Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C)No.799 of 2023
Smt. Jharna Das,
wife of Sri Ranjit Das,
resident of Gorurbandh,
P.O. Urmai, P.S. Sonamura,
District-Sepahijala Tripura
---- Petitioner (s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Chief Secretary,
Government of Tripura, Agartala,
Civil Secretariat, P.O. Kunjaban, Pin-799006
2. The Secretary to the Government of Tripura,
Department of Social Welfare and Social Education,
Civil Secretariat, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, Pin-799006
3. Additional Secretary to the Government of Tripura,
Department of Social Welfare and Social Education,
Civil Secretariat, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, Pin-799006
4. The Secretary to the Government of Tripura,
Department of Finance Department, Civil Secretariat,
P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, Pin-799006
5. The Director of Social Welfare and Social Education,
Government of Tripura, Abhoynagar, P.O. Abhoynagar,
Agartala, P.S. East Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799005
6. Additional Director of Social Welfare and Social Education,
Government of Tripura, Abhoynagar, P.O. Abhoynagar, Agartala,
P.S. East Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799005
7. Child Development Project Officer,
Government of Tripura, Melaghar NP ICDS Project,
Melaghar, Sepahijala District
8. Accountant General, Tripura,
Malancha Nibash, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. East Agartala,
District-West Tripura
----Respondent(s)
_____________________________________________________
For Petitioner (s)
:
Mr. Kundan Pandey, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, DSGI.
Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. G.A.
Date of Hearing
:
16.04.2025
[---
Date of Judgment
& Order
:
25.04.2025
Whether fit for reporting :
YES
_________________________________________________________
(2)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
The present petitioner has filed this writ petition
seeking the following reliefs :
(I) Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show
cause as to why the Respondents should not
transmit all records relating to the case of the
Petitioner;
(II) As to why a writ in the nature of mandamus
should not be issued quashing or setting aside the
letter vide No.F.34(987)-DSWL/LA/2022/258(3)
dated 04.08.2023 issued by respondent No.5
whereby the prayer of the petitioner for counting
her past service rendered as a School Mother on a
consolidated
fixed
pay
w.e.f.
30.05.1990
to
01.10.2007 for the purpose of all retiral benefits
was regretted;
(III) As to why a writ in the nature of mandamus
should not be issued directing the Respondents to
count the past service of the petitioner which was
rendered as a School Mother on a consolidated
fixed pay w.e.f. 30.05.1990 to 01.10.2007 for the
purpose of all retiral benefits including Pension,
Gratuity, etc. and release all pensionary benefits
along with 12% interest per annum in favour of
the petitioner after counting of her past service as
School Mother;
(IV) As to why such other order/orders should not
be passed so as to give full relief to the Petitioner
and, upon causes shown, to make the Rule
absolute;
(V)
For
this
act
of
kindness
your
humble
Petitioner, as in duty bound, shall ever pray;
[2]
Heard
Mr.
Kundan
Pandey,
Learned
counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner and also heard Mr. Karnajit
De, Learned Addl. G.A. appearing on behalf of the Staterespondents.
(3)
[3]
Before concluding the writ petition, let us discuss
about the subject matter of the writ petition. According to the
petitioner, she was appointed by a memo dated 13.07.1990 as a
School Mother under the Directorate of Social Welfare & Social
Education Department, Government of Tripura, Agartala on a
consolidated fixed pay for a period of 12 months. In the said
memo, it was mentioned that they are appointed against the
newly created and sanctioned post vide Memo No.F.48(13-1)SWE/PLAN/88 dated 14.12.1989 issued by the Department of
Social Welfare and Social Education, Government of Tripura.
Subsequently, the respondent No.6 by a memorandum vide
No.F.3(3)-DSWE/ESTT/88(LOOSE) dated 30.07.1990 issued an
offer of appointment to the petitioner to the post of School
Mother [Annexure-1 & 2]. The Inspector, Social Welfare & Social
Education, Melaghar, Tripura accepted the joining report of the
petitioner along with others and the said Inspector issued a
Memo on 25.07.1990 in respect of joining report of the
petitioner. In the said memo, it was categorically stated that the
date of joining of the petitioner to the post of School Mother was
25.07.1990 [Annexure-3].
[4]
It was further submitted by the petitioner that
after satisfactory service of the petitioner, the Respondent No.5
issued
a
memo
vide
No.F.3(3)DSWE/ESTT/2007/2517(158)
dated 03.11.2007 whereby the service of the petitioner was
regularized as a Group-D employee w.e.f. 01.10.2007 in the pay
scale of Rs.2600-55-2985-60-2385-65-3545 as a School Mother
[Annexure-4]. From the year 1990 till 31.12.2021 the petitioner
served her department with complete honesty and integrity. The
petitioner
completed
her
whole
service
career
with
the
satisfaction of her higher authorities and after attaining 60 years
(4)
of age the service of the petitioner was further extended for a
period of 3 months w.e.f. 01.01.2022 to 31.03.2022 and the
petitioner ultimately retired from service on 31.03.2022. Being
aggrieved, the petitioner through her Learned counsel submitted
an advocates notice before the respondents No.2, 5, 6 & 7 on
27.09.2022 and prayed for counting of her past service rendered
as School Mother on a consolidated fixed pay w.e.f. 30.05.1990
to 10.10.2007 for the purpose of all retiral benefits including
pension, Gratuity, etc. and release all pensionary benefits along
with 12% interest per annum after counting her past service as
School Mother within a period of 30 days from the date of receipt
of the said notice. The said notice was duly received by the
Department
but
no
reply
was
given
[Annexure-5].
Being
aggrieved by non-cooperation of the Department, the petitioner
filed the writ petition before this High Court vide WP(C)No.925 of
2022 praying for counting her past service as a School Mother on
a consolidated fixed pay w.e.f. 30.05.1990 to 01.10.2007 for the
purpose of all other benefits. The said writ petition was disposed
of with the following observations [Annexure-6] :
“3. It is seen from the record that the petitioner
herein has submitted an advocate notice dated
26.09.2022 through his advocate to the respondent
agitating his grievance and the same is still
pending.
4. Accordingly, without expressing any opinion on
the merit of the case, this present writ petition is
disposed of with a direction upon the respondents
to decide the said representation made by the
petitioner through his advocate dated 26.09.2022
in accordance with law within a period of 3(three)
months from the date of receipt of copy of this
order.”
[5]
The
petitioner
thereafter
submitted
a
representation dated 14.06.2023 along with a copy of the
judgment before the respondents No.2, 5, 7 & 8 and prayed for
implementing the judgment of the High Court but no action was
taken. Copy of the representation was annexed as Annexure-7.
(5)
It
was
further
submitted
that
the
representation
dated
14.06.2023 was duly received by the respondents No.2, 5, 7 & 8
and the respondent No.8 issued a letter dated 05.07.2023 to the
respondent No.5 and requested to transmit pertinent proposal to
the respondent No.8 for necessary action. The said letter was
annexed as Annexure-8. But thereafter, on 04.08.2023 the
respondent No.5 issued a letter to the Learned counsel for the
petitioner [Annexure-9]. She further submitted that a similar
was case filed by one Smt. Mamta Rani Roy(Saha) before this
High Court which was numbered as WP(C)No.77 of 2015 for
counting her past service which she rendered as School Mother.
The Hon’ble High Court allowed the writ petition in favour of said
Smt. Mamta Rani Roy(Saha) with the following observation
[Annexure-10] :
“11. It would also be pertinent to mention that the
Central Government and the Government of Tripura
have taken a decision that even half of the services
rendered by an employee on daily wages shall be
counted towards qualifying service. The person
appointed on fixed pay basis is on a much better
footing than a person appointed on daily wages
and if half of the service rendered by a daily wages
employee can be counted for determining his/her
qualifying service, I see no reason why the full
service rendered by a fixed pay employee should
not be counted towards her qualifying service if
this uninterrupted service is followed by regular
service.
12. In view of the above discussion, the writ
petition is allowed with costs assessed at
Rs.5,000/- (rupees five thousand) and it is
directed that the service rendered by the petitioner
from the date of her joining as School Mother on
fixed pay basis pursuant to the letter of
appointment
dated
19-07-1990
till
her
regularisation shall be added to her regular service
from 01-10- 2007 till her superannuation on 0311-2007 for calculating her pension and other
retiral benefits. The State shall ensure that the
pension is accordingly fixed and all retiral benefits
be released in favour of the petitioner latest by
31st January, 2016 along with interest @ 9% per
annum from the date of retirement of the
petitioner, i.e. 30-06-2013 till payment/deposit of
this amount.”
[6]
She further stated that in spite of rendering
service over 30 years she had to retire without receiving any
(6)
pensionary benefits. It was further submitted that similarly
situated persons filed writ petition vide No.WP(C)853 of 2017
and by a judgment dated 21.08.2017 the said benefit was
granted. In another case vide WP(C)No.439 of 2020 similar relief
was sought for and that was also allowed in favour of the
petitioner. The petitioner also relied upon the judgment of
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of State of
Himachal
Pradesh
&
Anr.
versus
Sheela
Devi
dated
07.08.2023 wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court observed that the
past
service
as
a
contractual
employee
be
taken
into
consideration. Hence, the petitioner filed the writ petition.
[7]
The State-respondents contested the case by filing
counter affidavit denying the entire assertions. In para Nos.5 to
6 of the counter affidavit the State-respondents made the
following assertions :
“5. That, with regard to the statements made in
paragraph 12 of the Writ Petition, I say that, the
petitioner Smt. Jharna Das, had joined in the post
of School Mother on consolidated fixed pay on
25.07.1990. She had been regularized in the post
of School Mother w.e.f.01.10.2007. The Petitioner
had retired from her service on superannuation on
31.03.2022 (with extension). It is a fact that at the
time of retirement of the Petitioner, length of her
regular service was 14 years 06 months, whereas
minimum 10 years is required for entitlement of
pension and pensionary benefits. So, she was
entitled to get pension and other pensionary
benefits and there is no rule or provision under the
Govt. Of Tripura for counting of past service of
School Mother who was on consolidated pay and
had rendered regular service for minimum 10 years
or above. Therefore, counting the past service from
the date of her joining to the date of her
regularization is not required for pension and other
pensionary benefits and the petitioner is not
entitled to what she prayed for in the writ petition
as per existing rule of the State Government.
6. That, with regard to para 13 to 15 of the petition
it is submitted that, it is a fact that Smt. Mamata
Devi had filed a writ petition (Civil) No.77 of 2015
for counting her past service which was rendered
as consolidated School Mother. Smt Mamata Devi
was appointed as School Mother on consolidated
fixed pay basis on 19.07.1990 and regularized on
3.11.2007. She retired from Government service on
superannuation on 30.06.2013 and since Smt.
Mamata Devi had not completed 10 years of
service since her regular appointment in 2007, she
was not entitled to get pension. The Hon'ble High
(7)
Court directed in its judgment and order dated
08.10.2015 to count her service as consolidated
fixed pay for the purpose of pensionary benefits,
for the same purpose and similarly situated
persons writ petition (Civil) No.853 of 2017 and
other connected writ petitions were filed in the
Hon'ble High Court and again Hon'ble Court had
directed to count their service as consolidated
fixed pay for the purpose of pensionary benefits.
But in the instant case the petitioner Smt.
Jharna Das was entitled to get pension and other
pensionary benefits as she has completed 15 years
of service since her regular appointment in 2007.
So, the instant case is different to Smt. Mamata
Devi's case and therefore, the claim of the
petitioner for counting the past service since the
date of her joining is not required for pension and
other pensionary benefits as per existing rule or
provision and therefore, it is prayed before the
Hon'ble Court to dismiss the claim of the
petitioner. Further, it is also stated that 6(six) Writ
Appeals registered as Writ Appeal 135/2022,
136/2022, 137/2022 141/2022, 61/2023 &
62/2023, have been pending in the Division Bench
of Hon'ble High Court of Tripura which are also
similarly situated.”
[8]
At the time of hearing, Learned counsel for the
petitioner, Mr. K. Pandey drawn the attention of this Court that
the case of the petitioner is covered by the Judgment of Smt.
Mamata Rani Roy(Saha) versus The State of Tripura in
WP(C)No.77 of 2015 [Annexure-10 of the writ petition] wherein
the Division Bench of the High Court granted the benefit of past
service. In para Nos.8 to 12 the Division Bench of this High Court
made the following observations :
“8. This rule clearly lays down that qualifying
services of a Government Servant shall commence
from the date he takes charge of the post to which
he is first appointed either substantively or in
officiating or in temporary capacity. The petitioner
was appointed on contract basis on 19-07-1990
and she continued to work for 17 long years on
temporary basis till her services were regularised
in the year 2007.
9. Rule 14 of the CCS (Pension) Rules lays down
the conditions subject to which her service
qualifies. Under sub-rule (1) if the services of the
Government
servant
are
regulated
by
the
Government, then the services have to be taken
into consideration. The petitioner was working
under the direct control of the Government and she
was under the disciplinary control of the
Government and, therefore, this condition is
satisfied. The petitioner was being paid salary by
the Government out of a fund administered by the
State of Tripura and, therefore, qualifies for grant
of pension.
10. It is urged on behalf of the State that the
petitioner was in a non-pensionable establishment.
(8)
All employees of the Government have to be given
benefits either under some pension funds or under
the Provident Fund Scheme. There can be no
employment under the Government who does not
fall under either of the two beneficiary schemes.
Either there should be an Employees Pension
Scheme and in case, there is no such scheme, then
the employee would fall within the ambit of the
Pension Rules. Under the Employees’ Provident
Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952,
every employer is required to frame a scheme for
Employees
Pension
Scheme
providing
for
superannuation pension, retiring pension or
permanent total disablement pension. There has to
be a pension fund. The State cannot have it both
ways. It cannot claim that it is neither liable to pay
under the Employees’ Provident Funds Act nor is
liable to pay pension.
11. It would also be pertinent to mention that the
Central Government and the Government of Tripura
have taken a decision that even half of the services
rendered by an employee on daily wages shall be
counted towards qualifying service. The person
appointed on fixed pay basis is on a much better
footing than a person appointed on daily wages
and if half of the service rendered by a daily wages
employee can be counted for determining his/her
qualifying service, I see no reason why the full
service rendered by a fixed pay employee should
not be counted towards her qualifying service if
this uninterrupted service is followed by regular
service.
12. In view of the above discussion, the writ
petition is allowed with costs assessed at
Rs.5,000/- (rupees five thousand) and it is
directed that the service rendered by the petitioner
from the date of her joining as School Mother on
fixed pay basis pursuant to the letter of
appointment
dated
19-07-1990
till
her
regularisation shall be added to her regular service
from 01-10- 2007 till her superannuation on 0311-2007 for calculating her pension and other
retiral benefits. The State shall ensure that the
pension is accordingly fixed and all retiral benefits
be released in favour of the petitioner latest by
31st January, 2016 along with interest @ 9% per
annum from the date of retirement of the
petitioner, i.e. 30-06-2013 till payment/deposit of
this amount.”
Referring the same Learned counsel submitted
that since the case of the present petitioner is covered by the
said judgment, so, a direction may be given to the State
respondents to allow the benefit of past service as sought for by
the petitioner.
[9]
Learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner
further
submitted that the State Authority did not challenge the said
judgment and thus the said judgment has attained finality. He
also referred another judgment of the Division Bench of this High
(9)
Court passed in connection with Case No. W.A.135 of 2022, W.A.
No.136 of 2022, W.A. No.137 of 2022, W.A. No.141 of 2022
wherein the Division Bench of this High Court in the last few
paras made the following observations :
“This Court while deciding the issue of similarly
situated School Mothers had passed so many
judgments/orders wherein the respondents were
directed to count the past service rendered by
School Mothers irrespective of their nature of
employment on contractual or temporary basis. In
the case of Mamata Rani Roy(Saha) vs. State of
Tripura and Ors. in WP(C) No.77 of 2015, a
Division Bench of this Court was pleased to direct
providing retiral benefits and/or pensionary
benefits by adding the period of contractual service
rendered
by
the
petitioner
prior
to
her
regularization to the post.
We have also perused the judgment and order
passed by the Division Bench of this Court in
Mamata Rani Roy(Saha) (supra) confirming the
order of the learned Single Judge directing to add
the period of service they rendered on temporary
basis or on fixed pay basis along with the period of
their regular service for the purpose of granting
pension and other retiral benefits.
This well-settled principle cannot be disputed by
the State-appellant. The position of the writ
petitioners/respondents is similar and identical to
the facts of the case of Mamata Rani Roy(Saha)
(supra).
In view of this, we find no merit in the above
writ appeals. Accordingly, all the writ appeals
stand dismissed.”
[10]
The Division Bench also at the time of disposal of
the appeal filed by the State respondents referred the judgment
of
Mamata Rani Roy(Saha)(supra) and finally dismissed all
the appeals filed by the State respondents. The said judgment of
the Division Bench have also attained finality as because no
further SLP is preferred by the State respondents. So, Learned
counsel for the petitioner urged for allowing the petition filed by
the petitioner.
[11]
On the other hand, Mr. K. De, Learned Addl. G.A.
appearing on behalf of the State-respondents submitted that in
the case of Smti. Mamata Roy (Saha) (supra) she did not
complete 10 years of service, so, the Hon’ble High Court gave
the benefit to her. But here in the case at hand, since the
(10)
present petitioner has already completed 10 years of service so
there is no question of considering her period of past service.
Further he has submitted that the State has taken a concerned
decision in the cases wherein the petitioner of the respective
Departments have not completed their 10 years of service at the
time of consideration of their pensionary benefits so, they will be
given the same benefit but those who have completed more than
10 years of service they are/were not entitled to get the benefit
of past service. He referred some of the orders of the Division
Bench of the High Court passed in connection with W.A. No.25 of
2025 and W.A. No.18 of 2025.
[12]
But on perusal of the same, it appears that those
are not related to the case of said Smti. Mamata Roy (Saha)
(supra) and the subsequent appeals W.A.136 of 2022 and
W.A.135 of 2022 and others as mentioned above. Even, at the
time of hearing of argument, Learned Addl. G.A. although
submitted that the State has decided to prefer SLP before the
Supreme Court but in this regard, no stay order or any other
communication could be placed before this Court for staying
further proceedings of this case. Since, the case of Smti.
Mamata Roy (Saha) (supra) as discussed above and the
subsequent appeals being numbered as W.A.135 of 2022 and
others had been disposed of by order dated 04.07.2024 and no
further challenge is made to the said judgment/order and
Learned Addl. G.A. at the time of hearing of argument also was
failed to satisfy the Court that the judgment of Smti. Mamata
Roy (Saha) (supra) does not cover the case of the petitioner.
As such, in the considered opinion of this Court the present
petitioner is entitled to get the benefit, as prayed for.
(11)
[13]
The writ petition is accordingly allowed. The
respondent
authority
shall
accordingly
count
the
service
rendered by the petitioner from the date of her joining as School
Mother
on
consolidated
fixed
pay
pursuant
to
the
acknowledgment letter dated 13.07.1990 till her regularization
be counted as her regular service on and from 25.07.1990 to
01.10.2007 till her superannuation on 31.03.2022 for calculating
her pension and other retiral benefits. The respondent authority
shall ensure that the pension is accordingly fixed and all retiral
benefits be released in favour of the petitioner within a period of
4(four) months along with interest @ 7.5% per annum from the
date of retirement of the petitioner till payment/deposit of the
amount.
The writ petition is accordingly stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
SABYASACHI Digitally
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHAR BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2025.04.28
JEE
22:54:07 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review