Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.242 of 2022
Smti. Namita Paul
.....Petitioner
V_E_R_S_U_S
Food Corporation of India & 3 Others
.....Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, Advocate.
Mr. K. Pandey, Advocate.
Mr. A. Bhowmik, Advocate.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
02/05/2023
Heard Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel and Mr. K. Pandey, learned
counsel appearing for petitioner and Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This petition has been filed under Article-226 of the Constitution
of India for quashing the letter dated 29.10.2020 issued by the respondent No.2
whereby the respondents refused to refund the security deposit amounting to
Rs.3,03,080/- to the petitioner and further to refund the security deposit
amounting to Rs.3,03,080/- along with interest at the rate of 12% per annum
w.e.f. 23.03.2011 till the date of payment in respect of loading/unloading and
handling contract at FSD Nandannagar, Agartala on the basis of agreement
executed by the petitioner under appointment letter dated 14.03.2008 issued by
the respondent No.2.
[3]
The facts in brief of the present case are that the petitioner is a
transport contractor. A sum of Rs.3,03,080/- as security deposit against
transportation contract satisfactorily executed by the petitioner has not been
refunded by the respondents in spite of clearances by all concerned.
[4]
Hence, the present petition has been filed by the petitioner before
this Court for redress.
[5]
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has submitted that
the respondents cannot withheld the security deposit of the petitioner on the
ground that they suffered losses in connection with some other contract, though
practically, the respondents failed to show before any Court of law that they
suffered any losses due to fault of the contractor in connection with
appointment letter dated 29.04.2009.
[6]
The respondents cannot withhold any amount of money
arbitrarily, without any authority of law with such vague pleas. As a result, the
letter dated 29.10.2020 is liable to be quashed and set aside and the petitioner is
entitled to refund of security deposit amounting to Rs.3,03,080/-. The petitioner
could not utilize the said money in his business and as such has suffered loss in
the form of huge bank interest on her loan and therefore, the respondents are
liable to refund the said amount along with interest @12% per annum from the
date of claim i.e. 23.03.2011till the date of payment inasmuch as, withholding
of payment is arbitrary and groundless.
[7]
The respondents mentioned three numbers of contracts in their
impugned order dated 22.07.2022 that they suffered losses due to the fault of
the petitioner but fact remains the said contracts are in no way related with the
present contract and moreover, in the aforementioned cases, it has already been
decided against the respondents in relation to the aforesaid contracts with
observation that FC did not suffer any loss due to the fault of the petitioner,
rather petitioner suffered losses due to fault of FCI, the respondents.
[8]
He has further contended that after passing of the judgment by
the Court of law, the respondents cannot defy the order, rather the respondents
are duty bound to accept the directions passed by the Court. the respondents
suppressed the facts that they did not suffer any losses due to the fault of the
petitioner as a result the Clause-X(C) and Clause-XII (e) of the agreement is
not applicable in the present case and the respondents cannot set off the
security deposit of the petitioner, fact remains that after judgment passed by
several Courts it is settled that set off clause will not apply in the present fact
and situation. As a result, the order dated 22.07.2022 is illegal and liable to be
quashed.
[9]
The petitioner also stated that the said civil suits were already
decided by this Court and the Court decided the said case against the FCI
respondents. The Court observed that FCI did not suffer any losses due to any
fault of the petitioner. As a result, the petitioner has submitted that there is no
breach of contract in the present case and no loss was suffered by FCI in the
present contract. Moreover, FCI already issued a no demand certificate and in
the said certificate it was specifically submitted that no loss is suffered by the
FCI in the present contract, no demurrage was incurred due to negligence of the
contractor and contractor has not been responsible for any loss or damage to
articles.
[10]
As a result, the respondents cannot withhold the security deposit
of the petitioner without any justifiable ground and without any authority of
law. Moreover, the ground for withholding of present security deposit was
never raised by the respondents in any Court of law drawing pendency of other
cases and the amount of security deposit was never disputed by the respondents
rather they admitted the said amount or security deposit. The respondents are
duty bound to refund the security deposit to the petitioner along with interest.
[11]
Mr. A. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the respondents
has submitted that refund of security deposit is subject to other clauses of the
contract. In the present case the security deposit of the petitioner has been
forfeited /set off under Clause-XII (b) and XII (e) of the Contract Agreement.
The respondent corporation has issued a no demand certificate is totally false,
baseless and fabricated aiming to mislead this Court for gaining illegally. It is
further submitted that there is no clauses or provisions in the present tender
agreement that no demand certificate is to be issued by the respondent
corporation. It is also stated that the respondents corporation never issued any
no demand certificate to the petitioner. No demand certificate is submitted by
the contractors themselves. Thus, the claim of the petitioner must not be
granted.
[12]
The petitioner is trying to make out a false case on the basis of no
demand certificate submitted by herself. Further, non-existence of any liability
in a particular contract does not give any immunity to any contractor from
recovery of liabilities pertaining to other contracts from the instant security
deposit to make good the losses incurred at his/her hands. Thus, the security
deposit of Rs.3,03,080/- had to be set off and appropriated against the losses
sustained by the corporation in accordance with Clause-X(c) XII (b) and XII
(e) undertaking furnished by the petitioner in Appendix-V under a valid
agreement executed between the petitioner and the respondents corporation.
[13]
The petitioner tried and made an all out attempt to hide her own
written commitment under Clause-XII (b) and Clause-XII (e) in which the
petitioner has agreed that any sum of money due and payable to the contractors
may be appropriated and set off against any claim of the corporation for the
payment of any sum of money arising under this or under any other contract
made by the contractor with the corporation. Thus, under this clause, the
petitioner has allowed and agreed in principle for setting off or adjustment of
the security deposit with the losses sustained by the corporation relating to the
contract in issue or any other contracts executed by her with the corporation.
[14]
Further, it is reiterated herein that the submission of the petitioner
that no demand certificate has been issued by the respondent corporation is
false, baseless and without any substance, as no such demand certificate has
ever been issued by the respondent corporation. Thus the submission of the
petitioner on this score is to mislead this Court for her illegal gain and to
misuse the public money in particular. However, M.S. No.27 of 2010 filed by
the petitioner was dismissed by the learned Civil Judge on merit. Against the
said judgment and decree dated 11.05.2016 passed by the learned Civil Judge
Senior Division, Court No.1, West Tripura, Agartala the petitioner had
preferred appeal before this Court which was registered as RFA. No.14 of
2016. Vide judgment and decree dated 26.02.2021, the said appeal filed by the
petitioner was allowed as FCI failed to prove the actual loss suffered by FCI by
adducing documentary evidence.
[15]
Moreover, the petitioner is relying upon judgments and decrees
passed by the Civil Courts in writ proceedings which is not permissible under
the law. In fact, the findings of the learned Civil Court vide judgment and
decree dated 11.05.2016 passed in MS.No.27 of 2010 and M.S. (CC) 14 of
2011 as merged with the judgment and decree dated 26.02.2021 passed in RFA.
No.14 of 2016 passed by this Court is against the petitioner.
[16]
In view of above discussion, the present petition stands disposed
of directing the petitioner to represent the matter before the respondents along
with all relevant documents in support the claim of the petitioner more
particularly, any judgment of the High Court or any other Court on receipt of
the representation, the respondents shall consider the same in accordance with
law within a period of three months from the date of receipt of the copy of such
representation.
[17]
It has been contended by the learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner that a sum of Rs.3,03,080/- which is given towards the security
deposit has been withheld on the ground of loss sustained by the respondents
for performing another contract by the petitioner but, for the said contract, the
respondents cannot withhold the security deposit pertaining to some other
contracts. This issue has been by the principle laid down by the High Court
stating that in the event if any loss has been caused to any organization for any
reason committed by the contractor, the said loss needs to be recovered in
accordance with law but, not withholding the security deposit. In view of
above, without expressing any opinion, the present writ petition stands
disposed of directing the respondents to re-consider the same in the light of
above. Consequently, the impugned order stands set aside. Accordingly, the
present petition stands disposed of. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications
pending, if any, shall stand closed.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review