Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2023.12.22
TELEN KOM Date:
17:38:43 +05'30'
Item No.66
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
Smt. Yambem Kamala Devi aged about 55 years W/o K. Achouba Singh,
resident of Tangkham, PO Pangei Yangdong, PS Heingang, Imphal East
District, Manipur-794114.
…Petitioner
- Versus -
1. The State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner/Secretary
Education (S), Govt. of Manipur, Secretariat Block, PO & PS Imphal,
Imphal, Manipur-795001.
2. The Director of Education(S), Govt. of Manipur at Lamphel Pat, Imphal
west, PS Lamphel.
3. The School Managing Committee(SMC) of Cosmopolitan High School,
Chingkhu(Government Aided), through the Secretary SMC, Chingkhu, PO
Pangei Yangdong, Imphal East, Manipur-795114.
4. Shri S. Mani Singh, aged about 60 yrs S/o.(L), S. Paka Singh, a resident
of Naoremthong Khumanthem Leikai, Takyel Mapal, PO Langjing & PS
Patsoi, Manipur-795113.
5. K. Tolendro Singh, Science Graduate Teacher EIN(054890), of Praja Hr.
Sec. School, retired on 31.01.2022 S/o (L) Koijam Mangol Singh a resident
of Lamshang Bazar, Near Bridge, PO & PS Lamshang, District Imphal
West-795146.
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
Page 1
6. S. Nabakumar Singh, Science Graduate Teacher EIN(059310) of
Kasturba Girls’ Jr. High School, retired on 31.05.2022 S/ (L) Sinam Dijen, a
resident of Hillghat Sorok Atingbi, Jiribam, PO & PS Jiribam-795116.
7. E. Gouramohon Singh, Primary Teacher EIN(064075) of Hiyanglam Jr.
High School, retired on 30.06.2022 S/o. Elangbam Tomchou Singh, a
resident of Hiyanglam, PO Kakching, PS. Hiyanglam, District Kakching795103.
8. Ringkahao Ringui, Principal, EIN(061200) of Jessami Hr. Sec. School
(retired on 31.01.2022) Jessami Village PO & PS Jessami, Ukhrul District,
Manipur-795142.
…Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE JUSTICE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
ORDER
(ORAL)
19.12.2023
[1]
Heard Mr. K. Achouba, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner, Mr. Abdul Baqee, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
No.4 and Mr. H. Debendra, learned Deputy AG assisted Mr. Somendro
Roy, learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos. 1 & 2.
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
Page 2
[2]
The respondent Nos. 3, 5,7 & 8 did not make appearance in
spite of proper service and the respondent No.6 submitted representation
dated 21.10.2023 stating that he has no objection in passing appropriate
order by this Court.
[3]
The respondent Nos. 1, 2 &4 filed counter affidavits.
[4]
The case of the petitioner in brief is that she is the senior most
teacher of Cosmopolitan High School, Chingkhu(Govt.Aided), Imphal East.
On the retirement of respondent No.4 as Headmaster of Cosmopolitan
High School, Chingkhu(Govt.Aided), Imphal East, the petitioner was made
in-charge as headmistress vide order dated 28.03.2022 passed by the
School Management Committee(Respondent No.3) and vide order dated
31.03.2022, the ZEO Zone-II, Government of Manipur acknowledged the
same. Thereafter, vide order dated 22.04.2022 issued by Deputy
Secretary(Education-S), Government of Manipur, the service of the private
respondent No.4 to 8 were extended for period of 1 year/2(two) years as
per the office memorandum dated 27.03.2015 issued by the Department of
Personnel and Administrative Reforms, Government of Manipur. The Office
memorandum dated 27.08.2015 empowers the Government for extension
of service of national awardees and State awardees for 2(two) years and
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
Page 3
1(one) years respectively in recognition of their services and for optimum
utilization subject to their willingness and other eligibility conditions such as
medical and other. Para (i) of the office Memorandum dated 27.03.2015 is
reproduced herein.
“(i). The services of teachers conferred with National Award
shall be extended for a maximum period of 2(two) years for
National Awardees and 1(one) year for State Awardees
respectively beyond the date of superannuation with the
same status and powers enjoyed by them before the
extension is allowed w.e.f 31.12.2012.
[5]
Being aggrieved by the order dated 24.04.2022 issued by the
Government of Manipur extending the service of the private respondents,
the petitioner approached this Court by way of the present writ petition for
quashing the same and the prayers are reproduced as
(i) Issue rule in nisi and call for record:
(ii) Issue a writ in the nature of certiorari or any other
appropriate writ or direction for quashing and setting aside the
impugned orders dated 22.04.2022(Annexure-A/3) under No.
PS1-701/2/2021-EDN(S)
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
extending
service
of
S.
Mani
Page 4
Singh(Respondent No.4) pursuant to DP’s O.M. dated
27.03.2015
(iii) Issue a writ in the nature of certiorari or any other
appropriate writ or direction for quashing and setting aside the
impugned
order
dated
30.04.2022(Annexure-A/5)
Headmistress appointment and allowing Respondent No.4 to
act as Headmaster in the school.
(iv) Issue an appropriate writ or direct the official respondents
to consider for appointment of the petitioner as Headmistress
in the Cosmopolitan High School.
[6]
Mr. K. Achouba, learned counsel for the petitioner submist that
the impugned order dated 22.04.2022 is issued in violation of the name of
the private respondent as State and National Awardee of OMs dated
06.08.2016, 19.12.2018 and 07.11. 2019 have been cancelled and the
names of the private respondents are mentioned in Annexure A1 at serial
No.7,11,21 and 24 Annexure A3 serial No.8.
[7]
It is submitted that since their names have been cancelled
from list of awardee, the impugned order dated 22.04.2022 extending their
service for period of 2/1 years is illegal, perverse and in violation of the
Office Memorandum dated 21.02.2020. It is also submitted that after
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
Page 5
retirement and upon extension by the impugned order, the respondent No.4
cannot
be
Headmaster
of
the
Cosmopolitan
High
School,
Chingkhu(Govt.Aided), Imphal East. The petitioner is mainly aggrieved by
the extension of the service of the respondent No.4.
[8]
Mr. K. Achouba, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
distinguishes the case of the respondent No.4 from that of other private
respondents on the ground that the respondent No.4 and the petitioner are
teachers in the Government Aided School while other private respondents
are teacher in the Government School. He further states that in
Government Aided School after retirement the incumbent cannot get any
retirement benefits.
[9]
It is the submission of Mr. K. Achouba, learned counsel for the
petitioner that Office Memorandum dated 21.02.2020 cancelled the names
of the private respondent and other mentioned in the memorandum issued
starting from the year 2016 and afterwards, their names cannot be
considered for service extension relying on the O.M of 2015.
[10]
This Court is of the opinion that this submission seemed to be
attractive but has no substance.
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
Page 6
[11]
Mr. H. Debendra, learned Deputy AG has raised the question
of maintainability of the writ petition on ground that the petitioner has not
challenged office Memorandum dated 27.03.2015 and the writ petition is
not maintainable as the petitioner has not challenged the Office
Memorandum dated 27.03.2015 which empowers the State for extension of
service of the meritorious State and National awardee teachers for period
of 1(one) and 2(two) years except for adding one line in the prayer.
[12]
Mr. H. Debendra, learned Deputy AG submits on merits that
the Office Memorandum dated 27.03.2015 issued by Department of
Personnel(DP), Government of Manipur covered the teachers under the
Education Department irrespective of whether he is in Government or
Government Aided Schools. This O.M. dated 27.03.2015 does not
distinguish between teacher working in Government Aided Schools and
Government Schools and as such in Para (i) of the O.M. says that Awardee
after extension shall have the same status and power prior to that
retirement. He further clarifies that the O.M. dated 21.02.2020 only
cancelled the name of the Awardees mentioned at Annexure(I) to (IV) and
it does not debar the deleted awardees for consideration in future.
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
Page 7
[13]
It is submitted that it will be clarified by para No.2 of OM.
Dated 21.02.2020 which stipulates that the Government may issue relevant
office memorandum for engagement of the canceled candidates from time
to time not earlier than 6(six) months from the different date of due
retirement.
[14]
Mr. Achouba, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
any office memorandum issued in this regard prior to year of 2016 cannot
be considered for consideration of the extension of the services of the State
Awardees and National Awardees. This submission has no substance. It
will be clear from the Para 2 of the office memorandum dated 21.02.2020
that the State Government may consider the names of the cancelled
candidates from time to time for extension by issuing relevant office
memorandum but not earlier than 6(six) months from the date of retirement.
It is further mentioned that there is no time period after the retirement.
[15]
Mr. H. Debendra, learned Deputy AG submits that in the
impugned order, the services of the respondent Nos. 4, 5 and 8 were
extended after retirement and that of respondent Nos. 3 & 4 were extended
prior to 2(two) months from the date of retirement.
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
Page 8
[16]
It is submitted that the O.M. dated 21.02.2020 issued in
pursuance to the Office Memorandum dated 27.03.2015, the caption of the
order such as office memorandum/notification/order does not affect the act
of the extension.
[17]
It is stated that office memorandum dated 27.03.2015 is a
State policy and this has not been reversed or reviewed by the State till
date.
[18]
It is prayed that the writ petition may be dismissed on the
ground of maintainability as well as on merit.
[19]
Mr. Abdul Baqee, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent No.4 has adopted the submissions of the learned Deputy AG
and stated that there is no illegality and
in the impugned order dated
22.04.2022 and the services of the respondent No.4 and other respondents
services be extended in terms of the Memorandum dated 27.03.2015. It is
submitted that the O.M. dated 27.03.2015 is not challenged in the present
writ petition.
[20]
This Court has perused the materials available on record and
considered the submissions made at Bar. By Office Memorandum dated
27.03.2015, the State Government formulates a scheme where in order to
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
Page 9
recognize the services of the meritorious State and National Awardee
teachers and for optimum utilization of their services and proposed to
extend 2(two) years services in case of National Awardees and 1(one) year
in case of State Awardees from the date of their superannuation provided
to their willingness and mental fitness working beyond the age of
superannuation. Para (i) of the said O.M. stipulates that the teacher will
have the same status and power enjoyed by them prior to extension and
this is the general rule for extending the service of the National and State
Awardees teacher working in Government Aided School and Government
Schools under the Government of Manipur.
[21]
In exercising the power conferred under O.M. 27.03.2015, the
State used to issue office memorandum or order listing the names of the
State Awardee for consideration for extension. Vide office memorandum
dated 21.02.2020 various listed names
of the State and National
Awardees have been cancelled and the same O.M. empowers the State
Government to issue relevant office memorandum for engagement of the
cancelled/deleted names for consideration of their services extension in
terms of the O.M dated 27.03.2015.
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
Page 10
[22]
The Office Memorandum dated 21.02.2020 does not prescribe
any outer time limit for extension after retirement.
[23]
The O.M. dated 21.02.2022 deleted the name of Awardees
annexed with the different O.Ms as mentioned in the (I) to (IV) annexed to
it. However, it does not say that deleted names are debarred from
consideration in future or it does not review/recall the office memorandum
dated 27.03.2015 which laid down a scheme for extension of the State and
National Awardees.
[24]
This Court, on perusal of the impugned order dated
27.04.2022, found that the services of the respondent Nos. 4, 5 & 8 have
been extended after the date of their retirement and that of respondent 6 &
7 prior to 2(two) months from the date of their retirement.
[25]
This Court is of the view that the extension of the private
respondent Nos. 4 to 8 are in consonance with the O.M dated 27.03.2015
as well as para 2 of the O.M dated 21.02.2020 where the names of the
private respondents and other have not deleted. Accordingly, this Court
uphelds the impugned order dated 22.04.2022. It is clarified that not
mentioning office memorandum in order dated 22.04.2022 does not affect
the legality of the order as the same is issued in compliance of the O.M.
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
Page 11
dated 27.05.2023 extending the service of the National and State
Awardees by 2(two) and 1(one) year respectively.
[26]
Accordingly, this writ petition is dismissed. No Costs.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
John kom
WP(C)No.684 of 2022
Page 12
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review