Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.579/2024
Smt. Sangita Debbarma, D/O. Late Bishurai Debbarma, W/O. Sri Juliya
Debbarma, resident of Debram Thakur Para, P.O. + P.S.-Bodhjungnagar,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799008, aged about-32 years.
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, represented by its Principal Secretary, Health and
Family Welfare Department, Government of Tripura, having its Office at New
Secretariat Building, P.O.-Secretariat, P.S.-New Capital Complex, DistrictWest Tripura, PIN-799010.
2. The Under Secretary, Health & Family Welfare Department, Government of
Tripura, P.O.-Secretariat, P.S.-New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura,
PIN-799010.
3. The Director, Directorate of Health Services, Government of Tripura, having
its office at Health Directorate Building, Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru Complex, 1 st
Floor, P.O.-Agartala, P.S.-West Agartala, District-West Tripura, PIN-799001.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
07/09/2024
Heard Mr. Arijit Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. Dipankar Sarma, learned Addl. Government Advocate
appearing for the respondents-State.
2.
The impugned order dated 16.07.2024 issued by the competent
authority under the Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of
Tripura has rejected the representation of the petitioner for compassionate
appointment under die-in-harness scheme in lieu of death of the father of the
petitioner on 19.11.2016 in harness while working as Night Guard for the
reason that the petitioner did not apply within one year from the date of
occurrence of the death of deceased Government servant as per the rule.
3.
There was a previous round of litigation in WP(C) No.321 of
2024. Petitioner had approached this Court with a prayer for consideration of
her case in Support Category-I or III under the die-in-harness scheme of 2019
issued vide Memorandum dated 02.03.2019 (Annexure-9) as according to her,
the deceased died at the age of 45 years, i.e. less than 50 years. At that stage,
dependent petitioners and legal heirs of the deceased employee had got the
financial benefit of Rs.1 lakh under Category-II of the Scheme of 2019. This
Court on consideration of the rival submissions of the parties and the relevant
provisions of the scheme of 2019 disposed of the matter without making any
comments on the merits of the case of the petitioner in the following manner:
"[6] Since the claim of the petitioner has been entertained and
benefits have been granted under the scheme of 2019, the eligibility of the
petitioner to be covered under the scheme is not an issue herein. It is the
category under which the petitioner’s case falls, what requires to be
examined. Petitioner in the pleadings has stated that she would fall in either
Support Category-I or Support Category-III. There are no documents which
conclusively establish as to what was the correct age of the deceased
employee. The death certificate would not serve the purpose so far as the
correct age of the deceased employee is concerned under Category-I, had the
deceased been equal to or more than 50 years on the date of occurrence, the
family would be entitled to special pension amounting to difference between
last drawn salary and pension in addition to the normal pension till the
affected employee attains 60 years of age provided that there is no earning
member in the family. After attaining 60 years of age, only normal pension
will be paid. If the petitioner’s father was less than 50 years of age as on the
date of occurrence which is defined under Clause 2.3(i) as the date of death of
the Government servant in harness, the dependent family member eligible for
government job as per eligibility criteria mentioned in this memorandum
would be considered for suitable government employment if there is no
earning member in the family subject to fulfillment of other required
qualification as per recruitment rules and earmarked vacancy for the
concerned financial year in the parent department under Category-III.
Apparently, the impugned order does not dilate on the reasons as to why she
has been granted the benefit of Support category-II instead of Category- I or
III. If the case of the petitioner was eligible for other categories like Support
Category-I or Support Category-III, the benefits would be substantially more.
[7]
As such, petitioner appears to have a genuine grievance.
However, since all relevant factors germane to be considered are not been
reflected on perusal of the impugned order, this Court instead of entering into
the merits of the case, deems it proper to remit the matter to the competent
authority/Director of Health Services, Government of Tripura, respondent
No.2 to take a fresh decision on the application of the petitioner, in
accordance with law, within a reasonable time preferably 12 weeks from the
date of receipt of copy of this order. In the process of reconsideration, the
order dated 12.02.2024 (Annuxure-7) impugned herein shall not come in the
way to the petitioner.
[8]
Let it be made clear that this Court has not made any
comments on the merits of the case of the petitioner. Needless to say, if the
competent authority deems it necessary to require other supporting documents
from the petitioner, petitioner would be obliged to supply the same within the
same period."
Pursuant to the directions of this Court, her claim was
reconsidered and had been rejected by the impugned order dated 16.07.2024
for the reasons indicated hereinabove.
4.
Apparently, under Clause 9 of the 2019 scheme, time limit for
considering applications for compassionate appointment and admissible
financial assistance was within one year from the date of occurrence of the
deceased Government servant or missing or permanent invalidation while on
Government duty. However, Clause 9 also provided that for admissible
financial assistance, time period for application can be extended by 1(one) year
on valid grounds. Clause 19 is the repeal clause by which existing orders/
instructions issued from time to time in connection with the die-in-harness
scheme stood repealed w.e.f. 21.11.2018. As such, the existing scheme of 2015
during subsistence of which the deceased died on 19.11.2016 stood repealed
and it is also obvious from the nature of financial assistance granted to the
petitioners that such assistance has been granted under Category-II of the 2019
scheme. Since the administrative instruction or scheme was repealed by the
2019 scheme, case of the petitioner was neither considered nor such claim
could have been granted under the repeal scheme. But the claim was
considered even under the 2019 scheme despite delay in making such
representation though time limit for considering applications for compassionate
appointment under Clause 9 required to be submitted within one year from the
date of occurrence. It was extendable for one year for granting admissible
financial assistance on valid grounds. It appears that the competent authority
under the department took a liberal view of the matter and granted financial
assistance in favour of the petitioners to the tune of Rs.1 lakh treating them to
be under Category-II of the 2019 scheme. However, the claim for
compassionate appointment has been rejected on reconsideration this time on
the ground that such claim was not submitted within one year from the date of
occurrence, i.e. the date of death of petitioner's father on 19.11.2016.
5.
Claims for compassionate appointment are liable to be considered
under the terms and conditions of the die-in-harness scheme framed by the
employer, i.e. the State Government in this case. Provisions thereof have to be
read in a beneficial manner as it is in the nature of a social welfare legislation
or subordinate legislation. However, time limits for making such application
have to be adhered strictly unless the scheme itself provides for relaxation. In
the absence of any provision under the scheme including Clause 9 which
prescribes for time limit for considering applications for compassionate
appointment, no direction to entertain such a belated claim can be issued by a
Writ Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India as writs in the nature
of mandamus or such directions can be issued only to enforce a legally
enforceable right. Directions contrary to law or provisions of the scheme
cannot be issued as it would be beyond the scope of the scheme and would
create bad precedents. It is true that by granting the benefit of admissible
financial assistance, the respondents have treated the petitioner eligible for such
claim even under the 2019 scheme but since claim for compassionate
appointment could be entertained only within the period of one year from the
date of occurrence with no condition to extend it beyond that, it would not be
proper for this Court in exercise of writ jurisdiction to issue such a direction
upon the respondent authorities. The reason for rejection of the claim for
compassionate appointment on the ground that it has not been made within one
year as per rules cannot be said to be illegal or erroneous which can be
corrected in certiorari jurisdiction of this Court. As such, this Court does not
find any merit in the writ petition calling for interference.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the respondents
may not withdraw the benefit of financial assistance granted to the petitioners
earlier vide order dated 12.02.2024. In the circumstances noted above where
the observations have been made in relation to the claim of compassionate
appointment in the present case, this Court does not find any reason as to why
benefits already extended to the petitioners earlier should be withdrawn.
7.
The writ petition is dismissed accordingly.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
SIDDHARTHA LODH
LODH
Date: 2024.09.11 17:16:25 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review