Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No. 670 of 2021
1. Smt. Ila Deb
W/o Sri Habul Sarkar of Badharghat
near BOC PS Amtali, Agartala,
West Tripura, 56 years
2. Sri Sourav Dasgupta
S/o Lt Santosh Lal Dasgupta of
Ramnagar Road No.4, PS-West
Agartala, West Tripura, 58 years
3. Sri Partha Sarathi Paul
S/o Lt. Ashutosh Paul of Palace
Compound, near Sale Tex Office
PS-East Agartala, West Tripura
4. Sri Pranab Sengupta
S/o Lt. Tegendranath Sengupta of
Office Tilla Nutan Palli
PS- Bishalgarh, Sepahijala
Sepahijala District, 59 years
5. Sri Rathindra Ch. Ghosh
S/o Lt. Nibaran Chandra Ghosh of
A.D. Nagar Police Quarters Complex,
PS, A.D. Nagar, West Tripura,
59 years
6. Sri Dhiraj Laskar
S/o Lt. Manindra Chandra Laskar of
Police Quarter Lane, PS- A.D. Nagar,
Agartala, West Tripura, 56 years
7. Sri Pradyut Ch. Datta
S/o Sri Pramesh Ch. Datta of
Natun Palli PS- Dharmanagar, North
Tripura, 59 years
8. Sri Swapan Ch. Das
S/o Lt. Kshitish Chandra Das of
Gajaria S.D Mission PS- A.D. Nagar,
Agartala West Tripura, 57 years
9. Sri Benu Lal Kar
S/o Lt. Shital Chandra Kar of
Ramnagar Road No.4 (Near Sankar
Chowmuhani) PS- West Agartala, West
Tripura, 58 years
10. Sri Debasish Banerjee
S/o Lt. Debabrata Banerjee of Krishnanagar,
Kadamtali PS- West Agartala West Tripura,
58 years
11. Sri Shyamal Chakraborty
S/o Lt. Haran Chakraborty of A.D. Nagar
Road No.1 PS- A.D. Nagar, Agartala,
West Tripura, 57 years
12. Sri Kamal Kar Chowdhury
S/o Lt. Naresh Kar Chowdhury of
Ramnagar Road No.2, PS-West Agartala,
Agartala, West Tripura, 58 years
13. Sri Ranendu Kishore Bhattacharjee
S/o Lt. Rabindra Kumar Bhattacharjee,
1/A By- Lane Srinagar, Milanchakra, PS-A.D.
Nagar, Agartala, West Tripura, 59 years
14. Sri Kapil Das
S/o Lt. Krishna Mohan Das of Badharghat
(Matripalli) PS-A.D. Nagar Agartala,
West Tripura, 60 years
15. Sri Paloram Das
S/o Lt. Sudhan Chandra Das of Baltali,
A.D. Nagar Road No.9. PS- A.D.
Nagar West Tripura, 59 years
16. Sri Anup Kumar Das
S/o Lt. Amarendra Das of Town
Rajarbag, PS-R.K Pur, Gomati District, 56 years
17. Sri Priti Ranjan Laskar
S/o Lt. Rati Ranjan Laskar of
Dhaleswar Road No.14 PS- East Agartala,
West Tripura, 59 years
18. Md. Abdul Matin
S/o Lt. Habib Ali of Jamirala College
Road, PS- Dharmanagar, Dharmanagar,
North Tripura, 58 years
19. Sri Kanti Lal Baidya
S/o Lt. Anil Chandra Baidhya of
Kalyani PS- East Agartala,
Agartala, West Tripura, 59 years
20. Sri Ratan Kumar Deb
S/o Lt. Haripada Deb of Ramnagar
A.K Road PS- West Agartala,
West Tripura, 58 years
21. Sri Balaram Sen
S/o Lt. Ashutosh Sen of Shyamalima
Apartment, Flat No.4/10 Block- 4,
Near ILS Hospital, PS- New Capital
Complex, Agartala, West Tripura,
58 years
22. Sri Subrata Chakraborty
S/o Lt. Sudhir Bandhu Chakraborty of
Haneman Homio Hall, 91 Motor Stand
Road PS- East Agartala, West Tripura,
57 years
...The Petitioners
Vs
1.The State of Tripura
(To be represented by the Secretary,
Department of Home, Government of
Tripura), New Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
P.S- New Capital Complex, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN 799010
2. The Director General of Police,
Govt. of Tripura, A.K Road, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN- 799001
3. The Principal Secretary,
GA (P&T) Department, Govt. of
Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New
Capital Complex, Kunjaban, P.S- New
Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN 799010
4. The Inspector General of Police (Administration),
O/o the Director General of Police, Govt. of
Tripura, A.K Road, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN- 799001
5. Tripura Public Service Commission,
To be represented by its Secretary,
Govt. of Tripura, A.K Road, Agartala,
West Tripura, PIN- 799001
….The Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate
Mr. S. Bhattacharya, Advocate
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, GA
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate
Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, Advocate
09.01.2023
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
By way of filing the instant writ petition, the petitioners have
prayed for following reliefs:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
Issue Rule upon the Respondent to show cause as to
why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order/direction shall not be issued whereby
directing the Respondents to exercise the „power to
relax‟ in terms of Rule-34 of the Tripura Police
Service Rules, 1967, by relaxing the age criteria as
laid down by Rule-14(4) of the Tripura Police
Service Rules, 1967, for promotion to the post of
TPS Grade-II from Inspectors of Police.
Issue Rule upon the Respondent to show cause as to
why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order/direction shall not be issued whereby
directing the Respondents to exercise power to
relax as provided vide Rule-34 of the Tripura
Police Service Rules, 1967, by relaxing the age
criteria as laid down in Rule-14(4) of the Tripura
Police Service Rules, 1967, for promotion to the
post of TPS Grade-II from Inspectors of Police, in
pursuance to the letter, dated, 08.07.2021,
containing the proposal for such relaxation, issued
by the Inspector General of Police (Adm.), to the
Principal Secretary, GA (P&T) Department, Govt.
of Tripura.
Issue Rule upon the Respondent to show cause as to
why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or
Order/direction shall not be issued whereby
quashing & cancelling the Order; dated,
08.09.2021, passed by the Principal Secretary, GA
(P&T) Govt. of Tripura.
Pass an interim order, restraining the
Respondents not to proceed with the DPC for
promotion to TPS Grade-II from the feeder posts
of Inspectors of Police, till the decision for
(v)
(vi)
(vii)
2.
exercising power to relax under Rule-34 of TPS
Rules, 1967, is taken for relaxing the age criteria
for promotion to the TPS Grade-II from Inspectors
of Police or during the pendency of writ petition.
Make the rules absolute,
Call for records,
Pass any further order/orders as this Hon‟ble High
Court considered fit and proper.”
The petitioners had earlier approached this Court by means
of filing a writ petition being WP(C) No.582 of 2021. While
disposing of that writ petition this Court had observed thus:
“A bare perusal of the above observation in the
notification dated 22nd June, 2021, it has become crystal
clear that all promotions in various departments under the
State-government were made stalled since 01.04.2017 only
because of the order of „status-quo‟ order dated
27.07.2015 passed by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court as an
interim measure.
In the light of above, the submission of learned
Advocate General that there was no stay order passed by
Hon‟ble Supreme Court, according to this court, appears
to be insignificant for the reason that it was only due
to the order of Supreme Court to maintain „status-quo‟, the
promotions in the services of the State-government had
remained withheld.
The word „status-quo‟ means “ the situation that
currently exists”. It is the government who interpreted the
order of „status-quo‟ as passed by the Supreme Court in its
order dated 27.07.2015 and, ultimately in view of this
order, the State-government at their own wisdom abstained
from initiating any process of promotion in any of the posts
from the feeder posts in all the departments under it. In my
opinion, for such decision or action of the Stategovernment, the petitioners cannot be blamed and they
should be held responsible for the inaction of the
government in this respect for the last several years.
In furtherance thereof, in my considered view, the
reasoning as given by the state‟s Director General of
Police in the matter of promotion of his officers should be
given due weightage by the government because
such reasoning appears to be in consistent with the
decision of the government where it desired to initiate the
exercise of promotions in the vacant posts in order to
“augment efficiency of state administrations”.
In the instant case, ultimately, the IGP being the
head of the organization is the best person to decide who
would be the best officers to provide an efficient
administration in the interest of public. From his
communication dated 08.07.2021 it is manifested that he
for obvious reasons wanted to fill up the posts of TPS
Grade – II from the senior most officers and the IGP did
not want to deprive those senior and competent officers
who rendered their sincere and dedicated service in the
interest of public. The IGP also observed that it would be
deemed unfair to the legitimate career expectations of
these officers for no fault of them.
For the foregoing reasons, I am of the prima facie
view that the petitioners were not at fault in any manner to
raise their claim for consideration of promotion in the post
of TPS, Grade-II and they cannot be held responsible for
the stalemate created by the government itself. On
conjoint reading of paragraphs 3 and 4 of the notification
dated 22nd June, 2021, it manifests that „status quo‟ order
passed by the Supreme and consequential government
decision stood in the way of the petitioners‟
chances of promotion from being fairly considered when it
was due for such consideration and I re-iterate that delay
in taking the exercise of such promotion made them
ineligible
for
such
consideration
which
fact
the respondents ought to have kept in mind while rejecting
the proposal of IGP to give one-time relaxation of age
invoking Rule 34 of TPS Rules, 1967.
However, considering the submission of learned
Advocate General that the petitioners should make
representations to the Government of Tripura, I direct the
petitioners to submit a common representation to the
Government of Tripura, particularly, the Secretary,
General Administration (P&T) and the Secretary, Home
Department, Government of Tripura, to consider their
promotion in the post of TPS Grade-II invoking Rule 34 of
the Rules, 1967 for relaxation of age of 55 years,
one-time measure, as contemplated under Rule 14(4) of the
Rules, 1967. It is further directed that the petitioners shall
submit representation before the authorities concerned of
the government within a period of 4 (four)
days from today. The competent authorities of the
government shall consider the representation if filed by the
petitioners within the next 7 (seven) days and dispose of
the same with speaking order. Till then, the
State-respondents shall not proceed further with the
process of promotion, as initiated under notification dated
18th August, 2021. It is made clear that this order will be
confined only to the petitioners of this writ petition.
Needless to say, that the petitioners are at liberty to
approach this court, if they are aggrieved of the response
of the respondents regarding their representation.
Accordingly, the instant writ petition filed by the
petitioners stand disposed in the light of the above
observations and directions.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed
of.”
3.
In terms of the above directions, the petitioners had
submitted representation to the State-respondents (Annexure-11 to
the writ petition). Thereafter, the respondents vide order dated 8th
September, 2021 had rejected the representation compelling the
petitioners again to present the instant writ petition claiming the
above reliefs.
4.
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. S. Bhattacharya, learned counsel and Mr. K. Nath, learned
counsel appearing for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. D.
Bhattacharya, learned GA assisted by Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents-State and Mr. R.G. Chakraborty,
learned counsel appearing for the respondent-TPSC.
5.
Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel has submitted that
rejection of the prayers made by the petitioners in their
representation itself is arbitrary and not in consonance with the
object for which the provision for relaxation was made under Rule34 of Tripura Police Service Rules, 1967 (for short, TPS Rules).
Learned senior counsel has further submitted that even the
Government has not considered the well-reasoned suggestions
given by the Inspector General of Police requesting the State
Government to invoke Rule-34 of TPS Rules.
6.
Mr. Bhattacharya, learned GA has submitted that he received
instructions from the Government as directed by the Court which
will be revealed from the note nos.- 13,17 and 18. Learned GA has
also placed the relevant file containing the notes given by the
Government on the subject in issue of the present writ petition.
7.
I have perused the note nos.-13, 17 and 18. In note nos.17
and 18, the State Government has instructed the learned GA to wait
for the decision of the High Court.
8.
In view of this, I have taken up the matter for hearing on
consent of the learned counsels for the parties. I have perused order
dated 8th September, 2021, issued by the Principal Secretary to the
Government of Tripura. The principal reason as assigned by the
Government in the order dated 8th September, 2021 is that
“whereas; if the relaxation of age are being considered in favour
of the instant petitioners, then other incumbent concerned those
who are holding the feeder post of TCS/TFS etc. may also prefer
claim for relaxation of age. Moreover, at present, those who are
eligible to be considered for promotion (as per existing rules) may
be deprived of promotion and this will create administrative
inconvenience.” Another reason which is also necessary to be
pointed out as indicated by the State-respondents is that “whereas,
in order to avoid future legal complicacy, it is felt not necessary to
relax any of the provisions of the rules by the State respondents
with respect to any class or category of persons or posts in
accordance with Rule-34 of the said rules”.
9.
Before advert to the merits of the subject matter and the
submission advanced by learned counsels appearing for the parties
coupled with the “notes” placed before this Court, it would be
relevant to take into account the intention of the State Legislatures
to allow promotion despite the order of status-quo as stated here-inabove.
It comes to fore that the Government of Tripura as a matter
of policy decision intended to exercise the matter of promotions to
its employees subject to the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the vacant posts in order to “augment efficiency in State
administrations”.
10.
Rule-14 of the Rules, 1967 provides conditions of eligibility
& procedures for selection to the TPS Grade-II, under Rule-5(1)(b)
of the Rules, 1967.
Rule-14(1) of the Rules, 1967 provides that the Committee
shall consider from time to time the cases of Officers eligible under
Rule-5(1)(b) who have served in the cadre of Inspector of Police &
Subedars of Tripura State Rifles, for not less than 5 years &
prepare a list of Officers recommended taking into account the
actual vacancies at the time of selection and those which are likely
to occur during a year. The selection for inclusion in the list shall
be on merit & suitability in all respects for appointment for service
with due regard to the seniority.
Rule-14(3) of Rules, 1967 provides that
minimum
educational qualification for promotion to TPS Grade-II Service
shall be graduation.
11.
Sub-rule-4 of Rule-14 of the TPS Rules, has been amended
under Tripura Police Service (14th Amendment) Rules, 2013, vide
Notification, dated, 21.12.2013, issued by the GA (P&T)
Department, Govt. of Tripura. After amendment Rule-14(4) of the
TPS Rules-1967 reads as follows:
“The Committee shall not consider the cases of
officers in the feeder posts who have attained the age of 55
years on the 1st day of January of the year in which the
Committee meets”.
12.
It is pertinent to mention here, that, Rule-34 of the Rules,
1967, deals with “Power to Relax” , which may be quoted herein-below, in extensor, for convenience”
“34. Where the State Government is of the opinion that it is
necessary or expedient so to do, it may by order, for reasons to be
recorded in writing and in consultation with the Commission,
relax any of the provisions off these rules with respect of any
class or category of persons or posts.”
13.
This Court while taking up the matter for disposal, requested
learned GA to take instructions from the Government about the
steps the Government has taken to address the grievance of the
petitioners. On instruction, learned GA has placed the files before
this Court where the competent authorities of the State Government
have decided to wait for the outcome of the decision of the present
writ petition by the Court, which prompted this Court to revisit the
reasons assigned by the State Government to reject the prayers
made by the petitioners in the earlier round of litigation followed
be their representations in terms of the order of this Court.
14.
In the opinion of this Court, the State Government has taken
the decision for not invoking the “Power to Relax” clause in a
mechanical manner. I do not find any logical ground as regard to
the reasons stated above for non-consideration of the promotion of
the petitioners. While assigning the reasons as quoted here-inabove, the competent authorities of the State has not considered the
material aspect that in view of the status quo order passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, promotion of State Government
employees was held up by the State Government itself. Thereafter,
out of administrative exigencies, the Government has made a
policy decision that promotions of the eligible employees should be
considered irrespective of the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
of India on ad hoc basis. The object was to augment efficiency in
administration.
15.
The promotion of the petitioners to the posts of TPS Grade-
II could not be considered for the last few years due to an order
passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and not due to any fault of
the petitioners. Keeping it in mind, the IGP of Tripura, the
competent authority of the Police Organisation, who knows the
pros and cons and competency of his officers, had suggested under
his written communication dated 08.07.2021 that the officers who
are eligible for promotion but not considered for promotion due to
the Court’s order should be considered for promotion and the
situation demands to invoke Rule 34 of TPS Rules.
16.
Needless to say, before arriving at the said decision and
communicating the same to the Government, the competent
authority (IGP) must have taken care of the interests of all of its
officers. Furthermore, he being the competent authority is the best
person to hold that who would be the best officers to serve the
interests of the State in protecting the discipline of the police
administration. The IGP had kept in mind the necessity to keep the
high morale factor of his officers in discharging their services.
17.
Here, it would be relevant to abstract the observations of the
Inspector General of Police of the State Government which he
made in his communication dated 08.07.2021:
“4. It is seen that, as on 01/01/2021, 33 (thirty-three)
Inspectors of Police who otherwise meet all the eligibility
criteria had become 55 years or older, Annexure-A
provides
the
entire
list
of
these
officers.
5. It may be noted that all the officers have rendered long
years of service, including service for at least 5 years in
the rank of Inspector. Due to maintenance of „status quo‟
in matters of promotion in compliance with the interim
order dated 27.07.2015 passed by the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court of India, these officers had not considered for
promotion to the next higher rank since last promotion in
the rank of TPS Gr-II on 05/06/2013
6. At this stage when promotions are being resumed,
depriving the above mentioned 33 Inspectors of Police
from being considered for promotion to the next higher
rank in TPS Gr-II for no fault of any one individual, will be
deemed unfair to the legitimate career expectations of
these officers.
7. In view of the above, it is proposed that, in exercise of
Rule 34 “Power to Relax” of The TPS Rules, 1967, the
competent authority may kindly relax Rule 14(4) of the
TPS Rules, 1967, to allow the DPC to be constituted for
the post of TPS Gr-II to consider cases of all officers
irrespective of their current age, as a one-time measure.”
18.
Now, if we consider the reasoning given by the State’s IGP
and the Government, according to this Court, the opinion passed by
the IGP is more logical, reasonable and acceptable. The ground
taken by the Government that if the senior officers are promoted,
then, junior officers may raise their claim and there may be legal
complications in future are not in consonance with the objects the
legislatures wanted to achieve qua the reasons assigned by the IGP,
Tripura being the competent authority to look after the interests of
police administration.
19.
The petitioners being the senior most eligible police officers
for promotions to the posts of TPS Grade-II had/have always
legitimate expectation for having fair treatment in their service
career and any infringement can form the basis of judicial review.
Rule of equity does not suggest that the junior officers can claim
the advantage over the senior officers and, if senior officers are
promoted, the junior officers cannot have any grievance and thus,
the apprehension of the Government that junior officers may be
deprived of promotion has no substance at all.
20.
In furtherance thereof, the senior officers who already have
crossed their age of 55 years would retire very soon, and at best
they are having their 3/4 years of service and, in this situation the
junior officers would have enough opportunity to get their
promotions against the posts which will fall vacant on retirement of
the senior most officers. It is informed at the Bar that many eligible
officers have already been retired by this time and very few officers
are still in service.
21.
It is settled proposition of law that action of the State and its
instrumentalities must reflect an approach informed by reasons.
The reasons are the links between the materials on which certain
conclusions are based and the actual conclusion. They disclose how
the mind is applied to the subject matter for a decision whether it is
purely administrative or quasi-judicial. The reasons should reveal
the real nexus between the facts considered and the conclusions
reached. Only in that eventuality, the decision recorded be shown
to be manifestly just and reasonable. A good administration raises a
reasonable or legitimate expectation in every citizen to be treated
fairly in his interaction with the State and its instrumentalities. To
satisfy the requirement of non-arbitrariness in a State action, it is,
therefore, necessary to consider and give due weight to the
reasonable or legitimate expectations of the persons likely to be
affected by the decision or else that unfairness in the exercise of the
power may amount to an abuse or excess of power apart from
affecting the bonafides of the decision in a given case. The decision
so made would be exposed to challenge to the ground of
arbitrariness. Thus, rule of law does not completely eliminate
discretion in the exercise of power, as it is unrealistic, but for
control of its exercise by judicial review.
22.
It goes without saying that mere reasonable or legitimate
expectation of a citizen in such a situation may not by itself be a
distinct enforceable right, but failure to consider and give due
weight to it may render the decision arbitrary and this is how the
requirement of due consideration of a legitimate expectation forms
part of the principle of non-arbitrariness, a necessary concomitant
of the rule of law.
23.
Further, every legitimate expectation is a relevant factor
requiring due consideration in a fair decision-making process,
which is required to be considered keeping in view larger public
interest.
24.
In the instant case, the action/decision taken by the State
government appears to me to be highly unrealistic, unreasonable,
arbitrary and also attracts the doctrine of legitimate expectation.
25.
The State or its instrumentalities cannot treat unequals as
equals as that would be in violation of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. The senior officers in a department cannot be
equated with their juniors in the matter of promotion. Furthermore,
it is now well-settled that action of the State must have nexus with
the object sought to be achieved.
26.
In the present case, the legitimate expectations of the
aspiring senior most police Inspectors for promotion in a fair
manner have been infringed. The promotions of the senior officers
are required to be considered before the promotions of the junior
officers to the posts of TPS Grade-II, which, to re-iterate, they
legitimately expected.
27.
In State of U.P. vs. Johri Mal, AIR 2004 S.C. 3800, the
Supreme Court held as follows:
“where administrative action is challenged under
Article 14 as being discriminatory, equals are treated unequally or
unequals are treated equally, the question is for the constitutional
courts as primary reviewing courts to consider the correctness of
the level of discrimination applied and whether it is excessive and
whether it has a nexus with the objectives intended to be achieved
by administrator. For judging the arbitrariness of the order, the
test of unreasonableness may be applied” and in such eventuality,
the Court can interfere when the decision with regard to the action
is arbitrary, discriminatory and having no nexus the law makers
intended to achieve.
28.
The sweep of Article 14 of the Constitution covers all State
action. Non-arbitrariness and fairness are the two immobile and
unalterable cornerstones of a legal behavioral baseline.
29.
This Court is not unoblivious of the fact that the power of
relaxation of recruitment rules should be exercised sparingly under
service jurisprudence. It is a matter of policy decision of the
Government, but, this Court is also concerned to the legal position
that the legislature incorporates the provision for relaxation of
recruitment rule in any Act or Rule keeping in mind certain
invisible situations or some unavoidable circumstances in the
matter of promotion, or in exigencies of effective administration,
and in appropriate cases, keeping in view the object the legislature
empowering its executives or implementers of the Rule to relax any
of the service conditions encrypted in the Recruitment Rule. The
implementors i.e. the executives should always keep in mind the
object of incorporation of the provision of relaxation in a particular
fact situation.
30.
In the case on hand the State Government must give due
weightage to the opinions rendered by the State’s IGP, which, if
read carefully, have direct nexus with objects the State legislatures
sought to achieve while restoring the exercise for promotions of its
employees aimed to augment efficiency in administration.
31.
In the opinion of this Court, if, in appropriate cases the
executives fail to address the object of the legislatures, then,
“Power to Relax” rule would be frustrated, and if, it is permitted,
then, the object of the legislature legislating this particular clause in
TPS Rule, 1967 will be defeated. In that case, the Court must step
in to protect the hardship caused to a particular employee or class
of employees for not exercising the power of relaxation to meet the
injustice caused to such employee or class of employees.
32.
In the instant case, the Government should not have awaited
for the decision of the Court as revealed from the “Note” nos.-13,
17 and 18, but ought to have proceeded to relax the relevant Rule to
obviate genuine hardship caused to a class of employees, that is,
the petitioners herein and other similarly situated persons directing
their promotions in relaxation of the Rules.
33.
Indubitably, power to relax Recruitment Rule or any other
Rule made by the State Government is conferred upon the
Government to meet any emergent situation where injustice might
have been caused or where the working of Rule might have become
impossible. Under service jurisprudence as also the Administrative
Law, such a power has necessarily to be conceded to the employer
particularly the State Government or the Central Government who
have to deal with hundreds of employees working under them in
different departments including the Central or the State
Government [Ref: Ashok Kumar Uppal vs. State of J&K, (1998) 4
SCC 179]
34.
In State of Maharashtra v. Jagannath Achyut Karandikar
[1989 Supp (1) SCC 393 : 1989 SCC (L&S) 417 : (1989) 10 ATC
593 : AIR 1989 SC 1133 : (1989) 1 SCR 947] it was held as under:
(SCC p. 398, para 12)
“The power to relax the conditions of the rules
to avoid undue hardship in any case or class of
cases cannot now be gainsaid. It would be,
therefore, futtile for the respondents to make any
grievance.”
35.
In J.C. Yadav v. State of Haryana [(1990) 2 SCC 189: 1990
SCC (L&S) 218 : (1990) 12 ATC 745] , it was held as under: (SCC
pp. 194-95, para 6)
“The relaxation of the Rules may be to the
extent the State Government may consider necessary
for dealing with a particular situation in a just and
equitable manner. The scope of Rule is wide enough
to confer power on the State Government to relax the
requirement of Rules in respect of an individual or
class of individuals to the extent it may consider
necessary for dealing with the case in a just and
equitable manner. The power of relaxation is
generally contained in the Rules with a view to
mitigate undue hardship or to meet a particular
situation. Many a time strict application of service
rules create a situation where a particular individual
or a set of individuals may suffer undue hardship and
further there may be a situation where requisite
qualified persons may not be available for
appointment to the service. In such a situation the
Government has power to relax Requirement of
Rules. The State Government may in exercise of its
powers issue a general order relaxing any particular
rule with a view to avail the services of requisite
officers. The relaxation even if granted in a general
manner would ensure to the benefit of individual
officers.”
36.
This decision was followed in Sandeep Kumar Sharma v.
State of Punjab [(1997) 10 SCC 298 : 1997 SCC (L&S) 1682] in
which Hon'ble Punchhi, J. (as His Lordship then was), observed as
under: (SCC p. 304, para 14)
“The power of relaxation even if generally included
in the service rules could either be for the purpose of
mitigating hardships or to meet special and deserving
situations. Such rule must be construed liberally,
according to the learned Judges. Of course arbitrary
exercise of such power must be guarded against. But a
narrow construction is likely to deny benefit to the
really deserving cases. We too are of the view that the
rule of relaxation must get a pragmatic construction so
as to achieve effective implementation of a good policy
of the Government.”
37.
In the light of above analysis and discussions on the subject,
in my considered view, the present case is an appropriate and fit
case to invoke the provision as enshrined under Rule 34 of TPS
Rules relaxing the age bar of the petitioners for consideration of
their promotions to higher post, i.e. TPS Grade-II to obviate the
hardship caused to the senior most Inspectors of police.
38.
Accordingly, I am constrained to direct the respondents to
relax the age bar of the petitioners for consideration of their
promotions to the next higher rank i.e. TPS Grade-II.
The entire exercise of promotion of the eligible officers shall
be completed within a period of 3(three) weeks from today.
Needless to say, this judgment will be applicable to all the eligible
senior police Inspectors.
39.
As a sequel, the impugned order dated 08.09.2021 issued by
the Principal Secretary to the Government of Tripura stands set
aside and quashed.
With the above observations and directions, the instant writ
petition stands allowed and thus disposed of.
JUDGE
Snigdha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review