Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 22ND DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C M JOSHI
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 3126 OF 2007 (PAR)
BETWEEN:
SMT. SHARADA,
W/O. KALLAPPA NAKADI,
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. SHAHAPUR, BELGAUM-590 003.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI SHREEVATSA HEGDE, ADVOCATE)
AND:
Digitally signed
by NAGARATHNA
TEKAL
SUBBARAO
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
1.
SMT. ANASUYA RAMAKANT PAWSAHE,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. BHARAT NAGAR,
BELGAUM-590 004.
2.
PRASHANT RAMAKANT PAWASHE,
AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS,
OCC. PRIVATE SERVICE,
R/O. BHARAT NAGAR,
BELGAUM-590 004.
SRI LUMANNA CHOLAPPA CHOPADE
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
3.
SMT. GANGUBAI LUMANNA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. 4488, CHAVAT GALLI,
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
BELGAUM-590 002.
4.
SRI YALLAPPA LUMANNA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
R/O. 4488, CHAVAT GALLI,
BELGAUM-590 002.
5.
SRI PARASHURAM LUMANNA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
R/O. 4488, CHAVAT GALLI,
BELGAUM-590 002.
6.
SRI SHANKAR LUMANNA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS,
R/O. 4488, CHAVAT GALLI,
BELGAUM-590 002.
7.
SRI SHRIKANT LUMANNA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,
R/O. 4488, CHAVAT GALLI,
BELGAUM-590 002.
8.
SRI MAHENDRA LUMANNA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS,
R/O. 4488, CHAVAT GALLI,
BELGAUM-590 002.
9.
SRI MARUTI CHANGAPPA MANNURKAR
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
9(a) SRI SHYAM MARUTI MANNURKAR,
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
OCC. BUSINESS.
9(b) SRI SURESH MARUTI MANNURKAR,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
OCC. BUSINESS.
BOTH ARE R/O. H.NO.436, NAZAR CAMP,
CROSS NO.3, VADAGAON, BELAGAVI-590 005.
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI S.B DEYANNAVAR, ADVOCATE AND
SMT. N.S PATTAR, ADVOCATE FOR R-1 & R-2;
SRI D. RAVIKUMAR GOKAKAKAR, ADVOCATE FOR R-9 (b &
c);
R-3, R-4, R-5, R-6, R-7 & R-8 ARE SERVED;
R-9 (a) & (d) APPEAL DISMISSED)
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 100 OF CPC AGAINST
THE JUDGMENT AND DEREE DATED 14.09.2007 PASSED IN
R.A.NO.314/2004 ON THE FILE OF THE PRL. DIST. JUDGE,
BELGAUM (R.A.21/2000 BEFORE PRL. CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.),
BELGAUM), DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND CONFIRMING THE
JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 29.11.1999 PASSED IN
O.S.NO.149/1995 ON THE FILE OF THE II ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE
(JR.DN), BELGAUM.
THIS RSA HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED ON
31.10.2025, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT
THIS DAY AT BENGALURU BENCH, COURT DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C M JOSHI)
This second appeal arises out of the judgment and
decree passed by the learned II Additional Civil Judge
(Jr.Dn.), Belgaum, in OS.No.149/1995 dated 29.11.1999,
which came to be confirmed by the First Appellate Court
i.e., Principal District and Sessions Judge, Belgaum in
RA.No.314/2004
(Old
No.RA.No.21/2000
before
the
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
Principal Civil Judge (Sr.Dn.), Belgaum) dated 14.09.2007.
The defendant No.1 in the said suit is before this Court in
appeal.
2.
The factual matrix in brief that is relevant for the
purpose of this appeal may be summarized as below:
(a)
Plaintiff No.1 and defendant No.1 are sisters,
their mother was Tulasabai and father was Laxman.
Sister of the plaintiff No.1 and defendant No.1 by
name Fakira died unmarried. Therefore, the properties
that were held by Laxman and his wife Tulasabai have
devolved upon plaintiff No.1 and defendant No.1. The
relationship between the parties is not in dispute.
(b) It is a case of the plaintiffs that deceased Laxman
had about 06 properties
which were under his
cultivation and enjoyment and out of which 05
properties are the suit schedule properties. The suit
schedule properties are as below:
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
Sl.No.
R.S.No.
Acres. Gs.
Assessment
Rs. Ps.
(c)
1.
107/6
0-18
03.10
2.
107/8
0-11
01.78
3.
107/9
0-10
01.48
4.
106A/10B
0-14-8
00.44
5.
106A/9
0-13
00.23
Out of the above 5 properties, Item Nos.1 and 4
properties were under the tenancy. Rest of the
properties were under the ownership of Laxman. Apart
from this, Tulasabai had also purchased one property,
which
was
her
Sy.No.106A/10A/1
self
acquired
measuring
property
9.12
bearing
guntas.
(This
property was bequeathed to husband of plaintiff No.1
and is not part of this suit.)
(d)
The plaintiffs contended that the propositus died
long back and her sister Fakira also died unmarried.
On the death of Laxman, the suit schedule properties
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
devolved upon plaintiff No.1, defendant No.1 and
Tulasabai. The said Tulasabai died on 05.03.1998.
(e)
Tulasabai had executed a registered Will in
respect of her undivided 1/3rd share in the suit
schedule properties on 24.06.1989. She bequeathed
her
undivided
1/3rd
properties in favour of
share
in
the
suit
schedule
plaintiff No.2, (who is none
else than the son of plaintiff No.1) and defendant No.2
and defendant No.3, who were the sons of sister and
the brother of son-in-law. Names
of these legatees
came to be entered in the record of rights under
M.E.No.6165 dated 17.03.1990 and the same was
challenged by defendant No.1 before the Assistant
Commissioner. The Assistant Commissioner set aside
the certification of the said mutation entry and
remanded the matter for fresh enquiry, stating that
the parties have to resolve their disputes before the
Civil Court.
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
(f)
Plaintiffs contended that there is no partition in
respect of the suit schedule properties between the
plaintiff No.1 and the defendants at any time. The
plaintiffs demanded their share by mutual partition.
However, the defendants did not cooperate for the
same and as such, they were constrained to file the
suit for partition of their respective shares.
(g)
They contended that plaintiff No.1 is entitled for
1/3rd share in the suit schedule properties and plaintiff
No.2 has also become the owner of the properties
given to him under the registered Will executed by
Tulasabai and he is entitled for his share. Defendant
No.2 and defendant No.3 have become owners to the
extent of the properties which were bequeathed to
them by the said Tulasabai and as such, they are
included as parties to the suit. The plaintiffs sought for
the partition of their shares.
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
3.
On
service
of
summons,
defendant
No.1
appeared before the trial Court and filed the written
statement. Defendant Nos.2 and 3 did not appear despite
service of summons and therefore, they were placed exparte.
4.
Defendant No.1 in the written statement took up
following contentions:
(a)
Defendant
No.1
admitted
the
relationship
between the parties and the fact that Fakira died
unmarried. Defendant No.1 denied the Will alleged to
have been executed by Tulasabai and termed the
same to be false, sham and fabricated.
(b)
It
is
Sy.No.107/6
contended
that
measuring 0.18
the
land
bearing
guntas was of
the
ownership of one Ravindra Bembalgi and Laxman was
the tenant. On the advent of the Land Reforms Act,
Tulasabai, mother of
No.1 filed Form
plaintiff No.1 and defendant
No. 7 and got declared as the
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
occupant of the said land and therefore, it is a
tenanted land and is not of the ownership of the
deceased Laxman. It is contended that defendant No.1
has paid the occupancy price on 24.10.1990.
(c)
The land bearing Sy.No. 106/A/10 measuring
0.14 guntas was of the ownership of a Legade family
and it was a tenanted land. Defendant No.1 had filed
CP.No.8821/1991 before the High Court of Karnataka,
Bengaluru and the owner Vardichand Legade had also
filed OS.No.373/1983 before the I Additional Civil
Judge (Jr.Dn), Belgaum and it was stayed as the
modified issue of tenancy is involved in the matter. It
was contended that the tenancy issue was not decided
yet.
(d)
Defendant No.1 admitted that the remaining
lands i.e., Sy.Nos.107/8, 107/9 and 106/A/9 are
ancestral lands of the family of
defendant No.1.
plaintiff No.1 and
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
(e)
Defendant No.1 also denies about the challenge
to
the
ME.No.6165
and
that
the
Assistant
Commissioner had remanded the matter directing
cancellation of the ME.No.6165.
(f)
It is admitted that there is no partition in the
family. But it is denied that suit schedule properties
are the joint family properties. However, it is the case
of defendant No.1 that 03 of the lands are ancestral
properties and 02 others are tenanted properties,
regarding which the dispute is still pending.
(g)
It
was
contended
that
Sy.No.107/6
and
106A/10B are the tenanted lands and since, the
tenanted lands are granted under the Karnataka Land
Reforms Act and therefore, they cannot be transferred
by any deed and any such transfer including the Will is
hit by the provisions of KLR Act and as such, the suit
deserves to be dismissed.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
5.
On the basis of the above contentions, the
following issues were framed by the trial Court:
ISSUES:
(1) Whether the Plaintiffs prove that the Suit
properties are joint family properties of
Plaintiffs and Defendants?
(2) Whether Plaintiffs prove that they have /3rd
share each in the Suit properties as alleged?
(3)
Whether
the
Plaintiffs
prove
that
the
deceased Smt. Tulusabai had executed her
last valid Will on 24/06/1989 bequeathing
her 1/3rd share in the Suit properties in
favour of Plaintiff No.2?
(4) Whether the Defendant No.1 proves that
the claim in respect of Rs. no. 107/6 and
106/A/10B under alleged Will is hit by
Karnataka Land Reforms Act?
(5) Whether Plaintiffs are entitled for partition
and separate possession of their legitimate
shares in the Suit Properties?
(6) What Order or decree?
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
6.
Plaintiff No.1 got herself examined as PW.1 and
two witnesses were examined as PWs 2 and 3 and Exs.P1
to P6 were marked in evidence. The husband of defendant
No.1 as her PA holder was examined as DW.1 and Exs.D1 to
D4 were marked in evidence.
7.
After hearing the arguments, the trial Court held
Issue No.1 and Issue No.4 in the affirmative, remaining
issues partly in the affirmative and partly decreed the suit.
The trial Court held that the Will has been proved by the
plaintiffs and Section 21 of the Karnataka Land Reforms
Act, applies in respect of the tenancy lands and therefore,
Tulasabai could not have bequeathed her share in those
properties to non-family members. The trial Court also
holds that the Will binds only 1/3rd share of the Tulasabai in
the ancestral properties and as such, decreed the suit only
in respect of the ancestral properties.
8.
Being aggrieved by the judgment of the trial
Court, defendant No.1 approached the First Appellate Court
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
in Regular Appeal. The First Appellate Court by the
impugned judgment dismissed the appeal. A cross appeal
filed by respondent Nos.1 and 2 also came to be dismissed.
Being aggrieved, defendant No.1 is before this Court in
Second Appeal.
9.
This Court while admitting the appeal, has
framed the following substantial questions of law:
(1) Whether bequeathing of the tenanted property by
Smt. Tulasabai in favour of persons out side the "family"
as contemplated under the Karnataka Land Reforms Act,
1961 (for short "the Act") is hit by Section 21 of the Act
as amended in 1974?
(2) Whether both the courts have committed error in not
looking to the aspect of suit being for partial partition of
the property without including the joint family properties?
Arguments:
10. Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
appellant/defendant No.1 submits that the suit schedule
properties are the joint family properties of plaintiff No.1
and defendant No.1. Out of the 05 suit schedule properties,
03 were ancestral properties and 02 were the tenanted
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
lands which were under the tenancy of Laxman. He submits
that
the
executed
Will
by
Tulasabai
is
shrouded
in
suspicious circumstances. It is submitted that there are
about 06 suspicious circumstances and in fact, those
circumstances
are
not
satisfactorily
explained
by
the
plaintiff No.2. He submits that the other properties were at
Sulage village and they should have been included in the
suit schedule and as such, the suit is hit by the noninclusion of all the properties and a suit for partial partition
is not sustainable. He submits that Exs.D9 to 11 are the
records in respect of the properties situated at Sulage
Village and they are not included by the plaintiffs in the suit.
11. In
this
regard,
he
places
reliance
on
the
judgment in the cases of KAVITA KANWAR Vs. PAMELA
MEHTA1, STATE OF HARYANA VS. HARNAM SINGH
(deceased) THROUGH LRS AND OTHERS2, S.SATNAM
SINGH VS. SURINDER KAUR AND ANOTHER3 and lastly,
(2021) 11 SCC 209
(2022) 2 SCC 238
2009 AIR SCW 249
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
on SWARNALATHA AND OTHERS VS. KALAWATH AND
OTHERS4.
12. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents/plaintiffs,
contended
that
the
partition
is
ordered only in respect of three of the properties. The
tenanted lands are not part of the decree. He submits that
the Will is held to be valid and proved in accordance with
law by the trial Court as well as the First Appellate Court
and this question of fact cannot be gone into in the second
appeal. He submits that the learned counsel appearing for
the appellant has not advanced his arguments on the
substantial questions of law framed by this Court and his
main thrust
of the argument was on the Will of Tulasabai.
Therefore, he submits that the judgment of the trial Court
as well as the First Appellate Court deserve to be upheld.
13. Regarding the substantial questions of law, he
submits that those questions have been answered by the
2022 1 SCR 847
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
trial Court adequately and therefore, there is no need for
re-agitation of the same before this Court.
Analysis:
14. It is pertinent to note that apart from the two
substantial questions of law, the parties have argued the
matter at length on the proof concerning the Will executed
by Tulasabai, which is at Ex.P6. It appears that the thrust of
the argument between the parties is only in respect of the
Will executed by Tulasabai and its appreciation by the trial
Court as well as the First Appellate Court. With this
background, let me consider the contentions raised by the
parties.
Re. first substantial question of law:
15.
It is to be noted that the first substantial
question of law really was not raised by the appellant in the
appeal memo. The bequeathing of the tenanted property by
Tulasabai in favour of plaintiff No.2 and defendant Nos.2
and 3 and also the husband of the plaintiff No.1 was not
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
raised by the appellant even in the arguments also. It is
worth to note that the said question has been held by the
trial Court in favour of the appellant to the extent
properties
granted
by
the
Land
Tribunal
of the
under
the
provisions of KLR Act. The trial Court in its judgment has
placed a reliance on a judgment of this Court in the case of
R. PRAKASH VS. THE LAND TRIBUNAL, BANGALORE
SOUTH TALUK5. In the said judgment, this Court had
relied on another judgment in the case of TIMMAKKA KOM
VENKANNA NAIK VS. LAND TRIBUNAL6, wherein, this
question was dealt with and it was held that under Section
21(1) there is a bar against the subdivision or subletting of
the land held by a tenant or assignment of any interest
there under. The Court interpreted a Will as an assignment
of the rights and therefore, it held that such a bequeath in
favour of an outsider is invalid. The trial Court has rightly
relied upon the said judgments and came to the conclusion
that the properties which were under tenancy and the
1987 (2) KLJ 337
1987 SCC Online Kar 172
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
occupancy rights of which were granted to Tulasabai are not
susceptible for a bequeath under the Will of Tulasabai.
16. By holding so, it restricted the decree only in
respect of the ancestral properties i.e., the Sy.No.107/8,
107/9 and 106A/9. In fact, this finding is in favour of the
appellant and it excludes two of the suit schedule properties
from the purview of the Will. Therefore, the first substantial
question of law is redundant and it is not necessary for this
Court to delve more into that. Hence, the same is answered
in the 'affirmative'.
Re. second substantial question of law:
17. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant
submits that by way of additional grounds in the appeal
memo, the appellant has raised the question of partial
partition. He contends that the propositus Laxman and
Tulasabai had certain properties at Sulage Village and those
properties are not included in the suit. He submits that
Exs.D9 to 11 show that certain properties were standing in
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
the
name
of
Tulasabai
at
Sulage
Village
and
those
properties should have been included in the suit. Therefore,
the suit is one for partial partition and no reason is assigned
by the plaintiffs to show as to why the properties at Sulage
are not included and hence, the suit is not maintainable.
18. It is trite law that a suit for partial partition is
maintainable provided proper explanation or reasons are
assigned and it is disclosed by the plaintiffs. There cannot
be any doubt on this aspect and in a catena of judgments,
the Courts have held that a suit for partial partition is not
maintainable unless the same is proved and properly
explained.
19. A careful perusal of the written statement filed
by defendant No.1 show that there is no such ground raised
by defendant No.1 regarding partial partition. The plaint
nowhere mentions that there were any other properties at
Sulage Village and therefore, it was before the First
appellate Court that such contention was raised. Perusal of
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
the written statement of the appellant shows that no such
ground was raised and there is no whisper about the
properties that were possessed by Tulasabai at Sulage
Village. No doubt, Exs.D9 to 11 show that certain properties
did exist in the name of Tulasabai at Sulage Village. The
cross-examination of PW.1 shows that it was suggested that
there are certain properties in the name of Tulasabai at
Sulage
Village.
PW.1
in
her
cross-examination
dated
22.06.1999, in the very first paragraph, denies that there
were any such ancestral properties at Sulage Village. She
denies that Sy.No.3B/11 belonging to the father of Laxman
was there at Sulage Village. Though she admits that there
were some properties belonging to Laxman at Sulage
Village, but she do not know whether the properties are
standing in the name of Laxman at present or not.
20. It is pertinent to note that the existence of a
property at Sulage Village should have been raised by
defendant No.1 in the written statement but such a
contention was not at all raised by the defendant and as
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
such, there is no such issue concerning the question of
partial partition. Existence of ancestral property bearing
Sy.No.3B/11 was raised for the first time in the crossexamination of PW.1 on 22.06.1999. The power of Attorney
Holder of defendant No.1 contends that Sy.No. 111, 3/B/11
and 33/11 are there at Sulage Village as per Exs.D9 to 11
and these properties are not shown by the plaintiffs. This
evidence of DW.1 happens to be bereft of any support of
the pleadings. Thus, it is clear that the contention of
defendant No.1 that there were other properties belonging
to the joint family, which are not subject matter of the suit
was raised for the first time in the cross-examination of
PW.1 and in the testimony of DW.1 in his examination-inchief.
21. It is trite law that a contention if it is to be
determined in the form of an issue has to be raised by the
defendant in the pleading and on such contention, evidence
has to be led. Thus, when the written statement is totally
silent and it never whispers about any property that existed
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
in the name of Laxman or Tulasabai at Sulage Village, the
said contention in the evidence is not justified. Any
evidence cannot be considered by the Court unless there
are pleadings. Even in the cross-examination of PW.1, only
the existence of one property at Sulage Village was
suggested. Though PW.1 admits that certain properties did
exist at Sulage Village, she says that at present there are
no such properties.
22. Under these circumstances, the defence that the
suit is hit by the principles governing the partial partition
are applicable to the case on hand, cannot be sustained.
Such a contention appears to be an afterthought only.
When the PW.1 entered the witness box, nothing prevented
defendant No.1 to raise such a contention by way of an
amendment to the written statement and also by seeking
framing of an additional issue. Under these circumstances, a
contention which is bereft of any pleading cannot be raised
at a subsequent stage and raise the said aspect in a second
appeal. The appellant is trying to build her case without a
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
foundation. Hence, at any stretch of imagination, it cannot
be held that the suit is hit by the principles governing the
law regarding partial partition.
23. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
raised the question as to whether the evidence regarding
the Will has been properly appreciated by the Courts below
or not.
24. A perusal of the judgment of the First Appellate
Court shows that it did not appreciate the evidence on
record afresh. It squarely relied on the appreciation of the
evidence made by the trial Court and holds that such
appreciation is proper and correct. Such approach of the
First Appellate Court regarding the appreciation of the
evidence concerning a Will is not in accordance with the
requirements of law, where the First Appellate Court was
bound to re-appreciate the evidence and then consider the
reasons assigned by the trial Court.
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
25. Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
appellant/defendant No.1 contends the following suspicious
circumstances which render the Will executed by Tulasabai
at Ex.P6 is invalid,
(a) He contends that Tulasabai has disinherited
defendant No.1 and therefore, it is one of the
suspicious circumstances.
(b) He raises the contention of active participation
of defendant No.1 who is beneficiary under the Will
and therefore, it is suspicious. He points out that
PW.2 said that after execution they went to the
office of the Sub-Registrar and even PW.2 and
other witnesses is suspicious.
(c) The witness advocate T.Y. Honagekar signed
the Will on 27.06.1989 but the Will was signed by
the Testatrix on 24.06.1989. He points out that it
was presented for registration before the SubRegistrar on 27.06.1989.
(d) Consequently, the endorsement of the Medical
Officer
Dr.M.S.Pushalkar
25.06.1989.
bears
the
date
as
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
(e) He contends
the presence of PW.1, the
legatee under the said Will at the time of the
execution
of
participated
the
show
Will
regarding
that
execution
he
of
actively
the
Will.
Therefore, on above grounds, it is submitted that
the Will is full of suspicious circumstances and the
provisions and the Sub-Registrar had not followed
Rule No.73(1) of the Registration Rules.
26. A perusal of the impugned judgment of Trial
Court would show that it considers the evidence concerning
the Will at length in paragraph No.16 onwards. It comes to
the
conclusion
that
there
are
no
such
suspicious
circumstances and the witnesses are deposing after lapse of
more than 10 years and therefore, minor discrepancies in
the testimonies are quite possible and as such, the Will has
been proved by the propounder of the Will i.e., the plaintiff
No.1.
27. Regarding
the
first
suspicious
circumstance
raised by the learned counsel for the appellant, the trial
Court holds that Tulasabai had not disinherited anybody
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
under the Will. It is pointed out that Tulasabai had
bequeathed only her 1/3rd share in the suit schedule
properties in favour of plaintiff No.2 and defendant Nos.2
and 3 and she had bequeathed her self acquired property in
favour of the husband of plaintiff No.1. He points out that
the remaining property in which defendant No.1 had a share
remained with her and it was only the one third share of the
Tulasabai, which was subject matter of the Will. Therefore,
the trial Court holds that there is no such disinheritance of
the properties by virtue of the Will. It was her undivided
share in the property which was bequeathed to plaintiff
Nos.2 and 3.
28. The trial Court appreciates the evidence of PW.2
and PW.3 and considers their evidence at length. In
paragraph No.17, the trial Court notices that the testimony
of the witnesses have to be considered in the light of what
they have stated before the Court after 10 years. It notices
that PW.2 and PW.3 state that the writing of the Will,
execution and registration had taken place on one day. But
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
on
the
other
hand,
Ex.P6
Will
shows
otherwise.
In
paragraph No.18, the trial Court considers the discrepancy
concerning the dates of execution, registration and the
endorsement by the Medical Officer in detail and it holds
that it is a natural human error under which PW.2 and 3
have spoken that they went for registration on the same
day.
29. The perusal of the testimony of PW.2 Narayan
Yallappa Yadakavi shows that he was one of the attesting
witnesses to the Will. He says that he went to the place of
the bond writer at the instance of the Testatrix and after it
was written,
Tulasabai put her thumb impression after
admitting the contents of the Will and thereafter, he and
the other witness Jakappa and the advocate T.Y. Honagekar
put their signatures and then they went to the SubRegistrar's Office. In the cross-examination, nothing worth
is elicited which would discredit the testimony of this
witness. It is elicited that it was at about 01.00 p.m. and
the Will was written in his presence. The testimony of PW.3
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
Prakash Shivaram Shinde shows that he is a bond writer
and he states that he wrote the Will as requested by the
Testatrix. He states that after writing the same he read over
the contents of the Will to Tulasabai and she has put her
thumb impression in his presence after admitting the
contents and all the witnesses also put their signatures in
his
presence.
In
the
cross-examination,
there
is
a
suggestion to the effect that as per the instructions of
Tulasabai, he had written the Will. There is also a
suggestion that as per the instructions of the Tulasabai, he
wrote the Will. This suggestion to PW.2 shows that PW.3
wrote the Will, at the instance of Tulasabai. There is nothing
which is elicited about the dates borne out of the Ex.P6.
30.
The learned counsel appearing for the appellant
has placed reliance on the judgment in the case of Kavita
Kanwar v. Pamela Mehta and others (referred supra). In
the said case, the Apex Court observed that when the trial
Court has written the findings against the appellant after
fresh appreciation of the evidence and the High Court had
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
affirmed such findings, it is not open for the Apex Court to
go into re-appreciation of evidence again. It was also
noticed that when there was no dispute about testamentary
capacity and soundness of the mind of the Testatrix, the
execution having been proved, the other minor suspicious
circumstances as stated in para 27 of the said judgment
cannot come in the way.
31.
It is pertinent to note that the judgment of this
Court in the case of Sri J.T. Surappa & Another Vs. Sri
Satchidhanandendra Saraswathi Swamiji Public Charitable
Trust & Others7 lay down the five steps in the inquiry that
is to be conducted by the Court concerning a Will. The Court
termed those five steps as 'panchapadi'. If we apply the
principles laid down therein, it is evident that the trial Court
has done this exercise exhaustively and it has come to the
right conclusion.
2008 ILR KAR 2115
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
32.
So also the judgment of the Apex Court in the
case of H. Venkatachala Iyengar v. B.N. Timmajamma8
is a judgment which acts as a beacon and lays down the
principles on which a Will has to be appreciated. Therefore,
the other judgments relied by the learned counsel for the
appellant can very well be distinguished in view of the facts
involved in those cases and other different circumstances
which pose as the suspicious circumstances.
33.
A perusal of the Will at Exhibit P6 would show
that the Will is written in Marathi and the Thumb impression
of the Testatrix may be found in page No.4. The Will is
signed by the witnesses Jakappa and PW2. It is also signed
by
Advocate
T.Y.
Honagekar
on
27.06.1989.
The
endorsement of the Doctor may be found at page No.5,
wherein it is stated that Tulasabai Lakshmana Patil is
physically and mentally fit to sign i.e., to give her thumb
impression. It is evident that the document was presented
for registration on 27.06.1989. It may be noted that
AIR 1959 SC 443
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
execution is on 24.06.1989, signed by the Medical Officer
on 25.06.1989 and it was presented for registration on
27.06.1989. The Sub-Registrar has endorsed that the Will
was presented for registration by none else than Tulasabai
herself and she admitted the execution of it on 24.06.1989
itself. In the above circumstances, it may be gathered that
the Will was executed by the Testatrix on 24.06.1989 in the
presence of the two witnesses and it was endorsed by the
Medical Officer on 25.06.1989 and thereafter, it was
presented for registration on 27.06.1989 on which day the
advocate T.Y. Honagekar also signed the said Will. There
was no necessity for the advocate T.Y. Honagekar to sign
the said Will, but it is not known why he also signed it. It
may be true that he assisted the said Tulasabai to present
the said Will for registration before the Sub Registrar. This
aspect has been considered by the trial Court in detail in
para 18 and it holds that when the witnesses are speaking
about the execution of the Will after nearly about 10 years,
it is quite natural that the dates may not have been
- 32 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
correctly stated by them. It holds that the Execution of the
Will by Tulasabai on 24.06.1989 is categorically spoken by
PW2 in his deposition. It notices that PW3, the scribe has
been suggested that the Will was written at the instructions
of Tulasabai and insofar as the presence of the beneficiary
at the time of the execution of the Will is concerned, the
testimony of PW2 show that when he went as per the
instructions of Tulasabai to the place of the bond writer, the
said Tulasabai, plaintiff No.1 and the stamp vendor i. e.,
Prakash were present. There is nothing in the crossexamination which would show that
plaintiff No.1 had
taken active participation in the same. It may also be noted
that in the Will itself it is mentioned that it is the plaintiff
No.1 and her husband were looking after the Testatrix.
Therefore, the presence of plaintiff No.1 at the time of the
execution cannot be inferred to be a factor which would
negate the execution of the Will out of the uninfluenced
volition of the Testatrix. It is pertinent to note that the
cross-examination of PW3 does not mention anything about
- 33 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
the presence of plaintiff No.1 except the one sentence in the
cross-examination of PW1, where she admits that plaintiff
No. 1 was present, nothing is available to show that plaintiff
had influenced the Testatrix in writing the Will and his
participation was active. Above aspects would show that
except the presence of PW1 at the time of the Will as stated
by PW2 and the discrepancy about the date on which the
execution took place, date when medical officer examined
and when it was presented for registration, there is nothing
else which raises any doubt. It is pertinent to note that the
appreciation of the evidence in a particular manner by the
trial Court has to be respected. The Appellate Courts cannot
replace their own views at the place of the views of the trial
Court. The judgment of the Apex Court in the case of
Santosh Hazari Vs. Purushotham Tiwari
dead by
LRs.,9 lays down and observes that the appreciation of the
evidence shall be on the same lines as is done by the trial
Court and only if the trial Court has gone perverse or
(2001)3 SCC 179
- 34 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
arbitrary, then the Appellate Court can interfere. The
traversing of the evidence of the witnesses and other
traversing of the evidence on record has to be done as is
done by the trial Court and then the discrepancy has to be
pointed out. It is pertinent to note that the trial Court had
the advantage of seeing the demanor of the witnesses and
therefore, such appreciation by the trial Court stands on a
higher footing than that of the Appellate Court. Therefore,
the appreciation of the evidence by the trial Court in respect
of the Will at Exhibit P6 cannot be replaced for a simple
reason that another construction is possible. Under these
circumstances, the exhaustive and detailed appreciation of
the evidence on record by the trial Court cannot be found
fault with. The trial Court in para 22 observes that the Will
insofar as it relates to the tenanted properties cannot hold
good, as it is hit by the provisions of Section 21(1) of the
Karnataka Land Reforms Act. Insofar as the ancestral
properties
are
concerned,
the
Will
is
binding.
After
observing so the trial Court culls out its entire finding in
- 35 NC: 2026:KHC-D:787
RSA No. 3126 of 2007
HC-KAR
para 22 of the impugned judgment, which cannot be found
fault with. The second substantial question of law is
answered accordingly.
34.
In the result,
the substantial questions of law
and other contentions having been dealt with, the appeal is
bereft of any merits and as such, the same deserves to be
dismissed. Hence, the following:
ORDER
The appeal is dismissed.
Sd/(C M JOSHI)
JUDGE
tsn*
List No.: 19 Sl No.: 3
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review