The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
4. To whom applicable: The Scheme shall be applicable to the dependent family member(s) of following categories of employees who dies while in service including unnatural death or family of missing Government employee or family of the government servants who become permanently invalid while on duty, causing incapacitation to perform government duties(i) A Government servant serving under the State Government; (ii) Teaching and non-teaching employees of privately managed government aided schools; (iii) Home Guards/Woman Guards/Border Wing Home Guards.” [6] Since the claim of the petitioner has been entertained and benefits have been granted under the scheme of 2019, the eligibility of the petitioner to be covered under the scheme is not an issue herein. It is the category under which the petitioner’s case falls, what requires to be examined. Petitioner in the pleadings has stated that she would fall in either Support Category-I or Support Category-III. There are no documents which conclusively establish as to what was the correct age of the deceased employee. The death certificate would not serve the purpose so far as the correct age of the deceased employee is concerned under Category-I, had the deceased been equal to or more than 50 years on the date of occurrence, the family would be entitled to special pension amounting to difference between last drawn salary and pension in add…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.321 of 2024
Smt. Sangita Debbarma
...... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
State of Tripura and another
..…. Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. A. Bhaumik, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharya, G.A.,
Ms. Kahina Reang, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
=O=R=D=E=R=
03/05/2024
Heard Mr. A. Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and also heard Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharya, learned Government
Advocate appearing for the respondents-State.
[2]
Petitioner is the elder daughter of late Bishurai Debbarma,
Night Guard attached to the office of Director of Health Services,
Government of Tripura who unfortunately died in harness on 19.11.2016.
Petitioner has one younger sister and two younger brothers. Unfortunately,
her mother also passed away on 13.09.2017. She made an application for
compassionate appointment. By the impugned order dated 12.02.2024, her
case was considered and held entitled to avail the benefit of Support
Category-II under the scheme for compassionate appointment /benefits for
Government employees of Tripura laid down in the notification dated
02.03.2019 of the GA(P&T) Department. Under that category, legal heirs of
deceased employees are paid financial assistance of one lakh only if there is
an earning member in the family (Annexure-7). Petitioner has referred to the
death certificate where his age was recorded as 50 years, which appears to be
an approximation. There are no other documents on record to show as to
what was his correct age. The survival certificate issued by the SDM, Jirania
(Annexure-4) indicates that petitioner is the eldest married daughter and rest
of the family members are, namely, Ms. Anita Debbarma, another daughter,
Mr. Bibhishan Debbarma, aged 24 years and Mr. Bishal Debbarma, aged 16
years both sons.
[3]
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that as per the
Scheme of 2019, petitioner’s case ought to have been considered in the
Support Category-I or III. The impugned order reflects that there is no
earning member in the family to bring her case under Support Category-II.
Petitioner is entitled to compassionate appointment under support CategoryIII if the age of the government servant is less than 50 years on the date of
occurrence and there is dependent family member eligible for getting
government job. If the age of the deceased was above 50 years on the date of
occurrence, the family will be paid special pension amounting to difference
between last drawn salary and pension in addition to the normal pension till
the affected employee would have attained 60 years of age provided that
there is no earning member in the family under Category-I. After attaining
60 years, only normal pension will be paid. It is submitted that the relevant
factors germane to consideration of the case of the applicant has not been
taken into account while passing the impugned order. Therefore, she has
approached this Court.
[4]
Learned counsel for the State submits that the writ petition has
been taken up for the first time and instructions are awaited. He further
submits that in case this Court is inclined to remit the matter to the
concerned respondents, petitioner’s claim may be considered, in accordance
with law, taking into account all relevant factors pleaded by her.
[5]
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the relevant materials placed from record. The
scheme for compassionate appointment/benefit of government employees of
Tripura notified on 02.03.2019 by the GA(P&T) Department, Government
of Tripura has been made effective from 21.11.2018. The scheme under
paragraph 3 contains the nature of support to be granted to the dependents of
the affected government servant which is extracted hereunder :
“3. Nature of Support
3.1. Government appointment or financial assistance of Rs.1.00 lakh (Rupees one lakh) or
Rs.10.00 lakh (Rupees ten lakh) only, as the case may be depending upon the category to
which the affected Government Servant belongs to.
3.2. Support Category-1
If the age of the affected Government Servant is equal to or more than 50 years on the date
of occurrence, then the family will be paid Special Pension amounting to difference
between last drawn salary and pension in addition to the normal pension till the affected
employee would have attained 60 years of age, provided that there is no earning member in
the family. After attaining 60 years of age, only normal pension will be paid.
3.3 Support Category-2
If there is an earning member in the family of the affected Government Servant, then the
next of kin will be paid a lump sum ex-gratia of Rs.1.00 lakh (Rupees one lakh) only.
3.4. Support Category-3
If the age of the affected Government Servant is less than 50 years on the date of
occurrence and there is dependent family member eligible for getting government job as per
eligibility criteria mentioned in this Memorandum and there is no earning member in the
family, in such case suitable Government employment [Group-C & Group-D] post only
shall be admissible subject to fulfilling other required qualifications as per Recruitment
rules of the respective post. Such employment will be subject to availability of direct
recruitment vacancy in the parent Department and maximum 15% of total available
vacancy as on First April of the concerned Financial Year in the parent Department may be
utilized for this purpose.
3.5 Support Category-4
If the occurrence date of the affected Government Servant is before attaining the age of 50
years and there is neither earning member in the family nor any dependent eligible member
for Government employment, in such case one time financial assistance of Rs.10.00
(Rupees ten lakh) only shall be given to the next of kin.
3.6 Explanation
i. if the candidate belongs to support category[3] does not get employment in the parent
Department of the affected Government Servant within one year from the date of
occurrence due to non-availability of vacancy in that Department, then the candidate may
be considered for posting in other Departments with the concurrence of the Finance
Department.
ii. Eligibility to be determined as on date of occurrence of the affected Government
Servant.
Iii One family will be eligible to get only one benefit out of Support Category-1 to 4
mentioned above.
3.7. Benefits admissible in different categories are tabulated as hereunder:
Category
Support-I
Occurrence date on or
after attaining the age of
50 years.
Support-II
Benefit admissible
Remarks
Special pension amounting to
difference between last drawn
salary and pension in addition
to the normal pension till the
affected Government Servant
would have attained 60 years
of age.
i. There is no earning member
in the family.
Rs.1.00 lakh (Rupees one lakh)
only.
There is an earning member in
the family.
Government job against any
suitable posts (Group-C or
1. Applicant should be eligible
for government job as on the
date of occurrence.
ii. In case of there is minor
survivors, then one suitable
local guardian may be declared
by the Administrative
Department concerned in
consultation with the deceased
government servant’s family.
Occurrence date at any
point of time during the
entire Service
Support-III
Occurrence date prior to
attaining the age of 50
years
Group-D) as per qualification
of the applicant concerned
2. No earning member in the
family.
Support-IV
Rs.10,00,000 (Rupees ten lakh)
only.
1.
No earning member in
the
2.
family
2. Eligible dependent(s) for
government job not available.
4. To whom applicable: The Scheme shall be applicable to the dependent family
member(s) of following categories of employees who dies while in service including unnatural death or family of missing Government employee or family of the government
servants who become permanently invalid while on duty, causing incapacitation to perform
government duties(i) A Government servant serving under the State Government;
(ii) Teaching and non-teaching employees of privately managed government aided schools;
(iii) Home Guards/Woman Guards/Border Wing Home Guards.”
[6]
Since the claim of the petitioner has been entertained and
benefits have been granted under the scheme of 2019, the eligibility of the
petitioner to be covered under the scheme is not an issue herein. It is the
category under which the petitioner’s case falls, what requires to be
examined. Petitioner in the pleadings has stated that she would fall in either
Support Category-I or Support Category-III. There are no documents which
conclusively establish as to what was the correct age of the deceased
employee. The death certificate would not serve the purpose so far as the
correct age of the deceased employee is concerned under Category-I, had the
deceased been equal to or more than 50 years on the date of occurrence, the
family would be entitled to special pension amounting to difference between
last drawn salary and pension in addition to the normal pension till the
affected employee attains 60 years of age provided that there is no earning
member in the family. After attaining 60 years of age, only normal pension
will be paid. If the petitioner’s father was less than 50 years of age as on the
date of occurrence which is defined under Clause 2.3(i) as the date of death
of the Government servant in harness, the dependent family member eligible
for government job as per eligibility criteria mentioned in this memorandum
would be considered for suitable government employment if there is no
earning member in the family subject to fulfillment of other required
qualification as per recruitment rules and earmarked vacancy for the
concerned financial year in the parent department under Category-III.
Apparently, the impugned order does not dilate on the reasons as to why she
has been granted the benefit of Support category-II instead of Category- I or
III. If the case of the petitioner was eligible for other categories like Support
Category-I or Support Category-III, the benefits would be substantially
more.
[7]
As such, petitioner appears to have a genuine grievance.
However, since all relevant factors germane to be considered are not been
reflected on perusal of the impugned order, this Court instead of entering
into the merits of the case, deems it proper to remit the matter to the
competent authority/Director of Health Services, Government of Tripura,
respondent No.2 to take a fresh decision on the application of the petitioner,
in accordance with law, within a reasonable time preferably 12 weeks from
the date of receipt of copy of this order. In the process of reconsideration,
the order dated 12.02.2024 (Annuxure-7) impugned herein shall not come in
the way to the petitioner.
[8]
Let it be made clear that this Court has not made any comments
on the merits of the case of the petitioner. Needless to say, if the competent
authority deems it necessary to require other supporting documents from the
petitioner, petitioner would be obliged to supply the same within the same
period.
[9]
The writ petition is disposed of in the manner and to the extent
indicated above.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH) CJ
SIDDHARTHA LODH LODH
Date: 2024.05.09 17:26:59 +05'30'
Dipesh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review