Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WP(C) No.346 of 2024
Smt. Minati Das, aged about 55 years, wife of Bimal Chandra Das,
residents of Bolananda Palli, near Kali Bari, Barjala, Agartala, P.OKunjaban Kathal Bagan, P.S- NCC Police Station, District- West Tripura,
Pin-799006.
...... Petitioner(s)
VERSUS
(i) The State of Tripura, to be represented by Secretary Department of
Home, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New Capital
Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
(ii) The Secretary, Finance Department, Government of Tripura, New
Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala, West
Tripura, Pin-799010.
(iii) The Secretary, Health & Family Welfare Department, Government of
Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
(iv) The Director General of Police, Tripura Police Head Quarter, Akhaura
Road, Joynagar, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
(v) The Assistant Inspector General of Police, Tripura Police Head Quarter,
Akhaura Road, Joynagar, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799010.
(vi) Principal/Chairman, Tripura Standing Medical Board, AGMC & GBP
Hospital, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799006.
..…. Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate,
Mr. Dipjoyti Paul, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of Judgment & Order : 11th July, 2024.
Whether Fit for Reporting : YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. Kawsik Nath, learned counsel and Mr. Dipjoyti Paul, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. Mangal Debbarma, learned
Additional Government Advocate appearing for the State-respondents.
[2]
The order dated 17.05.2024 in essence encapsulates the case
of the petitioner and is therefore reproduced hereunder :
“Petitioner was initially referred to the ILS Hospitals, Agartala on 08.09.2021 by
the State Referral Board, AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala for further
investigation and treatment vide Annexure-2. However, ILS Hospitals, Agartala
referred her to Higher Centre vide Annexure-3 dated 18.09.2021 making the
following observations:
“Course of Treatment in Hospital : 49 years old female was initially having
sudden onset of reduce responsiveness followed by vomiting headache & double
vision. She was initially treated in GBP hospital and diagnosed as a case of
subarachnoid hemorrhage. Thereafter she was referred to ILS hospital for further
management. Upon receiving in SICU her GCS was found to the E4V5M6 and
conservative treatment was started. She was diagnosed as Angio negative SAH
Fisher grade 4. She was kept in SICU under observation and physiotherapy was
started. She was started on “HHH” regiment and oral NIMODIPINE. Serial
NCCT Brain were done and it showed resolving SAH & No hydrocephalus. She
was discharged on 15/09/2021. But in the hospital, on the day of discharge she
developed acute onset right side hemiplegia and aphasia. MRI Brain (Plain)
showed ischaemia involving caudate nucleus, multiple small regions in frontal
lobe s/o vasospastic event. Presently she is able tp verbalise, right UL power 3/5,
right LL power 1/5. Since no endovascular facility is available here, referring to
higher centre for further management.”
Petitioner was airlifted for treatment to the Institute of Neurosciences, Kolkata.
She was discharged after treatment on 05.10.2021 by the Institute of
Neurosciences, Kolkata. Her claim for medical reimbursement for treatment at
ILS Hospitals, Agartala for an amount of Rs.96,293/- has been allowed by the
department, but the remaining bills for treatment at Institute of Neurosciences,
Kolkata has been regretted as there was no referral to a Higher Centre outside the
State by the State Referral Board. Therefore, petitioner has approached this
Court.
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Additional Government Advocate for the respondentsState, submits that apparently the claim has been regretted as there was no
referral for treatment outside the State by the State Referral Board as per the
scheme for medical reimbursement under the State Government.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that since ILS Hospitals,
Agartala did not have the facility to treat her condition and precious time would
have been lost in seeking referral from the State Referral Board, petitioner was
airlifted to the Institute of Neurosciences, Kolkata for proper treatment.
Fortunately, she survived the ordeal and was discharged. In cases of such
emergency, requirement of a prior referral from the State Referral Board may
sometimes prove to be counterproductive and fatal, as it is ultimately the human
life which has to be saved. Emergency treatment such as this warrants no delay.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance upon a decision
dated 04.05.2018 in the case of Sri Uttam Pal v. The State of Tripura & others
passed in WP(C) No.1479 of 2017 [Annexure-8] wherein this Court has held that
the requirement of referral by the State Medical Board is directory in nature. As
such, respondents ought to have examined the case of the petitioner in that light
and allow the claim.
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Additional Government Advocate for the respondentsState, is therefore allowed to seek instructions whether it is possible for the
department to place the case of the petitioner before the State Referral Board for
post-facto approval of her treatment outside the State in the facts and
circumstances narrated above.
Accordingly, matter be listed on 21.06.2024.”
[3]
Counter-affidavit has been filed by the respondents wherein
the following stand has been taken :
“4. That, in reply to para 1 and 1.2 of the writ petition, I say that it is admitted
fact that the petitioner has been paid vide Bill No.706/MR/NGOS/PHQ/2022
dated 05.03.2022 for an amount of Rs.96,293/- as M.R bill claim in connection
with her treatment at GBP Hospital and ILS Hospital Agartala from 06.09.2021
to 18.09.2021. Copy of vide Bill No. 706/MR/NGOS/PHQ/2022 dated
05.03.2022 is annexed herewith and marked as Annexure-R/1.
5. That, in reply to para 4 of the writ petition, I say that as per record, the
petitioner was admitted in ILS Hospital on 06.09.2021 and discharged on
15.09.2021 from ILS Hospital, Agartala as referred by the Standing Medical
Board of AGMC & GBP Hospital.
It also appears from the Annexure No.3 to the writ petition, that the petitioner
was admitted again in ILS Hospital Agartala on 15.09.2021 afternoon without
referred by the Standing Medical Board and discharged on 18.09.2021 from
which she has been referred to higher centre for further management/treatment by
the ILS Hospital. However, her treatment expenditure incurred by the petitioner
at GBP Hospital and ILS Hospital Agartala from 06.09.2021 to 18.09.2021 has
been paid on 05.03.2022 and thereby the MR bill as referred by the Standing
Medical Board was completed. Copy of the discharged certificate dated
15.09.2021 is annexed herewith and marked as Annexure-R/2.
6. That, in reply to para 6 & 7 of the writ petition, I say that the petitioner after
discharged from ILS Hospital on 18.09.2021 she never intimated the authority for
her further treatment outside the State and referred by the ILS Hospital, Agartala.
Thereafter, the petitioner submitted a fresh MR Bill for Rs.11,71,180/- in
connection with her treatment at the institute of Neurosciences Kolkata with
effect from 18.09.2021 to 05.10.2021. The same was forwarded to Home
Department vide PHQ letter dated 06.04.2022 (Annexure-5 to the writ petition)
for Administrative approval and sanction which was regretted by Government of
Tripura (Home/Finance) vide their letter dated 13.05.2022 on the ground that the
treatment of the petitioner was done outside the State without referral from the
State Medical Board (Annexure-6 to the writ petition).
It is pertinent to mention here that as per latest medical reimbursement policy of
the State Government vide memo dated 22.12.2022 (Annexure-4 to the writ
petition) the ex-post facto approval may be allowed for medical reimbursement to
Group-A & B of the State Government employee without referral from the State
Medical Board subject to condition that in case of emergency or acute illness
arising while the Government servant is staying outside the State with station
leave permission. In the instant case, there is no scope to consider under ex-post
facto approval of the Government.
7. That, in reply to para 8 to 10 of the writ petition, I say that there is no
indication in the relevant record/papers of the instant M.R bill that the treatment
of the petitioner was undertaken at Institute of Neurosciences Kolkata as the case
of emergency/acute illness.”
[4]
The fact relating to the treatment of the petitioner, a Group-B
employee, posted as Office Superintendent in the Police Headquarters at
Agartala, West Tripura and her referral to the ILS Hospital, Agartala on
08.09.2021 by the State Referral Board, AGMC & GBP Hospital,
Agartala for treatment vide Annexure-2 is not in dispute. The fact that she
was treated there and discharged on 15.09.2021 and again admitted on
15.09.2021 for serious complications is also not in dispute. The fact that
on 18.09.2021 she was discharged by the ILS Hospital, Agartala and
referred to higher centre for further management/treatment by the ILS
Hospital and that she was airlifted to the Institute of Neurosciences,
Kolkata and admitted there on 18.09.2021 is also not in dispute. The fact
that she survived after her treatment at Institute of Neurosciences, Kolkata
and was discharged on 05.10.2021 from the said Institute is also not in
dispute. The fact that the medical bills of Rs.96,293/- in connection with
her treatment at GBP Hospital and ILS Hospital, Agartala from
06.09.2021 to 18.09.2021 have been reimbursed by the department is also
not in dispute. What is disputed is reimbursement of medical bills of the
petitioner for her treatment at Institute of Neurosciences, Kolkata between
18.09.2021 to 05.10.2021.
[5]
The reasons for regretting her claims are said to be based
upon medical reimbursement policy of the State Government contained in
memorandum dated 22.12.2022. According to the respondents, ex-post
facto approval may be allowed for medical reimbursement to Group-A &
B employee of the State Government without referral from the State
Medical Board subject to the condition that in case of emergency or acute
illness arising while the government servant is staying outside the State
with Station leave permission. According to the respondents, in the
present case, there is no indication from the relevant records of the
medical reimbursement bills that the treatment of the petitioner was
undertaken at Institute of Neurosciences, Kolkata as the case was of
emergency/acute illness. This stand is categorically reflected at paragraph
7 of their counter-affidavit in reply to paragraph 8 to 10 of the writ
petition as has been extracted hereinabove.
[6]
The policy for medical reimbursement vide memorandum
dated 22.12.2022 (Annexure-4) deals with such a contingency is usefully
extracted hereunder :
“Government of Tripura
Health & Family Welfare Department
No. F.2(10-43A)-DHS/ESTT/MR/2022
Dated 22.12.2022
MEMORANDUM
Subject :- Re-imbursement facility to the State Government employees of medical
expenditure incurred by the employees for treatment inside/outside the State.
With a view to simplify and streamline the operational guidelines of medical reimbursement facility for the eligible State Government employees, the Council of
Minister’s has examined the existing provision and in supersession/partial
modification of all existing guidelines as follows :
The Governor, Tripura is pleased to lay down following guidelines with regards to
admissibility of medical expenses to State Government Officials inside/outside the
State.
(a) Group-A and Group-B officials of the State Government employees and their
dependent family members when referred by the Standing Medical Board to a
particular listed referral institution/hospital as Annexed (A) for medical treatment but
undertakes the treatment at some other Institution/Hospital of his/her own
choice/volition, he/she shall be entitled to get reimbursement for
treatment/investigations(s) undertaken at the rates of their referred institution
including journey expenses for the purpose as existing T.A. Rules.
(b) Medical reimbursement expenses to Group-A and Group-B of the State
Government employees and their dependent family members may avail treatment in
any enlisted referral hospital inside/outside the State approved by the State
Government without referral of the Standing Medical Board subject to condition that
ex-post facto approval shall be given only in case of emergency or acute illness arising
while govt. servant is staying outside the State with station leave permission. In such
case a certificate stating the emergency status and ICD diagnosis has to be obtained
from the treating hospital. If treatment is undertaken in any such hospital
reimbursement would be at CGHS rate.
(c) The dependent family members of State Government Group-A & B employees
who are not residing with the concerned government employees due to staying outside
the State and require medical treatment in any health institution, will be eligible to get
reimbursement of treatment expenses at latest CGHS rates.
(d) Group-C & D officials of the State Government employees when referred by the
Standing Medical Board to a particular listed referral institution/hospital for medical
treatment but undertakes the treatment at some other Institution/Hospital of his/her
own choice/volition, he/she shall be entitled to get reimbursement for
treatment/investigation(s) undertaken at the rates of their referred institution including
journey expenses for the purpose of existing T.A. Rules.
(e) Medical reimbursement expenses to Group-C & D of the State Government
employees himself/herself or any member of his/her family suffers from cancer and is
referred to a particular medical institution/hospital outside the State on being referred
by the State Standing Medical Board, Government of Tripura but undertakes the
treatment at some other Institution/Hospital of his/her own choice/volition, he/she
shall be entitled to get reimbursement for treatment/investigation(s) undertaken at the
rates of their referred institution including journey expenses for the purpose as existing
T.A. Rules.
(f) In case of all categories of the State Government employee (Group-A, B, C and D),
while being outside the State in connection with official works/for his own duty, with
station leave permission where he/she fell ill and requires medical treatment in any
health institutions, will be eligible to get reimbursement of treatment expenses at latest
CGHS rates subject to condition that it is applicable in acute emergency cases like
chest pain, cardiac failure, brain stroke, trauma and head injury and 1st time cancer
etc.
(g) The reimbursement facility to all categories of the State government employees
(Group-A, B, C and D) for implanting of Pacemaker shall continue to be admissible,
subject to limit therein vide Finance Department Memo No.F.30(1)-FIN(G)/2009,
dated 12.05.2009 and in continuation of this Deptt. Memo No.F.5(2)-FIN(G)/93, dated
24th May, 1997.
(h) The State Government employees who are posted in Tripura Bhavan at Guwahati,
Kolkata and New Delhi and require medical treatment for his/her own in any health
institution, will be eligible to get reimbursement of treatment expenses at latest CGHS
rates and dependent family members of Group-A & B employees, require medical
treatment in any health institution, will be eligible to get reimbursement of treatment
expenses at latest CGHS rates or any hospital of choice whichever less.
(i) Reimbursement of cost of medical expenses of pensioners and spouse referred by
the Standing Medical Board, Government of Tripura for treatment outside the State
once in 5(five) years subject to ceiling of Rs.50,000/- Rupees Fifty Thousand). The
other terms & conditions of the original OM No. F.8(3)-FIN(G)/88, dated 25th June,
1991 shall remain unchanged.
(j) The empanelment of referral hospitals outside the State from time to time approved
by the Government is Annexed (A).
(k) Finance Department, Government of Tripura has concurred the proposal of the
Department vide U.O. No.170-FIN (EXPDT-II)/2022 dated 21.11.2022. The Council
of Ministers approved the proposal of the department, dated 03.12.2022. This order
shall take with immediate effect.
By order of the Governor
SD/(D. Basu)
Secretary to the Government of Tripura”
[7]
The State Government has framed the policy for medical
reimbursement to its employees for different classes which is in the nature
of a social security measure to the employee and/or his dependents in case
of medical treatment in lieu of the services rendered by the employee to
the State. Paragraph-b of the scheme extracted above contemplates ex-
post facto approval in case of emergency or acute illness arising while the
government servant is staying outside the State with station leave
permission. In such a case a certificate stating the emergency status and
ICD diagnosis has to be obtained from the treating hospital. If treatment is
undertaken in any such hospital reimbursement would be at CGHS rate.
[8]
The facts of the instant case are stark and cannot be
overlooked. Petitioner, a Group-B employee, was treated at ILS Hospital,
Agartala between 08.09.2021 to 18.09.2021 on the reference made by the
State Referral Board, AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala. The
observations of the ILS Hospital, Agartala at the time of her discharge on
18.09.2021 (Annexure-3) which has been quoted in the foregoing part of
this order depict the acute state of emergency in which she was referred
for treatment at a higher centre as ILS Hospital, Agartala did not have the
facility. The observations of the medical team of ILS Hospital, Agartala
for her reference to higher centre even from a layman’s point of view
indicates that because of her acute conditions she was somehow kept
stable but no endovascular facility was available there for further
treatment and management. Such was the exigency that she had to be
airlifted to Institute of Neurosciences, Kolkata on the same day where she
was admitted. She fortunately survived the ordeal and has come back
alive to serve the department. She is only 49 years of age and has more
than 10 years to serve the State Government. One can only imagine if she
was not airlifted for treatment to the Institute of Neurosciences, Kolkata
on the advice of the medical experts at ILS Hospital, Agartala where she
was being treated on reference by the State Referral Board, whether she
could have survived. A precious life may have been lost in the process
and the State would have also lost the services of a competent employee
for more than 10 years. Such was her state that her airlifting for treatment
at a higher centre in Kolkata brooked no delay seeking further approval
from the State Referral Board for treatment outside the State. If this could
not be an emergency what else could be.
[9]
The policy of medical reimbursement framed by the State
Government is a social welfare measure in the nature of a beneficial
subordinate legislation. If the very purpose of the scheme is defeated by
such mechanical and myopic approach of the authorities of the concerned
department, the whole purpose of such a beneficial scheme would be
defeated. The respondents seem to have adopted a very mechanical and
insensitive approach in rejecting the claim of medical reimbursement of
the petitioner for treatment undertaken at Institute of Neurosciences
Kolkata by stating that there is no indication in the relevant records/papers
that it was a case of emergency or acute illness. The decision can
therefore be said to be irrational in the light of the Wednesbury principles
of reasonableness.
[10]
The judgment in case of Tata Cellular versus Union of
India, reported in (1994) 6 SCC 651, the Apex Court has expatiated on
the meaning of the expression irrationality. Irrationality which could be
referred to as “Wednesbury unreasonableness” applies to a decision which
is so outrageous in its defiance of logic or of accepted moral standards
that no sensible person who had applied his mind to the question to be
decided could have arrived at. The relevant part of paragraph 79 of the
judgment is extracted hereunder :
“79. ………………………
This summary by Lord Greene has been applied in countless subsequent cases.
"The modern statement of the principle is found in a passage in the speech of Lord
Diplock in Council of Civil Service Unions v. Minister for Civil Service19:
'By "irrationality" I mean what can now be succinctly referred to as "Wednesbury
unreasonableness". (Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd. v. Wednesbury
Corpn.31) It applies to a decision which is so outrageous in its defiance of logic or
of accepted moral standards that no sensible person who had applied his mind to
the question to be decided could have arrived at.' "
[11]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel for the petitioner
has rightly placed reliance upon paragraph 13 of the judgment rendered by
the Apex Court in case of Shiva Kant Jha versus Union of India in
WP(C) No.694 of 2015 dated 13.04.2018. Paragraph 13 of the judgment is
quoted hereunder :
13) It is a settled legal position that the Government employee during his life
time or after his retirement is entitled to get the benefit of the medical facilities
and no fetters can be placed on his rights. It is acceptable to common sense, that
ultimate decision as to how a patient should be treated vests only with the Doctor,
who is well versed and expert both on academic qualification and experience
gained. Very little scope is left to the patient or his relative to decide as to the
manner in which the ailment should be treated. Speciality Hospitals are
established for treatment of specified ailments and services of Doctors specialized
in a discipline are availed by patients only to ensure proper, required and safe
treatment. Can it be said that taking treatment in Speciality Hospital by itself
would deprive a person to claim reimbursement solely on the ground that the said
Hospital is not included in the Government Order. The right to medical claim
cannot be denied merely because the name of the hospital is not included in the
Government Order. The real test must be the factum of treatment. Before any
medical claim is honoured, the authorities are bound to ensure as to whether the
claimant had actually taken treatment and the factum of treatment is supported by
records duly certified by Doctors/Hospitals concerned. Once, it is established, the
claim cannot be denied on technical grounds. Clearly, in the present case, by
taking a very inhuman approach, the officials of the CGHS have denied the grant
of medical reimbursement in full to the petitioner forcing him to approach this
Court.
[12]
Therefore, judging both from point of view of the beneficial
nature of policy of the medical reimbursement of the State Government
dated 22.12.2022 which is a social welfare legislation and also on the test
of “Wednesbury reasonableness” the impugned decision dated 13.05.2022
contained in Annexure-6 regretting the claim for medical reimbursement
bills of the petitioner for her treatment at Institute of Neurosciences,
Kolkata for an amount of Rs.11,71,180/- as not admissible being
undertaken without reference by the State Standing Medical Board is
unsustainable in law and on facts and fit to be set aside. It is accordingly
set aside. In view of the discussion made and the reasons recorded
hereinabove, the respondent-department is directed to reimburse the
admissible bills of the petitioner for treatment at the Institute of
Neurosciences, Kolkata, after granting post-facto approval, in accordance
with law, within a period of 6(six) weeks from the date of receipt of copy
of this judgment.
[13]
The writ petition is allowed and disposed of with the
aforesaid observations and direction.
Pending application(s), if any, also disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH) CJ
DIPESH DEB
Date: 2024.07.18 16:01:19 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review