Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
D.B. Criminal Death Reference No. 1/2024
CNR: RJHC021042732024 | URN: CRLDR / 1U / 2024
State of Rajasthan through P.P.
----Petitioner
Versus
Ramgopal @ Gopal son of Kanaram, R/o Aloda, Police Station
Khatushyamji, District Sikar
----Respondent
Connected With
D.B. Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 488/2024
CNR: RJHC021089812024 | URN: CRLAD / 798U / 2024
Sandeep Gurjar S/o Shri Sheopal, R/o Amarpura, Tan. Aloda, P.S.
Khatushyamji, District Sikar. (at present confined in Central Jail,
Bikaner).
----Appellant
Versus
State of Rajasthan through P.P.
----Respondent
D.B. Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 497/2024
CNR: RJHC021107392024 | URN: CRLAD / 810U / 2024
Ramgopal @ Gopal S/o Kanaram, R/o Aloda, Police Station
Khatushyamji, District Sikar Rajasthan (presently confined in
Central Jail, Jaipur)
----Appellant
Versus
State of Rajasthan through Public Prosecutor
----Respondent
D.B. Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 498/2024
CNR: RJHC021100042024 | URN: CRLAD / 811U / 2024
Nandlal son of Jagdish, R/o Aloda, Police Station Khatushyamji,
District Sikar Rajasthan (presently confined in District Jail, Sikar)
----Appellant
Versus
RAVI SHARMA
Date: 2026.10.30
16:58:01 IST
(2 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
State Of Rajasthan Through P.P.
----Respondent
D.B. Criminal Appeal (SB) No. 3246/2024
CNR: RJHC021044672024 | URN: CRLAS / 5201U / 2024
Rajesh Kumar S/o Shri Phool Chand, R/o Ward No. 3, Reengus,
Police Station Reengus, District Sikar (Rajasthan)
----Appellant
Versus
State of Rajasthan through P.P.
----Respondent
D.B. Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 21/2025
CNR: RJHC020015152025 | URN: CRLAD / 40U / 2025
1. Mahendra Kumar Choudhary S/o Sh. Banwari Lal, aged about
35 Years, R/o Aloda, Police Station Khatushyamji, District Sikar
(at present confined at Central Jail, Bikaner.)
2. Madanlal Chandiwal S/o Moolchand, aged about 27 Years, R/o
Aloda, Police Station Khatushyamji, District Sikar (at present
confined at Central Jail, Bikaner)
----- Appellants
Versus
State of Rajasthan through P.P.
----Respondent
D.B. Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 22/2025
CNR: RJHC020013512025 | URN: CRLAD / 41U / 2025
1. Babulal @ Harnek S/o Sh. Narayan, aged about 39 Years, R/o
Aloda, Police Station Khatushyamji, District Sikar (at present
confined at Central Jail, Bikaner)
2. Beerbal Dhaka S/o Mothuram, aged about 38 Years, R/o Aloda,
Police Station Khatushyamji, District Sikar (at present confined
at Central Jail, Bikaner)
----Appellants
Versus
State of Rajasthan through P.P.
----Respondent
D.B. Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 23/2025
(3 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
CNR: RJHC020003982025 | URN: CRLAD / 42U / 2025
Sohanlal
S/o
Shri
Bhagirath,
R/o
Aloda,
Police
Station
Khatushyamji District Sikar (Raj) (presently is confined at Central
Jail, Bikaner)
----Appellant
Versus
State of Rajasthan through P.P.
----Respondent
D.B. Criminal Appeal (DB) No. 24/2025
CNR: RJHC020003462025 | URN: CRLAD / 43U / 2025
1. Mahadev S/o Shri
Kanaram, R/o
Aloda, Police Station
Khatushyamji, District Sikar (presently confined at Central Jail,
Bikaner)
2. Parsaram Chopra S/o Shri Mohanlal, R/o Madani, Police Station
Khatushyamji, District Sikar (presently confined at Central Jail,
Bikaner)
----Appellants
Versus
State of Rajasthan through P.P.
----Respondent
For State
For Appellant(s)
:
:
Mr. Amit Kumar Punia, P.P.
Mr. V.R. Bajwa, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Amar Kumar
Ms. Savita Nathawat
Mr. R.R. Baisla
Mr. Rajveer Singh Gurjar with
Mr. Avtar Singh Rathore and
Mr. Kapil Nagayach
Mr. Rajesh Goswami with
Mr. Shiv Kumar Jangir
Mr. Garvit Saraswat
Mr. Jay Bhardwaj and
Ms. Monika Shekhawat
Mr. Rahul Sharma with
Ms. Chanchal and
Mr. Utkarsh Goyal for
Mr. Rajneesh Gupta
Mr. Narendra Singh Gurjar
Legal Team appointed :
by RSLSC
Mr. N.A. Naqvi, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Susheel Pujari
Mr. Dharmendra Gurjar
Mr. Happy Sharma
(4 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Mr. Mohd. Numan and
Mr. Firoz Khan
For Respondent(s)
Mr. Ashvin Garg with
Mr. Sandeep Pathak
Mr. Sanjay Khedar
Mr. Mohit Goyal
Mr. Hem Bhushan Vedi and
Mr. Utkarsh Meena
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MAHENDAR KUMAR GOYAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BHUWAN GOYAL
Judgment
Date of Conclusion of Arguments
Judgment Reserved On
::
::
16/10/2026
16/10/2026
Whether the full judgment or
only the operative part is pronounced : : Full Judgment
Judgment Pronounced On
::
30/10/2026
Per Hon’ble Mahendar Kumar Goyal, J.
The aforesaid death reference as also the connected criminal
appeals arises out of the judgment of conviction and the order of
sentence dated 30.11.2024 passed by the learned Additional
Sessions Judge No.1, Sikar (for short- `the learned trial court') in
Sessions Case (CISN 21/2020) CNR No.RJSK01-000354-2020
whereby the accused-appellants (for short-`the appellants’) have
been convicted and sentenced as under:
Appellant-Ramgopal @ Gopal
Section 302/149 IPC:- Death sentence and
fine of ₹1,00,000/-; in default whereof, one year’s
additional imprisonment.
Section 364/149 IPC:- Life imprisonment and
fine of ₹50,000/-; in default whereof, six months’
additional rigorous imprisonment.
(5 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Section
201/149
IPC:Three
years’
imprisonment and fine of ₹20,000/-; in default
whereof,
three
months’
additional
rigorous
imprisonment.
Section 147 IPC:- Two years’ rigorous
imprisonment and fine of ₹5,000/-; in default
whereof,
one
month’s
additional
rigorous
imprisonment.
Section 120-B IPC:- Ten years’ rigorous
imprisonment and fine of ₹20,000/-; in default
whereof,
three
months’
additional
rigorous
imprisonment.
All the substantive sentences to run concurrently.
Appellants-Mahadev, Mahendra Kumar Choudhary, Sandeep
Gurjar,
Beerbal
Dhaka,
Nandlal,
Madanlal
Chandiwal,
Sohanlal, Babulal @ Harnek, Parsaram Chopra
Section 302/149 IPC:- Life imprisonment and
fine of ₹1,00,000/-; in default whereof, six months’
additional rigorous imprisonment.
Section 364/149 IPC:- Life imprisonment and
fine of ₹50,000/-; in default whereof, six months’
additional rigorous imprisonment.
Section
201/149
IPC:Three
years’
imprisonment and fine of ₹20,000/-; in default
whereof,
six
months’
additional
rigorous
imprisonment.
Section 147 IPC:- Two years’ rigorous
imprisonment and fine of ₹5,000/-; in default
whereof,
one
month’s
additional
rigorous
imprisonment.
Section 120-B IPC:- Ten years’ rigorous
imprisonment and fine of ₹20,000/-; in default
whereof,
three
months’
additional
rigorous
imprisonment.
All the substantive sentences to run concurrently.
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(6 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Appellant-Rajesh Kumar
Section 201 IPC:- Three years’ rigorous
imprisonment and fine of ₹20,000/-; in default
whereof,
three
months’
additional
rigorous
imprisonment.
All the substantive sentences to run concurrently.
The relevant facts, in a nutshell, are that the complainant
Baldev Godara (PW1) submitted a written report-Ex.P1 on
23.10.2019 at about 12.10 PM with Police Station Ranoli alleging
that on the previous night at about 11.16 PM five persons named
therein and some other persons whose names were not known,
summoned his brother Ganpat Lal to the ESSAR petrol pump (for
brevity-`the petrol pump’), Palsana Bypass, beaten him and took
him away in a passenger vehicle, CCTV footage whereof was
available at the petrol pump. Based thereon, an FIR No.0400
dated 23.10.2019 was registered at the Police Station Ranoli,
District Sikar for the offences under Sections 365 and 323 IPC.
During the course of investigation, dead bodies of Ganpat Lal as
also of
a woman named Prem were recovered and after
investigation, a charge-sheet under Sections 147, 364, 302, 201
read with Sections 149 and 120B IPC was filed against the
accused persons, namely, Ramgopal @ Gopal (for brevity`Ramgopal'), Mahadev, Choturam @ Chotu, Mahendra Kumar
Choudhary, Mahendra Gurjar, Rajesh Kumar, Sandeep Gurjar and
Beerbal Dhaka. Thereafter, a supplementary charge-sheet under
the aforesaid Sections came to be filed against the appellants
Sohanlal Jat, Madanlal Chandiwal, Nandlal @ Nandkar and Babulal
@ Harnek Faldoliya. After further investigation, the police filed a
second supplementary charge-sheet under Sections 147, 302 read
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(7 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
with Sections 149 and 120B IPC against the appellants Parsaram
Chopra and Mahendra Singh Chopra.
Charges under Sections 147, 364, 302, 201 and 120B IPC
read with Section 149 IPC were framed against the accused
persons, namely, Ramgopal, Sandeep Gurjar, Mahadev, Mahendra
Kumar Choudhary, Beerbal, Sohanlal Jat, Madanlal Chandiwal,
Nandlal @ Nandkar, Babulal @ Harnek Faldoliya, Parsaram Chopra
and Mahendra Singh Chopra. Against the accused persons,
namely, Rajesh Kumar and Mahendra Kumar Gurjar, charges were
framed under Section 201 read with Section 149 IPC and a charge
under Section 176 IPC was framed against the accused Choturam
@ Chotu. After trial, while the accused persons, namely, Choturam
@ Chotu and Mahendra Kumar Gurjar were acquitted of the
charges framed against them, the appellants have been convicted
and sentenced, as stated hereinabove.
Pursuant to the directions issued by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in the case of Aman Singh & Anr. Vs. State of
Bihar: (2023) 13 SCC 563, a legal team comprising learned
Senior Advocate Shri Nasir Ali Naqvi, assisted by learned counsel
S/Shri Sushil Pujari and Dharmendra Gurjar, was appointed by the
Rajasthan State Legal Services Committee (for short-`RSLSC')
vide order dated 15.09.2026. The State of Rajasthan also
submitted nominal roll of the appellant Ramgopal facing the death
penalty as well as his psychiatric and psychopathological report
furnished by the Medical Board, Psychiatric Centre, Jaipur.
Shri V.R. Bajwa, learned Senior Counsel for the appellants
Ramgopal, Mahadev, Parsaram, Mehendra Kumar Choudhary and
Madanlal, assailing the impugned judgement of conviction and the
(8 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
order of sentence, contended that the findings of the learned trial
court are based on conjectures and surmises without being
supported by any legally admissible evidence available on record.
He asserted that the prosecution has suppressed the true genesis
of the case and the FIR-Ex.P11 was hit by Section 162 Cr.P.C.
inasmuch as, from the prosecution evidence, it was proved that
before approaching the Police Station Ranoli, the complainant
party
had
already
lodged
a
report
at
the
Police
Station
Khatushyamji which never saw the light of day. He submitted that
though the case is based on circumstantial evidence but, the
prosecution failed to prove a complete chain of circumstances
leading only to the hypothesis of appellants' guilt. Elaborating on
his submissions, learned Senior Counsel canvassed that the
prosecution relied heavily upon the CCTV camera footage to show
their complicity in the crime. He submitted that a set of CCTV
cameras was installed at the residence of the appellant Ramgopal,
whereas another set of CCTV cameras was installed at the petrol
pump. He further submitted that the Digital Video Recorder (DVR)
attached to the CCTV cameras installed at the petrol pump was
seized vide memo-Ex.P68 on 06.02.2020, i.e., after a delay of
about three and a half months from the date of the incident. The
DVR from the house of the appellant Ramgopal was seized on
25.10.2019 vide memo-Ex.P33 but was not sealed. Learned
Senior Counsel contended that the footage from the DVR seized
from the house was copied onto a pen drive-Article 1 which was
seized vide memo dated 07.11.2019-Ex.P65 but was also not
sealed. Shri Bajwa asserted that although, the DVR seized vide
Ex.P33 was deposited in the malkhana on the date of its seizure
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(9 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
but, there was no corresponding entry recording its removal for
the purpose of retrieving its data onto the pen drive-Article 1 on
07.11.2019. Learned Senior Counsel argued that Pawan Kumar
(PW19), a Constable, stated that after the pen drive was marked
as Article 1, it was not sealed again and the footage analysis
report-Ex.P66 was prepared from this unsealed pen drive which
compromised its probative value. Inviting the attention of this
Court to a letter dated 08.02.2020-Ex.P98 issued by Shri Umesh
Kumar, the expert, Shri Bajwa urged that the same was treated as
a certificate under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872
(for short-`the Act of 1872’); however, no evidence was led to
show that he was an expert competent to issue such certificate.
He further canvassed that the certificate did not disclose the
details either of the DVR or of the pen drive mentioned therein.
Referring to the statement of the Investigating Officer Shri Rajesh
Arya (PW65) dated 12.09.2024 when the pen drive-Article 1 was
played in the Court, Shri Bajwa submitted that though objections
were raised by the defence that in the CCTV footage, faces of the
persons were not identifiable on account of low light/poor clarity,
but without addressing these objections, the learned trial court
placed reliance upon the footage for recording their conviction.
Similarly, qua seizure memo of the pen drive-Article 2Ex.P14 onto which the CCTV footage from the DVR installed at the
petrol pump was retrieved, Shri Bajwa contended that the same
was also not sealed. He further submitted that although, the
prosecution had relied upon the certificate dated 14.01.2020Ex.P75 and the letter of even date-Ex.P76, both issued by Shri
Shrawn Singh-owner of the petrol pump, as the certificates under
(10 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Section 65B, but the learned trial court did not appreciate that he,
as PW-26, had denied having issued any certificate under Section
65B of the Act of 1872. Drawing the attention of this Court to the
testimony of the first Investigating Officer, namely, Richpal Singh
(PW61), the learned Senior Counsel urged that he had admitted
that the appellant-Ramgopal was not seen in the CCTV footage of
the petrol pump. He argued that against that backdrop, the
learned trial court erred in relying upon the footage analysis
report-Ex.P67 of the pen drive-Article 2 to record their conviction.
Referring to the statement of the Investigating Officer Shri Rajesh
Arya (PW65) dated 12.09.2024 when the pen drive-Article 2 was
played in the Court, Shri Bajwa submitted that at that time also,
objections were raised by the defence that the persons shown
therein were not identifiable as their faces were not clearly visible,
which
was
also
admitted
by
the
PW65
during
his
cross-
examination, but the learned trial court erred in placing reliance
upon the same to hold them guilty of kidnapping the deceased
Ganpat from the petrol pump.
Learned Senior Counsel asserted that before reliance can be
placed upon the FSL report/electronic evidence, it is incumbent
upon the Court to record a satisfaction that the prosecution has
shown an unbroken chain of custody of the samples. However,
such a chain was completely absent in the instant case as is
evident from the facts narrated hereinabove.
Shri Bajwa also canvassed that neither the DVRs nor the pen
drives allegedly containing copied footage were subjected to FSL
Examination to rule out a possibility of any tampering therewith.
He contended that though there was an allegation against some of
(11 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
the appellants that they tried to delete the CCTV footage from the
DVR installed at the petrol pump on the very next morning of the
incident, i.e., 22.10.2019, but the prosecution is completely silent
as to why no such attempt was made with the DVR installed at the
house of Ramgopal, which was seized only on 25.10.2019, i.e.,
four days after the date of incident.
With regard to recovery of the dead bodies at the instance of
appellant Ramgopal, Shri Bajwa contended that his disclosure
statement was recorded on 23.10.2019 at about 8.15 PM and the
bodies were recovered vide memo-Ex.P78 at 9.00 PM on that very
day. However, the complainant and some of the other witnesses
have stated that the dead bodies were recovered at 5-6 PM on
that day rendering the recovery at the instance of the appellant
doubtful. In this regard, he further submitted that the learned trial
court has relied upon the FSL report wherein human blood was
found on the soil and the leaves of the tree seized from the place
where
the
dead
bodies
were
recovered,
but
ignoring
and
overlooking that the recoveries were made on 25.10.2019, i.e.,
two days after the recovery of the dead bodies without any
explanation for this delay.
Next, it was contended by Shri Bajwa that qua most of the
disclosure statements given by the appellants, the Investigating
officer did not utter the exact words, in his Court deposition, said
to him by the appellants rendering the disclosure statements
inadmissible in evidence.
Learned Senior counsel further contended that as per the
prosecution case, the Bolero Car allegedly used by the appellant
Ramgopal in disposing of the dead bodies was driven by him to
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(12 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Khatushyamji Police Station where it was shown to have been
recovered; however, had the appellant used the car to commit the
crime, he would not have taken it to the police station.
Qua the appellant Mahendra Kumar Choudhary, learned
Senior Counsel submitted that he has been roped in on account of
seizure of a Scorpio car and a fan belt allegedly used by him in the
commission of the offence. He submitted that, as per the
prosecution case, on the fateful night of 21.10.2019, the appellant
had brought the deceased Prem in the subject Scorpio car from
her maternal uncle’s home to her paternal home, where she and
Ganpat were murdered. Drawing the attention of this Court to the
findings recorded by the learned trial court in this regard, Shri
Bajwa contended that to fortify its conclusion, the testimony of
Shri Murari Lal Sharma (PW13), the Shift in-charge, Reliance Toll
Plaza was relied upon, wherein he had stated that at about 12.22
hours (for convenience, hereinafter referred to as, '00.22 hours')
on the night of 22.10.2019, the subject Scorpio car passed
through the Toll from Jaipur towards Sikar and the same car
passed in the same night at about 03.10 AM back towards Jaipur.
He had exhibited the relevant CCTV footage as Exs.P40 and P41.
However, during cross-examination he admitted that the Exs.P40
and P41 were open to manipulation and he was unaware whether
the Operator had fed wrong data in these documents. With regard
to recovery of the fan belt, learned Senior Counsel argued that in
the absence of any human blood on it, the appellant could not
have been connected with the alleged crime on its basis.
Shri Bajwa contended that the appellant Madanlal Chandiwal
was found to be involved in the crime on the strength of recovery,
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(13 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
at his behest, of a piece of cable and a motorcycle belonging to
the deceased. Elaborating on his submission, he canvassed that
the cable was neither found to be blood-stained nor sent to FSL
examination to prove that it was the weapon of offence used by
the appellant in the commission of the offence. With regard to
recovery of the motorcycle allegedly belonging to the deceased
Ganpat Lal which was made from an open place more than nine
months after the date of incident, he argued that the prosecution
did not lead any evidence to show that it was lifted by him from
the place it was last parked by the deceased Ganpat Lal and
disposed of at the place of its seizure.
Shri V.R. Bajwa argued that the appellants Parsaram and
Mahadev have been held to be involved in the crime only with the
aid of recovery of a piece of cable from each of them. Inviting the
attention of this Court to the site plans of seizure of the subject
cables- Ex.P131 and Ex.P134, he submitted that the same were
recovered from the agricultural field and the residential house of
the appellant Ramgopal; however, the prosecution did not lead
any evidence to show their presence at that place at the relevant
time.
Shri Bajwa, the learned Senior Counsel submitted that the
seizure memos of cable recovered from the different appellants
reflect that they were of different thickness, although it was the
prosecution's case that these were part of the same bundle of the
cable which raises a serious doubt as to the veracity of the
prosecution case.
He, to buttress his submissions, relied upon the following
judgements:
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(14 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
1. Ramanand @ Nandlal Bharti vs. State of Uttar Pradesh:
(2023) 16 SCC 510;
2. Babu Sahebagouda & Ors. Vs. State of Karnataka: 2024
Livelaw (SC) 510;
3. State of Tamil Nadu vs. Ponnusamy & Ors.: 2026 INSC
507;
4. Pooranmal vs. State of Rajashan & Ors.: 2026 INSC 217;
5. Allarakha Habib Memon & Ors. Vs. State of Gujarat:
(2024) 9 SCC 546.
Qua the sentence, the learned Senior Counsel submitted that
the case did not fall within the category of the “rarest of the rare
cases” and, therefore, the death penalty was not warranted.
Shri R.R. Baisla, the learned counsel for the appellant
Sandeep Gurjar, contended that he has been found to be involved
in the crime on the strength of recovery, on his disclosure
statement, of a motorcycle allegedly used for following and
catching hold of the deceased Prem and Ganpat, whereas the
prosecution led no evidence to show that the deceased fled on a
motorcycle and he caught hold of them following them on the
subject motorcycle.
Shri Rajveer Singh Gurjar, the learned counsel appearing for
the appellant Rajesh Kumar, contended that though he was
charged with having attempted to delete the CCTV footage from
the DVR installed at the petrol pump; however, he was convicted
of the offence under Section 201 IPC and not of an attempt
thereof. He further contended that even otherwise, he was not
identifiable in the CCTV footage so to connect him with the alleged
crime.
(15 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Shri Rajesh Goswami, the learned counsel, canvassed that
the appellants Babulal @ Harnek and Beerbal Dhaka were falsely
implicated in the case. He urged that Babulal alias Harnek was
convicted on the strength of recovery of a piece of cable from his
home on his disclosure statement, but the prosecution could not
prove that it was used by him in the murder of Prem and Ganpat.
Qua the appellant Beerbal Dhaka, learned counsel argued that he
was found to be involved in the offence on the basis of recovery,
on his disclosure statement, of a passenger vehicle allegedly used
in the kidnapping of Ganpat. He contended that in this regard, the
prosecution relied upon the CCTV footage of the cameras installed
at the petrol pump, which admittedly, did not show registration
number of the subject vehicle and it was assumed to be involved
in the offence only because “Rainbow Children Academy” was
written on its side. Inviting the attention of this Court to the
testimony of the Investigating Officer (PW65), learned counsel
argued that he did not deny that there could be about 30 such
vehicles
in
the
school,
and
that,
in
the
absence
of
any
incriminating material found in the subject vehicle, the appellant's
complicity could not have been held to be proved merely on
account of recovery of a vehicle with “Rainbow Children Academy”
written on it.
Shri Rahul Sharma, the learned counsel for the appellant
Sohanlal, contended that his involvement in the offence was found
on the basis of recovery of a piece of cable and discovery of the
place, on his disclosure statement, where mobile phone of the
deceased Ganpat was allegedly burnt. With regard to the piece of
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(16 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
cable, he argued that there was no material on record to show
that this was used by him in the commission of the offence;
recovery whereof, even otherwise, was from an open place. Qua
the discovery of the place where mobile phone of Ganpat was
burnt, inviting the attention of this Court to its site plan-Ex.P94,
learned counsel canvassed that no mobile-related sign was found
there.
Shri Narendra Singh Gurjar, the learned counsel appearing
for the appellant Nandlal @ Nandkar, contended that he has been
convicted on the basis of recovery of a piece of cable as also of a
purse and a PAN card allegedly belonging to the deceased Ganpat
Lal. With regard to the recovery of the cable, he adopted the
submissions advanced by the other learned counsel. Qua the
recovery of the purse and the PAN card of the deceased, learned
counsel argued that the recovery was from an open place and that
too, about nine months after the date of the incident which was
not sufficient to warrant his conviction.
In the aforesaid factual backdrop, learned counsel for the
appellants prayed that the death reference be answered in the
negative, the appeals be allowed, the impugned judgment of
conviction and the order of sentence dated 30.11.2024 be
quashed and set aside and they may be acquitted of the charges
framed against them.
Learned Senior Counsel Shri Nasir Ali Naqvi, assisted by
S/Shri Susheel Pujari and Dharmendra Gurjar, the learned
counsels and the members of the legal team appointed by RSLSC
vide
order
dated
15.09.2026,
supporting
the
contentions
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(17 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
advanced by the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant
Ramgopal alias Gopal, submitted that the prosecution could not
establish a complete chain of circumstances consistent only with
the hypothesis of his guilt. It was asserted that even otherwise,
the case did not fall within the category of the “rarest of rare
cases” so as to warrant the death penalty.
E Converso, opposing the submissions and supporting the
findings recorded by the learned trial court, the learned Public
Prosecutor Shri Amit Punia, assisted by S/Shri Ashwin Garg and
Sandeep Pathak, learned counsel for the complainant, contended
that the judgment is well reasoned and the findings are based on
proper appreciation of the evidence and sound legal principles
which warrant no interference. It was canvassed that the appellant
Ramgopal had lodged a written report-Ex.P110 on 23.10.2019 at
the Police Station Khatushyamji, Sikar alleging that on the night of
21.10.2019, his daughter Prem was kidnapped by some unknown
persons, whereupon an FIR was registered. However, after
thorough investigation, the allegation was found to be false
culminating into submission of a negative final report which was
accepted by the court. It was submitted that this false FIR was
lodged by the appellant Ramgopal only to create an artificial
defence to the offences of kidnapping and murder of not only his
daughter but also of Ganpat Lal committed by him and his coconspirators. He submitted that relying upon the testimony of Shri
Dharampal (PW 69), the learned trial court has recorded a
categorical finding that both the deceased were last seen together
on a motorcycle at the petrol pump from where they were
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(18 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
kidnapped by some of the appellants and taken to the house of
the appellant Ramgopal, where they were beaten to death. It was
canvassed that their dead bodies were recovered from another
place on the disclosure statement of the appellant Ramgopal. It
was argued that the involvement of all the appellants in the crime
was well established by the footage captured by the CCTV
cameras installed at the petrol pump as also at the house of the
appellant Ramgopal, which was played in the court from the pen
drives, i.e., the Articles 1 and 2, authenticity of which was beyond
any doubt. It was asserted that the defective investigation, if any,
would not come to aid of the appellants whose guilt was
established beyond reasonable doubt. It was also argued that the
appellants did not offer any explanation for the incriminating
circumstances suggested to them during the course of their
examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C. and, therefore, the learned
trial court did not err in holding the same to be an important link
in the chain of circumstantial evidence while recording their
conviction. It was contended that since it was a case of honour
killing, the learned trial court did not err in awarding the death
penalty to the appellant Ramgopal and the suitable sentences to
the rest of the appellants. It was, therefore, prayed that the death
reference be answered in the affirmative and the appeals be
dismissed. They relied on the judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in the cases of C. Muniappan & Ors. vs. State of
Tamil Nadu : (2010) 9 SCC 597; Munish Mubar vs. State of
Haryana : (2012) 10 SCC 464 and Kumari Shubha alias
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(19 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Shubhashankar vs. State of Karnataka and Another : 2025 INSC
830.
Heard. Considered.
As per the prosecution story, it was a case of honour killing.
The deceased Ganpat Lal and the deceased Prem, daughter of the
appellant Ramgopal were in love with each other which was not
acceptable to Ramgopal, resulting in their murder by him in
conspiracy with the other appellants.
The postmortem report of the body of the deceased Ganpat
Lal-Ex.P80, which was proved by Dr. Ranjit Singh (PW30), Dr.
Sukh Chain Singh (PW31) and Dr. Aman Singh Rathore (PW36),
the members of the medical board which conducted the autopsy,
revealed 22 injuries on his body with a fracture of right parietaltemporal bone. The cause of death opined was to be shock and
excessive haemorrhage due to cumulative effect of multiple antemortem multiple injuries on the body.
The postmortem report of the body of the deceased PremEx. P81, which was proved by the same members of the medical
board, who also conducted her autopsy, reflected a total 12
injuries on her body and the cause of death was opined to be
asphyxia due to ligature strangulation.
From the aforesaid evidence, it is established that the deaths
were not natural, rather were on account of injuries received in
the assault and asphyxia due to strangulation, respectively and,
therefore, amounted to culpable homicide, a proposition not even
disputed by the learned counsel for the appellants.
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(20 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
In the absence of any ocular evidence, the prosecution case
hinges solely on circumstantial evidence. In the much celebrated
judgment in the case of Sharad Birdhichand Sarda Vs. State of
Maharashtra: (1984) 4 SCC 116, their Lordships laid down the
following five golden principles to be applied while adjudicating
cases based on circumstantial evidence:
“153. A close analysis of this decision would show that
the following conditions must be fulfilled before a case
against an accused can be said to be fully established:
(1) the circumstances from which the
conclusion of guilt is to be drawn should be
fully established.
It may be noted here that this Court indicated that
the circumstances concerned 'must or should' and
not 'may be' established. There is not only a
grammatical but a legal distinction between 'may be
proved' and 'must be or should be proved' as was
held by this Court in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v.
State of Maharashtra MANU/SC/0167/1973: 1973
CriLJ 1783 where the following observations were
made:
Certainly, it is a primary principle that the
accused must be and not merely may be
guilty before a Court can convict and the
mental distance between 'may be' and 'must
be' is long and divides vague conjectures
from sure conclusions.
(2) the facts so established should be
consistent only with the hypothesis of the
guilt of the accused, that is to say, they
should not be explainable on any other
hypothesis except that the accused is guilty.
(3) the circumstances should be of a
conclusive nature and tendency.
(4) they should exclude every possible
hypothesis except the one to be proved, and
(5) there must be a chain of evidence so
complete as not to leave any reasonable
ground for the conclusion consistent with
the innocence of the accused and must show
(21 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
that in all human probability the act must
have been done by the accused.
154. These five golden principles, if we may say so,
constitute the panchsheel of the proof of a case based
on circumstantial evidence.”
A three-judge bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India,
in Tomaso Bruno & Anr. vs. State of U.P. : (2015) 7 SCC
178, authoritatively held that the circumstances from which the
conclusion of guilt is drawn should be fully proved and must be
conclusive in nature. All the circumstances should be complete,
there should be no gap left in the chain of evidence and the
circumstances must be consistent only with the hypothesis of the
guilt of the accused and totally inconsistent with his innocence.
If the circumstantial evidence led by the prosecution in the
instant case is tested on the touchstone of the aforesaid salutory
principles laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, we
arrive at following conclusions:A perusal of the impugned judgment reveals that the
learned trial court has relied upon following circumstances to
return a finding of guilt against the appellants:
(1)
Last seen,
(2)
Recovery
of
incriminating
material
on
their
disclosure
statement or otherwise.
(1) Last seen:
So far as the evidence of last seen is concerned, the
prosecution has heavily relied upon the CCTV footage to bring
home the guilt of the appellants. As a matter of fact, a perusal of
the impugned judgment reflects that the CCTV footage was the
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(22 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
main axis of the circumstantial evidence relied upon by the
prosecution. The investigating agency had collected the CCTV
footage from two places, i.e., the house of the family of the
appellant Ramgopal and the petrol pump. As per the prosecution,
the deceased Ganpat Lal was kidnapped from the petrol pump and
taken to the house of Ramgopal, where he and Prem were beaten
to death.
First, we would like to deal with the CCTV footage obtained
from the cameras installed at the house of Ramgopal which, as
per the prosecution, shows that Prem was being severely beaten
by Ramgopal on the night of 21.10.2019.
The DVR attached to the CCTV cameras installed at the
house of the appellant Ramgopal was seized on 25.10.2019 vide
memo-Ex.P33. The seizure memo does not reflect that the DVR
was sealed at the time of its seizure. It was so admitted by
Subhash Chand (PW32) also, the then Constable at the CO office,
Sikar Rural and a motbir witness to the seizure memo. Further, the
Investigating Officer Rajesh Arya (PW65) also admitted in his
deposition dated 26.09.2024 that, till that day, the DVR was lying
unsealed.
Moreover,
the
prosecution
witnesses,
namely,
Subhash
Chand (PW32) and the Investigating Officer Rajesh Arya (PW65)
admitted during their cross-examination that they had visited the
house of Ramgopal almost on a daily basis for three days prior to
the seizure of the DVR and had minutely examined the scene of
crime, i.e., the house but, conspicuously, they furnished no
explanation as to why the DVR was not recovered and seized
(23 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
immediately after the incident once they had come to know that
the CCTV footage contained therein revealed that Prem was
beaten by her father on the night of 21.10.2019. They further
admitted that the subject DVR was, at the time of its seizure,
under the control of the parents and other family members of the
appellant Ramgopal, meaning thereby it was not under his
exclusive control and possession.
Moreover, the malkhana register-Ex.P265A reflects that the
seized DVR was deposited in the malkhana vide entry number 379
on 25.10.2019, but there is no corresponding entry of it having
been taken out on 7.11.2019 for retrieving the footage onto pen
drive seized vide memo-Ex.P65. The malkhana In-charge, Shri
Nannu Ram (PW67), admitted during his cross-examination that
the DVR was deposited in an unsealed condition and was taken
out on the date marked “C-D” in the register, i.e., on 14.4.2020.
He
further
stated
that
the
register
did
not
contain
any
endorsement as to who had taken out the DVR and for what
purpose.
He also stated that he was unaware of how many
months the DVR was out of the malkhana and when it was
deposited back.
The CCTV footage from the seized DVR was copied onto a
pen drive on 7-11-2019 and the pen drive was seized vide memo
of even date-Ex.P65. However, Ex. P65 does not reflect that even
the pen drive was sealed, also admitted by Shri Pawan Kumar
(PW9)-one of the motbir witnesses during his cross-examination.
Further, the seized pen drive was never deposited in the
malkhana.
(24 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Additionally, the investigating agency prepared a footage
analysis report-Ex.P66 on 7-11-2019 by playing the pen drive in
the office computer of the Circle Officer, Sikar Rural. However, the
Ex.P66 does not contain the description of the played pen drive.
This omission assumes much significance as the pen drive was
neither sealed at the time of its seizure nor deposited in the
malkhana.
We also find that Shri Subhash Chand (PW32), one of the
motbir
witnesses
to
Ex.P66,
admitted
during
his
cross-
examination that the Investigating Officer attempted at three or
four places to get the data in the subject DVR developed but, as
the DVR was locked, the attempts
remained unsuccessful.
However, the Investigating Officer (PW65), taking a contrary
stand, stated during his cross-examination that they tried to open
the DVR, but could not be done so either by him or his staff.
Further, as per the prosecution case, the footage from the
DVR was copied onto the pen drive by Shri Umesh Kumar, who, as
PW37, corroborated it. However, taking a conflicting stand, the
Investigating Officer (PW65) categorically stated that the footage
onto the pen drive was copied by the CCTV expert, i.e., the PW37
through `cut-paste’ from the footage contained in the office
computer. It is worth noting here that neither the DVR nor the pen
drives onto which the footage was copied, were subjected to FSL
examination to verify that no tampering was done and the data
contained therein was intact.
Furthermore, the prosecution treated Shri Umesh Kumar as
an expert as he was operating a computer and CCTV shop in Sikar.
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(25 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
But, the Investigating Officer (PW65) admitted in his crossexamination that he did not obtain any document to show that
PW37 was a technical expert of DVRs and had obtained any
training in this regard. As a matter of fact, there was nothing on
record to suggest that Umesh Kumar was a technical expert
competent to copy data onto the pen drive, either from the DVR or
from the computer.
We further notice that Umesh Kumar (PW37), during his
cross-examination, stated that he did not know whether the data
and footage in the DVR had been manipulated or tampered with
before he copied the same onto the pen drive. He also stated that
the pen drive was brought by the police and he was unaware
whether it was empty or preloaded. From the aforesaid, it is
apparent that even the expert relied upon by the prosecution did
not vouch for the authenticity and integrity of the data contained
in the DVR and copied onto the pen drive.
Moreover, the prosecution relied upon the letter dated
08.02.2020-Ex.P98 issued by PW37 to the Deputy Superintendent
of Police, Circle Sikar Rural, as the certificate under Section 65B of
the Act of 1872. However, PW37 admitted during his crossexamination that the typed letter-Ex.P98 was brought to him by
the police and that he merely put his signature and seal on it. This
fact undermines the integrity and probative value of the certificate
issued under Section 65B(4). Further, as per Ex.P98, when Umesh
Kumar reached the CO Office, the DVR was already lying there,
but the prosecution did not lead any evidence to show who
brought it from the malkhana and when. At the cost of repetition,
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(26 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
we may observe here that as per the malkhana register-Ex.P265A,
after it was deposited on 25.10.2019, it was taken out only on
14.04.2020 and not earlier either on 07.11.2019 or on any other
day.
Thus, from the conspectus of aforesaid analysis of the
evidence, we find that the DVR installed at the house of the
appellant Ramgopal was seized on 25.10.2019, i.e., on the fourth
day of the incident, despite the Investigating Officer and other
police personnel visiting the house almost on a daily basis for the
previous three days and no explanation was furnished as to why it
was not seized at the earliest. It is also revealed that the DVR was
under the control of the parents and other family members of the
appellant Ramgopal and was not in his exclusive control and
possession. The DVR was seized in an unsealed condition and was
deposited as such in the malkhana on the date of its seizure, i.e.,
25.10.2019. Indisputably, it was found in the unsealed condition in
the CO office of Sikar Rural on 07.11.2019, when the footage was
copied onto the pen drive, but there was no corresponding entry
of it being taken out on that day in the malkhana registerEx.P265A. Moreover, as per prosecution case, the footage from it
was copied onto the pen drive which was seized vide memoEx.P65; however, we find a contradiction in the prosecution case
as to whether the footage onto the pen drive was copied from the
DVR, as claimed by PW37 or from the computer through `cut
paste' as stated by the Investigating Officer (PW65). We also find
that the so-called expert (PW37) did not vouch for the integrity
and authenticity of the data contained in the DVR and also
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(27 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
admitted that he did not examine the pen drive to see whether it
was blank or preloaded. It is also revealed that the pen drive was
seized vide Ex.P65 on 07.11.2019, but was neither sealed nor
deposited in the malkhana. The pen drive-Article 1 was played in
Court on 12.09.2024 during the course of testimony of the
Investigating Officer (PW65) but the prosecution did not lead any
evidence to show where the pen drive was lying from the date of
its seizure, i.e., 07.11.2019, till it was played in the Court on
12.09.2024.
It is trite law that, before any electronic evidence/ sample
can be relied upon against an accused, it is bounden duty of the
prosecution to establish a safe and unbroken chain of custody.
Their Lordships have, in State of Tamil Nadu Vs. Ponnusamy
and others, MANU/SC/0498/2026 : 2026 INSC 507, while
rejecting the gait analysis report relied on by the prosecution to
show the complicity of the accused in the crime, held that the
CCTV footage could not be relied upon on account of serious
apprehensions regarding its mishandling and an inconsistent chain
of custody. It was observed that the pen drive onto which the
CCTV footages were copied, was kept by the officer copying it and
was never examined as a witness by the prosecution. It was
further held that the IO failed to act on the CCTV footage for over
a month, and when it was recovered, it was forwarded to the FSL,
but was returned unexamined for want of the DVR. After
examining the facts of the case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
observed that the Investigating Officer had completely mishandled
(28 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
the electronic evidence and had failed to maintain the chain of
custody.
In Prakash Nishad vs. State of Maharashtra: AIR 2023
SC 2938, the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India held that that the
samples collected by the Investigating Agency must be sent to the
FSL with promptitude and without any delay to rule out the
possibility of contamination and the concomitant prospect of
diminishment in value, and the prosecution must establish the
chain of custody, which implies that right from the time of taking
of the samples to the time their role in the investigation and
processes subsequent is complete, each person handling such a
piece
of
evidence
documentation,
so
must
as
to
be
duly
ensure
acknowledged
that
its
in
integrity
the
is
uncompromised. It was observed that the alertness with which the
samples are sent to the FSL and the maintenance of the chain of
custody are vital aspects which are indispensable to the vitality of
such evidence. It was further held that a document should be duly
maintained, cataloging the custody and it should include the name
or initials of the individual collecting the evidence, each person or
entity subsequently having custody of it, the dates on which the
items were collected or transferred, the agency and case number,
the victim’s or the suspect’s name and the brief description of the
item.
Thus, in the backdrop of the aforesaid precedential law and
the factual context narrated hereinabove, we are of the considered
view that since the prosecution failed to maintain a complete and
unbroken chain of custody of the subject CCTV footage, it was not
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(29 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
safe for the learned trial court to rely upon the CCTV footage
copied from the DVR attached to the CCTV cameras installed at
the house of Ramgopal to return a finding of guilt against the
appellants.
There is another important aspect of the matter. Section 65B
of the Act of 1872 envisages that before secondary electronic
evidence can be relied upon, a certificate in terms of Section
65B(4)
is
mandatory.
Indisputably,
the
DVR,
the
primary
electronic evidence, was relied upon neither by the prosecution
nor by the learned trial court and they both relied upon the
footage copied onto the pen drive, i.e., the secondary electronic
evidence. The prosecution has submitted the purported certificate
in the form of a letter-Ex.P98 written by Umesh (PW-37).
However, we are not convinced.
A three-judge bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Anvar
P.V. versus P.K. Basheer :AIR 2015 SC 180, after examining
the scheme of the Act of 1872 pertaining to electronic evidence,
held as under:
“13. Any documentary evidence by way of an electronic
record under the Evidence Act, in view of Sections 59 and
65A, can be proved only in accordance with the procedure
prescribed under Section 65B. Section 65B deals with the
admissibility of the electronic record. The purpose of these
provisions is to sanctify secondary evidence in electronic
form, generated by a computer.
It may be noted that the Section starts with a non obstante
clause. Thus, notwithstanding anything contained in the
Evidence Act, any information contained in an electronic
record which is printed on a paper, stored, recorded or
copied in optical or magnetic media produced by a computer
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(30 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
shall be deemed to be a document only if the conditions
mentioned under sub- Section (2) are satisfied, without
further proof or production of the original. The very
admissibility of such a document, i.e., electronic record
which is called as computer output, depends on the
satisfaction of the four conditions under Section 65B(2).
Following are the specified conditions under Section 65B(2)
of the Evidence Act:
(i) The electronic record containing the information should
have been produced by the computer during the period over
which the same was regularly used to store or process
information for the purpose of any activity regularly carried
on over that period by the person having lawful control over
the use of that computer;
(ii) The information of the kind contained in electronic record
or of the kind from which the information is derived was
regularly fed into the computer in the ordinary course of the
said activity;
(iii) During the material part of the said period, the computer
was operating properly and that even if it was not operating
properly for some time, the break or breaks had not affected
either the record or the accuracy of its contents; and
(iv) The information contained in the record should be a
reproduction or derivation from the information fed into the
computer in the ordinary course of the said activity.
14. Under Section 65B(4) of the Evidence Act, if it is desired
to give a statement in any proceedings pertaining to an
electronic record, it is permissible provided the following
conditions are satisfied:
(a) There must be a certificate which identifies the electronic
record containing the statement;
(b) The certificate must describe the manner in which the
electronic record was produced;
(c) The certificate must furnish the particulars of the device
involved in the production of that record;
(31 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
(d) The certificate must deal with the applicable conditions
mentioned under Section 65B(2) of the Evidence Act; and
(e) The certificate must be signed by a person occupying a
responsible official position in relation to the operation of the
relevant device.”
Although, the aforesaid judgment has been reckoned not to
lay down good law to the extent it required the certificate to
accompany
the
secondary
electronic
evidence;
but,
the
proposition contained in para 14 has been reaffirmed time and
again by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India.
Thus, before a certificate under Section 65B(4) can be relied
upon, the conditions prescribed in para 14 of the judgement in
Anvar P.V. are required to be satisfied. However, we find that in
the instant case, the mandatory conditions were given a complete
go-bye. The letter-Ex.P98 did not furnish the particulars of the
devices involved in the production of the record. Nor did it deal
with the applicable conditions mentioned under Section 65B(2) of
the Act. Rather, the person issuing the letter, namely, Umesh
Kumar (PW37) admitted during cross-examination that he did not
know whether the DVR was tampered with. He further stated that
he was unaware whether the pen drive brought by police was
empty or preloaded. He also admitted that the typed letter-Ex.P98
was produced before him by the police personnel and he merely
signed it, which further undermined the sanctity of the certificate.
Although, in this regard, the prosecution has relied upon a
recent judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Kumari
Shubha alias Shubhashankar (supra), but, we are afraid that it
does not came to its rescue. In that case, it was held that the
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(32 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
certificate not given in the prescribed format per se will not make
it invalid, especially when authenticity of the marked documents
was not in dispute. In that case, the secondary electronic evidence
was in the shape of call detail records and a certificate issued by a
person holding the position of Head of Marketing and sales and
coordinator for statutory legal enforcement agencies, and the
Assistant Manager were held to be holding the responsible official
positions and to be competent to issue the certificate. However, in
the instant case, the facts are entirely different, as discussed and
analysed hereinabove.
In the conspectus of aforesaid analysis of evidence available
on record and in the backdrop of the settled legal principles, we
are of the view that the letter-Ex.P98 did not meet the mandatory
requirement of a valid certificate under Section 65 B(4) of the Act
of 1872 rendering the CCTV footage contained onto the pen driveArticle 1 inadmissible in evidence. On that premise also, we are of
the considered view that the learned trial court erred in placing
reliance upon the CCTV footage played in the Court on 12.09.2024
during the deposition of the Investigating Officer, Rajesh Arya
(PW65). However, to demonstrate that the findings of the trial
court in this regard are based on assumptions not supported by
any legally admissible evidence, we would like to refer the same
as under:
In the first folder of the footage, a vehicle and a motorcycle
were seen, but their registration numbers were not visible. Since
the footage was in black and white, colour of the vehicles was also
not reflected. In the second folder, a few persons were visible, but
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(33 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
on account of darkness, their faces were not visible. In the third
folder, a lady, a boy and a girl were seen, whom the Investigating
Officer identified as mother of Prem and brother/sister. The person
in a white banyan was identified by the witness as Ramgopal. The
defence objected that neither the face nor the physique of any of
the persons was visible in the picture. In the sixth folder, a person
was found bringing a wire or rope in his hand whom the witness
identified as Ramgopal, but the defence objected that on account
of darkness, his face or the physique were not clear. In the eighth
folder, the man in the white banyan was seen beating a sleeping
girl with a wire who were identified as Ramgopal and Prem,
respectively. The defence again objected that their faces were not
clearly visible. In the ninth folder, the person in white banyan was
seen beating a girl. Thereafter, he handed a mobile phone to the
girl, who was seen talking on it. The witness identified the man as
Ramgopal and the girl as Prem. He further stated that Ramgopal
was asking his daughter Prem to summon her lover Ganpat.
Thus, the defence repeatedly objected, while the pen
drive-Article 1 was being played, that the faces and / or physique
of the persons seen in the footage were not clearly visible or
identifiable on account of darkness or otherwise; but, without
addressing these objections, the learned trial court recorded a
finding that the person in white banyan was Ramgopal and the girl
being beaten was his daughter, the deceased Prem. In this regard,
the learned trial court also relied upon the photograph pasted on
the arrest memo-Ex.P12 of the appellant Ramgopal to compare it
with the image in the CCTV footage to record a finding that both
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(34 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
were the same person. However, it is trite law that an arrest
memo is not a substantive piece of evidence and the prosecution
did not prove, by leading any evidence, that the photograph
pasted on it was that of the appellant Ramgopal. Out of the two
motbir witnesses to the arrest memo, namely, Jagdish and Raju
Tiwari, only Jagdish was examined who, as PW2, did not utter a
word that the arrest memo bore photograph of the appellant
Ramgopal. As a matter of fact, there was no evidence on record to
demonstrate who pasted the photo on the arrest memo and when,
and whether it was of the appellant Ramgopal.
Furthermore, although, the Investigating Officer (PW65)
claimed to have identified the appellant Ramgopal and the
deceased Prem in the CCTV footage but, he categorically admitted
during his cross examination that, before the incident, he was not
acquainted either with the appellant Ramgopal or with his family
members.
Additionally, one of the motbir witnesses to Ex.P66, namely,
Pawan Kumar (PW19) also admitted in his cross-examination that
he was not acquainted with Ramgopal and that he could not
identify him even on the date of deposition.
In the aforesaid factual backdrop, we are not convinced that
it was safe for the learned trial court to hold the image in the
CCTV footage played in the Court to be that of the appellant
Ramgopal, especially without meeting the objection raised by the
defence that neither the face nor the physique was clearly visible
or identifiable on account of darkness or poor clarity.
(35 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
It is also worth noticing here that while Ex.P66, the footage
analysis report dated 07.11.2019, (veracity of which we have
already
found
to
be
doubtful
for
the
reasons
mentioned
hereinabove) records that the footage of the camera No. 3 dated
21.10.2019, at about 20:25 hours, showed that the appellant
Ramgopal had taken a piece of cable after cutting it, but the same
pen drive, when played in the Court on 12.09.2024, did not reflect
any such footage. However, the prosecution did not explain this
important omission. Since it was the prosecution story, based on
the CCTV footage, that the deceased were beaten to death by the
appellants with the pieces of cable cut from a bundle of cable by
the appellant Ramgopal, the absence of such footage onto the pen
drive, when played in the Court, assumes great significance and
further undermines the credibility of the footage contained onto
the pen drive.
In view of the aforesaid analysis, we do not concur with the
findings of the learned trial court based on the CCTV footage
played from the pen drive-Article 1. Rather, we hold that the
prosecution was not able to establish that the appellant Ramgopal
was seen beating his daughter Prem on the night of 21.10.2019.
Now, we would like to deal with the footage obtained from
the CCTV cameras installed at the petrol pump.
As per the prosecution, the footage revealed that some of
the appellants caught hold of Ganpat Lal at the petrol pump, beat
him and took him away in a passenger vehicle with “Rainbow
Children Academy” written on its side.
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(36 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
The footage was copied on 24.10.2019 onto a pen drive
which was seized vide memo even dated-Ex.P14. The memo does
not show that the pen drive was sealed at the time of its seizure.
Further, it does not reveal who had copied the footage onto the
pen drive and from which source, i.e., whether from the computer
attached to the cameras or the hard disk or the DVR. One of the
motbir witnesses to it, namely, Jagdish (PW2), simply stated that
a pen drive was seized by the police personnel from the petrol
pump in his presence and the memo-Ex.P14 was signed by him.
However, during his cross-examination, he stated that the CCTV
footage was seen by the Circle Officer in the morning of the
23.10.2019. At one stage of the cross-examination, he stated that
CCTV record was seized by the CO on 23 rd itself; however,
subsequently denying that any such footage was seized on the
23rd, he stated that it was seized on 24.10.2019. He professed
ignorance as to who had transferred the data onto the pen drive.
Another motbir witness, namely, Bhagchand (PW10) stated that
the pen drive was furnished by Mahendra Gurjar, one of the
appellants. He further stated in his cross-examination that the pen
drive was developed by the police personnel. Richpal Singh
(PW61), the first Investigating Officer, stated that he seized the
pen drive on 24.10.2019. However, he admitted that it was neither
sealed nor, bore the signature of either the petrol pump owner or
of any employee. The second Investigating Officer (PW65)
admitted during his cross-examination that the subject pen drive
was received by him from the earlier Investigating Officer. Further,
indisputably, it was not deposited in the malkhana.
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(37 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
In view thereof, it is apparent that the prosecution evidence
is completely silent as to who had copied the CCTV footage onto
the pen drive and from which source. Moreover, the pen drive was
neither sealed nor deposited in the malkhana.
Furthermore, the prosecution relied upon a certificate dated
14.01.2020-Ex.P75 and a letter of even date-Ex.P76; both issued
by Shri Shrawan Singh, the owner of the petrol pump as the
certificates under Section 65B(4) of the Act of 1872. While the
certificate-Ex.P75, does not mention who had prepared the pen
drive, the letter-Ex.P76 mentioned that its author got the data
retrieved onto the pen drive, but was silent as to through whom.
However, as is apparent from Ex.P14-the seizure memo of the pen
drive and the statements of motbir witnesses, it bore signature
neither of the petrol pump owner, i.e., Shri Shrawan Singh nor of
any of the staff members and on that premise, the validity and
sanctity of the letter-Ex.P76 become doubtful. Further, Shrawan
Singh had turned hostile as PW26 having denied issuing either the
certificate under Section 65B or the letter in respect thereof. He,
however, during his cross-examination by the learned Additional
Public Prosecutor, admitted his signatures on Ex.P75 and Ex.P76,
but stated categorically, in the same breath, that the signatures
were obtained by the police personnel on blank papers.
In addition, both the certificate and the letter mentioned that
the subject footage was copied onto a video CD and a pen drive
but, conspicuously, no video CD was seized and produced in
evidence
by
the
certificate/letter.
prosecution
to
lend
credibility
to
the
(38 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
It is worth noticing here that though the incident is alleged
to have taken place on 21.10.2019, the pen drive of the CCTV
footage was seized on 24.10.2019 and the subject DVR attached
to the CCTV cameras installed at the petrol pump was seized as
late as on 06.02.2020 vide memo-Ex.P68 and no explanation was
furnished for this inordinate delay in its seizure. Although, the
DVR was deposited in the malkhana on the date of its seizure as is
apparent from the malkhana register (Ex.P265A); however, it also
reflects that it was taken out on 14.04.2020, but the evidence is
silent, by whom. The malkhana In-charge, Nannu Ram (PW67),
admitted during his cross-examination that there was no entry in
the register who had taken out the DVR and for what purpose. He
also admitted that it was also not mentioned whether the DVR was
redeposited in a sealed condition.
Moreover, we find that the footage analysis report-Ex.P67
was prepared in the CO office on 07.11.2019 by playing the pen
drive in the office computer. Although, this report discloses the
description
of
the
pen
drive;
however,
conspicuously,
no
description was given either in the seizure memo-Ex.P14 or in
certificate purportedly issued under Section 65B(4)-Ex.P75 or in
the letter-Ex.P76, which raises grave suspicion about its validity.
Further, Ex.P67 does not show who had brought the pen drive to
the office and from where.
We also notice that although, some of the appellants have
allegedly been identified in the footage analysis report, but the
Investigating Officer (PW65) admitted that at the time of its
preparation in his office, no independent person was available to
(39 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
identify the appellants. He further admitted that no marks of
identification
of
the
appellants
named
in
the
report
were
mentioned nor was it mentioned that their faces were clearly
visible. In view thereof, in our considered opinion, the footage
analysis report-Ex.P67, which otherwise is not a substantive piece
of evidence, carries no probative value qua the complicity of the
appellants allegedly identified therein.
Furthermore, the aforesaid analysis of evidence reveals that
the CCTV footage at the petrol pump was seen on 22.10.2019 or
23.10.2019 and in any case, before copying the same onto the
pen
drive
on 24.10.2019
vide memo-Ex.P14.
However,
no
explanation for this delay in the seizure of the pen drive was
furnished by the prosecution. Further, the pen drive was neither
sealed nor deposited in the malkhana and the seizure memo did
not contain a description of the pen drive. The prosecution could
not lead any evidence to show who had copied the CCTV footage
onto the pen drive and from which source. The footage analysis
report-Ex.P67 was prepared on 07.11.2019 in the CO office by
playing the pen drive in the office computer, but it was not
revealed who had brought it to the CO office and from where.
Moreover, it was played in the Court on 12.09.2024 with no
evidence to show where it was lying interregnum. The subject DVR
was seized on 06.02.2020, i.e., with a delay of about three and a
half months from the date of the incident for which no explanation
was furnished. As per the entry in the malkhana registerEx.P265A, it was taken out from the malkhana on 14.04.2020, but
there is no corresponding entry as to by whom and for what
(40 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
purpose. The malkhana In-charge, Nannu Ram (PW67), stated
that he was unaware who had taken it, for what purpose and
when it was redeposited in the malkhana. Thus, the prosecution
miserably failed to show a chain of custody with regard to CCTV
footage at the petrol pump rendering its authenticity and integrity
doubtful.
Furthermore, the aforesaid pen drive-Article 2 was played in
the Court on 12.09.2024 during the deposition of Investigating
Officer. As per it, the deceased Ganpat and the appellants Beerbal
Dhaka, Sohanlal, Nandlal, Babulal Faldoliya, Ramgopal and Rajesh
were identified by the Investigating Officer. He, however, during
his cross-examination as PW65, admitted that before the incident,
he was acquainted neither with Ramgopal nor with the other
accused-appellants. In view thereof, it is highly doubtful how he
could have identified either the deceased or the appellants in the
footage onto the pen drive. Moreover, the defence raised an
objection that the faces of the person sitting in the vehicle and of
those present nearby, were not clearly visible and, therefore, were
not identifiable. It was also admitted by the Investigating Officer
that the faces of the four persons namely Ganpat, Beerbal Dhaka,
Sohanlal Jat and Nandlal Meena were not clearly visible, but
claimed
that
they
were
identifiable
from
their
gait
and
appearance, and on zooming in the video. However, in the same
breath, he admitted that there was no material on record to
demonstrate that he identified these persons by zooming in the
video footage. He also admitted that the face of the appellant
Babulal Faldoliya was not visible in the CCTV footage but, he was
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(41 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
identified from his gait and appearance alone. He further admitted
that none of the persons sitting in the vehicle was visible or
identifiable. One of the motbir witnesses to Ex.P67, namely,
Pawan Kumar (PW19) also admitted in his cross-examination that
he could not identify any of the appellants named therein.
It is worth noticing here that if the Investigating Officer was
not acquainted with the appellants visible in the footage, it was
almost impossible for him to have identified them by their gait and
appearance which, even assuming does not require some special
skill, requires, at least, an evaluation based on several distinct
characteristics, such as build, symmetry, posture, step-length etc.
Furthermore, a perusal of the impugned judgement reflects
that the learned trial court has recorded a finding of guilt against
the appellants allegedly identified in the CCTV footage
by
comparing the images with their photographs pasted on the arrest
memos ignoring and overlooking that the prosecution did not lead
any evidence to show when and by whom the photographs were
pasted on the arrest memo. As already observed, an arrest memo
is not a substantive piece of evidence.
There is another important aspect of the matter. The
complainant, the younger brother of the deceased, namely, Baldev
Godara (PW1), admitted during his cross-examination that in his
Section 161 Cr.P.C. statement-Ex.D2, he had stated that Mahendra
Gurjar and Rajesh had deleted the CCTV footage of the petrol
pump at the instance of the appellant Ramgopal. Bhagchand
(PW10), brother-in-law of the deceased Ganpat Lal, also stated
that
Mahendra
Gurjar
informed
them
that
he,
along
with
(42 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Ramgopal and Rajesh, deleted the footage. During his crossexamination, he claimed to have stated in his Section 161 Cr.P.C.
statement-Ex.D4 that the subject CCTV footage from the petrol
pump was deleted, but he did not know why this was not so
mentioned therein. However, he admitted that it was rightly stated
in Ex.D4 that the subject footage was deleted. Moreover, the
appellant Rajesh Kumar has been found guilty of the offence under
Section 201 IPC, i.e., of deleting the CCTV footage, on the
morning of 22.10.2019, from the DVR installed at the petrol
pump. On that premise, it is doubtful how the CCTV footage was
copied onto the pen drive, which was seized vide Ex.P14 on
24.10.2019.
In
Chandra
Bhan
Sudam
Sanap
Vs.
State
of
Maharashtra; 2025 INSC 116, the Hon'ble Supreme Court of
India was pleased to allow the appeal preferred by the accusedappellant facing death penalty on accounts, inter alia, that
infirmities were found in the CCTV footage relied upon by the
prosecution and for want of a proper and valid Section 65-B of the
Act of 1872.
It was precisely held as under:"41. We find that the infirmities referred to by
the defence namely, about the life span of the CCTV
footage in DVR-II being 12 days; the absence of
identification of both the appellant and deceased in the
same footage by the witnesses; the absence of
explanation as to how the Police knew that the person
PW-18 and 19 were speaking to was the same person
in the footage and other infirmities raised have not
been adequately answered by the prosecution in its
evidence. Learned Additional Solicitor General Mr. Raja
Thakare painstakingly took us through the available
evidence and objectively placed the matter before us.
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(43 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
However, from the material available on record, these
lingering doubts in our mind have not been adequately
addressed."
In the conspectus of the aforesaid analysis, we are unable to
persuade ourselves to agree with the findings recorded by the
learned trial court as to the complicity of the appellants based on
the CCTV footage obtained either from the house of the appellant
Ramgopal or from the petrol pump. Therefore, we hold that the
prosecution failed to establish the evidence of `last seen'.
After meticulously scanning the evidence available on record,
we notice that the prosecution appears to be labouring under a
confusion and has come with self-contradictory stories as to the
manner in which the incident took place. On the one hand, it has
been the prosecution case that on the fateful night of 21.10.2019,
until the CCTV cameras installed at his house were switched off by
the appellant Ramgopal at about 10.00 PM, he was seen beating
his daughter Prem. Thereafter, Prem and Ganpat Lal went to the
petrol pump together Ganpat Lal's motorcycle from where they
were kidnapped and taken to Ramgopal's house in a passenger
vehicle, where they were beaten to death. To this extent, the
prosecution story appears to be plain and simple. However, there
is an incomprehensible and irreconcilable twist in the story. The
appellant Mehendra Singh Choudhary has been convicted by the
learned trial Court on the allegation that he brought Prem in a
Scorpio car from her maternal uncle's home, and as per the CCTV
footage of the Toll Plaza, the Scorpio car was found to be travelling
from the Jaipur side towards Sikar in the intervening night of 2122.10.2019 at about 00.22 hours. However, neither the name of
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(44 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
the maternal uncle nor his address was disclosed by the
prosecution. Be that as it may, we fail to reconcile both the
stories. If Prem was present at Sikar from 8.00 PM till she was
beaten to death any time after 11.30 PM, how could she have
been brought to Sikar from a place situated towards Jaipur in the
same night after 00.22 hours.
Be that as it may, we, now, proceed to examine another link
in the chain of circumstantial evidence.
(2) Recovery of Incriminating Evidence:
Once the important link in the chain of circumstances relied
upon by the prosecution, i.e., last seen based on the CCTV
footage, collapses, we are left only with recovery of incriminating
evidence on the disclosure statement of the appellants or
otherwise.
Appellant Ramgopal:
The following incriminating evidence was found against the
appellant Ramgopal on his disclosure statement or otherwise:(1) Discovery of the scene of crime, (2) recovery of a piece of
cable, (3) discovery of the place where the dead bodies were
disposed of, and recovery of blood stained soil and leaves from
there, (4) recovery of a Bolero car allegedly used in the disposal of
the dead bodies and (5) lodging of a false report-Ex.P110 by him.
Insofar as the scene of crime is concerned, its site plan is
Ex.P82 which reflects that on the night of 21.10.2019, the
appellant Ramgopal brought his daughter Prem and her lover
Ganpat Lal from Palsana in a vehicle and beat them to death in
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(45 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
the room marked `X’. The bloodstains from the room were
recovered vide seizure memo-Ex.P32.
In this regard, it may be relevant to mention here that the
prosecution has come out with a story that Prem was forced by
her father to summon Ganpat Lal over mobile phone; both of
them reached the petrol pump at Palsana Bypass on Ganpat Lal's
motorcycle from where they were kidnapped, brought to the
house of the appellant Ramgopal, were beaten to death in the
subject room and their bodies were disposed of at another place.
Dharampal (PW69), the then Assistant Sub-Inspector at Police
Station Ranoli, stated in his examination-in-chief that upon receipt
of information that a girl had been kidnapped, he went to the
petrol pump, where the employees informed him that in the
intervening night of 21-22.10.2019, 3-4 persons had come in a
passenger vehicle following a girl and a boy and had taken them
away in that vehicle and the entire episode was shown to him in
the CCTV recording. In his cross-examination, he emphasised that
he had seen in the CCTV footage a boy and girl coming to the
petrol pump on a black motorcycle, the girl wearing a salwar suit
and the boy a pant and shirt. The Investigating Officer (PW65)
also stated during his cross-examination that he had found during
the investigation that the deceased Prem had come to the petrol
pump with the deceased Ganpat Lal on a motorcycle and the
motorcycle was parked beside the petrol pump. The complicity of
the appellant Sandeep Gurjar in the crime has been found on the
allegation that he followed Prem and Ganpat on the motorcycle of
the appellant Ramgopal and caught hold of them. However,
neither was any charge of kidnapping of Prem framed, nor did the
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(46 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
prosecution lead any such evidence to establish that Prem had
come to the petrol pump on a motorcycle along with deceased
Ganpat Lal from where they were kidnapped by some of the
appellants in a passenger vehicle and were taken to her home.
Rather, we find unexplained and glaring gaps in this story. Firstly,
as per the CCTV footage of the house of the appellant, he was
found to be severely beating his daughter Prem between 8.30 PM
to 10.00 PM.
Although, the Investigating Officer (PW65) stated in his
deposition on 12.09.2024 when the pen drive Article-1 was played
in Court, that Ramgopal forced his daughter Prem to summon her
lover Ganpat over the mobile phone but, indisputably, the footage
contained no audio. Further, as already observed, there was no
evidence on record to identify the man as Ramgopal and the girl
as Prem. Moreover, the prosecution did not lead any evidence to
demonstrate that there was any mobile conversation between
Prem and Ganpat Lal on the night of 21.10.2019. We have also
held that there is no evidence available on record to show that
Prem and Ganpat Lal had left for the petrol pump together on a
motorcycle from where they were allegedly kidnapped. As a
matter of fact, there was no evidence on record to show that they
were seen together on the fateful night.
In addition, as per the CCTV footage of the petrol pump,
Ganpat Lal was seen running in a black T-shirt at about 11.18 PM.
However, as per Shri Dharampal (PW69), he saw the deceased
Ganpat Lal at the petrol pump in a pant and shirt. Be that as it
may, as per the allegation found to be proved against the
appellant Mahendra Kumar Choudhary, he brought Prem on the
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(47 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
fateful night from her maternal uncle’s home to her paternal
home. However, neither the name of her maternal uncle nor his
address was disclosed by the prosecution. Moreover, as per the
testimony of Murari Lal Sharma (PW13), the Shift In-charge,
Reliance Toll Plaza, the Scorpio car allegedly used by Mahendra
Kumar Choudhary in bringing Prem, passed through the Toll Plaza
in the intervening night of 21-22.10.2019 at about 00.22 hours
travelling from Jaipur to Sikar and returned towards Jaipur the
same night at about 03.10 AM. If the prosecution case is believed
Prem was severally beaten by her father Ramgopal at their house
until 10.00 PM in the night of 21.10.2019. Thereafter, both the
deceased came to petrol pump on a motorcycle driven by Ganpat
Lal and in the CCTV footage of the petrol pump, Ganpat Lal was
seen running at about 11.18 PM and he was kidnapped from there
by some of the appellants in a passenger vehicle. Meaning
thereby, some time after 10.00 PM, Prem and Ganpat Lal met and
came together on motorcycle to the petrol pump, from where they
were kidnapped and were taken to house of Ramgopal in a
passenger vehicle where they were beaten to death. If the
incident happened in the manner claimed by the prosecution, how
could the appellant Mahendra Kumar Choudhary have brought
Prem from Jaipur to Sikar that too, if the testimony of Murari Lal
Sharma is to be believed, after 00.22 hours as the subject vehicle
was claimed to have passed at that time from the Toll Plaza
travelling from Jaipur towards Sikar. Moreover, as per the
prosecution case itself, before Prem came to the petrol pump
along with Ganpat Lal, she had already been severely beaten by
her father with a cable, which should inevitably have entailed
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(48 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
profuse bleeding but, conspicuously, no bloodstains were found at
the petrol pump, Ganpat Lal's motorcycle and in the passenger
vehicle in which they were allegedly carried to the house of the
appellant Ramgopal. Further, Prem was not visible at all in the
CCTV footage of the petrol pump. All this raises grave doubt as to
the veracity of the prosecution case.
Furthermore, so far as the scene of crime is concerned, the
Investigating Officer (PW65) admitted that it was under the
possession and control of the parents and other family members
of Ramgopal. He further admitted that he did not conduct any
investigation through the revenue authorities or otherwise as to
who owned and possessed the scene of crime. On that premise, it
could not be held that it was in the exclusive control and
possession of the appellant Ramgopal. Moreover, the blood seized
from the scene of the crime vide memo Ex.P32 was found to be
human blood as per the FSL report-Ex.P259, but the blood
grouping remained inconclusive. Their Lordships, in Raja Naykar
vs. State of Chhattisgarh: (2024) 3 SCC 481, held that in
absence of blood grouping, mere presence of human blood on the
sample is of no assistance to the prosecution case.
Another piece of incriminating evidence found against the
appellant Ramgopal was the recovery of the dead bodies on his
disclosure statement and recovery of blood smeared soil and tree
leaves from the place of recovery of the dead bodies. As per the
seizure memo-Ex.P78, the bodies were recovered on 23.10.2019,
at about 9.00 pm. Although, the time in the Ex.P78 has been
interpolated, which the prosecution could not explain; however,
the other evidence on record also creates a doubt as to the time
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(49 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
of its recovery. Ramgopal was arrested vide memo Ex.P12 on
23.10.2019 at 8.00 PM and he made disclosure statementEx.P143 on the same day at about 8.15 PM pursuant whereof the
bodies were recovered at 9.00 PM. However, the complainant
Baldev Godara (PW1) stated during his cross-examination that at
about 5-6 PM, he came to know from Ranoli Police Station that the
dead bodies of his brother Ganpat Lal and of Prem had been
recovered by the police at the instance of Ramgopal. The
Investigating Officer (PW65) also admitted during his crossexamination that the witnesses, namely, Baldev, Bhagchand,
Jagdish and some others had stated that the dead bodies were
recovered at about 5-6 PM on 23.10.2019. Manoj Kumar (PW29),
one of the motbir witnesses to Ex.P78-the seizure memo of the
dead bodies, had stated that the seizure was photographed and
videographed without the source of light being disclosed although
the place was unlit and deserted, and it was 9.00 PM in the winter
season. His statement was corroborated by another motbir
witness, namely, Jhabarmal (PW35). Thus, it is doubtful whether
the dead bodies were recovered on 23.10.2019 at 9.00 PM on the
disclosure statement of the appellant Ramgopal.
Further, insofar as the recovery of dead bodies on the
disclosure statement of Ramgopal is concerned, the information
given by him under Section 27 of the Act of 1872 was reduced in
writing vide Ex.P143. The relevant portion whereof reads as
under:
^^eSaus o esjs us lkfFk;ksa feydj fnukad 21-10-19 dh jk=h dks esjs ?kj
ij esjh yMdh izse o mlds izseh x.kir yky dh gR;k dj mudh
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(50 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
yk'kksa dks eSaus o esjs lkFk okyksa us th.kekrk ls vkxs g"kZ dh rjQ
tkus okyh jksM ds uhps Mky fn;k Fkk eSa pydj nksuksa dh yk'k
cjken djk ldrk gwaA**
"My companions and I together murdered my daughter
Prem and her lover Ganpat Lal at my house on the night of
21.10.19 and my companions and I had thrown their bodies
below the road going towards Harsh beyond Jeenmata. I can
go along and get the bodies of both recovered." (English
translation)
However, during his Court deposition, the Investigating
Officer Richpal Singh (PW61) said about Ex.P143 as under:
^^nkSjkus vuqla/kku eqyfte jkexksiky dks nQk 27 lk{; vf/kfu;e
dh bryk nh xbZ Fkh tks izn'kZ ih&143 gSA**
"During the investigation, accused Ramgopal was informed
under Section 27 of the Evidence Act, which is Exhibit P143." (English translation)
Thus, from the aforesaid, it is apparent that in his court
deposition, the Investigating Officer did not reproduce the exact
words as used by the appellant Ramgopal in his disclosure
statement; rather, stated that the appellant was informed under
Section 27.
Dealing with the issue as to how Section 27 information is to
be proved, the Hon’ble Apex Court, in Ramanand @ Nandlal
Bharti vs. State of Uttar Pradesh : (2023) 16 SCC 510,
refused to accept the evidence of discovery on the premise that
the Investigating Officer, in his oral evidence, did not state the
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(51 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
exact words uttered by the accused at the police station. It was
specifically held as under:
“59. The requirement of law that needs to be fulfilled before
accepting the evidence of discovery is that by proving the
contents of the panchnama. The investigating officer in his
deposition is obliged in law to prove the contents of the
panchnama and it is only if the investigating officer has
successfully proved the contents of the discovery panchnama
in accordance with law, then in that case the prosecution
may be justified in relying upon such evidence and the trial
court may also accept the evidence. In the present case,
what we have noticed from the oral evidence of the
investigating officer, PW7, Yogendra Singh is that he has not
proved the contents of the discovery panchnama and all that
he has deposed is that as the accused expressed his
willingness to point out the weapon of offence the same was
discovered under a panchnama. We have minutely gone
through this part of the evidence of the investigating officer
and are convinced that by no stretch of imagination it could
be said that the investigating officer has proved the contents
of the discovery panchnama (Exh.5). There is a reason why
we are laying emphasis on proving the contents of the
panchnama at the end of the investigating officer, more
particularly when the independent panch witnesses though
examined yet have not said a word about such discovery or
turned hostile and have not supported the prosecution. In
order to enable the Court to safely rely upon the evidence of
the investigating officer, it is necessary that the exact words
attributed to an accused, as statement made by him, be
brought on record and, for this purpose the investigating
officer is obliged to depose in his evidence the exact
statement and not by merely saying that a discovery
panchnama of weapon of offence was drawn as the accused
was willing to take it out from a particular place.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(52 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
73. Thus, in the absence of exact words, attributed to an
accused person, as statement made by him being deposed
by the investigating officer in his evidence, and also without
proving the contents of the panchnama (Exh.5), the trial
court as well as the High Court was not justified in placing
reliance upon the circumstance of discovery of weapon.”
Further, in Babu Sahebagouda Rudragoudar & Ors.
(supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court referring to the judgement in
Ramanand @ Nandlal Bharti (supra), held as under:
“The first and the basic infirmity in the evidence of all the
aforesaid prosecution witnesses is that none of them have
deposed the exact statement said to have been made by
the appellant herein which ultimately led to the discovery of
a fact relevant under Section 27 of the Evidence Act.”
Thus, it was held in the aforesaid judgements that it was
obligatory upon the Investigating Officer to depose to the exact
words uttered by the accused in his disclosure statement, in the
absence whereof no reliance could be placed on the discovery
based on that disclosure statement. In the instant case, we have
noticed that the Investigating Officer, in his Court deposition, did
not state the exact words uttered by the appellant Ramgopal in his
disclosure statement-Ex.P143 and, therefore, we are of the view
that the learned trial court erred in placing reliance upon the
discovery of the dead bodies based on the information furnished
by Ramgopal under Section 27 of the Act of 1872.
Moreover, the blood smeared soil and the blood smeared tree
leaves from the place where the dead bodies were found were
seized on 25.10.2019 vide memo-Ex.P85 and were sealed in a
white cloth bag marked `E’. However, the prosecution furnished no
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(53 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
explanation as to why these articles were not recovered on the
day the dead bodies were seized, rather were seized with the
delay of two days. Moreover, as per the FSL report-Ex.P259, only
blood smeared soil was found in the packet-E and not the blood
smeared dry leaves. No explanation was furnished for the absence
of the blood smeared leaves from the packet-E which creates
doubt as to whether the sample was kept intact from the date of
its collection until it reached the FSL. Furthermore, as per the FSL
report, though the human blood was found in the blood smeared
soil, but the blood grouping remained inconclusive which does not
advance the prosecution case.
The next piece of incriminating evidence relied upon by the
prosecution against the appellant Ramgopal was the recovery, on
his disclosure statement, of a piece of cable allegedly used by him
in beating the deceased but, we do not find that the evidence on
record was sufficient to establish that it was the weapon of offence
used in the murder of Ganpat Lal and Prem. As per the
prosecution case, this piece of cable represented a part of a
bundle of cable lying at the house of the appellant Ramgopal from
which the appellant cut a number of pieces with a fodder cutter
machine which were also used by some of other appellants in the
commission of the offence. However, we find a huge gap in the
prosecution story in this regard. As per the prosecution, the
appellant was seen in the CCTV footage of his home cutting the
piece of cable with a fodder cutter. Although, we have not relied
upon the CCTV footage contained onto the pen drive-Article 1 but,
even assuming it to be genuine and authentic, we do not find that
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(54 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
any of the folders on the pen drive-Article 1 played in the Court on
12.09.2024, contained any footage of the appellant Ramgopal
cutting the pieces of cable with the fodder cutter. Further, as
admitted by the Investigating Officer (PW65), the fodder cutting
machine was not shown in any of the various site plans of the
subject house such as Ex.P2 or Ex.P24. Furthermore, indisputably,
the bundle of cable from which several pieces were allegedly cut,
was not seized by the investigating agency, in the absence
whereof we are unable to record a finding that the piece of cable
recovered at the instance of the appellant constituted part of the
bundle of cable. Additionally, its seizure memo-Ex.P15 does not
reflect it was blood stained, nor was it sent to FSL examination.
On that premise, we are not convinced that the appellant could
have been connected with the alleged crime with the aid of this
piece of incriminating evidence.
The next piece of incriminating evidence relied upon by the
prosecution against him was the recovery of a Bolero car allegedly
used in disposing of the dead bodies. As per the seizure memoEx.P31, it was recovered from the Khatushyamji Police Station.
Although, the prosecution came out with a story that the appellant
himself had parked this vehicle at the Police Station Khatushyamji,
but no evidence was led to substantiate it. Even otherwise, we
find substantial force in the submission advanced by his learned
Senior Counsel Shri Bajwa that it would be contrary to natural
human conduct for the appellant himself to park the very vehicle
at the Police Station which, allegedly was used in disposing of the
dead bodies. Although from the seat cover of the Bolero car,
(55 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
human
blood
was
detected
but,
[CRLDR-1/2024]
its
grouping
remained
inconclusive.
The learned trial court has also relied upon the reportEx.P110 lodged by the appellant on 23.10.2019 at Police Station
Khatushyamji with regard to kidnapping of his daughter Prem
which gave rise to FIR No.278/2019-Ex.P111, wherein the police,
after investigation, submitted a negative final report which was
stated to have been accepted by the jurisdictional court. However,
we do not find on record any order accepting the FR. Although, it
is trite law that the lodging of a false report by the accused about
the same incident shows an attempt to mislead the investigation
and is relevant conduct under Section 8 of the Act of 1872, but it
is also a well settled legal principle that neither the FIR nor the
negative Final Report is a substantive piece of evidence in itself.
The prosecution is under an obligation to prove the falsity of the
FIR at trial through witnesses and other legally admissible
evidence. However, in the instant case, apart from exhibiting
these documents, no further evidence was led to substantiate the
same. Even otherwise, it can be taken only as an additional link in
the chain of circumstances and not as a piece of the circumstantial
evidence in itself. On that premise, even assuming that the FIR
lodged by the appellant was found to be false, this fact alone does
not advance the case of the prosecution against him.
In the conspectus of aforesaid analysis, we are of the
considered view that the prosecution was not able to establish,
beyond
reasonable
doubt,
the
complicity
of
the
Ramgopal for the offences for which he was charged.
appellant
(56 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Appellants Mahadev, Parsaram Choudhary and Babulal @
Harnek:
The appellants, namely, Mahadev, Parsaram Choudhary and
Babulal @ Harnek have been convicted solely on the strength of
the recovery of a piece of cable wire from each of them on their
disclosure statements. The reasoning assigned by this Court in
disbelieving
the
prosecution
case
connecting
the
appellant
Ramgopal with the crime on the strength of the recovery of a
piece of cable, applies on all fours to the case of the aforesaid
appellants as well. In view thereof, we do not approve of the
findings of conviction recorded by the learned trial court against
them.
However, we find no merit in the submission advanced by the
learned Senior Counsel Shri Bajwa that the thickness of different
pieces of the cables recovered differed. In one of the seizure
memos, the thickness was shown as 5 cms. whereas, in some
other, it was stated to be a finger thick. Though, no evidence was
shown to us to demonstrate thickness of a finger, it is a matter of
common knowledge that the average thickness of an adult male's
finger is about 5-6 cms.
Appellant Sandeep Gurjar:
His conviction is recorded by the learned trial court on the
basis of recovery, on his disclosure statement, of a motorcycle
allegedly used by him in following the deceased Prem and Ganpat
and in catching hold of them.
As already held, the prosecution failed to lead any evidence
to show that Ganpat Lal and Prem were seen together on the
fateful night. On that premise, we find no occasion for the
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(57 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
appellant Sandeep Gurjar to follow them on a motorcycle. Further,
surprisingly, the prosecution is completely silent as to the place
from where the appellant started following Ganpat Lal and Prem
and where they were caught by him. In the conspectus of the
aforesaid analysis, we are not able to persuade ourselves to
sustain the finding of his guilt recorded by the learned trial court
vide the impugned judgement.
Appellant Beerbal Dhaka:
His complicity in the crime has been found by the learned
trial court on the basis of the recovery of a passenger vehicle vide
memo-Ex.P7 allegedly used in kidnapping of the deceased Ganpat
Lal from the petrol pump. As already held, we have disbelieved
the CCTV footage of the petrol pump relied upon by the
prosecution to show that Ganpat Lal was kidnapped by some of
the appellants in the subject vehicle. In addition, we find that no
incriminating material was recovered from the subject vehicle to
establish that it was used in the kidnapping of the deceased
Ganpat Lal. Further, indisputably, its registration number was not
visible in the CCTV footage and it was connected with the crime
only because “Rainbow Children Academy” was written on its side
as seen in the CCTV footage. However, the Investigating Officer
(PW65) did not deny a suggestion, put to him, during his crossexamination that the school might have had about 30 such
vehicles. In view thereof, we do not find it prudent to sustain the
finding of his guilt based on such sketchy evidence.
Appellant Sohanlal:
He has been found to be involved in the crime on the
strength of recovery of a piece of cable and the discovery of the
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(58 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
place where he allegedly burnt the mobile phone of the deceased
Ganpat Lal.
So far as the recovery of the cable is concerned, we have
already held it not to be an incriminating piece of evidence to
connect the appellant with the crime. Moreover, conspicuously,
thickness of the seized cable is not mentioned in the seizure
memo-Ex.P1.
So far as the discovery of the place where the mobile phone
of Ganpat Lal was burnt is concerned, its site plan-Ex.P94 clearly
records that no mobile related traces were found. We failed to
understand how, if the information under Section 27 of the Act of
1872 did not lead to discovery of a new fact, it could have been
relied upon against the appellant. On that premise, we are not
able to concur with the finding of his guilt recorded by the learned
trial court.
Appellant Nandlal:
He has been convicted on the basis of the recovery of a piece
of cable and seizure of a purse and PAN card belonging to the
deceased, on his disclosure statement.
So far as recovery of cable is concerned, we disbelieve the
same for the reasons assigned hereinabove qua the other
appellants.
So far as recovery of purse and PAN card is concerned, the
same were recovered, on his disclosure statement, about nine
months after the date of incident. Further, we find from the site
plan-Ex.P136 that it was an open place and, as admitted by the
Investigating Officer, was frequently visited by the villagers.
Furthermore, no evidence was brought to our notice to show that
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(59 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
the purse and the PAN card were identified as belonging to Ganpat
Lal. Even otherwise, we do not find it safe to sustain the finding of
his conviction on this count alone.
Moreover, we find that in his information under Section 27 of
the Act of 1872, the appellant had stated as under:
^^jkexksiky ehy dh yM+dh izse o mlds izseh x.kir dh gR;k ds
ckn jkexksiky us eq>s e`rd x.kir dk ,d ilZ fn;k Fkk] ftldks
eSus [kkjM+k esa QSad fn;k Fkk] og LFkku vc eSa vkids lkFk pydj
crkdj ilZ cjken djok ldrk gwaA^^
"After the murder of Prem, the daughter of Ramgopal Meel,
and her lover Ganpat, Ramgopal gave me a purse belonging
to the deceased Ganpat which I threw in Kharda. I can now
go with you, point out the place and get the purse
recovered." (English translation)
The Investigating Officer, in his Court deposition as PW65,
stated as under with regard to the disclosure statement:
“vkjksih uanyky mQZ uandkj dh /kkjk 27 lk{; vf/kfu;e dh
bryk tks e`rd x.kir ds ilZ dh cjkenxh ls lacaf/kr Fkh dks
eqfrZc fd;k Fkk tks izn'kZ ih&157 gSA”
"The information under Section 27 of the Evidence Act by
the accused Nandlal @ Nandkar relating to the recovery of
the purse of the deceased Ganpat was reduced to writing
which is Exhibit P-157."
Thus, the exact words uttered by the appellant were not
stated by the Investigating Officer in his Court deposition in
violation of the mandate of law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Ramanand @ Nandlal Bharti (supra) which renders the
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(60 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
discovery of the purse of the deceased pursuant thereto, of no
consequence.
Appellant Mahendra Kumar Choudhary:
His complicity in the crime was found by the learned trial
court on the strength of the recovery of a Scorpio car and a fan
belt. As per the prosecution, the Scorpio car was used by him in
bringing the deceased Prem from her maternal uncle’s home to
her paternal home and the fan belt was used in beating the
deceased. Murari Lal Sharma (PW13), the Shift In-charge,
Reliance Toll Plaza deposed, based on CCTV footage-Ex.P40 and
Ex.P41, that the subject Scorpio car passed through the Toll Plaza
in the intervening night of 21-22.10.2019 at about 00.22 hours
travelling from Jaipur towards Sikar and returned towards Jaipur
on the same night at about 03.10 AM. However, during his crossexamination, he stated that only System Manager could say
whether the data of the CCTV footage-Ex.P40 and Ex.P41 could be
manipulated or not. He further stated that he was unaware if the
wrong data was fed by the Operator into the footage.
In view thereof, his testimony, based on Ex.P40 and 41, is
rendered of no consequence. Even assuming it to be reliable, it
was not the prosecution case that Prem was at her maternal
Uncle’s home at Jaipur, had returned to Sikar after midnight of
21.10.2019; rather, as per the prosecution story, she was beaten
by her father at their home between 8.30 PM to 10 PM on the
night of 21.10.2019 which belies the case that the subject Scorpio
Car was used for bringing her from her maternal Uncle’s home.
Similarly, the fan belt recovered from the car was neither found to
be blood stained nor subjected to FSL examination to substantiate
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(61 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
the plea that it was used in beating the deceased. On that
premise, we do not approve the findings of his guilt recorded by
the learned trial court.
Appellant Rajesh Kumar:
Although, the charge against him was of attempting to delete
the CCTV footage from the cabin of the petrol pump but, he has
been convicted under Section 201 IPC. Even otherwise, the
findings of the learned trial court in this regard are based on the
CCTV footage contained onto the pen drive-Article 2. Since we
have already disbelieved the CCTV footage contained onto the pen
drive,
his conviction based thereon cannot be sustained in the
eyes of law.
Furthermore, as per the impugned judgment, he was
identified in the CCTV footage by the Investigating Officer (PW65)
and after comparing his image in the CCTV footage with the
photograph appended to his arrest memo-Ex.P19, the learned trial
court held the person in the footage to be the appellant. However,
an arrest memo is not a substantive piece of evidence and none of
the prosecution witnesses proved that the photograph appended
to it was that of the appellant. Rather, Subhash Chand (PW32),
one of the motbir witnesses to the arrest memo, categorically
admitted in his cross-examination that the photograph was not
brought by the appellant rather, had been developed later on,
though he professed ignorance as to where. He also admitted that
the photograph was pasted later and it did not exist at the time of
the arrest. Moreover, a photograph is not primary evidence, rather
secondary evidence and, if taken with the digital camera, is
secondary electronic evidence. Since neither the negative nor a
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(62 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Section 65B(4) certificate was produced along with the subject
photograph, we find that it was not proved in evidence. In view
thereof, the learned trial court erred in relying upon the
photograph affixed to the arrest memo-Ex.P19.
Appellant Madanlal:
The learned trial court has recorded his conviction on the
strength of the recovery, on his disclosure statement, of a piece of
cable and of a motorcycle belonging to the deceased Ganpat Lal.
With regard to recovery of cable, the reasonings assigned by this
Court qua other appellants apply on all fours to his case as well
and, therefore, cannot be believed to connect him with the alleged
crime.
So far as the recovery of motorcycle is concerned, the
prosecution could not prove where the deceased had parked it.
Further, it was recovered on 02.08.2020, i.e., more than nine
months after the incident and that too from an open place.
Moreover, the prosecution did not lead any evidence to show how
it reached the place of recovery. Even otherwise, only on this
count alone, we are unable to sustain the finding of his guilt
recorded by the learned trial court.
There is one more important aspect of the matter. The
appellant has stated in his disclosure statement as under:
^^jkexksiky ehy dh yM+dh ds izseh x.kir dh gR;k ds ckn e`rd
x.kir dh eksVjlkbZfdy ctkt fMLdoj dks eSus fnukad 22-10-2019
dh jkf= esa th.kekrkth ls jSoklk dh rjQ lM+d ls dqN nwjh ij
fLFkr igkM+h ij ,d [kM~Ms esa Nqik fn;s Fks] og eksVjlkbZfdy vc eSa
vkids lkFk pydj cjken djok ldrk gwaA^^
(63 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
"After the murder of Ganpat, the lover of Prem-the daughter
of Ramgopal Meel, I had hidden the deceased Ganpat's Bajaj
Discover motorcycle on the night of 22.10.2019 in a pit on a
hillock located at some distance from the road from
Jeenmataji towards Raiwasa. I can now go with you and get
that motorcycle recovered." (English Translation)
However, the Investigating Officer (PW65), in his Court
deposition, stated, with regard to Ex.P150 as under:
^^fnukad 01-08-2020 dks vkjksih enuyky pkanhoky dh /kkjk 27 lk{;
vf/kfu;e dh bryk tks e`rd dh eksVjlkbZfdy dh cjkenxh ls
lacf/kr Fkh dks eqfrZc fd;k Fkk tks izn'kZ ih&150 gSA**
"On 01.08.2020, the information under Section 27 of the
Evidence Act by accused Madanlal Chandiwal regarding the
recovery of the deceased's motorcycle was reduced to
writing, which is Ex. 150." (English translation)
Thus, we find that the disclosure statement was not proved
by the Investigating Officer in the manner mandated by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Ramanand @ Nandlal Bharti
(supra) and, therefore, the recovery of the motorcycle of the
deceased based on such a disclosure statement could not have
been used as an incriminating piece of evidence against the
appellant Madanlal.
Insofar as the recovery of an incriminating piece of evidence
from the appellants is concerned, since it is a case that rests
solely upon circumstantial evidence, the prosecution was under an
obligation
to
prove
a
complete
and
unbroken
chain
of
circumstances leading only to the hypothesis of the guilt of the
accused. Further, as already observed by us, the prosecution could
not prove the last seen evidence. In that factual context, even
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(64 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
assuming that the confessional statements of some of the
appellants led to the recovery of some incriminating evidence, this
circumstance standing alone is not sufficient to sustain the
findings of conviction.
The Hon'ble Jharkhand High Court has, in Sanjay Kujur vs.
the State of Jharkhand, Criminal Appeal (DB) No.1359 of
2023, dated 24.04.2024, held as under:
"21. Thereafter, the only circumstance, which remains is
recovery of murder weapon on confessional statement on
pointing out by the appellant. In our opinion a conviction
cannot be based solely on the recovery of a murder
weapon. There must be some corroborative evidence to
establish the guilt of the accused beyond all reasonable
doubt. Confessional statement leading to recovery of
weapon, stand alone, cannot be a ground of conviction.
There must be other credible corroborative evidence. Even
if the murder weapon is recovered and it is blood stained
also, that does not prove the guilt of the accused. This
single circumstance by no means can be a ground to convict
the appellant. The other circumstance, except the recovery
should also be looked into and there must be some chain
and corroboration to convict the appellant. In this case
there are no other corroborative material, rather no
evidence at all.
22. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Raja Naykar
vs. State of Chhattisgarh reported in (2024) 3 SCC 481
at paragraph 29 thereof while referring to the judgment
rendered in the case of Mustkeem vs. State of Rajasthan
reported in (2011) 11 SCC 724 has held as under: "29. It can thus be seen that, the only circumstance
that may be of some assistance to the prosecution case
is the recovery of dagger at the instance of the present
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(65 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
appellant. However, as already stated hereinabove, the
said recovery is also from an open place accessible to
one and all. In any case, the blood found on the dagger
does not match with the blood group of the deceased.
In Mustkeem vs. State of Rajasthan, this Court held
that sole circumstance of recovery of bloodstained
weapon cannot form the basis of conviction unless the
same was connected with the murder of the deceased
by the accused. Thus, we find that only on the basis of
sole circumstance of recovery of bloodstained weapon,
it cannot be said that the prosecution has discharged its
burden of proving the case beyond reasonable doubt."
Very recently, in Khalil Pasha & Ors. vs. Abdul Rasheed
& Ors.-MANU/SC/0748/2026, their Lordships held as under:
"18. Section 27 recovery of the weapon has been proved,
and blood stains were found on it, which on chemical
analysis was found to be human blood. The prosecution did
not confront the eyewitness with the weapon, which the
Trial Court was described in a manner, which was not in
consonance with the physical appearance of the weapon
produced before the Court. Section 27 recovery alone
cannot lead to a conviction and here it fails to implicate A4
since there is no connection to the crime proved, but for the
human blood found, not indicated to be that of the accused.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
20. The only evidence is the blood stains found on the
weapon recovered under Section 27 of the Evidence Act
which by itself cannot lead to a finding of guilt without other
circumstances which provide a complete chain leading to
the hypothesis of guilt being the only one possible,
excluding any hypothesis of innocence. The facts proved by
the prosecution is the homicidal death, the brutal murder of
a person and nothing to inculpate the accused except the
eye-
witness
testimonies
which
are
suspect.
Our
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(66 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
reappreciation of the evidence, manifestly indicates that
this was not a fit case for converting the revision petition
filed before the High Court to an appeal."
Thus, in the backdrop of the aforesaid precedential law, we
are not able to sustain the impugned judgement of conviction
based on circumstances evidence.
We also notice that the learned trial court has held it to be
case of honour killing. In this regard, suggestions made by the
defence to Dharampal (PW69) during his cross-examination were
relied upon to conclude that the defence had indirectly admitted
that Ganpat and Prem came to the petrol pump together on a
motorcycle. However, after scanning the entire testimony of the
PW69 including his cross-examination, we are unable to persuade
ourselves to agree with the findings so recorded by the learned
trial court. In his examination-in-chief, he had stated that the
employees at the petrol pump informed him that 3-4 persons had
taken away a boy and a girl in a passenger vehicle which was
shown to him in the CCTV recording. However, indisputably, the
prosecution did not produce any such footage in evidence. Rather,
at the cost of repetition, we may observe here that, as a matter of
fact, the prosecution did not lead any evidence to prove that both
were seen together at all on the night of 21.10.2019. Further, in
his cross-examination, he also admitted that he could not identify
any person in the footage as he was not acquainted with them nor
were they subjected to test identification parade before him.
Moreover, he was questioned about the registration number of the
motorcycle, the clothes worn by the boy and the girl or the time
they had visited the petrol pump. Merely on account of these
(67 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
suggestions, the learned trial court could not have drawn such
inference that the defence had admitted that they had come to
the petrol pump together on a motorcycle.
Even otherwise, as already discussed, there was no evidence
on record to show that the deceased Ganpat Lal and the deceased
Prem were in love with each other apart from the oral testimony of
the Investigating Officer (PW65). When the pen drive-Article 1 was
played in the Court on 12.09.2024, he stated that the girl talking
on mobile phone was Prem and the man standing beside her was
her father Ramgopal and was asking her to call her lover Ganpat
over the mobile phone. However, he admitted in his crossexamination that he was not acquainted with Ramgopal or his
family members. Further, the footage, which otherwise could not
be proved in accordance with law, did not contain any audio.
Moreover, no call detail record was produced to prove that the
deceased Prem had talked to Ganpat over the mobile at that time.
Thus, it was only an assumption made by the Investigating Officer
unsupported by any legally admissible evidence. In the light of the
aforesaid, in our considered opinion, the learned trial court gravely
erred in reckoning it to be a case of honour killing.
Whether FIR was hit by Section 162 Cr.P.C.
Shri V.R. Bajwa, learned Senior Counsel, has asserted that
the FIR-Ex.P11 was hit by Section 162 Cr.P.C. inasmuch as the
complainant
had
earlier
lodged
Khatushyamji
which
was
not
investigating
agency
leading
a
report
brought
to
an
suppressed the true genesis of the case.
on
at
Police
record
inference
that
Station
by
the
it
had
(68 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
In this regard, the record reveals that Ex.P11 was based on
the
written
report-Ex.P1
submitted
by
Baldev
Godara
on
23.10.2019 at 12:10 PM at Police Station Ranoli. Jagdish (PW2), a
brother-in-law of the deceased Ganpat Lal, stated in his crossexamination that, on 22.10.2019, he had orally informed the SHO
Police Station Khatushyamji about the incident, but he did not
lodge any report;
however, the SHO immediately proceeded to
the petrol pump. Both; the first Investigating Officer (PW61) as
also the second Investigating Officer (PW65) admitted in their
cross-examination that the complainant had informed about the
incident to the Police Station Khatushyamji a day prior to
submission of Ex.P1. PW65 also accepted that suggestion that a
preliminary
inquiry
was
conducted
by
the
Police
Station
Khatushyamji; however, the enquiry report prepared by the Police
Station Khatushyamji was not made part of the record by him.
Their Lordships, in Allarakha Habib Memon & Ors.
(supra), held if the actual complaint filed with the police seems to
have been withheld, there are genuine reasons to hold that the
FIR is a post investigation document. In that case, reliance was
placed on the precedent of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of State of Andhra Pradesh vs. Punati Ramulu : 1994 Suppl
1 SCC 590 wherein it was held that once it is found that the
Investigating Officer has deliberately failed to record the FIR on
receipt of the information of a cognizable offence of serious nature
and had prepared the FIR after reaching the spot after due
deliberation, consultations and discussion, the conclusion becomes
inescapable that the investigation is tainted and it would,
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(69 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
therefore, be unsafe to rely upon such a tainted investigation as
one would not know where the Police Officer would have stopped
to fabricate evidence and create false clues. Their Lordships also
relied on the judgement in the case of Babu Sahebagouda
Rudragoudar vs. State of Karnataka : (2024) 8 SCC 149
wherein, in the backdrop that close relatives of the deceased had
gone to the Police Station but, no FIR was lodged then and there,
it was held that if the daily diary or the roznamcha entry of the
Police Station corresponding to visit of the so-called relatives of
the deceased was not brought on record, it created a grave doubt
on the genuineness of the FIR. It was also held that the
complainant admitted in the cross-examination that Poujadar
came to his house and that he narrated the incident to the officer
who scribed the same and thereafter, the complainant appended
his signatures on the writing. However, the ASI testified on oath
that the complainant had come to the Police Station and the
written report submitted by him was taken as the complaint of the
incident. He did not state anything about any complaint having
been recorded at the house of the complainant prior to lodging the
report. In that backdrop, the non-production of the daily diary
maintained at the Police Station was reckoned of great significance
and the FIR was treated as a post investigation document not
inspiring confidence.
In the case in hand, as is apparent from the testimony of
PW2, PW61 and PW65, before submitting the written report-Ex.P1
at the Police Station Ranoli on 23.10.2019, the complainant had
already lodged a report on the previous day at Police Station
(70 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Khatushyamji wherein investigation was conducted and a report
was also prepared. However, neither was the investigation report
made part of the record of the instant case nor was the statement
of
any
of
the
police
personnel
from
the
Police
Station
Khatushyamji recorded. Thus, in the backdrop of the law laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Allarakha Habib
Memon & Ors. (supra), we have no hesitation in holding that the
FIR-Ex.P11 was hit by Section 162 Cr.PC which raises a doubt that
the prosecution has suppressed the true genesis of the case.
We find no force in the submission advanced by the learned
Public Prosecutor, assisted by the learned counsel for the
complainant, that defective investigation should not come to the
rescue of the appellants. We have no qualm with the aforesaid
proposition; but, in the instant case, as already observed, the
prosecution could establish neither the circumstance of last seen
based on the CCTV footage nor the recovery of incriminating
evidence at the instance of the appellants in accordance with law
and, therefore, we do not concur with the finding of their guilt
recorded by the learned trial court.
Similarly, we find no merit in the contention raised by the
learned counsel for the State and the complainant that failure on
the part of the appellants to offer any explanation for the
incriminating circumstances put to them in their Section 313
Cr.P.C. statement, furnished an important link in the chain of
circumstantial evidence against them. It is a well-settled legal
principle that absence of an explanation by the accused when
confronted with the incriminating evidence against him in his
(71 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
Section 313 Cr.P.C. statement, may be treated as an additional
link in the chain of circumstantial evidence, it cannot be made the
basis for recording his conviction.
Dealing with an identical issue, their Lordships, in Shivaji
Chintappa Patil vs. State of Maharashtra:(2021) 5 SCC 626,
held as under:
"25. Another circumstance relied upon by the prosecution
is, that the appellant failed to give any explanation in his
statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. By now it is wellsettled principle of law, that false explanation or nonexplanation can only be used as an additional circumstance,
when
the
prosecution
has
proved
the
chain
of
circumstances leading to no other conclusion than the guilt
of the accused. However, it cannot be used as a link to
complete the chain. Reference in this respect could be made
to the judgment of this Court in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda
vs. State of Maharashtra:(1984) 4 SCC 116.
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxx
32. Insofar as the reliance placed by the learned counsel for
the State on the judgment of State of Rajasthan vs. Kashi
Ram: (2006) 12 SCC 254 is concerned, it would reveal, that
this Court had used the factor of non-explanation under
Section 313 Cr.P.C. only as an additional link to fortify the
finding, that the prosecution had established chain of
events unquestionably leading to the guilt of the accused
and not as a link to complete the chain. As such, the said
judgment would not be applicable to the facts of the
present case."
Very recently, in Santosh Gurung versus State of Sikkim:
MANU/SC/1114/2026, it was held that the accused’s silence or
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(72 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
failure to provide a reasonable explanation can act merely as an
additional link that would complete the chain. This, however,
would not shift the burden of proof onto an accused in a criminal
trial. In that case, earlier judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in Raj Kumar Singh @ Raju @ Batya vs. State of Rajasthan:
MANU/SC/0468/2013 : 2013 INSC 313 was also relied upon,
wherein it was observed that an answer given by an accused to a
question put to him under Section 313 CrPC cannot be used to fill
up the gaps left by the prosecution witnesses in their depositions.
It was also held that the statement of the accused is not a
substantive piece of evidence and, therefore, can be used only for
appreciating the evidence led by the prosecution; though, it
cannot be a substitute for the prosecution evidence and if the
prosecution's case is not found sufficient to sustain the conviction
of the accused, the inculpatory part of his statement cannot be
made the sole basis of his conviction. The Hon'ble Apex Court
further held that since the statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. is
not recorded after administering oath to the accused, it cannot be
treated as evidence within the meaning of Section 3 of the
Evidence Act and an adverse inference can be taken against the
accused only if the incriminating material stands fully established
and the accused is unable to furnish any explanation for it.
However, his right to remain silent, as he cannot be compelled to
become witness against himself, was recognized. In the backdrop
of aforesaid findings, their Lordships concluded that the response
of the accused recorded in his statement under Section 313 CrPC
could not be treated as a circumstance against him, especially
when
other
circumstantial
evidence
was
not
found
to
be
(73 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
satisfactorily pointing to the guilt of the accused alone and none
other.
In the backdrop of the aforesaid precedential law, we reject
the contention advanced by the respondents based on the
statements of the appellants under Section 313 CrPC inasmuch as
the prosecution miserably failed to lead evidence establishing a
complete and unbroken chain of events to prove their guilt.
In the conspectus of the aforesaid analysis, we are of the
view that the prosecution could not set up a complete and
unbroken chain of circumstantial evidence consistent only with the
hypothesis of the guilt of the appellants and, therefore, we do not
concur with the findings recorded by the learned trial court as to
their conviction.
Resultantly, the death reference is answered in the negative.
The appeals preferred by the appellants are allowed. The
judgement of conviction and the order of sentence dated
30.11.2024 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge No.1,
Sikar are quashed and set aside and the appellants are acquitted
of the charges framed against them. The sentence of appellantRajesh Kumar was suspended during the pendency of the appeal,
therefore, his bail bonds are discharged. He need not surrender
and shall be at liberty. The appellants Ramgopal, Sandeep Gurjar,
Nandlal,
Mahendra
Kumar
Choudhary,
Madanlal
Chandiwal,
Babulal @ Harnek, Beerbal Dhaka, Sohanlal, Mahadev, Parsaram
are in jail. They shall be released forthwith, if not required to be
detained in any other case.
In view of the provisions of Section 481 of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, the appellants are directed to
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(74 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
furnish a personal bond in the sum of ₹25,000/- each, and a
surety in the like amount before the Registrar (Judicial) of this
Court which shall be effective for a period of six months with the
stipulation that in the event of a Special Leave Petition being filed
against the judgment or on grant of leave, the appellants
aforesaid, on receipt of notice thereof, shall appear before the
Hon’ble Supreme Court.
Before we part with this judgement, we would like to make
some observations with regard to the casual, perfunctory and
lackadaisical manner in which the investigation was conducted in
the instant case. In the Katyayan Smriti, Mehrishi Katyayan
beautifully wrote about 1900-2000 years ago, as under:
^^lk{;a /keZL; p{kq'p] lk{;a U;k;L; lk/kue~A
vlk{;s ukfLr fu.kZ;ks] u fg lR;a fou';fr**AA
अररर त्-
lk{; dks /keZ dh vk¡[k dgk x;k gS vkSj ;gh U;k; izkIr djus dk
eq[; lk/ku gSA ;fn fdlh ekeys esa lk{; u gks] rks lgh fu.kZ; laHko
ugha gksrkA lR; dk LoHkko ;g gS fd og नष ugha gksrkA
"Evidence has been called the eye of righteousness, and it is
the primary means of obtaining justice. If there is no evidence
in a case, a just decision is not possible. The nature of truth is
that it is never lost. " (English Translation)
u lk{;ghueFkZa rq xzkg;sr~ lH;lŸke%A
u pkfi dsoya okD;a izek.ka /keZlk/kde~AA
;= ys[;a p lk{;a p ;qfä;qäa lefUore~A
r= lR;a fotkukfr U;k;ks Hkofr fu'p;%AA
अररर त्-
(75 of 77)
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
[CRLDR-1/2024]
fo}ku U;k;k/kh'k dks fcuk lk{; ds fdlh ckr dks Lohdkj ugha djuk
pkfg,A dFku ek= dks izek.k ugha ekuk tk ldrkA tgk¡ fyf[kr
izek.k] lk{; vkSj rdZ&rhuksa dk leUo; gks] ogha lR; Li"V gksrk gS
vkSj U;k; fuf'pr :i ls LFkkfir gksrk gSA
"A learned judge should not accept any matter without
evidence. A mere statement cannot be considered proof. Only
where written proof, evidence, and reasoning—all three are in
harmony—is the truth revealed, and justice definitely
established." (English Translation)
Thus, the dispensation of justice by the Courts in criminal
matters rests, in large measures, upon the quality of material
placed before them by the prosecution, for it is through such
material and the deposition of the witnesses that the Courts
perceive the truth.
While dealing with the cases involving electronic evidence in
the nature of either the CCTV footage or the call detail records, we
have noticed that many a time a casual approach is adopted by
the
Investigating
Officers
which
entails
prejudice
to
the
prosecution. From our experience at the Bench, we can say with a
sense
of
responsibility
Officers/Supervising
that
Officers
are
most
of
unaware
the
of
Investigating
the
procedure
required to be followed in the collection, seizure and preservation
of electronic evidence and the mode of its proof. Therefore, we
deem it just and proper to issue the following directions:-
1.
The Director General of Police shall, within two
months, frame and circulate a standard operating
procedure for the collection; seizure, preservation and
proof of electronic evidence; particularly CCTV footage
and call detail records, in conformity with the statutory
provisions contained in the Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023 and Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023.
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(76 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
The SOP shall, inter alia, provide for:A.
Prompt identification of the CCTV sources;
public or private and issuance of a written
requisition for preservation of footage at the
earliest;
B.
The seizure of the original storage devices
wherever feasible, or else preparation of a forensic
copy with its hash value computed and recorded in
the seizure memo at the spot;
C.
Recording of any difference between the
time displayed on the device and the actual time,
so that the timestamps in the footage can be
correctly relied upon;
D.
Obtaining call detail records, subscriber
details, Customer Application Forms (CAFs) and
cell-tower data through Nodal Officer(s) of the
service provider together with the requisite
certificate;
E.
Obtaining the requisite certificate under
Section
of
the
Act
of
BSA,
contemporaneously from the person in the lawful
control of the device or system;
F.
Proper sealing, labeling and malkhana
entry, and maintenance of a chain of custody
register recording every movement of electronic
record including its dispatch to and receipt back
from the FSL.
2.
The Director General of Police shall ensure periodic
training programs throughout the State for the
Investigating Officers, SHOs' and Supervising Officers on
the aforesaid aspects;
3.
The Supervising Officer shall verify compliance with
the SOP/statutory provisions before the charge-sheet is
filed in any case resting on the electronic evidence;
4.
The Director Prosecution, Rajasthan shall arrange
similar training for the Public Prosecutors on the proof of
the electronic evidence.
[2026:RJ-JP:41109-DB]
(77 of 77)
[CRLDR-1/2024]
A compliance report by the Officer(s) concerned shall be
submitted to this Court within three months.
The Registrar (Judicial) is directed to remit a copy of this
judgment to the Principal Secretary (Home), the Director General
of Police, the Director of Prosecution and the Director State
Forensic
Science
Laboratory,
Rajasthan
for
information
and
compliance.
(BHUWAN GOYAL),J
C-1-8
(MAHENDAR KUMAR GOYAL),J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review