The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. In view of this clear direction and dictum of the Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, this Court would refrain itself to take a contrary view and by-pass the ratio and the directions passed in Umadevi(3)(supra) unless and until the said judgment is overruled by a Constitution Bench. In the case of State of Karnataka vs. M.L. Kesari, reported in (2010) 9 SCC 247, the Hon’ble Supreme Court reiterated the principles settled in the case of Umadevi(3)(supra) and deprecated the decisions which run to counter to Umadevi(3)(supra) and dehors the constitutional scheme as enshrined under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. In the opinion of this Court, any direction of regularization ignoring the directions and the ratio laid down in Umadevi(3)(supra) would render the judgment of the Constitution Bench otiose.
18. In the light of above, keeping in mind the ratio laid down in Umadevi(3)(supra) and the subsequent decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in M.L. Kesari (supra)and Renu(supra) and in view of the decision passed by a Division bench of this Court in State of Tripura & ors. vs. Suprava Debnath, reported in 2023 SCC Online Tri 833 and by this Court in Sri Satya Ranjan Dey and Anr. vs. The State of Tripura and 4 Ors. passed in WP(C) No.5 of 2023, I am not inclined to grant the reliefs claimed by the petitioner herein for regularization of her service as well as service benefits including arrears in the present writ petition. Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands dismissed. Pending application(s), if any, also stands dismissed. +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.747 of 2022
Smt. Jyostna Shil, W/o: Sri Moti Lal Shil, resident of Purba Pratapgarh,
Shil Tilla, P.O: East Pratapgarh-799004, P.S. East Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura
…..Petitioner(s)
-VERSUS1. The State of Tripura, to be represented by the Principal Secretary,
Department of Agriculture & Farmers’ Welfare, Government of Tripura,
P.O. Kunjaban, P.S.: New Capital Complex, Agartala, District- West
Tripura, PIN: 799006.
2. The Principal Secretary, Department of Finance, Government of
Tripura, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S.: New Capital Complex, Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura, PIN: 799006.
3. The Director of Agriculture & Farmer’s Welfare, Krishi Bhawan,
Government of Tripura, P.O. Agartala-799001, P.S. West Agartala,
District- West Tripura.
4. The Superintendent of Agriculture, Dukli, Government of Tripura, P.O.
Madhuban (Dukli)-799003, P.S. Amtali, District- West Tripura.
…..Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. A. Bhaumik, Advocate
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. GA
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & Order
:
11.12.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes/No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
By way of filing the present writ petition, the petitioner has
sought for regularization of her service under the respondents in pursuance
of the scheme formulated in the year 2009.
2.
Shortly stated, the petitioner herein initially was engaged as
Cleaner on contract basis w.e.f. 01.03.2000, which will be evident from the
communication dated 28.02.2000 issued by the Director of Agriculture,
Government of Tripura(Annexure-1 to the writ petition). Thereafter, she had
been shown as Daily Rated Worker (DRW) from the date of her engagement
as Cleaner, which will be evident from the Memorandum dated 19.08.2004
(Annexure 3 to the writ petition) issued by the Director of Agriculture,
Government of Tripura, with the concurrence of the Finance Department,
Government of Tripura. Since 19.08.2004 the petitioner had been
discharging her duties for eight hours in a day as Cleaner (DRW) under the
respondents. It is the case of the petitioner that she had completed her ten
years of service as DRW as on 19.08.2014. The petitioner has relied upon
the scheme for regularization formulated by the Government of Tripura vide
Memorandum dated 21.01.2009 (Annexure 7 to the writ petition) issued by
the Finance Department. It is the further case of the petitioner that she was
entitled to be engaged as DRW w.e.f. 01.12.2012 as per Memorandum dated
07.11.2012 (Annexure-5 to the writ petition) issued by the Finance
Department, Government of Tripura. From the Memorandum dated
07.11.2012, it appears that by that memorandum it was decided that all Part
Time Workers (PTWs) working in different departments of Government for
two hours/three hours/four hours and who were engaged on or prior to
31.03.2003 and had completed ten years of service would be engaged as
Daily Rated Workers (DRWs), Group-D, w.e.f. 01.12.2012 with certain
conditions, as enumerated in the aforesaid Memorandum.
3.
On the aforesaid facts, I have heard Mr. A. Bhaumik, learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. D. Sarma, learned
Additional GA appearing for the respondents-State.
4.
Mr. Bhaumik, learned counsel for the petitioner at the very
outset has submitted that the petitioner is entitled to be regularized in service
since she had been initially engaged as Cleaner on contract basis on fixed
wages w.e.f. 01.03.2000 and thereafter from 19.08.2004 in terms of the
Memo dated 19.08.2004 she had been discharging her duties for eight hours
as Cleaner under the respondents. Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel has further
submitted that as she was discharging her duties for eight hours from
19.08.2004 on her completion of ten years of service w.e.f. 19.08.2004 till
18.08.2014, she was entitled to be regularized in view of the schemes
formulated by the Government of Tripura for regularization of
DRWs/PTWs/Casual workers etc. Mr. Bhowmik, learned counsel has also
urged that the petitioner is entitled to receive all service benefits including
arrears of financial benefits arising out of her regularization.
5.
Opposing the submissions of learned counsel for the petitioner,
Mr. D. Sarma, learned Additional GA for the respondents-State has
submitted that the petitioner is not entitled to be regularized since she was
not engaged against any regular vacant posts. She was only engaged as
Cleaner for discharging two hours duty without following the established
procedure of selection. According to Mr. Sarma, learned Additional GA, the
appointment of the petitioner is not only irregular but also illegal. The
appointment has been made at the whims and volitions of some of the
authorities. Learned Additional GA has also submitted that there is no
document to show that the petitioner has been considered as DRW by the
department and the letter dated 19.08.2004 (Annexure 3 to the writ petition)
is a forged one and has been done intentionally. Learned Additional GA has
also submitted that Annexure-4 to the writ petition is simply a proposal sent
to the Directorate for updating the Employees’ profile regarding
Memorandum dated 07.11.2012 and so the said document is not a valid
official document. Learned Additional GA has further submitted that the
Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court has strongly deprecated
the concept of engagement of persons without following the constitutional
schemes of equality enshrined in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of
India.
6.
I have considered the rival submissions of learned counsel
appearing for the parties. I have also gone through the documents enclosed/
annexed to the writ petition as well as the counter affidavit.
7.
Admittedly,
no
public
employment
notification
i.e.
advertisement was issued while engaging the petitioner under the
respondents as DRW. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in a catena of decisions
repeatedly held that employment notification or advertisements must be
published irrespective of the nature of the posts or nature of the appointment.
Any appointment or engagement dehors the constitutional schemes or the
statutory rules are illegal and not irregular. There cannot be any quarrel to
the principle that every government has a right to review its own policy
considering the socio-economic scenario of the State.
8.
It is not disputed that the Government reviewed the earlier
schemes and found shortcomings in those schemes and intended to follow
the established norms of employment as enshrined under Articles 14 and 16
of the Constitution of India. At para 43 of the case of Secretary, State of
Karnataka and others vs. Uma Devi (3) and others, reported in (2006) 4
SCC 1, the Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
adherence to the rule of equality in public employment is a basic feature of
our Constitution and since the rule of law is the core of our Constitution, a
Court would certainly be disabled from passing an order upholding violation
of Article 14 or in ordering the overlooking of the need to comply with the
requirements of Article 14 read with Article 16 of the Constitution.
It was also clarified in the same para that merely because a
temporary employee or a casual wage worker is continued for a time, beyond
the term of his/her appointment, he/she would not be entitled to be absorbed
in regular service or made permanent, merely on the strength of such
continuance, if the original appointment was not made by following a due
process of selection as envisaged by the relevant rules.
It was further held that it is not open to the Court to prevent
regular recruitment at the instance of temporary employees whose period of
employment has come to an end or of ad hoc employees who by the very
nature of their appointment do not acquire any right.
The Constitution Bench has further held that the High Courts
acting under Article 226 of the Constitution, should not ordinarily issue
directions for absorption, regularization, or permanent continuance unless
the recruitment itself was made regularly and in terms of the constitutional
scheme.
9.
At para 45 of the case of Umadevi(3)(supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held thus:
“45. While directing that appointments, temporary or casual, be
regularised or made permanent, the courts are swayed by the fact that the
person concerned has worked for some time and in some cases for a
considerable length of time. It is not as if the person who accepts an
engagement either temporary or casual in nature, is not aware of the nature
of his employment. He accepts the employment with open eyes. It may be
true that he is not in a position to bargain—not at arm's length—since he
might have been searching for some employment so as to eke out his
livelihood and accepts whatever he gets. But on that ground alone, it would
not be appropriate to jettison the constitutional scheme of appointment and
to take the view that a person who has temporarily or casually got
employed should be directed to be continued permanently. By doing so, it
will be creating another mode of public appointment which is not
permissible…….”
10.
It is clear from the schemes formulated by the Government that
the Government of Tripura had continued the process of regularization under
the realm of the schemes for long 10(ten) years depriving a large section of
candidates/unemployed
youths
of
the
State.
In
the
case
of
Umadevi(3)(supra), the Constitution Bench has categorically held that there
should not be any such appointment dehors the constitutional scheme after
the date of pronouncement of the judgment. In Umadevi(3)(supra), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court also directed the State Governments to formulate a
scheme for regularization of services of those employees who have
completed minimum 10(ten) years of service as on the date of the
pronouncement of judgment in the Umadevi(3)(supra) or as on the cut-off
date to be fixed by the respective State Governments.
11.
In the instant case, the concerned authority has flouted not only
the directions of the Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court but
also the petitioner was appointed in flagrant violation of the established
norms of public employment and dehors the constitutional schemes
enshrined under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India not only after
the date of pronouncement of the judgment in Umadevi(3)(supra) but also
after 7(seven) years of the cut-off date fixed by the Government of Tripura in
the scheme for regularization.
12.
As a corollary, in my opinion, since the initial appointment of
the petitioner was illegal and dehors the constitutional scheme of
employment, she is not entitled to claim financial benefits as those of the
employees/Cleaners who have been appointed on regular basis following the
established norms of public employment. In view of this, I repel the
submission of learned counsel appearing for the petitioner.
13.
In the case of Umadevi(3)(supra), at para 48 it is clearly held
that those who are working on daily wages formed a class by themselves,
they cannot claim that they are discriminated as against those who have been
regularly recruited on the basis of the relevant recruitment rules. It was
further held that there is no fundamental right in those who have been
employed on daily wages or temporarily or on contractual basis, to claim that
they have a right to be absorbed in service. If such employees are allowed to
be absorbed or directed to be paid regular scales of pay, it would amount to
treating the unequals as equals.
14.
Here, the petitioner is the backdoor entrant. So, she cannot
complain discrimination as she simply is not equal to those of the employees
appointed through regular selection process against the regular sanctioned
vacant posts. The appointments made dehors the established norms of public
employment and in violation of the statutory rules does not confer any right
upon any person for similar treatment, and an order made in favour of a
person in violation of the prescribed statutory procedure cannot form a legal
basis for any other person to claim pay parity.
(emphasis supplied)
15.
That apart, in my opinion, no such scheme which has been
made for giving some concession to some of the employees or a class of
employees who have been appointed irregularly without following
constitutional scheme of public employment should be allowed to perpetuate
for an endless period. It must be stopped within a reasonable period to open
the doors providing opportunity to thousands of job aspirants who have been
waiting for several years to participate in the competition for selection to
government posts.
16.
In the instant case, the government continued the schemes for
appointment of irregularly appointed employees for long 10(ten) years. In
my opinion, this period is enough and it shall not be continued for further
time.
17.
In view of this clear direction and dictum of the Constitution
Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, this Court would refrain itself to take
a contrary view and by-pass the ratio and the directions passed in
Umadevi(3)(supra) unless and until the said judgment is overruled by a
Constitution Bench. In the case of State of Karnataka vs. M.L. Kesari,
reported in (2010) 9 SCC 247, the Hon’ble Supreme Court reiterated the
principles settled in the case of Umadevi(3)(supra) and deprecated the
decisions which run to counter to Umadevi(3)(supra) and dehors the
constitutional scheme as enshrined under Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India. In the opinion of this Court, any direction of
regularization ignoring the directions and the ratio laid down in
Umadevi(3)(supra) would render the judgment of the Constitution Bench
otiose.
18.
In the light of above, keeping in mind the ratio laid down in
Umadevi(3)(supra) and the subsequent decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in M.L. Kesari (supra)and Renu(supra) and in view of the decision
passed by a Division bench of this Court in State of Tripura & ors. vs.
Suprava Debnath, reported in 2023 SCC Online Tri 833 and by this Court
in Sri Satya Ranjan Dey and Anr. vs. The State of Tripura and 4 Ors.
passed in WP(C) No.5 of 2023, I am not inclined to grant the reliefs claimed
by the petitioner herein for regularization of her service as well as service
benefits including arrears in the present writ petition.
Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands dismissed.
JUDGE
SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2024.01.04 10:07:02
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review