Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.519 of 2024
Smt. Tulsi Rani Das,
aged about 58 years,
Wife of Late Narayan Das,
Presently posted as Helper Gr-II in the
office of the Deputy General Manager,
Electrical Division, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura,
Resident of village 1 No. Ward, Rajnagar,
P.O. Udaipur Court, P.S. R.K. Pur,
Sub-Division: Udaipur, District: Gomati Tripura,
PIN:799 116
----Petitioner (s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura ,
Represented by the Principal Secretary,
Department of Power, New Secretariat Complex,
Khejur Bagan, P.O. Secretariat S.O.,
P.S. New Capital Complex,
District: West Tripura, PIN: 799 010
2. The Secretary,
Department of Finance,
New Secretariat Complex, Khejur Bagan,
P.O. Secretariat S.O.,P.S. New Capital Complex,
District: West Tripura, PIN: 799 010
3. The Tripura State Electricity Corporation Limited,
(A Government of Tripura Enterprise),
Represented by its Chairman having its office of the
Principal Secretary, Department of Power,
New Secretariat Complex, Khejur Bagan,
P.O. Secretariat S.O., P.S. New Capital Complex,
District: West Tripura, PIN:799 010
4. The Chairman,
Tripura State Electricity Corporation Limited,
(A Government of Tripura Enterprise)
Having its Office at the office of the Principal Secretary,
Department of Power,New Secretariat Complex,
Khejur Bagan, P.O. Secretariat S.O.,
P.S. New Capital Complex, District: West Tripura,
PIN:799 010
5. The Managing Director,
Tripura State Electricity Corporation Limited, Tripura,
Bidyut Bhavan, North Banamalipur, Agartala,
District: West Tripura, PIN:799 001
6. The Deputy General Manager,
Udaipur Electrical, Udaipur,
Gomati Tripura, PIN:799 116
---- Respondents (s)
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Date of Hearing
:
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
Mr. H. Laskar, Adv.
Mr. B. N. Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. K. Deb, Adv.
31.01.2025
06.02.2025
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
By means of filing this writ petition the petitioner has
prayed for the following reliefs:
(a) Admit the Writ Petition;
(b) Call for the records;
(c) Issue Writ in the nature of Certiorari to show
cause upon the Respondents as to why the Office
Order
vide
O.O.
NO.125
dated
03.06.2024
should not be declared as illegal, arbitrary and
non-est in the eye of law which has been issued
in contravention of the principle of the Judgment
and Order (Oral) dated 30.09.2021 passed in
W.P.(C) 792 of 2020 as well as in contravention
of
the
Memorandum
TSECL/HRM/Court
No.F.3(50)-
Case/2022/15882-97
dated
25.04.2022 passed by the TSECL, Agartala,
Tripura.
(d) Issue Writ in the nature of Certiorari to show
cause upon the Respondents as to why the
Memorandum
No.F.3(50)-TSECL/HRM/Court
Case/2022/50631-44 dated 07.12.2023 should
not be declared as illegal, arbitrary and non-est
in
the
eye
of
law
which
was
issued
in
contravention of the principle of the Judgment
and Order (Oral) dated 30.09.2021 passed in
WP(C) 792 of 2020 as well as in contravention of
the Memorandum No.F.3(50)-TSECL/HRM/Court
Case/2022/15882-97 dated 25.04.2022 passed
by the TSECL, Agartala, Tripura.
(e) Issue Writ in the nature of Mandamus
directing
the
Memorandum
Respondents
to
declare
the
No.F.3(50)-TSECL/HRM/Court
Case/2022/50631-44
dated
07.12.2023
as
illegal, arbitrary and non-est in the eye of law
and to quash and cancel the Memorandum
No.F.3(50)-TSECL/HRM/Court Case/2022/5063144 dated 07.12.2023 which has been issued in
contravention of the principle of the Judgment
and Order (Oral) dated 30.09.2021 passed in
WP(C)792 of 2020 as well as in contravention of
the Memorandum No.F.3(50)-TSECL/HRM/Court
Case/2022/15882-97 dated 25.04.2022 passed
by the TSECL, Agartala, Triura by declaring it as
illegal, arbitrary and non-est in the eye of law;
(f) Issue Writ in the nature of Mandamus
directing
the
Respondents
to
regularize
the
service of the petitioner to the post of Helper
Grade-II
with
pursuance
of
effect
the
TSECL/HRM/Court
from
01.12.2007
Memorandum
in
No.F.3(50)-
Case/2022/15882-97
dated
25.04.2022 passed by the TSECL, Agartala,
Tripura in compliance of the Judgment and Order
(Oral) dated 30.09.2021 passed by the Hon’ble
High Court of Tripura in WP(C) 792 of 2020;
(g)
Pass
such
further
relief/
reliefs,
direction/directions as the Hon’ble Court may
deem fits and proper having regards to the
circumstances of this case.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel Mr. H. Laskar appearing
for the petitioner and also heard Mr. B. N. Majumder,
Learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. K. Deb, Learned
counsel appearing for the respondents.
03.
The gist of the petition filed by the petitioner in
short is that the petitioner was engaged as a Contingent
Worker on 02.01.1999 by the Power Department. The
petitioner
filed
one
writ
petition
bearing
No.WP(C)
No.792/2020 against the Government, with assertions that
the Government had formulated a scheme vide memo dated
09.06.2019
for
regularization
of
all
DRWs/Casual/Contingent Workers working under the Power
Department whose services have been transferred on
deputation to the TSECL vide G.O. No.1 dated 28.12.2004.
The State Electricity Corporation adopted the said scheme.
One of the provisions of the scheme was that in case of
DRW/Casual/Contingent workers who had not completed 10
years of service as on 31.03.2003 but otherwise deserves to
be regularized, their cases would be considered upon
completion of ten years of service. The petitioner completed
10 years of service as a Contingent Worker on 01.01.2009.
As per memorandum dated 09.06.2009 (Clause-C) issued
by the Finance Department, Government of Tripura it was
observed that
communities
the
who
workers
had
belonging to
been
engaged
ST
on
and SC
or
before
31.03.2005 and whose names were issued vide memo
dated 14.03.2008 of the Finance Department would be
eligible for regularization with effect from 01.12.2007. The
petitioner was a member of the SC community and her
name was included at serial No.152 in the list for SC and ST
community
(Annexure-3)
published
by
the
Finance
Department declaring the names of the Contingent workers
eligible for regularization. According to the list, the services
of the petitioner ought to have been regularized with effect
from 01.12.2007 since the petitioner was engaged as the
Contingent
Worker
before
31.03.2003.
The
petitioner
received offer of appointment on 10.09.2015 issued by the
GM(Finance) & Company Secretary, TSECL, Agartala, but
the offer of appointment was kept in abeyance vide memo
dated 18.09.2015. But later on, the same was again
withdrawn vide order dated 07.08.2017. The writ petition
filed by the petitioner was disposed of vide order dated
30.09.2021 with the following directions:
“9. Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands disposed
with the following directions:(i) The corporation shall pass consequential order in
terms of the statement made and recorded hereinabove
within a period of two months from today.
(ii) Once this order is passed, the petitioner may make a
representation to the concerned authority for correct
seniority in the regular cadre. The concerned authority
shall consider Page 6 of 6 the same and pass a speaking
order within two months from the date of receipt of the
representation.
(iii) If there any grievance still surviving it would be open
for the petitioner to agitate the same in accordance with
the law.”
04.
It was further submitted by the petitioner that on
25.10.2021 after obtaining certified copy of judgment
passed in WP(C) No.792 of 2020 the petitioner submitted a
prayer for regularization of her service w.e.f. 01.12.2007
along with a copy of this judgment passed by this court. In
compliance of the judgment and order dated 30.09.2021
passed in the aforenoted case the authority of TSECL
sanctioned the arrear pay and allowances with notional
fixation w.e.f. 01.12.2007 and financial benefits vide memo
dated 25.04.2022. Accordingly pay due drawn statement for
the financial year 2022-23 and assessment year 2023-24
was prepared and arrear pay and allowances was disbursed
to the petitioner (memorandum dated 25.04.2022 along
with office order dated 20.06.2022 were annexed as
Annexure-9 and 10). It was further submitted by the
petitioner that all on a sudden after about eight months the
authority of the TSECL modifying the earlier memo dated
25.04.2022
and
issued
a
fresh
memorandum
dated
07.12.2023 stating inter alia that:
“In compliance of the Judgment & Order of the Hon’ble
High Court of Tripura against Case No.WP(C)792 of 2020
in favour of Smti. Tulshi Rani Das, Helper Gr-II, presently
posted in the office of the Deputy General Manager,
Electrical Division, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura would be
admissible similar benefit given to Smti Susmita
Chakraborty, MRCBC as per verdict of the Case No.
WP(C)704 of 2019 as the regulation of pay will be fixed
notionally with effect from 01.07.2008 and financial
benefit would be admissible with effect from 27.12.2010.
Henceforth the earlier Memorandum of this office
Memorandum
vide
No.F.3(50)-TSECL/HRM/Court
Case/2022/15882- 97 dated 25.04.2022 is hereby
modified.”
05.
After
receipt
of
the
copy
of
memo
dated
07.12.2023 the petitioner submitted an objection against
ex-parte
modification
of
earlier
memorandum
dated
25.04.2022 without assigning any reason misinterpreting
the judgment and order dated 30.09.2021 delivered by this
High Court in WP(C)No.704 of 2019. But on 03.06.2024
without considering the representation of the petitioner and
without giving any opportunity to the petitioner of being
heard the authority of the TSECL directed the office to
deduct the so-called excess payment in equal 12 nos. of
installment vide office order dated 03.06.2024 and the first
installment has already been deducted from the petitioner’s
salary bill of the month of June, 2023 payable in July
2023(Memorandum dated 07.12.2023, Office order dated
03.06.2024
and
representation
dated
24.01.2024
and
25.01.2024 are annexed with the petition as Annexure11,12, 13 and 14).
06.
The petitioner further asserted that one Shri
Uttam Debnath, MRCBC preferred one Writ Petition being
WP(C)692
of
seeking
his
regularization
w.e.f.
01.01.2007 in place of 01.01.2008 which was disposed of
on 31.01.2020 by this High Court with the following
direction in WP(C)704 of 2019 which runs as under:
“(i) The Corporation shall pass consequential order in
terms of the statement made and recorded hereinabove
within a period of two months from today.
(ii) Once this order is passed, the petitioner may make a
representation to the concerned authority for correct
seniority in the regular cadre. The concerned authority
shall consider the same and pass a speaking order within
two months from the date of receipt of the
representation.
(iii) If there any grievance still surviving it would be open
for the petitioner to agitate the same in accordance with
the law.
Petition is disposed of accordingly.”
07.
It was further submitted that in compliance of
the said judgment and order dated 31.01.2020 passed by
this High Court in WP(C)692 of 2019 TSECL has approved
the service of Shri Uttam Debnath with effect from
01.01.2007 instead of 01.07.2008 with financial benefits as
on 01.01.2007 and with admissible allowances vide memo
dated 24.12.2020. Copy of the order of the High Court and
the memo dated 24.12.2020 are annexed with the petition
as Annexure-15 and 16. It was further submitted that the
services of similarly situated persons have been regularized
in pursuance of the order dated 21.01.2020 in the case of
Smt. Susmita Chakraborty in WP(C)No.704 of 2019 with
effect from 01.07.2008 and in case of Uttam Debnath in
WP(C)692 of 2019 w.e.f. 01.01.2007 and several others
have been made regular, but the authority of TSECL after
eight months modifying an ex-parte order the earlier memo
dated 25.04.2022 issued a fresh memo dated 07.12.2023
as stated above. The petitioner further asserted that on
03.06.2024 without considering the representation of the
petitioner and giving any opportunity, the authority of
TSECL directed the office to deduct the so called excess
payment in equal 12 nos. of installments vide Office Order
No.125
dated
03.06.2024
which
may
cause
serious
deprivation of the petitioner due to the misinterpretation of
the order dated 21.01.2020 passed in WP(C)704 of 2019 by
the TSECL. The petitioner also submitted that the staterespondents willfully snatched away the financial benefits of
the petitioner in contravention of the principle enunciated in
order dated 21.01.2020 passed in WP(C)No.704 of 2019,
WP(C) 692 of 2019, WP(C) 522 of 2019 and WP(C)792 of
2020. It was also submitted that if the petitioner’s service is
not
regularized
with
effect
from
01.12.2007
by
the
appointing authority of the TSECL in pursuance of the
judgment and order dated 30.09.2021 passed in WP(C)792
of 2020 the petitioner shall suffer irreparable losses. Hence,
the petitioner has filed this writ petition seeking the reliefs
as stated above.
08.
The respondents-authority contested the case by
filing counter-affidavit. In para No.11 the respondents have
asserted the following facts:
“11. That the first para of the assertion made in is true
and hence admitted by the answering Respondents.
Paragraph No.5. That the remaining Paragraph of the
instant Writ Petition although admitted but the Petitioner
herein has made the averment with twisted view only to
support her case and thus the answering Respondents
under reply humbly submits that out of oversight the pay
of the Petitioner was notionally fixed from 01.12.2007
instead of notionally fixation from 01.07.2008 with
financial benefit from 27.12.2010. It is humbly submitted
by the answering Respondents that the Hon’ble High
Court in the Judgment dated 30.09.2021, passed in
connection with WP(C)792/2020 (Annexure-8/page 52
of the Writ Petition) referring the judgment of Susmita
Chakraborty (Supra) clearly directed to follow the same
direction. That following the said direction in case of
Susmita Chakraborty (Supra), Sushmita Chakraborty has
been provide with the regularization w.e.f. 01.07.2008
and pay has been fixed notionally from 01.07.2008 and
financial benefit from 27.12.2010.
The copy of the office order of pay fixation of
Sushmita Chakraborty vide dated 28.02.2020 is
attached here to as Annexure-R/2.
That actually the pay of Sushmita Chakraborty was also
notionally fixed from 01.07.2008 and financial benefit
was provided from 27.12.2010 and similarly the
representation of the Petitioner is squarely covered by
the case of Sushmita Chakraborty supra as per the
Judgment dated 30.09.2021 in connection with WP(C)
792/2020, and thus the notification dated 25/26.04.2022
(Annexure-9 of the Writ Petition) issued in favour of the
Petitioner by the answering Respondent is a bona-fide
mistake on the face of the record. More so the Petitioner
humbly submits that as there was an error apparent on
the face of the record in the Notification dated
25.04.2022 (Annexure-9 of the W.P) the answering
Respondent made
the necessary
correction vide
notification dated 07.12.2023 (Annexure-9 of the W.P)
and thus the objection made the Petitioner was not
considered being irreverent. The case of the Petitioner is
squarely covered by the case of Sushmita Chakraborty
and thus the decision of the answering Respondent is
valid. It is also required to be submitted here that though
initially it was directed to deduct the excess payment in
12 instalments but subsequently the arrear was directed
to recovered by 24 instalments.
The copy of the revised office order of pay fixation
of Sushmita Chakraborty vide dated 25.06.2024 is
attached here to as Annexure-R/3.”
The respondents also denied the other assertions
made by the petitioner in the writ petition and prayed for
dismissal of this writ petition.
Heard arguments of both the sides at length.
09.
Taking part in the hearing Learned Counsel
appearing for the petitioner Mr. H. Laskar submitted that in
similarly situated cases this High Court passed a direction
and accordingly the same was complied with by the
respondents, but in the case of present petitioner the
respondents
authority
illegally
without
affording
any
opportunity to the petitioner most arbitrarily passed an
order for deduction of the excess amount paid to the
petitioner which is not permissible in the eye of law.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that
if at all any excess payment was made, in that case the
present petitioner being a Group-D employee was not
responsible for that rather it was the fault of the department
who made the payment. So Learned counsel for the
petitioner in summing up prayed for allowing this writ
petition by setting aside the memo dated 07.12.2023 and
03.06.2024 issued by the authority.
10.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel Mr.
B. N. Majumder appearing on behalf of the respondents
submitted that the present petitioner has not come before
the court with clean hands. It was further submitted that
there was no willful latches or negligence on the part of the
respondents-authority to deduct excess payment from the
salary of the petitioner. Learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that the case referred by the petitioner in
WP(C)No.704 of 2019 dated 21.01.2020 and WP(C) No.692
of 2019 dated 31.01.2020 are not similar to the facts of the
case of the present petitioner. However, Learned Senior
Counsel further submitted that some error was committed
by the authority regarding fixation of pay actually which
should
be
with
effect
from
01.07.2008
in
place
of
01.12.2007 and accordingly necessary modification order
was issued by the authority in time and the department had
no intention to cause any hardship to the petitioner and the
respondents being the employer of the petitioner have got
the liberty to recover the excess payment if paid. So in
summing up Learned Senior Counsel prayed for dismissal of
the writ petition.
11.
I have heard detailed arguments of both the
sides at length and also perused the relevant papers
submitted by the parties. The petitioner filed her case on
the basis of memorandum dated 25.04.2022 and 20.06.22
i.e Annexure-9 issued by the authority and submitted that
the respondents-authority most arbitrarily without affording
any opportunity to the petitioner has issued subsequent
memos dated 07.12.2023 and 03.06.2024 i.e. Annexure- 11
and Annexure-12 of the writ petition without any basis
violating the observations made by the High Court in the
aforenoted cases for which both the memorandum and
office order
needs to
be
quashed.
The respondents-
authority in para-11 of the counter-affidavit specifically
admitted that due to oversight the pay of the petitioner was
notionally fixed from 01.12.2007 instead of notionally
fixation
from
01.07.2008
with
financial
benefits
from
27.12.2010 and according to Learned Senior Counsel for the
respondents,
the
same
was
rightly
modified
by
the
respondent-authority.
12.
So, after hearing arguments of both the sides
and also after going through the connected documents
annexed with the writ petition it appears that there was no
latches or default on the part of the present petitioner to
receive financial benefits from the respondents being a
Group-D employee rather it was the fault of the department
who made the payment and later on tried to recover it by
issuing subsequent memorandums i.e. Annexure-11 and
Annexure-12. Admittedly the petitioner was a Group-D
employee. In this regard I would like to refer herein below
the citation of the Hon’ble Apex Court in State of Punjab
and Others vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) and
Others reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334 wherein in para
No.16 and 17 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“16.This Court in Syed Abdul Qadir v. State of Bihar:
(2009) 3 SCC 475 held as follows:
"59. Undoubtedly, the excess amount that has
been paid to the appellant teachers was not
because of any misrepresentation or fraud on their
part and the appellants also had no knowledge that
the amount that was being paid to them was more
than what they were entitled to. It would not be
out of place to mention here that the Finance
Department had, in its counter- affidavit, admitted
that it was a bona fide mistake on their part. The
excess payment made was the result of wrong
interpretation of the Rule that was applicable to
them, for which the appellants cannot be held
responsible. Rather, the whole confusion was
because of inaction, negligence and carelessness
of the officials concerned of the Government of
Bihar. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellant teachers submitted that majority of the
beneficiaries have either retired or are on the
verge of it. Keeping in view the peculiar facts and
circumstances of the case at hand and to avoid any
hardship to the appellant teachers, we are of the
view that no recovery of the amount that has been
paid in excess to the appellant teachers should be
made."
(emphasis supplied)
Premised on the legal proposition considered above, namely,
whether on the touchstone of equity and arbitrariness, the
extract of the judgment reproduced above, culls out yet another
consideration, which would make the process of recovery
iniquitous and arbitrary. It is apparent from the conclusions
drawn in Syed Abdul Qadir's case (supra), that recovery of
excess payments, made from employees who have retired from
service, or are close to their retirement, would entail extremely
harsh consequences outweighing the monetary gains by the
employer. It cannot be forgotten, that a retired employee or an
employee about to retire, is a class apart from those who have
sufficient service to their credit, before their retirement.
Needless to mention, that at retirement, an employee is past his
youth, his needs are far in excess of what they were when he
was younger. Despite that, his earnings have substantially
dwindled (or would substantially be reduced on his retirement).
Keeping the aforesaid circumstances in mind, we are satisfied
that recovery would be iniquitous and arbitrary, if it is sought
to be made after the date of retirement, or soon before
retirement. A period within one year from the date of
superannuation, in our considered view, should be accepted as
the period during which the recovery should be treated as
iniquitous. Therefore, it would be justified to treat an order of
recovery, on account of wrongful payment made to an
employee, as arbitrary, if the recovery is sought to be made
after the employee's retirement, or within one year of the date
of his retirement on superannuation.
17. Last of all, reference may be made to the decision in Sahib
Ram Verma v. Union of India, (1995) Supp. 1 SCC 18, wherein it
was concluded as under:
"4. Mr. Prem Malhotra, learned counsel for the appellant,
contended that the previous scale of Rs 220-550 to which
the appellant was entitled became Rs 700-1600 since the
appellant had been granted that scale of pay in relaxation
of the educational qualification. The High Court was,
therefore, not right in dismissing the writ petition. We do
not find any force in this contention. It is seen that the
Government in consultation with the University Grants
Commission had revised the pay scale of a Librarian
working in the colleges to Rs 700-1600 but they insisted
upon the minimum educational qualification of first or
second class M.A., M.Sc., M.Com. plus a first or second
class B.Lib. Science or a Diploma in Library Science. The
relaxation given was only as regards obtaining first or
second class in the prescribed educational qualification
but not relaxation in the educational qualification itself.
5. Admittedly the appellant does not possess the required
educational qualifications. Under the circumstances the
appellant would not be entitled to the relaxation. The
Principal erred in granting him the relaxation. Since the
date of relaxation the appellant had been paid his salary
on the revised scale. However, it is not on account of any
misrepresentation made by the appellant that the benefit
of the higher pay scale was given to him but by wrong
construction made by the Principal for which the
appellant cannot be held to be at fault. Under the
circumstances the amount paid till date may not be
recovered from the appellant. The principle of equal pay
for equal work would not apply to the scales prescribed
by the University Grants Commission. The appeal is
allowed partly without any order as to costs.”
(emphasis supplied)
It would be pertinent to mention, that Librarians were equated
with Lecturers, for the grant of the pay scale of Rs.700-1600.
The above pay parity would extend to Librarians, subject to the
condition that they possessed the prescribed minimum
educational qualification (first or second class M.A., M.Sc.,
M.Com. plus a first or second class B.Lib. Science or a Diploma
in Library Science, the degree of M.Lib. Science being a
preferential qualification). For those Librarians appointed prior
to 3.12.1972, the educational qualifications were relaxed. In
Sahib Ram Verma's case: 1995 Supp (1)SCC 18, a mistake was
committed by wrongly extending to the appellants the revised
pay scale, by relaxing the prescribed educational qualifications,
even though the concerned appellants were ineligible for the
same. The appellants concerned were held not eligible for the
higher scale, by applying the principle of "equal pay for equal
work". This Court, in the above circumstances, did not allow the
recovery of the excess payment. This was apparently done
because this Court felt that the employees were entitled to
wages, for the post against which they had discharged their
duties. In the above view of the matter, we are of the opinion,
that it would be iniquitous and arbitrary for an employer to
require an employee to refund the wages of a higher post,
against which he had wrongfully been permitted to work,
though he should have rightfully been required to work against
an inferior post.”
I
have
also
gone
through
the
aforesaid
paragraphs of the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court and
after going through the relevant papers it appears to this
court that the respondent-authority without any basis
arbitrarily
issued
(Annexure-11)
and
memorandum
dated
07.12.2023
officer
dated
03.06.2024
order
(Annexure-12). Further in the aforesaid judgment Hon’ble
the Apex Court in para No.18 also observed as under:
“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship which would govern employees on the
issue
of
recovery,
where
payments
have
mistakenly been made by the employer, in excess
of their entitlement. Be that as it may, based on
the decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as
a ready reference, summarise the following few
situations, wherein recoveries by the employers,
would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to
Class-III and Class-IV service (or Group C
and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or
employees who are due to retire within one
year, of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the
excess payment has been made for a period
in excess of five years, before the order of
recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee
has wrongfully been required to discharge
duties of a higher post, and has been paid
accordingly, even though he should have
rightfully been required to work against an
inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court
arrives at the conclusion, that recovery if
made from the employee, would be
iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an
extent, as would far outweigh the equitable
balance of the employer's right to recover.”
From the aforesaid paragraphs it appears that by
the said judgment Hon’ble the Apex Court has given the
guidelines where recoveries by the employers would be
impermissible in law from the salary of the employees. Here
in the case at hand it appears that the case of the petitioner
falls under category of 18(i) of the aforesaid guidelines of
the Hon’ble Apex Court. Situated thus, it appears to this
court
that
the
respondents
have/had
no
legal
scope/authority to issue Annexure-11 and Annexure-12
upon the petitioner for which both the aforesaid memos
dated
07.12.2023
and
03.06.2024
are
needs
to
be
interfered with.
12.
In the result, the writ petition filed by the
petition
is
hereby
allowed.
The
memorandum
dated
07.12.2023 (Annexure-11) and the Office order dated
03.06.2024
(Annexure-12)
issued
by
the
respondent-
authority are accordingly stands quashed and set aside. The
respondents are hereby restrained from deducting any
amount from the pay of the petitioner as per the said
notification/office order and if any amount by this time is
recovered from the pay of the petitioner that should be
refunded by the respondents to the petitioner at an earliest.
With this observation and direction, this writ
petition stands disposed of.
Pending application, if any, stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.02.06
23:59:33 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review