Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.143 of 2025
1. Smti Rupanjali Saha
W/o:- Sandip Kumar Roy
D/o Rakhal Chandra Saha
Bankumari, Bartilla
P.O. Jogendra Nagar, PIN;799004
P.S. East Agartala, West Tripura.
……………Petitioner(s).
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
Represented by the Secretary to the Government of Tripura,
Department of Education, New Secretariat, Agartala,
P.O.- New Secretariat, PIN-799010
P.S. NCC, District: West Tripura, Tripura.
2. The Director of Higher Education,
Government of Tripura, Shiksha Bhavan, Office Lane,
Agartala, Tripura, PIN: 799001
3. Tripura Public Service Commission
Represented by its Secretary,
Akhaura Road, Agartala, PIN-799001
P.S. West Agartala,
District: West Tripura.
…………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Amrit Lal Saha, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate.
Mr. H. Sarkar, Advocate.
Date of hearing &
date of delivery of Judgment :
Whether fit for reporting :
19.05.2025
Yes
_B_E_ F_O_R_E_
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. Amrit Lal Saha, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner.
Also heard Mr. H. Sarkar, learned counsel appearing for
the State-respondents and Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel
appearing for the respondent-TPSC.
[1]
Before adverting to the issues involved in the writ
proceeding, for convenience of discussion and consideration, the
involved facts and the attending circumstance, as revealed from
the pleadings of the parties and the annexed documents thereto,
are highlighted hereinbelow in short outline:
i) The TPSC issued an advertisement bearing no.08 of 2014 dated
10.06.2014 for selection for the post of Asstt. Professor in Govt. General
Degree Colleges in different disciplines and accordingly the petitioner as
UR category candidate participated and was selected against the
subject- Physiology.
ii) Said recruitment was challenged in the High Court by filing
several writ petitions and the Division Bench of the High Court
analogously decided those petitions 26.02.2016 titled as 'Smti Bijaya
Bhattacharjee Vs. The State of Tripura & ors., WP (C) 172 of 2025'
decided with other writ petitions and finally set aside the selection
process with directions to the TPSC to prepare API scores of each
candidate in accordance with the guidelines of UGC without inviting any
fresh application in this regard and then to call top 05 candidates for
interview where there was only one vacant post and 8 most meritorious
candidate in case of two vacancies and three times the number of
vacancies in all other cases. Regarding reservation/de-reservation of
posts also some other directions were also issued.
iii) After said judgment was passed by the High Court, the
selection process was again initiated vide letter issued by the Under
Secretary, Govt. of Tripura in Education (Higher) Department on
21.07.2016 (Ext. R/2 of the counter affidavit), and the vacancy position
against Human Physiology subject was shown there as 11 posts (SC-02
and ST-09) and there was no post notified for UR category at that time.
The result of such selection was published by TPSC vide notification
dated 04.10.2016 (Annexure R/4) but due to non availability of suitable
candidate, said 11 nos. of post could not be filled up.
iv) Thereafter, the Education (Higher) Department issued another
letter dated 29.07.2017 to the TPSC for filling up of total 182 posts of
Assistant Professor in Government General Degree Colleges and
accordingly, TPSC issued advertisement no. 19 of 2017 for filling up of
total 18 posts (SC-03, ST-09, UR-06) against the discipline Physiology
along with other posts in respect of other subjects. Thereafter, vide
notification dated 02.01.2019 (Annexure R/7) said selection process
with some other selection processes were cancelled by TPSC.
v) On 23.08.2019, the petitioner through her Advocate sent one
notice to the Secretary cum Commissioner of Education (Higher)
Department, Govt. of Tripura requesting for resuming the process of
recruitment in terms of said judgment of the High Court as she was
running the age of 40 at that time and was likely to cross the upper limit
of age. In turn, the Director of Education (Higher) Department sent a
reply on 19.9.2019 informing that after the amendment of Recruitment
Rules is finalized, immediately requisition would be sent to TPSC for
recruitment for the post of Assistant Professor and reference therein was
also made in respect of para no. 4 of the Memorandum dated
20.08.2018 of GA (P&T) Department to the effect that if the petitioner
applied for the post of Assistant Professor in respect of earlier
advertisement no.19/2017, she would be entitled to one time relaxation
in upper age limit.
vi) On 16.10.2020, the Education (Higher) Department sent
another requisition to the TPSC vide Annexure R/8 for filing up of further
40 posts of Assistant Professor in such Govt. (General) Degree Colleges
and reference therein was made to one memorandum bearing no.
F.20(1)-GA(P&T)/18 dtd. 20.08.2018 of GA(P&T) Department, Govt. of
Tripura quoting the followings"As regards the candidates who has participated in the cancelled
recruitment processes, they are to be given one time relaxation in upper
age limit to enable them to participate once in the fresh recruitment
process subject to providing documentary evidence of their participation
in the earlier recruitment process for the same post(s)."
vii)
TPSC
accordingly
issued
Advertisement
No.01/2021
(Annexure R/9) for filling up of said 40 posts of which for the subject
Human Physiology the posts as notified was total 04 in numbers with
break up- ST-03, PH-01 but no post for UR category was shown
available there. In the Advertisement also, said one time relaxation
regarding upper age was noted.
viii) In the year 2022, further advertisement vide Advertisement
No.08/2022 (Annexure R/12) was also issued by TPSC for filling up of
further 40 posts of Assistant Professors in such Degree Colleges and at
that time, there were two posts against subject- Human Physiology
under UR category. Total posts for such Human Physiology as per said
Advertisement was 05 with the break up- SC-01, ST-02 & UR-02.
Necessary age relaxation, in this advertisement, was initially allowed
only for candidates of Physical Education, Commerce and Mathematics.
However,
another
corrigendum
notification
was
again
issued
on
26.04.2022 (Annexure R/13) by TPSC providing such age relaxation in
upper age in respect of SC & UR category of candidates against subject
Human Physiology in view of the fact that in Advertisement no.01/2021,
there was no post meant for SC and UR category against this subject. As
per communication 04.11.2022 of TPSC to the State Government, two
candidates of UR category were also selected against Human Physiology
subject.
ix) Now, the TPSC has again published another Advertisement
bearing no. 5/2025 (Annexure 5) for filling up of total 201 nos. of posts
of Assistant Professor against different discipline and in respect of
subject Human Physiology, steps for recruitment is being taken in
respect of total 14 posts with the break up- UR 05(2 reserved for
women), SC 02 & ST 07 (3 reserved for women). It appears that
following a representation dated 07.02.2025 submitted by one candidate
of Philosophy subject to TPSC authority praying for age relaxation on the
ground that in earlier Advertisements of the year 2021 and 2022, due to
non-availability of posts of subject Philosophy, that candidate could not
appear, the TPSC has issued one notification dated 07.03.2025
(Annexure R/18) giving one time relaxation of age in respect of subject
Philosophy (only for UR, ST & PH candidates), Sanskrit (only for SC
candidates), Economics (only for SC & ST candidates) and so on, as the
previous Advertisement No.01/2021 and No.08/2022 did not contain
such posts. But no such age relaxation has been further provided for UR
category of candidates of Human Physiology subject.
x) The petitioner submitted one representation on 07.02.2025 to
the Education (Higher) Department and then to TPSC on 18.02.2025 for
allowing her one time relaxation in upper age in her case but no reply
has been received by her in respect of the same. But she received one
message that her age was not suitable for the post of Human
Physiology.
xi) The petitioner also filed WP (C) 127 of 2025 but said petition
has been withdrawn at the motion stage. And now after the latest
notification of TPSC dated 07.03.2025 and 10.03.2025, this fresh writ
petition is filed. According to the petitioner, by notification dated
07.03.2025, age relaxation was granted only in respect of some
specified subjects and vide notification dated 10.03.2025, TPSC asked
the concerned candidates to submit documentary evidence to show their
participation in the Advertisement No.19 of 2017 to avail such age
relaxation benefit. According to the petitioner she applied for the post in
respect of Advertisement no. 19 of 2017 and therefore, she has right
and legitimate expectation to be considered for such age relaxation.
[2]
With that factual background, Mr. Amrit Lal Saha, learned
counsel submits that the initial advertisement No.08/2022 issued by the
TPSC for filling up 05 nos. of vacant post (SC:01, ST:02, UR:02) in
respect of discipline Human Physiology was taken up and the petitioner
was in the know of that advertisement but in the said advertisement no
age relaxation was given in respect of candidates of Human Physiology
subject. Thereafter, Mr. Saha, learned counsel submits, another
notification in the form of corrigendum was issued by the TPSC on
26.04.2022 wherein such age relaxation was also given in respect of SC
& UR category of candidates against Human Physiology subject, but the
notification itself indicates that no publication was made for general
information in this regard and, therefore, it was not within the
knowledge of the petitioner and hence she could not submit any
application in that recruitment process. Learned counsel also submits
that even till today any such notification dated 26.04.2022 is not found
available in the website of TPSC.
[3]
Mr. Saha, learned counsel also refers to the direction no.1 of
the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in above said WP(C)
No.172 of 2015 wherein the direction was issued that no fresh
application would be invited and only the candidates who had already
applied shall be considered for appointment to the post of Assistant
Professor and, therefore, it was not obligatory for the petitioner to apply
again for selection against any such post lateron. Mr. Saha, learned
counsel referring to one copy of acknowledgement placed under
Annexure-10 submits that in the recruitment processes initiated in the
year 2017 the petitioner duly applied, but said selection process was
cancelled by the State Government and, therefore, she is now entitled
to get one time age relaxation, at least once, in subsequent selection
processes.
[4]
Mr. Saha, learned counsel also submits that the petitioner
filed said previous writ petition number WP(C) No.127 of 2025 with
similar relief, but certain facts were required to be introduced further in
the proceeding and, therefore, the writ petition was withdrawn and the
present writ petition has been filed after incorporating those new facts.
Mr. Saha, learned counsel emphatically submits that in the previous writ
petition no decision was given on merit by the Court as it was withdrawn
at motion stage and in absence of any issue wise decision or decision on
merit, the principle of res judicata will not be applicable. Mr. Saha,
learned counsel in addition further submits that when fundamental right
of a person is infringed, normally a constitutional court does not shut
the door to the petitioner on any such technical ground of withdrawal of
previous writ petition. Mr. Saha, learned counsel tries to buttress his
submission relying on a decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sarguja
Transport Service versus State Transport Appellate Tribunal,
M.P., Gwalior, & Others (1987) 1 SCC 5, more particularly the
paragraph nos.8 & 9, as extracted hereunder:
8. The question for our consideration is whether it
would or would not advance the cause of justice if the
principle underlying Rule 1 of Order XXIII of the Code is
adopted in respect of writ petitions filed under Articles
226/227 of the Constitution of India also. It is common
knowledge that very often after a writ petition is heard
for some time when the petitioner or his counsel finds
that the court is not likely to pass an order admitting
the petition, request is made by the petitioner or by his
counsel to permit the petitioner to withdraw from the
writ petition without seeking permission to institute a
fresh writ petition. A Court which is unwilling to admit
the petition would not ordinarily grant liberty to file a
fresh petition while it may just agree to permit the
withdrawal of the petition. It is plain that when once a
writ petition filed in a High Court is withdrawn by the
petitioner himself he is precluded from filing an appeal
against the order passed in the writ petition because he
cannot be considered as a party aggrieved by the order
passed by the High Court. He may as stated in Daryao v.
State of U.P1 [1(1962) 1 SCR 574. AIR 1961 SC 1457] in
a case involving the question of enforcement of
fundamental rights file a petition before the Supreme
Court under Article 32 of the Constitution of India
because in such a case there has been no decision on
the merits by the High Court. The relevant observation
of this Court in Daryao case is to be found at page 593
and it is as follows:
If the petition is dismissed as withdrawn it cannot
be a bar to a subsequent petition under Article 32,
because in such a case there has been no decision on
the merits by the court. We wish to make it clear that
the conclusions thus reached by us are confined only to
the point of res judicata which has been argued as a
preliminary issue in these writ petitions and no other.
9. The point for consideration is whether a
petitioner after with-drawing a writ petition filed by him
in the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India without the permission to institute a fresh
petition can file a fresh writ petition in the High Court
under that article. On this point the decision in Daryao
case is of no assistance. But we are of the view that the
principle underlying Rule 1 of Order XXIII of the Code
should be extended in the interests of administration of
justice to cases of withdrawal of writ petition also, not
on the ground of res judicata but on the ground of
public policy as explained above. It would also
discourage the litigant from indulging in bench-hunting
tactics. In any event there is no justifiable reason in
such a case to permit a petitioner to invoke the
extraordinary jurisdiction of the High Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution once again. While the
withdrawal of a writ petition filed in a High Court
without permission to file a fresh writ petition may not
bar other remedies like a suit or a petition under Article
32 of the Constitution of India since such withdrawal
does not amount to res judicata, the remedy under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India should be
deemed to have been abandoned by the petitioner in
respect of the cause of action relied on in the writ
petition when he withdraws it without such permission.
In the instant case the High Court was right in holding
that a fresh writ petition was not maintainable before it
in respect of the same subject-matter since the earlier
writ petition had been withdrawn without permission to
file a fresh petition. We, however, make it clear that
whatever we have stated in this order may not be
considered as being applicable to a writ petition
involving the personal liberty of an individual in which
the petitioner prays for the issue of a writ in the nature
of habeas corpus or seeks to enforce the fundamental
right guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution
since such a case stands on a different footing
altogether. We, however leave this question open.
Finally Mr. Saha, learned counsel prays for allowing the writ
petition by giving a chance to the petitioner to appear in the ongoing
selection process of 2025 by providing one time age relaxation to her.
[5]
In reply, Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel, submits that the
corrigendum notification dated 26.04.2022 as stated above was duly
uploaded in the website of the TPSC and some indications is available on
the bottom note of the said corrigendum itself that copy of said
notification was sent to both IT Cell and RTI Cell. Mr. Datta, learned
counsel also in alternately submits that even if said notification was not
uploaded
in
the
website
for
general
information,
but
the
first
advertisement issued in connection with said Advertisement No.8/2022
was duly uploaded in the website and the petitioner was also in the
know of the same, but she did not challenge said notification despite the
fact that such age relaxation was only given to the candidates applying
for the subjects Physical Education, Commerce and Mathematics and no
such relaxation was provided to UR category candidates of Physiology
subject, therefore, she is now stopped from claiming any such one time
relaxation in the ongoing recruitment process. Mr. Datta, learned
counsel also submits that present writ petition is not maintainable in its
present form as the previous writ petition bearing number WP(C)
No.127 of 2025 was filed before the Court seeking similar relief, but
same was withdrawn on 07.03.2025 without seeking liberty to file a
fresh writ petition on the same reliefs. According to Ld. Counsel, Mr.
Datta, said fact is not disputed by the petitioner, otherwise they would
submit rejoinder challenging the specific plea taken in paragraph no.4 of
the counter affidavit submitted by TPSC.
[6]
Mr. Datta, learned counsel also similarly relies on the same
decision of Hon’ble Apex Court as rendered in Sarguja Transport
supra. Further, Mr. Datta, learned counsel also relies on another
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered in Avinash Nagra
versus Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti & Others, (1997) 2 Supreme
Court Cases 534 wherein at para 13 it was observed that the High
Court also was right in its conclusion that the second writ petition was
not maintainable as the principle of constructive res judicata would
apply there, inasmuch as the petitioner filed the writ petition in the first
instance, but withdrew the same without permission of the Court with
liberty to file the second writ petition and, therefore, the second writ
petition was not maintainable. Another decision on the same point as
relied on by Mr. Datta, learned counsel, is MJ Exporters Private
Limited versus Union of India & Others, (2021) 13 SCC 543
wherein also the followings were observing in paragraph no.15:
15. In these circumstances, we feel that when
this issue was raised and abandoned in the first writ
petition which was dismissed as withdrawn, the
principles of constructive res judicata which are laid
down under Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908, and which principles are extendable
to writ proceedings as well as held by this Court in
Sarguja Transport Service v. STAT [6 (1987) 1 SCC 5 :
1987 SCC (Cri) 19] would squarely be applicable.
[7]
Finally Mr. Datta, learned counsel relies on a recent decision
of Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of State of Orissa & Anr. vs. Laxmi
Narayan Das(Dead) through legal representatives & Others,
(2023) 15 SCC 273 wherein at paragraph no.37 the followings were
observed:
37. On the question, as to whether after the
withdrawal of a suit claiming the same relief without
having permission to institute fresh one for the same
relief, a writ petition will be maintainable before the
Court, the guidance is available from the judgment of
this Court in M.J. Exporters Private Limited v. Union of
India, wherein the principle of constructive res
judicata was applied. The case concerns a litigant who
sought to file a fresh writ petition after withdrawal of
the earlier writ petition filed for the same relief
without permission to file fresh one. The Court held
that the principles contained in Order 23 Rule 1
CPC are applicable even in writ proceedings. Para 15
thereof is extracted below:
“15. In these circumstances, we feel that when
this issue was raised and abandoned in the first writ
petition which was dismissed as withdrawn, the
principles of constructive res judicata which are laid
down under Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908, and which principles are extendable
to writ proceedings as well as held by this Court
in Sarguja Transport Service v. STAT [19 (1987) 1 SCC
5: 1987 SCC (Cri) 19]”
[8]
Mr. H. Sarkar, learned counsel for the State Respondents
also in the same way submits that present writ petition is not
maintainable for the grounds as raised by the TPSC.
[9]
Mr. A.L. Saha, learned counsel in reply submits that against
the advocate notice issued by the petitioner, the Director of Higher
Education specifically mentioned that one time age relaxation would be
granted to the petitioner in terms of the memorandum issued by
GA(P&T) Department vide no.F.20(1)-GA(P&T)/18 dated 20-08-2018.
So, the petitioner is now entitled to get said one time age relaxation
now. Mr. Saha, learned counsel also refers to the paragraph no.9 of the
counter affidavit submitted by the State-respondents which is also for
useful reference extracted hereunder:
9. That, with reference to the averments made in
para-5 of the writ petition, the answering Respondents
stated that the averment made in this para is a fact that
Petitioner couldn’t apply against the Advt. 01/2021 as
there was no UR seat for Human Physiology and in the
subsequent advt. i.e. No.08/2022 there was no upper
age relaxation given for Human Physiology except
Mathematics, Physical Education & Commerce; therefore,
the petitioner may be given one-time relaxation in upper
age limit against the advt. No.05/2025 if she could
provide documentary evidence of participating in the
Advt. No.19/2017 but not against the Advt. 08/2014. In
this
regard,
a
letter
vide
No.F.1(687)DHE/Estt(G)/2019/1798 dated 19.09.2019 had been
issued to the Ld. Advocate against the legal notice dated
23.08.2019 issued on behalf of Smt. Rupanjali Saha.
Mr. Saha, Ld. Cousel refers the abovenoted averments of the
counter affidavit to strength his submission that the state
government is also of the view that the petitioner is entitled to
get such onetime relaxation against the present advertisement of
the year 2025, but such submission is not convincing, for, said
paraghaps mainly contains the averments of the writ petitioner
made in the writ petition and not the opinion of the state
government.
[ 10 ]
This court has considered the submissions of both sides and
have meticulously gone through the record. Two primary issues arise
here in this writ petition for decision of the Court and these are- firstly,
whether the petitioner is entitled to get one time age relaxation in the
ongoing recruitment process despite the fact that she did not participate
in the recruitment process of 2022 and secondly, whether the present
writ petition is not maintainable in view of the fact that previous writ
petition was withdrawn by her. So far the first point of challenge is
concerned, it appears that there was no direction for the High Court in
the said judgment passed in WP(C) No.172 of 2015 for giving any such
age relaxation to the applicant in any such future recruitment process.
Rather from the letter dated 19.09.2019 was issued by the Director of
Higher Education Department to the learned counsel of the petitioner to
the effect that proposal for amendment of the recruitment rules was
under consideration of the State and as per paragraph no.4 of
memorandum dated 20.08.2018 issued by GA(P&T) Department was
relevant for the consideration of the petitioner as she was worried about
crossing of her upper age limit and as per para 4 of the said
memorandum, if she applied for the post of Assistant Professor with
reference to earlier Advertisement No.19/2017, she would be given
such onetime age relaxation in upper age limit to participate once in
fresh recruitment process subject to providing documentary evidence of
her participation in the said earlier recruitment process of 2017. Mr.
Saha, learned counsel has also brought to the notice of related
document containing acknowledgment to show that the petitioner
applied in the said recruitment process of 2017. Anyway, as indicated
above,
TPSC
issued
Advertisement
No.01/2021
(Annexure
R/9)
subsequently for filling up of 40(forty) posts of Assistant Professor out of
which only three posts (ST:03 PH:01) were meant for subject Human
Physiology. But, as at that time there was no post of UR category in that
advertisement against physiology subject, so in the recruitment process
of the year 2022, by a corrigendum notification dated 26.04.2022
(Annexure- R/13), such benefit of age relaxation was extended in case
of SC and UR category of candidates in respect of subject Human
Physiology. Admittedly the petitioner did not avail that opportunity.
[ 11]
Though it is argued before the Court that it was not within
the knowledge of the petitioner that such subsequent notification
extending such benefit to UR category of candidates was issued by TPSC
as the same was not found in the website of the TPSC, but no such
averments is made or ground is taken by the petitioner either in the writ
petition or by filing a rejoinder. Even if it is presumed that such
subsequent notification was not uploaded in the website of TPSC or no
newspaper publication was made in this regard, in that case certainly
there would be serious grievances of the petitioner persisted at that
time that despite assurance given by the State, no such benefit was
being extended to the UR category candidates, and in that case,
certainly she would challenge the same before the Court or atleast
would submit one representation to the TPSC or to the State ventilating
her such grievances, but nothing as such was done by her. Therefore,
this ground as being raised now only during hearing of the case, cannot
be entertained.
If a notification or advertisement was published for
general information, and if a person despite the same did not respond to
it, for whatsoever reason as stated, said person cannot derive any
subsequent legal right to claim for the same in any other subsequent
recruitment process. It is not a case that such one time age relaxation
was given to a particular person like the petitioner, rather State as a
matter of policy decision, extended such benefit in general for all
applicants who had meanwhile crossed the upper limit of the age and
could not participate in the earlier recruitment process as same was
cancelled. Therefore, any particular candidate cannot retain a choice of
availing the same in any particular recruitment processes subsequent
thereto as per his/her convenience.
Therefore, the claim of the
petitioner of such onetime age relaxation in the present recruitment
process is not tenable at law.
[ 12 ]
So far second point of challenge is concerned, it is admitted
position that with similar reliefs, earlier the petitioner submitted writ
petition bearing number WP(C) No.127 of 2025 which was withdrawn by
her on 07.03.2025 without reserving her liberty to file a fresh writ
petition with similar reliefs. All the above referred pronouncements of
Hon’ble Apex Court have made it settled that the principle of
constructive res judicata is applicable in writ proceeding and withdrawal
of any such writ petition without having liberty or permission to file fresh
writ petition for the same relief, precludes him for filing the same again.
It is also a fact that while said writ petition was withdrawn no liberty or
permission was obtained from the court by the petitioner for submitting
fresh writ petition with similar relief. Thus, the present writ petition is
not maintainable. Therefore, both the points are decided accordingly
against the petitioner.
In view of above discussion the writ petition is dismissed.
No order as to costs.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SATABDI DUTTA
SATABDI DUTTA Digitally
Date: 2025.05.21 13:02:04 +05'30'
Riki
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review