The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. 02.2019 was wrongly mentioned as 11.12.2014 in prayer and accordingly, the petitioners have filed misc. case being MC(WP(C))No.340 of 2022 seeking prayer to correct the same. Accordingly, this Court by an order dated 18.10.2022 passed in MC(WP(C))No.340 of 2022 permitted to petitioners to correct the wrong date of the impugned order as 14.02.2019 and accordingly necessary correction was made by the Registry. WP(C)No.491 of 2022 Page 8 [20] In the peculiar facts and circumstance of the case and in order to do complete justice, this Court directs to the respondents to give cash payment or arrear to the petitioner No.1 w.e.f. 01.04.2010 and with respect to petitioner Nos. 2 & 3 w.e.f. 11.12.2014 and the necessary rectification shall be made within 2(two) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. [21] It is further clarified that the direction of payment is confined to the petitioners herein. [22] With this observations, this writ petition is disposed of. FR/NFR John kom WP(C)No.491 of 2022 Page 9
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
TELEN
KOM
JOHN TELEN KOM
Date: 2023.12.22
17:38:10 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.491 of 2022
1. Smt. Yengkhom Romibala Devi, aged about 59 years, w/o Dr.
Thounaojam Kesho Singh, a resident of Kakching Turel Wangma
Ningthou Pareng, Kakching District, PO/PS Kakching, Manipur, Pin795103.
2. Shri Moirangthem Shantidash Singh, aged about 43, S/o (L) M.
Krishnamani Singh, a resident of Kakching Wairi, Senapati District,
PO/PS Kakching, Manipur, Pin-795103.
3. Smt. Noarem Renuka Devi, aged about 48 years, W/o. Thounaojam
Nando Singh, a resident of Kakching Paji Leikai, Kakching District,
P.O/P.S. Kakching Manipur, PIN – 795103.
…Petitioners
- Versus -
1. The State of Manipur represented by the commissioner/ Secretary
(SCERT), Government of Manipur, Babupara, 795001.
2. The Commissioner/Secretary (Finance), Government of Manipur,
Babupara, 795001.
3. The Director, SCERT (State Council of Educational Research
Training), Government of Manipur, Lamphelpat, 795001.
…Respondents
WP(C)No.491 of 2022
Page 1
BEFORE
HON’BLE JUSTICE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
ORDER
(ORAL)
19.12.2023
[1]
Heard Mr. Y. Nirmolchand, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. L. Raju, learned counsel for the petitioners and Mrs. CH. Sundari,
learned GA for all the respondents.
[2]
The case of the petitioners are that the petitioners No.1 was
appointed as Graduate teacher under the State Council of Education and
Research Training dated 21.06.1991, the petitioner No.2 vide order dated
11.12.2014 and petitioner No.3 vide order dated 11.12.2014 and their
service conditions and salary are governed by the State Government rules
as adopted for the employees of SCERT from time to time.
[3]
In the Manipur Services R.O.P 2010 issued by the Government
of Manipur, the date of enforcement of 6th Pay Commission was notionally
from 01.01.2006 with cash payment from 01.04.2010.
[4]
It is submitted that in the schedule of the R.O.P 2010 at serial
No.37 with respect to State Council of Educational Research & Training, the
pay upgradation with respect Primary Teacher, Under-Graduate Teacher
WP(C)No.491 of 2022
Page 2
and Graduate Teachers were inadvertently omitted. The petitioners along
with similarly situated employees of the SCERT submitted common
representation to the Hon’ble Education Minister, Government of Manipur for
inclusion of the posts left out in R.O.P. 2010. Vide order letter dated
24.01.2018, the Director, SCERT, Government of Manipur submitted a
proposal to the Joint Secretary, SCERT for inclusion of the 6th Pay R.O.P.
2010 of the left out teachers i.e. Primary, Under-Graduate and Graduate
teachers of SCERT and the matter was placed before the State Cabinet on
22.12.2018 and in pursuance to the Cabinet decision, an order dated
14.02.2019 was issued in exercise of the powers conferred under proviso to
Article 309 of the Constitution of India whereby the left out posts of the
SCERT i.e. Primary teacher, Under-Graduate Teacher and Graduate
Teacher were to be included in the R.O.P 2010. However, in para 2 of the
order dated 14.02.2019 which is impugned herein it is mentioned that
effective date will be from 01.01.2019.
[5]
The present writ petition is filed with the prayers to quash the
impugned order dated 14.02.2019 particularly the words “ w.e.f. 01.01.2019”
and to direct the respondents to make cash payment or arrear w.e.f.
01.04.2010 for petitioner No.1 and w.e.f. 11.12.2014 for petitioner Nos. 2 & 3
as prescribed under the Manipur Services(Revised Pay) Rules 2010 within a
WP(C)No.491 of 2022
Page 3
stipulated period mainly on the ground that this R.O.P 2010 will be enforced
notionally from 01.01.2010 and cash payment from 01.04.2010 for all the
employees under the Government of Manipur.
[6]
Mr. Y. Nirmolchand, learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioners submitted that the fixing of date of enforcement as 01.01.2019 in
the order dated 14.02.2019 is violative of the principle of equality under
Article 14 of the Constitution of India as all other employees of the State
Government are getting cash payment including other employees of the
same department(SCERT) from 01.04.2010. It is stated that the lapse is not
on the part of the petitioners. He also referred the decision of this Court in
Judgment and order dated 05.09.2022 in WP(C)No.253 of 2021 passed by
the learned Single Judge wherein similar relief i.e. the cash payment of the
left out candidates from the original date mentioning in the original R.O.P.
[7]
The learned senior counsel draws the attention of this Court
with para 5 of the counter affidavit filed by the State respondent Nos. 1 & 3
that the impugned order dated 14.02.2019 is issued in pursuance to the
cabinet decision with concurrence of the Finance Department(PIC) and
clarifies that none of the pleadings of the petitioners has been controverted.
[8]
Mr. Y. Nirmolchand, learned senior counsel for the petitioners
referred to a judgment and order dated 19.05.2009 passed by the Hon’ble
WP(C)No.491 of 2022
Page 4
Single Judge in WP(C)No.709 of 2005 passed by the then Gauhati High
Court( Now, High Court of Manipur) regarding the same matter and directed
that the date of pay of revised pay scale for the left out candidates should be
from the date of mentioning in the original R.O.P. Reference may be made
as follows;
“12. For the foregoing reason, this Court has no alternative but
to interfere with the effective date of revision of pay scale of
the petitioners under ROP 1999 w.e.f. 01.06.2004 for the
purpose of cash payment under the impugned order dated
22.06.2004. Accordingly, the effective date of the revision of
pay scale of the petitioners under ROP 1999 mentioned in the
impugned order 22.06.2004 is hereby set aside. The effective
date of the revision of pay scale of the petitioners as Executive
officers will be the same, i.e. w.e.f. 01.01.1996 as applicable to
all the other employees of the different Municipal Councils and
also the employees of the Government of Manipur”.
[9]
Accordingly, the State Government preferred a writ appeal
against the order dated 19.05.2009 and the Division Bench of Gauhati High
Court Imphal Bench upheld the finding of the learned Single Judge vide
order dated 11.08.2010 in WA No.27 of 2010.
[10]
At the Bar, Mr. Y. Nirmolchand, learned senior counsel for the
petitioners submitted a special SLP preferred by the State Government
WP(C)No.491 of 2022
Page 5
against the order of the Division Bench was also dismissed. Though the SLP
was dismissed but the detail number is not known. He further prayed that the
effective date of payment of the cash payment for the petitioners be
corrected in the impugned order dated 14.02.2019.
[11]
Mrs. Ch. Sundari, learned GA for the State respondents
submitted that the impugned order dated 14.02.2019 issued by the
Administrative Department SCERT is as per the decision of the State cabinet
decision and with concurrence of the Finance Department (PIC). It is
submitted that the Administrative Department has no power to grant revised
pay scale from the different date mentioned in the impugned notification. It is
further submitted that the Finance Department is yet to file any counter
affidavit.
[12]
It is also further submitted that the Administrative Department
submitted a proposal to the State Government for inclusion of the left out
categories and any correction will be subject to the reviewing/rectification of
the Government order with the approval by the Cabinet and the Finance
Department(PIC).
[13]
This Court has considered the submissions made by the
learned counsel for the parties and perused the materials on record. It is
seen that the R.O.P 2010 is notionally effective from 01.01.2006 with cash
WP(C)No.491 of 2022
Page 6
payment from 01.04.2010 and this is applicable to all the employees under
the Government of Manipur.
[14]
In the schedule of the R.O.P 2010 at serial No.37 with respect
to State Council of Educational Research & Training listed along with various
posts with old pay scale and new pay scale. However, the post of Primary
Teacher, Under-Graduate Teacher and Graduate Teacher are found missing
from the relevant column of the SCERT and this lapse is not on the part of
the petitioners herein. To rectify this lapse, the Director, SCERT proposed to
the Administrative Department vide order dated 24.01.2018 for inclusion of
the omitted category.
[15]
On perusal of the letter dated 24.01.2018, the Director SCERT
did not propose any cut of date and the matter is wholly for inclusion.
However, the proposal of the Administrative Department has been approved
by the State cabinet in its meeting held on 22.12.2018 with concurrence of
the Finance Department(PIC).
[16]
It is submitted that due to financial constraint the date of effect
for these 3(three) particular post i.e. Primary Teacher, Under Graduate
Teacher and Graduate Teacher of SCERT is made from 01.01.2019 and the
petitioners are aggrieved by the date of effective.
WP(C)No.491 of 2022
Page 7
[17]
This Court is of the opinion that there is no justification giving a
different date of enforcement of the cash payment to the petitioners. If the
post of the petitioners are mentioned in the original R.O.P. 2010 issued vide
notification dated 05.05.2010, they would have been entitled to get cash
payment from 01.04.2010 as received by the other employees including the
employees of the SCERT originally included in the R.O.P. This Court is
constrained to hold that the case of the petitioners be covered by the original
date i.e. for cash payment from 01.04.2010 as mentioned in R.O.P. dated
05.05.2010.
[18]
Considering the principle of equality enshrined in article 14 of
the Constitution of India, the State respondents are directed to make cash
payment or arrear for the petitioner No.1 w.e.f 01.04. 2010 and petitioner
Nos. 2 & 3 from 11.12.2014 [as both joined service on 11.12.2014]
[19]
It is submitted that the date of impugned order dated
14.02.2019 was wrongly mentioned as 11.12.2014 in prayer and
accordingly, the petitioners have filed misc. case being MC(WP(C))No.340 of
2022 seeking prayer to correct the same. Accordingly, this Court by an order
dated 18.10.2022 passed in MC(WP(C))No.340 of 2022 permitted to
petitioners to correct the wrong date of the impugned order as 14.02.2019
and accordingly necessary correction was made by the Registry.
WP(C)No.491 of 2022
Page 8
[20]
In the peculiar facts and circumstance of the case and in order
to do complete justice, this Court directs to the respondents to give cash
payment or arrear to the petitioner No.1 w.e.f. 01.04.2010 and with respect
to petitioner Nos. 2 & 3 w.e.f. 11.12.2014 and the necessary rectification
shall be made within 2(two) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.
[21]
It is further clarified that the direction of payment is confined to
the petitioners herein.
[22]
With this observations, this writ petition is disposed of.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
John kom
WP(C)No.491 of 2022
Page 9
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review