The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. For the reasons aforesaid, I find no merit in the instant second appeal. Concurrent finding recorded by the courts below is fully justified by the evidence on record. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed. Consequently, interim order, if any passed earlier, stands vacated. Decree be drawn accordingly. Parties shall bear their own costs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ARUN KUMAR SHARMA
SECOND APPEAL No. 1735 of 2017
BETWEEN:1.
SMT. SHAKUNTALA W/O. LATE SHRI
BALKISHAN MUNDA, AGED ABOUT 52
YEARS.
2.
VIKRAM S/O. LATE SHIR BALKISHAN
MUNDA, AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS,
BOTH ARE RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
CHAUPRAKHURD,
JABALPUR
NAKA,
DISTRICT DAMOH (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
(BY SHRI ABHIJEET AWASTHI - ADVOCATE )
AND
1.
SMT. KAMARJAHAN W/O. ASGAR
KHAN (DEAD), THROUGH LRs:(A) KASIM KHAN S/O. ASGAR ALI
ALI
(B) AZAM KAHN S/O. ASGAR ALI
(C) ASLAM KHAN S/O. ASGAR ALI
(D) NAGMA D/O. ASGAR ALI
ALL ARE RESIDENT OF VILLAGE – AAM
CHAUPRA, DISTRICT DAMOH (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
THE STAE OF MADHYA PRADESH,
THROUGH THE COLLECTOR DAMOH
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(NONE FOR THE RESPONDENTS )
Signed by: JITENDRA
KUMAR PAROUHA
Signing time: 7/25/2023
6:14:36 PM
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Reserved on
: 17-07-2023
Pronounced on : 25 -07-2023
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This appeal having been heard and reserved for order, coming on for
pronouncement this day, the court pronounced the following :
JUDGMENT
The appellants as plaintiffs have preferred present Second Appeal under
Section 100 of C.P.C. being aggrieved and dissatisfied by the judgment and
decree dated 21.8.2017 passed by Second Additional District Judge, Damoh
(MP) in Civil Appeal No. 114/17, whereby the judgment and decree passed by
the trial court has been affirmed.
2.
The relevant facts leading to the filing of this appeal as emerging from
the case made out by the appellants are narrated in a nutshell for a better
understanding and determination of the disputes between the parties are that the
plaintiffs as appellants presented the suit for permanent injunction to restrain the
respondents/defendants from interfering with the peaceful possession of them
over Khasra No. 62/7 situated at Village Choupara Khurd, Tahsil and District
Damoh. The facts which are undisputed between the parties are that the
consolidated Khasra No. 62/5 (hereinafter to be referred as ‘suit property’) was
owned by late Mohan Munda, who was survived by his two sons namely
Karelal and Balkishan. Subsequently upon death of Mohan Munda, the land
bearing Khasra No. 62/5 was recorded jointly in the name of Karelal, Balkishan
and their mother Smt. Puttri Bai. Although during the lifetime of Putri Bai and
Balkishan, they executed a sale deed to transfer 2/3 rd of their share in favour of
Signed by: JITENDRA
KUMAR PAROUHA
Signing time: 7/25/2023
6:14:36 PM
Karella. Subsequently, Karelal sold 4.60 acres of the land in his possession to
Balkishan, which led to creation of Khasra No. 62/6; whereas Khasra No. 62/5
remained in the name of Karelal. So far as Khasra No. 62/7 is concerned, the
same was jointly recorded in the name of Karelal and Balishan. After the death
of Balkishan, the name of appellant/plaintiff was recorded as legal heir of
Balkishan. So far as Khasra Nos. 62/5 and 62/6 are concerned, there is no
dispute between the parties. However, the parties are at logger heads with
respect to Khasra No. 62/7 admeasuring 2.79 acres. The portion of the land,
which was in possession of Karelal has already been sold out by him. However,
in order to create controversy in relation to the portion owned and occupied by
the plaintiff, there is controversy as Karelal in collussion with Revenue Officers
proceeded to include the portion of Khasra No.62/7 into Khasra No. 62/5 in
order to facilitate the transfer of property adverse to the plaintiff. Karelal
executed sale deed in the name of Sardar Darshan Singh for transferring portion
of Khasra No. 62/5; whereas the entire Khasra No. 62/5 was already sold by
Karelal and it is portion belonging to plaintiff, which was being transferred. Due
to execution of sale deed in favour of Sardar Darshan Singh, the revenue
authorities created Khasra No. 62/160. Accordingly, the plaintiffs went up to the
Board of Revenue to get this order set aside. Such application of the plaintiff
was allowed by Board of Revenue; vide order dated 23/04/1993. (Ex. P/1).
Despite of such order, the Revenue Authorities did not correct the record, which
resulted into execution of sale deed for Khasra No. 62/160 in favour of
respondents /defendants. Thereafter, the defendants tried to take forceful
possession of the land occupied by the plaintiffs. Accordingly, a suit for
permanent injunction as filed due to cause of action which arose on 04/10/2011.
3.
The original defendant Smt. Kamarjahan filed her written statement
denying the plaint allegations and stated that Mohan Munda in his life time had
sold some part of his land Khasra No. 62/5 Rakba 13.69 acre and on this land
Signed by: JITENDRA
KUMAR PAROUHA
Signing time: 7/25/2023
6:14:36 PM
only the house of Karelal, Balkishan and others were constructed and road is
also constructed on this land and Khasra No. 62/7 Rakba 2.79 acre is also made
out from Khasra No. 62/5 and presently there is no open land is available. The
respondent /defendant No.1 produced DW/7 Mohd. Saleem, who claimed that
he was revenue inspector in the year 1981 to 1985 and thereafter 1987 to 1990
at Damoh and he had done the demarcation of the land copies were given to
Karelal, Balkishan and one copy has submitted in the Tahsil Court. He has
further stated that there is no land remains in Khara No. 62/7 because Mohan
Munda earlier sold so many lands to different persons. However, during crossexamination, he admitted that there is no record of demarcation is available in
Tahsil and the demarcation Panchnama also does not contain the signature of
Balkishan and Putti Bai as well as Karelal. He has also not produced any sale
deed executed by Mohan Munda. He has also admitted that he has already
retired long back.
4.
Learned trial court having heard learned counsel for the parties and on the
strength of the material and evidence on record has dismissed the suit filed by
the plaintiffs vide judgment and decree dated 22.12.2016. Being aggrieved, the
appellants preferred first appeal before the lower appellate court which was also
dismissed.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellants has argued before this Court that
learned both the courts have committed an error by not appreciating that the
revenue records categorically reflects that Khasra No. 62/7 Rakba 2.79 acre and
order of SDO for merger the Khasra No. 62/7 into 62/5 was also set aside by
learned Revenue Board on 24/03/1993. Learned both the courts below have
erroneously given the findings that there is no land remains in Khara No. 62/7
on the basis of evidence of DW/7 Mohd. Saleem, Retired Revenue Inspector,
who admitted in the cross-examination that he did not bring any records and the
report of demarcation also not contain the signature of appellants father
Signed by: JITENDRA
KUMAR PAROUHA
Signing time: 7/25/2023
6:14:36 PM
Balkishan and Karelal. He has also not produced any document in order to
substantiate his statement that Mohan Munda sold this land to so many persons.
Learned lower courts have committed an error by not appreciating the facts that
the Board of Revenue set-aside the order of SDO and given the finding that the
mutation of Sardar Darshan Singh is also illegal and the learned Board also
diluted the new created Khasra No. 62/160. Learned lower courts have
committed error by not appreciating that Karelal had sold the land to the
respondent No.1-Smt. Kamar Jahan from the Khasra No. 62/5 and he is trying
to interfere in the peaceful possession of Khasra No. 62/7, which belongs to
appellant and respondent No.1 has no relation on the land bearing Khasra No.
62/7. Learned lower courts ought to have considered that the respondent No.1
has executed the sale deed from Sardar Darshan Singh of Khasra No. 62/160,
the mutation of Sardar Darshan Singh in Khasra No. 62/5 and existence of
Khasra No. 62/160 was set aside or diluted by learned Board of Revenue by
order dated 23/04/2023 and the same was not challenged by any party, it attains
finality so there is no prima facie right of respondent No.1 to interfere in the
peaceful possession of appellant on her Khasra No. 62/7. Hence, prayed that
the present appeal be allowed by setting the impugned judgments and decree
passed by learned both the courts below.
6.
None appeared on behalf of the respondents.
7.
I have bestowed my anxious consideration on contentions raised by
learned counsel for the appellants and perused the record and the judgments of
both the courts below.
8.
This Second appeal has been admitted vide order of this court dated
13.12.2017 on the following Substantial Question of law : -
Signed by: JITENDRA
KUMAR PAROUHA
Signing time: 7/25/2023
6:14:36 PM
“Whether both the Courts below are justified in
giving the findings contrary to the revenue which
has also been affirmed by the Board of Revenue ?”
9.
Learned trial Court has framed issues no. 1 and 2 relating to Khasra no.
62/7 having new number 62/7 to the effect that whether defendant no. 1 is in
illegal possession of the land of the plaintiffs of this Khasra number. The trial
court has not found the issues proved and accordingly disproved. Learned lower
appellate Court in its paragraphs no. 19 and 21 of the judgment has discussed
this and has affirmed the finding of the trial Court. Learned lower appellate
court has discussed the evidence of plaintiff Shakuntala and has held that
plaintiff Shakuntala could not establish by her evidence that at the time of filing
of the suit for permanent injunction how much land remained in Khasra no.
62/7. Learned lower appellate court further in para 21 while discussing the
evidence of Smt. Neelam Yadav (PW-2) has held that she too has failed to
establish whether plaintiff Shakuntala was in possession of the suit land bearing
Khasra no. 62/7. She also could not throw any light how much land of Khasra
no. 62/7 remained. Per contra, the defendants in their evidence have established
that they had purchased the land from Khasra no. 62/5 not from Khasra no. 62/7
and after purchasing the land from Khasra no. 62/5 new number 62/160 (ka)
came into existence. The finding given by both the courts below are finding of
fact. The courts below by elaborate evidence have given their findings that the
plaintiffs have failed to establish what was the total area of Khasra no. 62/7
remained at the time of filing of the suit and whom the land was sold. It is
settled law that the concurrent finding given by the courts below cannot be
interfered with by this Court under Section 100 of CPC. The question of law is
not a substantial question of law because the finding given by the Revenue
Board, is not binding on the Civil Court even otherwise the finding given by
any other Court is to be seen on the basis of the evidence led in that case. The
Signed by: JITENDRA
KUMAR PAROUHA
Signing time: 7/25/2023
6:14:36 PM
finding given by one court cannot operate and bind on other Court. The finding
given by the Revenue Court/ Board cannot bind the Civil Court. Therefore, no
substantial question of law is made out in this case.
10.
In (1999) 3 SCC 722 titled Kondiba Dagadu Kadam Vs. Savitribai
Sopan Gujar and others, Hon’ble Supreme Court held that it is not within the
domain of the High Court to investigate the grounds on which the findings were
arrived at by the last Court of fact being the first appellate Court. In a case
where from a given set of circumstances two inferences are possible, one drawn
by the lower appellate court is binding on the High Court in second appeal,
unless it is found that the conclusions drawn by the lower appellate court were
erroneous being contrary to the mandatory provisions of applicable law or
contrary to the law as pronounced by the apex court or was based upon
inadmissible evidence or arrived at without evidence. The above was reiterated
in (2019) 6 SCC 46 titled S. Subramanian vs. S. Ramasamy and others,
wherein it was inter-alia held that High court is not required to re-appreciate the
entire evidence on record and to come to its own finding when the findings
recorded by the Courts below, more particularly the first appellate court are on
appreciation of evidence. Similar view has also been adopted in 2012 (2) Shim.
LC 869, titled Maro (dead) through L.R. Paramjeet Kaur (Smt.) wife of
Shri Om Prakash vs. Khillo wife of Tirath Ram.
11.
From perusal of the record, it is found that there are concurrent findings
of the Courts below against the appellants. This Court would not examine
correctness of findings of facts in exercise of appellate Power in Second Appeal.
Since this Court does not find any the impugned decisions are not being
contrary to law or that decision having failed to determine some material issue
of law. Further that this Court does not find any substantial error or defect in
procedure provided by the Court or any other law for the time being in force,
Signed by: JITENDRA
KUMAR PAROUHA
Signing time: 7/25/2023
6:14:36 PM
which may possibly have produced error or defect in the decision of the case
upon the merit.
12.
In respect of exercise of jurisdiction under Section 100 of Code of Civil
Procedure, Hon’ble Apex Court in Gurnam Singh vs. Lehna Singh, reported
in (2019) 7 SCC 641 held as under :"13.1. The existence of a substantial question of law is a sine
qua non for the exercise of the jurisdiction under Section
100 of the CPC. As observed and held by this Court in the
case of Kondiba Dagadu Kadam (Supra), in a second appeal
under Section 100 of the CPC, the High Court cannot
substitute its own opinion for that of the First Appellate
Court, unless it finds that the conclusions drawn by the
lower Court were erroneous being: (i) Contrary to the
mandatory provisions of the applicable law; OR (ii)
Contrary to the law as pronounced by the Apex Court; OR
(iii) Based on inadmissible evidence or no evidence. It is
further observed by this Court in the aforesaid decision that
if First Appellate Court has exercised its discretion in a
judicial manner, its decision cannot be recorded as suffering
from an error either of law or of procedure requiring
interference in second appeal. It is further observed that the
Trial Court could have decided differently is not a question
of law justifying interference in second appeal.
13.
From perusal of the record, I find that the judgments and decree passed
by the Courts below are well reasoned and passed after due appreciation of oral
as well as documentary evidence on record. The learned counsel for the
appellants has failed to show that how the findings of facts recorded by the
Signed by: JITENDRA
KUMAR PAROUHA
Signing time: 7/25/2023
6:14:36 PM
Courts below are illegal, perverse and based on no evidence. Learned both the
courts below have legally and rightly dealt with the issue involved in the matter
with regard to the property in dispute.
14.
It is not out of place to mention here that the appellants having lost in
both the courts below have filed the present second appeal. The Supreme Court
taking into consideration the principles of law in the cases of Thiagarajan v.
Sri Venugopalaswamy B. Koil [(2004) 5 SCC 762], Commissioner, Hindu
Religious & Charitable Endowments v. P. Shanmugama [(2005) 9 SCC
232], State of Kerala v. Mohd. Kunhi [(2005) 10 SCC 139] and Madhavan
Nair v. Bhaskar Pillai [(2005) 10 SCC 553], has observed that the High Court
has no jurisdiction in second appeal to interfere with the findings of fact.
Recently, in another judgment reported as State of Rajasthan vs. Shiv Dayal
(2019) 8 SCC 637, it has been held that a concurrent finding of the fact is
binding, unless it is pointed out that it was recorded de-hors the pleadings or it
was based on no evidence or based on misreading of the material on records and
documents.
15.
For the reasons aforesaid, I find no merit in the instant second appeal.
Concurrent finding recorded by the courts below is fully justified by the
evidence on record. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed. Consequently, interim
order, if any passed earlier, stands vacated. Decree be drawn accordingly.
Parties shall bear their own costs.
16.
A copy of this order along with record be sent back to the courts below
for information and its compliance.
(ARUN KUMAR SHARMA)
JUDGE
JP/-
Signed by: JITENDRA
KUMAR PAROUHA
Signing time: 7/25/2023
6:14:36 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review