Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.613 of 2023
Smt. Namita Paul, W/o Sri Swapan Kumar Paul, resident of B.K Road, POAgartala, PS-East Agartala, District-West Tripura
.....Petitioner
Versus
1. Food Corporation of India, represented by its Managing Director, having
its Head Office at 16-20 Barkhamba Lane, New Delhi-110001.
2. The General Manager, Food Corporation of India, NEF Region, Mawlai,
Mawroh, Shillong-793008.
3. Assistant General Manager (Cont.), Food Corporation of India
(RO:NEF), Mawlai, Mawroh, Shillong-793008.
4. The Divisional Manager, Food Corporation of India, Colonel
Chowmuhani, Agartala, P.S-West Agartala, District-West Tripura
…..Respondents
For the Petitioner(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate
Mr. Kundan Pandey, Advocate
Mr. Ratan Datta, Advocate
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
14.05.2024
:
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment and Order (Oral)
By means of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioner has
challenged the impugned order dated 09.06.2023 issued by the respondent
no.2, the General Manager, Food Corporation of India, NEF Region,
Shillong, whereby and whereunder the claim of the petitioner for refund of
Earnest Money Deposit(for short, EMD) amounting to Rs.10,10,000/- with
interest was rejected.
2.
The petitioner has prayed for following reliefs:
i) As to why a Writ in the nature of Mandamus should not be issued
quashing the Order vide No.Cont/Legal/NEFR/WP(C) 118/2022/NP/21688
dated 09.06.2023 issued by the Respondent No.2 whereby the respondents
rejected the claim of the petitioner for refund of Earnest Money Deposit
amounting to Rs. 10,10,000/-.
(ii) As to why a Writ in the nature of Mandamus should not be issued
directing the Respondents to refund Earnest Money Deposit amounting to
Rs.10,10,000/- along with interest at the rate of 12% per annum w.e.f
17.11.2011 till the date of payment in respect of Contract No.
Cont.50/NEFR/ TE/2010 dated 01.07.2010 for transportation of food
grains/sugar/allied materials from Rly. Siding Changsari/CWC Godown
Amingaon/RH FSD Guwahati to Godown Complex, Agartala.
AND
(iii) As to why such other order/orders should not be passed so as to give
full relief to the Petitioner and, upon causes shown, to make the Rule
absolute”
3.
Brief fact of the case is that the petitioner is a Government
contractor and supplier by occupation and having expertise on that field for
several years, she had participated in a Notice Inviting Tender(for short,
NIT) vide No.Cont.50/NEFR/TE/2010 dated 01.07.2010 floated by the
respondents-Food Corporation of India(here-in-after referred to as “FCI”)
for transportation of food-grains/sugar/allied materials from Rly. Siding
Changsari/CWC Godown Amingaon/RH FSD Guwahati to Godown
Complex, Agartala. In terms of the NIT, the petitioner had deposited
requisite earnest money of Rs.10,10,000/- by way of two demand drafts vide
No.674073 dated 01.09.2010 amounting to Rs.6,62,000/- and No.674074
dated 01.09.2010 amounting to Rs.3,48,000/- in favour of the FCI which has
been confirmed by the Branch Manager, Canara Bank by issuing a letter
dated 10.08.2023(Annexure-25 to the writ petition).
3.1.
Subsequently, the petitioner came to know that she was not
selected for the said tender. The petitioner issued a letter dated 10.08.2017 to
the respondent no.2 for releasing the EMD, but, after receipt of the said
letter, the respondents neither gave any reply nor returned the said EMD to
the petitioner. Being aggrieved, again on 04.09.2017 and 12.04.2018 the
petitioner issued reminder letters to the respondent no.2 (Annexures-4 and 5
respectively to the writ petition). The petitioner requested the respondentsFCI by issuing several communications on different dates for releasing the
said EMD, but the respondents-FCI did not give any reply to the petitioner.
Subsequently, the petitioner through email dated 27.11.2020, 04.12.2020
and 10.12.2020 requested the respondents-FCI for releasing the said EMD
and finally, the respondents-FCI vide letters dated 29.10.2020 and
24.12.2020 informed the petitioner that the said EMD of Rs.10,10,000/- is
kept in abeyance due to pendency of Court case. Being aggrieved, the
petitioner filed writ petition being WP(C) No.118 of 2022 before this Court
praying for setting aside the communications dated 29.10.2020 and
24.12.2020. After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties, the
learned Single Judge had disposed of the writ petition vide judgment and
order dated 11.04.2023 on being observed thus:
“7. The impugned order dated 29.10.2020 and 24.12.2020, is only a
communication from the respondent company to the petitioner
indicating that his request for return of Rs.10,10,000/- cannot be
entertained. This Court is unable to support the case of the
respondent's letters dated 29.10.2020 and 24.12.2020 since the same
is an unreasoned communication and it is not fair on the part of the
respondents to withhold the EMD deposited by the petitioner herein
stating that the same is kept abeyance until the final outcome of the
Court case/in view of the pendency of the Court case. The same
amount to arbitrary action. In any event, if the respondents think that
the petitioner is not entitled, it is the prima facie duty of the
respondents to indicate under what provision of law her EMD cannot
be returned. In the event, if it is to be forfeited a separate proceeding
needs to be issued, or in the event if there is any resultant loss that has
been suffered by the respondents, on account of the petitioner's
contract, it is not just on the part of the respondents to withheld the
EMD without there being any expressed order forfeiting her EMD.
Withholding the EMD of the petitioner without giving any opportunity
to the petitioner amounts to violation of the principle of natural justice
and is also against the principle of ad alteram partem as clearly
indicated herein above.
8. In view of the above discussion, the impugned letter of the
respondents dated 29.10.2020 and 24.12.2020 is set aside and the
respondents are directed to reconsider the request of the petitioner in
accordance with the law within a period of 2(two) months from the
date of receipt of the copy of this order."
3.2.
The
petitioner
submitted
a
representation
before
the
respondents enclosing a copy of the aforementioned judgment and order
dated 11.04.2023 requesting to refund the withheld EMD amounting to
Rs.10,10,000/-. Without considering the said representation in the light of
the direction of the aforementioned judgment and order, the respondents
issued a show-cause notice against the petitioner seeking explanation as to
why the EMD submitted by the petitioner was not liable to be set
off/reimbursed/forfeited under Clause XII(b) and XII(e) of the tender
document against the losses suffered by them due to alleged negligence and
unworkmanlike performance of the petitioner(Annexure-20 to the writ
petition) relating to other contract works. On receipt of the show-cause
notice the petitioner submitted reply and without considering the reply of the
petitioner to the show-cause notice, the respondent vide order dated
09.06.2023 rejected the claim of the petitioner on the ground that the EMD
amount was never remitted into the account of the FCI against the said
tender(Annexure-22 to the writ petition).
3.3.
The petitioner vide letters dated 06.06.2023 and 27.06.2023
requested the Branch Manager, Canara Bank to provide confirmation
regarding the payment of demand draft No.674073 dated 01.09.2010
amounting to Rs.6,62,000/- and D.D. No.674074 dated 01.09.2010
amounting to Rs.3,48,000/- ,which was subsequently confirmed by the
Branch
Manager,
Canara
Bank
by
issuing
a
letter
dated
10.08.2023(Annexure-25 to the writ petition).
3.4.
It is the grievance of the petitioner that the respondents
violating the directions passed in the impugned judgment and order of this
Court issued the order dated 09.06.2023, which is not sustainable in law.
Furthermore, the respondents most illegally and arbitrarily relying upon
other contracts rejected the claim of the petitioner. The petitioner had
approached the respondents on several occasions to release the withheld
EMD, but the respondents did not return the said amount in favour of the
petitioner compelling the petitioner to file the present writ petition before
this Court.
4.
On the aforesaid background of facts, I have heard Mr. Raju
Datta, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as well as Mr. Ratan
Datta, learned counsel appearing for the FCI.
5.
At the very outset, learned counsel for the petitioner has drawn
my attention to a communication dated 24.12.2020(Annexure-15 to the writ
petition) whereby and whereunder the petitioner was informed that the
refund of the claimed amount against the EMD of Rs.10,10,000/- was kept
in abeyance in view of the pendency of court’s case where the Corporation
had suffered huge losses. Learned counsel for the petitioner drawing my
attention to another communication dated 08.07.2022 submits that the
competent authority of the FCI had informed the petitioner that the EMD
deposited by the petitioner amounting to Rs.10,10,000/- in NIT under
reference No.Cont.50/NEFR/TE/2010 dated 20.08.2010 inviting tender for
certain transportation contract was set off since the FCI had suffered huge
losses in terms of additional expenditure towards risk and cost in executing
transport contracts awarded vide Cont.9/NEFR/TC/CHNG-AGT/2008,
Cont.9/NEFR/TC/CBZ-CDR/2009 and Cont.9/NEFR/TC/CBZ-ADNR/2009
in terms of Clause XII(b) and XII(e) of the tender document(Annexure-16 to
the writ petition).
6.
I have perused the aforesaid communications.
7.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that
the setting off of the aforesaid amount of Rs.10,10,000/- which was
furnished at the time of submission of tender no.Cont.50/NEFR/TE/2010 is
illegal and arbitrary and is liable to be set-aside and quashed.
8.
On the other hand, Mr. Ratan Datta, learned counsel appearing
on behalf of the FCI has contended that the EMD deposited relating to
tender No.Cont.50/NEFR/TE/2010 dated 20.08.2010 was set off by way of
invoking sub-clause (b) and sub-clause (e) of the Clause XII of the tender
document.
Second fold of submission of Mr. Ratan Datta, learned counsel
for the FCI is that the petitioner had not deposited any EMD against the
tender No.Cont.50/NEFR/TE/2010 dated 01.07.2010 and it relates to “other
contract work” and for that reason the said DD was/is not traceable.
9.
To a query made by this Court, Mr. Ratan Datta, learned
counsel appearing for the FCI has failed to justify his submission exactly
against which tender number or “other contract work” the said EMD was
deposited.
10.
I have considered the submissions of learned counsel appearing
for the parties.
11.
From the records/documents annexed to the writ petition and
counter affidavit, particularly, from the communications dated 24.12.2020
and 08.07.2022(Annexure-15 and 16 respectively, to the writ petition) it
becomes apparent that the FCI had forfeited and set off the EMD amounting
to Rs.10,10,000/- deposited against the tender No.Cont.50/NEFR/TE/2010
dated 20.08.2010 due to the alleged losses it had to bear as additional
expenditure towards risk and cost caused while executing transport contracts
awarded in favour of the same petitioner vide Cont.9/NEFR/TC/CHNGAGT/2008, period 24.11.2008 to 23.11.2010, Cont.9/NEFR/TC/CBZCDR/2009, period 01.05.2009 to 30.07.2011 and Cont.9/NEFR/TC/CBZADNR/2009, period 16.11.2009 to 15.02.2012 in terms of Clause XII(b) and
XII(e) of the contract agreement. So, according to me, it is an admitted fact
that the FCI had set off the EMD of Rs.10,10,000/- for their alleged losses
relating to other contract works.
Furthermore, the second contention of Mr. Ratan Datta, learned
counsel appearing for the FCI that the petitioner had not deposited any EMD
against the tender No.Cont.50/NEFR/TE/2010 dated 01.07.2010 has no legs
to stand and accordingly, the said submission is repelled.
12.
At this juncture, the principal question centers around whether
the FCI could adjust or forfeit the EMD which was a condition precedent to
submit her tender for alleged losses suffered by the FCI in relation to other
contracts entered into with the petitioner.
13.
sum
Admittedly, the FCI denied to refund the EMD and forfeited the
by
invoking
Clause
XII(b)
and
XII(e)
of
the
tender
document/agreement. It leads me to peruse Clause XII(b) and XII(e) of the
tender document laying down certain terms and conditions which are
reproduced here-in-below:
“Clause XII. Liability of Contractors for losses etc. suffered by
Corporation:
(a)****
(b) The Corporation shall be at liberty to reimburse themselves of
any damages, losses, charges, costs or expenses suffered or
incurred by them due to contractors negligence and unworkmanlike performance of service under the contract or breach
of any terms thereof. The total sum claimed shall be deducted from
any sum than due or which at any time hereafter may become due
to the contractors under this or any other contract with the
Corporation. In the event of the sum which may be due from the
Corporation as aforesaid being insufficient the balance of the total
sum claimed and recoverable from the contractors as aforesaid
shall be deducted from the security deposit furnished by the
contractors as specified in Para XI. Should this sum also be not
sufficient to cover the full amount claimed by the Corporation, the
contractors shall pay to the Corporation on demand the remaining
balance of the aforesaid sum claimed.
(c)****
(d)****
(e) A set off any sum of money due and payable to the
contractors(including security deposit returnable to them) under
this contract may be appropriated by the Corporation and set-off
against any claim of the Corporation for the payment of any sum of
money arising of this or under any other contract made by the
contractors with the Corporation.”
13.1.
On careful reading of the provisions of Clause XII(b) and
XII(e) extracted here-in-above, in my considered view, before invoking setoff Clause under Clause-XII, it must be proved that the Corporation suffered
loss due to “negligence or un-workmanlike performance” of the contractor
in execution of any work under any contract. Further, in the instant case,
there is no material on records as to how the respondents have suffered loss
in execution of any other contract work.
13.2.
On bare perusal of Clause XII(b) and XII(e), it is crystal clear
that respondent-Corporation had taken the advantage of the expression “any
other contract” embodied in Clause XII(b) and XII(e). Clause XII(b) makes
a provision providing liberty to the Corporation to reimburse any sum of
money out of any loss or damage they suffer or incur due to contractor’s
negligence or failure in performance of the contract to the satisfaction of the
Corporation from any sum including the security deposit due or payable to
the contractor under the ongoing contract work or any other contract
executed by the same contractor in future under the Corporation.
13.3.
In the instant case, admittedly, the respondents having taken the
recourse of the expression “any other contract” forfeited the EMD of
Rs.10,10,000/-
deposited
by
the
petitioner
in
the
NIT
No.
Cont.50/NEFR/TE/2010.
13.4.
In my opinion, the expression “any other contract” means and
connotes that there must be a contract to be entered into between two
intending parties on certain terms and conditions enforceable in law.
13.5.
Section 2(h) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 defines the word
“contract” that connotes “an agreement enforceable by law”.
13.6.
In the case in hand, FCI-Corporation only floated the tender
inviting applications from the intending parties and such parties only
submitted their respective bids/offers. But, it was not proceeded further as
the petitioner was not successful. So, it would not just and proper to say that
there was existence of any contract entered into between the respondentsCorporation and the petitioner which was enforceable in law. In that case,
FCI had no authority to reimburse any amount or set-off EMD amount
deposited at the time of submission of offer by the contractor. Such setoff/forfeiture of EMD amount is illegal, arbitrary and dehors the terms and
conditions stipulated in tender documents and thus, the FCI-respondents is
liable to return/refund the EMD amount with interest to the petitioner.
14.
Now, the question is whether the respondents are liable to pay
interest for denying the refund of EMD to the petitioner. Mr. Ratan Datta,
learned counsel for the respondents to justify his submission that interest
will not be payable out of the delayed refund of EMD, has relied upon
Clause 4 of the tender document. Clause 4 may be reproduced hereunder:
“4. Earnest Money:
Each tender must be accompanied by an Earnest Money of
Rs.7,68,000/-(Rupees Seven Lakh Sixty Eight Thousand) only in form of a
Demand Draft/Pay Order issued by a Scheduled Bank in favour of the
General Manager, Food Corporation of India, Shillong and payable at
Shillong. Tenders not accompanied by earned money in the form prescribed
above shall be summarily rejected.
The earnest money shall be liable to forfeiture if the tenderer after
submitting his render resiles from or modifies his offer and or the terms and
conditions thereof in any manner, it being understood that the tender
documents have been made available to him and he is being permitted to
tender in consideration of his agreement to this stipulation. The earnest
money is also liable to be forfeited in the event of the tenderers failure, after
the acceptance of his tender, to furnish the requisite security deposit by the
due date without prejudice to any other rights and remedies of Corporation
under contract and law. The earnest money will be returned to all
unsuccessful tenderers as soon as practicable after decision on tenders and
to a successful tenderer, after he has furnished a security deposit, if the
successful tenderer does not desire the same to be adjusted towards the
security deposit. No interest shall be payable on the amount of earnest
money, in any case.”
14.1.
I have meticulously perused the said clause of the tender
document and also have considered the submission of learned counsel for
the FCI. On careful reading of the Clause 4, in the opinion of this Court, it
has three components. First part speaks about deposit of earnest money
along with the tender as a condition precedent to submit his/her bid/offer.
The second part is about the situations under which the FCI can
forfeit
the
EMD
accompanying
the
tender
submitted
by
the
bidder/contractor. Under this second part it is clearly stated that the EMD
can only be forfeited if the tenderer/contractor after submitting his tender
resiles from or modifies his offer and/or the terms and conditions thereof in
any manner whatsoever since stipulations mentioned in the tender
documents are binding on the bidders. It is further stated that the earnest
money is also liable to be forfeited in the event of the tenderer’s failure after
the acceptance of his tender, to furnish the requisite security deposit by the
due date without prejudice to any other rights and remedies of
Corporation/FCI under the contract and law. The first and the second part do
not create any such contingency giving liberty to the FCI to forfeit or set off
the EMD for the loss it suffered/incurred from other contracts entered into
with the contractor due to the non-performance or unsatisfactory
performance of the contract works by the said contractor.
The third part deals with the FCI’s obligation to return/refund
the EMD. The third part stipulates that the EMD would be returned to all
unsuccessful tenderers as soon as practicable after decision on tenders and to
a successful tenderer after he has furnished a security deposit, if the
successful tenderer does not desire the same to be adjusted towards the
security deposit. However, in such cases, the contractor cannot claim interest
on the amount of earnest money deposited with the FCI.
So, on plain reading of Clause 4 above, it can safely be said that
in absence of any of the contingencies mentioned in the second part of the
said clause, the FCI/Corporation has no right to withhold or to set it off or
forfeit the EMD and the Corporation is under obligation to return the EMD
to the unsuccessful bidders.
14.2.
In the instant case, there was no fault of the tenderer/contractor
i.e. the petitioner in submitting her tender. The petitioner had fulfilled all the
essentialities mentioned in “Instruction of bidders”. Neither the contractor
resiled from nor modified the terms and conditions made at the time of
submitting the tender. The petitioner only participated in the tender process
and was unsuccessful. Furthermore, the respondents denied to refund the
EMD despite repeated requests and demand notices served by the petitioner,
and, forfeited the same on the ground that the respondents had suffered huge
loss due to the failure of the contractor in execution of other contracts by
invoking Clause XII(e) of the tender document/agreement.
14.3.
In my opinion, failure to return the EMD to the petitioner after
she was unsuccessful is unreasonable, arbitrary and contrary to Clause 4
stated above. As such, the FCI-Corporation is liable to pay interest for its
failure to fulfill its solemn obligation to return the EMD to the petitioner as
stipulated at the third part of Clause 4 analysed here-in-above. In this
circumstance, the EMD amount shall definitely fetch interest for its
erroneous and arbitrary exercise of power under the garb of Clause XII(b)
and XII(e) of the contract.
15.
In view of the above analysis on law and facts and for the
reasons recorded here-in-above, the impugned order dated 09.06.2023 issued
by the respondent no.2 whereby the claim of the petitioner for refund of the
EMD was rejected is hereby set aside and quashed. The FCI is directed to
return/refund EMD with interest at the rate of 6% per annum payable from
the date when the earnest money was deposited by the petitioner till its
refund. The entire process shall be completed within a period of 30(thirty)
days from the date the copy of this judgment shall be received by the FCI
authority at Agartala.
The instant writ petition stands allowed in the above terms.
JUDGE
Snigdha
SAIKAT
KAR
Digitally signed
by SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2024.06.20
16:22:06 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review