The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. With the omission of sub-section (3) of Section 19 of the Agrarian Reforms Act from the statues after the Re-organization of State of Jammu & Kashmir, the jurisdiction with the civil court with regard to possessory rights seeking injunction thereon cannot be stated to be ousted. The case, on hand, has been filed by the plaintiff claiming that he has already been declared as owner by a revenue authority vide order dated 21.08.2020 and that he is holding possession over the suit land, as such, with a view to protect his possessory rights over the land of which he has been declared as the owner, he has filed a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction before the civil court. In such a situation, it is only the civil court which has jurisdiction over the matter and the contention of the petitioners/defendants that the civil court does not have jurisdiction, as such, the plaint was liable to be rejected by the trial court, is misplaced.
16. The trial court has passed a very reasoned order which does not call for any interference as the plaint cannot be rejected for the aforestated reasons on the ground that the trial court does not have jurisdiction in view of the Agrarian Reforms Act. The impugned order is upheld and civil revision, found to be without any merit and substance, is thus, rejected.
17. The civil revision is accordingly dismissed. ( Jammu:
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr.No.3
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CR No. 3/2026
CM No.232/2026
Cav No. 51/2026
Date of order:- 31.01.2026
Uploaded on:- 02.02.2026
1. Sohan Singh, Age 48 years
S/O Late Krishan Singh
2. Champa Devi, Age 61 years
W/O Late Prem Singh
3. Radha Rani, Age 63 years
W/O Late Krishan Singh
All R/O Bhagocha Chack (Bhaiya)
….Petitioners
Teh. Hiranagar, District Kathua.
Through :- Mr. Rohit Bharti, Advocate.
Versus
Chuni Lal S/O Bhulla
R/O Gurha Mundian,
Tehsil Hiranagar
District Kathua
….Respondent(s)
Through :- Mr. Amit Gupta, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
ORDER
31.01.2026
With the appearance of Mr. Amit Gupta, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the caveator-respondent, Caveat No.51/2026 is discharged.
CR No. 3/2026
1.
The instant revision petition, under Section 115 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, has been preferred by the petitioners against the order dated
30.12.2025 passed by the Court of learned Civil Judge (Junior Division),
Hiranagar, Kathua in File No.82/Civil, by virtue of which, application moved
by the petitioners under Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC was dismissed.
2.
CR No. 3/2026
The respondent-Chuni Lal filed a civil suit for permanent prohibitory
injunction seeking to restrain the defendants including the petitioners herein
from causing any sort of interference in any manner and by any mode, in the
peaceful possession of the plaintiff over the land, measuring 11 kanals 13
marlas, comprising of Khasra No.1194, situate at Bhaiya, Tehsil Hiranagar
and District Kathua, including by not creating obstruction in cultivation,
encroaching upon and grabbing the same and causing ouster of the plaintiff
therefrom forcibly either themselves or through anybody else.
3.
During the pendency of the suit, the defendants 5, 6 and 7 namely
Champa Devi, Sohan Singh and Radha Rani, (petitioners herein), moved an
application under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC seeking rejection of plaint,
pleading therein that the dispute raised in the suit pertains to alleged
cultivating possession and tenancy rights, which are matters exclusively
triable by the competent revenue authorities under the Jammu & Kashmir
Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976, as Sections 25 and 27 bar the jurisdiction of
civil courts from entertaining, deciding or dealing with any such question; that
the plaintiff had an equal efficacious remedy under the provisions of the J&K
Agrarian Reforms Act to approach the Tehsildar or Collector for redressal of
his grievance rather than invoking the civil court’s jurisdiction.
4.
After entertaining objections to the application filed by the plaintiff/non
applicant (respondent herein), the trial court rejected the application vide
impugned order holding that the suit does not appear to be barred by law i.e.
J&K Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976.
5.
Aggrieved of the order impugned passed by the trial court, the
petitioners have challenged the same through the medium of the present civil
revision moved under Section 115 of the CPC raising the ground that the trial
CR No. 3/2026
court has misdirected itself by holding that the court had jurisdiction in the
matter and overlooked the arguments raised before it, particularly, in view of
law laid down by the Full Bench of this Court in a case titled ‘Jagtu & Ors.
V. Badri & Ors.’ reported as 1979 KLJ 172.
6.
Heard and considered.
7.
The learned counsel for the petitioners has argued that the respondent
as plaintiff had pleaded in his plaint that the land in question was under his
cultivating possession, meaning thereby, that the land, being agricultural land,
was governed by Agrarian Reforms Act, which provides efficacious remedy
under Section 19(3)(e) of the Agrarian Reforms Act to move a Revenue
Authority seeking the relief which has been pleaded in the plaint, as the trial
court lacked jurisdiction in the matter in view of the authoritative judgment of
this court in a case titled ‘Jagtu & Ors. V. Badri & Ors.’ reported as 1979
KLJ 172. It was finally prayed that the impugned order passed by the trial
court be set aside, holding that the plaint is liable to be rejected and the suit
before the Trial Court be dismissed.
8.
The learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, argued that
the impugned order has been passed by the trial court perfectly in consonance
with the legal principles and does not warrant for any interference by this
court. He has argued that after the Re-organization of the State of Jammu &
Kashmir, the Jammu & Kashmir Agrarian Reforms Act has also been
amended and the relevant sub-section (3) of Section 19 has been omitted and
the argument raised by the learned counsel for the petitioners could be
relevant had this provision of law of the Agrarian Reforms Act be not
omitted. He has relied upon an order dated 10.10.2025, passed by a Coordinate Bench of this court in CR No. 38/2025 titled ‘Surjit Singh v.
CR No. 3/2026
Joraveer Singh’ whereby it has been held that in a similar facts and
circumstances of the case, the suit was held to be maintainable. It was, finally,
prayed that the revision petition be dismissed and the order impugned be
upheld, so that the trial court proceeds further in the matter.
9.
The respondent as plaintiff had filed a civil original suit before the
court below, asserting therein that his father Bulla S/O Gopi Brahman had
been cultivating land measuring 11 kanals 13 marlas, comprising of Khasra
No.1194 (hereinafter called ‘suit land’), situate at Village Bhaiya, Tehsil
Hiranagar, District Kathua prior to 1971 and the possession of his deceased
father was recorded in the cultivation column of revenue record; that soon
after the death of his father, the respondent-plaintiff along with his brother
stepped into his shoes and started cultivating the suit land and had been
cultivating the same continuously; that the respondent-plaintiff, along with his
brother, filed a suit for declaration of plaintiff as owner in possession of the
suit land by way of adverse possession under Section 19(3)(e) of the Agrarian
Reforms Act in the court of Sub Divisional Magistrate, Hiranagar, who on
21.08.2020, declared him as owner by way of adverse possession.
10.
The respondent-plaintiff had further alleged that on 28.09.2025, some
of the defendants trespassed into the suit land with common intention,
threatened the plaintiff to dispossess him from the suit land; that again on
18.11.2025, the defendants with common criminal intention trespassed into
the suit land with a tractor and tried to dispossess the plaintiff-respondent by
installing cemented poles with barbed wire around the suit land and making
tin shed in the middle of the suit land. As such, he was left with no other
option but to move a civil court and file the suit.
11.
CR No. 3/2026
The petitioners-defendants before the court below took a stand that the
respondent-plaintiff made a wrong claim that he was cultivator and that he
filed a suit for declaration before the competent revenue authority, in which
some order dated 28.08.2020 had been passed and stated that no such order
exists and fraudulent document has been annexed with the suit by the plaintiff
as is evident by the annexures placed on record by the defendants/petitioners
with their written statement.
12.
The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners-defendants to
rely upon the full bench judgment of this court in a case titled ‘Jagtu & Ors.
V. Badri & Ors.’ reported as 1979 KLJ 172 is misplaced in view of the fact
that the aforesaid judgment had been passed interpreting the provisions of
Section 19(3)(e) of the Agrarian Reforms Act, which after the Reorganization of the State of Jammu & Kashmir has been omitted from the Act.
As such, that judgment cannot be applied to the facts and circumstances of the
case before the trial court.
13.
This court in CR No.50/2010 titled ‘Suresh & Ors. V. Som Nath &
Anr.’ decided on 09.08.2023 has held that a civil suit seeking permanent
prohibitory and mandatory injunction concerning land possessory rights is
cognizable by a civil court and not barred under Section 19 of the J&K
Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976. This court, again, in a case CM(M) No.
202/2023 titled ‘Bagh Ali & Ors. V. Mushtaq Ahmed & Ors.’ decided on
23.03.2024 held that a plaint cannot be rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC,
unless the grounds explicitly mention that the provisions, such as, lack of
cause of action, improper valuation, insufficient court fee or barred under any
law are satisfied and that the court has to examine only the averments in the
plaint to determine such rejection.
14.
CR No. 3/2026
This court under the similar facts and circumstances of the case on
hand in CR No.38/2025 titled ‘Surjit Singh v. Joraveer Singh’ has held in
para 9 which is extracted as under for the convenience of reference:
“9. In the present case, none of the aforesaid disputes is subject
matter of determination before the learned trial court. The
respondent/plaintiff claims himself to be in the physical
possession of the suit land and he is seeking an injunction
against the petitioner/defendant, who according to him is
trying
to
interfere
in
his
possession.
The
respondent/plaintiff, in order to support his case is relying
upon gift deed dated 02.01.2009, the entries in the khasra
girdawari and the mutation attested in his favour. The
contention of the petitioner/defendant that the gift deed is a
sham document and it is actually he, who is in possession of
the suit land, can be determined only after the trial of the
case
and
not
at
this
stage.
Prima-facie,
the
respondent/plaintiff has placed on record documents which
show that he has title to the suit land and he is also in
possession of the same. Therefore, as per the illustrations
given by this court in the judgment titled ‘Jagtu Vs. Badri &
Ors.’ (AIR 1980 J&K 1) the suit of present nature is
cognizable by the civil court. Thus, the learned trial court
has not committed any illegality while passing the impugned
order.”
15.
With the omission of sub-section (3) of Section 19 of the Agrarian
Reforms Act from the statues after the Re-organization of State of Jammu &
Kashmir, the jurisdiction with the civil court with regard to possessory rights
seeking injunction thereon cannot be stated to be ousted. The case, on hand,
has been filed by the plaintiff claiming that he has already been declared as
owner by a revenue authority vide order dated 21.08.2020 and that he is
holding possession over the suit land, as such, with a view to protect his
CR No. 3/2026
possessory rights over the land of which he has been declared as the owner,
he has filed a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction before the civil court.
In such a situation, it is only the civil court which has jurisdiction over the
matter and the contention of the petitioners/defendants that the civil court
does not have jurisdiction, as such, the plaint was liable to be rejected by the
trial court, is misplaced.
16.
The trial court has passed a very reasoned order which does not call for
any interference as the plaint cannot be rejected for the aforestated reasons on
the ground that the trial court does not have jurisdiction in view of the
Agrarian Reforms Act. The impugned order is upheld and civil revision,
found to be without any merit and substance, is thus, rejected.
17.
The civil revision is accordingly dismissed.
(
Jammu:
31.01.2026
) (M.A. Chowdhary)
Judge
Raj Kumar
Whether the order is speaking?
Whether the order is reportable?
Raj Kumar
2026.02.02 17:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review