The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. In the case of Managing Director, Castrol India Ltd. Vs. State of Karnataka, reported in (2018) 17 SCC 275, the Hon’ble Apex Court held that in absence of specific averment made in complaint alleging role of Director/Managing Director in commission of offence, criminal proceeding cannot continue. In the instant case, it is also seen that at the time of taking cognizance, the learned trial Court below has not applied his mind. Applying the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court, it is held that in absence of any specific allegation against the present petitioner, who is discharging her duty as a Managing Director of the company, cannot be allowed to continue and the same is accordingly liable to be set aside and quashed, invoking the power conferred under Section 482 of the CrPC.
18. Accordingly, the impugned proceeding drawn under Section 500/34 of the Indian Penal Code, being Complaint Case No. 4285C/2013 and pending in the Court of learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate-I, Kamrup (M) at Guwahati and issuing the process against the present petitioner is hereby set aside and quashed. However, it is made clear that the case against the other accused persons will continue in accordance with law.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC010211062015
2026:GAU-AS:1409
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.Pet./348/2015
SMTI DIPANNITA JAISWAL
W/O SRI SANJEEV JAISWAL R/O KHARGHULI, GUWAHATI-4, P.S. LATASIL
DIST. KAMRUP M, ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM and ANR
2:SMT. DIPANNITA MUKHARJEE
W/O MD. MUKTAR HUSSAIN KHAN R/O LIG-2/5
HATIGAON BORSOJAI HOUSING COMPLEX
OLD
PRESENTLY KNOWN AS BAKULBAN HOUSING UNDER P.O. and P.S.
HATIGAON
GUWAHATI-38
IN THE DIST.OF KAMRUP
ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner
BORA,MR.A K BHUYAN
: MS.B BORA, MS.P PATHAK,MS.N CHOUDHURY,MR.M
Advocate for the Respondent : MR.P BORAHR-2, PP, ASSAM,MR. G CHOUDHURY(R-2),MR.A
K HALOI(R-2),
BEFORE
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MITALI THAKURIA
Page No.# 2/10
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 04.12.2025
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 04.02.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
: N/A.
operative part of the judgment?
Whether the full judgment has been
: Yes.
pronounced?
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. A.K. Bhuyan, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr.
B. Sarma, learned Addl. Public Prosecutor, Assam appearing for the State
respondent No.1 and Mr. G. Choudhury, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent No.2.
2.
This is an application under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C praying for quashing
of the impugned proceeding drawn under Section 500/34 of the Indian Penal
Code, being Complaint Case No. 4285 C/2013 and pending in the Court of
learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate-I, Kamrup (M) at Guwahati and issued
process against the present petitioner.
3.
In brief the case of the petitioner is that the petitioner is the Chairman cum
Managing Director of a Company, namely, M/s. Brahmaputra Tele Production
Pvt. Ltd., which is running a T.V. Channel namely, the DY 365 and the petitioner
is looking after the general administration of the company. It is submitted by the
petitioner that a summons was received in the office of the petitioner, whereby
Page No.# 3/10
she was asked to appear before the Court of learned Sub-Divisional Judicial
Magistrate- I, Kamrup (M) at Guwahati. From the Summons it has come to the
notice of the petitioner that a Complaint Case being C.R. Case No.4285 C/2013
has been registered under Sections 499/500/501/502/34 of Indian Penal Code,
1860 and by the impugned order dated 31.07.2014, the learned Trial Court was
pleased to take cognizance of offence under section 500/34 of Indian Penal
Code and issued process against the petitioner, fixing 12.09.2014 for
appearance.
4.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the drawing up of the proceeding
against the present petitioner in the instant case i.e. Complaint Case No.
4285C/2013, the petitioner has preferred the instant petition.
5.
It is contended by Mr. A.K. Bhuyan, the learned counsel for the petitioner
that no offence under section 500/34 of the Indian Penal Code is made out
against the present petitioner and there is no statement that it is the petitioner
who defamed Opposite Party No.2 and as such the impugned order dated
31.07.2014, taking cognizance is bad in law and the proceeding is liable to be
set aside and quashed. It is submitted by Mr. Bhuyan, the learned counsel for
the petitioner that the petitioner is the Managing Director of the company and
she has nothing to do with the programmes that are broadcasted by the news
channel and for the programmes broadcasted by the Television channel is the
sole responsibility of the Editor-in-Chief of the Television Channel and as such
issuing of process against the petitioner is bad in law and is liable to be set
aside and quashed. Mr. Bhuyan, the learned counsel for the petitioner further
submitted that under the Press Laws, it is always the Editor who controls the
Page No.# 4/10
selection of the matter for the purpose of broadcasting is responsible and the
Managing Director of the company cannot be fastened with criminal liability and
as such order of taking cognizance against the petitioner is bad in law and is
liable to be set aside and quashed.
6.
Mr. A.K. Bhuyan, the learned counsel for the petitioner further submitted
that no specific allegation has been brought against the present petitioner in the
complaint petition nor there is any statement as to how the present petitioner is
involved in broadcasting the said news item or whether she has any involvement
in selection of the news item, which is stated to be defamatory one. The present
petitioner is working as the Chairman cum Managing Director of the Company
and it is only the editor who is responsible or who controls the selection of the
news item or any matters for the purpose of broadcasting and as a Managing
Director, the present petitioner has no role in selection of any news item nor she
has any control over any matter which is to be broadcasted in the news
channel. More so, from the plain reading of the complaint as well as the
statement made by the three CWs, under Section 202 of the CrPC, at the time
of enquiry did not reveal any materials against the present petitioner that she
was also aware about the news items, which were broadcasted in the news
channel or as a Managing Director, she can also be roped in the present case.
He further submitted that it is the cardinal principle of the criminal jurisprudence
that there was no vicarious liability unless the statutes specifically provides for
it. To prove a case under Section 499/500 of the IPC, there has to be some
statements against the present petitioner, who is the Managing Director to held
that she was also responsible for broadcasting the said news item, as it is well
known that as a Managing Director, the selection of news item or broadcasting
of any materials are not directly under the control and supervision of any
Page No.# 5/10
Managing Director. It is the Editor-in-Chief/Editor who is responsible for the
selection of news items as well as broadcasting of the same in any news
channel.
7.
As such, Mr. Bhuyan, the learned counsel for the petitioner further
submitted that there is no prima face case at all to take cognizance against the
present petitioner under Section 500 of the IPC and accordingly, the case
against the present petitioner is liable to be quashed. In support of his
submission, Mr. A.K. Bhuyan, the learned counsel for the petitioner relied upon
the following decisions of this Court as well as of Kerala High Court:
(i) Criminal Petition No.556/2012 (Sri Pranoy Bordoloi and another vs. State
of Assam and another);
(ii) Criminal Petition No.33/2015 (Smti Dipannita Jaiswal vs. State of Assam
and another); &
(iii) Crl. MC No.5519/2019 (Fr. Joseph Kuzhinjalil and another vs. Visalakshi
and another).
8.
Citing the above referred judgments, it is further submitted by Mr. Bhuyan,
the learned counsel for the petitioner that from the order of cognizance dated
31.07.2014, it is also seen that the learned Trial Court below had after recording
the statement under Section 202 of the CrPC of Court witnesses, had simply
issued the process taking cognizance of the offence against all the accused
persons only with the observation that there is sufficient materials to proceed
with the case against all of them under Section 500/34 of the IPC. But there is
no statement at all that at the time of passing the order, any electronic record
etc. were produced before the learned Trial Court below as it is the allegation
that new items were broadcasted in the news channel where the petitioner was
discharging her duty as the Managing Director.
Page No.# 6/10
9.
The learned counsel for the petitioner emphasized in para 13 and 19 of the
judgment passed in Criminal Petition No.556/2012 (Supra), wherein it has been
held by a coordinate Bench of this High Court as under:
“13. From the principles that are laid down in the above line of decisions, it is manifest
that vicarious liability of the Managing Director, or a Director, or an employee of a
juristic entity like a company can arise provided there is any provision in the statute.
There is no such provision in the Indian Penal Code to bring in the concept of vicarious
liability automatically when it is evident that the alleged offence was done not in his
personal capacity and it was done in the course of his duty on behalf of the company in
which he is in employment.
19. Going by the projections made in the complaint and the expressions provided for in
the aforesaid statutes, the alleged defamatory news item or its transcript would fall in
the category of ‘documentary evidence’, more particularly, within the expression
‘electronic records’. Such electronic records can be proved either by primary evidence
or by secondary evidence, as per conditions laid down in the Evidence Act. The criminal
prosecution has been launched against the accused persons on the premise that the
alleged news item broadcasted through the television channel, DY365 is defamatory in
nature. During the course of enquiry, the said alleged defamatory news item, which, for
the complainant, is the foundation for launching the criminal prosecution, has not been
produced before the Court for its examination. It is not even mentioned in the statement
of the complainant that the said news item would be produced at a subsequent point of
time. Nothing has been said by the complainant that he made any effort to obtain the
alleged defamatory news item from the rightful source and had failed in his attempts.
Thus, the alleged defamatory news item was not before the learned trial court at the
time of taking cognizance of the offence and issuance of the process against the accused
persons to arrive at a prima facie opinion that the same was defamatory in nature”.
10. In the other two judgments which are also relied by the learned counsel
for the petitioner expressed the same view that in an ordinary course, the
Editor-in-Chief/Editor is responsible for selecting the news items and the
Managing Director has no direct role in selection of the news items and
therefore, the criminal prosecution alleging the defamation against the
Managing Director would not succeed at prima facie. Accordingly, Mr. Bhuyan,
the learned counsel for the appellant submitted that it is a fit case where in the
case against the present petitioner i.e. Complaint Case No. 4285C/2013 which is
pending in the Court of learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate-I, Kamrup (M)
Page No.# 7/10
at Guwahati is liable to be set aside with cost by invoking the extra ordinary
power under Section 482 of the CrPC.
11.
Mr. B. Sarma, learned Addl. Public Prosecutor, Assam appearing for the
State respondent No.1 submitted that the complaint petition is to be read as a
whole and being the Managing Director of the said news channel, the present
petitioner is equally liable for the broadcasting or telecasting the news item,
which is stated to be defamatory for the respondent No.2. Mr. Sarma further
submitted that in para 14 of the said complaint, the allegation is also brought
against the present petitioner and from the statement made in para 14 it also
reveals that the electronic record which is commonly called as master spool is in
the possession of the accused persons and accordingly the complainant prayed
for a direction to produce the same before the Court. He further submitted that
there is prima facie case against the present petitioner in the complaint and it is
not a case that the complaint does not disclose a case against the present
petitioner to set aside or quash the proceeding against her. Accordingly Mr.
Sarma submitted that this is not at all a fit case to quash the proceeding against
the present accused petitioner at this stage and the learned Court below had
taken cognizance against her after perusal of the complaint petition as well as
the statement made by the court witnesses, who were accordingly examined
under Section 202 of the CrPC.
12.
Mr. G. Choudhury, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent
No.2/complainant also submitted that the allegations are also brought against
the Managing Director and all other accused persons and it is specifically
mentioned that the accused Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 & 7, after prior meeting of mind
and in furtherance of common intention, broadcasted the defamatory news
Page No.# 8/10
item, with the intention to defame the present petitioner which seriously
harmed the reputation, prestige and her social image. Accordingly, Mr.
Choudhury, the learned counsel for the respondent No.2 submitted that there is
a prima facie case against the present petitioner to take cognizance and hence,
the learned trial Court below had rightly passed the order of taking cognizance
against the present petitioner along with other accused persons and hence, it is
not at all a fit case to quash the proceeding against the present petitioner,
invoking the power under Section 482 of the CrPC, as prayed for.
13. Hearing the submissions made by learned counsel for both sides, I have
also perused the case records and the annexures filed with the present petition.
14. From the order of cognizance passed by the learned trial Court below, it
reveals that no discussion has been made as to how the Court was satisfied
regarding the prima facie case against all the accused persons including the
present petitioner to take cognizance. Further, it is also seen from the statement
of the court witnesses as well as the complaint that no electronic records or
electronic document was produced before the learned trial Court below at the
time of taking cognizance against all the accused persons. Further it is also seen
that no specific allegation was brought in the complaint petition against the
present petitioner who is discharging her duty as the Managing Director of the
said company. Except one statement made in the complaint that all the accused
persons with prior meeting of mind and in furtherance of common intention had
broadcasted the said news item which defamed the complainant in the society
as well as her reputation. It is also evident from the order passed by the learned
trial Court below that the alleged defamatory news item or its transcript which is
stated to be the foundation of such criminal prosecution was also not produced
Page No.# 9/10
before the Court at the time of taking cognizance against the present petitioner.
15. As already relied by a coordinate Bench of this Court in case of Criminal
Petition No.556/2012 (Supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Maksud Saiyed vs. State of Gujarat , reported in (2008) 5 SCC 668, has
observed in para 13 of the said judgment as under:
“13. Where a jurisdiction is exercised on a complaint petition filed in terms of Section 156(3)
or Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the Magistrate is required to apply his mind.
Indian Penal Code does not contain any provision for attaching vicarious liability on the part
of the Managing Director or the Directors of the Company when the accused is the Company.
The learned Magistrate failed to pose unto himself the correct question viz. as to whether the
complaint petition, even if given face value and taken to be correct in its entirety, would lead to
the conclusion that the respondents herein were personally liable for any offence. The Bank is a
body corporate. Vicarious liability of the Managing Director and Director would arise provided
any provision exists in that behalf in the statute. Statutes indisputably must contain provision
fixing such vicarious liabilities. Even for the said purpose, it is obligatory on the part of the
complainant to make requisite allegations which would attract the provisions constituting
vicarious liability”.
16. But here in the instant case, it is seen that the present petitioner who
being the Managing Director of the company cannot manifest under the
vicarious liability as there is no such allegation brought against the present
petitioner regarding her involvement in telecasting/broadcasting the said news
item, against the present respondent No.2, which is stated to be defamatory
and unless there is no direct allegation against the present petitioner, she
cannot be roped in this case under the concept of vicarious liability. More so, it
is the Editor/Editor-in-Chief who is the controlling authority or responsible for
selection of any news item or any matter to be broadcasted in the news channel
and in all the cases, the Managing Director cannot be fastened with the criminal
liability, unless there is any specific allegation brought against the Managing
Director showing his/her involvement in the alleged offence.
Page No.# 10/10
17. In the case of Managing Director, Castrol India Ltd. Vs. State of
Karnataka, reported in (2018) 17 SCC 275, the Hon’ble Apex Court held that
in absence of specific averment made in complaint alleging role of
Director/Managing Director in commission of offence, criminal proceeding
cannot continue. In the instant case, it is also seen that at the time of taking
cognizance, the learned trial Court below has not applied his mind. Applying the
ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court, it is held that in absence of any
specific allegation against the present petitioner, who is discharging her duty as
a Managing Director of the company, cannot be allowed to continue and the
same is accordingly liable to be set aside and quashed, invoking the power
conferred under Section 482 of the CrPC.
18. Accordingly, the impugned proceeding drawn under Section 500/34 of the
Indian Penal Code, being Complaint Case No. 4285C/2013 and pending in the
Court of learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate-I, Kamrup (M) at Guwahati
and issuing the process against the present petitioner is hereby set aside and
quashed. However, it is made clear that the case against the other accused
persons will continue in accordance with law.
19. Criminal proceeding accordingly stands disposed.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Manoranjan Barman
Barman
Date: 2026.02.05 13:44:26 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review