officer, Jammu and in this communication the ZEO has
taken note of the factual aspect of the case. The findings of the ZEO are
extracted in verbatim as under:
SWP No. 1732/2015
“Sir after having a deep enquiry on spot from the concerned
and going through the representations U/s is in state of mess
that has been framed by the committee members and person
in que who are not either eligible or able to be considered for
tentative panels. And all the applicants are busy to collect
their documentary proofs who seems to be in the mood of
litigation against each other (copy of all are attached
herewith). Hence the report is submitted for your kind
information and necessary action please.”
12.
Thus, it is evident that the residential status of respondent No. 5 has not
been finally determined by the official respondents. Rather the official
respondents alongwith their response, have placed on record the order
dated 22.04.2015 to assert that the services of respondent No. 5 as
Anganwari Worker were terminated. The date of initial Advertisement
Notice was 14.06.2014 and subsequent Advertisement Notice was
issued on 10.07.2014. The eligibility of the candidates was required to
be determined at the time of submission of applications. The official
respondents have very conveniently in their response have concealed
the communicated dated 02.05.2015 (Annexure-4 to the objections filed
by the respondent No. 5) from this Court and have in fact tried to
support the candidature of respondent No. 5 by placing reliance on the
communications dated 14.11.2014 and 17.11.2014, which in the
opinion of this Court in no manner determines the residential status of
respondent No. 5 at the time of submitting applications for engagement
as ReT Teacher in Govt. Middle School, Manghal.
13.
Because the ZEO of Arnia described the situation as an absolute mess
and recorded no conclusive finding on the residential status of
respondent No. 5, this Court cannot resolve this issue while exercising
writ jurisdiction, as it constitutes a disputed question of fact.
SWP No. 1732/2015
14.
Accordingly, this petition is disposed of with a direction to the official
respondents to conduct and conclude an enquiry regarding the
residential status of respondent No. 5 as on the date of submission of
her application for engagement as ReT Teacher in Upgraded Primary
School, Manghal, within 30 days from the date of receipt of a copy of
this order, and thereafter proceed in accordance with the judgment of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union Territory of Jammu and
Kashmir & Others v. Saba Wani, 2026 INSC 439.
15.
In view of the above, the relief sought by the petitioner for a direction
to respondent No. 2 to approve the recommendation dated 15.10.2014
of respondent No. 3 and engage the petitioner as ReT Teacher in the
aforesaid school cannot be granted at this stage.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Jammu
23.07.2026
Karam Chand
Whether approved for reporting:
KARAM CHAND
2026.07.23 13:03
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review