Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 587 of 2024
Smt. Purabi Debbarma
daughter of Sri Kshirode Ranjan Debbarma,
resident of Beltali, A.D. Nagar,
Agartala, P.S. A.D. Nagar,
District- West Tripura, PIN-799003
……Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary to the Government of
Tripura, Department of Higher Education, P.O. Kunjaban,
P.S. N.C.C., District- West Tripura, PIN- 799006
2. The Secretary cum Commissioner, to the Government
of Tripura, Department of Higher Education, New Capital
Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. N.C.C., District- West
Tripura, PIN- 799006.
3. The Director of Higher Education,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
PIN- 799006.
4. The Principal,
Tripura Institute of Technology,
Narsingarh, Airport Road, Singerbil, P.O. Agartala,
P.S. Airport Police Station, District- West Tripura,
PIN- 799009.
.......Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. Sujata Deb (Gupta), Advocate
Mr. Bikram Paul, Advocate
Ms. Rumpa Dey, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing & delivery
of Judgment & order
:
24.04.2025.
Whether fit for reporting :
Yes
______
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
Heard Ms. S. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner. Also heard Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharya, learned
G.A. representing the State respondents.
[2]
This present petition is filed under Section 226 of the
Constitution of India seeking following reliefs:
“i. Admit the petition,
ii. Call for the records from the custody of the respondents;
iii. As to why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature
thereof shall not be issued for commanding/ directing the
respondent Nos. 2 to quash the impugned Order vide No.
F.10(874)DHE/LA/2023/1417(02) dated 21.05.2024.
iv As to why a writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature
thereof shall not be issued for commending/directing the
respondents to designate the petitioner as Assistant
Professor under the aforesaid respondents.
v. As to why a writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature
thereof shall not be issued for commending/directing the
respondents to fix the appropriate pay scale along with
Academic Grade Pay (ADP) and increment for Ph.D. holders
for the post of Assistant Professor as per UGC Guidelines.
vi. After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the Rule
Absolute in terms of prayer (iii), (iv) and (v) above;
vii. Costs of an incidental to this proceeding………...”
[3]
The case of the petitioner in brief is that she was
appointed on 01.08.2007 to the post of Senior Programmer
(Computer), (Group-B Gazetted) in the Polytechnic Institute, now
Tripura Institute of Technology (TIT for short), Narsingarh under the
Education
(Higher)
Department,
Government
of
Tripura.
The
petitioner obtained M. Tech degree in Computer Science and
Engineering Discipline from NIT Agartala, in the year 2014. She
initially appointed as Senior Programmer (Computer) provisionally
for two years against the vacant post of senior programmer of
Polytechnic Institute (now TIT) in the year 2007-2008. After
completion
of
provisional
period
the
petitioner
permanently
appointed as a Senior Programmer (Computer). It is contended that
as per the Recruitment Rule (RR for short) of Senior Programmer
under TIT, the required qualification is B.E./B.Tech and the nature
of work of the Senior Programmer (Computer) is to define, develop,
test, analyze and maintain new software applications in support of
the achievement of various course. But, the petitioner is rendering
the duties at TIT Narsingarh under the Department of Higher
Education, Government of Tripura since the day of her inception to
the service like conducting Theory and Practical classes, paper
setting, paper evaluation, exams/ seasonal conduction carrying out
the responsibility of lab in-charge, maintaining MIS software for TIT
and many other basic academic duties that any regular faculty
Assistant Professor) carry out throughout a season.
[4]
According to the petitioner, she has performed the duty
and responsibility which is similar to the post of assistant professor.
As such, she cannot be deprived of the right of equal pay for equal
work. The petitioner has submitted several representations before
the Respondent No. 3 for absorption of the post of Assistant
Professor
but
the
Department
did
not
reply
to
those
representations. Thereafter, being aggrieved, the petitioner filed a
writ petition, before this Court, vide WP(C) No. 556 of 2023 and this
Court, on 01.09.2023, passed a Judgment and Order in WP(C)
556/2023 directing the respondents to consider the representations
dated 14.11.2022, 13.03.2023 and 29.05.2023 of the petitioner.
Thereafter, the
petitioner on 06.09.2023, submitted a
fresh
representation
intimating
dated
01.09.2023
and
the
the
Judgment
respondent
No.
and
Order
forwarded
the
said
representation to the respondent No.3. The respondent No.3 has
passed an order vide No. F.10(874)DHE/LA/2023/1417(02) dated
21st May, 2024 in respect of the representation made by the
petitioner informing that consideration for promotion/absorption of
the petitioner into the post of Assistant Profession in Technical
Colleges under (Higher) Department, Govt. of Tripura is regretted.
Again on 22.07.2024, the petitioner submitted a representation to
the respondent No.3 praying to absorb the petitioner as Assistant
Professor by implementing a new scheme. But, the respondents
neither give any reply to the said representation dated 22.07.2024
nor take any steps to implement a new scheme. Being aggrieved,
the present writ petition is filed by the petitioner seeking the aforequoted reliefs.
[5]
Ms. S. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that as per the RR of Senior Programmer under TIT, the
required qualifications is B.E./B.Tech. The nature of work of the
Senior Programmer (Computer) is to define, develop, test, analyze
and
maintain
new
software
applications
in
support
of
the
achievement of various courses but, the petitioner herein, rendering
the duties under TIT, Narsingarh under the Department of Higher
Education, Government of Tripura, since the day of her inception to
the service she has been performing duties like any regular faculty
(Assistant Professor) carry out throughout the session. It is
submitted on behalf of the petitioner that since, she performs the
duty and responsibility which is similar to the post of Assistant
Professor, under such circumstances, denial of the designation of
the Assistant Professor to the petitioner along with the relevant pay
scale to the post of Assistant Professor as per the UGC Guidelines is
denial of the right of the petitioner of equal pay for equal work. To
support her submissions, learned counsel has placed reliance on
paragraph- 13 of the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Arindam Chatttopadhyay and others v. State of West Bengal
and others reported in (2013) 4 SCC 152 which reads as under:
“13. Reverting to the facts of this case, we find that although the
appellants were recruited as ACDPOs, the State Government
transferred and posted them to work as CDPOs in ICDS Projects. If
this would have been a stopgap arrangement for few months or
the appellants had been given additional charge of the posts of
CDPO for a fixed period, they could not have legitimately claimed
salary in the scale of the higher post i.e. CDPO. However, the fact
of the matter is that as on the date of filing of the original
application before the Tribunal, the appellants had continuously
worked as CDPOs for almost 4 years and as on the date of filing of
the writ petition, they had worked on the higher post for about 6
years. By now, they have worked as CDPOs for almost 14 years
and discharged the duties of the higher post. It is neither the
pleaded case of the respondents nor has any material been
produced before this Court to show that the appellants have not
been discharging the duties of the post of CDPO or the degree of
their responsibility is different from other CDPOs. Rather, they
have tacitly admitted that the appellants are working as fullfledged CDPOs since July 1999. Therefore, there is no legal or
other justification for denying them salary and allowances of the
post of CDPO on the pretext that they have not been promoted in
accordance with the Rules. The convening of the Promotion
Committee or taking other steps for filling up the post of CDPO by
promotion is not in the control of the appellants. Therefore, they
cannot be penalised for the Government's failure to undertake the
exercise of making regular promotions.”
[6]
Ms. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel for the petitioner
further contends that on 21.09.2022, a Notification vide No. F.
1(716)DHE/Estt(G)/2022/2728 has been issued by the concerned
authorities in compliance of the Judgment, dated 16.03.2021 arising
upon W.A. No. 201 to 205 of 2021 in WP(C) 1391 to 1395 of 2019,
passed by this Court. Accordingly, the Department has framed the
scheme, on 21.09.2022, to designate Post Graduate Teachers
(PGTs) working in Higher Education Institutes for absorbing in the
post of Assistant Professor. She, therefore, urges this Court to
direct the respondents to designate the petitioner as Assistant
Professor under them setting aside the impugned order dated
21.05.2024 passed by the respondent.
[7]
On the contrary, Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharya, learned
G.A. opposes the submissions made on behalf of the petitioner. He
contends that the petitioner was appointed as Senior Programmer in
the discipline of Computer Science and Engineering in Tripura
Institute of Technology, Narsingarh (erstwhile Polytechnic Institute)
as
per
Recruitment
Rules
(RRs)
N.F.1(10-18)-DHE/94
dated
27.02.1996 and as per existing RRs, there is no scope for promotion
into the post of Assistant Professor under the Department. The
attribute of the post of Senior Programmer is principally limited to
demonstrating
the
computer
programmes
in
Laboratories
at
Technical Institution, besides others assignments entrusted by the
Principal from time to time. The petitioner willingly accepted the
Offer & Appointment vide Memo. No.F.1(674)-DHE/Estt(G)/2006
dated 10.07.2007, including the terms and conditions vide no.2(iii)
as "Others conditions of service will be governed by the relevant
rules and orders in force from time to time" and accordingly, she
had joined the post of Senior Programmer on 01.08.2007. Thus, her
service will be governed by recruitment rules.
[8]
It is further contended that the post of Asst. Professor in
Tripura Institute of Technology (TIT) is a direct recruitment post to
be appointed through competitive selection process by the Public
Service Commission. There is no scope for the Senior Programmer
of TIT to be upgraded to the post of Asst. Professor and the
submission made on behalf of the petitioner is contrary to the
guidelines framed by the All India Council for Technical Education
(AICTE) and the
same cannot
be considered by
the State
respondents. To support his contention, learned G.A. has placed
reliance on the following judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court:
1.
Union of India v. Indian Navy Civilian Design Officers
Association and another reported in 2023 SCC OnLine SC 173.
2.
Order dated 29th August, 2024, passed in Shri
Metongmeren AO, (IAS Retd.) v. The State of Nagaland, case
No. Civil Appeal No. 10034 of 2011.
[9]
Mr. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. also submits that under
the Higher Education Department the eligible PGTs who are in
regular service and fulfils the eligible criteria for the post of
Assistant Professor are only absorbed in pursuant to the direction of
this Court passed in WA No. 201 to 205 in W.P(C) No. 1391 to 1395
of 2019 as per the scheme vide notification dated 21.09.2022 and
the same is specifically meant for the PGTs working in the Govt.
(General) Degree College and accordingly, the said scheme is not
applicable for the post of senior programmer. He, therefore, urges
this Court to dismiss the instant petition filed by the petitioner.
[10]
Heard the submissions made at the Bar. Perused the
material evidence on record. Counter-affidavit has also been filed
on behalf of the respondents.
[11]
It is seen from record that on 06.09.2023, the petitioner
has submitted a representation alongwith the judgment and order
of this Court dated 01.09.2023 passed in WP(C) 556 of 2023 and
subsequently, the concerned respondent has passed the impugned
order dated 21.05.2024 in the following manner:
“.......WHEREAS, Smt. Purabi Debbarma, Senior Programmer in the
discipline of Computer Science and Engineering in Tripura Institute of
Technology, Narsingarh (erstwhile Polytechnic Institute) was recruited
under Recruitment Rules N.F 1(10-18)-DHE/94 dated 27.02.1996 and as
per existing RRs, there is no scope to attain promotion into the post of
Assistant Professor under the Department. The attribute of the post of
Senior Programmer principally limited to demonstrating the computer
programmes in Laboratories at Technical Institution, besides others
assignments entrusted by the principal from time to time:
AND
WHEREAS, the petitioner willingly accepted the Offer &
Appointment vide Memo.No.F.1(674)-DHE/Estt(G)/2006 dated 10.07.2007
with a terms and conditions vide no.2(iii) as "Others conditions of service
will be governed by the relevant rules and orders in force from time to
time" and accordingly, she had joined to the post of Senior Programmer on
01.08.200;thus, her service will be in force as per aforesaid recruitment
rules,
AND
WHEREAS, the petitioner may possessacademic qualification for
the Post of Assistant Professor, but, without going through a specific
selection process as prescribed in the Recruitment Rules of Assistant
Professor for Technical Colleges, adopted by the Govt. of Tripura, in line
with AICTE Regulation's 2019, through Public Service Commission, cannot
be appointed to the Post of Assistant Professorin Technical Colleges as this
is direct entry post.
AND
WHEREAS, the scheme notified vide No.F.1(716) DHE/Estt(G)/2022 dated
21.09.2022 in compliance of interim order passed on 16.03.2021 arising
upon W.A No.201-205 of 2021 in W.P(C) No.1391 to 1395 was framed for
absorbing Post Graduate Teachers (PGTs) into the scale of pay of Assistant
Professor who are imparting teaching learning process in the General
Degree Colleges considering the terms and conditions of the said scheme
only meant for PGTsworking under Govt. General Degree Colleges;
NOW, THEREFORE, after proper examination of the representations of
Smt. Purabi Debbarma following recruitment rules of the post of the
Assistant Professor framed as per the AICTE norms, this department
hereby regrets for considering promotion/absorption into the post of
Assistant Professor in Technical Colleges under Education (Higher)
Department. Govt. of Tripura. This speaking order is issued in compliance
to the order dated 01.09.2023 passed by the Hon'ble High Court in W.P(C)
No.556/2023.”
[12]
Admittedly, it seen from record that the petitioner was
appointed as Senior Programmer in the discipline of Computer
Science
and
Engineering
in
Tripura
Institute
of
Technology,
Narsingarh (erstwhile Polytechnic Institute) as per Recruitment
Rules (RRs) and as per the existing RRs, there is no scope to attain
promotion/absorption into the post of Assistant Professor without
proper
selection
process
through
Public
Service
Commission
following Recruitment Rules of Assistant Professor of Technical
Institute under AICTE. Therefore, to examine the case of the
petitioner, the relevant contents of the judgment of the Hon’ble
Apex Court in Union of India v. Indian Navy Civilian Design
Officers Association and another reported in 2023 SCC OnLine
SC 173 is extracted as under:
“......9. Before adverting to the rival contentions raised by the
learned counsels for the parties, it deserves to be noted that the
power of judicial review of the High Courts in the matter of
classification of posts and determination of pay scale is no more
res integra. It has been consistently held by this Court in plethora
of decisions that equation of posts and equation of salaries is a
complex matter which is best left to an expert body unless there is
cogent material on record to come to a firm conclusion that a
grave error had crept in while fixing the pay scale for a given post
and the interference of the Court was absolutely necessary to undo
the injustice.
10. In State of U.P. v J.P. Chaurasia, while answering the
questions as to whether the Bench Secretaries in the High Court of
Allahabad were entitled to pay scale admissible to the Section
Officers and whether the creation of two grades with different
scales in the cadre of Bench Secretaries who were doing the same
and similar work was violative of the right to have "equal pay for
equal work" This Court observed as under:"18. The first question regarding entitlement to the pay
scale admissible to Section Officers should not detain us
longer. The answer to the question depends upon several
factors. It does not just depend upon either the nature of
work or volume of work done by Bench Secretaries.
Primarily it requires among others, evaluation of duties
and responsibilities of the respective posts. More often
functions of two posts may appear to be the same or
similar, but there may be difference in degrees in the
performance. The quantity of work may be the same, but
quality may be different that cannot be determined by
relying upon averments in affidavits of interested parties.
The equation of posts or equation of pay must be left to
the executive Government. It must be determined by
expert bodies like Pay Commission. They would be the best
judge to evaluate the nature of duties and responsibilities
of posts. If there is any such determination by a
Commission or Committee, the court should normally
accept it. The court should not try to tinker with such
equivalence unless it is shown that it was made with
extraneous consideration."***************
15. So far as the facts of the present case are concerned, it is not
disputed that the Recruitment Rules governing the JDOs are as per
the SRO 367 dated 08.12.1996, as amended by SRO 246 dated
21.11.2002, whereas the Recruitment Rules governing the CTOS
(Design) are as per the SRO 132 dated 12.05.1982. The probation
period in case of CTOs is longer than that of JDOs. The duties and
responsibilities of both the posts are different and the promotional
avenues also have different duration and different criteria. There
was not a single error, much less grave error pointed out by
learned Senior Advocate. Mr. Khurshid, in the fixation of the pay
scales for the JDOS and CTOs, which would have justified the
interference of the Tribunal.
16. Much emphasis was placed by the learned senior advocate Mr.
Khurshid on the noting made by the Officer of the Naval
Department in the file recommending pay scale of JDOs equivalent
to that of CTOS, however, it may be noted that a noting recorded
in the file is merely an expression of opinion by a particular officer,
and by no-stretch of imagination such noting could be treated as a
decision of the Government.
17. The powers of judicial review in the matters involving financial
implications are also very limited. The wisdom and advisability of
the Courts in the matters concerning the finance, are ordinarily not
amenable to judicial review unless a gross case of arbitrariness or
unfairness is established by the aggrieved party.
18. In that view of the matter, we are of the opinion that the
Tribunal and the High Court had committed gross error in
interfering with the pay scales recommended by the Fifth Central
Pay Commission and accepted by the appellant for the posts of
JDOs and CTOS, and in upgrading the pay scale of JDOs making it
equivalent to the pay scale of CTOS.
19. Consequently, the impugned orders passed by the High
Court and the Tribunal are quashed and set aside. The appeal
stands allowed accordingly.”
[13]
In view of the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court cited
(supra), this Court opines that in the absence of any provision in
the existing Recruitment Rules (RRs) and without any proper
selection process through Public Service Commission following the
Recruitment Rules of Assistant Professor of Technical Institute
under AICTE, no direction can be imposed upon the respondents for
promotion/absorption of the petitioner into the post of Assistant
Professor. It is also opined that the judgments as referred by the
learned counsel for the petitioner is not applicable to the facts and
circumstances of the present case. Hence, the present writ petition
filed by the petitioner is dismissed and the impugned order dated
21.05.2024 is hereby upheld.
[14]
With the above observations and directions, the instant
petition is dismissed and thereby, the same is disposed of. As a
sequel, miscellaneous application(s), pending if any, shall also stand
closed.
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
Sabyasachi G.
SABYASACHI GHOSH GHOSH
Date: 2025.04.25 11:44:58 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review