Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.712 of 2024
Smt. Satarupa Nama (Das),
Aged about 23 years,
W/o: Sujan Das,
D/o: Lt. Sushil Chandra Nama,
R/o: Chelagang, P.O. Chelagang,
P.S. Nutun Bazar, Karbook, Gomati, Tripura.
……..The Petitioner
–Versus–
1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary, Department of Education,
Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN799010.
2. The Director,
Directorate of Elementary Education, Govt. of Tripura, Shiksha
Bhavan, Office lane, Agartala, Tripura, PIN- 799001.
3. The Secretary, Department of Finance,
Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN799010.
4. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Karbook, Gomati, District, Tripura.
…….. The Respondents
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. Aradhita Debbarma, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, G.A.
Date of hearing and delivery
of Judgment & Order
:
15th May, 2025.
Whether fit for reporting
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (Oral)
Heard Ms. Aradhita Debbarma, learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner and Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, learned G.A.
appearing for the State-respondents.
[2]
The father of the petitioner, namely Sushil Chandra Nama,
was an Under Graduate Teacher serving at Karaichara, SRP SB School
and he died-in-harness on 01.06.2021. Thereafter, the petitioner
submitted her application on 07.10.2021, to the competent authority for
compassionate
appointment
under
the
Die-in-Harness
Scheme.
According to her, she possesses the academic qualification of Higher
Secondary (+2 Stage) passed and her date of birth is 15.01.2002. Ms.
Debbarma, learned counsel, submits that at the time of death of the
deceased, he left behind him his wife, Tapashi Mandal(Nama), the
present petitioner and another daughter, Raktima Nama, who are the
ultimate legal representatives of the deceased. As per the survival
certificate (Annexure-2 to the writ petition), said Raktima Nama, was
aged about 13 years as on 26.08.2021.
[3]
of the
Ms. Debbarma, learned counsel, submits that the application
petitioner
for
such
compassionate
appointment
was
also
accompanied by a No Objection Certificate (for short, ‘NOC’) issued by
her mother. Thereafter, respondent No.2 forwarded the said application
to the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Karbook, Gomati, and after the SDM,
Karbook submitted his report, again the matter was sent to him on
13.05.2024 (Annexure-8 to the writ petition), for causing necessary field
enquiry asto whether the petitioner was married at the time of death of
her father. Just before the same, one representation dated 06.05.2024
was also submitted by the petitioner to the respondent No.2, with a
request to provide her appointment in a Group-C post without further
delay. Getting no response, she then filed a writ petition bearing WP(C)
No.386 of 2024. Said writ petition was disposed of on 27.06.2024,
without making any observation on the merits of the case, with a
direction to respondent No.2 to take a decision on the representation of
the petitioner within 12 weeks.
[4]
the
Ms. Debbarma, learned counsel also submits that thereafter,
Director
of
Elementary
Education
vide
communication
dated
26.09.2024, rejected the claim of the petitioner on the ground that her
case was not covered by clause
No.2.6 of the Scheme dated
02.03.2019. Challenging the same, the present writ petition has been
filed.
[5]
Mr. Bhattacharyya, learned G.A., seriously opposes the
prayer of the petitioner, stating that the petitioner, being a married
daughter, she is not entitled to get any such job. Moreso, a major
daughter, as per the Scheme of 2019 or even as per the amended
Scheme of 2022, is not entitled to the benefit of compassionate
appointment.
[6]
This Court has given due consideration to the submissions of
both sides and has also perused the record. There is no dispute between
the parties that the application of the petitioner was submitted on
07.10.2021, and the Scheme for compassionate appointment under Diein-Harness policy as notified on 02.03.2019 is applicable in her case.
Along with the counter affidavit submitted by the State-respondents, the
final enquiry report of the SDM, Karbook dated 11.09.2024, is annexed
as Annexure-C. Lt. Sushil Chandra Nama expired on 01.06.2021 and
Smt. Satarupa Nama (Das), i.e., the petitioner, applied for government
job under the Scheme on 07.10.2021. The SDM, Karbook in his second
report has specifically stated that the petitioner was living with other
members of the deceased government employee prior to the date of
occurrence and she was not married at the time of her father’s death
and date of her marriage is 10.03.2022. The SDM finally proposed that
the case of the petitioner may be considered as per Notification/Scheme
issued by the Government on 02.03.2019.
[7]
The relevant clause No.2.6 of the said Scheme of 2019
based on which the respondents regretted her petition is extracted
hereunder:
“2.6. “Dependent family members(s)” shall cover the
following:(i)
Wife or husband, as the case may be;
(ii)
Legitimate children,
(iii) Legitimate step children,
(iv) Adopted children,
(v)
Dependent daughter-in-law,
(vi) Dependent parents;
(vii) Dependent unmarried brother(s),
(viii) Dependent unmarried sister(s),
(ix) Dependent widowed daughter(s) and
(x)
Dependent legally divorcee daughter(s).
Provided that a married son or daughter-in-law or
widowed daughter, if he or she lives or used to live
separately from other members of the family on or
before the date of occurrence shall not be considered
as family member and at the same time he or she shall
not be treated as earning member of the family of the
government employee for the purpose of providing
benefits under the Scheme only. Married daughter (s)
under any circumstances shall not come under the
purview of this Scheme.”
[8]
As per the said Scheme, a married daughter under any
circumstances shall not come under the category of dependent family
member. But there is no embargo to offer such compassionate
appointment to an unmarried daughter. Now, if we go by enquiry report
as relied on by both the parties, when the application was filed on
07.10.2021, as per the SDM, Karbook, she was unmarried and was
given marriage only on 10.03.2022, and therefore, at the time of death
of the deceased Government employee or even at the time of filing of
the application for compassionate appointment, she was unmarried.
Even the matter of entitlement of a married daughter of compassionate
appointment under the Die-in-Harness Scheme has been dealt with by
the Division Bench of this Court, in the case of The State of Tripura &
others vs. Smt. Debashri Chakraborty, (WA No.80 of 2020),
decided on 08.02.2022, along with some other identical writ appeals in
the following terms:
“[26] The very object of die-in-harness scheme is to
provide urgent relief to mitigate the hardships arising
out of the death of the earning member of the family.
Numerous situations can be contemplated where there
may be none other than the married daughter to
support the family of the deceased Government
servant. Such a situation having arisen, object of the
die-in-harness scheme to relieve the family of the
deceased Government servant of emergent financial
crisis by providing compassionate appointment to an
eligible member would be frustrated if the married
daughter, who is otherwise eligible for such
appointment, is kept beyond the purview of the scheme
only on the basis of her marital status. Marriage does
not break the bond between a daughter and her
parents as it does not do between a son and his
parents. A crisis in the family of her parents equally
worries a married daughter. As such, there is no
rationale behind exclusion of a married daughter from
the scheme. Therefore, a die-in-harness policy
inasmuch as it operates as a disqualification in the case
of married woman, as against a married man must be
held to be discriminatory and such policy, tested on the
touchstone of Articles 14 to 16 of the Constitution,
cannot be held to valid. As a result, we find no merit in
the appeals. Resultantly, the appeals stand dismissed.
[27] Appellants are directed to consider the
applications for compassionate appointment received
from the respondents afresh and dispose the same on
merit within a period of 3(three) months from today.”
[9]
Therefore, in no way it was justified for the respondents to
turn down the claim of the petitioner for compassionate appointment
under Die-in-Harness Scheme on the ground that she was a married
daughter. As per the clause No.2.6 of the Scheme dated 02.03.2019,
any
legitimate
children
is
entitled
to
get
such
compassionate
appointment. The claim of the petitioner for such compassionate
appointment cannot be denied just because she has married later on.
[10]
In view of the above discussions, the writ petition is allowed.
The respondents are directed to consider the application of the
petitioner for her compassionate appointment under Die-in-Harness
Scheme, if there is no other valid reason for negating her claim on any
other ground. The respondents shall dispose of the petition of the
petitioner for such compassionate appointment within 12 weeks of the
date of receipt of a copy of this order.
With such observations and directions, the writ petition is
disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
SATABD Digitally
SATABDI DUTTA
Date: 2025.05.17
I DUTTA 13:26:52 +05'30'
Dinashree
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review