Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH
DATED THIS THE 19TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.100283 OF 2018 (PAR/POS)
C/W
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO.100261 OF 2018
IN RFA NO. 100283/2018
BETWEEN:
BHARATHI
HM
BHARATHI H M
Location: HIGHCOURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
DHARWAD
SMT. HEMAVVA @ LATA
W/O. KALLANAGOUDA KHANDIBHAGUR,
AGE: 31 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE AND HOUSEHOLD,
R/O. DUDIHALLI VILLAGE, TQ. HIREKERUR,
DIST. HAVERI-581111.
…APPELLANT
(BY SMT. POOJA KULKARNI, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. DINESH M. KULKARNI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
DANAPPA
S/O. SADAPPA PATIL,
AGE: 56 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HIREMORAB VILLAGE,
TQ. HIREKERUR,
DIST. HAVERI-581111.
2.
SHIVANANDAPPA
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
S/O. BASAPPA HULATTI,
AGE: 64 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HIREMORABA VILLAGE,
TQ. HIREKERUR,
DIST. HAVERI-581111.
3.
SMT. AKKAMMA
W/O. DANAPPA PATIL,
AGE: 41 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HIREMORABA VILLAGE,
TQ. HIREKERUR,
DIST. HAVERI-581111.
4.
SHIVANAND (SHIVANAGOUDA)
S/O. RUDRAGOUDA PATIL,
AGE: 56 YEARS, OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HIREKERUR, DIST. HAVERI.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. S.G. KADADAKATTI, ADVOCATE FOR R1 AND R3;
SRI. GIRISH S. HULMANI, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
SRI. A.R. PATIL, ADVOCATE FOR R4)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 READ WITH 41 RULE 1
OF CPC, 1908, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 03.04.2018 PASSED BY THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND
JMFC., AT HIREKERUR IN O.S.NO.25/2012, IN REJECTING THE
COUNTER-CLAIM OF THE APPELLANT AND FINDING ON ADDL. ISSUE
NO.2, AS NULL AND VOID AND DECREE THE SUIT AS PRAYED FOR
AND ETC.
IN RFA NO. 100261/2018
BETWEEN:
DANAPPA S/O. SADAPPA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HIREMORAB-581210,
TQ. HIREKERUR, DIST. HAVERI.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. S.G. KADADAKATTI, ADVOCATE)
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
AND:
1.
SHIVANANDAPPA S/O. BASAPPA HULLATTI,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HIREMORAB-581210,
TQ. HIREKERUR, DIST. HAVERI.
2.
HEMAVVA W/O. KALLANAGOUDA KHANDIBAGUR,
AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURIST AND HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. DUDIHALLI-581111,
TQ. HIREKERUR, DIST. HAVERI.
3.
SMT. AKKAMMA W/O. DANAPPA PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS,
OCC. AGRICULTURIST,
R/O. HIREMORAB-581210,
TQ. HIREKERUR, DIST. HAVERI.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. GIRISH S. HULMANI, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
SMT. POOJA KULKARNI, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. DINESH M. KULKARNI, ADVOCATE)
THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 READ WITH 41 RULE
1 OF CPC, 1908, PRAYING TO CALL FOR RECORDS AND TO SET
ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 03.04.2018 PASSED BY
THE COURT OF SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC., HIREKERUR IN
O.S.NO.25/2012 AND DECREE THE SUIT AS PRAYED BY ALLOWING
THIS APPEAL AND ETC.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FURTHER ARGUMENTS, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE GEETHA K.B.)
RFA No.100261/2018 is filed by plaintiff/appellant,
praying for setting aside the judgment and decree dated
03.04.2018 passed in O.S.No.25/2012 on the file of the
learned Senior Civil Judge and J.M.F.C., Hirekerur and to
decree the suit as prayed for.
2.
The appellant-defendant No.2 has filed RFA
No.100283/2018 challenging the judgment and decree
dated 03.04.2018 passed in O.S.No.25/2012 in rejecting
the Counter-Claim of appellant and finding on additional
issue No.2 as null and void and for such other reliefs.
3.
they
Parties would be referred with their ranks as
were
before
the
Trial
Court
for
the
sake
of
convenience and clarity.
4.
Plaintiff has filed a suit praying for judgment
and decree of partition and separate possession of his half
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
share in suit schedule properties by metes and bounds for
good cause and for such a delay.
5.
The case of plaintiff before Trial Court in
nutshell and the G-tree of the family is that, one Basappa
is
the
original
propositus
having
a
wife
by
name
Gangawwa and two children. First one is Shivanandappa
and second one is Eramma. Shivanandappa is defendant
No.1 in the suit. Eramma died on 11.03.2000 leaving
behind her husband/plaintiff and her daughter-defendant
No.2 as her legal representatives. Marriage of Eramma
had taken place with plaintiff in the year 1989 and
defendant No.2 was born from the said wedlock. She was
married and residing in her husband’s house. Original
propositus and his wife Smt.Gangawwa died long back.
Defendant
No.1
and
Eramma
were
his
only
legal
representatives. After death of Eramma, plaintiff and
defendant No.2 being his legal representatives continued
with defendant No.1 as joint family members. Suit
schedule properties are “zÀvÀÛPÀ D¹ÛUÀ¼ÀÄ” of original propositus-
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
Basappa. There is no
partition
in
the joint family.
Defendant No.1 in collusion with Revenue Officials has got
mutated the suit schedule properties into his name, after
death of his father by getting M.E.No.1573 illegally without
the consent of Eramma. Those revenue entries will not
bind the legitimate right of plaintiff over suit schedule
properties. Plaintiff came to know about those illegal
revenue entries recently. Hence, the plaintiff demanded
his legitimate share in suit schedule properties with
defendant No.1. But defendant No.1 refused to effect
partition and told that, he is the absolute owner of suit
schedule properties and he will not give any share to
plaintiff. Hence, the suit for appropriate reliefs.
6.
appeared
After
service
through
his
of
notice,
counsel
and
defendant
filed
his
No.1
written
statement, wherein, he denied the entire averments made
in the plaint and further contended that, suit schedule
properties along with Sy.No.121/16 measuring 1 acre 15
guntas and re-survey.No.40/15 measuring 2 acres and 5
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
guntas situated at Hiremorab village belonged to the
father of defendant No.1. The father of defendant No.1
died on 10.07.1981 and after his death, all the above said
properties came to defendant No.1. Defendant No.1 has
given application to mutate the above said properties into
his name for that his mother-Gangawwa and his younger
sister-Eramma have given their consent and accordingly,
those properties were mutated into the name of defendant
No.1.
Gangawwa or Eramma during their lifetime have
not questioned the revenue entry in M.E.No.1573 and it
continued in the name of plaintiff absolutely. He is in
continuous exclusive possession and enjoyment of all the
above said properties. Plaintiff and defendant No.2 are not
having any right, title, interest in or over suit schedule
properties. 30 guntas in Sy.No.121/16 and 8 guntas in
Sy.No.40/15 were acquired by the Government for Upper
Tunga Project and in this regard, notification under Section
6(1) of the Karnataka Land Acquisition Act was published.
Under the notice issued under Section 5(1), bearing
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
No.Cr.90/2004-2005
dated
04.01.2004,
the
aforesaid
lands were acquired, and a notice under Section 12(2) was
issued to Defendant No.1, and compensation was awarded
to him by the concerned authorities. About 25 years prior
to filing of the written statement, marriage of Eramma has
taken place with plaintiff and at that time, defendant No.1
and his father have spent huge money and have given
gold ornaments. After the marriage, Eramma lived with
plaintiff for about 7-8 years. She died on 11.03.2000. She
has a daughter i.e., defendant No.2. Defendant No.1 has
performed the marriage of defendant No.2 by spending
entire marriage expenses. After death of Eramma, plaintiff
married Akkamma who is his second wife i.e., defendant
No.3 and thus, now plaintiff is not related to defendant
No.1 or to suit schedule properties. After death of
Eramma, plaintiff in collusion with Revenue Officials has
got mutated Re-survey No.40/15 measuring 2 acre 5
guntas situated at Hiremorab Village into his name behind
the back of defendant No.1 by getting M.E.No.2813. The
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
said mutation will not convey any right to plaintiff. He got
mutated the same as per M.R.No.97/2005-2006. But he is
not getting any right under said mutation and right of
defendant No.1 was not set aside.
Further, plaintiff by
concocting his second wife as the own sister of defendant
No.1
got
relinquishment
Sy.No.121/16
measuring
from
her
in
respect
acre
guntas
as
of
per
M.R.No.1836/2003-2004 behind the back of defendant
No.1 in collusion with Revenue Officials. Plaintiff in
collusion with defendant No.3 i.e. his second wife has filed
L.A.C.No.80/2006
compensation
in
and
L.A.C.No.79/2006
respect
of
for
re-survey
awarding
No.121/16
measuring 1 acre 15 guntas and Sy.No.40/15 measuring 2
acres 5 guntas even though, they are not having any
right, title, or interest in or over the said properties; they
got concocted the oral and documentary evidence and
have obtained compensation. In those cases, learned
Senior Civil Judge, Hirekerur has passed award granting
compensation to them. The said compensation awarded in
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
favour
of
present
L.A.C.Nos.79/2006
plaintiff
and
and
80/2006
defendant
is
No.3
in
challenged
by
defendant No.1 by filing O.S.No.9/2012 to declare him as
absolute owner of those properties. Even though, the facts
are as above, without including Sy.Nos.40/15 and 121/16,
plaintiff has filed this suit. Hence, suit is bad for nonjoinder of all properties. After marrying defendant No.3,
plaintiff severed all his ties with the family of defendant
No.1. Defendant No.2 is the daughter of Eramma and she
is the legal representative of Eramma. However, Eramma
has relinquished all her rights in suit schedule properties
during her lifetime itself. Hence, defendant No.2 is also not
entitled for any right in suit schedule properties. Eramma
died in the year 1981. Within 12 years from the date of
her death, plaintiff has not filed the suit. Hence, suit is
barred by law of limitation. Hence, prayed for dismissal of
suit with compensatory costs of ₹.30,000/-.
7.
Defendant No.2 filed her written statement,
wherein she contended that suit of plaintiff is based on
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
concocted facts and is not maintainable in law. She further
contended
that,
before
commencement
of
Hindu
Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 (for short referred as
“Act 2005”) Eramma died and Basappa died long back.
Hence, Eramma was having right in family properties only
as per the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 i.e., notional
partition. After the time of death of father-Basappa,
defendant No.1, Eramma and their mother-Gangawwa
were alive. Hence, all of them would get 1/3rd share each.
Thus, totally defendant No.1 would get 4/6th share and
Eramma would get 4/18th share. After death of Basappa,
defendant No.1 with the consent of his mother-Gangawwa
and his sister-Eramma, got mutated Re-survey No.121/16
into the name of defendant No.1. After death of Eramma
on 04.03.2000, without the knowledge and consent of
defendant Nos.1 and 2, plaintiff got mutated said property
into the name of defendant No.3-Akkamma as per MR
No.1836/2003-04. Defendant No.3 is in no way related to
the family of defendant No.1 or Eramma. However, it was
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
wrongly stated before revenue authorities that defendant
No.3 is the own sister of defendant No.1 and said revenue
entry came into existence in collusion with revenue
officials and defendant No.3 is not having any right, title or
interest in or over the said property. Said property stands
in her name and hence, she is also proper and necessary
party to the suit. After death of Basappa, defendant No.1
with the consent of his mother-Gangawwa has given
portion of item No.7 in ‘A’ schedule property, measuring 1
acre 15 guntas to his sister-Eramma as per M.E.No.2032.
However, after death
of Eramma
even
without the
knowledge of defendant No.2, plaintiff got mutated said
property into his name as per M.R.No.97/2005-2006 and
obtained compensation alone without including defendant
No.2. Plaintiff has obtained compensation in respect of resurvey No.121/16 in LAC No.80/06, but defendant No.2
has got 1/2 share in said property. Portion of said amount
21,649/- is in CCD No.36/2011-12. Hence, prayed for not
to disburse said amount to plaintiff till disposal of the suit
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
and finally prayed for 1/6th share by metes and bounds.
She is ready to pay Court fee in that regard.
8.
Defendant No.3 appeared through her counsel
and filed her written statement wherein she has taken
contention
that
one
Veerabasappa
was
the
original
propositus having two sons and three daughters i.e.
Basappa, Bailappa, Thippamma, Gangawwa and Nagavva.
Defendant No.1-Sivanandappa and Eramma are children of
Gangawwa and defendant No.3 is the daughter of Nagavva
through Subhas Chandra Rudragowda. She contended that
earlier plaintiff married the younger sister of defendant
No.1-Eramma and from said wedlock, they got defendant
No.2.
During
2000,
Eramma
died
due
to
cancer.
Afterwards, plaintiff married defendant No.3 with the
consent of defendant No.1 to look after his child-defendant
No.2. This is at the instance of defendant No.1. Defendant
No.1
has
performed
the
marriage
of
plaintiff
with
defendant No.3 and defendant No.1 told that he would
give the properties, which he is going to give to Eramma
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
to defendant No.3. Based on it, defendant No.1 has got
mutated M.R.No.1836/2003-2004 stating that defendant
No.3 is his own sister. Now, defendant No.1 is taking
contention that defendant No.3 is not his family members
only to grab the properties. With the consent of defendant
No.1, Sy.No.121/16 measuring 1 acre and 15 guntas was
mutated into the name of defendant No.3.
Defendant
No.1 has given consent to mutate Sy.No.40/15 measuring
2 acres to plaintiff and said property was acquired for
Upper Tunga Project, at that time, defendant No.1 has
given consent to mutate said property into the name of
defendant No.3 and also consented to give compensation
to defendant No.3. But defendant No.1 has concocted
records during 2010 and he has taken compensation in
respect of Sy.Nos.40/15 and 121/16. After plaintiff and
defendant No.3 came to know about it, they enquired with
defendant No.1. But he refused to give any share to them
and told that, he will not give any property or any
compensation to them. After marrying plaintiff, defendant
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
No.3 has fostered defendant No.2 as her own daughter
and performed her marriage with person of Dudihalli
Village. Hence, prayed for decreeing the suit of plaintiff
and to dismiss the contention of defendant No.1.
9.
On behalf of plaintiff, plaintiff was examined as
P.W.1, examined a witness as P.W.2, got marked Ex.P.1 to
24 and closed his side before trial court.
On behalf of
defendants, 4 witnesses were examined as D.W.1 to 4, got
marked Ex.D.1 to 38 and closed their side before trial
Court.
10.
After
recording
evidence
and
hearing
arguments, learned trial judge has dismissed the suit of
plaintiff on the ground that the suit is barred by limitation
and plaintiff has no share in suit schedule properties.
11.
Aggrieved by said judgment and decree, the
plaintiff/appellant IN RFA No. 100261/2018 and defendant
No.2/appellant in RFA No. 100283/2018 have preferred
these appeals.
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
12.
Heard arguments of both sides.
13.
Learned counsel for the appellant/defendant
No.2 Smt.Pooja Kulkarni in RFA No.100283/2018 would
submit that one Sri Basappa was the original propositus
who died on 10.07.1981 leaving behind his two children
i.e., Shivanandappa/defendant No.1 and Eramma and his
wife Gangawwa; Gangawwa also died subsequently. Thus,
only defendant No.1 and Eramma succeeded to the
properties of Basappa. Eramma died on 11.03.2000
leaving behind her daughter-defendant No.2 and her
husband-the plaintiff. She would further submit that all the
suit schedule properties are the ancestral and joint family
properties of defendant No.1 and Eramma. Hence, after
death of Basappa, both, defendant No.1 and Eramma
would get equal share. The share of Eramma is to be
equally divided between the plaintiff and defendant No.2,
who succeeded to the share of Eramma.
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
14.
Learned counsel for the appellant would further
submit that suit schedule A(6) and A(7) properties were
transferred into the name of the plaintiff by giving an
application by defendant No.1. Some portions of those
properties were acquired for Upper Tunga Project and
compensation was given to defendant No.1. The plaintiff
and defendant No.3 (2nd wife of the plaintiff) filed LAC
No.79/2006 and 80/2006 and compensation was awarded
on their behalf. However, defendant No.3 is not the family
member of the plaintiff and defendant Nos. 1 & 2 and thus
she will not get any share in those properties.
15.
Learned counsel for the appellant would further
submit that after commencement of Hindu Succession
(Amendment) Act, 2005, Eramma would get equal share
with defendant No.1. Based on the judgment of the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
the
case of Vineeth
Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma and others reported
in
(2020) 9 SCC 1, a coparcener, the daughter need not be
alive at the time of commencement of said Act. However,
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
the learned trial Judge has not considered these aspects
and has wrongly dismissed the suit of the plaintiff. Even
though defendant No.2 had prayed for a share in her
written statement by paying court fee, that was also not
considered by the trial Court. Hence, prayed for allowing
her appeal and to grant 1/4th share in all suit schedule
properties by metes and bounds.
16.
Learned counsel Sri S.G. Kadadakatti for the
appellant-(plaintiff) in RFA No.100261/2018 would submit
that, the
plaintiff, being
the husband
of deceased-
Eramma, is Class-1 heir as per Section 15 of Act 2005.
Hence, he is having right in the suit schedule properties.
He adopted the arguments of learned counsel for appellant
in RFA No.100283/2018 and submit that suit A(6) and
A(7) properties were mutated into his name as per the
application given by defendant No.1 to Revenue Officials.
However, the defendant No.1 denied his signature on such
application
along
with
his
signature
on
the
written
statement, affidavit evidence and vakalat. This shows the
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
conduct of defendant No.1. He would further submit that
some portion of items in suit schedule A(6) and A(7)
properties were acquired for Upper Tunga project and in
that regard, LAC No.79/2006 was filed by him. Defendant
No.3 is his second wife. Defendant No.1 himself got
performed the marriage of plaintiff with defendant No.3 by
assuring him that he would give the properties of Eramma
to defendant No.3 and thus he has given application to
change their names i.e., names of plaintiff and defendant
No.3 in revenue records pertaining to suit schedule A(6)
and A(7) properties. He would further contend that, LAC
Nos.79/2006 and 80/2006 were allowed, against which,
defendant No.1 filed O.S. No.9/2012 for declaration of his
ownership in respect of those properties which is pending
consideration with a new number O.S. No.128/2019 before
the court of Senior Civil Judge, Hirekerur. Hence, prayed
for allowing the appeal.
17.
Learned counsel Sri. G.S. Hulmani appearing for
respondent No.1/defendant No.1 would submit that, the
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
original propositus-Basappa died in the year 1981, at that
time itself, all the suit schedule properties along with two
more properties were mutated into the name of defendant
No.1 as per the consent of his mother and his sister i.e.,
Gangawwa and Eramma and since then he is enjoying
those properties as absolute owner and as a sole surviving
coparcener. During the year 2000, Eramma died and
during her lifetime, she has not questioned the revenue
entries bearing ME No.1573 dated 29.08.1981. She was
alive for about 19 years after such change in the revenue
entry. Furthermore, after 4 years of her death, the plaintiff
along with defendant No.3, who is his second wife, in
collusion with the revenue officials, got mutated revenue
entries in respect of suit schedule A(6) and A(7) properties
into their names, which was not known to defendant No.1.
Some portions of those properties were acquired for Upper
Tunga project and compensation was given to defendant
No.1 alone by the revenue authorities. Aggrieved by the
same,
the
plaintiff
and
defendant
No.3
filed
LAC
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
Nos.79/2006 and 80/2006 claiming compensation by
producing several concocted documents. Based on those
fraudulent and concocted documents, those LAC petitions
were allowed. Against which, defendant No.1 filed O.S.
No.9/2012 for the relief of declaration of his title over the
suit schedule A(6) and A(7) properties and also for the
relief of injunction before the learned Senior Civil Judge,
Hirekerur, which was decreed by judgment and decree
dated 22.07.2015. Against the said judgment and decree,
the plaintiff and defendant No.3 filed R.A. No.85 by 2015,
which was partly allowed and the matter was remanded to
trial Court for fresh trial by setting aside the judgment and
decree. The said suit was transferred to the Court of Civil
Judge and JMFC-Hirekerur on the point of pecuniary
jurisdiction and re-numbered as O.S. No.128/2019, which
is pending consideration. In the meanwhile, the plaintiff
filed the present suit i.e. O.S. No.25/2012 seeking
partition and separate possession of his ½ share in the
suit schedule properties. The plaintiff, in his cross-
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
examination has given categorical admission in respect of
the application given by his wife to revenue authorities to
change the entries in respect of the suit schedule
properties into the name of defendant No.1 and also given
several other admissions in his cross-examination which
clearly show that the plaintiff and defendant No.2 are not
having
any
right
over
suit
schedule
properties.
Furthermore, 12 years after the death of Eramma, the
present suit was filed by the plaintiff alone and defendant
No.2 has not filed any suit. Considering the aspect on the
point of limitation and other aspects, the learned trial
judge has rightly dismissed the suit of plaintiff. Hence,
prayed for dismissal of both appeals by confirming the
judgment and decree passed in O.S. No.25/2012.
18.
Being
aggrieved
by
dismissal
of
O.S.No.25/2012, plaintiff preferred RFA No.100261/2018
and defendant No.2 being aggrieved by rejection of her
Counter-Claim
in
No.100283/2018.
aforesaid
O.S.,
has
preferred
RFA
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
19.
Having heard the arguments of both sides and
verifying the trial court records and appeal papers of both
the appeals, the points that arise for consideration are:
i. Whether the plaintiff and defendant No.2 are entitled
for any share in suit schedule properties?
ii. Whether the judgment and decree passed by trial
Court is erroneous and it requires interference?
20.
The findings on these points are in “Negative”
for the following:
Reasons:The plaintiff has filed the suit for the relief of partition
and separate possession of his share in suit schedule
properties contending that the suit schedule properties are
the properties of original propositus-Basappa which came
to him through adoption. Basappa has a wife by name
Gangawwa, son – Shivanandappa (defendant No.1) and
daughter Eramma (wife of the plaintiff and mother of
defendant No.2). Basappa died on 10.07.1981 since then,
the suit schedule properties are the joint family properties
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
of plaintiffs and defendant Nos.1 & 2 and they are in joint
possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule properties
and there is no partition amongst them.
21.
In the written statement, defendant No.1 has
denied the relationship between the plaintiff and himself.
However, at the time of evidence, defendant No.1 has
categorically admitted the relationship between parties.
Some dates of incidents, which are not in dispute are very
important to decide the present case. Firstly, date of death
of Basappa is on 10.07.1981. At that time, the law in force
was that, “only male members were considered as
coparceners”. Hence, at that time, as per Section 6 of
Hindu Succession Act, 1956, first defendant was the only
sole surviving coparcener in the family. As per Section 8 of
the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the wife and daughter of
deceased Basappa would get a share in the share of
Basappa under notional partition. However, Eramma, who
died on 11.03.2000, during her lifetime, did not file any
suit for partition claiming her share in the suit schedule
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
properties. Mother of defendant No.1-Gangavva also died
long back and not claimed any share in the properties.
22.
After
death
of
Basappa,
Gangawwa
and
Eramma being the wife and daughter of deceased-Basappa
have given application as per Ex.P.7 dated 29.08.1981 to
change revenue entries into the name of defendant No.1.
Based on said application and after giving notice, which
was duly served on 02.10.1981, the M.E.No.1573 came
into existence and all the properties of Basappa were
succeeded by defendant No.1 by way of inheritance. They
continued in his name as on the date of suit and
subsequently
except
suit
schedule
A(6)
and
A(7)
properties.
23.
As far as suit schedule A(6) and A(7) properties
are concerned, plaintiff and his second wife have given
application
to
properties into
revenue
authorities
to
change
those
their names and accordingly as per
Ex.D.12, they were mutated into the name of plaintiff and
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
defendant No.3 As per M.E.No.2813 dated 15.05.2004 and
as per RTSCR No.853/2003-04 dated 17.03.2004.
24.
In the meanwhile, 30 guntas in suit schedule
A(6) property bearing Re.Sy.No.121/16 and 8 guntas in
suit schedule A(7) property bearing Re.Sy.No.40/15 were
acquired
for
Upper
Thunga
Project
and
initially
compensation was disbursed to first defendant; later LAC
No.79/2006 and LAC No.80/2006 were filed by plaintiff
and defendant No.3 and those petitions were allowed
holding that they are entitled for enhanced compensation
as per reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition
Act. At that time they have produced some revenue
entries i.e., Ex.D.12 and another revenue entry which is
not marked in this case and application as per Ex.D15.
25.
First defendant has filed O.S.No.9/2005 before
Senior Civil Judge, Hirekerur challenging the revenue
entries mutated into the name of plaintiff and defendant
No.3 in respect of suit schedule A(6) and A(7) properties
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
contending that they are the collusive revenue entries
based on fraud and misrepresentation and he has not
given any application to revenue authorities and based on
these pleadings, he has prayed for declaration of his title
over those properties and also for the relief of injunction.
Said
suit
was
decreed
initially.
After
such
decree,
R.F.A.No.85/2015 was filed by plaintiff and defendant No.3
and it was allowed partly by setting aside the judgment
and decree dated 22.07.2015 in O.S.No.9/2001 and the
matter was remanded back to the trial Court for fresh
disposal. Afterwards, said suit was transferred to Civil
Judge and JMFC., Hirekerur on the point of pecuniary
jurisdiction and re-numbered as O.S. No.128/2019 and it
is
still
pending
for
consideration.
Hence,
the
initial
judgment and decree in favour of defendant No.1 of this
suit is not having any bearing on the present suit.
26.
In this suit, plaintiff was examined as P.W.1 and
reiterated his contention in his affidavit evidence. In his
cross-examination, he has admitted that he married the
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
sister of defendant No.1-Eramma and his family is entirely
different from the family of defendant No.1. He also
admitted that from said marriage he got a daughter i.e.,
defendant No.2-Hemavva and her marriage is already
performed and she is residing in her husband's house. He
further
categorically
admitted
that
based
on
the
application given by Eramma and her mother Gangawwa
during 1981, the suit schedule properties were mutated
into the name of defendant No.1. He admitted that at the
time of marriage, sufficient dowry and cash was given to
Eramma and hence no property was given to her and thus
she has given application for change of properties into the
name of first defendant. He also admits that during her
lifetime, Eramma has not prayed for partition in joint
family properties.
27.
The above admission of plaintiff clearly and
categorically establish that the date of death of Basappa in
the year 1981, change of mutation entries into the name
of defendant No.1 in the year 1981 and death of Eramma
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
on 11.03.2000 are not in dispute. It is also not in dispute
that Eramma has not prayed for partition during her
lifetime in any of the properties of her parental family.
28.
It is to be noted that about four years after the
death of Eramma, suit schedule A(6) and A(7) properties
were mutated into the name of plaintiff and defendant
No.3, based on the alleged application given by defendant
No.1 to revenue authorities stating that defendant No.3 is
the own sister of defendant No.1.
29.
As already discussed above, defendant No.1 has
got only one sister-Eramma and this defendant No.3Akkamma is not his sister. However, she is the daughter
of his maternal aunt. But, application was given to
revenue authorities stating that she is the own sister of
defendant No.1 and some properties were mutated into
her name based on such application. In this regard,
plaintiff has categorically deposed that, he does not know
that about four years after the death of Eramma by
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
creating
concocted
documents,
survey
No.171/2016
measuring 1 acre 16 quntas and re-survey No.40/15,
measuring 2 acres 5 guntas were mutated into the name
of plaintiff and defendant No.3. He categorically admitted
that based on M.E.No.2813, she got mutation entries into
his name by concoction as per M.R.No.97/2005-06. He
also admitted that his second wife-Akkamma (defendant
No.3) is neither the sister of first defendant nor the sister
of
Eramma. He
admitted
that survey
No.121/16
is
mutated into the name of Akkamma by giving alleged
application that she is the own sister of first defendant and
said
entry
is
a
concocted
M.R.No.1836/200-04.
Tunga
Project,
He
those
entry
admitted
two
that
properties
based
under
were
on
Upper
acquired.
However, entire properties were not acquired but only a
portion
of
those
properties
were
acquired
and
compensation was given to defendant No.1 initially. She
admitted that he is in no way related to both those
properties. Only after filing of O.S.No.9/2012 by first
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
defendant, he impleaded those properties in this suit. He
categorically admitted that during her lifetime, his wife has
not prayed for
partition
and
likewise
his
daughter-
defendant No.2 also not prayed for partition in the share
of her mother.
30.
On behalf of plaintiff, a witness was examined
as PW.2. He also admitted about death of Basappa during
1981, change of properties into the name of defendant
No.1 during 1981.
It is to be noted here that after the
death of his first wife, plaintiff married third defendantAkkamma, who is not the member of the family of
Basappa but she is the daughter of Basappa's younger
sister. It is pleaded in the plaint itself that suit schedule
properties were the properties of Basappa as he was the
adopted son. Thus, the sisters of Basappa would not get
any right, title or interest in or over the properties of
Basappa. Under those circumstances, definitely defendant
No.3 being stranger to the family of Basappa would not
get any share in the properties of Basappa. However,
- 32 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
stating that first defendant has given application, she got
mutated some of the properties into her name before
revenue authorities, which will not create any title or
interest to her. Defendant No.3 was not having any title,
or interest over the property initially and hence, mere
revenue entries will not confer title to her.
31.
Only, if a party is having a right by birth or any
such right in the property before entering his name into
revenue records, then without any registered document,
only based on the application, revenue entries could be
mutated into the name of such party. But not vice versa.
32.
Earlier M.E. No.1573 came into existence and
revenue entries are mutated into the name of first
defendant because he was having right over the properties
immediately after death of his father. However, this
defendant No.3 is in no way related to the family of
Eramma and first defendant and hence her name could not
have been mutated into suit schedule A(6) and A(7)
- 33 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
properties only based on the application without any
registered document. Hence, a registered relinquishment
deed was very much required to change suit schedule A(6)
and A(7) properties into the name of defendant No.3,
which is not forthcoming in the present case. Hence, the
admission or denial of first defendant in giving an
application
to
change
suit
schedule
A(6)
and
A(7)
properties into the name of first defendant has no
relevance in this case. Hence, the argument of learned
counsel Smt.Pooja Kulkarni for Sri.Dinesh M. Kulkarni,
counsel for appellants that the attitude of first defendant
in denying his signature on said application along with
written statement, his affidavit evidence and also in
vakkalath has no consequence in this case.
33.
Admittedly, Basappa had a son and a daughter.
During his lifetime, marriage of his daughter was not
performed. Only after death of Basappa, her marriage was
performed in the year 1988-1989 as per the evidence of
both parties. Thus, at the time of death of Eramma in the
- 34 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
year 2000, she was not having any right over the
properties of her father, except if she had claimed notional
partition in the joint family properties by filing a suit or by
obtaining her share from defendant No.1. However, even
though she was alive for about 19 years, she never
claimed her right in any of the properties, which were
standing in the name of first defendant after death of his
father.
34.
It is an admitted fact that on 11.03.2000
Eramma died and present suit is filed on 26.06.2012 i.e.,
12 years after the death of Eramma.
35.
To file a suit for partition, based on notional
partition, the period of limitation would be 12 years and
within that period Eramma has not exercised her right and
within 12 years of her death, plaintiff and defendant No.2
have not exercised their right for partition.
apparently, the suit is barred by limitation.
Hence,
- 35 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
36.
Ex.D.15 is said to be the application given by
defendant No.1 to change khatha of Re.Sy.No.121/16
measuring 1 acre 15 guntas into the name of defendant
No.3. However, as discussed above, she is in no way
related to defendant No.1 and hence said application even
if given by defendant No.1 has no value in the eye of law.
Hence, M.E.No.2836 based on said alleged application is
also having no value in the eye of law.
37.
As far as Ex.D.12 is concerned, even the
application alleged to be given by defendant No.1 is not
produced in this case. Only based on an unavailable
application, it is M.E.No.2813 came into existence in
respect of 2 acres 5 guntas of Survey No.40/15. Thus,
these two entries would not confer any right over any of
the suit schedule properties either to plaintiff or to
defendant No.2. Only based on Exs.D.12 and D.15,
defendant No.1-plaintiff has given application as per Ex.
D.17 and got mutated those properties into his name,
which is also not a proper one. Under those circumstances,
- 36 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
the suit filed by plaintiff and the relief claimed by
defendant No.2 in her written statement are clearly barred
by time.
Even though, learned counsel for defendant
No.2 would submit that defendant No.2 has prayed for
Counter-Claim, on perusal of her written statement would
not establish the said fact.
She had only prayed for
allotting share to her and she was ready to pay court-fee.
However, the court-fee was also not paid.
38.
For the reasons stated above, both plaintiff and
defendant No.2 are not entitled for any of the reliefs
prayed in the plaint. Considering these aspects, rightly,
the learned trial Judge has dismissed the suit of the
plaintiffs.
39.
It
is
to
be
noted
here
that
in
Vineeth
Sharma's case, stated supra, the father need not be alive
at the time of commencement of Hindu Succession
(Amendment) Act, 2005.
But before commencement of
said Act, both the father and daughter were not alive.
- 37 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
Should parties be permitted to initiate litigation ex-post
facto, long after the demise of the original coparcener and
the subsequent death of the daughter—who would have
derived interest solely via the 2005, Act—it would result in
perpetual, unending litigation. Were centenarian partitions
or
century-old
revenue
entries
to
be
amenable
to
challenge subsequently, it would, without doubt, lead to
an incessant stream of litigation, which fundamentally
contradicts the legislative intent of the 2005, Act and
violates the principles articulated in Vineeth Sharma's
case, supra.
40.
The only intention is that the daughter who has
got right over the property, because of the Act, 2005 shall
not be deprived of such right by manipulation, concoction
of revenue entries or oral partition deeds. However, that is
not the situation in present case as discussed above.
41.
Considering
these
aspects,
we
are
of
the
opinion that the relief sought in the suit of the plaintiffs or
the relief sought by defendant No.2 cannot be granted.
- 38 NC: 2026:KHC-D:495-DB
RFA No. 100283 of 2018
C/W RFA No. 100261 of 2018
HC-KAR
Hence, both appeals shall not survive for consideration.
Accordingly, the points under consideration are answered
in “Negative” and we proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
RFA Nos.100283/2018 and RFA No.100261/2018
filed under Section 96 R/W 41 Rule 1 of CPC are dismissed
by confirming the judgment and decree passed in OS
No.25/2012 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge and JMFC.
Under the facts and circumstances of the case,
parties are directed to bear their own costs.
Sd/(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE
Sd/(GEETHA K.B.)
JUDGE
SSP: Para 1 to 7
kmv from Para 8-16
HMB: Para 17 to end
CT:PA
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 12
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review