The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
2. RINKU @ HARIMOHAN SIHVHARE S/O SHRI SEETARAM SHIVHARE, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS, BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH) .....RESPONDENTS (SHRI DINESH SAVITA - PANEL LAWYER FOR RESPONDENT NO.1 & SHRI RAM KRISHNA PATHAK - ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.2/ACCUSED) This application coming on for Admission this day, the court passed the following: The present application under Section 439 (2) of Cr.P.C. has been filed for cancellation of bail granted to the respondent no.2 by the Coordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 21/06/2022 passed in M.Cr.C. No.26979/2022. Brief facts for disposal of the case are that upon the death of Santosh Jain S/o Sumerchand Jain who was the husband of the petitioner a Merg No. 12:39:44 PM 26/2021 was registered under Section 174 of Cr.P.C. After enquiry, a Crime No. 461 of 2021 under Section 302 and 201 of IPC was registered against respondent No. 2-Rinku @ Harimohan Shivhare. Respondent no.2 filed an application for bail in M.Cr.C. No.26979/2022 and granted the benefit of bail by the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 21/06/2022 with certain conditions. The ground for cancellation for bail in brief are that the bail was obtained by placing wrong facts before the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court. The Police had not conducted the investigation in a fair manner. The petitioner gave a representation to Home Minister, Government of M.P. on 19.01.2022 for fair in…
20. It had not been the case of the prosecution that the appellant had misused the liberty or had comported herself in any manner in violation of the conditions imposed on her. We are impelled to observe that power of cancellation of bail should be exercised with extreme care and circumspection; and such cancellation cannot be ordered merely for any perceived indiscipline on the part of the accused before granting bail. In other words, the powers of cancellation of bail cannot be approached as if of disciplinary proceedings against the accused and in fact, in a case where bail has already been granted, its upsetting under Section 439 (2) CrPC is envisaged only in such cases where the liberty of the accused is going to be counteracting the requirements of a proper trial of the criminal case. In the matter of the present nature, in our view, over-expansion of the issue was not required only for one reason that a particular factor was not stated by the Trial Court in its order granting bail." In the case of State of Rajasthan Vs. Mubin and Ors.; 2011 Crl. L.J. 12:39:44 PM 3850, the Court has held as under; “9. The primary question which is to be considered by us in this case is as to whether the accused applicants had committed any offence, during the pendency of the appeal, on account of lodging of some first information reports. In other words, can it be said that a person has commi…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE SUNITA YADAV
ON THE 4th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. CRIMINAL CASE No. 14222 of 2023
BETWEEN:SMT REENA JAIN W/O LATE SHRI SANTOSH JAIN,
AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS, R/O GANDHI ROAD WARD NO.
6, MEHGAON, BHIND AT PRESENT GWALIOR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPLICANT
(SHRI HARI KRISHAN SINGH CHAUHAN - ADVOCATE FOR
APPLICANT/PETITIONER)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
POLICE STATION MEHGAON, DISTRICT BHIND
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
RINKU @ HARIMOHAN SIHVHARE S/O SHRI
SEETARAM SHIVHARE, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
NAGAR PALIKA NIGAM K SAMNE MEHGAON
BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI DINESH SAVITA - PANEL LAWYER FOR RESPONDENT NO.1 & SHRI
RAM KRISHNA PATHAK - ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.2/ACCUSED)
This application coming on for Admission this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
The present application under Section 439 (2) of Cr.P.C. has been filed
for cancellation of bail granted to the respondent no.2 by the Coordinate Bench
of this Court vide order dated 21/06/2022 passed in M.Cr.C. No.26979/2022.
Brief facts for disposal of the case are that upon the death of Santosh
Jain S/o Sumerchand Jain who was the husband of the petitioner a Merg No.
Signed by: LOKENDRA JAIN
Signing time: 1/6/2024
12:39:44 PM
26/2021 was registered under Section 174 of Cr.P.C. After enquiry, a Crime
No. 461 of 2021 under Section 302 and 201 of IPC was registered against
respondent No. 2-Rinku @ Harimohan Shivhare. Respondent no.2 filed an
application for bail in M.Cr.C. No.26979/2022 and granted the benefit of bail by
the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 21/06/2022 with certain
conditions.
The ground for cancellation for bail in brief are that the bail was obtained
by placing wrong facts before the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court. The Police
had not conducted the investigation in a fair manner. The petitioner gave a
representation to Home Minister, Government of M.P. on 19.01.2022 for fair
investigation, however, the police failed to do so. Respondent No. 2 threatened
the petitioner to change her statement upon which FIR was also registered
bearing Crime No. 470 of 2021. In these circumstances, the bail granted to the
respondent No.2 deserves to be recalled.
On the other hand, learned counsel for respondent No. 2 opposed the
application on the ground that there is no reason for cancellation of bail as
respondent No.2 has not committed any breach in respect to the condition
imposed upon him while granting bail. It is further submitted that the Coordinate Bench of this Court has considered on each and every aspect of the
case and heard the prosecution and thereafter granted bail. There is nothing on
record to show that any wrong fact was placed before the Co-ordinate Bench
of this Court for obtaining the bail. The present petition has been filed with
melafide intention, therefore, the same deserves to be dismissed.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in case the case of Dolat Ram Vs. State of
Signed by: LOKENDRA JAIN
Signing time: 1/6/2024
12:39:44 PM
Haryana [(1995) 1 SCC 349 : 1995 SCC (Cri) 237] has held as under:
“Very cogent and overwhelming circumstances are necessary for an
o rd e r directing the cancellation of the bail, already granted.
Generally speaking, the grounds for cancellation of bail, broadly
(illustrative and not exhaustive) are: interference or attempt to
interfere with the due course of administration of Justice or evasion
or attempt to evade the due course of justice or abuse of the
concession granted to the accused in any manner. The satisfaction of
the court, on the basis of material placed on the record of the
possibility of the accused absconding is yet another reason justifying
the cancellation of bail. However, bail once granted should not be
cancelled in a mechanical manner without considering whether any
supervening circumstances have rendered it no longer conducive to a
fair trial to allow the accused to retain his freedom by enjoying the
concession of bail during the trial. These principles, it appears, were
lost sight of by the High Court when it decided to cancel the bail,
already granted. The High Court it appears to us overlooked the
distinction of the factors relevant for rejecting bail in a non-bailable
case in the first instance and the cancellation of bail already granted”
In the case of Bhuri Bai vs. The State of Madhya Pradesh: 2022
LiveLaw (SC) 956, the Apex Court has held as under:
“1 9 . It remains trite that normally, very cogent and overwhelming
circumstances or grounds are required to cancel the bail already
granted. Ordinarily, unless a strong case based on any supervening
event is made out, an order granting bail is not to be lightly interfered
with under Section 439 (2) CrPC."
20. It had not been the case of the prosecution that the appellant had
misused the liberty or had comported herself in any manner in
violation of the conditions imposed on her. We are impelled to
observe that power of cancellation of bail should be exercised with
extreme care and circumspection; and such cancellation cannot be
ordered merely for any perceived indiscipline on the part of the
accused before granting bail. In other words, the powers of
cancellation of bail cannot be approached as if of disciplinary
proceedings against the accused and in fact, in a case where bail has
already been granted, its upsetting under Section 439 (2) CrPC is
envisaged only in such cases where the liberty of the accused is going
to be counteracting the requirements of a proper trial of the criminal
case. In the matter of the present nature, in our view, over-expansion
of the issue was not required only for one reason that a particular
factor was not stated by the Trial Court in its order granting bail."
In the case of State of Rajasthan Vs. Mubin and Ors.; 2011 Crl. L.J.
Signed by: LOKENDRA JAIN
Signing time: 1/6/2024
12:39:44 PM
3850, the Court has held as under;
“9. The primary question which is to be considered by us in this case
is as to whether the accused applicants had committed any offence,
during the pendency of the appeal, on account of lodging of some first
information reports. In other words, can it be said that a person has
committed an offence when a first information report is lodged
against him. In our considered opinion, merely lodging of a first
information report, does not amount to commission of an offence and
it is only accusation/allegation which can be said to be leveled
against the accused person at the stage. As a matter of fact, the
question as to whether an offence has been prim-facie committed or
not is considered when an opinion is formed by the Court after
applying mind on the material before it. That stage would come only
at the time of framing of charge. It would be relevant to mention here
that the legislature, in its wisdom, has clearly laid down the
distinction in the provisions under Section 228, Cr. P.C. and the
terminology used at the stages prior to it. The relevant provisions of
the Code of criminal procedure is as under:- “228. – Framing of
charge – (1) If, after such consideration and hearing as aforesaid, the
Judge is of opinion that there is ground for presuming that the
accused has committed an offence which –
(a) is not exclusively triable by the Court of Session, he may, frame a
charge against the accused and, by order, transfer the case for trial to
the Chief Judicial Magistrate (or any other Judicial Magistrate of the
first class and direct the accused to appear before the Chief Judicial
Magistrate, or, as the case may be, the Judicial Magistrate, or, as the
case may be, the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, on such date
as he deems fit, and thereupon such Magistrate) shall try the offence
in accordance with the procedure for the trial of warrant-cases
instituted on a police report;
(b) is exclusively triable by the Court, he shall frame in writing a
charge against the accused.”
In other words, an accused can be said to have committed an offence
only when a Court, after considering the material before it and
hearing the parties, forms an opinion to that effect, at the time of
framing of charge. It is only after judicious consideration by a Court
and an opinion is formed by it for presuming the commission of an
offence that an accused can be said to have committed an offence.
Therefore, an offence can be said to have been committed only at the
stage of framing of charge when the concerning Court forms an
opinion for presuming that the accused has committed the offence and
not at earlier point of time. The word ‘commit’ as per Johnson
Dictionary means 'to be guilty of a crime.”
Signed by: LOKENDRA JAIN
Signing time: 1/6/2024
12:39:44 PM
In view of the above settled principles of law, the perusal of the record
indicates that the respondent No. 2 was arrested on 12.12.2021 and letter
(Annexure P/3) was written on 19.01.2021, when the respondent No. 2 was still
in custody. The record further reveals that when FIR bearing Crime No. 470 of
2021 (Annexure P/6) was registered, respondent No.2 was under custody,
therefore, question of threatening the petitioner does not arise. Furthermore,
petitioner has failed to show that on the basis that FIR No. 470 of 2021, charge
sheet has been filed against the persons said to be relatives of the petitioneraccused and concerned competent Court has taken cognizance in that case.
As discussed above, there is no reason to recall the order granting bail to
respondent no.2.
Consequently, present petition sans merits and is hereby dismissed.
(SUNITA YADAV)
JUDGE
(LJ*)
Signed by: LOKENDRA JAIN
Signing time: 1/6/2024
12:39:44 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review