Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
M.A.NO.1149/2012
INTHE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT G WA L I O R
BEFORE
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE BINOD KUMAR DWIVEDI
MISC. APPEAL No. 1149 of 2012
BETWEEN:1. SMT.
POOJA
W/O
LT.SHRI
JITENDRA SINGH SIKARWAR,
AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS, R/O
VILLAGE UTTAMPURA,TEHSIL
DEVGARH, DISTRICT MORENA
M.P. PRESENT CHAR SHAHAR KA
NAKA HAJIRA, POLICE STATION
GWALIOR, DISTRICT GWALIOR.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2. RAGHAV S/O LATE RANU @
JITENDRA SINGH SIKARWAR,
AGED ABOUT 1 YEARS, R/O
VILLAGE UTTAMPURA,TEHSIL
DEVGARH, DISTRICT MORENA
M.P. PRESENT CHAR SHAHAR KA
NAKA HAJIRA, POLICE STATION
GWALIOR, DISTRICT GWALIOR.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3. SMT.
PARWATI
W/O
LATE
KAPTAN
SINGH
SIKARWAR,
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, R/O
VILLAGE UTTAMPURA,TEHSIL
DEVGARH, DISTRICT MORENA
M.P. PRESENT CHAR SHAHAR KA
NAKA HAJIRA, POLICE STATION
GWALIOR, DISTRICT GWALIOR.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4 SMT.
ASLEKHA
D/O
LATE
KAPTAN
SINGH
SIKARWAR,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,R/O
M.A.NO.1149/2012
VILLAGE UTTAMPURA,TEHSIL
DEVGARH, DISTRICT MORENA
M.P. PRESENT CHAR SHAHAR KA
NAKA HAJIRA, POLICE STATION
GWALIOR, DISTRICT GWALIOR.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
5. KUMARI GUDIA D/O LATE
KAPTAN
SINGH
SIKARWAR,
AGED ABOUT 17 YEARS, R/O
VILLAGE UTTAMPURA,TEHSIL
DEVGARH, DISTRICT MORENA
M.P. PRESENT CHAR SHAHAR KA
NAKA HAJIRA, POLICE STATION
GWALIOR, DISTRICT GWALIOR.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
6. KUMAR KHUSHBU D/O LATE
KAPTAN
SINGH
SIKARWAR,
AGED ABOUT 13 YEARS,R/O
VILLAGE UTTAMPURA,TEHSIL
DEVGARH, DISTRICT MORENA
M.P. PRESENT CHAR SHAHAR KA
NAKA HAJIRA, POLICE STATION
GWALIOR, DISTRICT GWALIOR.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
(BY SMT. MEENA SINGHAL - ADVOCATE)
AND
1. KAPTAN
SINGH
S/O
SHRI
DHANDHU SINGH R/O VILLAGE
LOHGARH, POLICE STATION
NURABAD,TEHSIL
MORENA,
DISTRICT MORENA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2. LEKHU JATAV S/O BADRI JATAV
R/O OF VILLAGE KHERIYA,
POLICE
STATION
GWALIOR,
DISTRICT GWALIOR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
3. UNITED
INDIA
INSURANCE
COMPANY LIMITED THROUGH
DIVISIONAL MANAGER MANDAL
M.A.NO.1149/2012
KARYALAY
PHOOLBAG
GWALIOR DISTRICT GWALIOR
MP (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI S. G. CHITNIS – ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.3)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Reserved on :
5.1.2024
Pronounced on : 10.1.2024
This Misc. Appeal having been heard and reserved for judgment,
coming on for pronouncement this day, Hon'ble Shri Justice Binod
Kumar Dwivedi pronounced the following:
JUDGMENT
Challenge in this Misc. Appeal is award dated 24.8.2012 passed by
Vth Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Gwalior in Claim Case
No.138/2011, whereby the appellants/claimants have been awarded
compensation of Rs.5,27,900/- with 6% interest per annum from the date
of filing of the claim petition.
2.
Learned counsel for the appellants submits that the appellants have
challenged the award mainly on the ground that learned Claims Tribunal
has erred in taking into consideration the actual income of the deceasedRanu @ Jintendra as Rs.3000/- per month. It is claimed by the appellants
that before his death on 14.6.2011,
deceased Ranu @ Jintedra was
earning Rs.20,000/- per month from the business of trading of mustered
husk (Bhusa) and Rs.10,000/- per month from the business of selling of
milk. Thus, his net income was Rs.30,000/- per month. Even after ample
proof given by the appellants, the Claims Tribunal failed to take into
consideration the same while adjudicating the claim petition. It has also
M.A.NO.1149/2012
been urged that the age of deceased was 25 years on the date of accidental
death but learned Claims Tribunal did not take into account future
prospect as per the law settled by the Apex Court in case of National
Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi 2017 (16) SCC 680. Further in the
light of decision of Apex Court in the case of United Insurance
Company Limited vs. Satinder Kaur alias Satwinder Kaur and Ors.
(2021) 11 SCC 780 loss of consortium at the rate of Rs.40,000/- + 10%
enhanced amount as per Pranay Sethi (supra) para-59.8, i.e. 44000/- each
should have been awarded to appellant No.1 Pooja, wife of deceased,
appellant No.2- Raghav, son of deceased and appellant No.3-Parbati,
mother of deceased along with funeral expenses and loss of estate at the
rate of Rs.16,500/- under each head. Appellants have restricted their
submissions to the extent indicated as herein above.
3.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent- Insurance Company
submits that learned Claims Tribunal has duly appreciated the evidence
regarding income of the deceased. No documentary evidence was
produced before the learned Claims Tribunals in respect to the income of
deceased at the time of death of deceased. Therefore, no fault can be
found with as regards to assessment of income by the learned Tribunal.
He has further submitted that this Court may take appropriate decision
with regard to the future prospect of deceased, consortium amount,
funeral expenses and for loss of estate.
4.
Heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused the
record.
5.
Regarding income of the deceased, Pooja (AW-1) wife of deceased,
M.A.NO.1149/2012
Devendra Singh (AW-2) brother of deceased in one tone have stated in
their statements before the Tribunal that the deceased before his death
was earning Rs.20,000/- from the business of mustered husk. He was
having six buffaloes producing 30-kg milk out of which the deceased
used to sell 25-kg per day and after deducting expenses, he was having
income of Rs.10,000/-, thus from both the business he was earning
Rs.30,000/- per month. Pooja (AW-1) in her cross examination para-11
and Devendra (AW-2) in his cross-examination para-4 have admitted that
they have not produced any document to substantiate the income of the
deceased by the business of mustered husk and selling milk. Kamal Singh
(AW-3) in his statement stated that he was purchasing 20 liters milk per
day from the deceased, thus the deceased was earning Rs.10,000/- per
month after deducting all the expenses but in his cross-examination he
has admitted that he did not produce any documents regarding purchasing
of milk from the deceased.
6.
In the light of above evidence available on record, learned Claims
Tribunal has rightly not placed reliance on the appellants’ version that
before death, deceased Ranu was earning Rs.30,000/- per month from
aforementioned business. Learned Tribunal after discussing the evidence
on record in para-29 of the award on guess work concluded that a
common labourer earns Rs.100/- per day and thus, Rs.3000/- per month
but did not resort to circular issued under minimum wages Act, 1948;
therefore, income of the deceased as Rs.3000/- per month as concluded
by learned Claims Tribunal is not proper.
7. In Sapna and Others vs. Mangilal and Another, 2021 ACJ 957,
M.A.NO.1149/2012
Coordinate Bench of this Court in para No.8 has held as under:“8.Having heard the learned counsel for parties and on
perusal of the record, it is noticed that the appellant had
deposed before the tribunal that the deceased was earning
Rs.8,000/- per month, but no document in support of which
was produced. The tribunal had noted that the deceased was
about 20 years of age and was a labourer, therefore,
considering the minimum wages and dearness allowance for
the relevant period, the tribunal has assessed the income of
the deceased as Rs.6000/-. No notification/circular of the
concerned Labour Officer was taken note of by the tribunal
while mentioning the daily wages of Rs.6000/-. The circular
dated 7/4/2018 issued by the Labour Officer, Barwani
applicable to the period from 01/4/2018 to 30/9/2018
produced by the appellants reveals that the monthly wages on
the basis of daily wages along with dearness allowance fixed
by the concerned Labour Officer was Rs.7325/-. Hence, the
tribunal ought to have fixed the monthly income on the basis
of the said circular.”
14. Coordinate Benches of this Court in the cases of Bhim
Singh vs. Jagmelsingh in MA No.5350 of 2022 dated 07th
July, 2023, Shankar and Others vs Dinesh and Others in MA
No.2057 of 2021 dated 08th September, 2023 and Sohanlal
and Others vs. Noorasingh and Others in MA No.7014 of
2019 dated 22.08.2023 has also determined income on the
basis of minimum wages notified under the Minimum Wages
Act, 1948.
15. Thus, from principles laid down in above cases, it is
evident that Hon'ble Apex Court as well as Coordinate
Benches of this Court has consistently determined the income
of the deceased/applicant on 10 the basis of Minimum Wages
duly notified under Minimum Wages Act.
16. It is correct that as per section 3 & other provisions of
Minimum Wages Act, 1948, minimum wages thereunder are
fixed & notified for employees employed in an employment
specified in the Act, i.e. in respect of scheduled employment
under the Act. But, in view of principles laid down in
decisions referred to in preceding paras, in this court‟s
considered opinion, in absence of other evidence on record, to
obviate uncertainty & for sake of reasonable uniformity &
M.A.NO.1149/2012
consistency, it would be just & proper to apply yardstick of
Minimum Wages duly notified under Minimum Wages Act,
1948 for determining compensation under the Motor Vehicles
Act.
17. In view of section 57 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872,
judicial notice can be taken of Minimum Wages duly notified
under Minimum Wages Act, 1948. Hence, the same need not
to be proved separately.
8.
In the present case the deceased was skilled or semi skilled has not
been proved by placing relevant evidence on record; therefore, he will be
taken as unskilled labourer. Vide order of Collector, Gwalior dated
21.11.2011 referring Labour, Commissioner, State of Madha Pradesh,
Indore
Notification
No.1/9/Anvey/Five/2010/26638-937
which
is
applicable from 1.4.2011 to 30.9.2011 and covers the date of incident
14.6.2011 in the present case monthly wages for unskilled labour are
fixed at Rs.4395/-. In the light of aforesaid observations, the monthly
income of deceased will be taken at Rs.4395/- as per minimum wages Act
and not Rs.3000/- per month as taken by learned Claims Tribunal.
Future Prospects:9.
It is not in dispute that deceased was of 25 years of age on the date
of his death. In view of observation in para-59.4 in judgment of Pranay
Sethi (supra) where the deceased was below the age of 40 years self
employed or on a fixed salary, an addition of 40% of the established
income should be the warrant. In para-59.8 of the above judgment it has
been held that reasonable figures on conventional heads, namely, loss of
estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses should be Rs.15000/-,
Rs.40,000/- and 15000/- respectively. The aforesaid amount should be
enhanced at the rate of 10% in every three years.
M.A.NO.1149/2012
Consortium:
10.
In Magma General Insurance Company Limited vs. Nanu Ram
alias Chuhru Ram and Others, (2018) 18 SCC 130, Hon'ble Apex
Court in para No.21 to 25 has held as under:“21.A Constitution Bench of this Court in Pranay Sethi
(supra) dealt with the various heads under which
compensation is to be awarded in a death case. One of these
heads is Loss of Consortium. In legal parlance, “consortium”
is a compendious term which encompasses “spousal
consortium”, “parental consortium”, and “filial consortium”.
The right to consortium would include the company care help
comfort, guidance, solace and affection of the deceased,
which is a loss to his family. With respect to a spouse, it
would include sexual relations with the deceased spouse.
21.1.Spousal consortium is generally defined as rights
pertaining to the relationship of a husband wife which allows
compensation to the surviving spouse for loss of “company,
society, co-operation,affection, and aid of the other in every
conjugal relation.”
2. Parental consortium is granted to the child upon the
premature death of a parent, for loss of“parental aid,
protection, affection, society, discipline, guidance and
training.”
3. Filial consortium is the right of the parents to
compensation in the case of an accidental death of a child. An
accident leading to the death of a child causes great shock and
agony to the parents and family of the deceased. The greatest
agony for a parent is to lose their child during their lifetime.
Children are valued for their love, affection, companionship
and their role in the family unit.
22.Consortium is a special prism reflecting changing norms
about the status and worth of actual relationships. Modern
jurisdictions world over have recognized that the value of a
child‟s consortium far exceeds the economic value of the
compensation awarded in the case of the death of a child.
Most jurisdictions therefore permit parents to be awarded
compensation under loss of consortium on the death of a
M.A.NO.1149/2012
child. The amount awarded to the parents is a compensation
for loss of the love, affection, care and companionship of the
deceased child.
23.The Motor Vehicles Act is a beneficial legislation aimed at
providing relief to the victims or their families, in cases of
genuine claims. In case where a parent has lost their minor
child, or unmarried son or daughter, the parents are entitled to
be awarded loss of consortium under the head of Filial
Consortium. Parental Consortium is awarded to children who
lose their parents in motor vehicle accidents under the Act. A
few High Courts have awarded compensation on this count.
However, there was no clarity with respect to the principles
on which compensation could be awarded on loss of filial
consortium.”
32. A three-Judge Bench in United India Insurance
Company Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur alias Satvinder Kaur and
others, (2021) 11 SCC 780, had reaffirmed the view of two
Judge Bench in Magma General insurance Company Ltd.
(supra). The Three-Judge Bench from para 53 to 65, dealt
with three conventional heads. The entire discussion on three
conventional heads of three-Judge Bench is as follows: - "53.
In Pranay Sethi (supra), the Constitution Bench held that in
death cases, compensation would be awarded only under three
conventional heads viz. “loss of estate”, “loss of consortium”
and funeral expenses. The Court held that the conventional
and traditional heads, cannot be determined on percentage
basis, because that would not be an acceptable criterion.
Unlike determination of income, the said headshave to be
quantified, which has to be based on a reasonable foundation.
It was observed that factors such as price index, fall in bank
interest, escalation of rates, are aspects which have to be taken
into consideration. The Court held that reasonable figures on
conventional heads, namely, loss of estate, loss of consortium
and funeral expenses should be Rs. 15,000/-, Rs. 40,000/- and
Rs. 15,000/- respectively. The Court was of the view that the
amounts to be awarded under these conventional heads should
be enhanced by 10% every three years, which will bring
consistency in respect of these heads. a) Loss of Estate – Rs.
15,000 to be awarded b) Loss of Consortium”.
11.
Learned counsel for the appellant after relying on Magma General
M.A.NO.1149/2012
Insurance Company Ltd. (supra) submits that Tribunal has committed
error in not awarding any amount in the head of consortium to other
claimants. From discussion in foregoing paras, it is clearly established
that appellants No.4 & 6 who are sisters of the deceased not entitled for
any amount in the head of consortium as they do not come within the
purview of “filial consortium” or “parental consortium”. In the light of
Pranay Sethi (supra) para 59.8 and Smt. Anjali (supra), in the present
case, appellant No.1-Pooja, wife of deceased, appellant No.2- Raghav, son
of deceased and appellant No.3- Parvati, mother of deceased are entitled
to spousal consortium, parental consortium and filial consortium at the
rate of Rs.40,000/- + 10% increase =44000/- each.
12.
In Smt. Anjali and Others vs. Lokendra Rathod and Others,
AIR 2023 SC 44, Hon'ble Apex Court in para No.17 has held as under:“17.A three-Judge Bench of this Court in United India
Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Satinder Kaur @ Satwinder Kaur and
Ors. (2021) 11 SCC 780 after considering Pranay Sethi
(Supra),has awarded spousal consortium at the rate of
Rs.40,000/ (Rupees forty thousand only) and towards loss of
parental consortium to each child at the rate of Rs.40,000/
(Rupees forty thousand only). The compensation under these
heads also needs to be increased by 10%. Thus, the spousal
consortium is awarded at Rs.44,000/ (Forty-four thousand
only), and towards parental consortium at the rate of
Rs.44,000/ each (Total Rs.1,32,000/) is awarded to the three
children. 5 (2021) 11 SCC 780”.
13.
So far as future prospects is concerned, perusal of impugned award
reveals that Tribunal has not awarded any amount for future prospects. In
the instant case, Tribunal has held that at the time of accident deceased
was aged 25 years and Tribunal has held that deceased was an unskilled
M.A.NO.1149/2012
labourer. Therefore, in view of para-59.4 of the judgment in the case of
Pranay Sethi (supra), claimants are also entitled to get 40% of
Rs.4395/- as future prospects. In view of 25 years of age, multiplier of
18 would be applicable as per guideline given in para-42 in the case of
Sarla Verma vs. Delhi Transport Corporation (2009) 6 SCC 121.
Relevant paragraph-42 of above case reads as under:“42. We therefore hold that the multiplier to be used should
be as mentioned in Column (4) of the table above (prepared
by applying Susamma Thomas [(1994) 2 SCC 176 : 1994
SCC (Cri) 335], Trilok Chandra (1996) 4 SCC 362] and
Charlie[(2005) 10 SCC 720 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 1657] ), which
starts with an operative multiplier of 18 (for the age groups of
15 to 20 and 21 to 25 years), reduced by one unit for every
five years, that is M-17 for 26 to 30 years, M-16 for 31 to 35
years, M-15 for 36 to 40 years, M-14 for 41 to 45 years, and
M-13 for 46 to 50 years, then reduced by two units for every
five years, that is, M-11 for 51 to 55 years, M-9 for 56 to 60
years, M-7 for 61 to 65 years and M-5 for 66 to 70 years”.
Calculation of total compensation:14.
In view of above discussion, appellants are entitled to the following
amount as compensation:-
Sr.No. Head
Compensation awarded
Income
Rs.4395/- per month
Future prospect
Rs.1758 (40%)
Deduction towards personal expenses
(1/5th
4395+1758=6153)
Total annual income
4923 (6153 -1230)x12=59076/-
Multiplier
of
M.A.NO.1149/2012
Loss of dependency
59076 x 18= 10,63,368/-
Funeral expenses
Rs.16500/-
Loss of estate
Rs.16,500/-
Loss of spousal consortium
Rs.44,000/-
Loss of parental consortium to appellant Rs.44,000/No.2
Loss of filial consortium to appellant No.3
Rs.44,000/-
Total compensation
12,28,368/-
15.
Thus, the just and proper amount of compensation in the instant
case is Rs.12,28,368/- as against the award of the Tribunal of
Rs.5,27,900/-. Accordingly, appellants No. 1 to 3 are entitled to an
additional sum of Rs.7,00,468/- over and above the amount which has
been awarded by the Tribunal.
16. Resultantly, the appeal is partly allowed by enhancing the
compensation amount by a sum of Rs.7,00,468/-. The enhanced amount
shall bear interest at the same rate as awarded by the Tribunal. The other
findings recorded by the Tribunal shall remain intact.
17.
Appellants have valued the appeal only to the extent of Rs.5 lakhs
and paid the Court fee accordingly. However, for the remaining amount
of Rs.2,00,468/- the Court fee shall be paid by the appellants within a
period of 60 days from the date of the order of this Court and thereafter
the amount shall be released by the Insurance Company on receiving the
certificate. In case the certificate has not been filed before the Insurance
Company up to a period of three months, the appellants/claimants shall
not be entitled to receive the interest on the enhanced amount of
M.A.NO.1149/2012
compensation.
18.
In the result, the appeal is allowed in part and to the extent
indicated herein above.
(BINOD KUMAR DWIVEDI)
JUDGE
Ahmad
MOHD AHMAD
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH BENCH GWALIOR, ou=HIGH COURT OF
MADHYA PRADESH BENCH GWALIOR,
2.5.4.20=76cd720db57b34b7642c70ed7eaf9b624f80d89cea07317bb14d87e882cf0d0f,
postalCode=474001, st=Madhya Pradesh,
serialNumber=F3F56CD397D8CD6A76865A062F285CC6010CB90C4A13B78A9AEC4BA8C6
5B56BA, cn=MOHD AHMAD
Date: 2024.01.10 17:56:12 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review