Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
R
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 27TH DAY OF JANUARY 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 100096 OF 2019 (PAR/POS)
BETWEEN:
SMT. SAROJA
W/O. VASANTRAO MURALKAR,
AGE: 62 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O: GARAG VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. ARUN L. NEELOPANT, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
SMT. RAJESHWARI
W/O. RAJARAM BETSUR,
AGE: 53 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O: C/O SHRI. GOVIND N. SANGAM,
7-1-397/57/1, NO.MIG 113/3,
SANJEEVARADDY NAGAR,
HYDERABAD-500038,
ANDHRA PRADESH.
2.
SMT. KAMALAKSHI
W/O. DEVAPPA MURALKAR,
AGE: 60 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O: STAFF QUARTERS, 211,
BANGUR NAGAR, DANDELI-581325,
DIST: UTTARA KANNADA.
BHARATHI
HM
BHARATHI H M
Location: HIGHCOURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DHARWAD
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
3.
SMT. SHWETA
W/O. DEVAPPA KULKARNI,
AGE: 70 YEARS,
OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O: HULGUR-581126,
TQ: SHIGGAON, DIST: HAVERI.
4.
ASHOK
S/O. SHIVASIDDAPPA KOLAR,
AGE: 48 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS,
R/O: KOLAR PETROL PUMP,
BELUR-580011, TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
5.
ANAND
S/O. TAYAPPA SURYAVANSHI,
AGE: 58 YEARS, OCC: SERVICE,
R/O: H.NO.36, LINGARAJ NAGAR (SOUTH),
31ST CROSS, VIDYA NAGAR-5880031,
HUBBALLI, DIST: DHARWAD.
6.
PEERAJI
S/O. TAYAPPA SURYAVANSHI,
AGE: 54 YEARS, OCC: SERVICE,
R/O: ADHYAPAK NAGAR,
NARAGUND-582207, DIST: GADAG.
7.
NAMDEV
S/O. TAYAPPA SURYAVANSHI,
AGE: 52 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
8.
SMT. SHASHIKALA DAKAPPA SURYAVANSHI,
AGE: 53 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEWIFE,
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
9.
SHANKAR
S/O. DAKAPPA SURYAVANSHI,
AGE: 36 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
10. MANJUNATH
S/O. DAKAPPA SURYAVANSHI,
AGE: 31 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
11. JAYASHREE
D/O. DAKAPPA SURYAVANSHI,
AGE: 33 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEWIFE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
12. IRAPPA
S/O. SHEDAPPA TAVARENAVAR,
AGE: 78 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
13. BHIMAPPA
S/O. SHEDAPPA TAVARENAVAR,
AGE: 76 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
14. SMT. RUKAMAVVA
W/O. NAGAPPA TAVARENAVAR,
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
AGE: 58 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEWIFE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
15. SHEDAPPA
S/O. NAGAPPA TAVARENAVAR,
AGE: 36 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
16. SHIVAJI
S/O. NAGAPPA TAVARENAVAR,
AGE: 32 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
17. GANAPATI
S/O. NAGAPPA TAVARENAVAR,
AGE: 30 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LR’S
AMENDMENT IS CARRIED OUT
AS PER ORDER DATED 01-07-2022
THE LEGAL HEIR IS ALREADY ON RECORD
AS PER RESPONDENT NO.14
18. SMT. RUDRAVVA
W/O. RAMESH DHAVALE,
AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEWIFE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
19. SMT. RENUKA
W/O. GURUPRASAD DHAVALE,
AGE: 31 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEWIFE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
20. ASHOK SHEDAPPA TAVARENAVAR,
AGE: 68 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
21. SMT. RADHAWWA
W/O. MAHARUDRAPPA TAVARENAVAR,
AGE: 48 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEWIFE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
22. SMT. SHILPA
W/O. BASAVARAJ HARANI,
AGE: 28 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEWIFE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
23. SHANKAR
S/O. MAHARUDRAPPA TAVARENAVAR
AGE: 29 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
24. MADIVALLAPPA
S/O. MAHARUDRAPPA TAVARENAVAR,
AGE: 27 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
25. NINGAPPA BASAPPA GAMANNAVAR,
AGE: 68 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O: TADKOD VILLAGE-581105,
TQ/DIST: DHARWAD.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. S.N. BANAKAR, ADVOCATE FOR R1, R4, R15 & R25;
SRI. SURESH P. HUDEDAGADDI, ADVOCATE FOR R7;
R2, R3, R5, R6, R9, R12, R13, R14, R16,
R20-R24 ARE SERVED; R17 WAS DEAD R14 IS LR OF R17;
R8, R10, R11, R18, R19 HELD SUFFICIENT)
THIS REGULAR FIRST APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
96 OF THE CPC, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE IMPUGNED
JUDGMENT
AND
DECREE
DATED:
30.10.2018
PASSED
IN
O.SNO.67/2011 PASSED BY THE COURT OF III ADDITIONAL
SENIOR JUDGE AND CJM DHARWAD IN SO FAR AS NOT
GRANTING SHARE TO THE APPELLANT IN SUIT SCHEDULE-A
PROPERTIES AND DECREE THE SUIT BEARING O.S.NO.67/2011
IN ITS ENTIRETY IN THE OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY AND ETC.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.)
Plaintiff-appellant has filed this appeal under Section
96 of Code of Civil Procedure challenging the judgment and
decree dated 30.10.2018 passed in O.S.No.67/2011 on the
file of the III Additional Senior Civil Judge and C.J.M.,
Dharwad (for short, ‘Trial Court’) in not decreeing the suit in
respect of the suit ‘A’, ‘A(i)’, ‘A(ii)’, and ‘A(iii)’ schedule
properties.
2.
Parties would be referred with their ranks, as
they were before the Trial Court for the sake of convenience
and clarity.
3.
Plaintiff has filed the suit before Trial Court
praying for partition and separate possession of her 1/5th
share in suit ‘A’ and ‘B’ schedule properties by metes and
bounds; for the reliefs of declaration that the sale deed
dated 03.01.2011 in respect of suit ‘A’ schedule properties,
sale deeds in respect of suit ‘A(i)’, ‘A(ii)’, and ‘A(iii)’
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
schedule properties are null and void and not binding on her
share; for the relief of permanent injunction restraining
defendant
No.5
from
interfering
with
the
peaceful
possession and enjoyment over suit ‘A’ schedule property;
for mesne profits from defendant No.2; for court costs and
for such other reliefs.
4.
The case of plaintiff in nutshell before trial Court and
the genealogy stated by plaintiff in nutshell is as follows:
Dattatreya (Dead)
Chidambar (Dead)
Indirabai (Dead)
Rangubai
(1st Wife)
(2nd Wife-Deft.No.1)
Rajaram
Saroja
Kamalakshi
Shweta
(Dead)
(Deft.No.2)
(Plff.)
(Deft.No.3)
(Deft.No.4)
5.
The
plaintiff
contended
that
the
plaintiff
and
defendant Nos.1 to 4 are members of Mitakshara School of Hindu
joint family. The plaintiff further contended that the suit schedule
properties are ancestral and joint Hindu family properties of
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
plaintiff and defendant Nos.1 to 4 and they were inherited by her
father-Chidambar. Since the plaintiff was born after 17.06.1956
and her father died after 09.09.2005, she is considered as
coparcener
of
the
joint
family
as
per
Hindu
Succession
(Amendment) Act, 2005 (in short, ‘the Act, 2005’).
6.
The
plaintiff
further
contended
that
suit
‘A(i)’
schedule property bearing Block No.590/2 measuring 3 acres
was sold for a sum of Rs.1,75,000/- on 02.03.2006; Suit ‘A(ii)’
schedule property bearing Block No.590/3 measuring 4 acres
was sold in favour of defendant Nos.13 to 25 on 19.04.1994 and
suit ‘A(iii)’ schedule property bearing Block No.590/4 measuring
6 acres 10 guntas was sold for a sum of Rs.10,000/- on
18.04.1981 in favour of defendant Nos.6 to 12 and those sale
deeds are not for legal necessity and hence, those sale deeds are
not binding on the share of the plaintiff. Chidambar was not the
absolute owner of the suit properties to sell them without
affecting
partition.
The
family
was
financially
sound
and
daughters’ marriage was performed long back and there was no
need to incur expenses to maintain the family. All those
registered sale deeds are concocted in collusion with her father
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
by defendant Nos.6 to 26 and thus, they are non-est and not
binding on the share of plaintiff.
7.
After death of her husband- Rajaram, defendant No.2
got entered her name in respect of suit ‘A’ schedule property
behind the back of plaintiff and defendant Nos.1, 3 and 4 in
collusion with revenue authorities and based on the alleged
relinquishment deed and Varsa varadi, name of Rajaram was
also not entered in revenue records but directly name of
defendant No.2 was entered in record of rights as the sole legal
heir to late Chidambar. Defendant No.2 taking undue advantage
of entries in her name in respect of suit ‘A’ schedule property,
has sold the same to defendant No.5 under registered sale deed
dated 03.01.2011 for a sum of Rs.10,94,000/-. The said
transaction is illegal, void and not binding on the plaintiff.
Defendant No.2 is not the sole and absolute owner of suit
schedule
property
to
alienate
the
same
without
affecting
equitable partition by metes and bounds with co-sharers. She did
so, with malafide intention to defeat the legitimate share of
plaintiff, step-mother and sisters of plaintiff i.e., defendant Nos.3
& 4, in connivance with Village Accountant of Tadakod.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
8.
The plaintiff has never relinquished her share in
favour of defendant No.2 at any point of time. Defendant Nos.2
and
have
played
fraud
on
the
plaintiff.
The
alleged
relinquishment deed and Panchayatdast do not bear the date.
The alleged transactions are bogus, void and not binding on
plaintiff. Recently during December-2010, plaintiff came to know
about these illegal entries and questioned them and also
demanded her legitimate share. Instead of effecting partition,
defendant No.2 sold suit ‘A’ schedule property to defendant No.5.
Hence, the suit for appropriate reliefs.
9.
Defendant No. 1, the step-mother of plaintiff, filed
her written statement, wherein, she admitted the allegations
made in the plaint and prayed for allotment of 1/5th share to her
in suit schedule properties and she is ready to pay requisite
Court fee. Defendant Nos.3 & 4 have also filed their separate
written statements, wherein, they have also admitted the plaint
pleadings and prayed for allotting share in joint family properties
to them and they are ready to pay Court fee.
10. Defendant No.2 filed her written statement, wherein,
she admitted the relationship between the parties but denied all
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
other averments made in the plaint. Defendant No.2 further
contended that the Court fee paid is not proper as plaintiff is not
in joint possession of suit ‘A’ schedule property and therefore,
the suit is liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 of the
Code of Civil Procedure. Defendant No.2 also contended that,
Block No.590/1 measuring 10 acres 5 guntas, i.e., suit ‘A’
schedule property, originally belonged to one Dattatreya, who
died leaving behind his only son, Chidambar. Chidambar's wife
Smt. Indubai died, leaving behind her children i.e., her sonRajaram, plaintiff and defendant Nos.3 & 4 as her daughters.
Rajaram died leaving behind defendant No.2 as his sole legal
heir.
11. It
is
further
contended
that
during
lifetime
of
Rajaram, the plaintiff and defendant Nos.3 and 4 have received a
sum of Rs.50,000/- each and relinquished their rights in favour
of Rajaram by executing a deed in his favour in respect of suit ‘A’
schedule property. After his death, the plaintiff and defendant
Nos.3 & 4 together have executed relinquishment deed in favour
of defendant No.2 by relinquishing their rights in respect of suit
‘A’ schedule property. By virtue of it, the revenue entries were
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
certified and the revenue authorities after accepting Rs.1,000/towards
stamp
duty
for
relinquishment
deed
as
per
the
Government circular have got entered the name of defendant
No.2 as per M.R.No.101/2009-10 dated 30.03.2010. Thus,
defendant No.2 became the absolute owner of said property and
she has executed sale deed dated 03.01.2011 for a sum of
Rs.10,94,000/- in favour of defendant No.5 by receiving entire
sale consideration amount of Rs.10,94,000/-. Since, from the
date of such sale, defendant No.5 is in possession and enjoyment
of suit ‘A’ schedule property. The plaintiff cannot question it; she
has no right, title or interest in or over suit ‘A’ schedule property.
Thus, suit is false, frivolous, vexatious and untenable in law.
Hence, prayed for dismissal of the suit with compensatory costs
of Rs.50,000/-.
12. Defendant No.4 filed her written statement, wherein,
she also admitted the relationship between parties and she is
sailing with defendant No.2 and contended that she, along with
defendant No.3 and the plaintiff have executed relinquishment
deed by accepting Rs.50,000/- from their brother and after his
death, in favour of defendant No.2, and defendant No.2 sold the
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
property in favour of defendant No.5. Hence, prayed for
dismissal of suit with costs.
13. Defendant No.5 filed his written statement, wherein,
he has taken the contention similar to which was taken by
defendant No.2 and contended that plaintiff has suppressed true
facts and filed false, frivolous, vexatious and untenable suit with
the sole object of causing unnecessary inconvenience and
harassment to defendant No.5. Hence, prayed for dismissal of
suit with exemplary costs.
14. After filing written statement by defendant Nos.1 to
5, the plaintiff amended the suit and included suit ‘A(i)’ to ‘A(iii)’
schedule properties and impleaded defendant Nos.6 to 26.
15. Defendant No.8 has filed his written statement,
wherein, he denied the plaint averments and contended that
defendant Nos.6 to 12 are concerned only in respect of suit
‘A(iii)’ schedule property, bearing Block No.590/4, measuring 6
acres 10 guntas, which was sold by Chidambar S/o Dattatreya
Betasur,
in
favour
of
father-in-law
of
defendant
No.9,
grandfather of defendant Nos.10 to 12, father of defendant No.6
to 8-Tayappa S/o Dakappa Suryavanshi for a sum of Rs.10,000/-
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
under registered sale deed dated 18.04.1981. The said sale deed
came into existence in the year 1981 and it cannot be challenged
in the year 2011. Furthermore, the said sale deed is saved by
the Proviso of Section 6 of the Act, 2005. Hence, prayed for
dismissal of suit in respect of suit ‘A(iii)’ schedule property.
16. The written statement of defendant No.8 is adopted
by defendant Nos.6, 7, 9 to 12.
17. Defendant No.16 filed his written statement, wherein,
he contended that predecessors of defendant Nos.15 to 20, 22 to
25 have purchased the western portion abutting to canal
measuring 4 acres in R.S.No.590 under registered sale deed and
said sale deed is saved under Proviso to Section 6 of the Act,
2005. Suit challenging the said sale deed is barred by limitation.
Hence, prayed for dismissal of suit with costs.
18. Defendant No.26 filed his written statement, wherein,
he had taken contention that he has purchased suit ‘A(i)’
schedule property bearing Block No.590/1 measuring 3 acres of
land on eastern portion under registered sale deed dated
02.03.2006. He further contended that only after confirming the
title of deceased-Chidambar, who is the absolute owner of the
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
property and also personally visiting the property and on
verification with neighbouring landowners, he has purchased said
property for value and said property was standing in the name of
Chidambar, he was the absolute owner in possession of it.
Revenue records were standing in his name. Since, from the date
of purchase, defendant No.26 is in actual, physical and lawful
possession and enjoyment of said property. Hence, prayed for
dismissal of suit with costs.
19. From the above facts, the trial Court has framed the
following issues and additional issues on different dates:
“ISSUES
1. ªÁ¢ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ 1 ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 3 gÀÄ vÁªÀÅ ºÉüÀĪÀAvÉ zÁªÁ
D¹ÛUÀ¼ÀÄ ªÁ¢ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ 1 jAzÀ 4 gÀ MlÄÖ PÀÄlÄA§zÀ
dAn ¸Áé¢Ã£Á£ÀĨsÀªÀzÀ°ègÀĪÀ D¹ÛUÀ¼ÀÄ gÀÄdĪÁvÀÄ JAzÀÄ
¥Àr¸ÀÄvÁÛgÉAiÉÄ?
2. ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ 2, 4 ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 5 vÁªÀÅ ºÉüÀĪÀAvÉ ªÁ¢ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ 1
ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 3 zÁªÁ D¹ÛUÀ¼À°è£À ªÉÄð£À vÀªÀÄä »¸ÉìAiÀİè£À vÀ¯Á
50 ¸Á«gÀ gÀÆUÀ¼À£ÀÄß vÀªÀÄä ¸ÀºÉÆÃzÀgÀ ªÀÄÈvÀ
gÁeÁgÁªÀĤAzÀ ¹éÃPÀj¹ zÁªÁ D¹ÛUÀ¼À°è£À vÀªÄÀ ä
»¸ÉìAiÀÄ£ÀÄß vÀªÀÄä ¸ÀºÉÆÃzÀgÀ gÁeÁgÁªÀÄ£À ¥ÀgÀªÁV
©lÄÖPÉÆnÖzÁÝgÉAzÀÄ gÀÄdĪÁvÀÄ ¥Àr¸ÀÄvÁÛgÉAiÉÄ?
3. ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ 2, 4 ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 5 gÀªÀgÀÄ ªÀÄÄAzÀĪÀgÉzÀÄ vÁªÀÅ
ºÉüÀĪÀAvÉ zÁªÁ ¥Àj²µÀÖ J gÀ D¹Û ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ 2 gÀ
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
¸ÀA¥ÀÇtð
ªÀiÁ°ÃPÀvÀéPÉÌ
M¼À¥ÀlÖzÝÀ
¸Áé¢üãÁ£ÀĨsÀªÀzÀ°èzÀÝ D¹ÛAiÀiÁVvÀÄÛ JAzÀÄ
¥Àr¸ÀÄvÁÛgÉAiÉÄ?
DPÉAiÀÄ
gÀÄdĪÁvÀÄ
4. ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ 2, 4 ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 5 gÀªÀgÀÄ ªÀÄÄAzÀĪÀgÉzÄÀ vÁªÀÅ
ºÉüÀĪÀAvÉ zÁªÁ ¥Àj²µÀÖ J gÀ D¹ÛAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ¸ÀjAiÀiÁV
ªÀtð£É ªÀiÁqÀzÉà EgÀĪÀÅzÀjAzÀ F zÁªÉ £Á ¥Àæ ¸ÀA PÀæ 7
¤AiÀĪÀÄ 3 jAzÀ ¨Á¢¸À®ànÖzÉ JAzÀÄ gÀÄdĪÁvÀÄ
¥Àr¸ÀÄvÁÛgÉAiÉÄ?
5. ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ 2, 4 ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 5 gÀªÀgÀÄ ªÀÄÄAzÀĪÀgÉzÄÀ vÁªÀÅ
ºÉüÀĪÀAvÉ, F zÁªÉUÉ PÀ£ÁðlPÀ £ÁåAiÀiÁ®AiÀÄ ±ÀÄ®Ì ªÀÄvÀÄÛ
zÁªÁ ªÀiË®åªÀiÁ¥À£Á PÁAiÉÄÝ AiÀÄ PÀ®A 38 gÀ°è
£ÁåAiÀiÁ®AiÀÄ ±ÀÄ®Ì PÀ®A 35(2) gÀ°è ¨sÀj¹gÀĪÀ
¨sÀj¸À¨ÉÃQzÀÄÝ ¸ÀzÀj PÁAiÉÄÝ £ÁåAiÀiÁ®AiÀÄ ±ÀÄ®Ì ¸Àj
E®èzÀÝjAzÀ F zÁªÉ £Á ¥Áæ ¸ÀA PÀæ 7 ¤AiÀĪÀÄ 11 gÀ°è
ªÀeÁ AiÉÆÃUÀå JAzÀÄ gÀÄdĪÁvÀÄ ¥Àr¸ÀÄvÁÛgÉAiÉÄ?
6. ªÁ¢, ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ 1 ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 3 vÁªÀÅ PÉýgÀĪÀ zÁªÁ
D¹ÛUÀ¼À°è£À 5/1 CA±ÀzÀ ¥Á®Ä ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ¥ÀævÉåÃPÀ ¸Áé¢üãÀvÉUÉ
CºÀðgÉÃ?
7. ªÁ¢ vÁªÀÅ PÉýgÀĪÀ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ 2 gÀÄ zÁªÁ ¥Àj²µÀÖ J gÀ
D¹Û ¸ÀA§AzsÀ ¥ÀæwªÁ¢ 5 gÀ ¥ÀgÀªÁV eÁjUÉÆÃ½¹gÀĪÀ
¥Àæ²ßvÀ £ÉÆÃAzÀt PÀæAiÀÄ ¥ÀvÀæ ¢£ÁPÀ 3-1-2011 vÀªÀÄä »¸ÉìUÉ
§AzsÀ£ÀPÁjAiÀÄ®è J£ÀÄߪÀ WÉÆÃµÀuÉAiÀÄ ¥ÀjºÁgÀPÌÉ CºÀðgÉÃ?
8. ªÁ¢ vÁªÀÅ PÉýgÀĪÀ ±Á±ÀévÀ ¤¨sÀAðzÀPÁeÉÕ ¥ÀjºÁgÀPÉÌ
CºÀðgÉÃ?
9. ªÁ¢ vÁªÀÅ
CºÀðgÉÃ?
PÉýgÀĪÀ
¨sÀ«µÀåzÀ
zsÀªÀiÁð£ÀÄ
GvÀà£ßÀ PÉÌ
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
10. K£ÀÄ DzÉñÀ CxÀªÁ rQæ?
ADDITIONAL ISSUES DATED 9-12-2015
1. Whether the defendant No.5 proves that suit is bad
for non joinder of necessary parties?
2. Whether the defendant No.5 proves that suit of the
plaintiff is suffers from non inclusion of other properties?
ADDITIONAL ISSUES DATED 7-3-2017
1. Whether the defendant Nos. 6 to 12 prove that their
predecessor Tayappa S/o Dakappa Suryavanshi on 184-1981, purchased suit schedule A (iii) property and
thereby they are the bonafide purchasers of the said
property?
2. Whether defendant No. 13, 14 and 21 prove that they
and predecessor of defendant No. 15 to 20 and 22 to 25
on 19-4-1994, purchased western portion 4 acres of land
in suit property bearing R.S No.590 and thereby they are
the bonafide purchasers of the said property?
3. Whether defendant No.26 proves that he on 2-3-2006
purchased eastern portion 3 acres of land in suit
property bearing R.S No.590/1 and thereby he is the
bonafide purchaser of the said property?”
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
20. On behalf of plaintiff, plaintiff was examined as PW1,
got marked Exs.P.1 to P.24 and closed her side before trial court.
21. On behalf of defendants, totally 11 witnesses were
examined as DWs.1 to 11, got marked Exs.D1 to D38 and closed
their side before trial Court.
22. After recording evidence of both sides and hearing
arguments of both sides, the learned trial judge has decreed the
suit in respect of suit ‘B’ schedule house property and dismissed
the suit in respect of suit ‘A’, ‘A(i)’ to ‘A(iii)’ schedule properties
on the ground that plaintiff and defendant Nos.3 & 4 have
relinquished their rights earlier in favour of husband of defendant
No.2 and after his death, in favour of defendant No.2 and thus,
they cannot claim any right, title or interest in or over suit ‘A’
schedule properties and dismissed the suit in respect of suit ‘A(i)’
to ‘A(iii)’ schedule properties on the ground that they were
executed by father of plaintiff and he has got every right to
alienate it and suit is filed long after execution of some of those
sale deeds and thus, they bind the share of plaintiff.
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
23. Aggrieved by said judgment and decree in respect of
suit ‘A’, ‘A(i)’ to ‘A(iii)’ schedule properties, plaintiff/appellant has
filed the present appeal.
24. Heard arguments of both sides.
25. Learned counsel Sri. Arun L. Neelopant for appellant
submitted his arguments that he is not pressing his appeal in
respect of suit ‘A(ii)’ and ‘A(iii)’ schedule properties because
those sale deeds were executed in the year 1994 and 1981
respectively and thus, he is restricting his arguments only in
respect of suit ‘A’ & ‘A(i)’ schedule properties measuring 10 acres
5 guntas and 3 acres respectively. Learned counsel for appellant
submits that the relationship between parties is admitted by both
sides. Under those circumstances, plaintiff being the daughter of
late Chidambar, has got right by birth as coparcener in suit ‘A’
and ‘A(i)’ schedule properties by virtue of the Act, 2005 and that
confers coparcenery rights upon plaintiff. Hence, without her
consent, her father could not have sold suit ‘A(i)’ schedule
property on 02.03.2006 to defendant No.26 and said sale deed is
not for legal necessity or for family benefit. He would further
submit that after death of Chidambar and after death of brother
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
of plaintiff-Rajaram, defendant No.2 being the wife of her brother
has got entered her name in revenue records in collusion with
revenue officials by concocting several documents and based on
such revenue entry, has sold suit ‘A’ schedule property under
registered sale deed dated 03.01.2011 in favour of defendant
No.5, which would not bind the share of plaintiff as it is not for
legal necessity or family benefit and defendant No.2 cannot be
called as Karta of the joint family. However, learned trial judge
has misread the provisions of law, especially the Registration Act
and only based on a stray admission of receipt of Rs.50,000/- by
plaintiff from her brother, came to the wrong conclusion that
plaintiff has relinquished her right in respect of suit ‘A’ schedule
property and thus, wrongly dismissed the suit in respect of suit
‘A’ and ‘A(i)’ schedule property and hence, prayed for allowing
the appeal in respect of those two properties.
26. During pendency of the suit, the second wife of
Chidambar i.e., defendant No.1 died and she has no Class-I heirs
and thus, her share is devolved upon the remaining sharers
i.e., plaintiff and defendant Nos.2 to 4 and thus, prayed for
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
decreeing the suit by granting 1/4th share in suit ‘A’ and ‘A(i)’
schedule property by metes and bounds.
27. Learned counsel Sri. Suresh P. Hudedagaddi for
defendant No.8, would submit that long prior to commencement
of the Act, 2005 on 18.04.1981, father of plaintiff has sold suit
‘A(iii)’ schedule property in favour of father of defendant Nos.6 &
7 under registered sale deed. Since then, the father of defendant
Nos.6 & 7 and after his death, defendant Nos.6 to 12 being the
legal heirs are in joint possession and enjoyment of said property
and plaintiff cannot claim any share in said property on the
ground of limitation and also on the ground of saving the
registered document prior to cut-off date 20.12.2004. Hence,
prayed for dismissal of appeal against defendant Nos.6 to 12.
28. Learned counsel Sri. S.N. Banakar for defendant
Nos.2, 5, 15 & 26 respectively (respondent Nos.1, 4, 15 & 25)
would submit that the plaintiff has relinquished her share in
respect of suit ‘A’ schedule property by receiving a sum of
Rs.50,000/- during lifetime of her brother-Rajaram and executed
relinquishment deed as per Ex.D.25 and after death of Rajaram,
plaintiff and defendant Nos.3 & 4 along with defendant No.1
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
have executed relinquishment deed as per Ex.D.27 in favour of
defendant No.2. At that time, defendant No.2 has paid additional
fee of Rs.1,000/- to Tahsildar as per the circular issued by the
Government and thus, after such payment of Rs.1,000/- and
relinquishment deed executed by the plaintiff and defendant
Nos.1, 3 & 4, revenue entries are mutated into the name of
defendant No.2 alone. About one year after such revenue
entries, defendant No.2 has executed registered sale deed in
favour of defendant No.5 in respect of suit ‘A’ schedule property
and thus, said sale deed binds the plaintiff and now, she cannot
claim any share in that property after relinquishing her share.
During lifetime of father, father has executed registered sale
deed in respect of ‘A(i)’ schedule property in favour of defendant
No.26 and that is also for legal necessity and family benefit. Both
sale deeds are for legal necessity and family benefit and thus,
they bind even the share of plaintiff. Hence, considering this
relinquishment deed and other factors, rightly learned trial judge
has dismissed the suit in respect of suit ‘A’, ‘A(i)’ schedule
properties and decreed only in respect of ‘B’ schedule property.
Hence, prayed for dismissal of appeal with costs.
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
29. In this regard, respondent Nos.1, 4, 15 and 25 relied
upon the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court between Dalip
Singh Vs. State Of U.P. & Ors in Civil Appeal No.5239 of
2002.
30. Having heard the arguments of both sides, verifying
appeal papers along with trial Court records, the points that arise
for consideration are:
1) Whether the appellant proves that the sale deed executed
by defendant No.2 in favour of defendant No.5 does not
bind the share of plaintiff?
2) Whether the appellant establishes that the sale deed
executed by father of appellant Sri Chidambar in favour of
defendant No.26 does not bind the share of plaintiff?
3) Whether the judgment and decree passed by the learned
trial judge is erroneous?
4) Whether interference on the above said judgment is
required?
31. Our answer to point No.1 in the affirmative;
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
Point No.2 in the negative;
Point Nos.3 and 4 partly in the affirmative for the
following:
REASONS
The relationship between parties is admitted. It reveals that
one Chidambar was the son of Dattatreya and he inherited suit
A, A(i) to A(iii) and ‘B’ schedule properties from his fatherDattatreya. This Chidambar died on 11.01.2007, leaving behind
his second wife (defendant No.1), plaintiff (his daughter),
defendant
Nos.3
&
(daughters)
and
his
son
Rajaram.
Chidambar had a first wife called Indrabai. From her plaintiff,
Rajaram and defendant Nos.3 & 4 were born. Said Indrabai died
in the year 1989. Only after her death, Chidambar married
defendant No.1.
32.
During pendency of the suit, defendant No.1 also
died and she had no issues and thus she had no Class-I heir.
Plaintiff and defendant Nos.2 to 4 are her Class-II heirs who
would equally succeed to her share.
33.
It is not in dispute that the father of plaintiff had
executed registered sale deed dated 18.04.1981 in respect of 6
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
acres 10 guntas of suit-‘A’ schedule property in favour of father
of defendant Nos.6 & 7 and then father of defendant Nos.6 & 7
was in possession and enjoyment of said property. After his
death defendant Nos.3 to 6 being his legal representatives are in
possession and enjoyment of said property. It is also not in
dispute that father of the plaintiff had executed registered sale
deed dated 19.04.1994 in respect of 4 acres in favour of
defendant Nos.13 to 15 and they are in possession and
enjoyment of the said property. Thus, two sale deeds came into
existence much earlier to commencement of Act, 2005 and
present suit is filed in the year 2011. Hence, challenging those
two sale deeds does not arise at all. The suit would be barred by
limitation in respect of those two properties. Furthermore,
learned counsel for plaintiff fairly submitted that he is not
pressing the appeal in respect of those two properties.
34.
A(i) schedule property is sold by father of plaintiff to
defendant No.26 under registered sale deed dated 02.03.2006.
as per Ex.D.18. Defendant No.26 has taken contention that only
after verifying revenue records and verifying with neighbors and
also by making proper enquiries, he was satisfied that the father
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
of plaintiff was absolute owner of the properties and thus he
purchased said property for valuable consideration.
35.
There is a recital in Ex.D.18 that seller was having
some family problems and he was in need of money and hence
he sold the said property to defendant No.26 for highest market
value of ₹.1,75,000/- and hence said property is sold to
defendant No.26.
36.
Plaintiff is a married daughter of Chidambar. She was
born in the year 1959 and married long back and was residing in
her husband's house. Under those circumstances, even though,
plaintiff was having a right over said property, for family benefit
it was being sold in favour of defendant No.26 by her fatherKarta of the family. In this regard, in her cross-examination,
plaintiff admitted that she has not challenged said sale deed
executed by her father in this suit. Only after this evidence, it
appears that she had included said property and impleaded
defendant No.26. She has deposed that after such purchase,
other defendant Nos.13 to 25 have spent huge amount and
developed those properties. She also admitted that after such
sale, name of purchasers entered in the revenue records. Hence,
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
the sale by father, being karta of the family binds other
coparceners if it is for the family benefit or legal necessity.
Hence, we are of the considered opinion that sale deed by father
in favour of defendant No.26 definitely binds the share of plaintiff
and defendant Nos.3 & 4.
37.
The
remaining
contention
of
plaintiff
is
that
defendant No.2 got revenue entries in her name by concocting
several revenue documents and concocting the signature of
plaintiff, defendant Nos.3 & 4 on those documents and obtained
revenue entries into her name, without even entering the name
of her husband-Rajaram in the revenue entries and after such
revenue entry, she has executed registered sale deed in favour
of defendant No.5 for value of ₹.10,94,000/- without the consent
and knowledge of plaintiff. Immediately after plaintiff came to
know about it, she has filed the present suit challenging the
same.
38.
Exhibit D.11 is the certified copy of registered sale
deed executed by defendant No.2 in favour of defendant No.5 for
a sum of ₹.10,94,000/-.
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
39.
Defendant Nos.2 & 5 mainly relies upon Ex.D.11,
D.25 and D.27 to prove their contention. Ex.P.14, Ex.D.27 and
Ex.D.33 are one and the same document; likewise, Ex.D.23 and
Ex.D.35 are one and the same document.
40.
It is to be noted here that defendant No.5 in his
written statement and affidavit evidence has not taken the plea
that he is bonafide purchaser of the property for value. On the
other hand, he has taken only the plea that he is the purchaser
of property from defendant No.2 and defendant No.2 was the
owner of the property because plaintiff, defendant Nos.3 & 4
have relinquished their share in favour of defendant No.2.
41.
On careful perusal of the recitals of Ex.D.25, it is
alleged in that document that plaintiff, defendant Nos.3 & 4 have
signed the said document. In this document, it is stated that
they have received ₹.50,000/- each from their brother in
presence of elders and they have no objection to continue
possession of the landed properties only with their brother and
they have voluntarily executed such document on 15.11.2007. It
is signed by three witnesses. The third one was examined as
DW.10. DW.10 in his affidavit evidence has stated that he is the
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
scribe of said document and he has recited the contents of said
document in his affidavit evidence. In the cross-examination, he
has deposed that he has not signed the document as a scribe.
But, deposed in fag end of his cross-examination by defendant
No.3 that signature found on Ex.D.25 as per Ex.D.25(a) is not
his signature and according to him its recitals are written by him.
42.
Based on Ex.D.25, no revenue entries were mutated.
However, the brother of plaintiff i.e. husband of defendant No.2
died on 03.04.2008. After his death, Ex.D.27 came
into
existence. Under Ex.D.27, the similar recitals of Ex.D.25 are
forthcoming. But there is no mention about receipt of ₹.50,000/in the said document and it is only stated before the revenue
officials that plaintiff and defendant Nos.2 & 3 have relinquished
their right in favour of defendant No.2 and they have consented
for mutation of property into the name of defendant No.2. Even
though, name of defendant No.1 is not mentioned in recitals, but
her signature is also forthcoming on the said document.
43.
It is the contention of defendant Nos.2 & 5 that at
that time the Government has given some relaxation and only by
receiving this ₹.1,000/- as stamp duty, the Tahasildar got
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
mutated the suit ‘A’ schedule property into the name of
defendant No.2. In this regard he relied upon some of the
Articles of the Stamp Act.
44.
The Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 was amended in
respect of payment of stamp duty in case of transaction within
family members. According to Article 48 of Karnataka Stamp
Act,1957 the maximum stamp duty payable on relinquishment
deed would be ₹.1,000/- if any family member relinquishes
his/her right in favour of other family members. This is the
stamp duty payable at the time of registration of the document
to sub-Registrar. Tahsildar not being Sub-Registrar cannot
receive said stamp duty and enter the name of defendant No.2 in
the revenue records. Always relinquishment deed relinquishing
the title in immovable property is compulsorily registerable
document if the property worth more than ₹.100/- as per Section
17 of the Registration Act, 1908. There is no amendment to this
provision of law. The Government cannot relax it.
45.
In this regard, learned counsel for the appellant
relies upon the judgment of the co-ordinate Bench of this Court
in the case of Malakappa Vs. Annapurna and others reported
- 32 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
in
ILR 2010 KAR 2748, wherein, at para No.8, it is held as
under:
“8. Even
otherwise,
the
1st defendant
having
admitted that it was an unregistered deed which in law
does not take effect, either for gaining or losing rights in
immovable property worth more than one hundred rupees,
in view of the provisions of Section 17 of the Registration
Act, 1908 (for short, the Act),
17.
Documents
of
which
registration
is
compulsory
(1) The following documents shall be registered, if the
property to which they relate is situate in a district in
which, and if they have been executed on or after the date
on which, Act No. XVI of 1864, or the Indian Registration
Act, 1866, or the Indian Registration Act, 1871, or the
Indian Registration Act, 1877 or this Act came or comes
into force, namely:—
(a) xxx
(b) other non-testamentary instruments which purport or
operate to create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish,
whether in present or in future, any right, title or interest
whether vested or contingent, of the value of one hundred
rupees, and upwards, to or in immovable property;
(c) xxx
(d) xxx
(e) xxx
- 33 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
read with Section 49 of the Act, which reads as under:
49. Effect of non-registration of documents
required to be registered: No document required
by Section 1732 (or by any provision of the Transfer
of Property Act, 1882) to be registered shall(a) affect any immovable property comprised
therein, or
(b) xxx
(c) xxx:
the appeal has only to be dismissed, confirming the
judgment and decree passed by the trial Court, and it is
accordingly dismissed.
Appeal is dismissed.”
46.
Thus, the relinquishment deed executed by the
family member in favour of other family member requires only a
little
registration
fee.
But,
it
is
compulsorily
registerable
document. Under those circumstances, merely mentioning that
the Tahsildar has received ₹.1,000/- from defendant No.2 and
entered the name of defendant No.2 in revenue records, by
relying upon Ex.D.25 is of no consequence and this document
cannot be looked into for any purpose, as it is unregistered
document.
- 34 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
47.
Learned
counsel
Sri.S.N.Banakar
for
respondent
Nos.1, 4, 15 & 25 would submit that he has paid Stamp duty and
penalty of more than ₹.11,000/- in respect of Ex.D.25 and thus,
it cures the defect of non-payment of stamp duty on the
document and it is admissible in law.
48.
In this regard, learned counsel for respondent would
rely upon Sections 34 to 37 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957.
Under Section 34 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 any
instrument chargeable with duty shall not be admitted in
evidence for any purpose unless, such instrument is duly
stamped.
49.
Under section 35 of Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 if
instrument is insufficiently stamped and even if it is admitted in
law then it shall not be called in question at any stage of the suit
that such instrument has not been duly stamped.
50.
In the instant case, Ex.D.25 was marked by paying
stamp duty and penalty as ordered by the Court. Hence, it is
admissible in law.
- 35 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
51.
Under Ex.D.25, the property was not mutated as
discussed above. It is only under Ex.D.27, the property was
mutated into the name of defendant No.2. There is a specific
recital in Ex.D.27 as follows:
“ ¸ÀªÀÄäw ¥ÀvÀæ
EzÀgÀ°è SÁvÉÃzÁgÀgÁzÀ ²æÃ azÀA§gÀ zÀvÁÛvÉæÃAiÀÄ ¨Él¸ÀÆgÀ EªÀgÀÄ
¢£ÁAPÀ 11-01-2007 gÀAzÀÄ ¥ÉÆÃwAiÀiÁVgÀÄvÁÛgÉ. ¸ÀzÀjÃAiÀĪÀjUÉ £ÁªÀÅ
ªÁgÀ¸ÀÄzÁgÀgÀÄ EgÀÄvÉÛêÉ. ªÁgÀ¸Á ªÀiÁqÀĪÀ PÁ®PÉÌ £ÀªÀÄä ºÉ¸ÀgÀÄUÀ¼À£ÀÄß zÁR®
ªÀiÁqÀ¨ÁgÀzÀÄ
£ÀªÀÄä
PÀÄlÄA§zÀ°è
ºÉÆAzÁtÂPÉ
DzÀ
¥ÀæPÁgÀ
dǀ̣ˀ
SÁvÉÃzÁgÀgÀ UÀAqÀÄ ªÀÄUÀ£À ºÉAqÀwAiÀiÁzÀ ²æÃªÀÄw. gÁeÉñÀéj PÉÆÃA gÁeÁgÁªÀÄ
¨Él¸ÀÆgÀ EªÀjUÉ £ÀªÀÄä ºÀPÀÄÌ©lÄÖ PÉÆnÖgÀÄvÉÛêÉ.
¸ÀzÀgÀ D¹ÛAiÀÄ zÉÃRgÉÃT
ªÀÄvÀÄÛ AiÀiÁªÀvÀÆÛ PÉ®¸ÀUÀ¼À£ÀÄß EªÀgÉà ªÀiÁqÀÄvÁÛgÉA§ÄªÀzÀjAzÀ ªÁgÀ¸Á ¥ÀæPÁgÀ
ºÀPÀÄÌ §zÀ¯ÁªÀuÉ ªÀiÁqÀĪÁUÀ £ÀªÀÄä ºÉ¸ÀgÀÄUÀ¼À£ÀÄß zÁR® ªÀiÁqÀ¨ÁgÀzÀÄ PÉêÀ®
£ÀªÀÄä SÁ¸À CtÚ£À ºÉAqÀwAiÀiÁzÀ ²æÃªÀÄw. gÁeÉñÀéj PÉÆÃA gÁeÁgÁªÀÄ
¨Él¸ÀÆgÀ EªÀgÀ£ÀÄß ºÁUÀÆ EªÀgÀ ºÉ¸ÀgÀ£ÀÄß zÁR°¸À®Ä £ÀªÀÄäzÀÄ J®ègÀzÀÆ
¸ÀªÀÄäw EgÀÄvÀÛzÉ CAvÁ £ÁªÀÅ J®ègÀÆ ¥ÀÆwð M¦àPÉÆAqÀÄ ¸ÁQëzÁgÀgÀ ¸ÀªÀÄPÀëªÀÄ
DvÀä¸ÀAvÉÆÃµÀ¢AzÀ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ CPÀÌ® ºÀĵÁj¬ÄAzÀ §gÀPÉÆlÖ ºÀPÀÄÌ©lÄÖ PÉÆlÖ §UÉÎ
¸ÀªÀÄäw ¥ÀvÀæ
52.
¸À»
vÁjÃRÄ :- “
Below this document, the date is not mentioned, but
only signatures of plaintiff, defendant Nos.3 & 4 and on the next
page, the signatures of defendant No.1 and panchas are
forthcoming.
The
recitals
of
this
document
clearly
and
categorically establish that this is a relinquishment deed wherein
- 36 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
plaintiff, defendant Nos.3 & 4 have relinquished their rights in
favour of defendant No.2. Hence, it is compulsory registerable
document as discussed above. Without such registration, no
rights would be conferred upon defendant No.2 to call her as
absolute owner.
53.
Merely because the document is admissible in law, it
will not create or extinguish any right to the party, unless the
instrument is registered as it is compulsorily registerable
instrument as per the Section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908
because, it is pertaining to immovable property and its worth is
more than Rs.100/-.
54.
Section 17 of Registration Act, 1908 reads as
follows:17. Documents of which registration is
compulsory
(1) The following documents shall be registered,
if the property to which they relate is situate in a
district in which, and if they have been executed
on or after the date on which, Act No. XVI of
1864, or the Indian Registration Act, 1866, or
the Indian Registration Act, 1871, or the Indian
- 37 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
Registration Act, 1877 or this Act came or comes
into force, namely:—
(a) xxx
(b) other non-testamentary instruments which
purport or operate to create, declare, assign, limit
or extinguish, whether in present or in future, any
right, title or interest whether vested or contingent,
of the value of one hundred rupees, and upwards,
to or in immovable property;
(c) xxx
(d) xxx
(e) xxx
55.
The effect of non-registration of a document under
this Section is explained in section 49 of Registration Act, 1908.
56.
Section 49 of Registration Act,1908 reads as follows:
49.
Effect
of
non-registration
of
documents required to be registered: No
document required by Section 1732 (or by any
provision of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882)
to be registered shall—
- 38 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
(a) affect any immovable property comprised
therein, or
(b) xxx
(c) xxx:
57.
As per Section 49 of Registration Act, 1908 if
document required by Section 17 of Registration Act, 1908 to be
registered shall not affect the transfer of any immovable
property comprised therein.
58.
The only exception to this rule is enumerated in its
Proviso that in a suit for specific performance of the contract, the
unregistered sale agreement may be received as evidence and
evidence of any collateral transaction not required to be effected
by registered instrument may be received in evidence.
these
Ex.D.25
&
are
being
compulsorily
Thus,,
registerable
documents under Section 17 of the Registration Act,1908 and
non-registration of the instruments cannot be cured by paying
duty and penalty or by paying Rs.1,000/- to Tahasildar for
change
of
mutation.
Under
those
circumstances,
those
documents will not confer any right, title or interest to the
person in whose favour relinquishment is being done and it will
- 39 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
not take away the right, title and interest of the party who
relinquishes his right on the property.
59.
Based on revenue entry standing in her name,
defendant No.2 has executed sale deed in favour of defendant
No.5. It will not confer any right, title or interest in favour of
defendant
No.5,
except
what
defendant
No.2
possessed.
Defendant No.2 possessed only 1/4th share in suit ‘A’ schedule
property. The sale deed is valid only in respect of her share i.e.
1/4th share.
60.
Defendant No.2 cannot be called as Karta of the
family at any stretch of imagination because she is only the
daughter-in-law of the original propositus and she is the sisterin-law of plaintiff, defendant Nos.3 & 4. Hence, the sale deed
executed by defendant No.2 cannot bind the shares of plaintiff
and defendant Nos.3 & 4.
61.
Even though, the plaintiff and defendant No.4 in their
respective cross-examinations admitted the receipt of ₹.50,000/from their brother; that would not mean that they have
relinquished their right in respect of suit ‘A’ schedule property.
The said amount of ₹.50,000/- might have been given to plaintiff
- 40 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
and defendant Nos.3 & 4 for some other purpose also or at least
even if it is presumed that it is given in lieu of their rights in suit
’A’ schedule property, as the document is not a registered one,
that would not take away their rights in suit ‘A’ schedule property
and will not confer right upon defendant No.2 in respect of said
property.
62.
Under those circumstances, revenue entries in favour
of defendant No.2 and in turn, sale by defendant No.2 in favour
of defendant No.5 would only bind the share of defendant No.2
and not the share of plaintiff and defendant Nos.3 & 4. Without
considering this legal aspect in a proper manner, the learned trial
Judge has dismissed the suit in respect of the suit ‘A’ schedule
property on the ground that relinquishment deed is executed by
plaintiff and defendant Nos.3 & 4 and mutation entries were not
challenged by the plaintiff.
63.
It is to be noted here that mere mutation entry will
not confer any right, title or interest OR take away the right, title
or interest of the party. Mutation entry and revenue entries are
only for the collection of tax on the property and not to confer
title on the property. Under those circumstances, challenging the
- 41 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
mutation entry by plaintiff would not arise at all. Furthermore,
within a span of 1-1-½ years of such mutation, plaintiff has filed
the present suit. Hence, said reasoning assigned by the learned
trial Judge is completely erroneous and not in accordance with
the proposition of law. Accordingly, the points raised are
answered as above and we proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
The appeal filed by the appellant/plaintiff under Section
96 of CPC is partly allowed by modifying the judgment and
decree of the trial Court as follows:
i)
Suit of plaintiff in O.S.No.67/2011 on the file of III
Addl. Senior Civil Judge and Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Dharwad is partly decreed in respect of suit ‘A’
schedule property bearing Block No.590/1 measuring
10 acres 5 guntas along with suit ‘B’ schedule
property.
ii)
Suit in respect of A(i) to A(iii) schedule property is
dismissed by confirming the judgment and decree of
trial Court on that point.
- 42 NC: 2026:KHC-D:983-DB
RFA No. 100096 of 2019
HC-KAR
iii)
Plaintiff is entitled for 1/4th share in suit ‘A’ and ‘B’
schedule property excluding A(i) to A(iii) properties
by metes and bounds.
Draw preliminary decree accordingly.
Sd/(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE
Sd/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
SH-1 to 3
RKM-4 to 28
HMB-29 to end
CT-MCK , LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 20
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review