Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) 942/2022
Smt. Kalpita Sutradhar
…..Petitioner
Versus
The State of Tripura and 6 ors.
…..Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate
Mr. P. Debbarma, Advocate
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, GA
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Order
25/01/2023
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. P.
Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. D.
Bhattacharjee, learned GA, assisted by Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents-State.
2.
By means of filing this writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for the
following reliefs:
“(i)
Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to show cause
as to why a Writ of Certiorari and/or in the nature thereof, for directing the
respondents, to transmit the records, appertaining to this writ petition, lying with
them, for rendering substantive and conscionable justice to the petitioner, and for
quashing/setting aside the impugned Notification dated 27.11.2020 & the impugned
Notification dated 11.02.2022 (Annexure 5, 6 & 9 respectively supra) insofar as the
same does not include the name of the petitioner;
(ii)
Issue Rule, calling upon the respondents and each one of them, to show cause
as to why a Writ of Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, for mandating/directing
the respondents, to forthwith revoke/rescind the impugned notification dated
27.11.2020 & the impugned notification dated 11.02.2022 (Annexures- 5, 6 & 9)
respectively supra) insofar as the same does not include the name of the petitioner,
and further, for mandating/directing them, to issue Offer of Appointment, in favour of
the petitioner, in tune with the statutory mandate, contained in Tripura Scheduled
Castes and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Act, 1991 & the Tripura Scheduled Castes
and Scheduled Tribes Reservation Rules, 1992;
(iii)
Call for the records appertaining to this petition;
(iv)
After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the Rule Absolute in terms of i.
& ii. above;
(v)
Cost of and incidental to this proceeding;
(vi)
Any other Relief(s) as to this Hon’ble High Court may deem fit and proper”.
3.
Briefly stated, initially a notification was issued by the respondent-
State for filling up of vacant post of Post Graduate Teacher in connection
with filling up 12 (twelve) numbers of vacant posts of Post Graduate
Teacher in Music subject. Out of the said 12 posts, 6 (six) posts are meant
for UR candidates, 2 (two) for SC candidates and 3 (three) for ST
candidates. Subsequently, by advertisement dated 02.03.2019 online
application was invited for filling up of 10 vacant posts for the subject
‘Music’ out of which 4 posts are for UR candidates, 2 for SC candidates and
4 for ST candidates. Following the recruitments made by TRBT in the year
2018 and 2019 by a notification dated 27.11.2020 it was enumerated that out
of 7 vacancies, 1 post is for UR candidates, 2 posts are for SC candidates
and 4 posts are for ST candidates. Thereafter, TRBT issued a notification on
22.12.2021 enumerating subject wise cut-off marks. It is the further case of
the petitioner that for publication of subject-wise merit list selection for the
post of Post Graduate teacher, 2020, TRBT issued a notification dated
11.02.2022 selecting 3 candidates belonging from SC category.
4.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the petitioner has
brought on record the number of years and the posts that were carry forward,
in a tabular form, which is as under:“
Year
Total Vacancies
UR
6 (50%)
SC
ST
Remarks
2 (16.66%) 4 (33.33%) Excess reservation
for ST: None found
eligible
12 (totally
carried
forward)
6 (50%)
10 (12-2=10
carried
forward)
4 (40%)
7 (10-3=7
carried
forward)
1st carry forward in
the next recruitment
year:
Excess reservation
for ST:
2 UR found eligible
2 (20%)
4 (40%)
2nd carry forward in
the next recruitment
year impermissible:
Excess reservation
for SCs & STs:
Further 3 UR found
eligible
2 (28.57%) 4 (57.14%) 3rd carry forward in
the next recruitment
year impermissible:
Excess reservation
for SCs & STs
2 (16.66%) 4 (33.33%)
”
5.
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned GA appearing on behalf of respondents-
State has not disputed the facts mentioned in the above table regarding
carrying forward of the posts.
6.
It is pertinent to mention herein that Clause (c) of sub-rule 8 of Rule 8
of the Tripura Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Reservation of
Vacancies in Services and Posts) Rules, 1992 [for short, the Rule, 1992]
clearly stipulates that the reserved vacant posts shall be carried forward to
the next recruitment year.
7.
A Division Bench of this court has interpreted this provision in case
no. W.A. 458 of 2020 and others [titled as Pankaj Bhowmik vs. The State
of Tripura and others], wherein it was held that in the first recruitment year
the competent authority may undertake so many recruitment processes, as
they desire. After end of the said first recruitment year, the reserved vacant
category of posts can be carried forward in terms of sub-rule 8(c) of Rule 8
of the said Rules, 1992, that is, during the next recruitment year, but, not in
the subsequent years.
8.
In this case, admittedly, the first recruitment year for recruiting Music
teacher was in the year 2017. The posts could not be filled up due to nonavailability of the eligible reserved candidates. The said posts of Music
teacher under reserved category were carried forward during the year 2018.
That time also no eligible reserved category candidates were found.
Thereafter, these posts were further carried forward in the year 2019-20,
which is contrary to the statute as provided under sub-rule 8(c) of Rule 8 of
the Rules, 1992.
9.
The Division Bench in the case of Pankaj Bhowmik (supra)
explained and interpreted the provision under sub-rule 8(c) of Rule 8 of the
Rules, 1992, as under:
“19. Under the second amendment Rules,2007 the State’s lawmakers only
preferred to limit their exercise to the extent of the insertion of the words
“vacant posts” in clause (c) of sub-rule 8 of Rule 8 of Rules,1992, which reads as
under:
“(c) If the required number of candidates are not available even after
further attempt within a recruitment year the reserved [vacant posts] shall
be carried forward to the next recruitment year”.
20. The language of this provision, according to us, is very clear and
unambiguous. The well-neigh principle is that Rule of “literal construction” is
the safe rule and should be followed unless the language used is contradictory,
ambiguous, or leads really to absurd results. Besides, legislation is always to be
understood first in accordance with its plain meaning. A plain reading of subrule 8(c) of Rule 8 of amended Rules, 2007 makes it clear that despite Clause
(4-B) of Article 16 of the Constitution of India, the State Government had
consciously taken a decision that the unfilled vacancies if not filled up within a
recruitment year, the reserved [vacant posts] shall be carried forward to the
next recruitment year. In other words, the law-makers wanted to limit carry
forward rule to fill up the reserved [vacant posts] i.e. backlog vacancies up to
the next recruitment year only and not in any further subsequent/succeeding
years. It is clarified that the expression “if the required vacancies of candidates
are not available even after further attempt within a recruitment year” would
mean and connote that the authorities concerned can exercise the process of
recruitment indicating the unfilled backlog vacancies for a number of times
within the same year i.e. initial/first recruitment year.
21. On careful reading of sub-rule 8(c) of Rule 8 of the Rules, 1992 as amended
in 2007, we are of the considered opinion that while Article 16 (4-B) had given
wide discretion upon the State Government/Legislature for enacting any law to
decide the number of year or years up to which unfilled vacancies will be
carried forward, the State Government under Clause (c) of sub-rule (8) of Rule
8 of the Rules,1992 legislated that in case the required number of candidates
are not available even after further attempt within a recruitment year, the
reserved vacant posts shall be carried forward to the next recruitment year.
22. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dr. Jaishri Laxmanrao Patil (supra) it was
held [per majority] while interpreting a newly inserted provision which was
enacted to bring it in alignment with existing pari materia provisions, the Court
should not be unmindful of the existing constitutional provisions. When
constitutional amendments introduce new definition, judicial interpretation
has leaned in favour of giving literal meaning to the terms used which had led
to change. The Supreme Court on numerous occasions has given full literal
effect to the terms of the amendment brought in by the legislature, after
understanding the rationale for the change.
23. By now, it is well-settled that when a power is given to do a certain thing in
a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not all [AIR 1936 PC
253(2)]. In the case of Ramchandra Keshab Adke Vrs. Govind Joti Chavare,
reported in AIR 1975 SC 915, the apex court held that when a power is given to
do certain thing in a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at
all and that other methods of performance are necessarily forbidden. In the
instant cases, the advertising department, i.e. the Director of Health Services,
Govt. of Tripura, the respondent no.2 in both the appeals and the respondent
no.5 in the writ petition, have no power to carry forward backlog vacancies
years after years, which if allowed, will be in direct conflict with the provisions
encrypted in the Rules, 1992. Such unauthorized act of the Director of Health
Services, Government of Tripura in both the appeals and the Member
Secretary, Teacher’s Recruitment Board, Tripura, Office of the School
Education, Govt. of Tripura, in the writ petition, had given undue advantage to
the reserved category of candidates which offends the equality clause in the
matter of appointment as enshrined under Article 16 of the Constitution of
India. The action of the official respondents invites inequality amongst the
equals. The official respondents ought to have taken into account that relevant
provision under Clause (c) of sub-rule (8) of Rule 8 of the Rules, 1992 clearly
provides carry forward rule to fill up he backlog vacancies only limited up to
the next recruitment year as stated above in para 20 of this judgment. Thus, by
way of by-passing the mandatory provision of sub-rule(c) of sub-rule (8) of Rule
8 of SC & ST Rules, 1992, the official respondents have committed a vital
mistake in overlooking statutory dictum as provided therein. The Staterespondents ought not have violated the statutory provisions. It is well settled
that there is no estoppel against law or statute. We have noticed, in the instant
cases, statutory violation ought to have subsisting since inception, i.e., since
the date of publication of the employment notification for filling up the
vacancies in the posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) under the Directorate of
Health Services.
24. In our considered view, since the official respondents acted contrary to law
and in contravention of the Rules,1992 (as amended in 2007), they had violated
the statutory provisions, and in that case, the respondents are prohibited to
take the plea of estoppels to defend such unlawful act. Clause(c) of sub-rule (8)
of Rule 8 of the Rules,1992 is such provision which cannot be waived or
dispensed with on the ground of estoppel and if such violation is permitted,
then, it would ultimately tantamount to repeal the provision which is inserted
in the statutory rule with a view to uphold constitutional ethos. Doctrine of
estoppel is founded on the principles of equity and the issues of constitutional
validity cannot be thwarted, by applying the doctrine of estoppel. Bearing in
mind the aforesaid principle, we are unable to agree with the decision of
learned Single Judge that the challenge made by the petitioners suffers from
the doctrine of estoppel.
25. In the above conspectus, the conclusion is inevitable that the official
respondents have breached the mandatory provision embodied in Clause(c) of
sub-rule (s) of Rule 8 of the Rules, 1992 (Second amendment,2007) in following
the carry forward rule to fill up the unfilled vacancies in the posts of
Pharmacist (Allopathy) from reserved category of candidates in succeeding
recruitment years including the current recruitment under employment
notification dated 30.10.2013, issued by the Director of Health Services and the
notification dated 15.07.2022 issued by the respondent no.3 in the writ
petition. It is clearly held under Clause(c) of sub-rule(8) of Rule 8 of SC & ST
Rules, 1992 that unfilled reserved backlog vacancies shall be carried forward
only after the first recruitment year in any posts and not in the succeeding
years.
26. Under Clause(c) of sub-rule (8) of Rule 8 of the Rules, 1992 the State is
barred to apply carry forward rule to clear backlog vacancies of reserved
category candidates beyond next recruitment year. We make it clear that “next
recruitment year” means the year followed by the first recruitment process in
a particular year. As for example, a department issues an employment
notification in the year 2021 for filling up of 100 posts in a particular category.
For this purpose, 50% have been kept reserved for reserved category
candidates as per the State’s roster. After completion of the said selection
process, the department finds only 30 candidates eligible for filling up the said
posts identified for reserved category candidates. Remaining 20 (twenty)
unfilled posts, if kept vacant, these will be treated as “backlog vacancies”. If
the required numbers of candidates are not available, then, the authorities
concerned may make further attempts to fill up the unfilled vacancies within
the same year i.e. initial/first recruitment year. Now, suppose, in the year
2023, Govt. has created another 150 posts of the same category. Out of these
150 posts, 50% posts will be kept reserved for reserved category candidates
and further, 20 unfilled vacancies of 2021 will be added to determine the total
vacancies meant for reserved category candidates and it would be 75 +20 = 95
that is, 95 posts which will be kept reserved because it will be the next
recruitment year i.e. 2nd recruitment year followed by the first recruitment
year 2021. Again, suppose, out of 95 posts the department may find 80
candidates suitable for appointment, which means that 15 vacancies belonging
to reserved category have not been filled up. Thereafter, the department again
has issued fresh employment notification in the year 2025 for filling up 50
vacancies of the same category of posts. The department as usual will notify
50% vacancies for candidates belonging to unreserved category. But, in that
recruitment year, i.e.2025, if the department tries to fill up the backlog
vacancies of 15 which could not be filled up in the year 2023, by way of
following carry forward rule, then, it will violate the mandatory provision as
contemplated in Clause (c) of sub-rule (8) of Rule 8 of the Rules, 1992 as
amended by second amendment, 2007.
27. In the cases in hand, we find no inconsistency or irrationality to the
legislation brought in by the State Government under sub-Rule 8(c) of Rule 8 of
amended Rules, 2007. The State Government was well aware of the fact that
the object and purpose of insertion of Article 16(4-B) by way of Eighty-first
Amendment of the Constitution of India is to enable the State Governments to
legislate its own law considering the socioeconomic scenario of the State as
well as overall efficiency in administration as enshrined in Article 335 of the
Constitution of India.
28. In the opinion of this court, when the State law-makers had clear intention
to apply carry forward rule for clearing the “backlog vacancies” up to the next
recruitment year, that is, after the initial recruitment year, the court has no
jurisdiction to read and construe/interpret it otherwise which will definitely
defeat the object and purpose of the legislation brought in by the State lawmakers under Sub- Rule 8(c) of Rule 8 of amended Rules, 2007. We re-iterate
that the State legislature has thought it fair and just to apply the carry forward
rule only up to the next recruitment year and not years any further or
subsequent years. (emphasis supplied)
29. It is evident from the counter affidavits and additional counter affidavits
filed by the State-respondents as well as the submission of learned G.A. that
‘backlog vacancies’ to fill up the post of reserved category candidates are being
carried forward for a number of recruitment years after introduction of SC & ST
Act and the Rules,1992. According to us, it is inconsistent to and in
contravention to Clause (c) of sub-rule 8 of Rule 8 of amended Rules, 2007.
Therefore, this is a continuous breach of a statutory provision which escaped
the notice of the executives who have the primary duty to strictly adhere to
the legislative decision encrypted in the statute, and therefore, must be
stopped here to prevent further breach of legislative intent and object of the
legislatures to protect the interest of public in general for whose interest
particular legislation was introduced. The State-respondents have committed a
serious error in law to identify and keep 60 seats for reserved category
candidates out of total 73 posts for filling up the vacant posts of Pharmacist
(Allopathy), which is the subject matter in both the appeals; so also the subject
matter of the writ petition where out of 230 posts of Graduate Teachers, 201
numbers of posts were kept reserved for SC and ST candidates. We may in the
context of the case, unhesitatingly hold that reservation in excess of 50%
ceiling limit is inconsistent and contrary to law as contemplated under SubRule 8(c) of Rule 8 of Rules, 1992.
30. This Court in WP(C) No. 736 of 2022, by way of interim order asked the
respondents to continue the selection process, but, not to declare the results
of the examination. As we have already held in the above writ appeals that
ceiling limit of 50% cannot be breached in any manner whatsoever, in the
succeeding recruitment years beyond the second year of recruitment followed
by the first recruitment year. It is evident that so many recruitment processes
for recruitment of Graduate Teachers in many subsequent recruitment years
since the enactment of “Rules, 1992” have already been undertaken for filling
up reserved vacant posts i.e. the backlog vacancies of Graduate Teachers by
way of applying the carry forward rule, which exercise, according to us, were
carried out in direct contravention to Clause (c) of sub-rule 8 of Rule 8 of the
Rules,1992. In our considered view, the mistakes already committed by the
State executives in filling up the posts of Graduate Teachers in the State as
aforestated is unrepairable; however, such illegalities committed by the
respondents-authorities during the previous years cannot be permitted to
perpetuate by continuous mistake.
31. Here, we shall be failing to our solemn duty if we do not stop the
recurrence of such flouting of a statutory provision as enshrined in subrule 8(c)
of Rule 8 of the Rules,1992. It is for this reason such illegal exercise or practice
must be stopped here i.e. from the present recruitment year in question and
for all times to come. Excessive reservation beyond ceiling limit of 50% rule, if
not permitted or supported by any law or statute, is illegal, arbitrary and
discriminatory.
32. It is not unknown to this court that there is dearth of competent and
adequate Pharmacists (Allopathy) in the State of Tripura. If the posts are
allowed to remain vacant for non-availability of eligible reserved category
candidates for the years to come, then, the health services, which the
Government is necessarily to provide to its people, will badly be affected.
Similarly, complaints against adequate numbers of teachers in the schools are
a regular phenomenon in the State. So, if the vacancies in the posts of teachers
are not filled up, then, the education system of the State will also be adversely
affected when right to education has been made a fundamental right. Absence
of adequate numbers of teachers will frustrate the object the law-makers
wanted to achieve through providing of qualitative education.
33. Before we conclude, we must say, that, it is settled proposition of law that
the number of backlog reserved vacancies form a separate class and is treated
as a distinct group and are excluded from the ceiling limit of 50% reservation.
In the instant cases, these backlog reserved vacancies which are being carried
forward in the recruitment year under notification dated 30.10.2013 in WA No.
458/2020 and WA No.460/2020, for filling up the posts of Pharmacist
(Allopathy) and the notification dated 15.07.2022 in WP(C) No.736/2022, for
filling up the posts of Graduate Teachers are illegally kept reserved in
contravention to sub-rule 8(c) of Rule 8 of Rules, 1992. However, the mistake
as discussed in detail in the preceding paragraphs has been committed by the
official respondents in carrying forward the vacant reserved posts for years
together including the notification dated 30.10.2013, for which, according to
us, the appointments already made from this distinct group have not been
disturbed by this court. More so, we are in agreement with Ld. Single Judge
that no malpractice is found to be committed in the selection process as
alleged by the petitioners/appellants for filling up the posts of Pharmacist
(Allopathy), and in this respect, the common judgment and order dated
15.09.2020 passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.134 of 2015 and
WP(C) No.135 of 2015 is not interfered with.
34. For the reasons stated and discussed here-in-above, we pass the following
directions in WA No. 458/2020 & in WA No.460/2020:(i) The action of the official respondents to reserve 60 posts out of 73 posts
for filling up the posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) in the employment
notification
dated 30.10.2013 is illegal, arbitrary and discriminatory and in contravention
to Clause (c) of sub-rule(8) of Rule 8 of the Rules, 1992 being in excess of
ceiling limit of 50% reservation.
(ii) There shall not be application of carry forward rule in the matter of
appointment/filling up of the posts of Pharmacist (Allopathy) under the
employment notification dated 30.10.2013.
(iii) The posts which are in excess of ceiling limit of 50% rule, shall be filled up
by general category candidates, if not already filled up by reserved category
candidates, that is, from the candidates belonging to the distinct group. It is
made clear that the appointments already made in the posts of Pharmacist
(Allopathy) by applying the carry forward rule under notification dated
30.10.2013 shall not be disturbed. It is further made clear that if any
vacancies under the same notification still exists and left vacant those shall
be filled up by general category candidates according to their merits and in
that case, the official respondents shall prepare and publish the merit list of
general category
candidates.
(iv) The official respondents shall not apply the carry forward rule in any of
the future recruitment process for filling up the vacant posts of Pharmacist
(Allopathy).
34.1 Directions in WP(C) 736 of 2022
(i) The employment notification dated 15.07.2022, issued by the Member
Secretary, Teachers Recruitment Board, Tripura (TRBT), for filling up the
posts of ‘Graduate Teacher’ for the Classes-IX-X, wherein, 201 posts have
been kept reserved out of 230 posts, is also interfered with to the extent that
the number of vacancies carried forward shall not be given effect to.
(ii) The selection of reserved category candidates must be limited to 50% for
filling up the total number of posts of ‘Graduate Teacher’ under the
notification dated 15.07.2022. The respondents shall prepare the select list
following the said ceiling limit of 50% rule for reservation.
(iii) The official respondents shall not apply the carry forward rule in any of
the future recruitment process for filling up the vacant posts of ‘Graduate
Teacher’.
35. In the light of the above observations and directions, the impugned
common judgment and order, dated 15.09.2020, passed in WP(C) No. 134 of
2015 and WP(C) No. 135 of 2015 by learned Single Judge is modified to the
extent as indicated above.
36. As a sequel, both the writ appeals, accordingly, stand disposed in the
aforesaid terms, and the writ petition [W.P.(C) 736 OF 2022] filed by the
petitioner, stands allowed and disposed to the extent as indicated above. In
the above conspectus, the interim order dated 09.09.2022, passed in WP(C)
No.736 of 2022, shall stand disposed.”
10.
In the light of above, I direct the respondents-State i.e. authorities
concerned to recast/re-arrange the select list dated 11.02.2022 (Annexure 9
of the writ petition) taking into account the well-settled principle of 50%
ceiling limit in the matter of reservation, and also bearing in mind the
principle laid down in Pankaj Bhowmik (supra) case.
11.
Accordingly, the select list dated 11.02.2022 (Annexure 9 to the writ
petition) stands set-aside and quashed. The entire process of re-casting/ rearranging of select list shall be concluded within a period of 4 (four) weeks
from today in terms of the above directions.
12.
With the above observations and directions, the instant writ petition
stands allowed and thus disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
JUDGE
Saikat
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review