The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. 01.2022 rejecting two medical reimbursement applications, be set aside and respondents be directed to reimburse the amount of Rs. 2,27,068/- and Rs. 1,06,315/- as claimed by the petitioner for the two treatments undertaken by the deceased employee at Sky Hospital. [14] Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned G.A. for the State respondent, submits that the treatment has to be undertaken in Government empanelled hospital and the reimbursement was rightly rejected by the authority. It is also submitted that no prior permission was taken from the authority for undergoing treatment in the private hospital and it is prayed that writ petition be rejected on this ground alone. [15] This Court has perused the materials on record. Generally, in order to avail medical reimbursement, the treatments are to be undertaken in the Government hospital and in case of non-availability of facility in Government hospital or otherwise, Government employee can approach the empanelled hospital. But in the present case, the line of treatment to be given to the deceased employee is not available in any of the Government hospitals till date and other empanelled hospitals. On the advise of the treating Doctor of JNIMS referring to Higher Medical Institute, the Government employee was admitted in Sky Hospital and Research Centre for treatment especially TACE. In the case of Nepram Sonykumar case (Supra), treatment of chil…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Item No. 105
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 898 of 2022
Smt. W. Nichupelu
…..Petitioner/s
- Versus –
State of Manipur & 3 Ors.
.... Respondent/s
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
Order (Oral)
12.03.2026
[1]
Heard Mr. Seto T Kom, learned counsel along with Mr.
Karung H. Kom, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Th. Sukumar,
learned G.A. for the State respondent.
[2]
The petitioner is the widow of deceased Government
Employee namely Shri W. Thomas, who was serving as Grade-IV
employe in the Primary Health Centre (PHC in short) of Jessami, Ukhrul,
under the Medical Directorate, Manipur, Government of Manipur. As the
deceased employee was sick for some time, he attended the Out Patient
Dept. (OPD in short) of Jawaharlal Nehru Institute of Medical Sciences
& Hospital, Porompat, Imphal East (JNIMS) on 12.11.2018 and he was
diagnosed of sickness as Chronic Liver Disease (CLD) for which the
treating Doctor referred the deceased employee to the Higher Centre
with facilities for (a) TACE (Transcatheter Arterial Chemoembolisation,
where small embolic particles coated with Chemotherapeutic drugs are
injected through Catheter), (b) RFA (Radiofrequency Ablation) in which
radio waves are used to create a current heats in a small area of nerue
tissues. The heat destroys that area of the nerue, stopping it from
sending pain signals to the brain and (c) LDLT (Living Donor Liver
Transplantation).
[3]
As the above treatment facilities were not available in
JNIMS, RIMS and other Govt. Hospitals of Manipur, the deceased
employee was treated at a private hospital namely Sky Hospital &
Research Centre, RIMS Road, Imphal West, since 29.11.2018 and
discharged on 02.12.2018. In the second phase of treatment, the
deceased employee was treated at Sky Hospital from 13.08.2019 and
discharged on 16.08.2019. During these two phases of treatment, the
deceased employee was given TACE treatment at Sky Hospital as
advised by the treating Doctor of JNIMS. However, the Government
employee succumbed to his illness on 30.11.2019.
[4]
Thereafter, the medical reimbursement for the treatment
was submitted to the State Authority through the Chief Medical Officer,
Ukhrul to the Chairman of State Medical Board, Medical Directorate vide
letter dated 12.09.2019 for a sum of Rs. 2,72,068/- for the first phase of
treatment and for the second phase of treatment, a sum of Rs. 1,06,315/was submitted through the Chief Medical Officer, Ukhrul vide letter dated
17.03.2021 to the Chairman of State Medical Board. In respect of first
claim of medical reimbursement submitted on 12.09.2019, the same was
rejected vide letter dated 18.01.2022 issued by the Directorate of Health
Services, Manipur to the Chief Medical Officer, Ukhrul on the ground that
Sky Hospital and Research Centre is not a Government empanelled
hospital for the treatment of HCC and TACE for the treatment conducted
with effect from 29.11.2018 to 02.12.2018 and vide another letter dated
18.01.2022, the Directorate of Health Services, Manipur informed the
Chief Medical Officer about the rejection of medical reimbursement
submitted on 17.03.2021 for the second phase of treatment conducted
at Sky Hospital with effect from 13.08.2019 to 16.08.2019 for HCC and
TACE as the same hospital is not empanelled by the Manipur
Government.
[5]
By the present writ petition, the petitioner who is the widow
of the Government employee prays for quashing the impugned orders
both dated 18.01.2022 at Annexure-A/7 & A/8 rejecting the claim of
medical reimbursement for two phases of treatment conducted at Sky
Hospital for HCC & TACE.
[6]
The State respondent filed counter affidavit, inter-alia,
stating in para 6 that the Sky Hospital and Research Centre where the
Government employee undergone treatment for the procedure of HCC
and TACE was not empanelled by the Government of Manipur and
accordingly, the two applications for medical reimbursement were
rejected by the Medical Board and it is the case of the State respondent
that Sky Hospital and Research Institute is empanelled for treatment of
heart disease and not for HCC and TACE.
[7]
When the matter was taken up on 18.08.2025, Mr. Serto T
Kom, learned counsel for the petitioner, especially mentioned that the
treatment for TACE/RFA/LDLT is not available in any of the Government
hospital except Sky Hospital during the relevant period and in the
circumstances, rejection of medical claim on the ground that Sky
Hospital was empanelled only for heart disease and not for treating
TACE, RFA and LDLT is not tenable. Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned G.A. for
the State respondent, prayed for some time to take specific written
instructions as to whether the treatment of TACE/RFA/LDLT for liver
treatment is available in any Government hospital and/or empanelled
hospitals during 2018-2019 when the husband of the petitioner was
treated in Sky Hospital.
[8]
The Director, JNIMS informed Directorate of Health
Services, Manipur vide letter dated 18.09.2025 that TACE is not done in
JNIMS as there is no Cath. Laboratory facility since inception. The
Directorate of Health Services, Manipur submitted a letter dated
26.02.2026 addressed to the Ld. Addl. Government Advocate, High
Court of Manipur enclosing a letter dated 25.02.2026 issued by the
Medical Superintendent (i/c), RIMS that facility of TACE was not
available in RIMS hospital on 12.11.2018 and the same is not available
in the hospital till date. These two letters are taken on record.
[9]
It is cleared from the letters issued by the JNIMS and RIMS
Authority that treatment of TACE is not available in the two premier and
referral Government hospitals in Manipur. No document is on record to
establish that such facility is available in any other hospital in Manipur
except Sky Hospital.
[10]
Mr. Serto T Kom, learned counsel for the petitioner,
submits that rejection of medical reimbursement on the ground that the
Sky Hospital is/was not empanelled hospital for the treatment of HCC
and TACE as mentioned in the impugned letters dated 18.01.2019. It is
stated that as the facility for treatment was not available in the
Government hospital and he was treated at Sky Hospital & Research
Institute on the advise of treating Doctor of JNIMS. It is stated that right
to life of a person is paramount and reimbursement for treatment cannot
be denied on technical ground that the hospital is not empanelled by the
government.
[11]
Learned counsel for the petitioner refers to the decision of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of (i) Surjit Singh vs. State of
Punjab reported in (1996) 2 SCC 336, para 11 and (ii) Shiva Kant Jha
vs. Union of India reported in (2018) 16 SCC 187, para 17 & 19 to the
point that right of medical claim cannot be denied merely because the
name of the hospital is not included in the Government panel. The real
test must be the factum of treatment and once the factum of treatment is
supported by records duly certified by Doctors or hospitals concerned,
the claim cannot be denied on technical grounds.
[12]
Learned counsel for the petitioner also relies on the
decision of this Court in the order dated 16.08.2024 passed by this Court
in WP(C) No. 594 of 2023 in the case of Shri Nepram Sonykumar vs.
State of Manipur where this Court directed to reimburse expenses for
medical treatment done in private hospitals when the facility is not
available in the Government hospital. Similarly situated persons have
availed such facility for treating in the same hospital and their medical
bills have been released by State.
[13]
Mr. Serto T Kom, learned counsel for the petitioner,
submits that appeal preferred against the order dated 16.08.2024 in
Nepram Sonykumar Case (supra) has already been rejected by a
Division Bench of this Court in MC(WA) No. 123 of 2025 vide order dated
12.01.2026. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that in terms of
the letters submitted by the JNIMS and RIMS Authority, it is cleared that
facility of TACE for treatment of deceased Government employee at Sky
Hospital was not available in the referral Government hospitals in
Manipur. Relying on the above decision, it is prayed that two impugned
letters/orders
both
dated
18.01.2022
rejecting
two
medical
reimbursement applications, be set aside and respondents be directed
to reimburse the amount of Rs. 2,27,068/- and Rs. 1,06,315/- as claimed
by the petitioner for the two treatments undertaken by the deceased
employee at Sky Hospital.
[14]
Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned G.A. for the State respondent,
submits that the treatment has to be undertaken in Government
empanelled hospital and the reimbursement was rightly rejected by the
authority. It is also submitted that no prior permission was taken from the
authority for undergoing treatment in the private hospital and it is prayed
that writ petition be rejected on this ground alone.
[15]
This Court has perused the materials on record. Generally,
in order to avail medical reimbursement, the treatments are to be
undertaken in the Government hospital and in case of non-availability of
facility in Government hospital or otherwise, Government employee can
approach the empanelled hospital. But in the present case, the line of
treatment to be given to the deceased employee is not available in any
of the Government hospitals till date and other empanelled hospitals. On
the advise of the treating Doctor of JNIMS referring to Higher Medical
Institute, the Government employee was admitted in Sky Hospital and
Research Centre for treatment especially TACE. In the case of Nepram
Sonykumar case (Supra), treatment of child of the petitioner was
undertaken at Mother’s Care Children Hospital and Research Centre,
Imphal on the reference of the earlier hospital even though Mother’s
Care Children Hospital and Research Centre, Imphal was not
empanelled.
[16]
In Nepram Sonykumar Case (Supra), this Court directed
the State respondent to release admissible expenditure as per law on
the ground that preservation of one’s life is necessary concomitant on
right to life enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution and rejection of
the request
for reimbursement cannot be sustained when similar
reimbursement was allowed for treatment in the same hospital for other
Government employees.
[17]
In the present case also, the treatment for TACE is not
available in any Government hospital and treatment in Sky Hospital was
required to save life of the employee. In the circumstances, writ petition
is allowed. The impugned two letters dated 18.01.2022 rejecting the
medical reimbursement applications are set aside and the respondents
are directed to reimburse the medical expenses of the deceased
employee. After due fresh calculation, admissible reimbursement for the
two treatments of the deceased employee at Sky Hospital be released
to the petitioner within a period of two months from the date of receipt of
a copy of this order.
[18]
With this observation, writ petition is disposed of. Interim
order, if any, is merged with the final order.
KH.
JOSHUA
MARING
Digitally signed
by KH. JOSHUA
MARING
Date: 2026.03.13
15:33:17 +05'30'
JUDGE
Kh. Joshua Maring
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review