The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. 01.2024 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This revision having been heard and reserved for judgment, coming on for pronouncement this day, Justice Sanjeev S Kalgaonkar pronounced the following: This criminal revision under Section 397 read with Section 401 of Cr.P.C and Section 19(1)(4) of Family Courts Act has been filed assailing the order dated 14.01.2013 passed by learned Principal Judge, Family Court, Gwalior in MJCR No.114 of 2010 whereby, the application filed by the petitioner under Section 125 of Cr.P.C for grant of maintenance under Section 125 of CrPC was rejected. For the sake of convenience, petitioner Smt. Manju Ramchandani shall be referred to as “petitioner” and respondent Manish Ramchandani shall be referred to as “respondent” hereinafter. The exposition of facts, giving rise to this revision petition, is as under:(i) Petitioner Manju Ramchandani was married to respondent Manish Ramchandani @ Banti on 31.10.2004 at Delhi according to Hindu customs and rituals. Manish started harassing her for demand of dowry and expelled her from matrimonial home. Petitioner was compelled to live with her mother. She has no source of income, whereas Manish is earning Rs.1,00,000/- per month from his hotel business at Delhi. petitioner requested for grant of maintenance of Rs.30,000/- per month from respondent. (ii) In reply, …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGHCOURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT G WA L I O R
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANJEEV S KALGAONKAR
CRIMINAL REVISION No.127 OF 2013
BETWEEN:SMT. MANJU RAMCHANDANI W/O SHRI MANISH
RAMCHANDANI, D/O SHRI SEVAKRAM AHUJA, AGED
27 YEARS, OCCUPATION: NIL R/O KRISHNA COLONY,
KE PASS, SIKANDAR KAMPOO MAMA KA BAZAR,
LASHKAR GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI RISHIKESH BOHARE- ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONER)
AND
TH
ES
MANISH RAMCHANDANI @ BANTI S/O LATE SHRI
SURESH RAMCHANDANI, AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: OWNER OF RESTAURENT R/O 24 G,
OLD DOUBLE STORY, LAJPAT NAGAR, NEW DELHI.
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SHRI KARAN VIRWANI- ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENT)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Reserved on
:
02.01.2024
Pronounced on :
10.01.2024
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This revision having been heard and reserved for judgment,
coming on for pronouncement this day, Justice Sanjeev S Kalgaonkar
pronounced the following:
ORDER
This criminal revision under Section 397 read with Section 401 of
Cr.P.C and Section 19(1)(4) of Family Courts Act has been filed assailing
the order dated 14.01.2013 passed by learned Principal Judge, Family
Court, Gwalior in MJCR No.114 of 2010 whereby, the application filed
by the petitioner under Section 125 of Cr.P.C for grant of maintenance
under Section 125 of CrPC was rejected.
For the sake of convenience, petitioner Smt. Manju Ramchandani
shall be referred to as “petitioner” and respondent Manish Ramchandani
shall be referred to as “respondent” hereinafter.
The exposition of facts, giving rise to this revision petition, is as
under:(i)
Petitioner Manju Ramchandani was married to respondent Manish
Ramchandani @ Banti on 31.10.2004 at Delhi according to Hindu
customs and rituals. Manish started harassing her for demand of dowry
and expelled her from matrimonial home. Petitioner was compelled to
live with her mother. She has no source of income, whereas Manish is
earning Rs.1,00,000/- per month from his hotel business at Delhi.
petitioner requested for grant of maintenance of Rs.30,000/- per month
from respondent.
(ii)
In reply, respondent Manish Ramchandani submitted that petitioner
has left matrimonial home without any just reason, despite request of
respondent and family members, petitioner refused to reside with
respondent, therefore, both the parties approached Pujya Sindhi Hindu
General Panchayat, District Gwalior for cancellation. Both the parties
agreed for mutual dissolution of marriage before the Panchayat.
An agreement of dissolution of marriage dated 16.09.2007 was executed
between the parties and respondent has paid Rs.1,40,000/- to the
applicant towards maintenance and compensation. Petitioner is residing
with her mother at her own will, therefore, she is not entitled for
maintenance from respondent.
(iii)
Petitioner denied execution of agreement regarding dissolution of
marriage before Panchayat. It is further alleged that the agreement is
forged in the name of Sonia @ Bhoomika and it does not relate to the
petitioner.
(iv)
Learned Principal Judge, Family Court, Gwalior after recording of
evidence of both the parties passed the impugned order dated 14.01.2013
and rejected the application for maintenance filed by petitioner Manju.
Feeling aggrieved by the impugned order, this revision petition is
filed inter alia assailing the order on following grounds:(i)
Learned Principal Judge has committed an error in relying on the
agreement Exhibit (D-1). This document relates to Sonia @ Bhoomika
although it bears photograph of petitioner, but it is not executed by
petitioner Manju. Learned Family Court committed error in treating
petitioner Manju as Sonia @ Bhoomika. Learned Family Court
committed error in ignoring the inconsistency with regard to place of
execution of the agreement in the evidence of Manoj Bhatia (NA-3) and
Gyanendra Kumar Pandey (NA-5). Further, there is inconsistency in
evidence with regard to payment of Rs.1,40,000/- in furtherance of the
agreement.
(ii)
The witnesses of agreement mother of petitioner and brother-in-law
Suresh Kumar were not examined before the Court. Learned Family
Court committed an error in rejecting the maintenance on the ground of
forged agreement of dissolution of marriage.
(iii)
Learned Family Court committed error in ignoring the fact that
petitioner was compelled to leave her matrimonial home due to cruelty of
respondent with regard to demand of dowry.
(iv)
Petitioner is legally wedded wife, therefore, respondent is bound to
pay maintenance to her.
On aforesaid grounds, it is prayed that impugned order be set aside
and respondent is directed to pay maintenance to her.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the Family Court,
Gwalior committed grave error in relying on agreement for dissolution of
marriage (Ex.D-1). The respondent has failed to prove execution of this
agreement by petitioner Manju. There is no evidence that petitioner is
capable to maintain herself, therefore, the impugned order suffers from
impropriety and illegality.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent submits that
petitioner is residing separately without any sufficient reasons. Both the
parties have mutually agreed to dissolve their marriage through
agreement executed before the Panchayat as per the custom prevalent in
their caste. The revision petition has no merit and hence deserves to be
dismissed.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
It is an admitted fact that petitioner Manju was married to
respondent Manish on 31.10.2004. It is also an admitted fact that
applicant is residing with her mother since 2007. Manju (PW-1) had
stated that she was expelled from her matrimonial home by the
respondent, whereas Manish (DW-1) stated that petitioner left the
matrimonial home and went to her maternal home at Gwalior.
Section 125 (4) in the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 provides
that “No Wife shall be entitled to receive an allowance from her husband
under this section if she is living in adultery, or if, without any sufficient
reason, she refuses to live with her husband, or if they are living
separately by mutual consent”.
The initial burden to prove that wife has refused to live with her
husband without any sufficient reason lies on the husband. Manish (NA1) stated that applicant resided with him for one month after marriage,
thereafter, without any intimation, she went to Gwalior. He tried to
persuade applicant to return, but she refused. He came to Gwalior and had
a talk with applicant, but applicant refused to go with him, therefore, he
submitted an application to Gwalior Sindhi Panchayat. On insistence of
Panchayat, applicant went with him, but after 3-4 days again returned to
Gwalior. He along with his mother again came to Gwalior. A Panchayat
was convened when applicant refused to reside with him. Panchayat and
other people of society suggested that they may dissolve their marriage.
An agreement Exhibit (D-1) was accordingly executed between them. It
was agreed that they will not undertake any proceedings. He has paid
Rs.1,40,000/- cash, jewellry to the applicant in furtherance of the
agreement Exhibit (D-1) dated 16.10.2007. Applicant is residing with her
mother ever since. Kiran (NA-2) (mother of the respondent), Manoj
Bhatia (NA-3) agreement Exhibit (D-1), Anand Karara (NA-4), General
Secretary of Pujya Sindhi Hindu Panchayat, Gyanendra Pandey (NA-5),
scribe of agreement Exhibit (D-1) have corroborated the evidence of
Manish (NA-1). Learned Family Court extensively dealt with the
evidence of theses witnesses in Para 9 and 12 of the judgment and
concluded that agreement Exhibit (D-1) was executed by applicant in
presence of family members of both the parties and applicant has
executed the agreement in name of Sonia. The reasoning for conclusion is
appropriate. So far as inconsistency with regard to place of execution is
concerned, minor inconsistencies need to be ignored considering the
fragility of human memory. No patent illegality or perversity is made out
with regard to aforementioned conclusion.
It is not in dispute that marriage between Manju and Manish had
taken place as per the Hindu law, which is applicable to the parties. Once,
the parties are married, the same cannot be dissolved except by a decree
of divorce passed under the provisions of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. The
Act of 1955 also provides for divorce by mutual consent under Section
13 (b). Although Section 29(2) of the Act of 1955 saves the customary
right, however, the custom has to be pleaded and proved that the parties
were entitled for a customary divorce. The respondent has relied on
agreement (Ex.D-1) with regard to dissolution of marriage between them,
but it will not be of any help to the respondent as the customary divorce
was neither pleaded nor proved. Thus, learned Family Court committed
no error in holding that agreement (Ex. D-1) cannot be relied for the
purpose of dissolution of marriage between the parties. Still, it is
admissible to show that both the parties are living separately by mutual
consent.
Manju (AW-1) stated that Manish was not happy with the marriage
so he used to manhandle and abuse her. Manish used to consume liquor
and refused to have physical relations with her. In year 2007, Manish
expelled her from matrimonial home, so she came to her mother. Manish
never came to take her back. She tried to lodge report, but police refused
to take action. Learned Trial Court in Para 13 and 14 of the judgment, on
consideration of material on record and attending circumstances declined
to accept aforementioned testimony of the applicant. The reasons
assigned by learned Family Court are proper, therefore, no interference is
called for in exercise of revisional jurisdiction. Thus, learned Family
Court has committed no error in holding that the applicant has left her
matrimonial home without any proper and sufficient reason. The nonapplicant attempted to persuade the applicant to reside with him, but the
applicant refused to perform her matrimonial obligations. Both the parties
mutually agreed to live separately in a Panchayat convened by family
members of both the parties. Learned Family Court committed no error in
holding that the applicant has refused to live with her husband without
any sufficient reason and she is living separately by mutual consent,
therefore, applicant is not entitled for maintenance from her husband.
No patent illegality, propriety or perversity is made out in the
impugned order. Hence there is no reason to exercise supervisory
jurisdiction under Section 397 r/w 401 of CrPC.
The revision petition sans merits is therefore dismissed.
(SANJEEV S KALGAONKAR)
JUDGE
Avi/vijay
VIJAY
TRIP
ATHI
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF
MADHYA PRADESH BENCH
GWALIOR, ou=HIGH COURT OF
MADHYA PRADESH BENCH
GWALIOR,
2.5.4.20=663cb09dd950bfc3ea7ed
4f02d97ddae5364f1d4b042dbc599
21b76e812d2d6b,
postalCode=474001, st=Madhya
Pradesh,
serialNumber=58392D8C4E7C9693
BFEEB5B46B3CA006F1127E890089
52BBEC528CE4D82551BD,
cn=VIJAY TRIPATHI
Date: 2024.01.11 16:49:19 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review