Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE SUNITA YADAV
ON THE 8th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. APPEAL No. 703 of 2012
BETWEEN:NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED TH: ITS
SENIOR DIVISIONAL MANAGER HAVING DIVISIONAL
OFFICE NO.1 AT AYENDRAGANJ,GWALIOR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(MR. SHRINIVAS GAJENDRAGADKAR - ADVOCATE FOR APPELLANT)
AND
SMT.MADHU W/O ALTE RAJESH MADIL, AGED
ABOUT 38 YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOUSE HOLD R/O
1. DAMODAR BAGH COLONY,TOWARDS MASTAN
BABA
KI
DARGAH,BAHODAPUR,GWALIOR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
DEVANSHU MANDIL S/O LATE RAJESH MANDIL,
AGED ABOUT 11 YEARS, OCCUPATION: MINOR TH.
MOTHER SMT.MADHU MANDIL W/O LATE RAJESH
2.
MANDIL DAMODAR BAG COLONY TOWARDS
MASTAN BABA KI DARGAH BAHODAPUR GWALIOR
MP (MADHYA PRADESH)
PUNIT MANDIL S/O LATE RAJESH MANDIL, AGED
ABOUT 9 YEARS, OCCUPATION: MINOR TH.
MOTHER SMT.MADHU MANDIL W/O LATE RAJESH
3.
MANDIL DAMODAR BAG COLONY TOWARDS
MASTAN BABA KI DARGAH BAHODAPUR GWALIOR
MP (MADHYA PRADESH)
GAURISHANKAR MANDIL S/O KANNUMAL MANDIL,
AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS, OCCUPATION: NIL
4. DAMODAR BAG COLONY TOWARDS MASTAN BABA
KI DARGAH BAHODAPUR GWALIOR MP (MADHYA
PRADESH)
5. SANNULAL BAGHEL @ FAUJILAL S/O HIRALAL
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
BAGHEL OCCUPATION: DRIVER NEAR MADHOGANJ
THANA LAKKAD KHANA LASHKAR GWALIOR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
KIDDIS CORNER SCHOOL NAYA BAJAR LASHKAR
GWALIOR TH.PRINCIPAL KIDDIS CORNER SCHOOL
6. GWALIOR TH.PROP.VIJAY GARG S/O KRISHNADAS
GARG NAYA BAJAR LASHKAR GWALIOR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
DISTRICT MAGISTRATE AND DISTRICT ELECTION
7. OFFICER AND COLLECTOR GWALIOR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH TH.COLLECTOR
8.
DIST.GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(MR. B.D.VERMA - ADVOCATE FOR THE RESPONDENT & MR. KRIPAL SINGH
BATHAM - ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENTS NO. 1 TO 4 AND MR. UPENDRA
YADAV – ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO. 7)
MISC. APPEAL No. 730 of 2012
BETWEEN:SMT.MADHU MANDIL W/O LATE RAJESH MANDIL,
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOUSE WIFE
1. DAMODAR BAG COLONY, MASTAN BABA KI
DARGAH
KE
AGE,
ABHODAPUR
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
DEVANSHU MANDIL S/O LATE RAJESH MANDIL,
AGED ABOUT 11 YEARS, OCCUPATION: MINOR TH.
MOTHER MADHU MANDIL W/O LATE RAJESH
2.
MANDIL DAMODAR BAG COLONY MASTAN BABA KI
DARGAH KE AAGE BAHODAPUR GWALIOR MP
(MADHYA PRADESH)
PUNIT MANDIL S/O LATE RAJESH MANDIL, AGED
ABOUT 9 YEARS, OCCUPATION: MINOR TH.
MOTHER MADHU MANDIL W/O LATE RAJESH
3.
MANDIL DAMODAR BAG COLONY MASTAN BABA KI
DARGAH KE AAGE BAHODAPUR GWALIOR MP
(MADHYA PRADESH)
GAURISHANKAR MANDIL S/O KANNUMAL MANDIL,
AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS, OCCUPATION: NIL
4. DAMODAR BAG COLONY MASTAN BABA KI
DARGAH KE AAGE BAHODAPUR GWALIOR MP
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
(MR. B.D.VERMA- ADVOCATE FOR APPELLANTS/CLAIMANTS)
AND
SANNULAL BAGHEL @ FAUJILAL S/O HEERALAL
BAGHEL OCCUPATION: DRIVER MADHOGANJ
1.
THANE KE PAS, LAKKAD KHANA LASHKAR,
GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
KIDDIS CORNER SCHOOL NAYA BAJAR LASHKAR
GWALIOR TH.PRINCIPAL KIDDIS CORNER SCHOOL
2. GWALIOR TH.PROP.VIJAY GARG S/O KRISHNADAS
GARG NAYA BAJAR LASHKAR GWALIOR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
NATIONAL
INSURANCE
COMPANY
LIMITED
3. TH.DIVISIONAL
MANAGER
JAYENDRAGANJ
LASHKAR GWALIOR MP (MADHYA PRADESH)
JILA MAGISTRATE AVAM JILA NIRVACHAN
4. ADHIKARI AVAM COLLECTOR NIWASI GWALIOR
MP (MADHYA PRADESH)
STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH TH.COLLECTOR
5.
DIST.GWALIOR MP (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(MR. KAMAL KUMAR ROCHALANI - ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO.3/INSURANCE COMPANY)
….......................................................................................................................
These appeals coming on for Admission this day, the court passed the
following:
JUDGMENT
Since common question of law is involved in aforesaid M.A. Nos. 703
of 2012 and 730 of 2012, therefore, they are heard analogously and are
decided by this common judgment. For the sake of convenience, facts
mentioned in M.A. No. 703 of 2012 are taken into consideration.
These appeals have been filed assailing the award dated 12.4.2012
passed by Fifth Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Gwalior (M.P.)
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
in Claim Case No. 35/2010 filed by respondents No. 1 to 4 - claimants
(appellants in M.A. No.730 of 2012) for grant of compensation on account
of death of Rajesh Mandil in a road traffic accident occurred on 23.1.2010
involving offending vehicle bus bearing registration No.MP07-F-0689. At the
time of accident, respondent No. 5 - Sannulal Baghel @ Faujilal (respondent
No. 1 in M.A. No.730 of 2012) was the driver, respondent No. 6 - Kiddis
Corner School (respondent No. 2 in M.A. No.730 of 2012) was the owner of
the offending vehicle and the vehicle was insured with appellant - insurance
company (respondent No. 3 in M.A. No.730 of 2012) whereas the offending
vehicle was in the possession of respondents No. 7 and 8 (respondents No.4
and 5 in M.A. No.730 of 2012) for election.
Driver and owner of the offending vehicle filed their written statement
and denied the allegations made in the claim petition and prayed for rejection
of the claim petition.
Insurance company filed its written statement and denied the averments
made in the claim petition and further stated that offending vehicle was being
plied in violation of policy terms and conditions, therefore, insurance
company is not liable to pay the compensation.
Respondents No. 7 and 8 filed their written statements and stated that
offending vehicle was taken on rent from respondent No. 6 – owner of the
offending vehicle, therefore, they are not liable to pay the compensation.
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
Learned claims tribunal after hearing both the parties and going through
the evidence available on record partly allowed the claim petition of the
claimants and granted compensation to the tune of Rs.5,13,500/- and
insurance company was held liable to pay the compensation.
By filing M.A. No. 703 of 2012, learned counsel for the insurance
company has argued that learned Claims Tribunal has wrongly exonerated the
respondents No. 7 and 8 from their liability to pay the compensation to the
claimants without appreciating the fact that the offending vehicle was
requisitioned by the District Magistrate in exercise of its powers conferred
upon it under the provisions of Representation of People Act. It is further
argued that the registered owner i.e. Respondent No. 6 could not refuse to
abide by the order of requisition of vehicle by the District Magistrate. When
the vehicle remains under requisition, the owner of the vehicle does not have
any control over it. The driver may still be the employee of the owner of the
vehicle but he has to drive it as per the directions of the Officer of the State,
who is put in-charge thereof. He has no say as to whether the vehicle should
be driven at the given point of time or not. Further argument is that when a
vehicle is requisitioned, the owner of the vehicle has no other alternative but
to handover the possession to the statutory authority. Hence, the liability as to
pay the compensation was liable to be rested on the respondents No. 7 and 8.
It is further submitted that learned Tribunal has erred in not relying upon the
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
law laid down by the Apex Court. The amount of the compensation is also on
the higher side. Therefore, the appeal be allowed and finding of learned
Claims Tribunal in respect to resting the liability upon the insurance company
for payment of compensation thereby exonerating respondents No. 7 and 8
from the same be set aside.
On the other hand, learned counsel for respondents No. 7 – Upendra
Yadav opposed the submissions made by learned counsel for the insurance
company and argued that learned claims tribunal has rightly exonerated
respondents No. 7 and 8 from the liability to pay the compensation and no
interference is warranted in the same. In this regard, learned counsel relied
upon the case law of U.P. State Road Transport Corporation v. National
Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.; 2019 ACJ 269.
By filing M.A. No. 730 of 2012, learned counsel for the claimants
argued that learned Claims Tribunal has erred in calculating the income of the
deceased on the lower side without considering his income-tax returns. It is
further argued that as per the income-tax return of the year 2009-10, the
annual income of the deceased was Rs.2,00,500/-, therefore, the compensation
be enhanced in accordance with documentary evidence in respect to income
of the deceased.
Heard and perused the record.
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
The points for determination in these appeals are as follows: 1. Whether learned Claims Tribunal has erred in saddling the liability to
pay compensation on appellant/Insurance Company?
2. What should be just and proper compensation?
In this case the factum of accident as well as death of deceased Rajesh
by offending vehicle bus bearing registration No.MP07-F-0689 has not been
challenged. As per case of the claimant, the said bus was owned by
respondent No. 6 - Kiddies Corner School and was being driven by
respondent No.5-Sannulal Baghel @ Faujilal and at the time of accident the
offending vehicle was requisitioned by the Government of M.P. for the
purpose of election work.
On the other hand, as per written statement of respondents No. 7 and 8,
at the time of accident, offending vehicle bus bearing registration No. MP07F-0689 was taken on rent, therefore, these respondents are not responsible to
pay compensation.
To prove its case, respondents No. 7 and 8 have examined Surendra
Singh Gurjar. As per statement recorded as examination-in-chief of this
witness, on account of Gram Panchayat Election Work (2009-10), bus bearing
No. MP07-F-0689 was hired along with other vehicles. The offending vehicle
was hired for the period starting from 22.01.2010 at 8:00 A.M. to 24.01.2010
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
at 9:00 PM. The rent of said bus was paid to Kiddies Corner School,
therefore, respondents No. 7 and 8 are not responsible for payment of
compensation.
This witness though in his examination-in-chief has stated that
offending bus hired for Gram Panchayat Election work, however, in his crossexamination, at para 7, he specifically stated that when any vehicle is
requisitioned, the rent is paid for the period it is requisitioned. This witness
has proved the letter of Collector and District Electoral Officer dated
29.06.2010 (Exh.D/2) and register of Panchayat Election Office (Exh.D/3).
Bare perusal of the Exh. D/2 indicates that the offending bus was
requisitioned by respondents No. 7 and 8 for the purpose of Gram Panchayat
Election 2009-10 and notice was given to Principle of Kiddies Corner School
in respect to payment of rent of requisitioned vehicle. Thus, the document
proved by the witness of respondents No. 7 and 8 contradict their defense that
the bus was hired not requisitioned.
Respondent No. 6 - Kiddies Corner School had also examined Vijay
Bai to support this witness who also stated that the offending vehicle bus was
requisitioned by the Government for the works of Gram Panchayat Election.
The statement of this witnesses remained unchallenged in his crossexamination, therefore, in view of the statement of this witness, it is proved
that offending vehicle was requisitioned by the Government for the purpose of
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
election.
In the cases of National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Deepa Devi and Ors.
reported in Manu/SC/4557/2007 decided in Civil Appeal No. 5796 of 2007,
Purnya Kala Devi Vs. State of Assam and Anr, 2014 ACJ 1269, U.P. State
Road Transport Corporation Vs. National Insurance Co. Ltd. and Ors.
reported in 2019 ACJ 269 and Ganga Devi Vs. State of Jharkhand and Ors,
reported in 2012 ACJ 710, the Apex Court has held that when the vehicle was
requisitioned by the Electoral Officer for the purpose of Election work, it is
under management, control and possession of Electoral Officer of the State.
Whenever any vehicle is requisitioned by a statutory authority pursuant to the
provisions contained in a statute, the owner of the vehicle cannot refuse to
abide by the order of requisition of the vehicle by the authority. While the
vehicle remains under requisition, the owner does not exercise any control
thereover. The driver may still be the employee of the owner of the vehicle
but he has to drive it as per the direction of the Officer of the State, who is put
in-charge thereof.
In this case also, it is proved that the vehicle was requisitioned by
respondents No. 7 and 8 for the Gram Panchayat Election and therefore,
respondent No. 6 - Kiddies Corner School could not refuse to abide by the
order of requisition of the vehicle. Since, at the time of accident, the offending
vehicle was under requisition, the driver had to drive it as per the direction of
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
the Officer of the State, who is put in-charge thereof. Under these
circumstances, learned claims tribunal has erred in fastening the liability for
payment of compensation on the appellant/Insurance Company as the State is
liable to pay the same to the claimants.
Learned counsel for respondents No. 7 and 8 argued that in the light of
case law of U.P. State Road Transport Corporation (supra), liability should
be fixed on the insurance company, however, above argument is not
acceptable because in the above case cited by the respondents, an agreement
was executed between the owner and the Corporation. In this case, there is
nothing on record to show that any agreement was executed between the
Electoral Officer / Govt. of M.P. and the registered owner of the offending
vehicle. Therefore, above case law does not support the defence of
respondents No. 7 and 8.
Consequently, the findings of the learned Claims Tribunal in respect to
liability of appellant- insurance company to pay compensation is hereby set
aside and respondents No. 7 and 8 (respondents No. 4 and 5 in M.A. No.
730 of 2012) are held liable to pay the compensation to the claimants.
So far as quantam of the compensation is concerned, on the basis of the
evidence available on record, learned Claims Tribunal has rightly fixed the
age of deceased Rajesh as 43 years.
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
The main ground taken by the claimants is that learned claims tribunal
has ignored to consider the income-tax returns filed by the claimants to prove
the income of the deceased. This income-tax returns were filed before the
death of deceased Rajesh Mandel and in the light of principles laid down by
the Apex Court, the same be considered for assessment of income of the
deceased.
In this respect, the evidence of AW-2 Prakash Chandra Bhasne and AW4 Narendra Singh Rajppot are relevant. These witnesses were officials of
income tax department, Gwalior and proved income-tax returns filed by
deceased Rajesh Mandel.
As per AW-2 Prakash Chandra Bhasne, income-tax returns filed by
deceased Rajesh Mandil for the assessment year 2006-07 (Exh.P-27) his gross
income was Rs.1,31,520/- per annum, for the assessment year 2007-08
(Exh.P-28) was Rs.1,37,780/-, for assessment year 2008-09 (Exh.P-28) was
Rs.1,46,800/- and as per income-tax return for the assessment year 2009-10,
gross-income of the deceased was Rs.2,00,500/-. This witness has proved the
original documents and also stated that under Section 143 (1) of Income Tax
Act, no order was given for NIL demand. He has further stated that if there is
any demand, then only the notice for demand is given.
AW-4 Narendra Singh Rajput, who was also the Income-Tax Inspector,
corroborated the statement of AW-2 Prakash Chandra Bhasne and proved
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
income-tax returns for the year 2004-05 (Exh.P-9 and P-10). According to this
witness, in the ear 2004-05, gross-income of the deceased Rajesh Mandil was
Rs.87,000/-.
The statements of above witnesses remained unchallenged in their
cross-examinations and nothing emerged in their cross-examination which
may raise doubt over their statements as well as original documents of
Income-tax Returns filed by deceased Rajesh Mandil.
Learned claims tribunal disbelieved the income-tax returns on the
ground that the claimants have not proved the salary and other income of the
deceased by providing cogent evidence. However, claimant Manju Mandil has
corroborated the fact that deceased was a teacher and Manager in Ashish
Convent School and he was also earning from private tuition. The above
statement is supported by the income-tax returns which were filed much
before the death of her husband Rajesh Mandil and it cannot be said that these
income-tax returns were filed only to get more compensation because at the
time of filing these income-tax returns, deceased had no knowledge that he
would met with an accident in future. As per general tendency a tax payer try
to show the income on lower side not on the upper side so that he could avoid
high income-tax. Therefore, the arguments of the respondents are not
acceptable that these ITR are filed just to enhance compensation amount.
The Apex Court in its recent judgment in the case of Anjali & Ors. v.
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
Lokendra Rathore; 2023 ACJ 637 held that income-tax return is a statutory
document and has to be relied on to assess the income this principle has been
followed by the Apex Court in the case of K. Ramaiya & Ors. v. National
Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors.; Civil Appeal No.7046/2022 arising out of
SLP (Civil) No.31931/2017, by its judgment dated 30.9.2022 held that the
income-tax returns are the statutory documents. Therefore, in the light of
above law laid down by the Apex Court, learned claims tribunal has erred in
not considering the income-tax returns of the deceased.
Now the question is what would be the just and proper compensation?
In this case the accident occurred in the year 2010 and as per Incometax Return for the year 2009-10, income of the deceased was Rs.2,00,500/per annum.
In view of the case law of National Insurance Company vs. Pranay
Sethi & Ors; 2017 ACJ 2700 as well as Smt. Sarla Verma & Ors. vs. Delhi
Transport Corporation & Ors.; AIR 2009 SC 3104, considering the annual
income of the deceased to be Rs.2,00,500/-, 3/4th dependency (2,00,500 x 3/4
= 1,50,375), 25% future prospects (1,50,375 x 25/100 = 37594/-), multiplier
of 14 and Rs.70,000 in other heads, total compensation amount comes to
Rs.27,01,566/- [(1,50,375 + 37594) x 14 + 70000/-].
As such, the total amount awarded to the claimants is enhanced from
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
MA. NO. 703 OF 2012 AND M.A. NO. 730 OF 2012
Rs.5,13,500/- to Rs.27,01,566/-. The enhanced amount comes to
Rs.21,88,066/- (Rupees Twenty One Lakh Eighty Eight Thousand and
Sixty Six only), with interest at the rate as fixed by the tribunal in the award
which is directed to be paid to the claimants by respondents No. 7 and 8
(respondents No. 4 and 5 in M.A. No. 730 of 2012) / State of M.P. in the
same apportionment as directed by the claims tribunal. The enhanced amount
of compensation Rs.21,88,066/- shall be payable to the claimants within 12
weeks from the date of production of a certified copy of this order. Rest of the
award impugned passed by the Tribunal shall remain intact.
If the enhanced amount of compensation is in excess to the valuation of
appeal, the difference of the Court fee (if not already paid) shall be deposited
by the claimants within four weeks' from today and proof thereof shall be
submitted before the Registry. Thereafter, Registry shall issue the certified
copy of the order passed today.
Appeals stand allowed to the aforesaid extent and disposed of.
Original copy of this judgment be kept in M.A. No. 703 of 2012 and a
certified copy of this judgment be kept in connected M.A. No. 730 of 2012.
(SUNITA YADAV)
JUDGE
LJ*/AKS
Signed by: ALOK KUMAR
Signing time: 1/12/2024
04:30:22 AM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review