The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. Since the factual aspects and law involved in the present writ petition is similar and identical to the subject matter of the case of Kamanashis Das (supra), this Court is of the view that the present writ petition may be allowed and disposed of in the same terms.
8. Accordingly, the respondents are directed to provide one advance increment to the petitioners of the present writ petition in terms of Rule 13(1)(ii) of ROP 2009 from the respective dates when they were regularized in their service. However, the fixation of pay of the petitioners would be made notionally till the date of filing of this petition after which they would be entitled to arrears of salary. The respondents are also directed to complete the entire exercise within a period of 4(four) months from today.
9. With the aforesaid observations and directions, the instant writ petition stands allowed and disposed of. Saikat
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 174/2022
Smt. Silpi Bhowmik
…..Petitioner
Versus
The State of Tripura and 2 ors.
…..Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. A. Bhaumik, Advocate
Mr. D Sarma, Addl. GA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Order
13/01/2023
Heard Mr. A. Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner.
Also heard Mr. D. Sarma, learned Additional GA appearing for the
respondents.
2.
By means of filing this writ petition, the petitioner has claimed for the
following reliefs:
“i) Issue notice upon the Respondents.
ii)
Call for the Records.
iii)
Issue rule calling upon the respondents to show cause as to why the
Petitioner shall not be given the benefit of one increment as per Rule
13(1)(v) of the Tripura States Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009.
AND
Issue Rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to why
further direction to re-fix the pay of the Petitioner and grant arrears
accordingly upon grant of such increment to the Petitioner shall not be
issued.
AND
Issue Rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to why the
memorandum dated 6th July, 2011 issued by the Finance Department,
Government of Tripura shall not be set aside and quashed.
AND
Issue Rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to why the
Petitioner shall not be granted all financial benefits as per the Judgment
and order dated 19th March, 2021 passed in WP(C) No. 703/2019 by this
Hon’ble High Court.
AND
iv)
After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the rule absolute.
AND/OR
Pass any other order/orders as deemed fit and proper by this
Hon’ble Court.”
3.
Facts of the petitioner’s case, briefly, are that the petitioner herein was
appointed as Post Graduate teacher under the respondents on 30.03.2007.
She was appointed initially on fixed pay basis for 5(five) years as per
Government policy and after completion of her continuous 5(five) years of
service, she was regularized in the said post. It is the main contention of the
petitioner that she had completed her B. Ed degree prior to their entry into
service and accordingly, she is entitled to one advance increment as per Rule
13(1)(ii) of Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009 (for
short, “ROP 2009”).
4.
Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that
similar issue had already been decided by this Court in WP(C) No.703 of
2019 titled as Sri Kamanashis Das & 4 Ors vs. The State of Tripura & 3
Ors, vide judgment and order dated 19th March, 2021, wherein, the learned
Single Judge held that the writ petitioners of that writ petition would fall
under clause (ii) of Rule 13(1) of the Revised Pay Rules of 2009 as the
petitioners possessed the B.Ed. Degree before joining their services either as
Graduate or Post Graduate teachers.
5.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondents did not oppose the
submission of Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel for the petitioner. The relevant
portion of the said judgment passed in WP(C) No.703 of 2019 may be
reproduced here-in-below:
“[11] Insofar as the stand of the Government that as on 1st January 2006 the
petitioners were not covered by ROP 2009 is concerned, I find no difficulty in accepting
it. Rule 2 of ROP 2009 pertains to its applicability. Sub-rule (1) of Rule 2 provides that
unless otherwise provided under the rules, the said rules shall apply to persons
appointed in regular scales of pay to services and posts in connection with the affairs
of the State of Tripura. Sub-rule (2) of Rule 2 provides that unlessspecifically extended
under the express order of the Government, the said rules shall not apply to various
category of persons mentioned in clauses (a) to (h) of the said sub-rule. Clause (d)
pertains to persons paid on monthly fixed pay basis including those paid only on piece
rate basis. As on 1st January 2006 all the petitioners were engaged on fixed pay basis
and thus, by virtue of clause (d) of sub-rule (2) of ROP 2009 the said rules did not apply
to them. Considering the initial date of engagement of these petitioners, they had not
completed 5 years till 1st January, 2009 and thus, as on 1st January, 2009 also these
petitioners were not covered by ROP 2009. It is in this context, question of applicability
of clause (ii) or clause (v) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 13 has arisen. All these petitioners
having completed 5 years of service on fixed salary after 1st January, 2009 and
accordingly, having been brought over to regular scales after the said date, can claim
advance increment only if even post 1st January, 2009 clause (ii) of sub-rule (1) of Rule
13 continued to apply. On the other hand, if the Government’s interpretation is correct
and post 1st January, 2009 the entire scheme including one envisaged in clause (ii) was
replaced, the petitioners can only claim lump sum payment and not advance
increment.
[12] One may recall, clause (ii) of Rule 13(1) introduced the concept of granting one
advance increment to those teachers who entered the service with higher qualification
of B.Ed. Such increment would be available even to existing employees who may not
have got such benefit in the past. The date from which the benefit would be available
was 1st January, 2006(which obviously will cover existing teachers) or from the
date of coming over to the rules or from the date of appointment of the teacher
whichever is later. In other words, even if a teacher is appointed after 1st January,
2006 but possessed qualification of B.Ed at the time of the entry in service, he would
be entitled to advance increment in terms of the said clause from their date of
appointment. The third situation of being brought over to ROP 2009 can have
reference only for those who may have been appointed after 1st January, 2006 but
before 1st January, 2009. Thus, the third category of cases where the effective date of
grant of the benefit which is the date of appointment, must have a reference to those
who are appointed after 1st January, 2009 since, in their cases, there will be no
question of a choice of being brought over to the new rules. To my mind, thus there is
a clear indication in this rule itself that the same will continue to have effect even after
1st January, 2009.
[13] Let us now juxtapose this position with clause (v) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 13. This
clause essentially provides that in respect of the categories mentioned in the said
clause of employees existing system of providing training incentive in the form of one
increment would be replaced by a lump sum incentive of different sizes depending on
the nature of qualification and duration of the training. The note below clause (v)
provides that the system of providing lump sum incentive will take effect form 1st
January, 2009 for all cases who have completed training on or after 1st January, 2009.
If, as is argued by the Government, clause (v) was meant to replace all provisions for
training incentives including one provided in clause (ii), the note below clause (v) was
redundant. This note includes only those cases where training has been obtained after
1st January, 2009. To elaborate, if the main body of clause (v) were to include every
case where the claim for advance increment arises after 1st January 2009, the
clarification contained in the note was wholly redundant since it provides that the
system of providing lump sum incentive will take effect from 1st January, 2009 for
those persons who complete training on or after 1st January, 2009.
[14] Sum total of this discussion is that in my view, the provision for grant of advance
increment by way of training incentive to those teachers who entered the service with
higher qualifications would continue to operate even after 1st January 2009, however,
those who obtained such training after 1st January, 2009 will only be entitled to lump
sum payment. The case of the petitioners would fall under clause (ii) since they had
obtained B.Ed degrees long before 1st January, 2009. They possessed such degrees
when they joined the service. They were brought over under ROP 2009 upon
completion of 5 years period from respective dates of initial engagement. They would,
therefore, be entitled to the benefit under Rule 13(1)(ii) of ROP 2009, notwithstanding
the fact that the event of being brought over Rule 13(1)(ii) of ROP 2009 happened
after 1st January, 2009 in each of their cases.
[15] Two issues need to be sorted out before final directions can be issued. Firstly, in
facts of the case, the principle of estoppel cannot be applied since it is stated by the
petitioner that only 2 out of the 5 petitioners have received even the lump sum
payment and in their cases also the same was granted unilaterally by the Government.
Second is the question of delay and laches. It is true that these petitions were filed
long after the rights of the petitioners to claim increment arose. However, being a
matter of correct pay fixation, would have recurring effect. Subject to limiting their
past rights, their prayer for grant of advance increment cannot be rejected only on this
ground.
[16] In the result, it is provided that all the petitioners would be
entitled to one advance increment in terms of Rule 13(1)(ii) of ROP 2009 from the
respective dates when they were brought over to regular pay scales. This pay fixation
would, however, be for notional purpose till the date of filing of the petition after
which they would be entitled to arrears of salary. These directions shall be carried out
within a period of 4(four) months from today.
Petition is disposed of accordingly. Pending application(s), if any, also stands
disposed of.”
6.
Challenging the judgment and order dated 19.03.2021 passed in
WP(C) 703 of 2019, the respondents herein have preferred writ appeals
before this court. A Division Bench of this court after hearing the parties had
dismissed the appeals filed by the respondents-State upholding the judgment
and order dated 19.03.2021 passed in WP(C) 703 of 2019.
7.
Since the factual aspects and law involved in the present writ petition
is similar and identical to the subject matter of the case of Kamanashis Das
(supra), this Court is of the view that the present writ petition may be
allowed and disposed of in the same terms.
8.
Accordingly, the respondents are directed to provide one advance
increment to the petitioners of the present writ petition in terms of Rule
13(1)(ii) of ROP 2009 from the respective dates when they were regularized
in their service. However, the fixation of pay of the petitioners would be
made notionally till the date of filing of this petition after which they would
be entitled to arrears of salary. The respondents are also directed to complete
the entire exercise within a period of 4(four) months from today.
9.
With the aforesaid observations and directions, the instant writ
petition stands allowed and disposed of.
JUDGE
Saikat
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review