Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 53 of 2024
Rama Laskar Choudhury,
wife of Ashok Kr. Paul, care of Sri Ashok Kr. Paul,
resident of Ramnagar Road No.7 (middle),
PO- Ramnagar, PS- West Agartala,
District- West Tripura, Pin-799002.
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
represented by the Commissioner & Secretary
to the General Administration (Administrative Reforms)
Department, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, PO- Kunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division- Sadar, District- West Tripura.
2. The Commissioner & Secretary,
Finance Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Complex, Gurkhabasti, Agartala,
PO- Kunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex, Sub-Division- Sadar,
District- West Tripura.
3. The Lokayukta, Tripura,
represented by its Registrar, Office Compound of the District Magistrate &
Collector,
West Tripura, PO- Agartala, PS- West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin799001.
4. The Tripura State Legal Services Authority,
represented by its Member Secretary,
Old District & Sessions Judge Court Complex,
PO- Agartala, PS- West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin-799001.
---Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
Date of pronouncement
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
:
Mr. P Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. K. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. GA.
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate.
27.09.2024
03.10.2024
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment and Order
This is a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for
seeking the following relief(s):
(i) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show cause as to
why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued, to
transmit the records, lying with them, for rendering substantive and conscionable
justice to the Petitioner, and for quashing/setting aside the impugned Letter dated
19.12.2023 (Annexure-19 supra);
(ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and each one of them, to show cause as to
why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be issued,
mandating/directing them (more particularly, the Respondent No.3), to count half
of the continuous service period, as rendered by the Petitioner (on no work no pay
basis), under the Tripura State Legal Services Authority, for the purpose of
Pension, and thereupon, to grant Pension and other post retiral benefits, in favour
of the Petitioner;
(iii) Call for the records, appertaining to this Writ Petition;
(iv) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the Rule absolute in terms of (i) & (ii)
above;
(v) Costs of and incidental to this proceeding
(vi) Any other Relief(s) as to this Hon'ble High Court may deem fit and proper;
[2]
It is the case of the petitioner that from 08.12.2004 to 16.05.2012, the
petitioner had worked for a total period of 7 years (on no work no pay basis), but on
full time basis as Legal Service Worker Grade-II and subsequently as Service
Worker Grade-1, under the Tripura State Legal Services Authority (TSLSA). On
16.05.2012, the petitioner resigned from her said service under TSLSA. On
17.05.2012, the petitioner joined as UDC, under Lokayukta, Tripura, on fixed pay
basis. On completion of 5 years of service, the petitioner was regularized w.e.f.
17.05.2017. After serving for a total period of 9 years & 8 months in the Lokayukta
Tripura, on attaining the age of superannuation, the petitioner proceeded to
retirement 31.01.2022. Due to shortage of only 4 months for qualifying service of 10
years, the petitioner neither received pension, nor other post retiral benefits. Situated
thus, the petitioner submitted representations dated 18.01.2023 & 28.06.2023
praying for counting half of the service period as rendered by her under TSLSA. As
per Finance Department's Memorandum dated 25.02.2010, half of the said period is
to be counted towards pension. The petitioner served a Statutory Notice dated
05.07.2023 upon the respondents, seeking release of pension and post retiral
benefits. By a notification dated 20.12.2022, one Smt. Rama Chakraborty who was a
co-employee of the petitioner was granted the benefit of pension and post retiral
benefits, by counting half of her past service period, rendered on no work no pay
basis. But, the petitioner was deprived thereof. Thereafter, pursuant to a Writ
Petition [WP(C) No.608 of 2023], filed earlier by the petitioner. the Respondent
No.3 was directed to consider the case of the petitioner. On purported consideration
thereof, the respondent No.3 issued a letter dated 19.12.2023, thereby rejecting the
prayer of the petitioner. Aggrieved by the said action of the respondents, the
petitioner has approached this Court for seeking relief.
[3]
It is contended by the learned senior counsel for the petitioner that one
of the then co-employee of the petitioner, namely, Smt. Rama Chakraborty who
were conjointly promoted to the post of Legal Service Worker, Grade-I under
TSLSA, vide the office order dated 15.05..2008 was granted the benefit of pension
and other post retiral benefits by counting her past services rendered on no work no
pay basis, as per the policy decision of the Finance Department, Government of
Tripura.
[4]
It is further contended by the learned senior counsel for the petitioner
that both TSLSA and the Lokayukta, Tripura are administrative authorities, formed
uder the Tripura State Legal Services Authority Rule, 1998 and the Tripura
Lokayukta Act, 2008 respectively. As per Rule 10 of the Tripura State Legal
Services Rules, 1998 an employee of TSLSA is entitled to draw pay and allowance
in the scales of pay as admissible to Tripura Government employees holding
equivalent posts, and shall also have the same status, as of a Government employee.
[5]
On course of his submission, learned senior counsel also contended
that on account of her subsequent employment (i.e., under the Lokayukta, Tripura),
since, there was a shortage of only 4 months for completing the qualifying service, it
was obligatory on their part that by taking resort to the Finance Department's
Memoranda dated 16.08.1978, 26.09.1979, 19.07.1982 & 25.02.2010 (Annexures10, 11, 12 & 13 respectively supra) and in conformity with Rule 13 & Rule 14 of the
CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, count the half period of the past services, as rendered
by the petitioner under TSLSA for the purpose of pension, and thereupon, to grant
the benefit of pension and other post retiral benefits, in her favour.
[6]
It is apposite to extract herein below the relevant portion of
Memorandum dated 26.09.1979.
(a) half the period of continuous service rendered by a contingent worker
paid from „wages‟ and engaged on full time may be counted towards
pension when followed by employment in regular pensionable service.
[7]
Learned senior counsel has also drawn the attention of this court to the
Memorandum dated 25.02.2010 and the relevant portion is extracted herein under:
“After careful consideration of the matter, the Governor has been pleased
to decide that the benefit of counting of half of the period of continuous
service rendered by the DRWs/ Contingent Workers/ Monthly Rated
Workers/ Casual Workers who were engaged on full time basis and paid
from wages' would be counted towards pension following their
regularization with the approval of the Finance Department. The benefit
provided under this circular will not have any relevance in declaration of
employees as quasi permanent/ permanent/counting of seniority/counting
of period for the purpose of determining eligibility for extending benefit of
CAS/ACP.”
[8]
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner on the basis of the
memorandum cited above has urged before this court to allow the petition. This
Court is amazed to learn that no judgment has been placed to support the case of the
petitioner.
[9]
On the contrary, Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
Lokayukta has drawn the attention of this court to the order of engagement dated
07.12.2004 issued by the Member Secretary to the petitioner herein. For ready
reference the relevant portion of the order of engagement is extracted herein below:
ORDER OF ENGAGEMENT.
Smti. Rama Laskar Choudhury, W/O Shri Ashok Paul of Ramnagar Road
No.7, P.O.- Ramanagar, Agartaala, West Tripura is hereby engaged as
Grade -II Worker for a period of 6 (six) months w.e.f. the date she joins but
by 10.12.2004 to work under the Tripura State Legal Services Authority,
(Statutory body) Agartala on no work no pay basis with a monthly
remuneration of Rs.3300/-( Rupees three thousand three hundred) only. Her
service will be required in connection with various office works/Legal
services Programmes. Her service will not be required when there will be no
programme or fund from National Legal Services Authority, State
Government or other is not available or her performance is not satisfactory.
If she is willing to work, she is requested to report to the office of the
Tripura State Legal Services Authority, North West corner of the Palace
Compound, Agartala immediately.
[10]
Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel contended that the petitioner was
never appointed as a salaried employee and it was clearly reflected in the order of
engagement that her service will not be required when there will be no programme
or fund from National Legal Services Authority, State Government or other is not
available or her performance is not satisfactory.
[11]
It is also submitted by Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel that the
appointment of the petitioner to the post of UDC (Fixed pay) was not done by
following the norms and regulations and for appointment to the said post and no
advertisement was published nor any interview was conducted. As a result, the
petitioner is not entitled to get any relief as prayed for. It is worth mentioning here
that Anneure-10,11,12,13&14 to the writ petition are issued/related with Finance
Department, Government of Tripura regarding counting of past service but fact
remains said notification/memorandum were never adopted by the answering
respondents. Moreover, the writ petitioner had already submitted an application for
voluntary retirement and her request for voluntary retirement was accepted and as
such acceptance of her application for voluntary retirement, the petitioner cannot
claim for counting of her past service for the purpose of pension when there is no
pension scheme under the Tripura Lokayukta Act, 2008 and on this ground itself the
writ petition is liable to be dismissed.
[12]
To support his contention Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel for the
respondent no.3 has relied on a judgment of the apex court in Director General,
Doordarshan Prasar Bharti Corporation of India and Another vs. Magi H. Desai
reported in 2023 SCC Online SC 336 where the apex court has observed as follows:
13. The respondent is governed by the Central Civil Services (Pension)
Rules, 1972. Rules 13 & 14 of the 1972 Rules, which are relevant for
deciding the controversy in the present case, read as under:
“13. Commencement of qualifying service - Subject to the
provisions of these rules, qualifying service of a Government
servant shall commence from the date he takes charge of the post
to which he is first appointed either substantively or in an
officiating or temporary capacity:
Provided that officiating or temporary service is followed without
Interruption by substantive appointment in the same or another
service or post:
Provided further that (a) in the case of a Government servant in a Group 'D'........
(b) in the case of a Government servant not covered by clause (a)
14. Conditions subject to which service qualifies:
(1) The service of a Government servant shall not qualify, unless
his duties and pay are regulated by the Government, or under
conditions determined by the Government.
(2) For the purposes of sub-rule (1), the expression "Service"
means service under the Government and paid by that Government
from the Consolidated Fund of India or a Local Fund administered
by that Government but does not include service in a nonpensionable establishment unless such service is treated as
qualifying service by that Government.
(3) In the case of a Government servant belonging to a State
Government, who is permanently transferred to a service or post to
which these rules apply, the continuous service rendered under the
State Government in an officiating or temporary capacity, if any,
followed without interruption by substantive appointment, or the
continuous service rendered under that Government in an
officiating or temporary capacity, as the case may be, shall
qualify:
Provided that nothing contained in this sub-rule shall apply to any
such Government servant who is appointed otherwise than by
deputation to a service or post to which these rules apply."
14. Rule 13 of the 1972 Rules provides for commencement of qualifying
service. As per Rule 13, qualifying service of a Government servant shall
commence from the date he takes charge of the post to which he is first
appointed either substantively or in an officiating or temporary capacity. It
further provides that such officiating or temporary service is followed
without interruption by substantive appointment in the same or another
service or post. Therefore, the services rendered on a substantive post or
services rendered as officiating or temporary service shall be treated as
qualifying service. Service rendered as casual/contractual cannot be said
to be officiating or temporary service. Even the services rendered as
temporary service can be considered as qualifying service provided that
the officiating or temporary service is followed without interruption by
substantive appointment in the same or another service or post. Service
rendered as casual/contractual cannot be said to be service rendered on a
substantive appointment.
15. Under the circumstances and on a fair reading and interpretation of
Rule 13 of the 1972 Rules, the High Court has committed a very serious
error in observing that the services in temporary capacity will include the
classes of temporary service such as casual or even contractual. The High
Court has materially erred in observing that the contractual service would
be qualified as service in a temporary capacity. The question is not
whether the services rendered by a contractual employee would be
qualified as service in a temporary capacity. The question is, whether, in
fact, such contractual employee rendered the services as temporary or not.
16. Now so far as the submission on behalf of the respondent that in other
departments under the scheme the employees of such departments are
entitled to their services rendered as casual/contractual counted for
qualifying service for pensionary/service benefits is concerned, merely
because some other departments might have such schemes, the respondent
shall not be entitled to the same benefit in absence of any scheme in the
appellants' department/department in which the respondent rendered her
services. The appellant Doordarshan Prasar Bharti Corporation of India is
an autonomous independent department/body. As observed hereinabove,
neither the rule nor the regularisation scheme provide that services
rendered as casual/contractual shall be treated as temporary service
and/or the same shall be counted for the purposes pensionary/service
benefits.
[13]
Mr. Raju Datta, learned counsel for the respondent No.3 has
concluded his argument by stating that the petitioner herein has no case as none of
the memorandum relied by her is not accepted by the Lokayukta, Tripura and no
contractual employee appointed on “no work no pay” basis can demand for any
pensionary benefit neither their period of past service as contractual worker can be
counted for the service benefit. He further prayed to dismiss the writ petition.
[14]
Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. GA appearing for the respondent no. 4, at
the very outset has also drawn the attention of this court to the order of engagement
dated 07.12.2004 issued by the Member Secretary to the petitioner herein.
According to Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. GA it was already reflected in the order
of engagement that the service of the petitioner will not be required when there will
be no programme or fund from NALSA or State of Govt. or if her performance is
not satisfactory since her service was purely on the basis of “No work no pay”.
[15]
Moreover, he has also drawn attention of this court to the Rule 12 and
14 of the “Tripura State Legal Services Authority (Conditions of Services and
Salary and Allowance of the Officers and other Employees Rules, 2012” which are
extracted herein below:
12. Absorption of existing officers and other employees - (i) The existing
Legal Services Workers of Grade-1 & II and Group-D shall be absorbed in
the corresponding posts they may be holding in the capacity of Legal
Services Workers of Grade - 1 or Grade - 11 or Group-D on the
commencement of these rules and shall be eligible for pay and allowances
and other facilities as admissible to the State Government employees
holding equivalent posts provided they fulfill the criteria regarding the age
of retirement for such posts. In case the staff concerned employed does not
complete 10 years continuous service in the corresponding posts on the
date of absorption, he/she will have to be absorbed as a Fixed Pay
employee and he/she will get regular scale on completion of further 5 years
in the post. However, the staff concerned who has completed 10 years
service in the corresponding posts will be absorbed under regular scale in
the post.
14. The conditions of service and the Salary and Allowances of Officers
and other Employees:(i) The officers and other employees shall be entitled to draw pay and
allowances in the scale of pay at par with the State Government employees
holding equivalent posts;
(ii) In all matters like age of retirement, pension, Death-cum-Retirement
Gratuity, pay and allowances, leave, other benefits and entitlements the
officers and other employees shall be governed by the State Government
rules as are applicable to persons holding equivalent posts.
(iii) The officers and other employees shall be entitled to such other
facilities, allowances and benefits as may be notified by the State
Government, from time to time.
[16]
It is contended by Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. GA that if these above
mentioned rules are followed then the petitioner does not have any case and no relief
can be granted to her. It is evident from the record that the petitioner resigned from
her service on May, 2012 and the Gazette notification was published on 12th
December, 2012. She resigned from her service much earlier then the “Tripura State
Legal Services Authority (Conditions of Services and Salary and Allowance of the
Officers and other Employees Rules, 2012” came into being. Therefore, the case of
the petitioner cannot be entertained. He further prayed to dismiss the writ petition.
[17]
Heard learned counsel for the parties and also perused the record.
[18]
It is evident from the record that the Deputy Secretary, TSLSA has
sent a letter dated 16-01-2024 to the Registrar, Office of the Lokayukta, Tripura
conveying the decision of the TSLSA taken on the meeting held on 10-01-2024 with
regard to the regularization of the past service of the petitioner. The relevant
portions of the letter are as follows:"Agenda No.1-Discussion & decision on a correspondence received from
the Registrar, Lokayukta regarding statutory notice dated 05-07-2023 (the
letter may be seen at Flag-H) of Smt. Rama Laskar Choudhury in relation
to counting her past service for the purpose of pension and other
retirement benefit.
Resolution: All members present in the meeting discussed the issue and
resolved that the service of Smt. Rama Laskar Choudhury at Tripura State
Legal Services Authority as LSW-I & II cannot be counted as regular
service as her service was 'no work no pay' basis and it's a nonpensionable job. The matter stands rejected".
[19]
It is seen from the record that the petitioner was previously appointed
on 07.04.2004 on “No work no pay” basis. A bare perusal of the order of
engagement dated 07.04.2004 also shows that the her service would not be required
when there would be no programme or fund from National Legal Services
Authority, State Government or other is not available or her performance is not
satisfactory. Moreover, the petitioner expressed her intention to go on premature
voluntary retirement from contract service. Accordingly, TSLSA accepted her
resignation in the 23rd Meeting held on 18.09.2012 which makes it evident that the
petitioner did not get appointment under the Institution of Lokayuka through her
previous employer TSLSA. But before acceptance of the resignation of the
petitioner on 03.10.2012, the petitioner was appointed as Upper Division Clerk
under the Lokayukta, Tripura on 17.05.2012 and the petitioner joined in the office of
the Lokayukta before acceptance of her resignation by TSLSA. There was no
scheme of voluntary retirement and there was no provision of voluntary retirement
during the service period of the petitioner. The services of the petitioner being
engaged on “no work no pay” basis, it cannot be said that the letter submitted by the
petitioner as voluntary retirement cannot be treated as voluntary retirement but the
same amounts to resignation letter. Much before any rules were framed in respect of
Tripura State Legal Services Authority, the petitioner resigned and joined
Lokayukta. It cannot be said that it was an internal transfer or deputation and thus
the petitioner is not entitled for considering the services rendered by her in Tripura
State Legal Services Authority for computation of the services in Lokayukta for
claiming the service benefit of 10 years.
[20]
As far as the case of Smt. Rama Chakraborty, who was a co-employee
of the petitioner, is concerned this court does find any force to the submission of the
learned counsel for the petitioner to say that she got all the benefits as have been
asked for in this writ petition. In that case the lady concerned had completed 10
years service in the corresponding posts which enable her to get the pensionary
benefit and all other retiral benefits. But here is the case where the petitioner has
first served in the Tripura State Legal Services Authority as contractual basis and
also on “No work no pay” basis which is non pensionable job and then she resigned
to join another service in Lokayukta where she has also not completed her 10 years
of continuous service. So her past service is not liable to be counted to get
pensionary and all other retiral benefits.
[21]
With regard to the term “Technical Resignation, the GA (P&T)
Department, Govt. of India has defined the term in the office memorandum vide
No.DOPT-1669266628362 dated 24.11.2023 which reads as follows:
“As per Ministry of Finance OM No.3379-III(B)/65 dated 17th June 1965
the resignation is treated as a technical formality where a Government
servant has applied through proper channel for a post in the same or some
other Department, and is on selection, required to resign the previous post
for administrative reasons. The resignation will be treated as technical
resignation if these conditions met, even if the Government servant has not
mentioned the word "Technical" while submitting his resignation. The
benefit of past service, if otherwise admissible under rules, may be given in
such cases. Resignation in other cases including where competent authority
has not allowed the Government servant to forward the application
through proper channel will be treated as a technical resignation and
benefit of past service will not be admissible. Also, no question of benefit of
a resignation being treated as a technical resignation arises in case of it
being from a post held on ad hoc basis."
[22]
It is evident from the record that the petitioner has not completed her
10 years of service in the Lokayukta, Tripura. She served there for 9 years and 8
months which shows she was short of four months to complete the tenure of 10
years of continuous service. The petitioner even could not fulfill the criteria of
continuous 10 years of service to get her pensionary benefits.
[23]
In the corollary, this Court feels that the petitioner has not reached
before this Court with clean hands and this court having found force in the
submission as advanced by the learned counsel for the respondent No.3 and 4 is of
the opinion that the instant writ petition be dismissed.
[24]
With the above observation, the petition being devoid of merit stands
dismissed. As a sequel, stay, if any, stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any,
also stands closed.
JUDGE
Dipak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review