Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 11
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023
CrlM No. 2013/2023
CrlM No. 745/2025
Date of Pronouncement: 03.11.2026.
Date of Uploading:
13.11.2026.
Mrs.Sobia Khatoon, Aged 31 years
D/o Mohd. Khan
W/o Asif Ali Mustafa
R/o Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar
Distt. Poonch.
…..Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. S.H. Shah Ashrafi, Advocate
Mr. T.M. Khan, Advocate.
vs
1. Mohd. Parvaiz
S/o Mohd. Din
R/o Village Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar,
Distt. Poonch.
2. Mohd. Faiz
S/o Mohd. Din
R/o Village Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar
Distt. Poonch.
3. Amir Parvaiz
S/o Mohd. Parvaiz
R/o Village Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar,
Disttt. Poonch.
4. Sameer Parvaiz,
S/o Mohd. Parvaiz
R/o Village Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar,
Disttt. Poonch.
5. Ayaz Ahmed
S/o Mohd. Faiz
R/o Village Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar
Distt. Poonch
6. Masheeda Bi
W/o Mohd. Parvaiz
R/o Village Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar
Distt. Poonch.
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
7. Azmat Bi
W/o Mohd. Faiz
R/o Village Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar,
Distt. Poonch.
8. Reena Parvaiz
D/o Mohd. Parvaiz
R/o Village Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar,
Disttt. Poonch.
9. Tasleem Akhter
W/o Mohd. Niyaz
R/o Village Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar,
Disttt. Poonch.
10. Tamana Niyaz
D/o Mohd. Niyaz
R/o Village Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar,
Disttt. Poonch.
11. Shabeena Kouser
W/o Ayaz Ahmed
R/o Village Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar
Distt. Poonch.
12.Zeenat Bi
W/o Maqbool Hussain
R/o Village Galhatta, Tehsil Mendhar,
Distt. Poonch.
13.Sub Divisional Magistrate (SDM),
Mendhar.
14. Station House Officer (SHO),
Gursai, Tehsil Mendhar, District
Poonch.
.…. Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Arshad Majid Malik, Advocate with
Mr. Umar Shakeel, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
1.
The petitioner, Sobia Khatoon, has invoked the inherent jurisdiction of this
Court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.P.C.),
calling in question the legality and propriety of the order dated 02.08.2023
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Poonch, in a revision petition titled
“Mohd. Parvaiz & Others v. Sobia Khatoon”. By virtue of the impugned
order, the learned Revisional Court set aside the proceedings initiated by the
Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Mendhar, under Sections 145 and 146 Cr.P.C.,
including the order directing attachment of land comprising Khasra Nos.
1166/1, 1178, 1183, 1179, 1167 and 1185, falling under Khewat Nos. 175
and 176, situated at Village Gulhotta, Tehsil Mendhar, District Poonch. The
petitioner claims an inherited share measuring 45 kanals and 03 marlas in
the aforesaid property.
2.
The petitioner assails the impugned order primarily on the ground that the
learned Revisional Court failed to appreciate the circumstances necessitating
intervention by the Executive Magistrate to prevent an imminent breach of
peace. According to her, the order has the effect of prejudicing her lawful
claim to inheritance in the estate of her deceased father and exposing the
disputed property to unlawful interference by the respondents.
3.
The case projected by the petitioner is that she is the surviving daughter and
legal heir of late Mohd. Khan and, as such, is entitled to succeed to his share
in the ancestral property. It is alleged that the respondents, who are her close
relatives, have been obstructing her from enjoying the property and
exercising her rights therein, including her right to cut grass and harvest
crops from the land falling to her share.
4.
It is further pleaded that the conduct of the respondents resulted in repeated
confrontations between the parties, culminating in the registration of two
criminal cases. Apprehending a serious breach of peace, the petitioner
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
approached the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Mendhar, seeking initiation of
proceedings under Sections 145 and 146 Cr.P.C. and attachment of the
disputed property.
5.
Upon receipt of the application, the learned Sub-Divisional Magistrate
called for a report from the police agency regarding the factual position
obtaining on the spot. The police, after conducting verification and
recording statements of the petitioner and certain witnesses, reported that a
serious dispute existed between the parties concerning the land in question
and that the situation was likely to result in a breach of peace.
6.
The police report referred to FIR No. 59/2022, registered under Sections
447, 336, 504 and 506 IPC, arising out of an occurrence dated 11.05.2022,
wherein the respondents were alleged to have committed criminal trespass
upon the disputed land and resorted to stone-pelting. The report also referred
to FIR No. 142/2022, registered under Sections 353, 336, 147, 188 and 323
IPC, following another confrontation when the petitioner, accompanied by
police personnel, attempted to cut grass from the disputed property pursuant
to directions issued by the competent authorities.
7.
On consideration of the police report, the learned Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Mendhar, passed a preliminary order dated 23.12.2022 under Section 145
Cr.P.C., recording satisfaction regarding the existence of a dispute likely to
occasion a breach of peace. The police were directed to maintain vigil over
the disputed property, and the parties were restrained from indulging in
activities likely to disturb public peace and tranquillity. Subsequently, on
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
04.01.2023, the Magistrate ordered attachment of the property and directed
the concerned Station House Officer to take possession thereof.
8.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid proceedings, the respondents preferred a revision
petition before the learned Sessions Judge, Poonch. During the pendency of
the revision, the learned Sessions Judge, by order dated 15.02.2023, directed
that the operation of the order dated 23.12.2022 passed by the SubDivisional Magistrate, Mendhar, shall remain in abeyance. The revision
petition was ultimately allowed by order dated 02.08.2023, which is the
subject matter of challenge in the present proceedings.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
9.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the learned
Revisional Court has committed a manifest error of law and jurisdiction in
setting aside the proceedings initiated by the Executive Magistrate. It is
contended that the material collected by the police, particularly the
registration of two FIRs arising out of confrontations concerning the
disputed land, sufficiently established the existence of a serious dispute
likely to cause a breach of peace.
10. It is argued that the satisfaction contemplated under Section 145(1) Cr.P.C.
is primarily that of the Executive Magistrate and, once such satisfaction has
been recorded on the basis of a police report or other reliable information,
interference by the Revisional Court is unwarranted unless the proceedings
suffer from a jurisdictional defect or patent illegality.
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
11. Learned counsel further contends that the learned Sessions Judge erred in
proceeding on the premise that the parties were in joint possession of the
disputed land. According to the petitioner, the very fact that she was being
prevented from enjoying the property and exercising her rights therein
demonstrated the existence of a dispute requiring preventive intervention. It
is submitted that the attachment was intended only to preserve peace and
protect the property until the question of possession could be determined in
accordance with law.
12. It is additionally urged that any procedural irregularity in the order passed
by the Executive Magistrate ought not to have resulted in setting aside the
entire proceedings, particularly when the material on record disclosed a
genuine apprehension of breach of peace. The petitioner, therefore, seeks
exercise of the inherent powers of this Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to
prevent abuse of the process of law and secure the ends of justice.
13. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents supports the order
passed by the learned Revisional Court. It is submitted that the proceedings
initiated by the petitioner under Sections 145 and 146 Cr.P.C. were
misconceived and constituted an attempt to obtain possession of the
property through a summary preventive jurisdiction.
14. Learned counsel submits that the petitioner has nowhere specifically pleaded
that she was in actual physical possession of the disputed land and had been
forcibly or wrongfully dispossessed therefrom on any particular date. On the
contrary, the substance of her claim is that she is entitled to a share in the
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
ancestral property by inheritance and that the respondents are refusing to
deliver possession of such share.
15. It is further contended that the parties are already litigating before the
competent Civil Court at Mendhar in a suit for permanent prohibitory
injunction concerning the same property. In the said proceedings, an order
directing maintenance of status quo had been passed on 23.01.2021 and was
subsequently confirmed on 10.03.2021. The question of possession,
therefore, was already the subject matter of adjudication before the Civil
Court.
16. Learned counsel argues that the petitioner, instead of pursuing the remedies
available to her before the Civil Court, sought to invoke the jurisdiction of
the Executive Magistrate with the object of disturbing the existing
possession of the respondents. It is submitted that the preliminary order and
the subsequent attachment order were passed without proper application of
mind to the statutory requirements and were, therefore, rightly interfered
with by the learned Sessions Judge.
CONSIDERATION AND ANALYSIS
17. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
18. The principal question arising for determination is whether the learned
Sessions
Judge,
Poonch,
committed
any
illegality,
perversity
or
jurisdictional error in setting aside the proceedings initiated by the SubDivisional Magistrate, Mendhar, under Sections 145 and 146 Cr.P.C.
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
19. At the outset, it may be noticed that there is no dispute regarding the
competence of the learned Sessions Judge to exercise revisional jurisdiction
in relation to the orders passed by the Executive Magistrate. Indeed, during
the course of hearing, learned counsel for both sides fairly conceded that the
orders in question were amenable to scrutiny in revision. The controversy,
therefore, is confined to the legality of the exercise of such jurisdiction in
the facts and circumstances of the present case.
20. Section 145 Cr.P.C. confers preventive jurisdiction upon an Executive
Magistrate where, upon receiving a report from a police officer or other
information, the Magistrate is satisfied that a dispute likely to cause a breach
of peace exists concerning any land, water or the boundaries thereof. The
Magistrate is required to make an order in writing, stating the grounds of
such satisfaction, and calling upon the parties concerned to attend the Court
and put forward their respective claims regarding actual possession of the
subject matter of dispute.
21. The object underlying Section 145 Cr.P.C. is preventive rather than
adjudicatory. The jurisdiction is intended to preserve public peace by
addressing disputes concerning actual possession of immovable property. It
does not empower the Executive Magistrate to adjudicate questions of title,
ownership, inheritance or partition, which fall within the domain of the
competent Civil Court.
22. The distinction between a dispute concerning actual possession and a
dispute concerning entitlement to possession is of considerable significance.
While the former may attract the preventive jurisdiction of an Executive
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
Magistrate, the latter ordinarily requires adjudication by a Civil Court in
proceedings appropriately instituted for that purpose.
23. Under Section 145(4) Cr.P.C., the Magistrate is required to consider the
statements of the parties, receive such evidence as may be produced, and
determine, if possible, which party was in actual possession of the subject
matter of dispute on the date of the preliminary order. The statutory
provision also recognises a limited exception where a party has been
forcibly and wrongfully dispossessed within the period prescribed therein, in
which event such party may, for the purposes of the proceedings, be treated
as being in possession.
24. Section 146 Cr.P.C., on the other hand, empowers the Magistrate to attach
the subject matter of dispute after making an order under Section 145(1),
where the case is considered one of emergency, or where the Magistrate
decides that none of the parties was in possession, or is unable to satisfy
himself as to which party was in possession. The power of attachment is
thus ancillary to the proceedings under Section 145 and must be exercised in
accordance with the conditions prescribed by the statute.
25. Examined in the light of the aforesaid legal position, the record reveals that
the foundation of the petitioner's claim is her asserted right of inheritance in
the estate of her deceased father. Her grievance, in substance, is that
although she is entitled to a share in the property, the respondents are not
permitting her to enjoy or obtain possession of the land corresponding to
that share.
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
26. Significantly, the application submitted by the petitioner before the
Executive Magistrate does not disclose any specific instance of her having
been forcibly and wrongfully dispossessed from actual physical possession
of the disputed property on a particular date. Nor does the material placed
before the Magistrate clearly establish that the petitioner was in exclusive
physical possession of any identified portion of the land immediately before
the initiation of the proceedings.
27. The revenue entries, as referred to in the proceedings, indicate the joint
ownership and possession of the parties to the extent of their respective
shares. Such entries may be relevant to the determination of their civil
rights, but they do not, by themselves, conclusively establish the actual
physical possession of the petitioner over a separately identifiable portion of
the disputed property.
28. The police report undoubtedly refers to two incidents resulting in the
registration of criminal cases. These incidents indicate strained relations
between the parties and the existence of a dispute concerning the property.
However, the registration of FIRs, by itself, does not determine which party
was in actual possession of the disputed land, nor can it substitute the
inquiry contemplated under Section 145(4) Cr.P.C.
29. The first incident, dated 11.05.2022, is alleged to have involved criminal
trespass and stone-pelting, while the second arose when the petitioner, with
police assistance, attempted to cut grass from the disputed land. The
circumstances surrounding these incidents may be relevant for the purposes
of the criminal proceedings instituted in respect thereof. Nevertheless, they
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
do not conclusively establish that the petitioner was in settled physical
possession of the land and was thereafter dispossessed within the period
contemplated by Section 145(4) Cr.P.C.
30. Rather, the material available on record indicates that the petitioner was
endeavouring to exercise her asserted right over a share in the joint property,
possession whereof was being resisted by the respondents. The dispute,
therefore, substantially concerns the enforcement of competing civil claims
arising from inheritance, co-ownership and possession.
31. Another material circumstance which cannot be overlooked is the pendency
of a civil suit between the parties concerning the very same property. The
respondents had instituted a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction before
the Court of Munsiff, Mendhar, wherein an order directing maintenance of
status quo was passed on 23.01.2021 and subsequently confirmed on
10.03.2021.
32. The Civil Court, upon consideration of the pleadings and material before it,
found that serious questions concerning possession required adjudication
and that preservation of the existing state of affairs was necessary to avoid
further complications. The interim order was accordingly continued.
33. Once the competent Civil Court was already seized of the controversy
concerning possession and had passed an order for preservation of the suit
property, the Executive Magistrate was required to exercise particular
caution before passing an order which could have the effect of altering the
existing possessory arrangement. The preventive jurisdiction under Section
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
145 Cr.P.C. cannot be employed as a parallel mechanism for obtaining relief
substantially involving the enforcement of civil rights.
34. This is not to suggest that the mere pendency of civil litigation invariably
excludes the jurisdiction of an Executive Magistrate under Section 145
Cr.P.C. Where the statutory conditions are independently satisfied and a
genuine apprehension of breach of peace exists, preventive jurisdiction may
still be attracted. However, such jurisdiction cannot be exercised in a
manner which circumvents or undermines subsisting orders of a competent
Civil Court, particularly where the controversy concerning possession is
already under judicial consideration.
35. In the present case, the learned Executive Magistrate appears to have
proceeded primarily on the basis of the police report referring to the two
criminal incidents, without adequately examining the nature of the
petitioner's claim, the existing civil proceedings, the subsisting order of
status quo and the material necessary for determining actual possession.
36. The existence of tension between the parties, though relevant to the
preventive aspect of Section 145 Cr.P.C., could not, in the circumstances of
the case, justify an order of attachment without due consideration of the
statutory requirements governing the exercise of power under Section 146
Cr.P.C.
37. The learned Sessions Judge, upon examining the record, found that the
preliminary proceedings suffered from non-application of mind and that the
attachment order was not sustainable in the factual and legal circumstances
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
obtaining in the case. The Revisional Court further noticed that the
petitioner had failed to demonstrate actual physical possession or any
specific instance of wrongful dispossession and that the dispute concerning
possession was already pending adjudication before the competent Civil
Court.
38. This Court finds no reason to differ with the conclusions so recorded. The
learned Sessions Judge has examined the material circumstances and the
nature of the dispute and has assigned reasons for interfering with the orders
passed by the Executive Magistrate. The impugned order cannot, therefore,
be characterised as perverse, arbitrary or contrary to the settled principles
governing proceedings under Sections 145 and 146 Cr.P.C.
39. The contention of learned counsel for the petitioner that the impugned order
deprives her of her lawful inheritance rights is equally misconceived.
Proceedings under Sections 145 and 146 Cr.P.C. neither create nor
extinguish proprietary rights. The setting aside of the attachment order does
not amount to a declaration that the petitioner has no right, title or interest in
the property inherited from her deceased father.
40. The petitioner's entitlement to inheritance, the extent of her share, and her
right to seek partition, separate possession or any other consequential relief
are matters to be determined by the competent Civil Court in accordance
with the applicable substantive law. Nothing observed in the present
judgment shall be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of
those claims.
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
41. It is also necessary to emphasise that the inherent jurisdiction of this Court
under Section 482 Cr.P.C. is to be exercised sparingly and with
circumspection, primarily to prevent abuse of the process of any Court or
otherwise to secure the ends of justice. Such jurisdiction does not warrant
interference with a reasoned revisional order merely because another view
of the material may be possible.
42. In the case at hand, the petitioner has failed to demonstrate any patent
illegality, jurisdictional error or manifest miscarriage of justice in the order
passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Poonch. The exercise of revisional
jurisdiction, in the circumstances noticed hereinabove, cannot be said to
suffer from any infirmity warranting interference by this Court.
CONCLUSION
43. For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
learned Sessions Judge, Poonch, was justified in interfering with the
proceedings initiated by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Mendhar, under
Sections 145 and 146 Cr.P.C. The order dated 02.08.2023 does not suffer
from any illegality, perversity or jurisdictional error calling for interference
in exercise of the inherent powers of this Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
44. Accordingly, the present petition is dismissed, and the impugned order
dated 02.08.2023 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Poonch, is upheld.
45. It is, however, clarified that the observations made herein are confined to the
legality of the proceedings under Sections 145 and 146 Cr.P.C. and shall not
prejudice the rights and contentions of either party in the civil proceedings
CRM(M) No. 1006/2023; CrlM No. 2013/2023;CrlM No. 745/2025
pending before the competent Court. The Civil Court shall adjudicate the
controversy independently, on the basis of the pleadings, evidence and
applicable law, uninfluenced by any observations made in the present
judgment concerning the respective claims of ownership or possession.
46. The parties shall strictly abide by the subsisting orders passed by the
competent Civil Court concerning the disputed property and shall refrain
from taking the law into their own hands or disturbing public peace.
47. Disposed of in the above terms.
( Sanjay Parihar )
Judge
Jammu
03.11.2026
Rahul Sharma
Whether the order is speaking: Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
Bunty Kumar
2026.11.13 14:21
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review