Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
TRHC010006192026
2026:THC:547
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A. No.72 of 2026
Smt. Ratna Das,
W/o Sri Sujit Das, resident of Nayadil, Meghli Bandh, P.S. Sidhai, West
Tripura, Pin-799212.
............Petitioner(s);
On behalf of:
Sri Sujit Das,
S/o Late Jatindra Das, resident of Nayadil, Meghli Bandh, P.S. Sidhai, West
Tripura, Pin-799212.
............Accused person(s).
–Versus–
Union of India,
Represented by: Sri Rahul Sharma, Inspector, Divisional Preventive Force,
Customs Division, Agartala, under Ministry of Finance, Department of
Revenue, Government of India.
……..Respondent(s);
Along with
B.A. No.74 of 2026
Sri Sanjit Das,
S/o Late Amulya Das, resident of Vill- Ghaniarbill, Tuichindrai, P.S.
Teliamura, Khowai, Tripura, Pin-799205.
............Petitioner(s);
On behalf of:
Sri Suman Das,
S/o Sri Sanjit Das, resident of Vill- Ghaniarbill, Tuichindrai, P.S. Teliamura,
Khowai, Tripura, Pin-799205.
............Accused person(s).
–Versus–
Union of India,
Represented by: Sri Rahul Sharma, Inspector, Divisional Preventive Force,
Customs Division, Agartala, under Ministry of Finance, Department of
Revenue, Government of India.
……..Respondent(s);
Along with
B.A. No.75 of 2026
Sri Dipak Sarkar,
S/o Late Jatindra Das, resident of Vill-South Pulinpur, Karailong, P.S.
Teliamura, Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205.
............Petitioner(s);
On behalf of:
Sri Rupak Sarkar,
S/o Late Jatindra Das, resident of Vill-South Pulinpur, Karailong, P.S.
Teliamura, Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205.
............Accused person(s).
–Versus–
Union of India,
Represented by: Sri Rahul Sharma, Inspector, Divisional Preventive Force,
Customs Division, Agartala, under Ministry of Finance, Department of
Revenue, Government of India.
……..Respondent(s);
Along with
B.A. No.76 of 2026
Smt. Sima Debnath Das,
W/o Sri Raju Das, resident of Ward No.27, Aralia, P.S. East Agartala, West
Tripura, Pin-799004.
............Petitioner(s);
On behalf of:
Sri Raju Das,
S/o Late Ranjit Das, resident of Ward no.27, Aralia, P.S. East Agartala, West
Tripura, Pin-799004.
............Accused person(s).
–Versus–
Union of India,
Represented by: Sri Rahul Sharma, Inspector, Divisional Preventive Force,
Customs Division, Agartala, under Ministry of Finance, Department of
Revenue, Government of India.
……..Respondent(s);
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. D. Biswas, Advocate,
Mr. A. Kar, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
Date of hearing
:
:
Mr. B. Roy, Advocate.
23.04.2026.
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
29.04.2026.
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The instant bail applications are filed on behalf of the accused
persons namely Sri Sujit Das, Sri Suman Das, Sri Rupak Sarkar, and Sri
Raju Das who are in custody from 30.09.2025 in connection with case no.
04/CL/NDPS/DPF/AGT/2025-26,
dated
29.09.2025
21(C)/22(C)/23(C)/25/25A/28 and 29 of the NDPS Act.
under
Sections
[2]
The complaint was filed by one Rahul Sharma, Inspector,
Divisional Preventive Force (DPF), Customs Division, Agartala, on behalf of
the Union of India against the above said four accused persons, alleging that
on the basis of a secret information, he constituted a team and set an
ambush on 29.09.2025 at around 08:00 hours at a place 6 km away from
Khowai Chowmuhani towards Agartala and at around 09:05 hours, the
suspected vehicle bearing no.TR061767 arrived there. Thereafter, he
followed the said truck with his team and at around 13:00 hours, another
person arriving on a motorcycle met with the occupants of the said truck at
Shanitala Noabadi area. There were three occupants in the said truck
including the driver. These persons handed over one white muddy coloured
plastic sack taking out from the truck. At that time, all of them were detained
and total 11.03 kg of methamphetamine tablets (yaba) were recovered
therefrom and after re-checking of the vehicle as per verbatim of those four
persons, two trolley bags were further recovered which were deeply hidden
behind sacks containing ginger inside the cargo bed of the truck. Upon
opening each of the trolley bags, the officer further recovered brown packets
and upon opening brown packets, blue and black plastic sachets containing
small pink tablets with a pungent smell believed to be yaba, were found.
Then he completed all the related seizure procedure and arrested them.
Since then they are in custody.
[3]
Mr. D. Biswas, learned counsel for the petitioners, submits
that while arresting the four petitioners in the case, the provisions of
Section 36 of BNSS were not scrupulously followed by the arresting officer.
Neither the arrest memo was attested by any family member of the
accused or a respectable person from the locality where the arrest was
made, nor the accused persons were informed by the arresting officer of
their right to have a relative or a friend or any other person named by them
to be informed of their arrest.
[4]
Learned counsel, Mr. Biswas, further submits that the seizure
in the instant case was made on 29.09.2025, whereas statements of
seizure witnesses were recorded on 20.12.2025 which creates further
doubts. Learned counsel also refers to the provisions of Section 51 of
NDPS Act to show that in the case of searches, seizures and arrests, the
provisions of Cr.P.C. or BNSS, 2023, as the case may be, are applicable
so far the same are not contradictory to any provision of NDPS Act.
[5]
Learned counsel, Mr. Biswas, relies on a decision of Hon’ble
the Supreme Court in case of Romila Thapar and others versus Union
of India and others [(2018) 10 SCC 753]. The relevant paragraphs of the
said decision referred by the learned counsel are extracted hereunder:
“77.
One of the circumstances which must certainly bear
upon the fairness and impartiality of the process which has
been followed by the investigating agency is in regard to the
importation of two panch witnesses from Pune, when the
arrests were carried out. Section 41-B of the Code of Criminal
Procedure emphasises the importance of an independent
witness while making an arrest. Section 41-B of the Code
provides as follows:
"41-B. Procedure of arrest and duties of officer
making arrest. – Every police officer while making an arrest
shall –
(a) bear an accurate, visible and clear identification of
his name which will facilitate easy identification;
(b) prepare a memorandum of arrest which shall bei.
attested by at least one witness, who
is a member of the family of the
person arrested or a respectable
member of the locality where the
arrest is made,
ii.
countersigned by the person arrested;
and
(c) inform
the
person
arrested,
unless
the
memorandum is attested by a member of his family,
that he has a right to have a relative or a friend
named by him to be informed of his arrest."
(emphasis supplied)
The two panch witnesses in the present case are
employees of the Pune Municipal Corporation. It is not disputed
before this Court that they travelled as part of the police team
which made the arrest.
78.
It was in D.K. Basu v. State of W.B. (1997) 1 SCC
416: 1997 SCC (Cri) 92, that this Court laid down requirements
to be followed in all cases of arrest, which included the
following: (SCC pp. 435-36, para 35)
"35. (2)
That the police officer carrying out the arrest
of the arrestee shall prepare a memo of arrest at the
time of arrest and such memo shall be attested by at
least one witness, who may either be a member of the
family of the arrestee or a respectable person of the
locality from where the arrest is made. It shall also be
countersigned by the arrestee and shall contain the time
and date of arrest"
This Court observed that the requirements it had
enunciated emanated from Articles 21 and 22(1) of the
Constitution and "need to be strictly followed" falling which
action for contempt of court would be initiated.”
[6]
Learned counsel, Mr. Biswas also relies on a decision of
Single Bench of Gauhati High Court in case of Amirul Islam Alias Nengra
Police and another versus the State of Assam [Bail Appln./3650/2025]
decided on 20.01.2026 wherein the learned Bench observed that the
violation of mandatory provision of Section 36 of BNSS, 2023 would
override the embargo of Section 37 of the NDPS Act, 1985. It was also
observed by the said learned Court that Section 36 and Section 62 of
BNSS, 2023 are only statutory exposition of constitutional norm provided
under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, and hence, same could not be
overridden merely because of the presence of a non-obstante clause
in Section 37 of the NDPS Act, 1985.
In said judgment the Gauhati High Court also disagreed with
the observations made by Division Bench of High Court of Kolkata in case
of Hero Sarkar versus Union of India (CRM) (NDPS 445/2025) wherein it
was observed by the Court that as Section 37 of the NDPS Act, 1985 was
not in issue before the Apex Court when the judgment of " D. K. Basu Vs.
State of Bengal" was delivered and as Section 37 of the NDPS Act, 1985
starts with a non-obstante clause giving overriding effect to the provisions
of said section over other provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973, even if an arrest is made without complying with the provisions
of Section 41B of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, it would not per
se override the embargo of Section 37 of the NDPS Act, 1985.
[7]
Learned counsel, Mr. Biswas further relies on a decision of
Calcutta High Court in case of Ansar Ali versus State of West Bengal
[CRM No.5708 of 2018] decided on 10.08.2018 wherein the Hon’ble High
Court observed as under:
“9. Having
considered
the
materials
on
record
particularly the seizure list, labels, memo of arrest in the instant
case, we find gross inconsistencies and/or contradictions in the
said documents. Although it is claimed that the seizure was
witnessed
by
independent
witnesses,
namely,
Masidul
Rahaman, Jayanta Sarkar and Nabin and their signatures
purportedly appear on the seizure memo and labels on the
seized articles, it is significant to note that no signature of a
relation or a respectable member of the locality is affixed to the
arrest memo of the petitioner.
10. In fact, in the arrest memo under the column titled
“Relation or respectable member of the locality” it is recorded
“no one turned up” It is inexplicable when the aforesaid local
people agreed to witness the search and recovery of narcotic
substance from the petitioner, why they declined to sign on the
arrest memo. Signature on the arrest memo of a relation or
respectable member of the locality is a requirement which
stems from the mandate of the Apex Court in the case of D. K.
Basu v. State of West Bengal (AIR 1997 SC 610). It is not an
empty formality and the presence of such signature gives a
stamp of authenticity to the lawful apprehension of the accused
at the place and time as stated therein. Absence of signature in
the arrest memo of a respectable member of the locality
particularly when it is alleged that apprehension and recovery
from the petitioner was at a public place in presence of
independent witnesses gives rise to reasonable grounds that
the arrest of the petitioner may not have occurred in the manner
as alleged by the prosecution leading credence to the
petitioner’s plea of prior arrest and wrongful detention.”
It is further observed by the Hon’ble High Court that the
statements of the so-called search witnesses were not recorded on the day
of seizure or soon thereafter and only after one and half months of the
incident their statements were recorded. On the other hand, statements of
certain witnesses were recorded on the date of seizure whose signatures
were noticeably absent in the seizure memo, arrest memo or labels
prepared contemporaneously at the time of search and seizure.
Considering all these aspects it was held by the High Court that petitioner
was able to rebut the statutory restrictions for grant of bail under Section
37 of the NDPS Act.
[8]
Learned counsel, Mr. Biswas, also relies on another decision
of Calcutta High Court in case of Chandra Bahadur Tamang @
Chandara B Tamang versus the State of West Bengal [CRM (NDPS)
No.435 of 2023] decided on 27.07.2023 wherein for violation of provisions
of Section 41B of Cr.P.C., the bail was granted. The accused person in
that case relied on the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of D.K.
Basu versus State of West Bengal in Writ Petition [(CRL) No.592 of
1987] [(1997) 1SCC 416]. The High Court also observed that the arrest
memo was not signed by either a member of the family of the accused
petitioner or by a respectable member of the locality where the arrest was
made and column 10 was absolutely kept blank and no explanation was
advanced from the side of prosecution for non-compliance of Section 41B
of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
[9]
Learned counsel, Mr. Biswas, lastly relies on a decision of
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Vijay Singh versus Union of India
[Special Leave Petition (Criminal) Dairy No(s). 43071/2024] wherein
Hon’ble the Supreme Court observes that Article 21 of the Constitution of
India over-rides Section 37 of the Act and if there is an undue delay on the
part of the persecution in concluding the trial and that too for no fault on the
part of the accused, then accused cannot be kept in jail for indefinite period
of time.
[10]
On the same point, learned counsel, further relies on another
decision of Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Directorate of
Enforcement versus Subhash Sharma [(2025) 1SCR 1409] wherein the
Hon’ble Supreme Court observed that once a Court, while dealing with a
bail application, found that the fundamental rights of the accused under
Article 21 and 22 of the Constitution of India had been violated while
arresting the accused or after arresting him, it was the duty of the Court
dealing with the bail application to release the accused on bail. The reason
was that the arrest in such cases stands vitiated.
According to learned counsel, in said case, there was a
violation of Clause 2 of Article 22 of the Constitution of India, as the
arrestee was not produced before the nearest Magistrate within the
stipulated time of 24 hours which infringed the fundamental rights under
Clause 2 of Article 22 of the Constitution of India.
[11]
Mr. B. Roy, learned counsel for the respondent, however,
fairly admits that the signature of the near relative of the arrested accused
persons or any respectable person from the locality was not obtained in the
arrest memo, and prima facie, there was a violation of Section 36 of BNSS
by the arresting officer.
[12]
Learned counsel, however, submits that even if there is
violation of provisions of Section 36 of BNSS in the arrest memo, the
accused persons are still not entitled to get bail, as the embargo of Section
37 of NDPS Act is there against them. In this regard, he relies on a
decision of Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Narcotics Control
Bureau versus Mohit Aggarwal [Criminal Appeal Nos. 1001-1002 of
2022 arising out of Special Leave to Appeal (CRL.) No.6128-29 of
2021] decided on 19.07.2022 wherein Hon’ble the Supreme Court
observed as under:
“14.
To sum up, the expression "reasonable
grounds" used in clause (b) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 37
would mean credible, plausible and grounds for the Court to
believe that the accused person is not guilty of the alleged
offence. For arriving at any such conclusion, such facts and
circumstances must exist in a case that can persuade the Court
to believe that the accused person would not have committed
such an offence. Dove-tailed with the aforesaid satisfaction is
an additional consideration that the accused person is unlikely
to commit any offence while on bail.”
[13]
Learned counsel, Mr. B. Roy, also submits that Section 37 of
the NDPS Act starts with non-obstante clause stating that notwithstanding
contained anything in Cr.P.C. 1973, bail cannot be granted to the accused
persons unless the twin conditions as embodied in the said provisions are
satisfied.
[14]
This Court has appreciated the submissions of both sides. Very
recently, in the case of State of Punjab versus Sukhwinder Singh @Gora
[Criminal Appeal arising out of SLP (Crl.) No.5020 of 2026] decided on
24.04.2026, Hon’ble the Apex Court at paragraph no.9, has categorically
held that in the matters involving recovery of contraband in commercial
quantity, the twin conditions under Section 37(1)(b)(ii) of the NDPS Act are
mandatory and entail no relaxation merely on the ground that the accused
has undergone prolonged incarceration during the pendency of trial. The
provision casts upon the Court a duty to record, before enlarging an accused
on bail, its satisfaction on two cumulative conditions, first, that there exist
reasonable grounds for believing that the accused is not guilty of the offence
charged; and second, that he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail
and such provisions of Section 37 is mandatory and not merely directory,
and that an order granting bail without such recorded satisfaction stands
vitiated and cannot be sustained. It is also further observed that the right to
speedy trial, rooted in Article 21 of the Constitution, is undoubtedly a
precious Constitutional right. However, such right under Article 21 must be
exercised within the framework of Section 37 and cannot be pressed into
service solely on the ground of delay to override it. The Constitutional right
under Article 21 and the special provision of law under Section 37, NDPS
Act are to be read harmoniously and not placed in opposition to each other.
Ultimately, the bail granted to the respondent was cancelled.
[15]
In the case diary, there are prima facie materials corroborating
the statements of witnesses regarding the recovery and seizure of huge
quantity of contraband items from the accused persons. The Forensic
authority, after examining those items, also submitted a report confirming the
presence of methamphetamine and caffeine in those tablets. Therefore, the
rigors of Section 37 of the NDPS Act are satisfied in this case.
[16]
Thus, in view of above recent decision of Hon’ble Supreme
Court in case of Sukhwinder Singh (supra) and also considering the
materials placed on record, the instant bail applications are rejected.
Re-consign the case diary to the respondent-Union of India with
copy of this order.
Return the LC record.
Also, communicate a copy of this order to learned Special
Judge, West Tripura, Agartala.
JUDGE
Munna
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review