Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.12 of 2024
1.
Smt. Sushanti Debnath,
wife of late Nirendra Debnath
2.
Sri Bimal Debnath,
son of late Nirendra Debnath
3.
Smt. Sheli Debnath,
daughter of late Nirendra Debnath
4(a).
Smt. Shanta Debnath,
wife of late Nirmal Debnath
4(b).
Sri Neelava Debnath,
son of late Nirmal Debnath
All are residents of P.O & P.S. Panisagar,
District- North Tripura
5.
Smt. Sefali Debnath,
wife of Sri Bimal Nath, daughter of late
Nirendra Debnath of Netaji Chowmuhani,
Dighalbank, P.S. Dharmanagar, DistrictNorth Tripura
–Versus–
The Satsang,
a registered Society registered under the
Societies Registration Act, 1960, District &
P.O. Deogarh, Jharkhand having its branch
(Ashram) all over the country including one
at Panisagar, represented by the Secretary,
Managing Committee, Panisagar Satsang
Kendra, Panisagar, North Tripura
……… Appellant (s)
…….. Respondent (s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. Deb, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Datta, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D.K. Biswas, Sr. Adv.
Mr. G.K. Nama, Adv.
Mr. D.S. Kunwar, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
25.09.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & order
:
17.12.2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The appeal arises from the judgment dated 18.12.2023
passed by the learned District Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar in
Title Appeal No.20 of 2022 and related decree thereof. By said
judgment, learned First Appellate Court affirmed the judgment dated
01.08.2022 of the learned Civil Judge, Sr. Division, Court No.2, North
Tripura, Dharmanagar in Title Suit No.30 of 2017, whereby the right,
title and interest of the plaintiff (the respondent herein) in the suit
land was declared and prayer for recovery of possession of a part
thereof, described in the ‘B’ schedule of the plaint was granted.
[2]
The appellants (the defendants of the original suit) being
aggrieved by the concurrent findings of both the learned courts below
have preferred this appeal.
[3]
The plaintiff, a Society, called the Satsang, institutes the
suit with the averments that they became the owner of 0.15 acres of
land of CS Plot No.2269 and 2265 (P) [described in the schedule of
the plaint] by way of registered gift deed executed by one Thakurmani
Debnath vide deed of gift No.1-2504 dated 22.04.1976 [Exbt.2].
According to them, said Thakurmani Debnath, purchased 0.15 acres
of land by a registered deed No.1-7030 dated 11.11.1970 [Exbt.C]
from one Nalini Mohan Das and further 0.08 acres of land from
Nirendra Ch. Debnath [the predecessor of the defendants] vide sale
deed no. 1-6942 dated 02.11.1970 [Exbt.D] and became the owner
in possession of total 0.23 acres of land and out of the said property,
he gifted 0.15 acres of land to the plaintiff, but, on 18.12.2005
suddenly the defendants illegally occupied a portion of the said land
by raising fence and therefore, the prayer for recovery of possession
has been made.
[4]
According to the plaintiff, in the year 1997, the defendants
filed a suit bearing No.T.S.26 of 1997 against them claiming right,
title and interest in the suit land and recovery of possession and the
said suit was partly decreed and partly dismissed by Ld. Trial Court.
Against the said judgment and decree, the appeal bearing No.T.A.18
of 2005 was preferred and the learned first appellate court dismissed
the entire suit with the findings that the plaintiff had right, title and
interest in the entire suit land. Thereafter, the said judgment and
decree were not challenged by the defendants in the higher forum
making it binding on them.
[5]
The defendants in their written statement have challenged
the ownership of the plaintiff in the entire suit land. According to
them, one Nagendra Chandra Debnath and another Nirendra Chandra
Debnath [the predecessors of the present defendants] were the
owners in possession of total land area 0.45 acres of C.S. Plot
No.2265 [0.30 acres], C.S. Plot No.2266 [0.10 acres] and C.S Plot
2269 [0.05 acres] of Mouja-Panisagar having 50% share each
therein. Said Nagendra Chandra Debnath sold out 0.19 acres of land
vide registered deed
No.1-6841 dated 08.12.1967 [Exbt.A] to one
Nalini Mohan Das and said Nalini Mohan Das, again sold out 0.17
acres of land therefrom to their predecessor Nirendra Ch. Debnath
vide sale deed No.1-7233 dated 10.10.1968 [Exbt.B] and thereafter
he again sold out 0.15 acres of land to Thakurmani Debnath vide sale
deed No.1-7030 dated 11.11.1970 [Exbt.C] though he had only
transferable interest of 0.02 acres of land therein after his such
transfer of said 0.17 acres of land to Nirendra Ch. Debnath. They also
stated that said Nirendra Ch. Debnath sold out 0.08 acres of land to
Thakurmani
02.11.1970
Debnath
[Exbt.D]
vide
and
registered
thereafter,
deed
said
No.1-6942
Thakurmani
dated
Debnath
transferred 0.15 acres of land to Satsang as claimed by the plaintiff
though he was not the rightful owner of 0.15 acres of land at that
time. According to them, the suit land was all along in their
possession under their fencing and therefore, the question of alleged
dispossession of plaintiff does not arise.
[6]
The learned trial court framed the following 6[six] issues in
the suit:
[i] Whether the suit maintainable in its present form and
nature?
[ii] Whether there is cause of action for filing this suit?
[iii] Whether the plaintiff has right, title and interest over the
suit land?
[iv] Whether the facts of possession of the plaintiff over the
suit land and his dispossession therefrom on 18.12.2005 are
true? If so, whether the plaintiff is entitled to recovery of
possession of the suit land?
[v] Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get the decree for
perpetual injunction?
[vi] Whether the
relief/relief(s)?
plaintiff
is
entitled
to
any
other
[7]
The learned trial court after considering the evidences of
both sides along with the documents submitted by them finally
decreed the suit basically on the ground that already in the previous
suit the right, title and interest of the plaintiff was decided by the
court and therefore, it became res judicata. The learned trial court
decided the ownership of the plaintiff in the suit land while deciding
the Issue Nos.(iii), (iv), (v) & (vi) together.
[8]
In appeal, the learned first appellate court also subscribes
its concurrence with the decision of the learned trial court. It is also
held by the first Appellate Court that the admitted position of the
parties was that the suit property of T.S.26 of 1997 and the present
suit were same and the plea of right, title and interest of the
defendants was already discussed in details in T.S.26 of 1997 and also
in the connected appeal and it was categorically held that the present
defendants had not right, title and interest in the suit land and
therefore, the question regarding title in respect of the suit land was
directly and substantially in issue in T.S.26 of 1997 and in the
consequent appeal No.T.A.18 of 2005. According to the learned first
appellate court, the appellants did not challenge the said judgment of
T.A.18 of 2005 in the higher forum and therefore, it was finally
decided that the present plaintiff had right, title and interest in the
suit land and therefore, the first appellate court dismissed the appeal.
[9]
Mr. S. Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the
defendant-appellants argues that the previous suit was regarding 2
[two] gandas of land, which was dismissed by the learned first
appellate court of that suit, but, the in the present suit, the suit land
is of 0.15 acres of land i.e. more than 7[seven] gandas and therefore,
the suit lands of previous suit and the present suit are not similar. The
second point as raised by Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel is that no
specific issue on the point of res judicata was framed by the courts
below and moreover, the provision of Order XLI Rule 31 of the CPC
was also not complied by the learned first appellate court. Mr. Deb,
learned senior counsel seriously challenges the impugned judgment
on the ground that only two points were taken up for decision by the
learned first appellate court which were-whether the plaintiff became
the owner of the suit property on the basis of gift deed executed by
Thakurmani Debnath and whether the defendants dispossessed the
plaintiff from the suit land measuring 0.07 acres as described in ‘B’
schedule of the plaint and there was no whisper in those ‘points for
decision’ about the issue of res judicata. Another point of challenge as
raised by Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel is that the boundary
description of ‘A’ schedule land and boundary description of ‘B’
schedule land of the plaint do not tally with each other, for, in the first
schedule land, Satsang temple has been shown on the western side of
the suit land whereas in the ‘B’ schedule land, the said Satsang
temple has been shown in the eastern side. However, this point
cannot be taken up for consideration in the second appeal for the first
time as no such plea of wrong boundary description was taken in the
written statement of the defendants. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel
also relies on some decisions of the Apex Court and the Privy Council
which will be discussed in due course.
[10]
Mr. D.K. Biswas, learned senior counsel appearing for the
plaintiff-respondent firstly argues that there is no substantial question
of law involved in the second appeal as the questions involved in this
appeal are purely the question of apperception of facts. Mr. Biswas,
learned senior counsel also argues that even though the appeal has
been admitted for hearing on substantial question of law but as per
sub-Section 5 of Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the
respondent has the right to show that the case does not involve any
such substantial question. According to Mr. Biswas, learned senior
counsel, the matter of res judicata is already embodied in the Statute
and therefore, no substantial question of law is permissible to be
formulated on that ground. Mr. Biswas, learned senior counsel
continues to argue that the perversity on findings of facts is not a
substantial question of law and only the perversity relating to a pure
question of law which is not decided yet by the Apex Court or by the
High Court can be entertained in the appeal. Mr. Biswas, learned
senior counsel also contends that DW-2 in his evidence admitted the
fact of previous suit and therefore, there was no scope of any
interference as already the decision taken in the earlier suit became
binding on the defendants. Referring to Section 103 of the CPC, Mr.
Biswas, learned senior counsel further submits that in any second
appeal, the High Court may determine any issue necessary for
disposal of the appeal only within the ambit of section 103. According
to Mr. Biswas, learned senior counsel, unless there is any perversity
committed by the courts below is not shown by the other side, this
court cannot enter into the re-appreciation of the facts.
[11]
The present appeal has been admitted on the following
substantial questions of law:
[i] Whether the findings of the learned first appellate court
that the suit was barred by res judicata was perverse?
[ii] Any other substantial question of law may also be heard
during haring of the appeal?
[12]
The entire controversy centres upon the question of res
judicata from the court of first instance below. This appeal also
basically admitted on the point whether any perversity has been
committed by the courts below while holding that the right, title and
interest of the parties were already decided in the previous suit
keeping in view of the attending facts and evidences as placed by the
parties. According to Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel, both the courts
below misapplied the provisions of Section 11 of the CPC and as such,
misapplication of law itself is a substantial question of law. However,
there is no dispute at the bar that both the parties of the instant suit
were also parties in the previous suit. Only contention of the present
defendants is that only a part of the present suit land was involved in
the previous suit and therefore, principle of res judicata cannot be
applied. In the contexts of submissions and counter submissions of
the parties, the relevant decisions of the Apex Court and Privy Council
as relied on by Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel are also required to
have reference now.
[13]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel first relies on a decision of
the Privy Council arising from an order of High Court of Judicature of
Fort William in Bengal in between Raja Jagadish Chandra Deo
Dhabal Deb vs. Gour Hari Mahato and others decided on
30.06.1936, wherein the Privy Council observed that the High Court
declined to allow the appellant to go into the question of res judicata
on the ground and it had not been properly raised by the pleadings or
in the issues. Said observation was approved by the Privy Council.
[14]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel further relies on another
decision of the Apex Court in Sajjadanashin Sayed Md. B.E.
Edr.(D) by Lrs. vs. Musa Dadabhai Ummer and others, (2000) 3
SCC 350, and at paragraph 18, the Apex Court observed as follows:
“18. In India, Mulla has referred to similar tests (Mulla, 15th
Ed.p.104). The learned author says: A matter in respect of
which relief is claimed in an earlier suit can be said to be
generally a matter 'directly and substantially' in issue but it
does not mean that if the matter is one in respect of which no
relief is sought it is not directly or substantially in issue. It
may or may not be. It is possible that it was 'directly and
substantially' in issue and it may also be possible that it was
only collaterally or incidentally in issue, depending upon the
facts of the case. The question arises as to what is the test for
deciding into which category a case falls? One test is that if
the issue was 'necessary' to be decided for adjudicating on the
principal issue and was decided, it would have to be treated as
'directly and substantially' in issue and if it is clear that the
judgment was in fact based upon that decision, then it would
be res judicata in a latter case. (Mulla, p.104) One has to
examine the plaint, the written statement, the issues and the
judgment to find out if the matter was directly and
substantially in issue (Ishwar Singh vs. Sarwan Singh: AIR
1965 SC 948 and Sayed Mohd. Salie Labbai vs. Mohd. Hanifa:
AIR 1976 SC 1569). We are of the view that the above
summary in Mulla is a correct statement of the law.”
(underscore emphasised)
[15]
Both the learned senior counsel also rely on another
decision of the Apex Court rendered in K. Ethirajan (Dead) by Lrs.
vs. Lakshmi and others, (2003) 10 SCC 578 wherein at Para-20 it
was observed that the argument that principle of res judicata cannot
apply because in the previous suit only a part of the property was
involved when in the subsequent suit the whole property is the
subject matter, cannot be accepted. It was further held that the
principle of res judicata under Section 11 of the Code of Civil
Procedure is attracted where issues directly and substantially involved
between the same parties in the previous and subsequent suit are the
same, may be in the previous suit only a part of the property was
involved when in the subsequent suit, the whole property is the
subject matter.
[16]
This decision as rendered by the Apex Court will answer
the challenge as made by Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel that in the
previous suit only a part of the present suit land was involved and
therefore, principle of res judicata was not applicable. In view of
above said decision, such plea is not tenable.
[17]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel also relies on another
decision of the Apex Court in V. Rajeshwari (Smt.) vs. T.C.
Saravanabava, (2004) 1 SCC 551, wherein it was held by the Apex
Court that the foundation for the plea must be laid in the pleadings
and then an issue must be framed and tried. A plea not properly
raised in the pleadings or in issues at the stage of the trial, would not
be permitted to be raised for the first time at the stage of appeal.
However, an exception was carved out by the Apex Court that the
plea was permitted to be raised, though not taken in the pleadings
nor covered by any issue, because the necessary facts were present
to the mind of the parties and were gone into by the trial Court where
the opposite party had ample opportunity of leading the evidence in
rebuttal of the plea. In such a situation, the Apex Court concluded
that when the point of res judicata had throughout been in
consideration and discussion, the want of pleadings or plea of waiver
of res judicata could not be allowed to be urged. It was also further
discussed that not only the plea has to be taken, but it has to be
substantiated by producing the copies of the pleadings and issues and
judgment of the previous suit. It was also observed that, may be in a
given case only copy of judgment in the previous suit is filed in proof
of plea of res judicata and the judgment contains exhaustive or in
requisite details the statement of pleadings and the issues which may
be taken as enough proof, but the basic method to decide the
question of res judicata is first to determine the case of the parties as
put forward in their respective pleadings of their previous suit and
then to find out as to what had been decided by the judgment which
operates as res judicata.
[18]
The last citation as referred by Mr. Deb, learned senior
counsel on this point of res judicata is a case in between Har
Narayan Tewari (D) Thr. Lrs. vs. Cantonment Board, Ramgarh
Cantonment and others, (2024) SCC OnLine SC 1643. The
relevant paragraphs 15 and 16 are extracted below:
“15. The submission is that the plaintiff-appellant was nonsuited by the First Appellate Court, on the ground that his suit
was barred by res judicata. One of the essential conditions for
the applicability of principle of res judicata as enshrined
under Section 11 of the CPC is that the issue in the earlier suit
and the subsequent suit ought to be directly and substantially
the same. In the earlier Suit No. 8/64 instituted by Maharani,
her claim was that she is the lawful owner of the entire 5.38
acre of land of Village Ramgarh, on the basis of the
maintenance grant made in her favour by the Raja. In the
said suit, the plaintiff- appellant was defendant no. 32 and the
Cantonment Board, Ramgarh was defendant No. 1. The claim
set up by Maharani was not accepted and ex-facie there was
no adjudication regarding the rights of the co-defendants over
the suit land viz 0.30 acres of land of plot Nos.432 and 438 as
claimed by the plaintiff-appellant in the present suit. The
limited issue therein was whether the Maharani had acquired
any right in the above entire property on the basis of
maintenance in grant alleged to be executed by the Raja in her
favour. There was no issue as to whether the suit land as
claimed by the plaintiff-appellant belonged to him or was
settled or not settled in his favour as claimed. Thus, in the
facts and circumstances of the case, a clear substantial
question of law as to whether the present suit as filed by the
plaintiff-appellant was barred under Section 11 CPC on
principle of res judicata inasmuch as there was no
adjudication of the rights of the co-defendants in the previous
suit with regard to the suit land and the issue therein was not
directly or indirectly and substantially the same as in the
present suit.
16. In view of the above, we are of the opinion that the High
Court manifestly erred in dismissing the second appeal in
limine on the ground that there was no substantial question of
law involved therein.”
[19]
In view of above said observations of the Apex Court as
underlined, the submission of Mr. Biswas, learned senior counsel that
the principle of res judicata is embodied in Section 11 CPC and
therefore, no such second appeal can be admitted on substantial
question of law on the point of res judicata, is not convincing and
acceptable. The improper application of Section 11 of the CPC leading
to serious perversity affecting the valuable right of the parties itself
constitutes a substantial question of law. The Apex Court in Union of
India Vs Ibrahim Uddin & another, (2012) 8 SCC 148 at
paragraph No.67 observed that there was no prohibition to entertain a
second appeal even on question of fact provided the Court is satisfied
that the findings of the courts below were vitiated by nonconsideration of relevant evidence or by showing erroneous approach
to the matter and findings recorded in the courts below were
perverse.
[20]
In view of the law as settled already by the Apex Court as
well as by the Privy Council as discussed above, it is required to be
examined first as to whether the decision of the previous suit i.e.
decision of TA 18 of 2005 forms res judicata and whether the same
was specifically taken in the pleading enabling the other side to take
defence against it. The relevant paragraph of the plaint of the present
suit for such purposive demonstration is extracted hereinbelow:
“3. That in the year 1997, the defendants herein filed a suit in
the Court of the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Dharmanagar,
North Tripura, for recovery of possession of the suit land on
the ground that their predecessor in interest namely, Nirendra
Debnath, was the owner and possessor of the suit land and
after his death the Defendants, being his Legal Heirs, became
the owner thereof having lawful right, title and interest over
the suit land. The said suit was registered as Case No. T.S.-26
of 1997 and was partly decreed by the Ld. Trial Court, against
which First Appeal has been preferred before the Ld. Addl.
District Judge, Dharmanagar, North Tripura which was
registered vide Case No.- T.A. 18 of 2005. In the Appeal, the
Ld. First Appellate Court, dismissing the case of the
defendants herein with a finding that the plaintiffs here have
good title and possession over the entire suit land, that is,
land gifted by Thakurmoni Debnath. The specific finding of the
Ld. First Appellate Court in last part of the para-9 of its
Judgment dated 03.12.2005 is thus,
„So, it reveals that though the contesting
respondents challenged the order of the ASO the
Exhibit-2 but on careful consideration of the sale
deed, I find no infirmity and irregularity of the
revenue authority to record the suit land in the
name of the Sat Sangha as the Tahkur Mani
Debnath has got transferable title on the land gifted
by him to the Sat Sang.‟
No further appeal being preferred against the said
Judgment of the First Appellate Court, the said Judgment
dated 03.12.2005 reached its finality. So, now, there is no
cloud over the Plaintiff‟s title on the suit land.”
[21]
The reply given by the present defendants against such
assertions of the plaintiff in Para-12 of their written statement for
such purposive reference is also quoted hereinbelow:
“12. Regarding para 3 of the plaint under reply it is stated that
the defendant No.1, 2, 3, 4, 5 being plaintiff filed T.S.26 of
1997 before the court of Ld. Civil Judge (Sr. Division),
Dharmanagar, North Tripura against Sri Nityananda Das and
others for declaration, recovery of possession, correction of
record of rights and injunction and after full trial the suit was
partly decreed against which the defendant of T.S.26 of 1997
preferred 1st appeal before the Addl. District Judge,
Dharmanagar, North Tripura and as per judgment dated 0403-2005 passed in c/w T.A.13 of 2004 it was remanded back
for trial to the original court and after fresh trial the Ld. Court
of Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Dharmanagar, North Tripura
again passed decree partly vide judgment dated 16-05-2005
and decree dated 16-05-2005 against which the defendant of
T.S.26 of 1997 preferred appeal being T.A.18 of 2005 before
the Addl. District Judge, Dharmanagar, North Tripura and after
hearing Appellate Court was pleased to set aside judgment
and decree dated 03-12-2005 but unfortunately due to
financial inability the plaintiff of T.S.26 of 1997 could not
preferred appeal before the Hon‟ble High Court……….”
[22]
From such averments of the written statement, it appears
that the defendants admitted the decision of the said suit up to the
stage of the first appellate forum and also otherwise admitted the fact
that the same had reached it’s finality without further challenge
before the High Court. Therefore, they were although conscious above
such specific pleas taken by plaintiff in their plaint of the present suit
about the decision of said previous suit. They have not taken any plea
that said decision was not at all related to the present suit land. The
defendant No.2 in his cross-examination rather admitted that the said
title suit bearing No.T.S.26 of 1997 was instituted with regard to the
present suit land.
[23]
In Title Appeal No.18 of 2005 based on the decision of
which the entire controversy of res judicata has cropped up, learned
Addl. District Judge, North Tripura, as it appears, in the judgment
dated 03.12.2005 dealt with exhaustively the claim of both the
present plaintiff and the defendants regarding the ownership of the
suit C.S. Plots No.2269 and 2265. In Para-5 of the said judgment,
learned first appellate court discussed the issues framed in that earlier
suit and the relevant portion of such discussions and observations are
as follows:
“5. On the pleading of the parties the learned court below
formulated as many as seven issues for decision of the suit.
The issue No. (i) and (ii) are regarding the maintainability and
cause of action of the suit. Issue No. (iii) is regarding the
limitation. Issue No.(iv) is regarding the alleged possession of
the plaintiffs over the suit land and the alleged dispossession
by the defendants there from. Issue No. (v) is regarding the
right, title and interest of the plaintiffs over the suit land and
the issue No. (vi) and (vii) are regarding the relief claimed by
the parties. The learned court below examined four PWs from
the side of the respondents and proved four numbers of
documents and taken into evidence namely, the certified copy
of Khatian order of objection case No. 168, certified copy of
Khatian 585/2549 and the certified copy of title deed No.1783 of 1968 executed by Nalini Mohan Das in favour of the
Nirendra Chandra Debnath. From the side of the appellant also
examined three DWs and proved seven documents namely
Khatian No.222, certified copy of deed dated 21-09-67, 14-0970 and 11-11-70, certified copy of gift deed dated 22-04-76
and certified copy of map. After considering the oral and
documentary evidence the learned court below decreed the
suit partly and being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the
judgment and decree the appellant (defendant) has preferred
the appeal. But the respondents (plaintiffs) has not filed any
cross-appeal/cross-objection against the partly decree
granted in their favour. The respondents No.7(a) to 7(e) have
taken part in the hearing of the appeal but they have not
contested the appeal rather supported the case of the
appellants.”
[24]
While revisiting the decisions on above said Issue Nos.(i),
(ii) and (iii), the learned first appellate court did not interfere with the
findings of the learned trial court. But while dealing with the other
issues of the said previous suit, the learned first appellate court held
as under:
“8. The main controversy in the present suit is that the
plaintiffs claimed title over the suit land by way of inheritance
from their predecessor in interest namely Nirendra Nath and
on the basis of title have prayed for recovery of possession
stating that they were dispossessed by the defendants from
the suit land on a certain date and manner which was denied
by the appellants as defendants asserting their title over the
suit land by way of gift by Takur Mani Debnath. The learned
court below has elaborately and critically discussed and
considered the oral and documentary evidence on record and
decided that the respondent have only the right, title and
interest over a part of the suit land measuring 4 decimals of
land under C.S. plot No. 2265 but the appellants have right,
title and interest over the remaining four decimals of land
under C.S. plot No.2269. From the side of the respondents
during trial of the suit have produced the documents executed
by Nalini Mohan Das in favour of the Nirendra Chandra
Debnath, the predecessor in interest of the contesting
respondents transferring 17 decimals of land which was
purchased by him on 21-09-67. As such the learned court
below held that though Nagendra Nath sold out land
measuring 19 decimals from their joint property the
predecessor in interest of the plaintiffs namely Nirendra Nath
purchased 17 decimals of land and accordingly at the time of
selling of land by Nalini Mohan Das to Takur Mani Debnath
said Nalinimohan Das had no title to transfer 15 decimals of
land to Takur Mani Debnath in the year 1970, rather he had
only 12 decimals of land to transfer but he transferred 15
decimals of land to Takur Mani Debnath and said Takur Mani
Debnath purchased 8 decimals of land from Nirendra Chandra
Debnath. So, Takur Mani Debnath practically got 20 decimals
of land from Nalini Mohan Das and Nirendra Debnath by
purchase in the year 1970. But in 1976 Takur Mani Debnath
transferred 15 decimals of land to Sat Sangha. So, the decision
of the learned court below that Takur Mani Debnath has no
transferable right and title on the land measuring 15 decimals
to Sat Sangha is not correct and acceptable as Takur Mani
Debnath purchased 20 decimals of land i.e. 8 decimals of land
from Nirendra Debnath and 12 decimals from Nalani Mohan
Das. Though Nalini Mohan Das had transferable title of 12
decimals of land still Takur Mani Debnath had transferable
title over 20 decimals of land. He gifted 15 decimals of land to
the Sat Sangha, the organization of the appellants is not
beyond the law or is transferred by way of gift cannot be
branded as having no title to transfer the said 15 decimals of
land. So, the finding of the learned court below on the issue
No. (iv) and (v) is erroneous and as such liable to be
interfered as the finding of the title of the land measuring four
decimals by the learned court below in favour of the appellant
is based on no documents. After critical consideration and
analysis of the documentary evidence under Exhibit A to F and
Exhibit-4 reveals that at the time of execution of the Exhibit-F
Takur Mani Debnath has transferable title over the land
measuring 20 decimals but he has transferred only 15
decimals of land including the suit land to the Sat Sangha
Ashram of the appellants. So, the finding of the learned court
below is not based on materials and evidence on record and as
such liable to be interfered and accordingly interfered on the
finding of the issue no.(v) and accordingly said finding of the
learned court below is hereby interfered and reversed.
9. As a general rule title follows the possession. If a person
has a good title he is entitled to recover the same but in the
present suit it reveals that as the contesting respondents have
failed to establish their title over the suit land mentioned to
the schedule of the plaint they are not entitled to recovery of
the possession. The respondents led the oral evidence to show
that on a certain date as mentioned in the plaint the appellant
dispossessed them and from the suit land and as such prayed
for recovery of the same. But the documentary evidence
reveals that they have no title over the suit land. As such from
the evidence of the PWs was not prevailed over the
documentary evidence. So, it reveals that though the
contesting respondents challenged the order of the ASO the
Exhibit-2 but on careful consideration of the sale deed I find
no infirmity and irregularity of the revenue authority to record
the suit land in the name of the Sat Sangha as the Takur Mani
Debnath has got transferable title on the land gifted by him to
the Sat Sangha. Accordingly the finding of the learned court
below on the issue no. (iv) also interfered and reversed.
10. In view of the finding on the issue No. (iv) and (v) the
respondents are not entitled to get the decree as prayed for in
this suit but the learned court below partly decreed the suit
deciding the issue No. (ii) and (vii) partly in favour of the
respondents. So, the said finding of the learned court below
liable to be interfered and set aside and accordingly set
aside.”
[25]
The said final observations and decisions of the previous
suit were within the knowledge of the present defendants and
thereafter, they did not challenge the same in the higher forum and
accepted the decision as final. On perusal of the judgment of the
learned Addl. District Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar dated
03.12.2005 [Exbt.1], it also appears that the said learned court
further mentioned of another sale instance as the case of present
plaintiff, where the predecessor of the present defendants namely,
Nirendra Ch. Debnath transferred 0.10 acres of land to Nalini Mohan
Das on 14.09.1970 but said fact is not disclosed by either of the
parties in this suit. Anyway, taking note of all the relevant deeds of
transfer as proved in that previous suit, the learned first appellate
court came to the definite and conclusive finding that Thakurmani
Debnath had transferable interest over the land measuring 0.20 acres,
out of which, he only transferred 0.15 acres of land to said Satsang
Ashram. As a result, said learned court set aside the decree, partly
passed in favour of the present defendants by the trial court. The
source and basis of the title to the suit property as are agitated by the
parties including the defence of the present defendants in the present
suit were similar and identical in the previous suit which was decided
finally by a court of competent jurisdiction in favour of the present
plaintiff and in the present suit, said facts of previous suit were
sufficiently brought to the notice of the defendants to which they also
admitted the same. Therefore, they cannot be allowed to re-open the
entire controversies again for fresh adjudication. In view of above, it
is held that the learned courts below were justified in decreeing the
suit
of
the
plaintiff
without
entertaining
the
defendants
reopening and re-adjudicating of the entire controversy again.
from
[26]
The last point as argued by Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel
was non-compliance of provisions of Order XLI Rule 31 of the CPC by
the learned first appellate court. Said provision envisages as follows:
31. Contents, date and signature of judgment- The judgment
of the Appellate Court shall be in writing and shall state(a) the points for determination;
(b) the decision thereon;
(c) the reasons for the decision; and
(d) where the decree appealed from is reversed or varied, the
relief to which the appellant is entitled;
and shall at the time that it is pronounced be signed and dated
by the Judge or by the Judges concurring therein.
[27]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel also relies on few decisions
in the matter of compliance of said provision by the learned appellate
courts which are referred below.
[28]
In B.V. Nagesh and another vs. H.V. Sreenivasa
Murthy, (2010) 13 SCC 530, as relied on by Mr. Deb, learned senior
counsel, the following were observed by the Apex Court:
“4. The appellate Court has jurisdiction to reverse or affirm
the findings of the trial court. The first appeal is a valuable
right of the parties and unless restricted by law, the whole
case is therein open for re-hearing both on questions of fact
and law. The judgment of the appellate Court must, therefore,
reflect its conscious application of mind and record findings
supported by reasons, on all the issues arising along with the
contentions put-forth and pressed by the parties for decision
of the appellate Court. Sitting as a court of first appeal, it was
the duty of the High Court to deal with all the issues and the
evidence led by the parties before recording its findings. The
first appeal is a valuable right and the parties have a right to
be heard both on questions of law and on facts and the
judgment in the first appeal must address itself to all the
issues of law and fact and decide it by giving reasons in
support of the findings. [Vide Santosh Hazari vs. Purushottam
Tiwari, (2001) 3 SCC 179, SCC p.188, para 15 and Madhukar
vs. Sangram, (2001) 4 SCC 756, SCC p.758, para 5]”
[29]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has also referred United
Engineers and contractors vs. Secretary to Government of
Andhra Pradesh and others, (2014) 16 SCC 109 wherein the
matter was remanded by the Apex Court to the High Court for fresh
decision of the appeal for not adhering to the provision of Order XLI
Rule 31 of the CPC.
[30]
The third decision, as relied on by Mr. Deb, learned senior
counsel, is in case of Kanailal and others vs. Ram Chandra Singh
and others, (2018) 13 SCC 715. In that case, at Para-12 it was
observed by the Apex Court that it was obligatory for both the first
appellate court and the second appellate court to comply with the
provisions of Order XLI Rule 31 of the CPC and in case of second
appeal, the court has to further ensure compliance with the
requirements of Section 100 of the CPC.
[31]
The last decision as referred on this point is Malluru
Mallappa (Dead) through legal vs. Kuruvathappa and others,
(2020) 4 SCC 313 wherein at Para-18 it was observed by the Apex
Court that the judgment of the first appellate court has to set out
points for determination, record the decision thereon and give its own
reasons. Even when the first appellate court affirms the judgment of
the trial court, it is required to comply with the requirement of Order
XLI Rule 31 of CPC and non-observance of this requirement leads to
infirmity in the judgment.
[32]
Taking into consideration of the impugned judgment of the
learned first appellate court passed in T.A. 20 of 2020, as indicated
earlier, the learned first appellate court already drew two points for
decision in the appeal in compliance of the provisions of Order XLI
Rule 31 CPC and the point No.1 was whether the respondent became
the owner of the suit property on the basis of gift deed executed by
Thakurmani Debnath and while deciding the said point, the learned
first appellate court exhaustively discussed the matter of applicability
of res judicata based on the decision of previous appeal filed against
T.S.26 of 1997 and observed that the defendants had no right, title
and interest in the suit property. Though it is fact that no specific
issue was framed on the point of res judicata by the learned trial court
and a specific ‘point for decision’ was drawn by the learned first
appellate court on the point of res-judicata in specific words, but both
the courts below took up the said issue for decision and also decided
the said issue while going to decide the right, title, interest of the
parties in the suit land. The defendants were all through conscious
about the decision of the previous suit attaining it’s finality and the
said point was also raised by Mr. Biswas, learned senior counsel
before the first appellate court and therefore, the defendants had
ample opportunity to answer the same. Therefore, even if specific
point for determination in relation to res judicata was not taken up in
specific words by the learned first appellate court, there is nothing to
show that any prejudice has been caused to the present defendantappellants thereby and more so, it is not a case of gross violation of
total non-compliance of Order XLI Rule 31 CPC by the learned first
appellate court. Even the present defendants before the said learned
first appellate court in T.A 20 of 2022 did not raise any challenge
regarding the decision of the learned trial court on the point of res
judicata except to the effect that the lands of previous suit and the
lands of the present suit were not same. Such plea was basically on
the ground that earlier suit was only regarding a part of the present
suit land.
[33]
In view of above discussions, it is held that there is no
merit in the present appeal requiring any interference with the
concurrent findings of Courts below.
The appeal is accordingly dismissed with cost in favour of
the respondent.
Return the records of Courts below.
Registry is to prepare the decree accordingly.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2024.12.17 19:19:43 +05'30'
Sujay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review