Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.757 of 2024
Smt. Mela Rani Noatia,
D/O- Sri Binoy Krishna Noatia of vill and P.O- Garjee, Gomati
Tripura.
-----Petitioner(s)
Versus
1.The Union of India,
represented by the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of
India.
2.The Under Secretary,
Staff Selection Commission, Block No.12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, Near JLN Stadium, New Delhi, Delhi- 110091.
3.Staff Selection Commission,
represented by Chairman, Block No.12, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, Near JLN stadium, New Delhi, Delhi- 110091.
4.North Eastern Regional Office,
Staff Selection Commission, Gauhati, represented by Regional
Director, Housefed Complex, West End Block, Last Gate- Basistha
Road, P.O- Assam Sachivalaya, Dispur, Gauhati- 781006.
5.Director General, CRPF (Central Reserve Police Force),
(Recruitment Branch) East Block-07, Level-4, Sector-01, R.K
Puram, New Delhi- 110066, (Ministry of Home Affairs).
6.Detail Medical Examination Board,
represented by the Presiding Officer, the Commandant, IRLA5456, 140 BN, Presiding Officer, DV/DME, RECTT. Board, GC
CRPF, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin – 799101.
….Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. R. Purkayastha, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. S.G.I.
Date of Hearing
:
07th August, 2025.
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
20th September, 2025.
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
No
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
J_U_D_G_M_E_N_T
&
O_R_D_E_R
One
advertisement
was
issued
on
24.11.2023
(Annexure-A) for the appointment of constable (GD) in Central
Armed Police Forces (CAPFs), SSF and Rifleman (GD) in Assam
Rifles Examination to be conducted through Staff Selection
Commission. The Petitioner, being an aspirant for the post of
constable (GD), applied for the same. As per the advertisement,
the entire selection process was divided into 5 phases; firstly
Computer Based Examination (CBE), then Physical Standard Test
(PST), thereafter Physical Efficiency Test (PET), then Medical
Examination and finally, Document Verification.
[2]
Ld. Counsel appearing for the petitioner, Ms. R.
Purkayastha submits that Physical Standard Test and Physical
Efficiency Test were combined in a single test. According to the
petitioner, she qualified for all the tests but at the time of
document verification, she was excluded from selection on the
ground that in her online application she had mentioned the
name of her district to be Gomati, whereas in her Permanent
Resident Tripura Certificate (for short-‘PRTC’), the name of her
district was mentioned as South Tripura. As the said document
did not match with her address, more particularly with reference
to the name of her district, as given in her application form, her
candidature was rejected. However, before such rejection, she
was allowed 4 days time to produce the original domicile
certificate of Tripura which matches with her address as
furnished in her online application form. Ld. Counsel, Ms.
Purkayastha also submits that within the said 4 days, the
petitioner could not get necessary correction of the name of the
district in her PRTC, but subsequently she got it on 17.10.2024
(Annexure-G) and tried to submit the same but she was refused.
In fact, it was not a correction of her original certificate, rather as
it appears, a fresh certificate was issued to her mentioning the
name of her district to be ‘Gomati’.
[3]
She, thereafter, sent a mail to the appropriate
authority of the respondents annexing said corrected PRTC and
also on the same date, sent a notice to the respondents
(Annexure-H) but getting no response, she thereafter filed the
present writ petition.
[4]
Ld. Counsel, Ms. R. Purkayastha, strongly argues that
originally the name of the district of the petitioner was South
Tripura, wherein her village ‘Garjee’ was situated, but later on,
due to bifurcation of the district by State Government,
a new
district was created, namely Gomati District and for that reason,
said village ‘Garjee’ now falls within Gomati and therefore, when
PRTC was issued in the name of the petitioner, it was showing
the name of the district to be South Tripura, but when she
applied for the post, she mentioned in her application form, the
present name of her district to be ‘Gomati’. According to Ld.
Counsel Ms. Purkayastha, the petitioner had no fault in this
regard in mentioning the name of her district in the application
form and moreover, as per the Advertisement Notice, the
vacancies were supposed to be filled up state-wise as a whole
and not District-wise. In addition, according to her, the vacancies
earmarked for Border Guarding Districts/Militancy/ Naxal affected
Districts are also supposed to be filled up in tune with the said
Advertisement
Notice(Annexure-A)
and
as
per
the
said
advertisement (Annexure-A), all the eight districts of Tripura
including Gomati are earmarked as Border Guarding Districts and
also as Militancy affected Districts and more so, the petitioner
applied against both State category quota as well as against
Border
Guarding
District/Naxal
affected
Districts
quota.
Therefore, even a change in the name of the district in her
application form would not have any bearing on the selection
process. Ld. Counsel continues to submit that apart from the
quota of Border Guarding Districts or Militancy/Naxal affected
Districts, even under
the State
category quota
also, the
petitioner is entitled to be selected since all the Districts of
Tripura are also covered within the State category quota.
[5]
One additional affidavit is also submitted by the
petitioner asserting that under the State category quota, there
were 9 vacant posts for Scheduled Castes (ST) category
candidates and similarly, there were further 9 vacant posts under
Border Guarding quota for ST candidates in the state of Tripura
and as per order of this Court passed in IA No.1 of 2024, one
post has already been kept vacant subject to decision of this
Court and therefore, there is no impediment now in giving effect
to the direction by this Court, if any, for providing a job to the
petitioner as a successful candidate.
[6]
The
petitioner
also
submitted
certain
documents
under Annexure-J as were annexed with the advertisement which
show that against the vacancy for constable(Female) under
Border Guarding quota in state of Tripura, total vacancy was 37
and vacancy for constable (Female) against Naxal affected area
in Tripura was NIL. The petitioner along with her said additional
affidavit also submitted a list of Border Guarding districts which
was annexed as Annexure-XI to the advertisement and it shows
that all the districts of Tripura are marked as Border Guarding
districts and similarly, all the districts of Tripura are also marked
as
Militancy/
Naxal
affected
districts.
Ld.
Counsel,
Ms.
Purkayastha, in this context, submits that the change in the
name of district in the domicile certificate being a very technical
issue, will not cast any bearing on the candidature of candidate,
inasmuch as for her selection against State category quota, the
only requirement is to submit the domicile certificate of that
particular state which was complied by the petitioner and
regarding
both
Border
Guarding
District
quota
and
Militancy/Naxal affected District quota, all the districts of Tripura
are covered by said two categories. Therefore, according to Ld.
Counsel, the difference or mismatch in the name of the district in
domicile certificate had no bearing on the matter of selection of
candidates from Tripura.
[7]
Ld. Counsel, Ms. Purkayastha, relies on a decision of
this Court in Shri Arpan Chowdhury Vs. Union of India and
Ors [WP(C)117 of 2021] decided on 07.12.2021 to buttress
her submission that under Article 226, the Court has jurisdiction
to interfere with such selection process. In that case, the Court
directed the respondents to adjust the petitioners against the
available vacancies or against the supernumerary vacancies to be
created according to the need, to save the services of the
persons who had secured less marks than the petitioners and got
selected. Interference with selection process, in that case, was
made by the Court on different grounds, unlike the present case
in hand.
[8]
Ld. Dy. S.G.I, Mr. Bidyut Majumder, strongly opposes
the contention of the petitioner submitting that there were
specific conditions incorporated in the advertisement that the
candidate should be very careful and must exercise due diligence
while providing information about domicile state and district in
the online application form, as no request for change of names of
domicile
state
and
district
would
be
entertained
by
the
Commission after submission of the application form under any
circumstances and if there is any variation of the name of the
district or the state mentioned by the candidate in the online
application form with the domicile certificate submitted by
him/her at the time of document verification, said candidature
will be cancelled forthwith.
[9]
Relying on the terms and conditions as embodied in
the advertisement, Ld. Dy. S.G.I submits that it was the duty of
the petitioner to be more careful while submitting the online form
and the documents in support of the same, so that there would
be no mismatch between these two. Therefore, in terms of the
advertisement, the selection committee was completely justified
in cancelling her candidature, after giving her an opportunity to
rectify the defect within four days by submitting the corrected
document.
[10]
Ld. Dy. S.G.I, Mr. Majumder, also submits that the
petitioner or any candidate cannot be allowed to submit anything
going beyond the cutoff date fixed for submission of the same
and the department or the selection committee has the full
authority to fix up such cutoff date.
[11]
In support his submissions, Ld. Dy. S.G.I relies on a
decision of the Apex Court in case of Ashok Kumar Sonkar Vs.
Union of India and Ors., (2007) 4 SCC 54 and the relevant
para 20 is extracted hereunder:
“……………………
Possession of requisite educational qualification is
mandatory. The same should not be uncertain. If an
uncertainty is allowed to prevail, the employer would
be flooded with applications of ineligible candidates. A
cut-off date for the purpose of determining the
eligibility of the candidates concerned must, therefore,
be fixed. In absence of any rule or any specific date
having been fixed in the Advertisement, the law,
therefore, as held by this Court would be the last date
for filing the application.”
[12]
Ld. Dy. S.G.I also refers another decision of the Apex
Court in Bedanga Talukdar Vs. Saifudaullah Khan and Ors.,
(2011) 12 SCC 85 to gain support for his submission that when
some stipulations in the advertisement are inscribed, there
cannot be any deviation there from, and the candidates are
required to scrupulously follow the same without any relaxation
in terms and conditions of the advertisement unless such a power
is specifically reserved. The relevant paragraph Nos. 29 and 30 of
the said decision are extracted herein below:
“29. We have considered the entire matter in detail.
In our opinion, it is too well settled to need any
further reiteration that all appointments to public
office have to be made in conformity with Article 14 of
the Constitution of India. In other words, there must
be no arbitrariness resulting from any undue favour
being shown to any candidate. Therefore, the
selection process has to be conducted strictly in
accordance with the stipulated selection procedure.
Consequently,
when
a
particular
schedule
is
mentioned in an Advertisement, the same has to be
scrupulously maintained. There cannot be any
relaxation in the terms and conditions of the
Advertisement unless such a power is specifically
reserved. Such a power could be reserved in the
relevant Statutory Rules. Even if power of relaxation is
provided in the rules, it must still be mentioned in the
Advertisement. In the absence of such power in the
Rules, it could still be provided in the Advertisement.
However, the power of relaxation, if exercised has to
be given due publicity. This would be necessary to
ensure that those candidates who become eligible due
to the relaxation, are afforded an equal opportunity to
apply and compete. Relaxation of any condition in
Advertisement without due publication would be
contrary to the mandate of equality contained in
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
30. A perusal of the Advertisement in this case will
clearly show that there was no power of relaxation. In
our opinion, the High Court committed an error in
directing that the condition with regard to the
submission of the disability certificate either along
with the application form or before appearing in the
preliminary examination could be relaxed in the case
of respondent No. 1. Such a course would not be
permissible as it would violate the mandate of Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.”
[13]
Ld. Dy. S.G.I further relies on a decision of Division
Bench of Delhi High Court in case of Rohit Kumar and Anr. Vs.
Union of India and Ors. [(2022) 3 HCC (Del) 525:2022 SCC
OnLine Del 1219]. In this case, there was non compliance of
conditions of the advertisement by the petitioner who did not
submit the OBC certificate as per the format as was published by
the recruiting authority in official website of the Indian Coast
Guard. Finally, declining any relief to the petitioner, Delhi High
Court observed as follows:
“17.We are of the judicial opinion that the conditions
imposed by the respondents for recruitment to the
post of Navik (DB) as per clauses 5(c)(i) which
provides that all the information provided in the online
application has to match with all the original
documents including caste certificate and any
inconsistency in the documents and
application
including caste certificate will lead to failure in
document verification and the candidature will be
cancelled and Clause 6(c)(v) Note (aaa) which
provides that OBC(Non creamy layer) Certificate of
candidates should be as per the format for
appointment for post under the Govt. of India and any
other format would lead to cancellation of candidature
and format of OBC (Non Creamy) are cannot be
regarded as unreasonable and arbitrary. The
Advertisement does not prescribe any relaxation from
prescribed conditions. These conditions were well in
knowledge of petitioner when he submitted online
application for post of Navik (DB). The format of OBC
(Non-Creamy Layer) certificate was also available on
website of Indian Coast Guard. The petitioner has not
submitted OBC certificate in the format as prescribed
and provided in the Advertisement. The petitioner also
did not mention date of issuance of OBC Certificate as
per requirement of Advertisement. These were the
mandatory conditions which the petitioner was
required to comply with but has failed to comply with
at the time of online submission of the application for
the post of Navik (DB) and in subsequent selection
process. These conditions were equally applicable to
all potential candidates without any discrimination
and favoritism. The petitioner did not challenge
original Advertisement and also participated in
selection process. The respondents also considered
the representation dated 30.11.2021 and as such the
petitioner was given due opportunity of being heard.”
[14]
Ld. Dy. S.G.I also relies on paragraph 8 of another
decision of the Apex Court in case of Yogesh Kumar and Ors.
Vs. Govt. of NCT, Delhi and Others, (2003) SCC 548. In this
case the petitioners had B.Ed qualification and they applied for
the post of Assistant Teachers but the professional qualification
as mentioned in the advertisement did not incorporate B.Ed
qualifications. In that context, the Apex Court observed that the
High Court had rightly come to the conclusion that B.Ed
qualification, although a well-recognized qualification in the field
of teaching and education - being not prescribed in the
advertisement, only some of the B.Ed candidates who took a
chance to apply for the post could not be given entry in the field
of selection. Further, in paragraph No.8, it was held that
recruitment to a public service should be strictly in accordance
with the terms of advertisement and the recruitment rules, if any
and deviation from the rules allows entry to ineligible persons
and deprives many others who would be competent for the posts.
The entire para 8 is extracted herein below:
“8. This last argument advanced also does not
impress us at all. Recruitment to Public Services
should be held strictly in accordance with the terms of
Advertisement and the recruitment rules, if any.
Deviation from the Rules allows entry to ineligible
persons and deprives many others who could have
competed for the post. Merely because in the past
some deviation and departure was made in
considering the B.Ed. candidates and we are told that
was so done because of the paucity of TTC candidates,
we cannot allow a patent illegality to continue. The
recruitment authorities were well aware that
candidates with qualification of TTC and B.Ed. are
available yet they chose to restrict entry for
appointment only to TTC pass candidates. It is open to
the recruiting authorities to evolve a policy of
recruitment and to decide the source from which the
recruitment is to be made. So far as B.Ed. qualification
is concerned, in the connected appeals [CA No. 172628 of 2001] arising from Kerala which are heard with
this appeal, we have already taken the view that B.Ed.
qualification cannot be treated as a qualification
higher than TTC because the natures of training
imparted for grant of certificate and degree are totally
different and between them there is no parity
whatsoever. It is projected before us that presently
more candidates available for recruitment to primary
school are from B.Ed. category and very few from TTC
category. Whether for the aforesaid reasons, B.Ed.
qualification can also be prescribed for primary
teachers is a question to be considered by the
authorities concerned but we cannot consider B.Ed.
candidates for the present vacancies advertised as
eligible. In our view, the division bench of the Delhi
High Court was fully justified in coming to the
conclusion that B.Ed. candidates were rightly excluded
by the authorities from selection and appointment as
primary teachers. We make it clear that we are not
called upon to express any opinion on any B.Ed.
Candidates appointed as primary teachers pursuant to
Advertisements in the past and our decision is
confined only to the Advertisement which was under
challenge before the High Court and in this appeal.”
[15]
Ld. Dy. S.G.I finally contends that in the writ petition
there is no allegation that the respondents have violated any
provision of the prescribed recruitment rules or any terms of the
advertisement and therefore, the writ petition deserves rejection.
[16]
On consideration of the contentions of both sides, it
appears
that
the
relevant
clauses
as
embodied
in
the
advertisement in this context require examination first, and as
such, they are extracted hereunder:
“3.3. As the vacancies in CAPFs have been earmarked
States/UT-wise, candidates are required to submit Domicile
/Permanent Residential Certificate of the State/UT indicated
by them in the online Application Form at the time of
DME/Documents Verification failing which their candidature
will be cancelled forthwith and they will not be allowed to
appear in the Detailed Medical Examination. If a candidate
produces Domicile/Permanent Resident Certificate (PRC)
issued by a State other than the State mentioned in his/her
application, he/she shall not be allowed to change the State
at the time of Document Verification and his/her
candidature shall be cancelled straightaway. Therefore,
Candidates should fill the Application Form very carefully.
4. Nationality/Citizenship: Candidate must be a citizen of
India. Vacancies in CAPFs & AR are State/UT/ area wise
hence a candidate must submit domicile/PRC against his
state/UT.
6.6. Candidates will be considered for recruitment in their
respective State/UT on production of valid “Domicile
/Permanent Residential Certificate(PRC)” issued by the
competent authority so authorized by the concerned
State/UT to prove their domiciliary status at the time of
Documents Verification(DV) failing which his candidature
will be cancelled forthwith. The Domicile/PRC certificate
must be of the State/UT indicated by the candidates in their
online Application Form, failing which, their candidature
will be cancelled forthwith.
8.6. Before submission of the online application, candidates
must check that they have filled correct details in each field
of the form.
10.1. After the closing date for receipt of online
applications, the Commission will provide a period of 3 days
to enable candidates to correct/ modify online application
parameters, wherein candidates will be allowed to resubmit applications after making requisite corrections/
changes in the one-time registration/ online application
data as per their requirement.
…………………………………………
10.9. Before submission of the corrected application,
candidates must check that they have filled correct details
in each field of the form. After expiry of 'Window for
Application
Form
Correction',
no
change/
correction/modification
will
be
allowed
under
any
circumstances. Requests received in this regard in any form
like Post, Fax, Email, by hand, etc. shall not be entertained
by the Commission and will be summarily rejected.
………………………
14.13 Candidates will be considered for the vacancies of a
State/UT and further for the vacancies of Border Guarding
Districts, Militancy/ Naxal affected Districts based on the
information provided by them in the online Application
Form and subsequent submission of relevant Domicile
Certificate at the time of DME/Document Verification.
Candidate may note that domicile district/ State filled by a
candidate in the specific column of application form will
only be considered as his/her domicile State/ district.
Domicile District/ State will not be considered/ determined
from the column/ box of Permanent/Correspondence
Address provided in the online application form.
14.14 Therefore, candidates should be very careful and
must exercise due diligence while providing information
about domicile state and district in the online application
form. No request for change of domicile state and district
will be entertained by the commission after submission of
application form under any circumstances. If there is any
variation of district and/or state mentioned by the
candidate in the online application form and the domicile
certificate submitted by them at the time of DME/ document
verification, their candidature will be cancelled forthwith
and they will not be allowed to participate in the detailed
medical examination.
…………………………
14.17 Candidates belonging to naxal/ militancy affected
areas will first be considered against the vacancies of
naxal/ militancy affected areas and then against the
vacancies of general areas. Similarly, candidates belonging
to border areas will first be considered against the
vacancies of border area and then against the vacancies of
general area Candidates belonging to both areas i.e. naxal/
militancy affected area as well as border area will first be
considered against the vacancies of naxal/ militancy
affected area followed by the vacancies border area and
general area respectively.
……………………………
20. Important instructions to the candidates:
………………………
11. CANDIDATES MUST BE VERY CAREFUL AND SHOULD
EXERCISE
DUE
DILIGENCE
WHILE
PROVIDING
INFORMATION ABOUT DOMICILE STATE AND DISTRICT IN
THE ONLINE APPLICATION FORM. NO REQUEST FOR
CHANGE OF DOMICILE STATE AND DISTRICT WILL BE
ENTERTAINED BY THE COMMISSION AFTER SUBMISSION OF
APPLICATION FORM UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES. IF
THERE IS ANY VARIATION OF DISTRICT AND/OR STATE
MENTIONED BY THE CANDIDATE IN THE ONLINE
APPLICATION FORM AND THE DOMICILE CERTIFICATE
SUBMITTED BY THEM AT THE TIME OF DME, THEIR
CANDIDATURE WILL BE CANCELLED FORTHWITH AND THEY
WILL NOT BE ALLOWED TO PARTICIPATE IN THE DME.
……………………………………
14. Before submission of the final online application,
candidates must check that they have filled correct details
in each field of the form. After submission of the final online
application form OR expiry of the period of 'Window for
Application Form Correction', no change/ correction/
modification will be allowed under any circumstances
Requests received in this regard in any form like Post, Fax,
Email, by hand, etc. shall not be entertained by the
Commission and will be summarily rejected.”
[17]
As per Instruction No.3.3 above, a candidate is
required to
submit
the domicile certificate issued by the
concerned state, and in case the domicile certificate is issued by
a state other than the state which the candidate has named in
the
application
form,
the
candidature
shall
be
cancelled.
Instruction No.4 clarifies that the vacancies in CAPFs & Assam
Rifles are State/UT/area wise and therefore, a candidate must
submit
domicile/PRC
Instruction
No.6
also
against
his
conveys
own
the
state/UT. Similarly,
similar
message
that
candidates will be considered for recruitment in their respective
state/UT on production of valid domicile/PRC issued by the
competent authority of that state failing which the candidature
will be cancelled forthwith. Instruction No.8.6, caution is also
given that the candidate must check that they have filled correct
details in each field of the form. Instruction no 10.1 gives a scope
to the candidates of 3 days to enable them to correct/modify online
application form or to resubmit the same after making requisite
corrections and in Instruction No.10.9, again a similar message is
conveyed that after expiry of 'Window for Application Form
Correction', no further correction or modification will be allowed
under any circumstances. All these instructions are not much
relevant for the present case in hand, for, the petitioner correctly
filled up the application form and her PRTC certificate was also
issued from Tripura.
[18]
Controversy centers round the submission of the PRTC
certificate mentioning the name of her district to be South
Tripura, though in her application form the name of her district is
mentioned as ‘Gomati’. The case of the petitioner is that her
village ‘Garjee’ earlier fell within the district ‘South Tripura’ when
said certificate was issued and later on, due to bifurcation of the
then South Tripura District, a new district namely ‘Gomati’ was
created wherein the village ‘Garjee’ falls. Therefore, it is not a
case where the petitioner has committed any mistake in filing up
her application form; rather, it is a case of mismatch in respect of
the name of her district in her online application form and the
domicile certificate, which occurred due to executive decision.
[19]
Ld. Dy. S. G .I submits that 4 days’ time was given by
the appropriate authority to rectify the defect but the petitioner
failed. In this regard, Clause No. 6.5.8 of the detailed guidelines
issued
by
the
Inspector
General
of
CRPF
(Annexure-R/1)
deserves reference. It is noted therein that there may be cases in
which a candidate may not bring original testimonials or Caste/
Domicile/Relaxation certificates in prescribed format or may
request for grant of extra time for producing the same and in
that case it will be appropriate if 4 days’ time is given to such
candidate(s) in the deserving cases. Said clause is also not
applicable in the present case, for, said instruction covers the
case where candidate fails to produce the original testimonials or
certificate in prescribed format to the authority.
[20]
The relevant instruction applicable in this case is the
Instruction No.14.14 as mentioned earlier. Said instruction
clearly envisages that the candidates should be very careful and
must exercise due diligence while providing information about
domicile state and district, both in the online application form and
in case of any variation of names of district and/or state, as
mentioned in the application form and the domicile certificate,
their candidature will be cancelled forthwith. Said instruction is
also again repeated in Clause 11 of Instruction No.20 as
extracted earlier. Apart from these clauses, in some other clauses
of the instruction manual also, it has been repeatedly cautioned
by the recruiting authority that candidates should be very careful
and diligent in filling up their application form. The petitioner
participated in the selection process after being completely aware
of said terms and conditions. Therefore, she cannot claim
anything now which is contrary to the said terms and conditions
of the selection process. It was her duty to ensure that her
address matches with her domicile certificate and therefore,
before she was called for document verification, she was
supposed to collect the PRTC certificate in modified form to avoid
such mismatch. She has, therefore, violated the Instruction
No.14.14 as noted above.
[21]
In Bedanga Talukdar (supra), the petitioner’s claim
for the job was against the post reserved for physically disabled
person in terms of Persons with Disabilities (Equal Opportunities,
Protection of Rights and Full Participation) Act, 1995. As per the
advertisement, and the corrigendum issued thereunder, the
candidates with Locomotor Disability were asked to produce the
supporting document of such disability in the office of Assam
Public Service Commission or in the examination hall before
commencement of preliminary examination and the last date of
submission of application was 6.7.2007. But the petitioner did
not submit the same before or at the time of appearing in such
examination. As per the advertisement, the candidates were
required to submit another application form before the final
examination,
and
the
petitioner
after
qualifying
for
the
preliminary examination, mentioned in his application form
submitted for the final examination that he was suffering from
Locomotor Disability and submitted his certificate in this regard.
He was also allowed to appear in the final examination and he
qualified for the said examination and also attended the
interview. But he was not ultimately selected and another
candidate who scored lesser mark than him was selected. The
petitioner also asserted that at the time of interview, all of his
related documents were verified by the authority. The recruiting
authority rejected his candidature on the ground that he did not
submit
his
identity
card
regarding
his
disability
with
his
application form. As per the direction of the High Court, said
selection authority again revisited the matter and rejected the
claim of the petitioner again on the ground that said identity card
was submitted at a different stage of the selection process. High
Court allowed the writ petition of the petitioner with a direction to
the Public Service Commission to consider the case of the
petitioner by taking into account the identity card produced by
him. Hon’ble Supreme Court, in that backdrop, while upsetting
the order of the High Court observed that the selection process
has to be conducted strictly in accordance with the stipulated
selection procedure and when a particular schedule is mentioned
in an advertisement, same has to be scrupulously maintained.
There cannot be any relaxation in the terms and conditions of the
advertisement unless such a power is specifically reserved.
Relaxation of any condition in
advertisement
without due
publication would be contrary to the provision of Articles 14 and
16 of the Constitution. Delhi High Court in Rohit Kumar (supra)
also rendered the decision in similar line.
[22]
In the present case, there is no power reserved in the
advertisement
to
relax
any
condition
including
the
Instruction/Condition No.14.14. Therefore, in view of the decision
of the Apex Court in Bedanga Talukdar (supra), there is no
scope for any interference by the Court by way of directing the
respondents to accept the second PRTC certificate produced by
her at a subsequent stage by relaxing the said Condition No.
14.14 or Clause 11 or Instruction no.20.
In view of above discussions, this writ petition is
dismissed being devoid of merit.
Connected application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Saikat Sarma
RUDRADEEP RUDRADEEP BANERJEE
2025.09.23
BANERJEE Date:
14:53:56 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review