Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHOUGRAK Digitally signed by
SHOUGRAKPAM
PAM
DEVANANDA
DEVANAND SINGH
Date: 2024.04.26
A SINGH
12:16:17 +05'30'
IN. 59
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No. 532 of 2020
Smt. W. Manileima Devi
Vs.
State of Manipur & ors.
… Petitioner
… Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(Oral)
25-04-2024
[1]
Heard Mr. I. Denning, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner; Mr. Th. Vashum, learned GA appearing for the respondents
No. 1 to 4 and Mr. S. Jasobanta, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent No. 5.
[2]
The case of the petitioner is that she was initially appointed as a
Substitute Assistant Graduate Teacher at Khurai Girls’ High School at
Imphal vide order dated 06-09-1986 issued by the Director of Education
(S), Government of Manipur, for a period of six months and her service was
extended from time to time. Subsequently, by an order dated 21-07-1992
issued by the Director of Education (S), Government of Manipur, the
petitioner along with other 151 (one hundred and fifty one) candidates were
appointed temporarily as Arts Graduate Teacher w.e.f. the date of issuance
of the said order. Later on, by an order dated 16-02-2005 issued by the
Director of Education (S), Government of Manipur, the period of service
rendered by the petitioner from the date of her appointment as Substitute
Teacher w.e.f. 06-09-1986 till the date of her regular appointment as Arts
Graduate Teacher, i.e., 21-07-1992 was regularized by linking up such
period of service. Thereafter, the petitioner retired from service w.e.f.
31-10-2019 on attaining the age of superannuation. After her retirement
from service, due process were taken up by the authorities for releasing
WP(C) No. 532 of 2020
Contd…/-
-2-
her pension and other retiral benefits. During the course of such process,
the Office of the Accountant General (A & E), Manipur, wrote a letter dated
01-05-2020 to the Under Secretary (Pension Cell), Government of Manipur
pointing out some irregularities in the fixation of the pay scale of the
petitioner as well as linking up of her past service and requesting for
making rectification of the irregularities and to submit a revised LPC,
statement of excess payment and for recovery of over-payment of pay and
allowances from the retiral benefits of the petitioner.
[3]
After receiving the said letter from the Office of the Accountant
General, Manipur, the concerned authorities of the State Government did
not take any action for making any rectification and as such, the petitioner
was not given any retiral benefits or pension even after her retirement from
service w.e.f. 31-10-2019 for the last about five years. Having been
aggrieved, the petitioner approached this court by filing the present writ
petition for redressing her grievances.
[4]
Mr. I. Denning, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submitted that even assuming that if any excess payments have been
made to the petitioner, the same had been done more than 19 years ago
and that since the petitioner has retired from service in the year 2019, the
respondents cannot make any recovery of any alleged excess payment
from the retiral benefits or pension of the petitioner. It has further been
submitted that the issue raised in the present writ petition is squarely
covered by the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case
of “State of Punjab & ors. Vs. Rafique Masih (White Washer) & ors.”
reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334 and the order dated 11-01-2024 passed by
this court in WP(C) No. 528 of 2018. The learned counsel, lastly, submitted
that as the petitioner has been suffering for the last about five years due to
non-payment of her pensionary and other retiral benefits, the present writ
petition may be disposed of by directing the authorities to expedite the
WP(C) No. 532 of 2020
Contd…/-
-3-
process of releasing her pensionary and other retiral benefits and to
release the same within a stipulated period.
[5]
Mr. S. Jasobanta, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
No. 5 submitted that scrutiny of pension papers of a retired Government
employee is the bounden duty of the Office of the Principal Accountant
General (A & E), Manipur and that on scrutiny of pension papers and
service records of the petitioner, it was ascertained that certain
irregularities have been committed by the authorities in fixation of her pay
scale and in regularizing her past service rendered on substitute basis
and as such, the Office of the Accountant General (A & E), Manipur, wrote
the impugned letter dated 01-05-2020 to the Under Secretary (Pension
Cell), Government of Manipur, for rectification of the irregularities and to
submit a revised LPC, statement of excess payment and recovery of
over-payment of pay and allowances from the retiral benefits of the
petitioner. The learned counsel accordingly, submitted that as the
authorities have not make any rectification, the Office of the Accountant
General could not process for releasing the pensionary and other retiral
benefits of the petitioner.
[6]
Mr. Th. Vashum, learned GA appearing for the State
respondents submitted that certain mistake has been committed by the
authorities in linking up and regularizing the past service rendered by the
petitioner on substitute basis and that the authorities have the power and
right to recover any over-payment of pay and allowances from the retiral
benefits of the petitioner on discovery of such irregularities, however, the
learned GA fairly submitted that as on today, the authorities have not taken
up any rectification process and as such, the authorities could not finalized
the payment of pension and other retiral benefits of the petitioner.
[7]
I have heard the rival submissions advanced by the counsel
appearing for the parties and also carefully examined the materials
WP(C) No. 532 of 2020
Contd…/-
-4-
available on record. On examination of the record, it is found that the
petitioner was appointed on regular basis by an order dated
21-07-1992 with immediate effect and the period of service rendered by
her on substitute basis was also regularized by an order dated 16-02-2005,
nearly two decades back and that the said order has not been modified or
revoked by the authorities till date. Even assuming that any irregularities
have been committed by the authorities in fixation of her pay and
allowances and assuming that excess payment of pay and allowances
have been given to the petitioner, the same had been done nearly two
decades back. Moverover, the petitioner has already retired from service
w.e.f. 31-10-2019 on attaining the age of superannuation. In such a
situation, this court is of the considered view that at this point of time, no
recovery can be made by the authorities from the retiral benefits and other
service benefits of the petitioner in view of the settled principle of law laid
down by the Hon’ble Apex Court as well as by this court.
[8]
In this regard, we can gainfully rely on the judgment rendered by
the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of “State of Punjab & ors. Vs. Rafique
Masih (White Washer) & ors.” reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334 wherein after
referring to a number of its earlier judgments, it has been held by the
Hon’ble Apex Court as under:“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship which
would govern employees on the issue of recovery, where
payments have mistakenly been made by the employer, in
excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may, based on the
decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as a ready
reference, summarise the following few situations, wherein
recoveries by the employers, would be impermissible in law:
(i)
Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III and
Class IV service (or Group C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the employees
who are due to retire within one year, of the order of
recovery.
WP(C) No. 532 of 2020
Contd…/-
-5(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess payment
has been made for a period in excess of five years, before
the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has wrongfully been
required to discharge duties of a higher post, and has been
paid accordingly, even though he should have rightfully
been required to work b against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the conclusion,
that recovery if made from the employee, would be
iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an extent, as would
far outweigh the equitable balance of the employer's right
to recover.”
[9]
In the case of Rafique Masih (White Washer) (supra), the
Hon’ble Apex Court laid down few situations/ exceptions wherein
recoveries by the employers would be impermissible in law. Some of such
situations where recovery is impermissible in law are:- (i) recovery from the
employees belonging to Class III and Class IV service (or Group C and
Group D service); (ii) recovery from the retired employees, or the
employees who are due to retire within one year, of the order of recovery;
and (iii) recovery from the employees, when excess payment has been
made for a period in excess of five years, before the order of recovery is
issued.
[10]
In the present case, since the petitioner holds a Class – III post
before her retirement and since any alleged excess payment has been
made nearly two decades back, this court is of the considered view that it
is not permissible to make any recovery from the retirement benefits of the
petitioner on ground of excess payment of pay and allowances, in view of
the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court referred to
hereinabove.
[11]
In the result, the present writ petition is allowed by quashing and
setting aside the letter dated 01-05-2020 of the Office of the Senior
Accounts Officer (Pension) addressed to the Under Secretary (Pension
Cell), Government of Manipur. The respondents No. 1 to 3 are directed to
WP(C) No. 532 of 2020
Contd…/-
-6-
furnish all the necessary pension papers of the petitioner to the Office of
the Principal Accountant General (A & E), Manipur within a period of two
months, if the same has not already submitted. The Office of the Principal
Accountant General (A & E), Manipur is directed to expedite the process
and to release the pension and other retiral benefits of the petitioner within
a period of two months from the date of receipt of all the pension papers.
It is further made clear that if the Office of the Principal Accountant General
(A & E), Manipur have already received the pension papers of the
petitioner, the process of payment of pension shall be completed within a
period of two months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
order.
With the aforesaid direction, the present writ petition is disposed
of. Parties are to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Devananda
WP(C) No. 532 of 2020
Contd…/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review