Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Non-reportable
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP(C) No.571 of 2018
Nongmeikapam Ibobi Singh,
aged about 66 years, s/o (L) N. Mani Singh,
resident of Bashikhong, PO Singjamei,
PS Irilbung, Imphal East District,
Pin No.795008.
… Petitioner
(Smt Nongmeikapam Sorojini Devi
Aged about 65 years w/o N. Ibobi Singh
resident of Bashikhong, PO Singjamei,
PS Irilbung, Imphal East District,
Pin No.795008.)
[impleaded as LR of the deceased petitioner vide order dated
01.03.2024]
-Versus1.
The State of Manipur, through the Principal
Secretary/Commissioner (Com & Ind),
Government of Manipur, New Secretariat Building,
Imphal, Manipur, Pin 795001.
2.
The Manipur Khadi & Villages Industries
Board through the Chief Executive Officer,
Lamphelpat, near ICM Office, Imphal,
Manipur, Pin 795001.
3.
The Chairman, Manipur Khadi and Village
Industries Board, Lamphelpat, near ICM
Office, Imphal West Manipur 795001.
4.
The Commissioner/Secretary (Finance/PIC),
Department of Finance, Govt of Manipur,
New Secretariat Building, Imphal
Manipur, Pin 795001.
… Respondents
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A.GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioner
::
Mr.Kh.Tarunkumar, Sr.Adv
Ms.Maria, Advocate
For the Respondents
::
Ms.Ch.Sundari, G.A
Date of hearing
::
10.03.2025
Date of judgment/
Order
::
23.12.2025
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
[1]
This Writ petition is filed by the petitioner praying for
setting aside the impugned letter dated 06.11.2017 and the order
dated 12.06.2018 with a further prayer to direct the respondent by
directing them to allow the petitioner to enjoy the benefit of arrear pay
salary and allowance including leave and gratuity under ROP 2010
w.e.f 1.04.2010 to 31.08.2012 which was fixed at rupees 8,81,454/within a stipulate period.
[2]
The deceased petitioner, a Government Employee,
retired from the post of the Chief Executive Officer of the Manipur
Khadi & Village Industries Board, Manipur in the month of August,
2012 on attaining the age superannuation. While he was in service, he
was appointed to the post of Financial Advisor and Accounts Officer of
the Board in the scale of pay of Rs.8000-13.5000/- p.m. vide order
dated 06.02.2008 which was issued under sub Section (1) of Section
13 of the Manipur Khadi & Village Industries Board Act, 1966.
[3]
It is the case of the petitioner that while he was serving
as Financial Advisor and Chief Accounts Officer of the Manipur Khadi
& Village Industries Board, the Principal Secretary (Commerce &
Industries), Govt of Manipur issued an order on 09.03.2010 whereby
he was appointed to the post of Chief Executive Officer in the scale of
pay of Rs.10,000-15,000/- p.m., vice one Shri Th.Birgopal Singh, who
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
retired with immediate effect. The said order further stated that he
would continue to look after all matters handled by the Financial
Advisor and the Chief Accounts Officer in addition to his new work
assignments.
[4]
Further it is stated that while he had been serving as
Chief Executive Officer of the Manipur Khadi & Village Industries
Board, the Principal Secretary (Finance), Government of Manipur vide
notification dated 5.5.2010 published the Manipur Services (Revised
Pay) Rules, 2010. The said rules deemed to have come into force
notionally on the 1st day of January 2006 with cash payment from 1st
April 2010. As per the said Rules, the scales of pay of all categories of
employees were classified into five categories such as 1S, PB-1, PB-2,
PB-3 and PB-4 and scale of pay for the post of Chief Executive Officer
i.e. scale of pay of Rs.10,000-15,200/- which was enjoyed by the
petitioner was included under PB-3 and the scale of pay was revised
at Rs.15,600-39,100/- and grade pay of Rs.6600/-.
[5]
The Department of Finance, Govt of Manipur issued OM
dated 7.7.2010 clarifying that Revision of Pay scales of the employees
of
the
Autonomous
Bodies/Local
Bodies/
Grant-in-Aid
Institutions/Public Sector undertaking etc shall be made only with the
concurrence of Finance Department (PIC) subject to the availability of
sufficient fund for the purpose. Later on Commissioner (Finance),
Government of Manipur issued OM dated 28.2.2011, whereby
references were made regarding grant of revised pay under the
Manipur Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2010 in respect of the
employees of Autonomous Bodies/ Local Bodies/ Grant-in-aid
Institution/ Public Sector undertakings. The CEO, Manipur Khadi &
Village Industries Board, Lamphelpat vide letter 17.10.2011 requested
the Director, Commerce & Industries, Government of Manipur
pertaining to the adoption of ROP Rules, 2010 in respect of the
employees of the Manipur Khadi & Village Industries Board. Further
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
the CEO, Manipur Khadi & Village Industries Board, Lamphelpat vide
letter dated 9.11.2011 addressed to the Director (Commerce &
Industries, Government of Manipur, intimated about the adoption of
ROP, Rules 1999 by the Khadi & Village Industries Board with the date
on which the same was adopted and requested to approve the
proposal for adoption of 2010 ROP Rules.
[6]
The Director, Commerce & Industries, Government of
Manipur vide letter dated 18.11.2011 forwarded the letters dated
17.10.2011 and 9.11.2011 to the Principal Secretary (Com &
Industries), Govt of Manipur for further necessary actions at the
Government level. Thereafter, the Dy. Secretary, Commerce &
Industries Department vide letter dated 14.8.2012 addressed to the
Chief Executive Officer, Manipur Khadi & Village Industries Board
intimated that proposal has been moved to FD (PIC) for necessary
approval with the observation that grant of revised pay may involve
an additional amount of Rs.5.62 lakhs p.m. approximately. In response
to the above letter, the petitioner, while in service as Chief Executive
Officer, vide letter dated 24.08.2012 addressed to the Principal
Secretary (Com & Ind), Govt of Manipur stated that the Manipur Khadi
& Village Industries Board is a statutory body and its establishment
expenditure including pay and allowances of the employees are born
by the State Government and the Board in its meeting held on
28.07.2012 under agenda item No.5 decided to adopt the revised scale
of pay including admissible allowances of the State Government
employees notionally w.e.f. 01.01.2006 with cash payment from
1.4.2010 with the approval of the Government.
[7]
It is also the case of the petitioner that the Vice
Chairman, Manipur Khadi & Village Board issued an order on
27.09.2013 whereby sanction was accorded to an expenditure not
exceeding a sum of Rs.3,50,000/- only for payment of retirement
gratuity to the petitioner who was allowed to retire from service. And
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
that as the respondents did not take up any positive steps to allow the
petitioner to enjoy the benefits of Manipur Services (Revised Pay)
Rules, 2010, he approached the Hon’ble Court by filing WP(C) No.916
of 2013 which was disposed of on 16.10.2014 by directing the
respondents to take a decision on the letter dated 21.12.2013 of the
CEO of the Manipur Khadi & Village Industries Board, Imphal within a
three months from the date of communication of the said order. On
25.8.2017 the Deputy Secretary (TC & I) Government of Manipur
informed the petitioner that his case for one-time payment of financial
benefit has been considered and because of the financial condition of
the State Government, is claim cannot be paid.
[8]
In reply to the representation dated 26.08.2017, vide
letter dated 06.11.2017 the Under Secretary (TC & I), Government of
Manipur intimated the petitioner that as the petitioner was appointed
as CEO (MKVIB) and retired on 31.08.2012 and ROP 2010 was
implemented in MKVIBB w.e.f. 28.09.2016 his case for payment of
arrear, pay and allowances under ROP 2010 cannot be considered.
[9]
Further, on 12.6.2018 the Secretary (Finance/PIC), Govt
of Manipur issued an order that the State Cabinet in its sitting held on
2.9.2016 approved to the grant of revised pay under MS (RP) Rules
2010 in respect of MKVIBB with immediate effect. It was further
ordered that the letter dated 21.12.2013 of the then CEO (MKVIB)
stands disposed of in compliance of the Hon’ble High Court’s order
dated 16.10.2014 passed in WP(C) No.916 of 2013. Hence, the present
Writ petition praying for releasing the arrear pay and allowances
including leave salary and gratuity under ROP 2010 w.e.f. 01.04.2010
to 31.08.2012.
[10]
Respondent Nos.2 and 3 filed affidavit in opposition
stating that the Manipur Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2010 was issued
vide Notification No.1/4/2008-FD (PIC) dated 05.05.2007 with notional
effect on 01.01.2006 with actual cash payment from 01.04.2010.
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
However, in case of employees of Autonomous Bodies/ Local Bodies/
Grant-in Aid Institution/ Public Sector Undertakings shall be made only
with the concurrence of Finance Department subject to availability of
sufficient fund for the purpose.
[11]
It is further stated that the petitioner, i.e., Shri N.Ibobi
Singh, retired on 31.08.2012 and Manipur Services (Revised Pay)
Rules, 2010 was implemented in Manipur Khadi and Village Industries
Board with effect from 28.09.2016, hence the proposal for payment of
arrear pay and allowance under ROP 2010 cannot be considered
though representation is submitted to the Principal Secretary (Com &
Ind), Government of Manipur. Further, it is stated that since the State
Cabinet in its meeting held on 02.09.2016 decided to grant revised pay
to the Manipur Khadi & Village Industries Board with prospective effect
and no with retrospective effect, the proposal for payment of arrear
pay and allowance cannot be entertained to the petitioner. It is also
stated that as prescribed in Section 14(6) of the Act was 500-35-745EB-40-45-1200-50-1350/- p.m. plus other allowance admissible to the
employee of the Government of Manipur in similar scale. Accordingly,
Shri N. Ibobi Singh (husband of the LR of the petitioner) was appointed
as CEO MKVIB in the scale of Rs.10,000-15,000/- pm under ROP 1999
which was effective during that period.
[12]
It is also stated that though the arrear pay and allowance
was already prepared and has been fixed at Rs.8,81,454/- and the said
amount of money is also not a huge amount the State Government
cannot release the said amount as the State Cabinet decided to grant
the revised pay to the MKVIB with immediate effect i.e. 28.09.2016
whereas the petitioner retired on 31.08.2012 before the day the
revised ROP 2010 came into effect.
[13]
The counsel of the petitioner submitted that in respect
of other autonomous body Manipur Pollution Control Board, Loktak
Development authority, Manipur Co-operative Union, the concerned
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
administrative departments have conveyed their approval without
further delay. In respect of the Manipur Pollution Control Board, The
Deputy Secretary (Forest & Environment), Government of Manipur
conveyed the approval of the government for granting revised pay of
ROP, 2010 to the employees Manipur Pollution Control Board on 1612-2010.
[14]
In respect of LDA, the special Secretary (Forest &
Environment), Government of Manipur on 08-03-2011 have conveyed
the approval of the Government to the grant of revised pay of ROP,
2010 to the employees of the LDA.
[15]
In respect of Manipur State Co-operative Union, the
under-secretary (Co-operation), Government of Manipur on 23-052011 conveyed the approval of the government to the grant of revised
pay of ROP, 2010 to the employees of the Manipur State Co-operative
Union.
[16]
In respect of Manipur Khadi and Village Industrial Board,
long after the retirement of the petitioner only on 28-09-2016, the
under-secretary (C&I) Government of Manipur conveyed the approval
of the government to the grant of revised pay under ROP, 2010, in
respect of the employees of the Manipur Khadi and Village Industrial
Board.
[17]
The counsel of the petitioner also submitted that the CEO
of Manipur Khadi and Village Industrial Board already requested the
Director, Commerce and Industries, Government of Manipur for
granting the revised pay Under ROP, 2010, was backed on 17-102011. There was a delay of about 5 years while granting the approval
of the government for adoption of the benefit of revision of pay under
ROP, 2010.
[18]
The counsel of the petitioner further submitted that if
the government acted on time, certainly he would have enjoyed the
benefit of revision of pay under ROP, 2010, as the benefit has been
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
affected with case payment from 01-04-2010. At the relevant time, he
was in service and he retired only on 31-08-2012. The authorities of
the Manipur Khadi and Village Industrial Board have already calculated
his due salary as rupees 8,81,454/- i.e. the due salary from the period
01-04-2010 to 31-08-2012.
[19]
The delay caused while granting approval of the
Government for giving the benefit of revision of pay under ROP, 2010
is a clear case of administrative lapses for which the petitioner shall
not be made a victim.
[20]
During the course of hearing, the Ld. Government
Advocate has pointed out that the petitioner did not challenge the
letter dated 28-09-2016 and in absence of challenging this letter, the
relief sought in the Writ Petition shall not be permitted. In this regard
the counsel of the petitioner submitted that a relief which is entitled
to the petitioner shall not be denied only on the technical plea of nonmentioning or non-challenging in the relief clause of the Writ Petition.
[21]
In the case of Rupandhar Pujari v. Ganghadhar
Bhatra :(2004) 7 SCC 654(relevant para 8) has clearly held that
relief to which a plaintiff or petitioner is entitled to, on the facts
established, held, should not ordinarily be denied merely because the
relief clause in the pleadings was not very happily worded.
[22]
The petitioner has cited the following judgement:
i. Bangalore Development Authority -versus- Vijaya Leasing
Ltd. & Ors (2013) 14 SCC 737 (relevant para 13,14,17) held that
under article 226 of the constitution of India, the Hon’ble Court can
interfere and order even if the same is not challenged in the said
Writ Petition.
ii. Bhartiya Seva Samaj Trust Through President & another versus- Yogeshbhai Ambalal Patel & another (2012) 9 SCC
310 (relevant para 28) held that if an party has committed a wrong,
he cannot be permitted to take the benefit of his own wrong.
iii. State of Mizoram & anr. -versus- Mizoram Engineering
Service Association & Anr. (2004) 6 SCC 218 (relevant para 7)
held that financial bundle on the state has not relevance when the
claim for revised pay is found to be fully justified.
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
iv. State of Manipur & Ors. -versus- Maisnam Mani Singh &
Ors. 2010 (5) GLT 979 held that there cannot be any discrimination
for granting the benefit of revised pay solely on the ground of
financial crunch.
v. Coal India Ltd. & Ors -versus- Saroj Kumar Mishra (2007) 9
SCC 625 (relevant para 19) held that only because there is a
possibility of a floodgate litigation, a valuable right of citizen cannot
be permitted to take away.
[23]
The counsel of the respondent no.1 submitted that the
Government of Manipur issued notification dated 05-05-2010, thereby
making the rules viz. The Manipur Service (Revised), Rules, 2010, and
the same was made applicable notionally from 1st January, 2006 and
case payment from 1st April, 2010. Para 2(2)(b) specifically mentioned
that these Rules shall not apply to person whose particulars are not
figured in the Computerized Personal Information System (CPIS).
[24]
Finance Department, Government of Manipur issued
O.M. dated 07-07-2010 thereby clarifying that “revision of pay scales
of the employees of the Autonomous Bodies/Local Bodies/Grant-in-Aid
Institutions/Public Sector undertakings, etc. shall be made only with
the concurrence of Finance Department (PIC) subject to availability of
sufficient fund for that purpose. (Annexure-A/4 to the Writ Petition).
[25]
The counsel of the respondent no.1 submitted that the
CEO of the KVIB sent letter dated 09-011-2011 to the Director of
(Commerce & Industries) to forward proposal to the Government for
grant of ROP and the same was referred to the Government vide letter
dated 18-11-2011 by the Director. But the said proposal was returned
by Finance Department with observation as under:
“It is observed that the proposed grant of revised pay may
involve as additional amount of rupees 5.62 lakh P.m. approximately.
It is therefore, requested kindly to clarify how the additional liability
shall be made”. (Annexure – A/7, A/8 and A/9 to the Writ Petition).
[26]
The respondent No.1 has cited the following judgement:
i. Chandrashekar A.K -versus- State of kerala & Ors. (2009) 1
SCC 73 (relevant para 14) held that the policy decision
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
recommendation relating to revision of pay scale required its
acceptance by the employer or the state which had ultimately to
bear the financial burden- unless revised pay scale is formally
implemented by the authority concerned, held, it does not
automatically comes into force.
ii. Union of India -versus- Arun Jyoti Kundu & Ors. (2007) 7
SCC 472 (relevant para 22) Grant of benefit by government from a
particular date, employee concerned cannot clear benefit with
retrospective effect.
iii. Krishna Priya Ganguly & Ors. -versus- University of
Lucknow & Ors. (1984) 1 SCC 307 (relevant para 26) Held that
the relief should be confined to those prayer specifically made in
the petition.
iv. State of Bihar & Ors -versus- Radha K. Jha & Ors. (2002) 6
SCC 308 (relevant para 11) Relief not claimed-grant ofimpermissibility.
v. State of Orissa & Ors -versus_ Mamata Mohanty (2011) 3
SCC 436 [relevant para 55 and 65(xviii)] Relief not claimed-cannot
be granted- Pleadings and particulars are required to enable the
court to decide the rights of the parties in the trial. Thus, the
pleadings are more to help the court in narrowing the controversy
involved and to inform the parties concerned to the question in
issue, so that the parties may adduce appropriate evidence on the
said issue. It is a settled legal proposition that “as a rule relief not
founded on the pleadings should not be granted”. Therefore, a
decision of a case cannot be based on grounds outside the
pleadings of the parties.
[27]
This Court considers the materials on record minutely,
the submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties and the
case laws cited at bar.
[28]
It is the settled law that for the autonomous bodies like
Khadi Board, the revision of new pay scale will not be automatically
applicable upon the State Government issuing notification in this
regard. For such bodies, the new pay revision has to be adopted by
the competent authority/board and the same has to be forwarded to
the State Government for final approval. In the present case, the
Manipur Khadi & Village Industries Board, in its meeting held on
27.08.2011, had already adopted the RoP 2010 for its employees
notionally wef 01.01.2006 with cash payment from 01.04.2010 in toto
with the approval of the State Government. The said resolution was
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
forwarded by the Chief Executive Officer of the Board to the Director,
Commerce & Industries, Government of Manipur to move the State
Government for its approval. The Director, in turn, wrote a letter dated
18.11.2011 to the Principal Secretary (Com & Ind), Government of
Manipur for doing needful. Deputy Secretary, Commerce & Industries
vide letter dated 14.08.2012 informed the CEO to submit clarification
about financial implication to the tune of Rs.5.62 lakh per month for
adoption of RoP 2010. Vide letter dated 24.08.2012, the CEO of the
Board submitted the clarification stating that since its inception, the
additional expenditures including pay and allowance were born by the
State Government. It may be noted that the forwarding of the
adoption of RoP 2010 by the Board was in tune with the Office
Memorandum dated 28.02.2011 requiring the autonomous bodies/
local bodies/PSUs to adopt the new revision of pay for their employees.
Vide the impugned letter/order dated 28.09.2016 issued by the Under
Secretary (C&I), Government of Manipur, the approval for revised pay
under RoP 2010 was granted with ‘immediate effect’. By this time, the
petitioner retired from service on attaining the age of superannuation
on 31.08.2012. Due to the delay in granting adoption of RoP 2010 as
late as 28.09.2016 with immediate effect, the petitioner was left out
of the benefit of high pay and allowance. It is an admitted fact that
approval of RoP 2010 to Manipur Pollution Control Board was granted
on 16.12.2020 notionally wef 01.01.2006 with cash payment from
01.04.2010. For Loktak Development Authority by order dated
08.03.2011, RoP 2010 was approved notionally wef 01.01.2006 with
cash payment from 01.04.2010. Similarly, for the Co-operative
Societies, Manipur, the approval for RoP 2010 was obtained on
23.05.2011 notionally wef 01.01.2006 with cash payment from
01.04.2010. In case of KV&IB, the approval was granted only on
28.09.2016 that too with immediate effect, while similar bodies were
given retrospective effect notionally wef 01.01.2006 with cash
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
payment from 01.04.2010. A departure was made only for Khadi Board
that too without any valid reason. It is seen that all the clarifications
were submitted by the Board to the State Government in time, but
delay in approval has not been explained. In the circumstances, the
petitioner has been denied the benefit of higher pay and allowance
under RoP 2010 thereby causing heavy financial loss to the tune of Rs.
8,81,454/- [as admitted in letter dated 25.04.2016 of the Board to
Commissioner (Com & Ind): Annexure-A-20]. In order dated
18.12.2024, this Court directed MKV&IB to explain the arrears of
Rs.8,81,454 and vide letter dated 04.02.2025, the Board explained
that the arrear shown in letter dated 25.04.2016 was just a proposal
of the arrear upon implementation of the RoP 2010 and the petitioner
was not entitled to the same.
[29]
This Court is of the view that Board has been treated
differently from other similarly situated bodies such as Pollution Board,
Lokatak Development Board and no justification is given for this
different treatment. Even if it is assumed that the sum of Rs.8,81,454/is an estimated arrear to be paid to the petitioner as per RoP 2010,
there is no reason to deny the same to the petitioner. Keeping in view
of the fear of floodgate of claims from other employees of the Board
as expressed by learned GA, this Court directs the respondent to pay
the arrear of Rs.8,81,454/- to the petitioner through his LR treating
the date of adoption of RoP 2010 for Manipur State Khadi & Village
Industries Board notionally wef 01.01.2006 with cash payment from
01.04.2010 for the petitioner only. It is clarified that this direction will
not be applicable to other employees of the Board who did not
approach this Court in time. This direction is issued in peculiar facts of
the present case and shall not be a precedent. This Court is refrained
from imposing cost. However, the payment should be credited to the
family pension of the petitioner, now enjoyed by his wife within a
period of three months from the date of receipt of this order. No cost.
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
[30]
Send a copy of this order to the Chairman, Manipur Khadi
& Village Industries Board for information and necessary compliance.
JUDGE
Priyojit
signed
RAJKUMA Digitally
by RAJKUMAR
R PRIYOJIT PRIYOJIT SINGH
Date: 2025.12.23
SINGH
13:32:10 +05'30'
WP(C) NO. 571 OF 2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review