Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.P.(C) No.157 of 2025
Smt. Mousumi Sen
D/O- Sri Swapan Sen of Dulucherra, North Jolaibari,
P.O- Jolaibari, District- South Tripura
…..Petitioner(s)
–Versus–
1.
The Union of India
represented by the
Government of India.
Ministry
of
Home
Affairs,
2.
The Secretary,
Staff Selection Commission,
Block No.12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, Near JLN
Stadium, New Delhi, Delhi-110091
3.
Staff Selection Commission,
represented by Chairman, Block No.12, CGO
Complex, Lodhi Road, Near JLN Stadium, New Delhi,
Delhi-110091.
4.
North Eastern Regional Office,
Staff Selection Commission, Gauhati, represented by
Regional Director, Housefed Complex, West End
Block, Last Gate- Basistha Road, P.O. Assam
Sachivalaya, Dispur, Gauhati-781006.
5.
Director General,
CRPF (Central Reserve Police Force) (Recruitment
Branch) East Block -07, Level-4, Sector-01, R.K.
Puram, New Delhi-110066 (Ministry of Home Affairs).
6.
Presiding Officer,
DV/DME Board of CT(GD) Exam-2022, Office atOffice of the Deputy Inspector General, Border
Security Force, Salbagan, Pin-799006, Agartala,
West Tripura.
7.
The Director General,
CRPF (Central Reserve Police Force), G.S. Road (9th
Mile, Amerigog, Guwahati, Assam, Pin-781023.
8.
The Inspector General,
Tripura Sector, CRPF, Agartala.
……. Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner (s)
:
Ms. R. Purkayastha, Adv.
For the Respondent (s)
:
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. SGI
Date of hearing and delivery :
of Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting
:
18.08.2025
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Ms. R. Purkayastha, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner and Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI appearing
for the respondents.
[2]
The petitioner earlier filed a writ petition bearing No.
W.P.(C) No.557 of 2023 asserting that she had participated as a UR
female category candidate bearing Roll No.5601011613 in a
selection process for recruitment to the post of Constable (GD) in
Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs), SSF, Rifleman (GD) in Assam
Rifles
and
Sepoy
in
Narcotics
Central
Bureau
against
the
advertisement published in the month of October, 2022 [AnnexureA of the writ petition]. The petitioner applied against both State
wise category [category code-33] and Border Guarding District
category [Sl. No.86-93] and thereafter, successfully qualified the
computer based examination scoring 57.44 marks. Thereafter, she
also qualified the physical efficiency test and physical standard test.
But at the time of document verification, it was detected that
wrongly, her date of birth was mentioned as 10.10.1999 in place of
correct date of birth 10.07.1999 in the online application form. It is
asserted by the petitioner that on detection of such a wrong entry,
the respondents asked her to submit an affidavit in respect of her
such mistake in recording her date of birth after completion of her
medical examination and accordingly, allowed her to appear for the
Detailed Medical Examination [DME] on 20.07.2023, wherein she
was declared unfit on account of presence of red blood cells in her
urine. Then she applied for Review Medical Examination [RME] and
on re-examination, she was declared medically fit in the said RME.
The petitioner also thereafter submitted her affidavit in respect of
her date of birth to the respondents as per their instructions but
unfortunately on 02.08.2023, she was handed over with one
rejection slip issued by the respondent No.6 on the ground of
mismatch in her date of birth. Thereafter, on 11.08.2023 she
wrote/sent an email to the Secretary, Staff Selection Commission
[the respondent No.2] narrating everything in details but
despite
the same, a notification dated 20.08.2023 had been issued by the
Staff Selection Commission declaring the State wise, post wise and
category wise vacancies and the filled up positions along with the
final merit list.
[3]
The petitioner also states that she learnt that 3[three]
posts against UR category vacancy in the General District/State
category [category code-G] in ITBP (category code-E) have been
kept vacant but despite the same, the petitioner has not been
favoured with any job. Thereafter, the petitioner submitted another
representation on 21.08.2023 to the respondent No.7 which went
unresponded.
[4]
The petitioner after that filed the writ petition before this
Court bearing No. W.P.(C) No.557 of 2023 for quashing of said
merit list, and after hearing both the parties, the Coordinate Bench
of this Court [Bench of Hon’ble the Chief Justice] disposed of the
matter vide order dated 06.09.2023 inter alia in the following
terms:
7. It, therefore, appears to the Court that the
respondents should consider the representation of the
petitioner in accordance with law taking into account the
fact that the educational certificate and all other
certificates named above showing date of birth entry do
not have a mismatch except that the mismatch is in the
month of the date of birth entry i.e. October (10-10-99)
instead of July (10-07-99) in her online application. It
also need to be kept in mind that such candidates
belongs to interior areas of states like Tripura in the
northeastern region and may not have the proper
assistance in submission of such online applications
invited by the recruiting agencies. In case the
respondents are satisfied that the error in the month of
her date of birth entry in the online application is
inadvertent and otherwise all admissible documents such
as educational certificates of Madhyamik Examination,
PRTC, Aadhaar Card, etc. show the same correct date of
birth
i.e.
10.07.1999,
the
competent
authority/respondent
No.5
should
consider
her
sympathetically. Let such consideration be made on the
representation of the petitioner within a period of 6(six)
weeks from the date of receipt of the copy of this order.
[5]
After
said
order
was
passed
by
this
Court,
the
respondent No.8 rejected her representation by office order dated
30.09.2024 (Annexure-L of the writ petition). Purposefully, the
entire contents of the said office order are extracted hereunder:
OFFICE ORDER
Advertisement for recruitment of Constable (GD) in
Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs), SSF, Rifleman (GD)
in Assam Rifles and Sepoy in Narcotics Central Bureau
Examination, 2022 was published by Staff Selection
Commission (SSC), New Delhi vide advertisement No.
F.No. PPI01/11/2022 PP_1. As per para 8 of the
recruitment Notice, Smt. Mousumi Sen D/o Shri Swapan
Sen, Village:- North Jolaibari, P.O: Jolnibari, PS-
Baikhora, Sub Division:- Santir Bazar, District: South
Tripura, Tripura had filled up her application online being
Registration No.10002013616 on 29/11/2022 with a
declaration as quoted below:1. I have read the notice of the examination and
accept all the terms & conditions of the notice of the
examination.
2. I hereby declare that all statements made in this
application are true, complete and correct to the
best of my knowledge and belief. I understand that
in the event of any information being found
suppressed/false or incorrect or ineligibility being
detected before or after the examination, my
candidature/appointment is liable to be cancelled. I
am willing to serve anywhere in India.
3. I declare that the photograph uploaded in the
application form has been taken on or after the
stipulated dated.
4. I agree to authorize SSC to use my Aadhar data
for verification purpose.
2. She filled up her Date of Birth in the online application
form as 10/10/1999. Accordingly Roll No.5601011613
was allocated to her and admit card was issued by SSC.
She appeared in Computer Based Examination and
secured 57.44712 marks. She also qualified in Physical
Standard Test (PST) and Physical Efficiency Test (PET).
At the time of verification of the documents, her Date of
Birth was found mismatch. Accordingly her Rejection Slip
was issued on 02/08/2023 by the Presiding Officer of
DV/DME Board of CT(GD) Examination 2022. In this
regard provisions contained in para 19(9) of the Notice of
Examination is re-produced as under:"The candidates must write their name, date of
birth, father's name and mother's name as given in
the
matriculation
certificate
otherwise
their
candidature may be cancelled at the time of
Document Verification or as and when it comes into
the notice of the Commission.”
3. Aggrieved with the decision regarding rejection of her
candidature due to mismatch in Date of Birth she filed
WP(C) No.557/2023 before the Hon'ble High Court of
Tripura, Agartala on 29/08/2023, Hon'ble High Court of
Tripura, Agartala passed the orders on the matter on
06/09/2023. The operative part of the order is as under:"It, therefore, appears to the Court that the
respondents should consider the representation of
the petitioner in accordance with law taking into
account the fact that the educational certificate and
all other certificates named above showing date of
birth entry do not have a mismatch except that the
mismatch is in the month of date of birth entry i.e.
October (10-10-99) instead of July (10-07-99] in
her online application. It also need to be kept in
mind that such candidates belongs to interior areas
of states like Tripura in the north eastern region and
may not have the proper assistance in submission of
such online applications invited by the recruiting
agencies. In case the respondents are satisfied that
the error in the month of her date of birth entry in
the online application is inadvertent and otherwise
all admissible documents such as educational
certificates of Madhyamik Examination, PRTC,
Aadhaar Card, etc. show the same correct date of
birth
i.e.
10.07.1999,
the
competent
authority/respondent No. 5 should consider her
sympathetically. Let such consideration be made on
the representation of the petitioner within a period
of 6 (Six) weeks from the date of receipt of the copy
of this order.
4.
As stated in the WP(C) No, 557/2023 filed by
Smt. Mousumi Sen she had sent an application on
11/08/2023 through E-mail to the Secretary, SSC Board,
Block No.12, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi110003. As stated in the said petition she also sent an
application dated 21/08/2023 to the DG, CRPF, G.S.
Road, 9 Mile, CRPF, Amerigog, Guwahati, Assam stating
that she mistakenly entered her date of birth as
10/10/1999 instead of 10/07/1999.
5. Alter enquiring the matter regarding the disposal
representation/application submitted by her outcome
emerged as under:
(i) RRC, GC, CRPF, Guwahati, 9th Mile, Guwahati vide
their office Signal No. R.II 1/2023-RRC-Gty dated
27/07/2024 intimated that application of candidate
addressed to DG, CRPF, Guwahati not received by
their office.
(ii) SSC HQ New Delhi vide letter No. HQPP106/7/2023-PP_1 (E-7455) dated 27/08/2024
has intimated to draw attention to Para 8.6 and Para
19(14) of the Notice of the Examination which reads
as follows:“Before
submission
of
the
final
online
application, candidates must check that they
have filled the correct details in each field of the
form. After submission of the final Online
Application
Form,
no
change/correction/modification will be allowed
under any circumstances. Requests received in
this regard in any form like Post. Fax, E-mail, by
hand etc. shall not be entertained by the
Commission and will be summarily rejected".
6.
Thus candidature of Smt. Mousumi Sen (Roll
No.5601011613) rejected rightly in consonance with the
existing instructions and rules as per the Advertisement
Notice
F.No.PPI01/11/2022-PP_1
issued
by
GOI,
Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pension,
DoPT, SSC, Block No. 12. CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New
Delhi-110003.
[6]
Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that the petitioner thereafter filed one contempt petition
before this Court for non-compliance of the direction of this Court
passed in the earlier writ petition, and the said contempt case
bearing No. Cont. Cas (C) No.44 of 2024 was disposed of by this
Court on 04.10.2024 with the following observations:
[5] This Court upon consideration of rival submissions of
the parties and after going through the affidavit in
opposition is of the considered view that the respondents
have issued an office order rejecting the candidature of
the petitioner on certain grounds. The merits of the
rejection order cannot be gone into in contempt
jurisdiction.
[6] Accordingly, the instant petition is disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed
of. Petitioner may have liberty to assail the order in an
appropriate proceeding.
[7]
According to Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel, in terms
of the order of the said contempt case, the present writ petition is
filed. Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel also strenuously argues
that despite the specific order passed by the High Court in the said
case, directing the respondents to consider whether such mistake
in the month of the petitioner’s date of birth in the online
application was inadvertent or not. The same was not at all
considered by the respondents, notwithstanding the fact that the
Court
specifically
respondent
No.5,
directed
to
the
consider
competent
the
case
authorities,
of
the
the
petitioner
sympathetically. Ms. Purkayastha, learned counsel, therefore, urges
the Court to cancel the said merit list, and direct the respondents
to provide the petitioner a job for the post of constable (GD
female). Learned counsel also urges for quashing the said office
order dated 30.09.2024 issued by the respondent No.8.
[8]
Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI appearing for the
respondents however, emphatically submits that the representation
of the petitioner was rejected by the respondent No.8 by an
exhaustive and reasoned order and therefore, no interference is
required in this regard. Learned Dy. SGI also submits that as per
the said terms and conditions of the advertisement, the petitioner
was under obligation to write her name, date of birth and fathers
name etc. as given in the matriculation certificate, otherwise the
same would be cancelled at the time of document verification or as
and when it came to the notice of the commission but despite the
same, there has been mismatch between the date of birth as
mentioned in her personal documents and also in her online
application and therefore, her candidature was rightly rejected by
the respondents. In this regard, learned Dy. SGI also relies on a
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in a case of Yogesh Kumar and
others vs. Govt. of NCT, Delhi and others, (2003) 3 SCC 548,
wherein at Para-8 it was observed that recruitment to public
services should be held strictly in accordance with the terms of
advertisement and the recruitment rules, if any, as deviation
therefrom the rules allows entry to ineligible persons and deprives
many other who could have competed for the post.
[9]
In that case, the petitioner contended that in the related
advertisement for recruitment, in Clause B (ii), the criteria
mentioned was one year’s teachers training certificate from a
recognised institution but, as such certificate was not granted
anywhere, the petitioner claimed that the aforesaid qualification
should be treated to be to mean to indicate BEd degree which is
also a one-year teacher’s training course after graduation. In that
contexts, such observation was made by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court.
[10]
Mr. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI further refers another
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in a case of Bedanga Talukdar
vs. Saifudaullah Khan and others, (2011) 12 SCC 85, wherein
it was observed that the selection process has to be conducted
strictly in accordance with the stipulated selection procedure and
consequently, when a particular schedule is mentioned in an
advertisement, the same has to be scrupulously maintained and
there cannot be any relaxation in terms and conditions of the
advertisement unless such power is specifically reserved.
[11]
Lastly, Mr. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI relies another
decision of Delhi High Court in a case of Rohit Kumar and
another vs. Union of India and others, 2022 SCC OnLine
Delhi 1219. The relevant Paragraph No.17 is extracted hereunder:
17. We are of the judicial opinion that the conditions
imposed by the respondents for recruitment to the post
of Navik (DB) as per clauses 5(c)(i) which provides that
all the information provided in the online application has
to match with all the original documents including caste
certificate and any inconsistency in the documents and
application including caste certificate will lead to failure
in document verification and the candidature will be
cancelled and Clause 6(c)(v) Note (aaa) which provides
that OBC(Non creamy layer) Certificate of candidates
should be as per the format for appointment for post
under the Govt. of India and any other format would lead
to cancellation of candidature and format of OBC
(Non Creamy) are cannot be regarded as unreasonable
and arbitrary. The Advertisement does not prescribe any
relaxation from prescribed conditions. These conditions
were well in knowledge of petitioner when he submitted
online application for post of Navik (DB). The format of
OBC (Non-Creamy Layer) certificate was also available on
website of Indian Coast Guard. The petitioner has not
submitted OBC certificate in the format as prescribed and
provided in the Advertisement. The petitioner also did
not mention date of issuance of OBC Certificate as per
requirement
of
Advertisement.
These
were
the
mandatory conditions which the petitioner was required
to comply with but has failed to comply with at the time
of online submission of the application for the post of
Navik (DB) and in subsequent selection process. These
conditions were equally applicable to all potential
candidates without any discrimination and favoritism.
The petitioner did not challenge original advertisement
and also participated in selection process. The
respondents also considered the representation dated
30.11.2021 and as such the petitioner was given due
opportunity of being heard.
[12]
In that case, the petitioner’s candidatures was rejected
on that ground that he did not submit the OBC certificate in the
format as prescribed and provided in the advertisement.
[13]
Keeping in mind, the submissions made by the learned
counsel of both sides and also on perusal of the records, it appears
that the contention of the present respondents regarding violation
of Clause-8.6 of the advertisement by the petitioner was dealt with
by the Court in said previous litigation and after considering all
aspects, this Court directed the respondents to consider the
representation of the petitioner in accordance with law taking into
consideration the fact that educational certificate and all other
certificates named in the earlier or the judgment showing the date
of birth entry, did not have a mismatched except the mismatch in
the month of the date of birth of the entry i.e. October instead of
July in her online application. The Court also emphasised the fact
that the petitioner belongs to interior areas of States like Tripura in
the North-eastern region and might not have the proper assistance
in submission of such online applications. Therefore, the Court
directed
the
respondents
to
examine
whether
the
error
in
mentioning the month of her date of birth in the online application
was inadvertent or and also examine the case of the petitioner and
in case the respondents are satisfied that the error in the month of
her date of birth entry in the online application was inadvertent and
otherwise, all admissible documents, such as educational certificate
of Madhyamik Examination, PRTC, Aadhar Card etc. showed the
correct date of birth i.e. 10.07.1999, in that case the competent
authority, the respondent No.5,
petitioner
sympathetically.
should consider the case of the
But
what
appears
from
the
correspondence made through said office order dated 30.09.2024
that the respondent No.8 without giving least consideration to what
the Court directed, has rejected the candidature of the petitioner
referring to
Clause 8.6 and Clause 19(14) of the advertisement
that before filing of the application the candidates must check that
they have filled up the correct details in each field of the form and
after
submission
of
online
change/correction/modification
would
application
form,
no
be
under
any
allowed
circumstances.
[14]
When the Court taking note of all factors as well as the
terms and conditions of the said recruitment procedure, has given a
specific direction, to consider the case of the petitioner, on a
different perspective, the respondents have no authority to reject
the candidature of the petitioner assigning a different reason. The
respondents cannot sit over the decision of the Court and decide
the matter in another form deviating from what the Court has
asked them to do. Consequently, the office order dated 30.09.2024
issued by the respondent No.8 is quashed. The respondent No.5 is
again directed to strictly comply with the direction of the Court’s
order dated 06.09.2023 passed by the Coordinate Bench of this
Court in W.P.(C) No.557 of 2023 in letter and spirit.
[15]
Rejection of the candidature of the petitioner on any
other grounds without following the directions passed in said
W.P.(C) No.557 of 2023 on 06.09.2023 or passed by this Court in
the present judgment, may be interpreted as a deliberate violation
of the Court’s order.
With such observation and direction, the writ petition
stands allowed and disposed of.
Interim application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2025.08.22 16:27:40 +05'30'
Sujay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review