Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
1. S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 17462/2025
Smt. Shabbo W/o Shri Abdul Rahim, R/o Near Rasid Bhai Paper
Wala, Kishorepura, Kota (Raj.)
----Petitioner
Versus
M/s. Sajni Mehndi Product, Owner / Proprietor Mohammed Yusuf
R/o Near Mohammed Yusuf Idgah, Kishorepura, Ward No. 33,
Sanjay Basti, Kota (Raj.)
----Respondent
Connected With
2. S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 17461/2025
Smt. Shabbo W/o Shri Abdul Rahim, Resident Of Near Rasid Bhai
Paper Wala, Kishorepura, Kota (Raj).
----Petitioner
Versus
M/s. Sajni Mehndi Product Owner/proprietor Mohammed Yusuf,
Resident Of Near Mohammed Yusuf Idgah, Kishorepura, Ward
No.33, Sanjay Basti, Kota (Raj).
----Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Shailesh Prakash Sharma with
Mr. Manan Sharma
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Sandeep Pathak with
Ms. Shefali Sharma
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANUROOP SINGHI
Order
REPORTABLE
27/01/2026
1.
The present writ petition(s) being S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.
17462/2025 has been filed assailing the order dated 04.10.2025
and S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 17461/2025 has been filed
assailing the order dated 16.10.2025, and as both the said
(2 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
impugned orders were passed by the learned Commercial Court,
Kota
(Raj.)
in
pending
Civil
Suit
No.
54/2023
(CNR
No.
RJKT1D0003732023) titled as M/s. Sajni Mehndi Product vs. Smt.
Shabbo, with the consent of learned counsel for the parties, both
the writ petitions are being heard together and are being decided
by this order.
FACTUAL MATRIX
2.
Facts leading to filing of these writ petitions are that the
respondent/non-applicant/plaintiff filed a civil suit against the
petitioner/applicant/defendant for infringement and passing off of
trademark, permanent injunction, damages and rendition of
accounts. Along with the plaint, an application for temporary
injunction was also filed.
3.
On 18.05.2023, the petitioner/applicant/defendant filed an
application under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 (hereinafter referred to as ‘CPC’) seeking rejection of plaint,
wherein, a specific objection with respect to the maintainability of
the abovementioned suit and the same being barred by law on
account of non-compliance with the mandatory provision of
Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the Act of 2015’) was raised. The said application
under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, along with another application dated
07.07.2023, both were dismissed by the learned Commercial
Court vide a common order dated 12.01.2024.
4.
Being aggrieved by both the orders dated 12.01.2024, the
petitioner/applicant/defendant approached this Court by filing S.B.
Civil Writ Petition Nos. 1991/2024 and 6223/2024 which came to
be disposed of vide a common order dated 05.12.2024, vide which
(3 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
the petitioner/applicant/defendant was granted liberty to make a
prayer before the learned Commercial Court for framing an issue
as to what is the effect of non-adherence of mandatory provision
of Section 12A of the Commercial Court Act by the plaintiff on the
present suit. Taking basis of the said order, an application was
filed by the petitioner/applicant/defendant for framing of the said
issue which was dismissed by the learned Commercial Court.
5.
Aggrieved
by
the
said
dismissal,
the
petitioner/applicant/defendant again knocked the doors of this
Court by filing S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 2545/2025, wherein, this
Court while taking note of the facts and by referring to the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Patil
Automation
Private
Limited
and
Others
v.
Rakheja
Engineers Private Limited reported in (2022) 10 SCC 1,
directed to frame the issue “As to what is the effect of nonadherence
of
mandatory
provision
of
Section
12A
of
the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 by the plaintiff on the present suit?”,
and further directed to consider and decide the said issue as a
preliminary issue after hearing both the parties with respect to the
effect of non-compliance of Section 12A of the Act of 2015.
6.
In compliance thereof, the Commercial Court on 12.05.2025
framed the above mentioned issue as preliminary issue No. 1-A.
Thereafter, the petitioner/applicant/defendant filed an application
dated 10.09.2025
for determining burden
of proof of the
respective parties and for seeking directions to lead evidence for
adjudication of the said preliminary issue No.1-A. Learned
Commercial Court vide its order dated 04.10.2025, rejected the
said application by holding that as the issue pertaining to effect of
(4 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
provision of Section 12A of the Act of 2015 is an issue of law,
there is no necessity to lead evidence for adjudication of the
same. Against the said order dated 04.10.2025, S.B. Civil Writ
Petition
No.
17462/2025
has
been
filed
by
the
petitioner/applicant/defendant.
7.
Subsequently, the Commercial Court proceeded to decide the
preliminary Issue No. 1-A and vide order dated 16.10.2025 held
that since a prayer for interim relief had been made by the
respondent/non-applicant/plaintiff, the provision of Section 12A of
the Act of 2015 would not be applicable to the present suit and its
non-compliance would have no bearing on the case, which has led
to filing of the present S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 17461/2025 by
the petitioner/applicant/defendant.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF PETITIONER
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner/applicant/defendant, Mr.
Shailesh Prakash Sharma,
vehemently submits that by passing
the impugned order dated 04.10.2025, so also the order dated
16.10.2025, the learned Commercial Court has miserably failed to
consider and adhere to the directions issued by this Court in its
orders dated 05.12.2024 (passed in S.B. Civil Writ Petition
No.1991/2024 and S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.6223/2024) and
18.02.2025 (passed in S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.2545/2025).
Learned counsel submits that in both the said orders, a specific
direction was issued to the learned Commercial Court to frame an
issue with respect to the non-compliance of provision of Section
12A of the Act of 2015.
9.
Learned counsel submits that this Court further went ahead
to mandate that the learned Commercial Court was required to
(5 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
consider and decide the same as a preliminary issue after hearing
both the parties. In light of the fact that a specific direction was
issued by this Court, the learned Commercial Court was left with
no option but to decide the said preliminary issue after leading
evidence, which undisputedly in the present case, it has failed to
do and this very fact by itself makes the impugned orders dated
04.10.2025 and 16.10.2025 bad in law.
10.
Learned counsel for the petitioner/applicant/defendant also
argues that the prayer for interim relief as sought by the
respondent/non-applicant/plaintiff in its application for temporary
injunction is merely a camouflage and an exercise to avoid
applicability of Section 12A of the Act of 2015, which, if permitted,
would certainly defeat the object of the mediation proceedings as
required to be carried out by adhering to the provision of Section
12A of the Act of 2015. Thus, it is prayed that the impugned
orders dated 04.10.2025, so also, dated 16.10.2025 be set aside
and the issue with respect to the effect of non-adherence of the
mandatory provision of the Act of 2015 be duly considered and
decided afresh as a preliminary issue after leading evidence for
the same and consequently, the present writ petition(s) be
allowed.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT
11.
E-converso, Mr. Sandeep Pathak, learned counsel for the
respondent/non-applicant/plaintiff submits that the orders dated
04.10.2025
and
16.10.2025
have
been
passed
after
due
consideration of the provision of Section 12A of the Act of 2015.
Learned
counsel
submits
that
once
an
application
seeking
temporary injunction has been filed along with the plaint, the
(6 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
applicability of the Section 12A of the Act of 2015 is not attracted,
as is evident from a bare perusal of Section 12A of the Act of 2015
which specifically provides that it is only when a suit does not
contemplate any urgent interim relief, then it cannot be instituted
without exhausting the remedy of pre-institution mediation, but
since in the case in hand an urgent interim relief has already been
prayed for by filing an application seeking temporary injunction
along with the civil suit, the said provision is not applicable.
12.
Learned counsel further submits that the issue with respect
to the applicability or non-applicability of Section 12A of the Act of
2015 is no more res integra in view of the recent pronouncement
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Novenco Building
And
Industry
A/S.
Versus
Xero
Energy
Engineering
Solutions Private Ltd. & Anr. reported in 2025 SCC Online SC
2278, wherein it has been held that mere delay in institution of a
suit by itself does not negate urgency when the infringement is
continuous
and
undisputedly
in
respondent/non-applicant/plaintiff
the
has
present
prayed
for
case,
an
the
urgent
interim relief on the ground of continuing infringement being
made by petitioner/applicant/defendant.
13.
Learned counsel submits that a bare perusal of the orders
dated 04.10.2025 and 16.10.2025 reveals that the directions as
issued by this Court in its order dated 05.12.2024 and 18.02.2025
have
been
duly
considered
and
followed
by
the
learned
Commercial Court while passing both the orders under challenge.
The order dated 16.10.2025 records a specific finding that mere
delay in filing the civil suit alongwith an application for temporary
injunction cannot result into an interpretation that no urgent
(7 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
interim relief is contemplated, and thus, merely on the said
ground, it cannot be said that provision of Section 12A of the Act
of 2015 is applicable, and the said finding recorded by the learned
Commercial Court deserves no interference.
14.
Learned counsel for the respondent/non-applicant/plaintiff
also submits that as the objection qua the applicability of Section
12A of the Act of 2015 was raised in the application filed by the
petitioner/applicant/defendant under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the
adjudication of such objection under no circumstances can travel
beyond the plaint and the interpretation as given by the
petitioner/applicant/defendant to the earlier orders of this Court is
in teeth with the settled principle of law.
15.
Lastly,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
respondent/non-
applicant/plaintiff submits that the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Novenco Building (supra) has
reversed the finding recorded by the Hon’ble High Court of
Himachal Pradesh in Novenco Building & Industry A/S Versus
Xero Energy Engineering Solutions Private Limited and
Another reported in 2024 SCC OnLine HP 5795, which was
relied
upon
by
the
learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner/applicant/defendant in the written submissions filed by
him before the learned Commercial Court, and thus, the very
basis of the submissions so made by the learned counsel for the
petitioner/applicant/defendant falls flat. Thus, it is prayed that
both the writ petitions deserve to be dismissed.
(8 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
16.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the record
and also the judgments relied upon.
17.
The sum and substance of the challenge raised in the writ
petitions is that the objection qua the applicability of Section 12A
of the Act of 2015 in the application filed under Order VII Rule 11
CPC should have been adjudicated by the learned Commercial
Court after framing an issue qua the same and hearing both the
parties, which would necessarily mean that the said issue was
required to be decided by the learned Commercial Court only after
leading evidence and not in the manner as has been done by the
learned Commercial Court. If the said argument made by learned
counsel for the petitioner/applicant/defendant is accepted as it is,
it would result in a situation wherein for adjudication of an
application filed by the petitioner/applicant/defendant under Order
VII Rule 11 CPC, leading of evidence would be required, which in
the considered opinion of this Court is absolutely contrary and
against the law as laid down in a series of judgments by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, wherein, in unequivocal terms it has been
so held that for the purpose of consideration and adjudication of
an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, it is the plaint alone
which has to be considered and nothing beyond that. Reliance is
placed upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case
of
Eldeco
Housing
and
Industries
versus
Ashok
Vidharthi And Others reported in 2024 (11) SCC 503, wherein
it has been held that for deciding an application under Order VII
Rule 11 CPC, only the averments in the plaint would be relevant
(9 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
and no amount of evidence can be looked into. Relevant paras 1618 and 25 of the said judgment reads as under:
“ 16. In Kamala v. K.T. Eshwara Sa [(2008) 12
SCC 661], this Court opined that for invoking
clause (d) of Order 7 Rule 11CPC, only the
averments in the plaint would be relevant. For this
purpose,
there
cannot
be
any
addition
or
subtraction. No amount of evidence can be looked
into. The issue on merits of the matter would not
be within the realm of the Court at that stage. The
Court
at
that
stage
would
not
consider
any
evidence or enter a disputed question of fact of
law. Relevant paragraphs thereof are extracted
below: (SCC pp. 668-69, paras 21-25)
“21. Order 7 Rule 11(d) of the Code has
limited application. It must be shown that the
suit is barred under any law. Such a conclusion
must be drawn from the averments made in the
plaint. Different clauses in Order 7 Rule 11, in
our opinion, should not be mixed up. Whereas
in a given case, an application for rejection of
the plaint may be filed on more than one
ground specified in various sub-clauses thereof,
a clear finding to that effect must be arrived at.
What would be relevant for invoking clause (d)
of Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code are the
averments made in the plaint. For that purpose,
there cannot be any addition or subtraction.
Absence of jurisdiction on the part of a court
can be invoked at different stages and under
different provisions of the Code. Order 7 Rule
11 of the Code is one, Order 14 Rule 2 is
another.
(10 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
22. For the purpose of invoking Order 7
Rule 11(d) of the Code, no amount of evidence
can be looked into. The issues on merit of the
matter which may arise between the parties
would not be within the realm of the court at
that stage. All issues shall not be the subjectmatter of an order under the said provision.
23. The principles of res judicata, when
attracted, would bar another suit in view of
Section 12 of the Code. The question involving a
mixed question of law and fact which may
require not only examination of the plaint but
also other evidence and the order passed in the
earlier suit may be taken up either as a
preliminary issue or at the final hearing, but,
the said question cannot be determined at that
stage.
24.
It
is
one
thing
to
say
that
the
averments made in the plaint on their face
discloses no cause of action, but it is another
thing to say that although the same discloses a
cause of action, the same is barred by a law.
25. The decisions rendered by this Court as
also by various High Courts are not uniform in
this behalf. But, then the broad principle which
can be culled out therefrom is that the court at
that stage would not consider any evidence or
enter into a disputed question of fact or law. In
the event, the jurisdiction of the court is found
to be barred by any law, meaning thereby, the
subject-matter
thereof,
the
application
for
rejection of plaint should be entertained.”
(emphasis supplied)
17. Similar was the view expressed in Shakti Bhog
Food Industries Ltd. v. Central Bank of India[Shakti
(11 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
Bhog Food Industries Ltd. v. Central Bank of India,
(2020) 17 SCC 260 : (2021) 4 SCC (Civ) 286 :
2020 INSC 413] and Srihari Hanumandas Totala v.
Hemant Vithal Kamat [Srihari Hanumandas Totala
v. Hemant Vithal Kamat, (2021) 9 SCC 99 : (2021)
4 SCC (Civ) 489 : 2021 INSC 387] .
18. The law applicable for deciding an application
under Order 7 Rule 11CPC was summed up by this
Court in Dahiben v. Arvindbhai Kalyanji Bhanusali
[Dahiben v. Arvindbhai Kalyanji Bhanusali, (2020)
7 SCC 366 : (2020) 4 SCC (Civ) 128 : 2020 INSC
450] . Relevant parts of para 23 thereof are
extracted below: (SCC pp. 377-79)
“23. to 23.1.***
23.2. The remedy under Order 7 Rule 11 is
an independent and special remedy, wherein
the court is empowered to summarily dismiss a
suit at the threshold, without proceeding to
record evidence, and conducting a trial, on the
basis of the evidence adduced, if it is satisfied
that the action should be terminated on any of
the grounds contained in this provision.
23.3. The underlying object of Order 7 Rule
11(a) is that if in a suit, no cause of action is
disclosed, or the suit is barred by limitation
under Rule 11(d), the court would not permit
the
plaintiff
to
unnecessarily
protract
the
proceedings in the suit. In such a case, it would
be necessary to put an end to the sham
litigation, so that further judicial time is not
wasted.
23.4. In Azhar Hussain v. Rajiv Gandhi
[Azhar Hussain v. Rajiv Gandhi, 1986 Supp SCC
315] , this Court held that the whole purpose of
conferment of powers under this provision is to
(12 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
ensure that a litigation which is meaningless,
and bound to prove abortive, should not be
permitted to waste judicial time of the court, in
the following words: (SCC p. 324, para 12)
‘12. … The whole purpose of conferment
of such powers is to ensure that a litigation
which is meaningless and bound to prove
abortive should not be permitted to occupy
the time of the court and exercise the
mind of the respondent. The sword of
Damocles need not be kept hanging over
his head unnecessarily without point or
purpose. Even in an ordinary civil litigation
the court readily exercises the power to
reject a plaint, if it does not disclose any
cause of action.’
23.5. The power conferred on the court to
terminate a civil action is, however, a drastic
one, and the conditions enumerated in Order 7
Rule 11 are required to be strictly adhered to.
23.6. Under Order 7 Rule 11, a duty is cast
on the court to determine whether the plaint
discloses a cause of action by scrutinising the
averments in the plaint [Liverpool & London
S.P. & I. Assn. Ltd. v. M.V. Sea Success,
(2004) 9 SCC 512] , read in conjunction with
the documents relied upon, or whether the
suit is barred by any law.
***
23.9. In exercise of power under this
provision, the court would determine if the
assertions made in the plaint are contrary to
statutory law, or judicial dicta, for deciding
whether a case for rejecting the plaint at the
threshold is made out.
(13 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
23.10. At this stage, the pleas taken by
the defendant in the written statement and
application for rejection of the plaint on the
merits, would be irrelevant, and cannot be
adverted to, or taken into consideration.
[Sopan Sukhdeo Sable v. Charity Commr.,
(2004) 3 SCC 137]
23.11. The test for exercising the power
under
Order
Rule
is
that
if
the
averments made in the plaint are taken in
entirety, in conjunction with the documents
relied upon, would the same result in a
decree being passed. This test was laid down
in Liverpool & London S.P. & I. Assn. Ltd. v.
M.V. Sea Success [Liverpool & London S.P. &
I. Assn. Ltd. v. M.V. Sea Success, (2004) 9
SCC 512] which reads as: (SCC p. 562, para
139)
‘139. Whether a plaint discloses a
cause of action or not is essentially a
question of fact. But whether it does or
does not must be found out from reading
the plaint itself. For the said purpose,
the averments made in the plaint in their
entirety must be held to be correct. The
test is as to whether if the averments
made in the plaint are taken to be
correct in their entirety, a decree would
be passed.’
23.12. In Hardesh Ores (P) Ltd. v. Hede &
Co. [Hardesh Ores (P) Ltd. v. Hede & Co.,
(2007) 5 SCC 614] the Court further held
that it is not permissible to cull out a
sentence or a passage, and to read it in
isolation. It is the substance, and not merely
(14 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
the form, which has to be looked into. The
plaint has to be construed as it stands,
without addition or subtraction of words. If
the allegations in the plaint prima facie show
a cause of action, the court cannot embark
upon an enquiry whether the allegations are
true
in
fact.
Janakiraman
D.
Ramachandran
v.
R.V.
[D.
Ramachandran
v.
R.V.
Janakiraman, (1999) 3 SCC 267; See also
Vijai Pratap Singh v. Dukh Haran Nath Singh,
1962 SCC OnLine SC 56 : AIR 1962 SC
267] .
23.13. If on a meaningful reading of the
plaint, it is found that the suit is manifestly
vexatious and without any merit, and does
not disclose a right to sue, the court would
be justified in exercising the power under
Order 7 Rule 11CPC.
23.14. The power under Order 7 Rule
11CPC may be exercised by the court at any
stage of the suit, either before registering
the plaint, or after issuing summons to the
defendant, or before conclusion of the trial,
as held by this Court in the judgment of
Saleem
Bhai
v.
State
of
Maharashtra
[Saleem
Bhai
v.
State
of
Maharashtra,
(2003) 1 SCC 557] . The plea that once
issues
are
framed,
the
matter
must
necessarily go to trial was repelled by this
Court in Azhar Hussain case [Azhar Hussain
v.
Rajiv
Followed
Gandhi,
in
Supp
Manvendrasinhji
SCC
315.
Ranjitsinhji
Jadeja v. Rajmata Vijaykunverba, 1998 SCC
OnLine Guj 281 : (1998) 2 GLH 823] .
(15 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
23.15. The provision of Order 7 Rule 11 is
mandatory in nature. It states that the plaint
“shall” be rejected if any of the grounds
specified in clauses (a) to (e) are made out.
If the court finds that the plaint does not
disclose a cause of action, or that the suit is
barred by any law, the court has no option,
but to reject the plaint.”
…
25.However, the fact remains that all the
aforesaid
documents,
referred
to
by
the
respondent in support of his plea for rejection of
the plaint, cannot be considered at this stage as
these are not part of the record with the court
filed along with the plaint. This is the stand
taken
by
the
respondent-defendant
in
the
application filed under Order 7 Rule 11CPC. As
noticed above, no amount of evidence or merits
of the controversy can be examined at the stage
of decision of the application under Order 7 Rule
11CPC. Hence, in our view, the impugned order
[ Order dated 27-9-2021 [Ashok Vidyarthi v.
Eldeco Housing & Industries Ltd., 2021 SCC
OnLine All 1135].] of the High Court passed in
the review application deserves to be set aside.
Ordered accordingly. “
(emphasis supplied)
Reliance is also placed on a recent judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Karam Singh versus Amarjit
Singh and Others reported in 2025 SCC Online SC 2240, para
15 of which reads as under:
(16 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
“15. Before we assess the correctness of the
impugned orders, we must remind ourselves of
the basic principles governing rejection of a
plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC. Here, the
defendants seek rejection of plaint under clause
(d) of Rule 11 (i.e., suit barred by law). Clause
(d)
makes
it
clear
that
while
considering
rejection of the plaint thereunder only the
averments made in the plaint and nothing else
is to be considered to find out whether the suit
is barred by law. At this stage, the defense is
not to be considered. Thus, whether the suit is
barred by any law or not is to be determined on
the basis of averments made in the plaint.”
18.
At this stage it would be apposite to reproduce the relevant
extract
of
the
application
filed
by
the
petitioner/applicant/defendant under Order VII Rule 11 CPC read
with Section 12A of the Act of 2015 seeking dismissal of the plaint
which reads as under:
"3. यह की वादी ने जानबू झकर से चा से से टूटरी
मेडडएशन डजसका मैडेटरी पावधान संससत करने से पहले
मधसता और समझौता कमडशरयल कोटरर स एक 2015 की
धारा 12 ए मे डदया गया है को बाईपास करने की नाकाम
कोडशश वादी दारा की गई है इस कारण वादी डडफालर है
एवं वादी का वाद barred by law होने से इस से ज पर
खाररज करने योग है ।"
(17 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
Also, provision of Order VII Rule 11(d), CPC which deals with
rejection of the plaint on account of being barred by any law reads
as under:
“11. Rejection of plaint.— The plaint shall be
rejected in the following cases:—
(a) ...
(b) ...
(c) ...
(d) where the suit appears from the statement
in the plaint to be barred by any law”
19.
Thus, taking note of the provision of Order VII Rule 11(d)
CPC, which makes it clear that while considering an application
seeking rejection of the plaint, only the averments made in the
plaint and nothing else is to be considered to find out whether the
suit
is
barred
by
law,
and
taking
guidance
from
the
pronouncements of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, this Court has no
hesitation
in
arriving
at
the
conclusion
that
the
learned
Commercial Court was fully justified in deciding the application
under Order VII Rule 11 CPC without leading evidence. Further, by
no stretch of imagination an order passed or directions issued by
this Court can be given such an interpretation which would have
required the learned Commercial Court to travel beyond the plaint
for adjudication of an application filed under Order VII Rule 11
CPC.
20.
The direction so issued by this Court vide its orders dated
05.12.2024 and 18.02.2025 undoubtedly required the learned
Commercial Court to frame a preliminary issue and to consider
and decide the same after hearing both the parties, however, in
(18 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
the considered opinion of this Court, by passing the order dated
16.10.2025, the learned Commercial Court has duly adhered to
the directions so issued and it cannot be said that as evidence was
not led for deciding the said issue, the order dated 16.10.2025
has been passed in defiance of the directions issued by this Court
in its order dated 18.02.2025. It goes without saying that any
interpretation of an order of this Court cannot be done in such a
manner which results into an interpretation which runs contrary to
the provisions of a statute and law settled by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court and thus, the submission of learned counsel for the
petitioner/applicant/defendant that deciding the issue without
leading
evidence
was
an
error
committed
by
the
learned
Commercial Court, cannot be accepted. Reliance in this regard is
placed on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of Shailesh Dhairyawan v. Mohan Balkrishna Lulla reported
in (2016) 3 SCC 619, relevant portion of which reads as under:
“31. … .The principle of "purposive interpretation"
or
"purposive
construction"
is
based
on
the
understanding that the court is supposed to attach
that meaning to the provisions which serve the
"purpose" behind such a provision. The basic
approach is to ascertain what is it designed to
accomplish? To put it otherwise, by interpretative
process the court is supposed to realise the goal
that the legal text is designed to realise. As Aharon
Barak puts it:
"Purposive interpretation is based on three
components
:
language,
purpose,
and
(19 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
discretion. Language shapes the range of
semantic
possibilities
within
which
the
interpreter acts as a linguist. Once the
interpreter defines the range, he or she
chooses the legal meaning of the text from
among the (express or implied) semantic
possibilities. The semantic component thus
sets the limits of interpretation by restricting
the interpreter to a legal meaning that the
text can bear in its (public or private)
language."”
21.
Further, as the order dated 16.10.2025 specifically records
that as an application seeking temporary injunction has been filed
by the respondent/non-applicant/plaintiff in a suit for infringement
of intellectual property rights, under no circumstances, any error
can be found in the said order, more particularly, in view of the
law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Novenco
Building (supra), operative portion of which reads as under :
“21.
Thus,
the
question
whether
a
suit
‘contemplates any urgent interim relief’ needs
to be examined on the touchstone of the
aforementioned criteria. The issue which arises
for consideration in this appeal is whether a suit
alleging continuing infringement of patent and
design rights, accompanied by a prayer for
interim injunction, can be said to contemplate
urgent relief within the meaning of Section 12A
(20 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
of the Act, notwithstanding certain delay in its
institution.
22. The subject matter of the present action is
continuing infringement of intellectual property.
Each act of manufacture, sale, or offer for sale
of the infringing product constitutes a fresh
wrong and recurring cause of action. It is well
settled in law that mere delay in bringing an
action does not legalise an infringement and
the same cannot defeat the right of the
proprietor to seek injunctive relief against the
dishonest user. The appellant has pleaded that
Xero
Energy,
its
former
distributor,
has
dishonestly appropriated its proprietary designs
and
patents
to
manufacture
and
market
identical fans under deceptively similar name.
The accompanying material demonstrates that
such
infringing
activity
is
continuing
and
causing immediate and irreparable harm to the
appellant's business reputation, goodwill and
proprietary rights.
23. From the standpoint of the appellant, each
day
of
continuing
infringement
aggravates
injury to its intellectual property and erodes its
market standing. The urgency, therefore, is
inherent in the nature of the wrong and does
not lie in the age of the cause but in the
persistence of the peril. The court cannot be
(21 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
unmindful of the fact that intellectual property
disputes are not confined to the private realm.
When imitation masquerades as innovation, it
sows confusion among consumers, taints the
market
place
and
diminishes
faith
in
the
sanctity of the trade. The public interest,
therefore, becomes the moral axis upon which
the
urgency
turns.
Therefore,
the
public
interest element, need to prevent confusion in
the market and to protect consumers from
deception further imparts a colour of immediacy
to the reliefs sought.
24. The appellant's prayer for injunction cannot
be characterised as mere camouflage to evade
mediation. It is a real grievance founded on the
continuing
nature
of
infringement
and
irreparable prejudice likely to be caused by the
delay. The court must look beyond time lag and
evaluate the substance of the plea for interim
protection. The insistence of pre-institution
mediation
in
infringement,
a
in
situation
effect,
would
of
ongoing
render
the
plaintiff remediless allowing the infringer to
continue to profit under the protection of
procedural formality. Section 12A of the Act
was not intended to achieve such kind of
anomalous result.
(22 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
[CW-17462/2025]
25. The learned Single Judge as well as the
Division Bench of the High Court erred in
construing the test for urgent relief enumerated
in Section 12A of the Act, in as much as the
courts
have
proceeded
to
examine
the
entitlement of the appellant to urgent relief
based on the merits of the case rather than
looking at the urgency as is evident from the
plaint and the documents annexed thereto from
the standpoint of the plaintiff. The High Court
has proceeded on the premise that lapse of
time
between
the
appellant's
discovery
of
infringement and filing of suit negated the
element of urgency. Such an approach, in our
considered view, is contrary to the principles
laid down by the decisions of this Court. The
High Court has also failed to take into account
that the present action is one of the continuous
infringement of intellectual property.
CONCLUSION
26. For the reasons stated above, we hold that
(i) In actions alleging continuing infringement
of intellectual property rights, urgency must be
assessed in the context of the ongoing injury
and the public interest in preventing deception,
(ii) Mere delay in institution of a suit by itself,
does
not
negate
urgency
infringement is continuing.
when
the
(23 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:3567]
27.
For
the
[CW-17462/2025]
aforementioned
reasons,
the
impugned judgment dated 28.08.2024 of the
ld. Single Judge in Commercial Suit No. 13 of
2024 and the judgment dated 13.11.2024 of
the
Division
Bench
of
the
High
Court
in
Commercial Appeal No.1 of 2024 are quashed
and set aside. The Commercial Suit No. 13 of
2024 is restored to the file of the High Court to
be proceeded with on merits in accordance with
law.”
(emphasis supplied)
CONCLUSION
22.
Thus, taking note of the above facts, law applicable and
judgments cited, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
orders dated 04.10.2025 and 16.10.2025 passed by the learned
Commercial Court, Kota (Raj.) deserve no interference and
consequently, the writ petitions stand dismissed.
23.
No order as to cost.
24.
Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed of.
(ANUROOP SINGHI),J
Dipesh Chayal /27-28
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review