Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 132 OF 2025
Smt. Ujjala Rani Paul,
D/o Lt. Rash Bihari Paul,
R/o Dhaleswar, Road No.3, P.O. Dhaleswar,
P.S. East Agartala, District-West Tripura.
….Petitioner.
Versus
1.Agartala Municipal Corporation,
To be represented by the Municipal Commissioner, AMC, City center,
Paradise Chowmuhani, P.O.- Agartala, Agartala, West Tripura-799001.
2.The Municipal Commissioner,
Agartala Municipal Corporation, City center, Paradise Chowmuhani, P.OAgartala, Agartala, West Tripura-799001.
3.The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary, Urban Development Department,
Govt. of Tripura, Agartala, New Secretariat Building, Kunjaban, P.S - New
Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN-799010.
4.The Secretary,
Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, Agartala, New Secretariat Building,
Kunjaban, P.S New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN799010.
5.The Director,
Urban Development Department, Govt. of Tripura, Near Rabindra
Satabarsiki Bhavan, P.O- Agartala, Pin-799001, West Tripura.
6.The Principal Accountant General,
O/o the Accountant General (A and E), Tripura, Agartala, P.O- Kunjaban,
West Tripura, PIN-799 006.
7.The Senior Accounts Officer,
O/o the Principal Accountant General (A and E), Tripura, Agartala, P.OKunjaban, West Tripura, PIN-799 006.
….Respondents.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, Advocate.
Date of hearing
: 12.02.2026
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
01.04.2026
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER
One Rash Bihari Paul who was a labourer in Agartala
Municipal Corporation, went on superannuation on 01.10.2004. During his
lifetime, he was receiving pension as per the rules. He died on
02.12.2018. His wife pre-deceased him.
2.
The present petitioner at the time of death of the original
deceased pensioner was given marriage to one person, namely Sir Pradip
Saha but thereafter the said marital bond could not sustain and ultimately,
they got a decree of divorce from the court of learned Judge, Family
Court, Agartala on 04.10.2021.
3.
Thereafter, the petitioner applied for family pension as per
Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pension) Rules, 2017 (hereinafter
referred as the Revised Pension Rules, 2017) on 23.02.2022 [Annexure11]. She, also sent remainder and legal notice in this regard and in turn,
the Municipal Authority rejected her prayer vide communication dated
04.10.2024 [Annexure-16] taking the plea that the notification dated
28.03.2018 of the State Government by which the amended provision of
pension rules was adopted entitling the divorcee daughter to get pension,
was not adopted by the Municipal Authority. Therefore, the present writ
petition has been filed by the writ petitioner.
4.
The Municipal Authority, however after appearing in this writ
petition contended through their counter affidavit that at the time of death
of the original pensioner, Rash Bihari Paul, the present writ petitioner was
not a divorced daughter and her such event of divorce took place much
later than the date of death of her father and therefore, she was not
entitled to any such family pension.
5.
Learned senior counsel, Mr. P. Roy Barman argues that just
after a few days of the marriage of the petitioner, her husband went
missing and she took shelter in her father’s house and there she was
living for more than 40 years. In support of such fact, he also relies on a
decree dated 04.10.2021, passed by learned Judge, Family Court,
Agartala, West Tripura which was drawn on the basis of compromise
petition submitted by the petitioner and her husband [Part-1 of Annexure-1
to the writ petition] and in said joint compromise petition, above said facts
were mentioned and ultimately, when the marriage tie between the parties
were irretrievably broken down and there were no relation between them
for a long period, they mutually agreed to go for a divorce.
6.
According to learned senior counsel, at the time of death of
her father, the petitioner was not a divorced daughter, but she was
dependent on her father and in the year 2021, she submitted the said
petition for divorce which was accordingly allowed. Learned senior
counsel, Mr. Roy Barman also contends that in the Revised Pension
Rules, 2017 [Annexure-R/1] as applicable to the employees of Agartala
Municipal Corporation by virtue of Notification dated 21.12.1991
[Annexure-7] and notification dated 04.01.1992 [Annexure-8], there is no
restriction placed in the said Rules that to get such family pension, the
divorce shall have to take place during the life time of the original
pensioner or the spouse, or that at least such petition shall have to be
filed when the original pensioner was alive. According to Mr. Roy Barman,
learned senior counsel, when no such differentiation has not been created
by the legislature, the respondents cannot deny family pension to the
petitioner by creating two different classes of the same homogeneous
section of the pensioner.
7.
To support his contention, Mr. Roy Barman also relies on a
decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of All Manipur Pensioners
Association vs. State of Manipur & Ors., AIR 2019 SC 3338. In the said
case, State of Manipur adopted the Central Civil Service Pension Rules,
1972 as amended from time to time and as per Rule 49 of the said Rules,
a govt. employee retired in accordance with the provision of the Rules
after completing qualifying service of not less than 30 years, would be
entitled to 50% of the average emoluments as monthly pension subject to
maximum of Rs.4500/- per month. However, considering the increase in
the cost of living, the Govt. of Manipur decided to increase the quantum of
pension as well as the pay of the employees and accordingly, they issued
an Office Memo. dated 21.04.1999 revising the quantum of pension with
stipulation that the employees who had gone on retirement on or after
01.01.1996 would be entitled to the revised pension at the higher rate
whereas those who had retired before 01.01.1996 would be entitled to a
lower percentage as was existing. Matter was finally challenged before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court. The Apex Court in that case while observing that
there cannot be two classes in a homogeneous group, holds that such
differentiation created by the State govt. of Manipur was arbitrary.
8.
Learned counsel, Mr. A. Bhaumik for the respondent-
Municipal Corporation submits that for getting family pension, the divorced
daughter should be a family member of the original pensioner having
dependency on him/her and such divorce proceeding should commence
at least when the original pensioner was alive. He also submits that the
eligibility to receive the pension should accrue immediately on the date of
death of the original pensioner and not subsequently and in the instant
case, the eligibility of the present petitioner to receive such family pension
arose only in the year 2021 when she was granted decree of divorce, and
therefore, it is clear that when the original pensioner died, she was not a
divorced daughter and therefore, she was not entitled to get any family
pension. He however did not dispute that said Revised Pension Rules of
2017 is applicable in case of employees of the municipal corporation.
Learned counsel also relies on two Office Memos. issued by the Govt. of
India, dated 11.09.2013 and 19.07.2017 wherein some clarificatory notes
were issued by the Central Govt. regarding claim of family pension by
divorced daughters. He also relies on a decision of a Division Bench of
Calcutta High Court in case of Union of India & Ors. vs. Mita Saha
Karmakar, WP.CT 36 of 2025, decided on 09.12.2025 to gain support of
his submissions.
9.
Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel further contends that the writ
petition is bereft of necessary particulars such as when divorce petition
was filed or when she was deserted by her husband or whether at the
time of death of original pensioner she was dependant on him or not etc.
Moreover, at paragraph nos. 16 and 29 of the writ petition, it is mentioned
that she is claiming pension from the date of death of her father, whereas,
she obtained decree of divorce in the year 2021.
10.
Mr. Bhaumik also submits that though the Central Govt.
notifications are not adopted in the State of Tripura, but for the purpose of
interpretation of pari materia provisions, assistance thereof can be taken
to. He also submits that the decree of divorce was a compromise decree
and no formal adjudication of dispute between the parties was there.
According to him, the required Form No.14 in terms of Finance
Department Memo. dated 28.03.2018 was also not complied with by the
petitioner and even, the income certificate as submitted was also not
issued by the competent authority.
11.
Learned senior counsel, Mr. Roy Barman in reply submits
that the Central Govt. notifications were never adopted in the State of
Tripura and therefore, the same cannot be applied in the State.
12.
As it appears from the rival contention of both sides, the core
issue involved in this case for decision is whether the petitioner who has
filed the petition for divorce long after the death of her father and has later
on obtained the decree of divorce can claim family pension. The Revised
Pension Rules, 2017 was notified on 11.07.2017 giving its force with
effect from 01.04.2017. The said Rules were framed exercising power
under Article 309 of the Constitution of India by the State Govt. and these
Rules are made in supersession or modification of the relevant provisions
contained in the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 as adopted
and made applicable to the State pensioners earlier with amendments
made by the State Govt. from time to time. It is also mentioned therein
that all other provisions in the adopted Rules which are not repugnant to
the provision of these Rules, shall continue to apply till amended or
repealed.
13.
Rule 8 of the said Rules makes provision for payment of
family pension to the unmarried/widow daughter/divorced/disabled
child in the following manner:
8. PAYMENT OF FAMILY PENSION FOR UNMARIED/ WIDOW
DAUGHTER/ DIVORCEE/DIVORCEE DAUGHER/ DISABLED CHILD:
Family
pension
shall
be
admissible
to
non-earning
unmarried daughter (until her marriage)/widow daughter (until her remarriage)/divorcee daughter (until restoration of her conjugal life) and
disabled children in the event of death of the pensioner and his/her
spouse.
Criteria
for
non-earning
unmarried
daughter/widow
daughter/divorcee daughter will be determined on the basis of monthly
income upto Rs.3000/-. This benefit shall be effective from 1st day of
Aril, 2017 and shall be extended only in genuine cases after proper
verification of the records.
14.
On plain reading of the said clause, it appears that the
divorced daughter of the original pensioner, government employee, is
entitled to get family pension on his or his spouse’s death as the case
may be. Therefore, the condition precedent for entitlement to family
pension is that the daughter should be a divorced daughter when the
original pensioner died as the right to receive such pension accrues on
the death of the original pension or on the death of his/her spouse who
was receiving the pension. There are many cases where divorce petition
though filed during the life time of the original pensioner or of his/her
spouse, could not be disposed of by granting a decree of divorce by the
concerned court before the death of the concerned parent of the
applicant. Therefore, with a holistic approach, the Govt. of India, Ministry
of Personnel, P.G. & Pension, Department of Pension & Pensioners’
Welfare by their Office Memos. dated 11.09.2013 and 19.07.2017 as
relied on by learned counsel, Mr. A. Bhaumik, has also extended the
benefit to these cases declaring them to be entitled to the family pension.
15.
In the Office Memo. dated 11.09.2013 it clarified that the
family pension is payable to the children as they are considered to be
dependent on the Govt. servant/pensioner or his/her spouse, and
therefore, only those children who are dependent and meet other
conditions of eligibility for family pension at the time of death of the Govt.
servant or his/her spouse, whichever is later, are eligible for family
pension and similarly family pension to a widowed/divorced daughter is
payable provided she fulfils all eligibility conditions at the time of
death/ineligibility of her parents and on the date her turn to receive the
family pension comes.
16.
In the Office Memo. dated 19.07.2017, it is further clarified
that benefit of family pension shall be extended to a divorced daughter in
such cases where the divorce proceeding has been initiated in a
competent Court during the life time of the employee/pensioner or his/her
spouse, but divorce took place after their death, provided that the claimant
fulfills all other conditions for grant of family pension.
17.
In the case of Mita Saha Karmakar (supra), the petitioner
was guided by the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 and
petition for divorce was filed by her prior to the death of her father, the
original pensioner. In the said case, the High Court after taking into
consideration of the Office Memo. dated 19.07.2017, held that she was
covered by the said Office Memo. and was entitled to the family pension.
18.
According to the Court, at the time of death of original
pensioner and/or her spouse, the divorced daughter should have her
dependency on her parent being separated from her husband. In the case
in hand, it appears that the present petitioner had her dependency on her
father at the time of his death. From the contents of her application
submitted on 23.02.2022 to the Municipal Commissioner [Annexure-11], it
appears that after a few days of her marriage, her husband left her in her
father’s house and did not take her back again. She thus became
dependent on her father but such dependency ceased to exist
immediately on the death of her father and at that time, her status was of
a ‘married daughter separated from her husband’ and not a divorced
daugher. The Rules do not permit grant of family pension to said category
of married daughters.
19.
The date of institution of said divorce proceeding is not
divulged by her in her writ petition. But from the order of the learned
Judge, Family Court it appears that she instituted the said suit for divorce
in the year 2021 as can be gathered from the registration number of said
proceeding. Vide order dated 04.10.2021, the Court granted her the
decree of divorce on compromise arrived at between the parties.
20.
Already it is discussed in the earlier paragraph that at the
time of death of the father of the petitioner, her status was not of a
divorced daughter rather of a married daughter separated from her
husband and dependant on her father. The Revised Pension Rules, 2017
does not cover the case of the petitioner to extend the benefit of family
pension in her favour and there is no challenge regarding said Rules on
the ground of arbitrariness or discrimination. The Court under Art.226
cannot rewrite a Rule by stretch of interpretation. This also cannot be
treated as a case of discrimination amongst one homogenous class of
people as only some specified categories of married daughters are
entitled to get benefit of family pension and not all.
21.
In Union of India v. Deoki Nandan Aggarwal, 1992 Supp
(1) SCC 323, Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:
“ 14. ……………….. It is not the duty of the court either to enlarge the
scope of the legislation or the intention of the legislature when the language of the
provision is plain and unambiguous. The court cannot rewrite, recast or reframe
the legislation for the very good reason that it has no power to legislate. The power
to legislate has not been conferred on the courts. The court cannot add words to a
statute or read words into it which are not there. Assuming there is a defect or an
omission in the words used by the legislature the court could not go to its aid to
correct or make up the deficiency. Courts shall decide what the law is and not what
it should be. The court of course adopts a construction which will carry out the
obvious intention of the legislature but could not legislate itself…..”
22.
In view of above discussions, it is held that the reliefs as
sought by the petitioner claiming family pension on the ground of death of
her father cannot be allowed.
23.
Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. No order as to
costs. Interim application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed.
JUDGE
signed by SANJAY GHOSH
SANJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2026.04.01 18:17:19 +05'30'
Sanjay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review