The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
1. 2.2013 (Exhibit A-6) in which the registration number of the truck bearing No.MP09/GF/7750 was also mentioned and so far as deposition of Ramendra Singh (PW-2) is concerned, he has been cross examined by counsel for the insurance company and has clearly denied that the accident has not taken place with the truck bearing registration No.MP09/GF/7750, and has also denied that a false case has been lodged by him to obtain the claim on account of death of the deceased-Bhawani Singh, who happens to be his uncle. 5] Counsel for the appellants has submitted that the learned Member of the claims tribunal has also erred in not assessing the loss suffered by the appellants and has dismissed the claim only on the ground that the accident with the truck bearing registration No.MP09/GF/7750 is not proved. It is also submitted that the deceased was earning a sum of Rs.15,500/- as a Supervisor with a contractor Ajay Solanki, who has also been examined as (PW-3), who has also given a salary certificate Exhibit A-17 of the of Rs.15,500/- which he used to give to the deceased, and thus, it is submitted that the claims tribunal ought to have decided the dependency taking note of the aforesaid monthly income and ought to have applied the multiplier of 14 looking to the age of the deceased as according to the postmortem report the age of the deceased was 45 years. It is also submitted that consorti…
15. 1.2013 whereas the FIR has been lodged on 1.2.2013 on a written complaint made by Ramendra Singh (PW-2). It is true that the initially the registration number of the offending truck was not informed to the police, however, it has been mentioned by Ramendra Singh (PW-2) for the first time in his written complaint dated 1.2.2013. It is also found that the truck was also seized during the course of investigation, and its driver Kalu/respondent no.1 was also arrested. However, the insurance company has made no efforts to examine the driver and owner of the truck, who could have thrown some light on the incident. 12] In such circumstances, merely because the registration number was informed subsequently, it cannot be said that the delay is so fatal so as to demolish the case of the claimants. It has to be borne in mind that the evidence has to be weighed on the principle of ‘preponderance of probability’, and not on the basis of principle of “beyond reasonable doubt”. In such circumstances, this Court is of the considered opinion that the learned Member of MACT has erred in rejecting the claim on the ground that the accident did not take place with the offending truck bearing registration No.M.P.-09/GH7750. 13] So far as the compensation which shall be granted to the claimants is concerned, it is found that the learned Member of the MACT has not cared to assess the compensation only…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUBODH ABHYANKAR
ON THE 18th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. APPEAL No. 1867 of 2016
BETWEEN:SMT.KUSUM W/O LATE BHAWANI
SINGH CHANDRAWAT, AGED ABOUT 42
YEARS, OCCUPATION: HOUSEWIFE
1.
GALI NO.4 RATNESHWAR ROAD
RATLAM,
TEH.RATLAM
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
KU ANKITA D/O LATE BHAWANI SINGH
CHANDRAWAT, AGED ABOUT
2. YEARS, GALI NO 4, TANESHWAR ROAD,
RATLAM, TEH AND DISTT RATLAM
(MADHYA PRADESH)
KU GOMTI D/O LATE BHAWANI SINGH
CHANDRAWAT, AGED ABOUT
3. YEARS, GALI NO 4 , RATNESHWAR
ROAD, RATLAM , TEH AND DSITT
RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANTS
SHRI MOHAN SHARMA, ADVOCATE
AND
KALU @ KALURAM S/O GANESHLAL
PALIWAL, AGED ABOUT 24 YEARS,
1.
M.B.38,
VINA
NAGAR
INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
NEW INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY
2. LTD. STATION ROAD, RATLAM DSITT
RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
SHRI ANIL GOYAL, ADVOCATE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 19-01-2024
09:51:48
Reserved on :
22/11/2023
Pronounced on :
18/01/2024
This appeal coming on for judgment this day, the court passed the
following:
JUDGMENT
1]
Heard finally, with the consent of the parties.
2]
This miscellaneous appeal has been filed under Section 173
(1) of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (in short 'the Act of 1988')
against the award dated 31/08/2016, passed in Motor Accident
Claim Case No.84/2013 by Additional Member MACT, District
Ratlam (M.P.) whereby, the claim of the appellant, has been
rejected.
3]
In brief, the facts of the case are that the accident in the
present case took place on 15.1.2013, at Mhow Neemuch
Highway road where the deceased Bhawani Singh, who was
going
on
his
motorcycle
bearing
registration
No.
MP-43/MC6783, from Badnawar to Ratlam, rammed into a truck
bearing registration MPNo.09/GF/7750 from behind as the driver
of the said truck suddenly applied break, as a result, the deceased
suffered head injuries and died on the spot. Subsequently, the
claimants filed the claim case to get the compensation on account
of death of the deceased Bhawani Singh, who was aged 45 years,
and the learned Member of the Claims Tribunal, after recording
the evidence has rejected the claim on the ground that the
appellants/claimants could not prove the accident.
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 19-01-2024
09:51:48
4]
Counsel for the appellants has submitted that the claims
Tribunal has rejected the claim mainly on the ground of delay in
lodging the FIR as the date of incident is of 15.1.2013 whereas
the FIR has been lodged on 1.2.2013 on a written complaint made
by Ramendra Singh (PW-2). It is further submitted that after the
death of the deceased, a Marg was also registered which is also
placed on record as Exhibit A-1 on the basis of the intimation
sent by Civil Hospital Ratlam, whereas the FIR was lodged on
1.2.2013 (Exhibit A-6) in which the registration number of the
truck bearing No.MP09/GF/7750 was also mentioned and so far
as deposition of Ramendra Singh (PW-2) is concerned, he has
been cross examined by counsel for the insurance company and
has clearly denied that the accident has not taken place with the
truck bearing registration No.MP09/GF/7750, and has also denied
that a false case has been lodged by him to obtain the claim on
account of death of the deceased-Bhawani Singh, who happens to
be his uncle.
5]
Counsel for the appellants has submitted that the learned
Member of the claims tribunal has also erred in not assessing the
loss suffered by the appellants and has dismissed the claim only
on the ground that the accident with the truck bearing registration
No.MP09/GF/7750 is not proved. It is also submitted that the
deceased was earning a sum of Rs.15,500/- as a Supervisor with a
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 19-01-2024
09:51:48
contractor Ajay Solanki, who has also been examined as (PW-3),
who has also given a salary certificate Exhibit A-17 of the of
Rs.15,500/- which he used to give to the deceased, and thus, it is
submitted that the claims tribunal ought to have decided the
dependency taking note of the aforesaid monthly income and
ought to have applied the multiplier of 14 looking to the age of
the deceased as according to the postmortem report the age of the
deceased was 45 years. It is also submitted that consortium
amount ought to have also been assessed by the Claims Tribunal
and on the other heads also the amount ought to have been
awarded, but it has also not even been assessed as the learned
Claims Tribunal has only reflected upon one issue that is, whether
the aforesaid accident has taken place with the aforesaid truck.
6]
Shir Anil Goyal, learned counsel for the respondent
Insurance Company, on the other hand, has opposed the prayer
and it is submitted that no case for interference is made out as the
learned Member of the claims tribunal has rightly passed the
order as the insurance company has been wrongly involved in the
case on the basis of a complaint which was lodged after a period
of 15 days.
7]
Shri Goyal has further submitted that there was no reason
for the complainant to remember the registration number of the
truck when he also did not inform the same to the police
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 19-01-2024
09:51:48
immediately after the incident, and, the complainant has also not
examined the owner of the truck.
8]
Shri Goyal has also drawn attention of this Court to the
deposition of Ramendra Singh (PW-2), who has lodged the FIR,
and has also stated that he had gone to the police station a couple
of times but did not inform the police about the vehicle involved,
even at the time when he had taken the articles of the deceased
from the police station.
9]
Counsel for the respondent Insurance company has also
submitted that even assuming that the witness was present on the
spot he has also stated that on the highway, the offending truck
was going in a different lane and the motorcycle of the deceased
was on a different lane. In such circumstances, there was no
occasion for the offending truck to collide with the deceased’s
motorcycle. It is also submitted that so far as the income of
deceased is concerned Ajay Solanki (PW-3) has not produced any
register or any other documents to demonstrate that the deceased
was an employee, and hence the certificate produced by him is
Exhibit A-17 is also a concocted documents and thus, no
interference is called for and the appeal is liable to be dismissed.
10] Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 19-01-2024
09:51:48
11]
From the record it is found that the accident took place on
15.1.2013 whereas the FIR has been lodged on 1.2.2013 on a
written complaint made by Ramendra Singh (PW-2). It is true
that the initially the registration number of the offending truck
was not informed to the police, however, it has been mentioned
by Ramendra Singh (PW-2) for the first time in his written
complaint dated 1.2.2013. It is also found that the truck was also
seized during the course of investigation, and its driver
Kalu/respondent no.1 was also arrested. However, the insurance
company has made no efforts to examine the driver and owner of
the truck, who could have thrown some light on the incident.
12]
In such circumstances, merely because the registration
number was informed subsequently, it cannot be said that the
delay is so fatal so as to demolish the case of the claimants. It has
to be borne in mind that the evidence has to be weighed on the
principle of ‘preponderance of probability’, and not on the basis
of
principle
of
“beyond
reasonable
doubt”.
In
such
circumstances, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
learned Member of MACT has erred in rejecting the claim on the
ground that the accident did not take place with the offending
truck bearing registration No.M.P.-09/GH7750.
13] So far as the compensation which shall be granted to the
claimants is concerned, it is found that the learned Member of the
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 19-01-2024
09:51:48
MACT has not cared to assess the compensation only on the
ground that the accident itself has not been proved. Thus, this
Court is also required to see the income of the deceased at the
time of the incident, and other factor having bearing on the
compensation. From the record, it is found that the deceased was
45 years old, and thus the multiplier of 14 can be implied in the
present case. So far as the salary of the deceased is concern
although the claimants have examined Ajay Solanki PW-3, who
was a proprietor of “Osani Construction and Engineers” and has
proved the salary certificate (Exhibit A-17) certifying that the
deceased was earning Rs.15,500/- per month. However, on
perusal of his deposition clearly reveals that apart from the
aforesaid certificate no other documents have been placed on
record that the deceased was working in this firm as a supervisor,
and neither the salary register nor any other documents to
demonstrate that such salary was indeed paid to the deceased
every month.
14] In such circumstances, the income of the deceased cannot
be treated to be Rs.15,500/-, and also that he was working as a
supervisor, hence, in the absence of any other evidence his
income has to be treated as notional income only, and the fact that
the accident has taken place on 15.1.2013, his income can be
considered on the basis of the guidelines issued by the
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 19-01-2024
09:51:48
M.P.State Legal Services Authority, which comes to Rs.4945/for unskilled worker, with addition of 25% towards future
prospects.
The assessment made by this Court is as under :Dependency 4945 + FP 25% (1236.25)=Rs.6,92,300/6181.25 x 12=74175 x 14=1038450 x 2/3 =
Loss of consortium to wife=
Rs.44,000/Parental Loss (for daughters)=
Rs.88,000/Funeral Expenses-=
Rs.16,500/Loss of estate
Rs.16,500/TOTAL
RS.8,57,300/-
15]
In view of the above, the appeal stands allowed, and the
appellants shall be entitled to receive an amount of Rs.8,57,300/towards the compensation along with interest from the date of
filing of the claim petition.
16]
With the aforesaid, the appeal stands partly allowed and
disposed of.
(SUBODH ABHYANKAR)
JUDGE
das
Signed by: REENA SUDHIR
DAS
Signing time: 19-01-2024
09:51:48
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review