Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 22ND DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C M JOSHI
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 5626 OF 2009 (DEC/INJ)
BETWEEN:
1.
SMT. LIMBATAI,
W/O. NEMU PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. SOUNDALAGA,
NOW R/AT. HUNNARAGI-591201,
TALUK: CHIKODI, DIST. BELAGAVI.
SINCE DECEASED BY HER LR,
SOU. INDUTAI, W/O. SHAMARO PAWAR/APPELLANT NO.2
2.
NAGARATHNA
TEKAL
SUBBARAO
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
SOU. INDUTAI, W/O. SHAMARO PAWAR,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
OCC. HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. SIDDENERLI-416 216,
TALUK: KAGAL, DIST. KOLHAPUR.
...APPELLANTS
(BY SRI B S KAMATE, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
APPA TUKARAM SAVAGAVE,
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SOUNDALAGA-591 201,
TALUK: CHIKODI, DIST. BELGAUM.
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.
1(a). BALASAHEB S/O. APPA SAVAGAVE,
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
AGED ABOUT MAJOR,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SOUNDALAGA,
TALUK: CHIKODI, DIST. BELGAUM.
1B. ANANDA S/O. APPA SAVAGAVE,
AGED MAJOR,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SOUNDALAGA,
TALUK: CHIKODI, DIST. BELGAUM.
2.
BABURAO TUKARAM SAVAGAVE,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. SOUNDALAGA-591 201,
TALUK: CHIKODI, DIST. BELGAUM.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI ANAND ASHTEKAR, ADVOCATE)
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 100 OF CPC, AGAINST
THE JUDGEMENT AND DECREE DATED 14.08.2009 PASSED IN
R.A.NO.49/2003 ON THE FILE OF THE FAST TRACK COURT-I,
CHIKODI, DISMISSING THE APPEAL, FILED AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT DATED 16.03.1999 AND THE DECREE PASSED IN O.S
NO. 55/1994 ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE (JR.DN) INPANI,
DECREEING THE SUIT FILED FOR DECLARATION AND PERMANENT
INJUNCTION.
THIS RSA HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED ON
02.12.2025, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT
THIS DAY AT BENGALURU BENCH, COURT DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C M JOSHI)
This appeal by the appellants/defendant Nos.1 and 2 arises
out of the concurrent findings of the trial Court in O.S.No.55/1994
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
dated 16.03.1999 and the First Appellate Court in R.A.No.49/2003
dated 14.08.2009, whereby the suit filed by the plaintiffs against the
defendants came to be decreed holding that they are the absolute
owners of the suit schedule property as per the Will executed by
their maternal uncle Nemu Hari Patil and as a consequence, the
defendants were restrained from causing obstruction to the plaintiffs'
possession and enjoyment.
2.
The factual matrix of the case as may be found from the
records is as below:
a)
The testator Nemu Hari Patil was adopted by one Hari
Patil. After death of Hari Patil, Nemu succeeded to the suit schedule
property as adopted son of Hari Patil.
b)
It was contended that Nemu Hari Patil had executed a
registered Will dated 17.04.1976 and he died on 15.01.1991. After
the death of Nemu Hari Patil, the plaintiffs as legatees of the Will,
inherited the property and became owners of the same.
c)
They contended that they are in actual possession and
enjoyment of the suit schedule property and the defendants having
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
no right, title or interest in the suit schedule property are obstructing
their possession and enjoyment.
d)
They also contended that the defendants claimed that
they are the wife and daughter of deceased-Nemu Hari Patil in order
to grab the property. But in fact, Nemu Hari Patil died unmarried and
issueless. They contended that Nemu Hari Patil was residing with
the mother of the plaintiffs, who was none else than his sister. It was
the plaintiffs and their mother, who looked after the deceased-Nemu
Hari Patil till his death and therefore, out of his love and affection,
Nemu Hari Patil had executed Will in favour of the plaintiffs.
e)
They contended that at the time of executing the Will, he
was in sound and disposing state of mind and he executed the Will
out of his own volition.
f)
After the death of Nemu Hari Patil, the plaintiff gave an
application to the Revenue Authorities to enter their name in respect
of the suit schedule property and despite objections by the
defendants, the name of the plaintiffs were entered. The matter was
carried in appeal and the Assistant Commissioner held that the
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
plaintiffs have to approach the Civil Court for declaration of their
right.
g)
When there was obstruction by the defendants, the
plaintiffs have approached the Court seeking declaration as above.
3.
Defendant Nos.1 and 2 having appeared before the trial
Court have filed their written statement contending as under:
a)
Nemu Hari Patil has never executed any Will in favour of
the plaintiffs and the one alleged by the plaintiffs is concocted one.
b)
They contended that the suit schedule property is
deemed to be an ancestral property of the Nemu Hari Patil and the
defendants, who are wife and daughter of Nemu Hari Patil, have
vested interest in the suit schedule property and the legality,
propriety and the authority of the said Will is seriously disputed by
the defendants.
c)
They contended that under the guise of the Will dated
17.04.1976, the plaintiffs are trying to grab the suit schedule
property.
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
d)
They also contended that
defendant No.1 is legally
wedded wife of Nemu Hari Patil and the marriage was solemnized as
per the rites and ceremonies prevailing in Maratha Community and
defendant No.1 could not pull on with Nemu Hari Patil, though there
was no differences between her and Nemu Hari Patil but the
differences were with his mother. It is contended that out of the
wedlock, defendant No.2 was born on 21.09.1950 and there was an
error in reporting the date to the School Authorities, which was
mentioned as 01.07.1949.
e)
All the records, including the Voter List etc., are showing
that defendant No.1 is the wife of Nemu Hari Patil and defendant
No.2 is the daughter. They contended that defendant No.2 is known
by name Gangutai, Indutai and Balabai and all the names refer to
defendant No.2 only. Conspicuously, the alleged Will does not
mention anything about defendant Nos.1 and 2 and that is one of the
strong suspicious circumstances. They contended that defendant
Nos.1 and 2 living separately from the deceased-Nemu Hari Patil
would not divest their rights to claim succession and inheritance in
the property owned by Nemu Hari Patil.
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
f)
It is contended that the property held by Nemu Hari Patil
are the property inherited by him from the adoptive family and
therefore, defendant Nos.1 and 2 have right in the suit schedule
property and as such, Nemu Hari Patil could not have bequeathed
the entire property to the plaintiffs.
g)
Thus, alleging that the Will is concocted one, is created
only for the purpose of usurping the property, which legitimately
belonged to the defendants, they sought for dismissal of the suit.
4.
On the basis of the above contentions, the following
issues and additional issues were framed by the trial Court:
“ISSUES
1. Whether the plaintiffs prove the due and voluntary
execution of will dtd: 17.4.1976 by the deceased
Nemu Hari Patil in their favour in respect of the suit
property?
2. Whether the plaintiffs prove their lawful possession
of the suit property as on the date of the filing this
suit?
3. Whether the defendants prove that the deceased
Nemu Hari Patil had no authority and capacity to
execute the will in respect of the suit property?
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
4. Whether the plffs. are entitle for the reliefs of
declaration and injunction sought for?
Additional Issue No.1:- Whether, the defendants
prove that, the defendant No.1 is legally wedded wife
of Nemu Hari Patil and defendant No.2 is legally born
daughter to them?
5. What decree or order?”
5.
Plaintiff No.2 was examined as PW1 and three
witnesses were examined as PW2 to PW4. Ex.P1 to Ex.P30 were
marked. On behalf of the defendants, defendant No.2 was examined
as DW1 and three witnesses were examined
as DW2 to DW4.
Ex.D1 to Ex.D6 were marked.
6.
After hearing the arguments, the trial Court decreed the
suit as prayed. Being aggrieved, the defendants approached the
First Appellate Court in R.A.No.49/2003 and by the impugned
judgment dated 14.08.2009 the appeal came to be dismissed.
Aggrieved by the same, defendants have approached this Court in
this regular second appeal.
7.
At the time of hearing on admission, the following
substantial questions of law were framed by this Court:
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
“i. Whether the trial Court as well as the first Appellate
Court have committed a serious error in ignoring the
material evidence of the defendants and consequently
doubting the relationship of the defendants with the
testator?
ii. Whether both the Courts have committed a serious
error in coming to the conclusion that the disputed will
in question has been specifically proved?”
8.
During
the
pendency
the
appeal,
appellant
No.1/defendant No.1 died and appellant No.2 is treated as her legal
representative. So also, respondent No.1/plaintiff No.1 died and his
legal representatives are brought on record.
9.
The learned counsel for the appellants would submit that
the trial Court and the First Appellate Court could not have doubted
the relationship of defendant No.1 with Nemu Hari Patil. He submits
that the testimony of the DW2, DW3 and DW4 especially, DW3Yamunabai could not have been discarded by the trial Court and the
First Appellate Court. It is submitted that the marriage of defendant
No.1 and Nemu Hari Patil was never denied by anybody at any point
of time and after such a long time, the plaintiffs are denying the
relationship of husband and wife. It is submitted that the school
records of the defendant No.2 clearly establish that she is the
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
daughter of Nemu Hari Patil and therefore, at this length of time,
doubting the parenthood of defendant No.2 would not be proper. It is
submitted that when nothing is available on record to show that the
relationship of Nemu Hari Patil and defendant No.1 was not doubted
and when the records revealed that they lived as husband and wife
for considerable long time, such evidence could not have been
discarded by the trial Court and the First Appellate Court.
10.
Secondly, he submits that the Will is ridden with many
suspicious circumstances. He submits that the participation of one of
the plaintiffs at the time of the execution of the Will by Nemu Hari
Patil itself is one of the suspicious circumstances. It is pointed out
that the Will does not mention anything about defendant Nos.1 and
2 and therefore, it raises doubt when the other evidence available on
record show their relationship.
11.
Thirdly, it is submitted that the rightful inheritance of
defendant No.2 has been disrupted by the said Will without any
reason. Hence, it is submitted that it also raises doubt about the
veracity of the Will.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
12.
Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the
respondents
submits
that
the
documents
produced
by
the
defendants specifically show that it was Nemagonda Patil but not
Nemu Hari Patil. He submits that Nemagonda Patil and Nemu Hari
Patil are two different persons and therefore, the contention of the
learned counsel appearing for the appellants cannot be accepted.
13.
Secondly, he submits that averments in the Will that the
deceased Nemu Hari Patil did not have any wife or children goes to
show that the relationship of the defendants was not admitted by
Nemu Hari Patil himself. It is submitted that it is only the contention
taken up in the Will that has been reiterated by the plaintiffs.
14.
Thirdly, he submits that the execution of the Will by
Nemu Hari Patil has been established as required under law, i.e.,
under Section 63 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 and under
Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, by examining the
attesting witnesses and as such,
document at Ex.P.1 being a
Registered Will has been proved as required under law.
15.
Fourthly, he submits that the documents produced by
the defendants nowhere establish that the defendants are the wife
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
and daughter of Nemu Hari Patil. But on the contrary their
documents depict that they are the wife and daughter of Nemagonda
Patil. It is pointed out that the name of Nemu Hari Patil is also not
found in any of the documents. Hence, it is submitted that the trial
Court as well as the First Appellate Court were justified in saying that
the Will has been proved by the plaintiffs beyond all suspicious
circumstances and therefore, the contentions of the learned counsel
appearing for the appellants cannot be accepted.
16.
He also submits that the anvil on which the Will has to
be proved is explained by this Court in the case of Sri J.T. Surappa
& Another Vs. Sri Satchidhanandendra Saraswathi Swamiji
Public Charitable Trust & Others1 and it is necessary to test the
evidence on record in the light of the five steps enunciated in the
said judgment.
Re. the first substantial question of law:
17.
the
This aspect relates to the relationship between
deceased
Nemu
appellants/defendants.
2008 ILR KAR 2115
It
Hari
is
Patil
the
case
and
the
of
the
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
plaintiffs/respondents herein that Nemu Hari Patil had gone
in adoption and he had the suit
schedule
property
inherited from the adoptive family. It is their case that
Nemu Hari Patil was never married defendant No.1 and as
such, defendant No.2/appellant No.2 herein cannot be his
daughter. The plaintiffs contend that Nemu Hari Patil had
executed a Will in favour of the plaintiffs in respect of the
suit schedule property and in the said Will he never
mentioned about defendant No.1 to be the wife and
defendant No. 2 to be his daughter. If at all the defendants
were the wife and daughter of Nemu Hari Patil, it would
have been mentioned in the Will.
18.
Keeping aside the Will, which is disputed by the
defendants, it is necessary to look into the evidence on
record concerning the relationship between the parties. Law
in respect of the relationship of the husband and wife is
quite settled. It may be noted that the evidence that is
required to prove a relationship of husband and wife is
basically that of the marriage. The rituals of the marriage
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
constitute one of the necessary ingredients of proving such
relationship. The proof regarding the rituals gets faded as
the time lapses. The efflux of time would result in a
presumption that there exists a relationship of husband and
wife, if such relationship is accepted by the neighbours and
the society and that they lived together as husband and
wife for quite long time. The standard of evidence that is
required to prove the relationship in respect of a marriage
which is in the recent past cannot be the same. As it is
required when such relationship dates back to several years
and several decades. In the case on hand, the plaintiffs are
disputing the relationship of Nemu Hari Patil and the
defendants after his death and claiming that he had
executed a Will in their favour. It is in this background that
the evidence that was led by the plaintiffs and defendants
needs to be appreciated.
19.
Before venturing into the findings by the trial
Court as well as the First Appellate Court, it would be
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
appropriate to consider the documentary evidence which
was placed on record by the plaintiffs.
20.
Exhibit P1 is the Will allegedly executed by Nemu
Hari Patil and as noted supra, it does not mention anything
about the defendants. On the contrary, it mentions that he
has no wife or children.
21. The next document which reflects upon the such
relationship is, the Ration Card which is produced at Exhibit
P18. Evidently, Exhibit P18 does not mention the name of
the defendant Nos. 1 and 2. But on the contrary, it
mentions the name of the plaintiffs.
22.
Exhibit P19 is the extract of the Voter List for the
year 1983. In this also the name of Nemu Hari Patil is
mentioned in respect of House No. 712/1 and it does not
contain the name of the defendants.
Exhibit P20 is the
extract of the Voter List for the year 1993 and it shows that
in House No. 1 /256, name of one Ambabai, Utham and
Kalpana, (wife of Utham), are mentioned along with one
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
Siddagouda Peeragouda Patil. In other words, Ambabai is
the wife of Siddagouda Peeragouda Patil, aged about 50
years and Siddagouda was aged about 70 years. Utham is
the son of Ambabai and Siddagouda; and Kalapana is the
wife of Utham.
23.
Exhibit P21 happens to be the extract of the
Births and Deaths of a Hunnargi Village. In this, it is
mentioned that birth of a female child is recorded on
15.05.1973 and father's name is shown as Siddagouda
Peeragouda Patil and mother's name is shown as Limbabai.
The
birth was informed to the concerned authorities by
none else than the said Siddagouda. It is also relevant to
note that it was the second child born to them and Limbabai
was aged about 30 years at that time. It appears that this
document has some relevance with reference to the oral
testimony, which would be discussed later. The Exhibit P28
shows that defendant No. 1, Limbabai Dattu Shintre, had
stood
for
an
election
of
a
Co-operative
Society
at
Hunnaragi. This Model Ballot Paper of the Elections for the
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
year 1997-1998, do not mention the husband's name of
defendant No. 1 to be Nemu Hari Patil, but it mentions the
father's name of Limbabai.
24.
It
is
pertinent
to
note
that
in
the
cross-
examination of DW1, she has admitted that she had stood
for elections and her name is shown as Limbabai in the
Model Ballot Paper. Therefore, it can safely be said that
defendant No.1 was also known as Limbabai and Limbathai.
Exhibit P29 is the Panchayat extract of House No. 54 of
Hunnargi and it mentioned the holder's name to be
Limbabai daughter of Dattu shintre and it pertains to the
year 1995-1996.
25. The next important document is Exhibit P30. In
this document, which is a Birth Extract for the year 196511, on 28.11.1965, the birth of a child by name Utham was
recorded. Name of father is shown as Nemagonda Patil and
mother's name is shown as Limbabai aged about 30 years.
It also mentioned that it was her second delivery.
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
26.
Coming to the documents produced by the
defendants, Exhibit D1 appears to be a Census Report
which is in Marathi. In this, name of Balabai is shown as
daughter of Nemu Hari Patil. Extract of the school records
belonging to
defendant No.2, who is also known as
Gangutai
and
Patil
her
father's
name
is
shown
as
Namagonda. The date of birth is shown to be 01.07.1949
and that she had appeared for the SSLC examination.
Exhibit D3 is the List of the Office Bearers of Mahilamandala
Hunnaragi, wherein the name of Limbabai Nemagonda Patil
is shown to be one of the Office Bearer. The aspect that she
was a member of the Mahilamandala is admitted by DW1.
27.
Exhibit D4 happens to be the marriage Invitation
Card of defendant No.2, wherein it is stated that Gangutai,
alias Indutai was the daughter of Nemagonda Hari Patil and
she
is
the
granddaughter
of
Conspicuously, the name of
mentioned in this invitation card.
Dattu
Nana
Shintre.
defendant No. 1 is not
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
28.
It is pertinent to note that the document at
Exhibit P19, the Voters List shows the age of Nemu Hari
Patil to be 73. The voters extract for the year 1993 Exhibit
P20 shows the age of Amababai as 50 years in the year
1993. If that is so, the age of the mother of the child born
on 15.05.1973 as per Exhibit P21 shown as 30 years and it
happens to be the second delivery of the child. Child has to
be held to be not that of defendant No.1.
shows that in
Exhibit P30
November 1965, Limbabai was aged about
30 years and it was her second child, that was born on
28.11.1965. If these two documents, that is Exhibit P30 and
Exhibit 21 are compared, it appears that in the year 1973
and in the year 1965 the age of the mother cannot be 30
years and it cannot be second delivery. In other words, the
Exhibit P21 and Exhibit P30 are unreliable unless a proper
explanation is offered in this regard. However, it is relevant
to note that the name of Nemu Hari Patil finds place in the
Voters List of the year 1983 pertaining to the house
belonging to the plaintiffs. The Voters List at Exhibit P20 in
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
respect
of
Siddagouda
Peeragouda
Patil,
Ambabai
Siddagouda, Utham Siddaguoda cannot be said to be
pertaining to
defendant No.1. Obviously, Limbabai was
staying and was possessing the house bearing No. 54. But
the one mentioned for Siddagouda is 1/256. Thus, from the
documentary
evidence
available
on
record,
which
is
produced by the plaintiffs, it can safely be said that Nemu
Hari
Patil was not staying with Limbabai when his name
can be found in the Voters List of the house belonging to
the plaintiffs. But it doesn't show that Limbabai was not his
wife. This takes us to oral testimony of the witnesses.
29.
Defendant No.1 deposed before the trial Court as
DW1. She states that her parents' place is Hunnargi and she
is married to Nemu Hari Patil. She states that the
ceremonies
were
performed
and
she
narrates
those
ceremonies in detail. She states that after marriage she
lived with Nemu Hari Patil for 2 years and out of the
wedlock, defendant No. 2 was born. She was born at
Hunnargi in the year 1950. She contends that she had
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
differences with the mother-in-law and therefore, she left
the matrimonial home and started staying with her father in
her parental house. She states that Nemu Hari Patil
was
never residing with the plaintiffs and this statement is
falsified by the Voters List which has been produced by the
plaintiffs.
30.
In her examination-in-chief, she also states that
she is working as the President of the Mahilamandal
Hunnaragi and her name is entered in the Voters List of
Hunnaragi Village. In all the records, her name is shown as
wife of Nemu Hari Patil. Interestingly, the defendants do not
produce any Voters List which shows that her name is
mentioned as Limbabai wife of Nemu Hari Patil, despite, she
states that her name appears in the Voters List. She states
that the villagers had recognised her as a wife of Nemu Hari
Patil and
in none of the records her name was shown as
daughter of Dattu Shintre. Again this aspect is falsified by
the Panchayat extract which is at Exhibit P29. She also
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
denies that she was never married to one Siddagouda of
Hunnaragi, Siddu Boje or Doulu Patil of Hunnargi.
31.
In the cross examination, which is elaborate, she
is not known in the village as daughter of Dattu Shintre.
She admits that in an earlier suit filed by the Bank for
recovery of the loan, she had appeared and her name was
shown as Limbabai Dattu Shintre and the said suit was filed
in the year 1994-1995. She also admits Exhibit P29 the
house property extract wherein her name is shown as
Limbatai Dattu Shintre. She admits the Model Ballot Paper
concerning Lakshmi Narayana Milk Diary, Hunnarigi, where
she was known as Limbabai Dattu Shintre. She vehemently
denies that she had lived with Siddagouda Peeragouda Patil
and that she has given birth to a child from him. Therefore,
it is clear that the contention of the plaintiffs that she lived
as the wife of Siddagouda Peeragouda Patil is not proved.
Though she denies the suggestion in the cross examination
that Nemu Hari Patil was residing with the plaintiffs and his
sister Dhondubai for last 50 years, she says that he was
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
residing in a separate house and she do not know the
panchayat number of the said house. She states that death
of Nemu Hari Patil was informed by one Yamunabhai and
then she attended the funeral.
32.
The testimony of DW2, who is none other than
defendant No. 2 is on similar lines. She states that she is
also called as Balabai and she was admitted to the school
and in the school records, the name of her father was
shown as Nemagonda. She states that Nemagonda is none
else than Nemu Hari Patil. According to the defendants, the
date of birth is shown as 01.07.1949 in the school records.
But in fact the date of birth of defendant No.2 is contended
to
be
21.09.1950.
Obviously,
the
two
birth
extracts
produced by the plaintiffs do not pertain to either the year
1949 or the year 1950.
33.
DW3- Yamunabai appears to be the cousin of the
said Nemu Hari Patil. Though she states that she is his
sister, in the cross-examination it is elicited that she is a
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
cousin. She has supported the case of the
defendants
contending that Nemu Hari Patil was married to defendant
No. 1 and that the defendant No. 2 was born out of the
wedlock of Nemu Hari Patil and the defendant No.1. She
states that she was aged 15 years at the time of the
marriage of defendant No. 1 and
Nemu Hari Patil.
Conspicuously, she states that she do not know about the
number of brothers in the genitive family of Nemu Hari Patil
and she do not know about the genitive father of Nemu Hari
Patil and his brothers. She states that genitive mother was
one Kashi Bai and that she is not daughter of sister of Kashi
Bai. She also states that she is not the daughter of the
genitive
uncle
of
Nemu
Hari
Patil.
Therefore,
the
relationship between Yamunabai and Nemu Hari Patil is not
clearly stated by her either in the examination-chief or in
the cross-examination and therefore, it is difficult to accept
that she had the knowledge about the plaintiffs and
knowledge about the relationship of defendant No.1 with
Nemu Hari Patil.
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
34. DW4 happens to be another witness who is aged
about 70 years and claims to be present at the marriage of
defendant No. 1 and Nemu Hari Patil. He states that the
marriage was performed in the year 1948 at Sadalaga. He
speaks about the various rituals that were conducted during
the marriage and in a cross-examination he states that he
do not know how many children
defendant No.1 has got
and he denies that Utham is the son born to defendant No.
1 from Siddagouda.
35. From
the
above
oral
testimonies
of
the
witnesses, it is evident that when the plaintiffs have denied
the relationship of defendant No. 1 with Nemu Hari Patil and
with certain clarity they have established that Nemu Hari
Patil had never recognised defendant Nos. 1 and 2 as wife
and daughter. It was the burden of proving that Nemu Hari
Patil was unmarried, appears to have been discharged by
them. Moreover, it is an admitted fact by defendant No.1
that she resided with Nemu Hari Patil only for 2 years and
thereafter, she never resided with him. It is also evident
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
that defendant No.1 was known as Limbabai daughter of
Dattu Shintre and she never proclaimed herself to be the
wife of Nemu Hari Patil. Therefore, for years, defendant
No.1 had distanced herself from such a relationship. This
takes us to a requirement of a clinching evidence to show
that defendant No.1 Limbatai had lived with Nemu Hari Patil
as a wife at least for few years, during which she had
begotten defendant No.2. The discrepancy in the name of
the father of the defendant as Nemagonda is clear. Nowhere
defendant No. 2 was mentioned to be daughter of Nemu
Hari Patil. She was known as daughter of Nemagonda.
Except the marriage invitation card, where the name of
Nemgonda again is shown and she happens to be the
granddaughter of Dattu Shintre, the name of Nemu Hari
Patil is not mentioned. The question whether Nemagonda
and Nemu Hari Patil are one and the same has not been
established by the defendants by any evidence. Nemu Hari
Patil and Nemagonda Patil are to be shown to be one and
the same person in order to take mileage of the school
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
records of defendant No.2 and the marriage invitation card.
Therefore, from the available evidence on record, the
relationship of defendant No.1 and the school records with
Nemu Hari Patil appears to be weak and unacceptable. On
the part of the plaintiffs, they have made an effort to place
on record that Limbabai had lived with one Siddagouda and
she had begotten children from them. But the Birth Extracts
of the children do not instill confidence in the said
proposition.
36.
However, the fact that Nemu Hari Patil had not
lived with defendant No. 1 has been established by two
aspects. One is that the Will executed by Nemu Hari Patil do
not mention that defendant No. 1 and defendant No. 2 are
the wife and daughter. Secondly, the Voters List and the
Ration Card show that Nemu Hari Patil had lived with the
plaintiffs in their house. Therefore, the testimony of DW1, is
not convincing since she says that in none of the records
her name is shown as Limbabai, daughter of Dattu Shintre.
But on the contrary several documents are there to show
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
that she is known as Limbabai daughter of Dattu Shintre.
There are several documents in this regard and admissions
by
defendant No.1 that she is known as Limbabai Dattu
Shintre, but not as Limbabai wife of Nemu Hari Patil.
37.
Under these circumstances, the trial Court is
justified in holding that the relationship of the defendants
with Nemu Hari Patil as wife and daughter is not available
and therefore, such relationship cannot be accepted. In the
result, doubting the relationship of the defendants with
Nemu Hari Patil is based on the available material on record
and none of the evidence has been ignored by the trial
Court as well as the First Appellate Court. In the result, the
first substantial question of law has to be held in the
negative that there is no error in the finding.
Re. second substantial question of law:
38. The plaintiffs contend that Nemu Hari Patil had
executed the Will in favour of the plaintiffs as per Exhibit
P1. the property that was standing in the name of Nemu
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
Hari Patil was belonging to his adoptive family and he had
inherited the same. This aspect is not in dispute. The trial
Court in Paras 8, 9 and 10 discuss the evidence of PW1 to
PW3 in detail and it has analysed the Exhibit P1 also and it
comes to the conclusion in paragraph 12 that the evidence
of PW2 and PW3 goes to show that PW1 was present at the
time of the execution of Exhibit P1, but he had not taken
any active participation in execution of the Will. It is worth
to note that the trial Court, having come to the conclusion
that
the
relationship
has
not
been
proved,
the
disinheritance of the defendants from the legacy of Nemu
Hari Patil cannot be a suspicious circumstance. Moreover,
even if it is held that defendant No.1 and defendant No.2
are the wife and daughter of Nemu Hari Patil, it is an
admitted fact by DW1 that she was not staying with Nemu
Hari Patil for quite long time. Within two years of marriage
she had distanced herself away from Nemu Hari Patil and
this definitely might have prompted Nemu Hari Patil to
bequeath
his
properties
in
favour
of
the
plaintiffs.
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
Therefore, disinheriting defendant Nos. 1 and 2 from the
legacy
of
Nemu
Hari
Patil
cannot
be
a
suspicious
circumstance. This aspect has also been considered by the
trial Court. The evidence of PW2 and PW3, as analysed by
the trial Court, shows that they have stated about the due
execution of the Will at Exhibit P1 by Nemu Hari Patil and
after he acknowledging the contents of the Will, they have
signed the same. It may be noted that Exhibit P1 is a
registered Will and there is nothing to indicate that the Will
is concocted. The attesting witnesses as well as the scribe
of the Will have been examined by the plaintiffs and their
testimony is in no way impeached by the plaintiffs.
39.
The trial Court, while discussing Issue Nos. 1, 3
and Additional Issue No. 1 notes that there are no such
suspicious circumstances surrounding the execution of the
Will. The testimony of PW2 shows that he had seen Nemu
Hari Patil signing the said Will after acknowledging the
contents of it and that was in the presence of another
witness to the Will. Therefore, due attestation has been
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
proved. This finding of the trial Court has been affirmed by
the First Appellate Court. Though the judgment of the First
Appellate Court is cryptic and short, it cannot be said that it
is incorrect. Both the Courts below have considered the
necessary
ingredients
of
Section
of
the
Indian
Succession Act and Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act
and have concurrently found that the Will has been proved
and there are no suspicious circumstances. Even if we
examine the testimony of PW1 to PW3 in the light of the
tests laid down by this Court in the case of Sri J.T.
Surappa
&
Another
Vs.
Sri
Satchidhanandendra
Saraswathi Swamiji Public Charitable Trust & Others
referred supra, there is nothing which would show that the
Will was either concocted, it was without the consent and
knowledge of the testator, or that it was obtained under
suspicious circumstances. Mere presence of the plaintiffs at
the time of execution of the Will cannot be a suspicious
circumstance when it is clearly stated that
PW1 did not
know for what purpose Nemu Hari Patil had called them. It
- 32 NC: 2026:KHC-D:792
RSA No. 5626 of 2009
HC-KAR
is worth to note that under these circumstances, the second
substantial question of law concerning the Will has to be
held in favour of the plaintiffs. Obviously, the Courts below
have not committed any error in appreciating the evidence
on the record. Hence, the second substantial question of
law is also held in the negative.
40.
In the result, the appeal is bereft of any merits
and it is dismissed.
Sd/(C M JOSHI)
JUDGE
tsn*
List No.: 19 Sl No.: 6
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review